1 s2.0 S0376738823001898 Main

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 11

Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Journal of Membrane Science


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/memsci

Mussel stimulated modification of flexible Janus PAN/PVDF-HFP nanofiber


hybrid membrane for advanced lithium-ion batteries separator
Mao Guo a, Jing Xiong a, Xuanyang Jin a, Shengjun Lu a, **, Yufei Zhang a, ***, Jian Xu b,
Haosen Fan a, *
a
College of Materials Science and Metallurgy Engineering, Guizhou University, Guiyang, 550025, China
b
Institute of Low-dimensional Materials Genome Initiative, College of Chemistry and Environmental Engineering, Shenzhen University, Shenzhen, 518060, China

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Keywords: Bicomponent polyacrylonitrile/Poly(vinylidene fluoride-co-hexafluoropropylene) (PAN/PVDF-HFP) Janus


M-PAN/PVDF-HFP nanofibers based hybrid membrane was successfully prepared by parallel electrospinning technology. Subse­
Janus nanofibers quently, modified PAN/PVDF-HFP hybrid membrane (M-PAN/PVDF-HFP) was further fabricated via mimicking
Electrospinning
the adhesive of mussel by coating dopamine alternative through polymerization of catechol and tetraethylene­
Flexible
pentamine (TEPA) in weakly alkali solution. M-PAN/PVDF-HFP maintains the abundant pore structure of the
Separator
electrospun hybrid membrane and further provides excellent electrolyte infiltration with high porosity (82.09%)
and outstanding electrolyte retention (553.23%). Simultaneously, the mechanical strength of the separator was
significantly improved (14.36 MPa). Electrochemical studies displayed that the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite
membrane delivered superior ion conductivity (2.81 mS/cm) and wide electrochemical stability window (~5.25
V). The cell assembled by M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separator presented outstanding rate capability with high specific
capacity of 147 mAh/g at 1 C and excellent cycle stability with discharge capacity of 120 mAh/g at 1 C after 600
cycles. Furthermore, M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separator exhibited ultra-flexibility with remarkable electrochemical
performance after repeated bending for 500 to 1000 time. This work provides new insights into polyamine
modified hybrid membranes for the potential practical applications in lithium-ion batteries separator.

1. Introduction commercial polyolefin separators.


Therefore, it is urgent to develop high-performance and satisfy sep­
The great crisis from excessive consumption of fossil fuels and arators with high porosity, good electrolyte wettability, excellent me­
climate change have been gradually becoming the enormous challenge chanical strength and thermal stability to satisfy the ever-increasing
of the world due to the huge carbon emissions. To achieve the goal of market requirement of high-energy LIBs.
green and low-carbon development, vigorous development of new en­ Electrospinning technology have been extensively used to develop
ergy sources such as secondary batteries and hydrogen energy from advanced LIBs separator with high energy density, which possess the
electrolysis of water become the research hot spot [1–6]. Among various advantage of high porosity, large specific surface area, ascendant elec­
secondary batteries, lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) present the advantage trolyte infiltration and excellent electrochemical performance [9,10].
of high energy density, no memory effect, low self-discharge, long cycle To date, various polymer such as polyacrylonitrile (PAN) [11,12], pol­
life and low cost in the field of new energy field and have been widely yimide (PI) [13,14], cellulose [15,16], poly(vinylidene fluoride) (PVDF)
used in new energy vehicles, portable computers, electronic medical and [17,18] and their derivatives were prepared by electrospinning tech­
other energy storage devices [7,8]. Although the LIBs technologies are nology and applied as advanced separator for LIBs. For example, Dong
becoming more and more attractive, many safety accidents of electric et al. prepared porous PAN nanofibers membrane with different surface
vehicles burning and explosion have frequently happened owing to the and internal structures using electrospinning and phase separation
insufficient mechanical strength and imperfect thermal stability of the technology by mixing N–N-dimethylformamide (DMF) and

* Corresponding author.
** Corresponding author.
*** Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: sjlu@gzu.edu.cn (S. Lu), yfzhang@gdut.edu.cn (Y. Zhang), hsfan@gzhu.edu.cn (H. Fan).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.memsci.2023.121533
Received 17 January 2023; Received in revised form 12 February 2023; Accepted 26 February 2023
Available online 27 February 2023
0376-7388/© 2023 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
M. Guo et al. Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

Tetrahydrofuran (THF) solutions with different concentrations. Micro­ 2. Experimental section


