Professional Documents
Culture Documents
US Healthcare System 101
US Healthcare System 101
US Healthcare System 101
Background Methodology
This report was developed in order to help New This research used secondary desktop research
Zealand businesses better understand the US based on publicly available sources and
healthcare market as they begin their discovery subscription databases such as Statista, the CDC,
journey. KFF, Census Bureau, McKinsey, NPR and other
sources.
2
Table of Contents
SECTION 1
SECTION 2
Regulatory Framework 23
SECTION 3
Trends 30
Appendix I
Dictionary of Terms 36
Appendix II
Other Content 47
Section 1
US Healthcare Statistics
As of the first half of 2021, 90.4% of According to the OECD, in 2020, life
Americans had health insurance. This a expectancy in the US is 77.3 years,
The US spent $4.1 trillion on health care in major improvement from some of the coming in 31st place. In first was Japan at
2020. In 2020. US national health expenditure lowest levels prior to the passage of the 84.7 years and New Zealand came in 14 th
was 19.7% of GDP. ACA, when some 16% of Americans went place at 82.1 years.
without health insurance in 2010.
Sources: Statista, “Health Expenditure in the US,” accessed March 16. 2022.; Statista: “Percentage of people in the US withou t health insurance, 1997-2021,” originally sourced from the CDC. 5
SECTION 1
5.0%
0.0%
United States Germany Switzerland France Japan United Australia New Zealand
Kingdom
Source: Statista health expenditures in the US Report, originally sourced from OECD, data from 2019. 6
SECTION 1
in billioins USD
increased over the last few decades.
3000
Spending really began to balloon moving into the 21st
century. Part of this rise is attributed to the growing 2000
population of aging adults in the US, but that accounts for
a small percentage of this growth. Much of it results from 1000
the fee for service model of the US healthcare system that
includes some distorted incentives as far as pricing, 0
consumption and cost savings projects go. There has been 1960 1970 1980 1990 20002005 2006200720082009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
a real increase in the cost of health care services. Truly, the
cost of care in the US is much higher comparatively than
in other countries.
An even more shocking revelation is that over 50% of the
expenditures made for health care in the US are attributed
to only 5% of people. In other words, the 5% of Americans
who spend the most on health expenditures each year are
responsible for 50% of all health expenditures in the US.
That being said, health care costs have been a notorious
problem for decades. A Health Affairs article details the
language used describing a health care crises in the US
since the 1960s.
Sources: Accessed in Statista from US CMS (Office of the Actuary) from the National Health Expenditure Accounts, released December 2021; Brookings Institute publication: “A dozen facts 7
about the economics of the US health-care system,” by Ryan Nunn, Jana Parsons and Jay Shambaugh, Mar 10, 2020; Health Affairs article, “Half a Century of the Health Care Crisis (And Still
Going Strong),” Michael Millenson, Sept 12, 2018.
SECTION 1
A unique design
New Zealand
Source: World101 – “How Health Care Works Around the World,” accessed Mar 8, 2022. 8
SECTION 1
A complicated matrix
9
Source: The Commonwealth Fund, “International Health Care System Profiles: United States,” Roosa Tikkanen, Robin Osborn, Elias Mossialos, Ana Djordjevic, George A. Wharton, June 5,
2020.
SECTION 1
The first thing to understand about health care in the US is some of the language used to describe the relationships at play.
10
SECTION 1
Hospitals per 1,000,000 people, 2016 Practicing Physicians per 1,000 people, 2017
South Korea 73.92 5.18
55.89 Switzerland 4.30
France 45.94 4.25
Sweden 4.12
37.64 3.99
Switzerland 33.80 Spain 3.88
3.68
31.36 Netherlands 3.58
Austria 31.25 3.16
Belgium 3.08
29.29 2.81
Canada 19.91 Canada 2.65
2.61
17.98 Japan 2.43
United States 17.11 2.34
China 2.01
16.44
Belgium 15.62 0.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00
0.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00 60.00 70.00 80.00
CT Scanners in hospitals, per million people, Hospital healthcare Administrative and other
Country All hospital employment staff hospital staff
2017 Switzerland 25.0 17.4 7.6
United States 20.1 10.6 9.5
South Korea 28.96 France 19.6 13.0 6.6
27.09
Italy 25.19 Belgium 18.4 11.8 6.6
24.96 Canada 17.5 11.5 6.1
Belgium 23.03 Germany 16.3 12.0 4.3
19.16
Sweden 18.49 Netherlands 15.0 15.0
17.50 Austria 13.3 13.3
Spain 16.40
12.96 Spain 12.0 9.1 2.9
France 12.32 Italy 10.3 7.6 2.7
0.00 5.00 10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00 35.00 South Korea 7.2 7.0 0.2
11
SECTION 1
In the United States, most Americans with health insurance are covered by a private Distribution of Insurance Access
insurance plan contracted through their employer.
