Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cimmic
Cimmic
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
1
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
2
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Foreword
In previous missions under UN command, from 1950 and forward, has
Civil Military Cooperation been a natural part in Peace Support
Operations (PSO) but its role has not explicitly been described.
This has lead to a more active search for definitions and doctrines to
clarify the purpose of, and deliver the basic platform of the design of,
cooperation between the civilian and the military resources in operation
in an area of Crises response.
3
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Sweden and the Swedish Armed Forces is within the framework of the
PARP process supporting the NATO stated view of the CIMIC function,
a view which will be a standard procedure within the EU military Crises
Response Force. It is obvious and necessary that the Swedish Armed
Forces adopt the CIMIC concept in accordance to the interpretation that
is a fact in the multinational Crises Response Forces where the Swedish
overseas force is practicing lessons learned and national competence
within the area of civil-military cooperation. The CIMIC function, as well
as other military disciplines will in the future be under continuous
development and adjustments as new lessons learned are made.
This handbook is focusing primarily on the tactical level and the practical
application in the field. The purpose is to offer the CIMIC personnel of
the Swedish overseas force guidance from the lessons learned made until
now and the established view on the CIMIC function that exists within
Swedish units organised for NATO and EU’s Crises Response Force.
4
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Index
Summary...................................................................................................8
Purpose....................................................................................................11
Basics.......................................................................................................14
Civil Military
Cooperation.................................................................................21
Support to Civil functions
Support to Military operations
Command and Control
Instable civil infrastructure
Lack of infrastructure
5
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Annex 2. Cooperation
Annex 3. Interpretors
Annex 4. Reports
Annex 5. CIMIC Centre
Annex 6. Projects
Annex 7. Abbreviations and Acronyms
Annex 8. Compilation of essential organisations
Literature references..........................................................................103
Sources.................................................................................................105
6
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
“ There is no greater sorrow on earth than the loss of one’s native land
and home....”
Euripides, 431 BC
7
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Summary
CIMIC is a military discipline within the frame of international Crises
Response. The concept contains the CIMIC headquarter function in a
multinational Crises Response Force and this function’s mission and
activities.
8
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
9
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
10
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
These guidelines shall offer the CIMIC appointed a structure of their work and base to
increase the effectiveness through utilise previous lessons learned.
The handbook shall not be taken as a regulation, instead it should support and guide.
The guidelines should always be used with judgement.
The handbook, which chiefly is to be used for CIMIC work on local (tactical) level is
written with the background of the former Yugoslavia.
When producing this Handbook CIMIC, the Danish Army Handbook in Civilian-
Military cooperation (HRN 810-025) has served as a model.
The objective is that the Handbook CIMIC should mirror updated Swedish knowledge
within the CIMIC area and the view on this function.
The handbook shall be a living document and be updated when changes in working
procedures are made or development of the Swedish commanding doctrines.
11
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
12
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
13
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Educational part
The lessons learned form Bosnia shows that the Military face is the one mainly is
contributing to the execution of an agreement.
The Civilian face will include difficulties, which has to be conquered. The Dayton
agreement was signed in December 1995 but in Bosnia is the civilian execution of the
agreement still struggling. The Civilian face is completely crucial if the mission will
be successful and for this is CIMIC an important headquarter function.
14
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
(NGO) civilian organisations, who are acting as partners and actors in areas of interest
and operations.
These factors can be affected by the different culture missions and working
procedures of the involving military and civilian organisations. To optimise the joint
effort it is therefore necessary to establish and preserve efficient connections with a
variety of civilian institutions and organisations, which means with the ones who is
present within the area of operations or have influence on planned or ongoing
operations.
15
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
The need
CIMIC could be a central part of a mission. This fact is valid in disaster relief and
humanitarian assistance. It has to be presumed that the military force engaged often is
dependent of the cooperation with the civilian organisations in the area of operations
concerning the use of resources and exchange of information. The military force is
dependant of the civilian authorities to maintain law and order. The freedom of
movement in the area of operation is often being limited without such cooperation.
The establishing and maintaining of good relations are often an efficient mean to
prevent the potential opponent to achieve equivalent advantages. The best way to live
up to the military commanders responsibility of the civilian inhabitants is because the
cooperation is working well with the civilian authorities and with the international and
non governmental organisations operating in the area.
Military success can often be achieved without using military enforcement, this
through the military commanders aim and means to be adapted to the civilian
situation in the mission area. This is especially valid during execution of Peace
Support Operations, when the civilian conditions could result in serious limitations. If
the adoption is not possible or asked for, e.g. in hostile area or in conjunction to a
rapid escalating conflict, CIMIC will anyway be an important factor to:
• grant the use of local resources
• be able to operate within frame of international Human Rights
• facilitate an eventual transmission to civilian administration.