porous structures could be formed in the fibers inside and out from
electrospinning process, which significantly increased porosity (67.7%) 2.1. Materials
and ion conductivity (1.96 mS/cm) of the separator [19]. Liang et al.
proposed a PVDF membrane obtaining from electrospinning and post PAN (Mw = 150 000) and n-Butanol were purchased from Macklin.
hot pressing process. The porosity of the PVDF membrane decreased PVDF-HFP (solef 21510) was provided by Dongguan Zhanyang polymer
slightly after heat treatment, but the mechanical strength of the mem­ material Co., Ltd. Catechol, TEPA, DMF (99.5%), Tris(hydroxymethyl)
brane was significantly improved. In compared with commercial sepa­ aminomethane, and N-methyl-pyrrolidone (NMP) were supplied by
rators, the PVDF membrane after heat treatment displayed wider Aladdin. PVDF, lithium metal, Lithium iron phosphate (LiFePO4), car­
operating voltage window (~4.8 V) and lower bulk resistance (93.5 Ω) bon black, Celgard 2325 separator, and 1 M LiPF6 electrolyte (EC: DMC:
[20]. However, the single component electrospun separators are still EMC, 1:1:1 wt%) were purchased from Guangdong Canrd New Energy
faced with the defects of low mechanical strength, poor thermal stability Technology Co., Ltd.
and low ionic conductivity. Therefore, bicomponent or multicomponent
composite membranes were proposed to meet the actual demand of 2.2. Fabrication of PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane
electrospun membranes for LIBs. Wei et al. employed coaxial electro­
spinning to produce a heat-induced shutting separator with high heat PVDF-HFP with optimum concentration of 18% was acquired by
sensitivity. As a biodegradable aliphatic polyester, Polybutylene succi­ adding PVDF-HFP powder into mixed solution (DMF: acetone, 7: 3 wt
nate (PBS) presents lower melting point than that of PE. The shell %), and an appropriate amount of PAN powder was dissolved in DMF
structure of PBS in core-shell fiber could endow the PAN@PBS com­ solvent to form 10% PAN spinning stock solution. The PAN/PVDF-HFP
posite membrane excellent thermal sensitivity. PAN could be used as the hybrid membrane was manufactured by parallel electrospinning tech­
core structure of composite membrane to expand the thermal closure nology. The PAN and PVDF-HFP solutions were divided into two
window of the fiber due to its superior thermal stability. At the same different syringes, and the electrospun film was collected on a roller 20
time, the PAN@PBS composite membrane also exhibited eminent elec­ cm away from the needles with voltage of 15 kV during the electro­
trolyte wettability and ionic conductivity [21]. Chen et al. prepared an spinning process. Simultaneously, the optimum feeding rates of PAN and
environmentally friendly PVDF/Triphenyl phosphate (TPP)/Cellulose PVDF-HFP solutions were set to 0.6 mL/h and 1 mL/h, respectively.
acetate (CA) electrospun separator. The PVDF/TPP/CA membrane dis­
played superior porosity, higher electrolyte uptake, and better thermal 2.3. Preparation of M-PAN/PVDF-HFP hybrid membrane
stability and flame retardancy than the commercial PE separator. Cel­
lulose delivered excellent electrolyte retention ability and high pyrolysis The above-mentioned PAN/PVDF-HFP complex membrane was first
temperature (~ 270 ◦ C), which endowed cellulose based hybrid mem­ rinsed in ethanol for 5 min, and then dried for further use. The clean
brane excellent thermal stability. Therefore, CA could be used to composite membrane was immersed in 10 mM Tris-HCl buffer solution
improve the ion transport rate and thermal properties of PVDF mem­ (pH = 8.5) containing TEPA (5 mM) and Catechol (5 mM) for 24 h, then
brane. At the same time, TPP is a commonly used flame retardant, and the separator was taken out, and washed several times with ethanol to
introducing TPP could manufacture a flame-retardant separator [22]. remove residual polymerization products. After that, the obtained M-
Recently, the strategy of Polydopamine (PDA) modified electrode PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane was dried at 60 ◦ C.
materials and separators have been widely used to improve electrical
conductivity, electrolyte infiltration and ionic conductivity [23–28]. 2.4. Characterization
Cao et al. prepared electrospun PVDF membrane with PDA coating on
the surface, which not only maintained the structure of PVDF nanofiber The microscopic morphologies of electrospun membranes were
membrane, but also increased the hydrophilicity of PVDF nanofiber examined by scanning electron microscope (SEM, ZEISS Gemini 300).
membrane with promoting Li+ transport [29]. Gao et al. prepared a The chemical composition of the membrane surface was determined by
PDA@PAN separator by spin coating and electrospinning. The surface of the Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy (Nicolet iS50) and X-
PAN fibers became rough and its diameter increased due to the coating ray photoelectron spectrometry (XPS, Thermo Scientific K-Alpha). The
of PDA, but it inhibited the formation of lithium dendrites through thermal contraction behaviors of Celgard 2325 separator and the M-
uniform distribution of Li+ flux. PDA modified layer not only increased PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane were observed by exposing membranes at
the ionic conductivity of separator (1.39 mS/cm), but also formed more the specific temperature for 30 min. Synchronous thermal analyzer (TG-
adhesive structures, which enhanced the physical properties of sepa­ DSC, Mettler TGA/DSC3+) and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA, TG
rator [30]. The PDA presented the advantage of extreme adhesion and 209 F1 Libra, Netzsch) were performed to further investigate the ther­
could significantly improve the hydrophilicity of the material surface. mal behavior of the membranes. DSC thermograms were recorded under
However, the high cost of dopamine significantly increased the cost of N2 with 10 ◦ C/min from 100 to 400 ◦ C, and TG results were analyzed
LIBs. Therefore, the search of dopamine alternative with economic value from 30 to 800 ◦ C with heating rate of 10 ◦ C/min under N2 atmosphere.
is urgent for LIBs separator. The separator was made into 10 mm × 50 mm sample, and the sample
Herein, self-polymerization of catechol and TEPA was selected to was tested by electronic universal testing machine (WANCE-104B) at a
simulate the modification process of dopamine to prepare a high ionic tensile speed of 20 mm/min.
conductivity separator. Initially, heat-resistant material PAN and high The weighing method was applied to measure the electrolyte uptake
mechanical strength polar polymer PVDF-HFP were chosen to prepare of separator by calculating the weight before and after the separator
an excellent two-component Janus nanofibers based composite mem­ absorbed the electrolyte for 2 h [31]:
brane by parallel electrospinning technology. PVDF-HFP significantly
W2 − W1
enhanced the mechanical strength of the hybrid membrane in compar­ Electrolyte uptake % = × 100% (1)
W1
ison of pure PAN films. Then, the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite mem­
brane was further obtained by the self-polymerization of catechol and Where W1 and W2 are the masses before and after the separator absorbed
TEPA, which presented superior electrolyte infiltration and low bulk the electrolyte, respectively. The absorption experiment of n-butanol
resistance. When used as separator of LIBs, M-PAN/PVDF-HFP hybrid was executed to detect the porosity of separator [32], as shown below:
membrane displayed remarkable electrochemical performance and
provided a potential application in the commercial use of LIBs system. Porosity % =
Wb − Wa
× 100% (2)
ρn × S × d