50.3%
50%
30%
20% 17.8%
15.6%
8.6%
10%
5.5%
2.3%
0%
Employer Non-group Medicaid Medicare Military Uninsured
Health insurance status
Source: Statista Report, “Health Insurance in the United States,” data from US Census Bureau, accessed May 2022. 12
SECTION 1
Percentage of population
The Affordable Care Act passed under President Obama, 92.5% 91% 91%
which caused a major uptick in insurance enrollment 90%
90.5%
between 2013-2015 when the ACA took effect. The ACA
88.5% 86%87%87%86% 87%
made health insurance coverage mandatory for all 86%86% 86%85%
86.5% 85%85%85%85%85% 85% 85%85%
Americans, implementing a penalty for those who could 84%84% 85% 85%
84%84%84%
not provide proof of insurance coverage. 84.5%
82.5%
In order to achieve this, the ACA also expanded various '90 '91 '92 '93 '94 '95 '96 '97 '98 '99 '00 '01 '02 '03 '04 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10 '11 '12 '13 '14 '15 '16 '17 '18 '19 '20
programs to subsidize the cost of insurance for those
falling in income gaps that made it affordable to them.
14.0%
11.5%
12.0% 10.3%
9.4% 9.7% 9.6%
10.0% 9.1% 9.0% 9.1%
8.0%
1997 2005 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021*
Source: Statista Report, “Health Insurance in the United States,” originally sourced from CDC. 13
SECTION 1
Favor Oppose
An ever contentious conversation in the US, this is 65%
perhaps one of the most partisan concerns in the US. Yet,
despite what the media would have folks believe in the
59%
US, a majority of the country support a medicare-for-all 60%
57% 57%
approach in the US. 56% 56% 56% 56% 56%
55%
Percentage of respondents
55% 53% 53% 53%
There are many reasons why a more universal approach 51% 51%
has not been implemented yet.
50%
47%
45%
Some of this comes down to language. The United States 45% 43% 43%
operates under a “fee for service” model, where a value 42% 42% 42%
41% 41%
based care model would be better suited to keep costs 39%
lower and provide better health outcomes for citizens. 40% 38% 38% 38%
37%
35%
30%
Source: Statista report, “Health Insurance in the United States,” originally sourced from Kaiser Family Foundation. 14
SECTION 1
Source: Harvard Business Review, “The Case for Capitation,” from the magazine July-Aug 2016, by Brent C. James, MD and Gregory P. Poulsen. 15
SECTION 1
Source: Primary Care Collective, “Value-Based Care in America: State-by-State,” published in 2019; Kaiser permanente; Statista, “Kaiser permanente’s number of members 2007-2021,” 16
accessed June 2022.
SECTION 1
Source: Ibisworld, NAICS Report 33451B, “Medical Device Manufacturing in the US,” updated January 2022 by Jack Curran; NAICS Report 42345, “Medical Supplies Wholesaling in the US,” 17
updated May 2022 by Jack Curran.
SECTION 1
Below are some of the most popular medical trade associations for certain sectors of the industry. Another great resource for
information and statistics about hospital systems is Becker’s Hospital Review.