16
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Picture 2. CIMIC with the use of conflict preventive activities and conflict
management
17
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Definitions
Swedish policy and doctrin concerning CIMIC is linked togehter with the NATO
definition of CIMIC according to AJP -9: “CIMIC facilitates co -operation between a
NATO Commander and all parts of the civilian environment within his Joint
Operation Area (JOA)”.
CIMIC is:
“The co -ordination and co-operation, in support of the mission, between the NATO
Commander and civiianl actors, including national population and local authorities,
as well as international, national and non-governmental organisations and
agencies”¹
According the UN model, the purpose of CIMIC is to support your own operational
task through improving the situation for the functions of the civilian environment and
support the humanitarian assistance.
18
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
In Sweden, the expression CIMIC is equivalent to the Defence co-operation and the
regular co-operation between authorities¹.
Supporting factors
Factors who are supporting the use of CIMIC:
• CIMIC-activities represent a part of the military commanders resources to execute
the overall mission.
• The CIMIC function would be a fully integrated part in the headquarter and have a
complete general view over CIMIC activities in the area of operations.
• CIMIC represent the interface with the civilian organisations. Primarily in the
initial stage will the military resources be used, but that cannot intrude on the
execution of the military mission.
19
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
The CIMIC activities and the CIMIC support to civilian assets is contributing to the
reduction of conflicts and tense among the civilian inhabitants, which often occur as a
result of the military activities. CIMIC activities should be simple and should be
supported with proper resources, including well trained (CIMIC) personnel. Early co-
ordination and negotiations with civilian authorities would ensure an effective and
successful operation.
The CIMIC activities in Bosnia-Herzegovina have the following generic struc ture:
At the operational level at SFOR HQ in Sarajevo it is the J9 who leads the CIMIC
activities within the SFOR area of operation.
At the tactical level there are the three multinational divisions with their G5 who co-
ordinates CIMIC within their respe ctive area of operation.
20
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Principles
• The principles of the CIMIC work could be divided in to three main categories.
• Civil-military Liaison (CML)
• Support to the Civil Environment (SCE)
• Support to the Force (STF)
Civil-military Liaison
CML is liaison between the military unit and the civilian organisations (IO, GO and
NGO), local authorities and the inhabitants in the area.
Through efficient liaison CIMIC is able to obtain an insight into the processes within
the civilian organisations and could consequently contribute to operational plans.
21
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
CIMIC is to facilitate the co-operation between the local inhabitants and civilian
authorities, so the military achievements will be successful when it comes to the
transmission of responsibility to the civilian agencies according the operational plans.
In accordance to all other functions of support, CIMIC must perform through efforts
with a fixed purpose to ensure the maximum effect. Commanders should be able to
prioritise and command CIMIC operations and activities in a way so that the military
efficiency is maintained, without any increased civilian suffering.
Economy
The military resources are proportioned to execute the military task. The CIMIC
function has to economize on the military resources so that support to civilian
operations/executions is adapte d to promote the execution of the main military task.
The use of military resources to civilian purposes would possibly create a dependant
civilian environment.
22
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Priority of efforts
The military task has under all circumstances priority.
The use of military resources should be used in operations where they contribute to
reach success. A priority when using military resources would contribute to improve
the civilian inhabitants’ opinion of the military and their intention to safeguard the
inhabitants’ interest.
Disunion concerning priority and the use of military resources might end up in a
limited effect on the inhabitants and the execution of the military tasks. This can
result in an extended mission, with all civilian and military consequences this will
involve.
Humanitarian obligations
A military commander has a juridical responsibility to maintain the international laws
and convention i conjunction with armed conflicts. The rules of war claim that the
military operations influence on non-combatants is limited. This is a basic principle
when establishing the legitimacy of a mission. The use of military power will lead to,
with few exceptions, a human suffering. As well, the individuals’ as the people’s
dignity and human rights should be respected and guarded according to international
law and units’ Rules of Engagement (ROE).
23
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Common aims
When links to the civilian authorities and the organisations are established, demands
have to be made to maintain and develop them in order to consolidate the co-
operation. Therefore, should common aims be stipulated and the military commander
should integrate these aims in military plans and operations.
Allocation of responsibility
Culture, organising and working methods in the civilian organisations that military
forces should be co-operating with are exceedingly different. Processing the common
aims should lead to agreement concerning allocation of responsibility and a valid and
an interchangeable co-operation should be established and be maintained.