2
M. Guo et al. Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

Where Wa and Wb are the masses of separator before and after absorbed obviously insoluble of PAN and PVDF-HFP is conducive to form Janus
n-butanol, respectively. The ρn is the density of n-butanol. The d and S structure nanofibers. Under the electric field, the two spinning stock
are the thickness and the area of separator, respectively. solutions converged into a two-component mixed Taylor cone at the end
point of the needle, and then the PAN/PVDF-HFP composite film was
collected on the roller, as shown in Fig. 1. Inspired by the adhesion of
2.5. Electrochemical test mussel protein, the modified M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane
was obtained through by self-polymerization of TEPA and catechol,
The electrochemical impedance spectra (EIS) were applied to presenting the yellow flexible membrane (Fig. 1 and 2a).
calculate the ion conductivity of separator by measuring stainless steel/ FTIR and XPS was adopted to analyze the chemical compositions of
separator with electrolyte adsorbed/stainless steel cell at 5 mV AC the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane, Fig. 2b FTIR results demonstrated
amplitude in the range of 0.1 Hz to 100k Hz on an electrochemical C–F and C–F3 stretching vibration peaks of PVDF-HFP at 840 cm-1, 875
workstation, as below [33]: cm-1, and 1180 cm-1, respectively [31,34,35]. Simultaneously, the peak
d at 2245 cm-1 could be attributed to the C≡N characteristic peak of PAN
σ= (3) polymer, which proved that the two-component PAN/PVDF-HFP com­
Rb × S
posite membrane had been successfully prepared. Furthermore, the
Where Rb is the bulk resistance of separator. The d and S represent the peaks at 1506 cm-1 and 1670 cm-1 were derived from the vibration of
thickness and the area of separator, respectively. Concurrently, linear N–H and the overlap of C– – C on the aromatic ring [36,37], which
sweep voltammetry (LSV) was performed at a rate of 5 mV/s in the indicated that Catechol and TEPA were successfully coated on the sur­
voltage range of 3–6 V for Li/separator/stainless steel batteries. face of PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane.
The electrochemical performance was evaluated by assembling In addition, as shown in Fig. 2c, the O 1s peak of the composite
LiFePO4/liquid electrolyte-soaked separator/Li battery. The mass membrane was attributed to the sample after the reaction of Catechol
loading of LiFePO4 was about 1.24 mg cm-2 and the cathode was with TEPA. The C 1s spectrum could be divided into five peaks at 284.77
composed of well mixed LiFePO4, carbon black, and PVDF in a mass eV, 286.40 eV, 288.61 eV, 290.89 eV, and 293.47 eV, which were
ratio of 7:2:1. The battery was charged and discharged at different attributed to C–C, C–O/C–N, C– – O, C–F, and C–F3, respectively (Fig. 2d).
current densities (0.1C, 0.2C, 0.5C, 1 C, 2 C, 3 C, and 0.1C, per 5 cycles), The N 1s spectrum could be fitted into three peaks (Fig. 2e), the char­
and the cycle stability was explored at 1 C current density over the acteristic peaks at 398.80 eV and 399.97 eV were assigned to C– – N and
potential range of 2.5–4.2 V. Furthermore, the flexibility of the M-PAN/ C–N, respectively. Besides, the peak at 401.63 eV was derived from the
PVDF-HFP membrane was evaluated by alternately bending and folding nitrile group of PAN. Similarly, the intense peak at 532.03 eV and the
to form various shapes. The electrochemical performance of battery with weak peak at 533.71 eV were attributed to C– – O and C–O bonds
bent M-PAN/PVDF-HFP flexible membrane was estimated by the same (Fig. 2f), respectively. XPS analysis results were in accordance with FTIR
method mentioned above. results, indicating the successful modification M-PAN/PVDF-HFP
membrane from Catechol and TEPA.
3. Results and discussion Fig. 3a–c demonstrated the surface micromorphology of PAN, PAN/
PVDF-HFP, and M − PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes. The PAN separator
The PAN and PVDF-HFP solutions were mixed together to obtain with uniform fiber was manufactured through electrospinning, which
1ight grey solution (Fig. S1a). After standing for 12h and 24h, the showed smooth fibers surface and average diameter of 221 ± 26 nm
mixture presents obvious solution delamination (Figs. S1a and b). The (Fig. 3a). As shown in Fig. 3b, PAN/PVDF-HFP bicomponent nanofibers

Fig. 1. Schematic illustration of electrospinning process of M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane.

3
M. Guo et al. Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

Fig. 2. (a) The digital photo of M-PAN/PVDF-HFP hybrid membrane; (b) FTIR results of PAN, PVDF-HFP, PAN/PVDF-HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes; (c)
XPS spectrum of M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane; (d-f) High-resolution C 1s, N 1s and O 1s spectra of M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane.

Fig. 3. (a-c) SEM of nanofiber membranes PAN, PAN/PVDF-HFP and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP; (d) EDS elements spectrum of M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite separator; (e)
EDS elements mapping of M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite separator.