Medical Devices: AdvaMed Surgery/Ortho: AAOS Health IT: HIMSS Telehealth: ATA
AdvaMed (Advanced Medical Technology The American Academy of Orthopaedic The Healthcare Information and The American Telemedicine Association
Association) is the world’s largest medical Surgeons (AAOS) provides education and Management Systems Society is a is a nonprofit focused on promoting
tech association that represents device, practice management services for nonprofit focused on improving health access to medical care for consumers
diagnostics and digital technology orthopedic surgeons and other health care quality, safety, cost-effectiveness through telecommunications.
manufacturers. professionals. and access through best use of IT and
Their website includes information about
management systems.
Their website includes research and Their website includes links to their recent policy related to telemedicine,
policy papers, offers the opportunity to publications, guidelines and best Their website includes a link to their information about coming events,
sign up for their newsletter, and includes practices around medical coding, patient library that makes many webinars relevant news, interest groups, and
information about registering for safety, quality programs, options to enroll available on demand, provides a section research and other resources.
membership or to participate in their in courses and information about their with information about related news, and
conferences. annual meeting. information about upcoming events.
Source: 18
Section 2
24
SECTION 2
Source: FDA.gov, accessed April 2022; Dept of VA.gov, accessed April 2022. 27
SECTION 2
29
Section 3
TRENDS
SECTION 3
Major changes are happening in health care sector as technology is driving many parts of the industry to innovate. While there had been advancements in this area before, Covid-19 really
accelerated a lot of these innovations, spurring on more investment in and development of different solutions. Some of the leading areas of change have been in the following areas:
• Telehealth/telemedicine
• AI/machine learning adoption in health care software
• Wearable devices
Telehealth in particular saw massive adoption over the last couple of years as Covid-19 raged, driving demand for virtual care options. Regulatory changes allowed for broader adoption,
where prior to that point care providers had not been able to bill for virtual visits. Removing this barrier drove rapid adoption and many patients have indicated that they plan to continue
using this care delivery option.
31
SECTION 3
Source: McKinsey article, “The next frontier of care delivery in healthcare,” Shubham Singhal, Mathangi Radha, and Nithya Vinjamoori, March 24, 2022. 32
SECTION 3
Source: McKinsey article, “Telehealth: A quarter-trillion-dallar post-Covid-19 reality?,” Oleg Bestsennyy, Greg Gilbert, Alex Harris and Jennifer Rost, July 9, 2021. 33
SECTION 3
Source: McKinsey article, “The next frontier of care delivery in healthcare,” Shubham Singhal, Mathangi Radha, and Nithya Vinjamoori, March 24, 2022; Forbes article, “The Five Biggest 34
Healthcare Tech Trends in 2022,” Bernard Marr, Jan 10, 2022.
Headline line 1
Headline line 2
SUBHEAD LINE 1
SUBHEAD LINE 2
Disclai mer: This docume nt only co ntai ns genera l info rmatio n and is no t formal advice. The New Zeala nd Go vernment and its ass ociate d age ncie s (‘the New Zealand Go vernme nt’) do
not e ndorse or warrant the accuracy, re liabili ty or fitness fo r any purpose of a ny i nformati on provide d. It is reco mme nded that yo u se ek i nde pende nt advice on any matter relate d to the
use of the i nformation. In no eve nt w ill the New Zeala nd Go vernment be lia bl e for any loss or da ma ge w hats oeve r arisi ng from the use of the i nformati on. While every effort is ma de to
ensure the accuracy of the i nformatio n contai ne d here in, the Ne w Zealand Go vernment, its officers, e mplo yees and a ge nts accept no l iabili ty for any erro rs or o miss ions o r a ny o pi ni o n
expresse d, and no respons ibi lity is accepte d w ith res pect to the s tandi ng of any fi rms, compa nies or indi viduals me nti one d. Please unders tand tha t, although your s pecific nee ds ma y
drive the direction of our research, our reports are prepared for NZ exporters generally and are likely to be shared with multiple exporters and/or published on myNZTE.
Appendix I
DICTIONARY OF TERMS
SECTION 5
Dictionary of Terms
Affordable Care Act (ACA) Annual Limit Accountable Care Organization (ACO)
Sometimes referred to as “Obamacare,” this was the piece This is the label given to a group of health care providers
Some insurance plans place a limit on the
of health care reform that went into effect in March 2010 who work collaboratively to coordinate care with the aim
amount of money they will pay each year. It
that established the infrastructure for the health care of achieving better health outcomes that result in cost
may be specific to certain services like
exchange, required Americans to have health insurance savings.
prescriptions or a set number of visits to certain
coverage, provided more opportunities for affordable
providers. If the annual limit is reached, the
insurance, required insurance companies to cover more
member/patient is then responsible for all costs
preventive services, and expanded the Medicaid program
billed after until the year ends.
to cover more adults (among other things).