Civilian advantages
Civilian authorities, agencies and organisations and the civilian inhabitants could due
to different reasons, be unwilling to co-operate with military entities. They could due
to lessons learned feel distrust towards the military or they could be worried about
that such co-operation should damage their independence and authority. A military
force could however be in a position to offer them resources, who could satisfy the
civilian needs in emergencies. This can be executed in many ways, i.e. through
offering medical resources, manpower, equipment or information.
Openness
To have successful CIMIC activities, mutual confidence and respect is needed
between the parties involved. The CIMIC work should be characterized by openness
and the ambition to get the confidence and faith of the civilian environment.
Tensions in the political, military humanitarian work or other kinds could sometimes
lead to confusion and misunderstanding. Such tension can get worse through political
prejudice, incorrect or delayed information by the media and the lack of
communication. The CIMIC personnel could be a valuable source to loca l and civilian
information. Nevertheless, these personnel could easily be ineffective if it is used
actively for other purposes, i.e. collection of military information.
24
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Communication
An efficient communication with civilian authorities, organisations and the civilian
inhabitants is determining a constructive co-operation to proceed. The difference
between military and civilian organisations is demanding tolerance, mutual respect
and patience.
There are civilian organisations who would like to establish an independent position
to co-operation and who consider that their independence is more important than the
co-operation. The maintaining of an open and continuous communication is by these
reasons necessary to increase the understanding between the parties.
25
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
The military force could be deployed into an area where no functioning infrastructure
exists. or where its insufficient or instable. Many organisations could exist -
international, governmental, non-governmental or private – who are trying to
compensate the limitation of stability. There could also be other military and para-
military forces and groupings in the area of operations.
A missing infrastructure
In a scenario like i.e. Kosovo, where no sufficient and stable infrastructure exists,
heavy demands are placed on the international efforts.
The military force is responsible for the overall security in the area.
26
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Components
The complete CIMIC capacity could be effective when the following three
components are in place:
• A fully developed doctrine outline (directives),
• The understanding for and willingness to use the doctrine for real (training)
• The physical capacity concerning trained staff
Sweden has Joint Military Doctrine reference PSO. The plans and procedures for
missions that Sweden will contribute to are made by the organisation who is
conducting the command and control of it.
The mission area and who is in OPCOM, will decide what structure the mission will
have concerning the CIMIC capability.
Force Protection
A well executed CIMIC operation in a mission area would be a good mean for Force
Protection and the inhabitants will accept the military force.
27
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Picture 5. The benefit use of a PSO unit in relation to its readiness to take risks
Unequivocal British lessons learned are stating that you have to be ready to accept
casualties if you want to accomplish anything in an area of conflict.
The lessons learned from Bosnia shows that the Nordic countries have a balanced
Force Protection and a good effect with their CIMIC operations.
28
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Carl Bildt
The High Representative
Sarajevo, May 1996
29
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
General
As mentioned in chapter 1, CIMIC will have a very important function
through the various phases of the whole conflict. The character or the
size of the different CIMIC tasks varies and are depending on:
• What phase of the conflict you are in to. Are you in the conflict
preventive phase, in the operational phase or in the post conflict
phase?
• What strength and intensity are in the actual phase?
• Where you are geographically deployed to execute your task (close
the confrontation line or outside the area of operations itself)?
• The size of the conflicts’ affection on the civilian environment.
• What level you are at: CJTF-, division-, brigade, battalion- or
company level
The military force should be responsible for a safe environment for the
civilian entities of the Peace force and for the humanitarian assistance
organisations that are operative in the area of conflict.
30
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
This will affect as well the structure and the assignments of military
force.
31
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
32
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Dayton agrement
Mandate
Freedom of Movement
Refugee problems
Visits over IEBL/borders
Return settlements
Democratisation
Coming elections
33
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
Tasks
• Civil-Military Liaison (CML) contains the relations and co-
operation between military units and civilian authorities, the co-
operation with various actors, organisations and the inhabitants in the
area where the force will operate or is planned to operate.
The Civil-military Liaison efforts are executed on a broad scale
during all faces in a conflict.
• Support to the Civil Environment (SCE) contains all support by
military entities to the civilian authorities, the co-operation with
various actors, organisations and the inhabitants.
• Support to the Force (STF), contains the need of support of civilian
resources to the military operation.
Civil-Military Liaison
34
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
35
Ulf Jinnestrand MEMO
SWEDINT 2003-08-29
DRAFT 1
36