4
M. Guo et al. Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

presented large fiber diameter (average diameter of 367 ± 48 nm). In addition, Celgard 2325 separator exhibited poor electrolyte
Moreover, the surface of the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP fiber was relatively wettability, in which electrolyte droplets existed in a semicircular state
rough and owned larger fiber diameter, with average diameter 372 ± on the surface with no apparent change within 3 s because of the low
41 nm (Fig. 3c). This could be attributed to the modified layer coated on surface tension and porosity of commercial separator (Fig. 5a). It is
the surface of PAN/PVDF-HFP nanofibers, and thickness of the modified widely known that electrospun membranes possess rich pore structures,
layer generated by Catechol and TEPA was only about 10 nm, which which could improve the absorption capacity of electrolyte. Therefore,
would not block the pores of the separator. the electrospun PAN separator presented a small contact angle, which
As illustrated in Fig. 3d–e, C, F, N, and O four elements were detected decreased from 32.6◦ to 17.8◦ within 3 s. After combination with PVDF-
on the surface of the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane, and the element HFP, the PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane exhibited better affinity
contents before and after membrane modification were compared. The for electrolyte than that of pure PAN membrane due to the strong af­
content ratio of C and F elements decreased after modification, and the finity for electrolyte of PVDF-HFP. The affinity for electrolyte was
component ratio of N and O elements increased to a certain extent (the O further improved by M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite separator modified
element in the unmodified separator may come from H2O or CO2 in the by Catechol and TEPA, and the contact angle of electrolyte was only 7.8◦
air), and the increased N and O elements mainly came from Catechol and after 3 s. The lower contact angle signified that M-PAN/PVDF-HFP
TEPA. Meanwhile, it could be observed from Fig. 3e that F, N, and O separator was more hydrophily to the electrolyte, which was conducive
three elements were uniformly present on the membrane surface, which to enhancing electrolyte uptake. Fig. 5b–c compared the diffusion rate
confirmed that the polyamine modified layer was uniformly distribution and the immersion height of Celgard 2325 and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP
on the membrane surface. membrane to the electrolyte. Apparently, M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane
The high porosity of separator is more conducive to the uptake of delivered the better diffusion rate in 30 s, and it expressed higher
electrolyte and the transport of Li+. The porosity of separator was infiltration height (38 mm) than that of Celgard 2325 separator (20
summarized in Fig. 4 and Table S1. The Celgard 2325 separator pre­ mm), which was ascribed to the lyophilic to the electrolyte of M-PAN/
pared by dry stretching had only 43.55% porosity, while the electrospun PVDF-HFP composite membrane.
membrane owned rich pore structure, which showed higher porosity. The thermal stability of membrane is an important parameter to
The two-component composite membrane PAN/PVDF-HFP prepared by evaluate the safety of LIBs. To study the thermal stability of separator,
parallel electrospinning showed the highest porosity (85.70%), almost Celgard 2325 and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separators were each heated at
twice that of the Celgard 2325 membrane. Catechol and TEPA were self- gradient temperatures for 30 min, and their thermal stability was
polymerized on the PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane surface, which slightly analyzed by observing the thermal contraction of separators. The Cel­
harmed the porosity of the modified M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite gard 2325 separator experienced severe thermal contraction at 150 ◦ C,
membrane, but it still had the high porosity of 82.09%. Consequently, with a shrinkage rate of up to 30% (Fig. 6a), and Celgard 2325 lost its
the modified layer polymerized by Catechol and TEPA could not block structural integrity in a molten state at 200 ◦ C, which could be attributed
the pore of the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane, which could better absorb to the low thermal stability of PP and PE. The M-PAN/PVDF-HFP
and retain electrolyte, and provide more Li+ transmission channels to separator showed superior thermal stability at 180 ◦ C and retaining
promote Li+ migration. more than 80% of the initial structure. The modified membrane also
The adsorption capacity of the membrane to the electrolyte is a exhibited preferable thermal stability at 200 ◦ C, retaining about 70% of
significant factor for the performance of LIBs. Fig. 4 and Table S1 its initial structure.
summarized the electrolyte retention rates of Celgard 2325 separator, It could be seen from the DSC spectrum in Fig. 6b that Celgard 2325
PAN, PAN/PVDF-HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP electrospun membranes. presented two endothermic peaks at 136 ◦ C and 162 ◦ C, corresponding
The Celgard 2325 separator presented retention rate of only 214.67%. to the melting temperatures of PE and PP, respectively [25]. However,
The electrospun PAN and PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes with abundant
pore structure exhibited excellent electrolyte retention, with electrolyte
retention rates of 467.86% and 502.32%, respectively. The M-PAN/
PVDF-HFP composite membrane exhibited higher electrolyte uptake of
553.23%. In conclusion, M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane
owned superior electrolyte uptake, which was instrumental in
improving Li+ transmission and enhancing the electrochemical perfor­
mance of cells.

Fig. 5. (a) Dynamic electrolyte contact angle tests of Celgard 2325, PAN, PAN/
PVDF-HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes with time; (b) Photographs of
the Celgard 2325 and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes after different wetting
Fig. 4. Porosity, electrolyte uptake, and ionic conductivity of Celgard 2325, time by electrolyte; (c) Contrast of Celgard 2325 and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP
PAN, PAN/PVDF-HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separators. membranes on electrolyte immersion-height.

5
M. Guo et al. Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

Fig. 6. (a) Thermal shrinkage behavior of separators at different temperature; b DSC results of Celgard 2325 and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separators; (c-d) TGA and DTG
results of PAN, PAN/PVDF-HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separators; (e) Stress-strain curves of PAN, PAN/PVDF-HFP and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes; (f-h)
Flexible and folding performance of M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane.