This legalese applies only to insurance plans offered For insurance plans with multiple covered This term refers to services or items covered under a
through job-based plan. This enables purchasers to qualify persons, this is the amount that must be health insurance plan. Insurers will often list out the
for a tax credit if the lowest-cost, self-only, job-based paid by the covered persons out of pocket benefits of different plans for consumers to consider
insurance plan available to them costs more than 9.61% of before the insurance company begins to before enrolling in the plan. The packages will list
the employee’s household income pay. information like deductibles, copays and co-insurances for
common types of services, as well as limits and out of
pocket maximums.
Dictionary of Terms
Coinsurance refers to the percentage of costs a member A copayment is a fixed fee patients pay for a A claim is a request for payment that is sent to the health
would pay for a certain service or item as stipulated by the covered health service. This payment goes to insurance company after a service has been provided. The
insurance plan. Oftentimes, coinsurances apply once a the service provider (ie doctor, laboratory, health insurance company will review the claim against
patient has met their deductible. etc) and is stipulated in the plan before the what is covered under the member’s individual plan and
patient enrolls. These can apply before or respond with an explanation of benefits (EOB) to the
after the deductible has been met, member and the service provider and include a payment
depending on how the plan is structured. if circumstances require.
Dictionary of Terms
Department of Health and Human Durable Medical Equipment (DME) Emergency Room Care
Services (HHS) DME refers to any equipment or supplies
This is the federal agency that sits over CMS. Emergency services tend to be quite costly and thus are
ordered by a health care provider used for covered under different language in a health insurance
everyday or extended use. For example, DME plan. Emergency room care refers to the services that
could refer to thing slike wheelchairs, oxygen result in a patient ending up in an emergency room.
equipment, crutches, etc
Dictionary of Terms
Exclusive Provider Organization (EPO) Emergency Medical Transportation Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA)
Plan (EMT)
This term refers to a type of managed care plan where This refers specifically to the ambulance This refers to the federal legislation that guarantees up to
services are only covered if provided by/within that plan’s services utilized during an emergency medical 12 weeks of leave for employees for certain circumstances.
networked providers. Normally exceptions are made for event. This could be for mental health, serious illness or disability,
emergency services. to have a child, care for a family member or for other
reasons.
Dictionary of Terms
HIPAA stands for the Health Insurance Portability and Established by the ACA, this is a federally This phrase refers to one’s legal entitlement to payment or
Accountability Act and was passed in 1996. This is a set of operated “exchange” where consumers can reimbursement for health services as stipulated under
federal laws designed to protect sensitive patient shop for and enroll in health plans. Some contract with a health insurance company or group
information from disclosure without patient consent. It states may run their own marketplaces. The health plan offered by your employer or a government
also outlines requirements to protect electronic storage landing page usually asks information about agency.
and sharing of patient records. your household and income to determine if
you qualify for tax credits or other programs.
Dictionary of Terms
This refers to the care received when admitted to a This refers to health insurance plans that are This is another phrase similar to “out of network” to refer
hospital or skilled nursing facility, normally for a longer offered to employees and their family members to a health care provider who does not have a contract
term period, as opposed to outpatient care which is through their employer. with a health insurance plan.
normally much shorter of a duration of time spent in the
medical facility.
Dictionary of Terms
This is a fixed payment paid each month to the insurance This is the term used to describe health The providers tend to be long term providers and can be
company regardless of whether the insurance is being services focused on prevention, wellness and licensed as MDs, DOs, NPs, or PAs. If your insurance plan
actively used or not. Under an employer based insurance treatment for common illnesses. requires referrals for specialists or prior authorizations for
plan, premium payments are typically shared between certain medications or procedures, these often need to be
the employer and the employee. provided by the primary care provider, viewed as the
coordinator of care for their panel of patients.