M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane showed no obvious melting after Catechol and TEPA modification. The tensile strength raised from
endothermic peak, and only an exothermic peak appeared at 320 ◦ C, 12.78 MPa to 14.36 MPa, and the breaking elongation increased from
because the PAN cyclization reaction occurred and the conjugated 21.74% to 27.84%. This could be attributed to Catechol and TEPA self-
structure was formed at this temperature [38]. DSC results were similar polymerize on the surface of nanofibers, thus forming more adhesive
to the above heat treatment results, which confirmed exceptional ther­ structures. The high mechanical strength of the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP
mal stability of the composite membrane based on PAN. In addition, separator satisfied the requirements of mechanical properties of sepa­
TGA was used to probe the thermogravimetric behavior of the rator for LIBs. To better explore the effect of separator flexibility on the
M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane. From Fig. 6c–d could be electrochemistry and security performance of LIBs, flexible bending
observed that PAN, PAN/PVDF-HFP and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes experiments and electrochemical tests after membrane bending were
presented similar thermogravimetric behavior and all began thermal characterized. The results indicated that the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP com­
decomposition at 310 ◦ C. Nevertheless, PAN and PAN/PVDF-HFP posite membranes displayed remarkable flexibility, which can be easily
membranes reached the maximum thermal decomposition tempera­ crosswise folded, multiple folded and even folded into paper plane
ture of 320 ◦ C for the first time soon after the initial decomposition. The (Fig. 6 f-h). The excellent flexibility of the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite
M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane showed higher thermal sta­ membrane provided more convenience and security, which could fully
bility, reaching the fastest pyrolysis temperature of 345 ◦ C for the first satisfy the transport and assembly of batteries and provided feasibility
time. Therefore, the modified M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite separator for practical application of the electrospun membrane.
owned outstanding thermal stability, which might greatly ensure the The combustion experiment of separators under flame was also
security of LIBs. simulated. Celgard 2325, PAN/PVDF-HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP sep­
The separator should possess excellent porosity, electrolyte affinity, arators were exposed to fire and the combustion process and final
and thermal stability, but also good mechanical strength, so that it could product of the separators were recorded (Fig. 7 and Fig. S2). Celgard
withstand the stress in the battery manufacturing process. Fig. 6e 2325 separator suddenly occurred thermal shrinkage at the moment of
showed the low tensile strength (5.86 MPa) and elongation at break contact with the flame, without any residual product after burning.
(17.29%) of the electrospun PAN film. PVDF-HFP with high mechanical PAN/PVDF-HFP and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separators had similar com­
strength could significantly ameliorate the tensile strength of the PAN/ bustion behaviors, showing superior thermal stability and forming res­
PVDF-HFP composite membrane. Meanwhile, the mechanical properties idues after combustion. Furthermore, compared with the PAN/PVDF-
of the PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane were further enhanced HFP membrane, the combustion residues of the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP

6
M. Guo et al. Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

Fig. 7. Combustion test of Celgard 2325, PAN/PVDF-HFP and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separators.

composite membrane presented fluffier carbon layer and richer pore The electrochemical stability windows of Celgard 2325, PAN, PAN/
structure. The resulting carbon layer acts as a protective layer shield by PVDF-HFP and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes were determined by LSV.
preventing the further penetration of oxygen and heat. In conclusion, The electrochemical oxidation limit is determined by the surge oxida­
the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP hybrid film with perfect thermal stability and tion current generated as the electrolyte is decomposed. The battery
physical properties showed great potential in the safety performance of with Celgard 2325 showed a sharp increase in oxidation current at
LIBs. ~4.25 V (Fig. 8b), while PAN, PAN/PVDF-HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP
The ionic conductivity of separator is one of the important parame­ separator cells all revealed a wide electrochemical stability window
ters to measure electrochemical performance. Fig. 8a exhibited the EIS (~5.25 V). In conclusion, M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane
spectra of Celgard 2325, PAN, PAN/PVDF-HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP showed excellent electrochemical stability.
separators. The Celgard 2325 separator displayed the largest bulk The electrochemical properties of the cells with various separators
resistance (1.89 Ω) with the low ionic conductivity of 0.47 mS/cm. The were analyzed by assembling Li metal/separator/LiFePO4 coin batteries.
electrospun membrane owned abundant pore structure and provided The discharge capacities of cells assembled by Celgard 2325, PAN/
good wettability and retention ability for electrolyte, which was PVDF-HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separators at 0.1C are 149 mAh/g,
conducive to promoting Li+ transmission. Therefore, PAN, PAN/PVDF- 169 mAh/g, and 170 mAh/g, respectively (Fig. 9a). Furthermore, the
HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes all delivered low bulk resis­ discharge capacities of three cells all decreased with the increase of
tance of 1.13 Ω, 1.03 Ω and 0.88 Ω, respectively. The bulk resistance and current rates, but the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane assem­
ionic conductivity of separators were summarized in Table S1 and bled cell showed the highest discharge capacity at each rate. Fig. 9b–c
Fig. 8a. Compared with the Celgard 2325 separator, PAN, PAN/PVDF- displayed the charge-discharge curves of cells at 0.1C and 3 C rates,
HFP and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes all manifested high ionic con­ respectively. When the current increased from 0.1C to 3 C, the discharge
ductivity with values of 2.03 mS/cm, 2.06 mS/cm and 2.81 mS/cm, capacities retained by batteries with three different separators were 91
respectively. The M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane showed the mAh/g, 102 mAh/g, and 117 mAh/g, respectively. The cell with M-
lowest bulk resistance and the highest ionic conductivity, which indi­ PAN/PVDF-HFP composite separator delivered the lowest specific ca­
cated that the modified layer of Catechol and TEPA enhanced the pacity decay of 31%, in comparison with 39% and 40% from Celgard
interface compatibility between the separator and electrodes. 2325 and PAN/PVDF-HFP membranes, which proved that the cell with

Fig. 8. (a) Nyquist plots and (b) linear sweep voltammetry of the batteries with various separators.

7
M. Guo et al. Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

Fig. 9. (a) Rate performance of batteries with various separators; (b-c) Charge-discharge curves of cells of three types of separators at rates of 0.1C and 3 C; (d-e)
Charge-discharge voltage platforms for cells assembled by Celgard 2325 and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separators at 1 C; (f) Comparison of rate capacity of M-PAN/PVDF-
HFP composite separator and others in literature; (g) Cycle performance of batteries with Celgard 2325, PAN/PVDF-HFP, and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separators at 1 C.

M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separator exhibited superior rate stability. Simulta­ discharge capacities of cells with Celgard 2325 and PAN/PVDF-HFP
neously, the cells with all separators showed stable charge-discharge separators were only 81 mAh/g and 102 mAh/g, and their capacity
voltage platforms at current densities of 0.1C and 3 C. Fig. 9f demon­ decays per cycle were 0.0551% and 0.0379%, respectively. Further­
strated that the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane modified by Catechol and more, the coulomb efficiency of the battery with the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP
TEPA showed excellent discharge capacity at various rates, compared separator was 98.20% after 600 cycles, which was much higher than the
with the separators reported in the literature [21,26,29,31,36,39,40]. battery with Celgard 2325 separator (94.96%). The high coulomb effi­
The M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane prepared in this work had ciency of LIBs is beneficial to the reversibility of batteries in practical
more advantages and could be used as a candidate material for the ideal applications. In conclusion, M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane
separator of high-performance LIBs. modified by Catechol and TEPA displayed good interface compatibility
The charge-discharge voltage platforms of the cells with Celgard with the electrodes, which was conducive to the transmission of Li+.
2325 and M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separators remained stable during the Therefore, the battery constituted by M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite
charge-discharge cycle, but the discharge capacities of batteries membrane could show high discharge capacity and cycle stability.
decreased gradually with the increased cycle life (Fig. 9d–e). Concur­ The M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane still guaranteed the integrity of
rently, the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP separator assembled battery showed the initial structure after alternately bending hundreds of times, due to
lower polarization due to its higher ionic conductivity. Fig. 9g showed the exceptional flexibility of the membrane. As shown in Fig. 10a,
the cycle stability of cells with Celgard 2325, PAN/PVDF-HFP, and M- flexible membranes formed by repeated bending 500 and 1000 times
PAN/PVDF-HFP separators. The battery with M-PAN/PVDF-HFP sepa­ were designed, named B-500 and B-1000, respectively. The electro­
rator demonstrated higher discharge discharge capacity and lower chemical testing of the batteries with flexible membranes was carried
discharge capacity attenuation (the specific capacity attenuation of the out. The same electrochemical test was performed for the cell with
cell per cycle was only 0.0306% after 600 cycles at 1 C). However, the flexible membrane as battery assembled by the unbent separator.

8
M. Guo et al. Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

Fig. 10. (a) Diagram of the alternate bending process of separator; (b) Rate performance of batteries with M-PAN/PVDF-HFP, B-500, and B-1000 membranes; (c)
Comparison of rate performance of cells with M-PAN/PVDF-HFP, B-500, B-1000, and Celgard 2325 separators at different rates; (d) Cycle stability of cells with M-
PAN/PVDF-HFP, B-500, and B-1000 membranes at 1 C; (e) Comparison of discharge capacity with M-PAN/PVDF-HFP, B-500, B-1000, and Celgard 2325 separators at
different cycles.

Fig. 10b–c showed that the rate capacity of the batteries assembled by bending during battery transport and assembly, and better ensure the
the bent separators had a certain degree of attenuation, and the B-1000 advance of cells.
battery exhibited outstanding rate stability and high discharge capacity
of 135 mAh/g, 123 mAh/g, and 95 mAh/g at rates of 0.5C, 1 C, and 3 C. 4. Conclusion
The batteries assembled by flexible membranes exhibited higher
discharge capacity than Celgard 2325 at high rates. Simultaneously, the In conclusion, the bicomponent PAN/PVDF-HFP composite sepa­
batteries with bent separator still displayed splendid cycle stability and rator prepared by parallel electrospinning technology showed the su­
coulomb efficiency at 1 C, and the B-500 and B-1000 batteries showed periorities of both PAN and PVDF-HFP polymers, and the high
high discharge capacities of 135 mAh/g and 123 mAh/g, respectively. mechanical strength of PVDF-HFP improved the mechanical strength of
Similarly, the cycle stability and capacity attenuation of the flexible the pure PAN membrane. In addition, the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite
separator batteries were superior to those of the Celgard 2325 batteries. membrane coated with Catechol and TEPA exhibited high porosity and
The electrochemical performance was adversely affected by the bending electrolyte wettability. Electrochemical tests delivered that the rate
of the membrane, and the capacity attenuation increased with the in­ performance and cycle stability of cells were conspicuously enhanced.
crease of the bending frequency. Although the discharge capacity of cell The high discharge capacity and capacity stability resulted from the fact
assembled by the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane had a certain attenua­ that the Catechol and TEPA modified layer enhanced the interfacial
tion after bending, it still showed excellent electrochemical perfor­ compatibility between separator and electrodes and promoted the
mance. It was proved that M-PAN/PVDF-HFP composite membrane transport of Li+. Moreover, the M-PAN/PVDF-HFP membrane displayed
obtained by parallel electrospinning technology and TEPA and Catechol exceptional flexibility, and exhibited prosperous electrochemical per­
coating modification had excellent flexibility, which could satisfy the formance after repeated bending 1000 cycles. Therefore, the M-PAN/