Dictionary of Terms
This is the system that distributes financial benefits to Urgent care clinics provide medical care This health care model is quite different from a fee for
retired or disabled folks and the spouses and dependents when an illness or injury requires urgent service model. This care model links provider payments to
based on their reported earnings. It is collected via tax attention but may not be severe enough to actual health outcomes. The goal is to reduce
payments made while people are working. warrant a visit to the emergency room. inappropriate care and reward better health outcomes.
Emergency room visits are quite expensive,
but it can be difficult to schedule urgent
appointments with a primary care provider
for acute issues, so urgent care can provide
a good solution in those moments.
Dictionary of Terms
Dictionary of Terms
Secondary Care
This is another term to refer to a specialist. This
refers to medical providers aside from one’s
primary care who may have a more specialized
expertise to assist with one’s condition.
OTHER CONTENT
47
SECTION 1
As previously mentioned, the cost of health care and 0 200 400 600 800 1,000 1,200
health insurance has ballooned in the US over the last
couple decades. Out-of-pocket 375.6
137.9
Private health insurance 1,078.7
204.8
The graph comparing 1990 to 2018 is particularly telling, Medicare 697.2
107.3
and part of the increase in cost resulted from employers Medicaid 532.8
69.7
looking for opportunities to ease the cost they were 15.5
CHIP*
contributing to premium payments for their employees
sponsored under their programs, but that was largely Other health insurance programs** 116.3
21.2
triggered by massive increases to premiums as well. Other third-party payers and programs*** 259.3
74.5
1,478 1,505
1,217 1,318
1,097 1,135
917 991
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
Source: Statista Report, “Health Insurance in the United States,” accessed May 2022. 48
SECTION 1
Source: Statista report, “Health Expenditures in the United States,” from CMS. 49
SECTION 1
1. Claim is created by
One of the contributing factors to the rise in health care provider after patient 2. Claim is reviewed and
costs in the US is the lack of transparency in the real costs receives service (will processed by insurance
of health care. include a diagnosis and a company based on
procedure code). Sent to patient policy.
insurance company.
It is a common complaint amongst consumers of health
care, that costs are practically impossible to find out in
advance and unexpected (and large) health care bills are
very common, even amongst those with health insurance
coverage.
3. If claim is approved,
4. Insurance coverage/benefits
If we look at the lifecycle of health care claims in the US, it payment and remittance explained to patient in form of
helps to explain how that could happen with the many advice sent to the EOB (explanation of benefits)
layers of review and adjustment that happen. provider. If denied, denial from insurer. Will indicate
is sent to the provider, whether anything was paid to
indicating no payment provider and whether patient
will still have a balance.
will follow.
Source: Statista report, “Health Insurance in the United States,” from US Census Bureau. 50
SECTION 2
Source: USA Today, “What health care and hospitals looked like 100 years ago,” John Harrington, Oct 13, 2019; NPR, “Accidents of History Created US Health System,” Alex Blumberg and 51
Adam Davidson, Oct 22, 2009; TIME, “The American Health Care System Has Lots of Problems. Here’s When They Started,” Lily Rothman, Jul 13, 2017.
SECTION 2
Source: Hajar, Rachel. “History of medicine timeline.” Heart views : the official journal of the Gulf Heart Association vol. 16,1 (2015): 43-5. doi:10.4103/1995-705x.153008; AMA Journal of Ethics, 52
Virtual Mentor. 2008;10(5):324-331. doi: 10.1001/virtualmentor.2008.10.5.mhst1-0805.
SECTION 2
At the same time, the cost of care was quite high and
most average families could not afford the very large bills
that resulted from hospital visits, resulting in hospitals
with empty beds.
Source: AMA Journal of Ethics, Virtual Mentor. 2008;10(5):324-331. doi: 10.1001/virtualmentor.2008.10.5.mhst1-0805; ; NPR, “Accidents of History Created US Health System,” Alex Blumberg 53
and Adam Davidson, Oct 22, 2009.
SECTION 2
Source: NPR, “Accidents of History Created US Health System,” Alex Blumberg and Adam Davidson, Oct 22, 2009. 54