9
M. Guo et al. Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

PVDF-HFP separator was obtained by modifying with catechol and [13] X. Song, Z. Wang, F. Zhao, Y. Sun, B. Cheng, J. Xing, A separator with a novel
thermal crosslinking structure based on electrospun PI/A-POSS for lithium-ion
TEPA could have bright prospects in replacing commercial batteries
battery with high safety and outstanding electrochemical performance, Adv. Mater.
separators. Interfac. 8 (2021), 2100458.
[14] L. He, J.-H. Cao, T. Liang, D.-Y. Wu, Effect of monomer structure on properties of
polyimide as LIB separator and its mechanism study, Electrochim. Acta 337 (2020),
CRediT authorship contribution statement
135838.
[15] N. Yang, Y. Liang, S. Jia, Enhanced thermal stability and electrochemical
Mao Guo: Data curation, Writing original draft; Xuanyang Jin and performance of polyacrylonitrile/cellulose acetate-electrospun fiber membrane by
Jing Xiong: Investigation; Jian Xu: Formal analysis; Yufei Zhang and boehmite nanoparticles: application to high-performance lithium-ion batteries,
Macromol. Mater. Eng. 306 (2021), 2100300.
Shengjun Lu: Supervision, Writing-review & editing; Haosen Fan: [16] S. Wang, D. Zhang, Z. Shao, S. Liu, Cellulosic materials-enhanced sandwich
Supervision, Methodology, Writing-review & editing. structure-like separator via electrospinning towards safer lithium-ion battery,
Carbohydr. Polym. 214 (2019) 328–336.
[17] L. Liu, T. Xu, X. Gui, S. Gao, L. Sun, Q. Lin, X. Song, Z. Wang, K. Xu, Electrospun
Declaration of competing interest Silsequioxane-grafted PVDF hybrid membranes for high-performance rechargeable
lithium batteries, Composites, Part B. 215 (2021), 108849.
[18] J.C. Barbosa, D.M. Correia, R. Goncalves, V. de Zea Bermudez, M.M. Silva,
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial
S. Lanceros-Mendez, C.M. Costa, Enhanced ionic conductivity in poly(vinylidene
interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence fluoride) electrospun separator membranes blended with different ionic liquids for
the work reported in this paper. lithium ion batteries, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 582 (2021) 376–386.
[19] T. Dong, W.U. Arifeen, J. Choi, K. Yoo, T. Ko, Surface-modified electrospun
polyacrylonitrile nano-membrane for a lithium-ion battery separator based on
Data availability phase separation mechanism, Chem. Eng. J. 398 (2020), 125646.
[20] Y. Liang, S. Cheng, J. Zhao, C. Zhang, S. Sun, N. Zhou, Y. Qiu, X. Zhang, Heat
Data will be made available on request. treatment of electrospun Polyvinylidene fluoride fibrous membrane separators for
rechargeable lithium-ion batteries, J. Power Sources 240 (2013) 204–211.
[21] Z. Wei, J. Gu, F. Zhang, Z. Pan, Y. Zhao, Core–shell structured nanofibers for
Acknowledgments lithium ion battery separator with wide shutdown temperature window and stable
electrochemical performance, ACS Applied Poly. Mater. 2 (2020) 1989–1996.
[22] Y. Chen, L. Qiu, X. Ma, L. Dong, Z. Jin, G. Xia, P. Du, J. Xiong, Electrospun cellulose
This work was supported by National Natural Science Foundation of polymer nanofiber membrane with flame resistance properties for lithium-ion
China (52101243), “100-level” Innovative Talents Project of Guizhou batteries, Carbohydr. Polym. 234 (2020), 115907.
Province China ([2016] 5653), Natural Science Foundation of Guang­ [23] H. Fan, H. Yu, Y. Zhang, J. Guo, Z. Wang, H. Wang, N. Zhao, Y. Zheng, C. Du,
Z. Dai, Q. Yan, J. Xu, 1D to 3D hierarchical iron selenide hollow nanocubes
dong Province (2023A1515012619) and Science and Technology Plan­ assembled from FeSe2@C core-shell nanorods for advanced sodium ion batteries,
ning Project of Guangzhou (202102010373). Energy Storage Mater. 10 (2018) 48–55.
[24] C. Cao, L. Tan, W. Liu, J. Ma, L. Li, Polydopamine coated electrospun poly
(vinyldiene fluoride) nanofibrous membrane as separator for lithium-ion batteries,
Appendix A. Supplementary data J. Power Sources 248 (2014) 224–229.
[25] M.Q. Wang, X.L. Liu, B.Y. Qin, Z.Y. Li, Y.F. Zhang, W. Yang, H.S. Fan, In-situ
Supplementary data to this article can be found online at https://doi. etching and ion exchange induced 2D-2D MXene@Co9S8/CoMo2S4 heterostructure
for superior Na+ storage, Chem. Eng. J. 451 (2023), 138508.
org/10.1016/j.memsci.2023.121533. [26] Y.K. Jeong, S.H. Park, J.W. Choi, Mussel-inspired coating and adhesion for
rechargeable batteries: a review, ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 10 (2018)
References 7562–7573.
[27] X. Li, H. Liang, B. Qin, M. Wang, Y. Zhang, H. Fan, Rational design of
heterostructured bimetallic sulfides (CoS2/NC@VS4) with VS4 nanodots decorated
[1] Q.X. Deng, M.Q. Wang, X.L. Liu, H.S. Fan, Y.F. Zhang, H.Y. Yang, Ultrathin cobalt
on CoS2 dodecahedron for high-performance sodium and potassium ion batteries,
nickel selenides (Co0.5Ni0.5Se2) nanosheet arrays anchoring on Ti3C2 MXene for
J. Colloid Interface Sci. 625 (2022) 41–49.
high-performance Na+/K+ batteries, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 626 (2022) 700–709.
[28] Q. Deng, X. Liu, Z. Li, H. Fan, Y. Zhang, H. Yang, Cobalt-nickel bimetallic sulfide
[2] Y. Ding, Q. Zhang, K. Rui, F. Xu, H.J. Lin, Y. Yan, H. Li, J.X. Zhu, W. Huang,
(NiS2/CoS2) based dual-carbon framework for super sodium ion storage, J. Colloid
Ultrafast microwave activating polarized electron for scalable porous Al towards
Interface Sci. 633 (2023) 480–488.
high-energy-density batteries, Nano Lett. 20 (2020) 8818–8824.
[29] C. Cao, L. Tan, W. Liu, J. Ma, L. Li, Polydopamine coated electrospun poly
[3] X.L. Liu, Z.T. Liu, W. Yang, M.Q. Wang, B.Y. Qin, Y.F. Zhang, Z.L. Liu, H.S. Fan, In
(vinyldiene fluoride) nanofibrous membrane as separator for lithium-ion batteries,
situ fragmented and confined CoP nanocrystals into sandwich-structure MXene@
J. Power Sources 248 (2014) 224–229.
CoP@NPC heterostructure for superior sodium-ion storage, Mater. Today Chem. 26
[30] Y. Gao, X. Sang, Y. Chen, Y. Li, B. Liu, J. Sheng, Y. Feng, L. Li, H. Liu, X. Wang,
(2022), 101002.
C. Kuang, Y. Zhai, Polydopamine modification electrospun polyacrylonitrile
[4] Y.F. Lu, H.J. Zhang, H.D. Liu, Z.T. Nie, F. Xu, Y. Zhao, J.X. Zhu, W. Huang,
fibrous membrane with decreased pore size and dendrite mitigation for lithium ion
Electrolyte dynamics engineering for flexible fiber-shaped aqueous zinc-ion battery
battery, J. Mater. Sci. 55 (2019) 3549–3560.
with ultralong stability, Nano Lett. 22 (2021) 9651–9660.
[31] M. Cai, D. Yuan, X. Zhang, Y. Pu, X. Liu, H. He, L. Zhang, X. Ning, Lithium ion
[5] Z.H. Su, J.H. Huang, R.H. Wang, Y. Zhang, L.X. Zeng, Y.F. Zhang, H.S. Fan,
battery separator with improved performance via side-by-side bicomponent
Multilayer structure covalent organic frameworks (COFs) linking by double
electrospinning of PVDF-HFP/PI followed by 3D thermal crosslinking, J. Power
functional groups for advanced K+ batteries, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 639 (2023)
Sources 461 (2020), 228123.
7–13.
[32] L. Zhang, X. Li, M. Yang, W. Chen, High-safety separators for lithium-ion batteries
[6] R. Sun, S. Dong, J. Yang, J. Xiong, C. Wang, S. Lu, Y. Zhang, H. Fan, Defect
and sodium-ion batteries: advances and perspective, Energy Storage Mater. 41
engineering of molybdenum disulfide nanosheets boosting super Zn2+ storage from
(2021) 522–545.
polyaniline intercalation, Chem. Commun. 59 (2023) 1845–1848.
[33] X. Shen, Z. Li, N. Deng, J. Fan, L. Wang, Z. Xia, Y. Liu, J. Liu, Rational designing of
[7] M. Waqas, S. Ali, C. Feng, D. Chen, J. Han, W. He, Recent development in
tree-like polymer gel membrane based on PVDF/lamellar organic montmorillonite
separators for high-temperature lithium-ion batteries, Small 15 (2019), 1901689.
nanofiber with excellent flame retardancy and superior ion conductivity for high-
[8] X.L. Liu, F. Xu, Z.Y. Li, Z.T. Liu, W. Yang, Y.F. Zhang, H.S. Fan, H.Y. Yang, Design
performance lithium-ion capacitor, Chem. Eng. J. 422 (2021), 130116.
strategy for MXene and metal chalcogenides/oxides hybrids for supercapacitors,
[34] S. Wu, J. Ning, F. Jiang, J. Shi, F. Huang, Ceramic nanoparticle-decorated melt-
secondary batteries and electro/photocatalysis, Coord. Chem. Rev. 464 (2022),
electrospun PVDF nanofiber membrane with enhanced performance as a lithium-
214544.
ion battery separator, ACS Omega 4 (2019) 16309–16317.
[9] M. Guo, H. Zhu, P. Wan, F. Xu, C. Wang, S. Lu, Y. Zhang, H. Fan, J. Xu,
[35] H. Zhao, N. Deng, J. Ju, Z. Li, W. Kang, B. Cheng, Novel configuration of heat-
Freestanding and ultra-flexible PAN/ZIF-67 hybrid membrane with controlled
resistant gel polymer electrolyte with electrospun poly (vinylidene fluoride-co-
porosity for high-performance and high-safety lithium batteries separator, Adv.
hexafluoropropylene) and poly-m-phenyleneisophthalamide composite separator
Fiber Mater. 4 (2022) 1511–1524.
for high-safety lithium-ion battery, Mater. Lett. 236 (2019) 101–105.
[10] M. Liu, N. Deng, J. Ju, L. Fan, L. Wang, Z. Li, H. Zhao, G. Yang, W. Kang, J. Yan,
[36] S. Jia, J. Long, J. Li, S. Yang, K. Huang, N. Yang, Y. Liang, J. Xiao, Biomineralized
B. Cheng, A review: electrospun nanofiber materials for lithium-sulfur batteries,
zircon-coated PVDF nanofiber separator for enhancing thermo- and electro-
Adv. Funct. Mater. 29 (2019), 1905467.
chemical properties of lithium ion batteries, J. Mater. Sci. 55 (2020) 14907–14921.
[11] W.U. Arifeen, J. Choi, K. Yoo, J. Shim, T.J. Ko, A nano-silica/polyacrylonitrile/
[37] C. Shi, J. Dai, S. Huang, C. Li, X. Shen, P. Zhang, D. Wu, D. Sun, J. Zhao, A simple
polyimide composite separator for advanced fast charging lithium-ion batteries,
method to prepare a polydopamine modified core-shell structure composite
Chem. Eng. J. 417 (2021), 128075.
separator for application in high-safety lithium-ion batteries, J. Membr. Sci. 518
[12] L.-Y. Yang, J.-H. Cao, B.-R. Cai, T. Liang, D.-Y. Wu, Electrospun MOF/PAN
(2016) 168–177.
composite separator with superior electrochemical performances for high energy
density lithium batteries, Electrochim. Acta 382 (2021), 138346.

10
M. Guo et al. Journal of Membrane Science 675 (2023) 121533

[38] X. Ma, P. Kolla, R. Yang, Z. Wang, Y. Zhao, A.L. Smirnova, H. Fong, Electrospun prompt and safer thermal lithium-ion battery shutdown, J. Electrochem. Soc. 167
polyacrylonitrile nanofibrous membranes with varied fiber diameters and different (2020), 020509.
membrane porosities as lithium-ion battery separators, Electrochim. Acta 236 [40] N. Kassenova, S. Kalybekkyzy, M.V. Kahraman, A. Mentbayeva, Z. Bakenov, Photo
(2017) 417–423. and thermal crosslinked poly(vinyl alcohol)-based nanofiber membrane for flexible
[39] W. Gong, Z. Zhang, S. Wei, S. Ruan, C. Shen, L.-S. Turng, Thermosensitive gel polymer electrolyte, J. Power Sources 520 (2022), 230896.
polyacrylonitrile/polyethylene oxide/polyacrylonitrile membrane separators for

11

You might also like