Professional Documents
Culture Documents
White Paper - Preventing Electrocutions and Injury With Industrial GFCIs
White Paper - Preventing Electrocutions and Injury With Industrial GFCIs
White Paper - Preventing Electrocutions and Injury With Industrial GFCIs
INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS
Prevention through Design with Special-Purpose GFCIs
TECHNICAL PAPER
PREVENTION THROUGH
DESIGN WITH SPGFCIs
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................................................................... 3
2.0 ELECTRICAL SHOCK OVERVIEW........................................................................................................................... 3
2.1 What Makes Electrical Shock So Dangerous...................................................................................................... 3
2.2 When and Why More than 50 Volts Can Be Lethal............................................................................................ 3
3.0 PREVENTION THROUGH DESIGN: GFCI ELECTRICAL SHOCK PREVENTION....................................................... 5
3.1 How GFCIs Work............................................................................................................................................... 6
4.0 SPECIAL-PURPOSE GFCIs...................................................................................................................................... 6
4.1 GFCI Classes and Their Applications.................................................................................................................. 6
4.1.1 Class A GFCIs (Non-Residential)............................................................................................................... 6
4.1.2 Class C, D, and E GFCIs (Special-Purpose GFCIs).................................................................................... .6
4.1.3 Proactive GFCIs Detect Ground Faults and Protect Against Fatal Shocks.................................................. 8
4.1.4 Where a 20-Milliampere Trip Level is Appropriate for Protection............................................................... 8
4.2 Not all Products Marketed as ‘GFCIs’ are Actually GFCIs.................................................................................. 8
4.3 Equipment Ground-Fault Protection Devices and Nuisance Tripping.................................................................. 8
4.4 How to Apply Industrial GFCIs........................................................................................................................... 9
4.5 Mitigation Methods Commonly Confused with Shock Protection Devices......................................................... 9
4.5.1 Ground-Fault Relays.................................................................................................................................. 9
4.5.2 High-Resistance Grounding Systems........................................................................................................ 9
5.0 INDUSTRY-SPECIFIC CHALLENGES AND SOLUTIONS.......................................................................................... 9
5.1 Locations Where GFCIs are Required by NEC 210.8(B) (Nonresidential)............................................................ 9
5.2 Commercial Kitchens and Restaurants.............................................................................................................10
5.3 Ground Check One Two: GFCIs for the Entertainment Industry and Temporary Installations............................10
5.4 GFCIs Designed for the Entertainment Industry and Temporary Installations...................................................11
6.0 CASE STUDIES......................................................................................................................................................12
6.1 Special-Purpose GFCI with 480 V Ac and 600 V Ac in Outdoor Locations and Confined Spaces.......................12
6.2 Heavy-Industry Manufacturing.........................................................................................................................13
6.3 Mine Extends GFCI Protection to 480-Volt Portable Equipment.......................................................................13
6.4 Submersible Pump Applications.......................................................................................................................13
7.0 CONCLUSION........................................................................................................................................................13
8.0 REFERENCES.........................................................................................................................................................14
9.0 DEFINITIONS.........................................................................................................................................................14
10.0 ADDITIONAL RESOURCES..................................................................................................................................15
10.1 Shock Safety Education..................................................................................................................................15
10.2 Shock Block Resources..................................................................................................................................15
10.2.1 Shock Block GFCI and EGFPDs..............................................................................................................15
10.2.2 Shock Block Rental Series for the Entertainment Industry.....................................................................15
Introduction
Acronyms
With power, comes great responsibility. Companies must
AC alternating current
never take electrical shock lightly, or believe that safety
training and PPE are enough on their own. Hundreds of BLS Bureau of Labor Statistics
workers are killed every year from electrical shock1. More DC direct current
than 90 % of electrical fatalities among US workers are due EGFPD equipment ground-fault protection device
to electrical shock, and tens of thousands of electrical shock GFCI ground-fault circuit interrupter
incidents over the years have resulted in injuries that require
HRG high-resistance grounding
time away from work.
PPE personal protective equipment
Ground-fault circuit protection is one of the most effective SPGFCI special-purpose ground-fault circuit interrupter
preventative measures against electrical shock because it
actively reacts to irregular electrical conditions regardless of
a person’s qualifications or use of PPE. Where applicable, symptoms. Electrical shocks can cause long-term injuries
they are an out-of-sight-out-of-mind practice that require with both neurological (such as loss of balance, poor
zero energy from the workers for it to guarantee their safety. coordination, and neuropathy), psychological (fatigue,
irritability, and depression) and physical symptoms (such as
This paper will begin with a brief overview of the conditions
muscle spasms, reduced range of motion, muscle aches,
that make an electrical shock hazard potentially lethal
and joint stiffness) [1].
(which aims to help readers understand why lower voltages
do not constitute safer conditions). Then, it will provide a Potential long-term consequences of electrical injuries may
discussion of how ground-fault circuit interrupters (GFCIs) include neurological (e.g., neuropathy, seizures, syncope,
are used to keep workers safe from electrical shock. tinnitus, paresthesias, weakness, loss of balance, poor
Specifically, this paper will discuss: coordination, or gait ataxia), psychological (e.g., memory or
attention difficulties, irritability, depression or post-traumatic
How electrical shock affects the human body
stress), ocular (e.g., cataracts) or physical (e.g., pain, fatigue,
How GFCIs work
contractures, muscle spasms, pruritus, headaches, fever or
night sweats, and reduced range of motion or stiffness in
Different GFCI classes and their respective the joints) disturbances.
applications
Electrical Shock Overview from foot to foot (the step potential, which is the
difference in voltage between each foot and the
What Makes Electrical Shock So electrode). A foot-to-foot path most commonly
occurs in incidents where the victim was standing
Dangerous
on a surface that became energized during a fault.
An electric shock is a sudden violent response to electrical
current flowing through any part of a person’s body. Even
minor shock injuries can result in life-altering and debilitating
1 Between 2003 and 2019, an annual average of 183 fatalities were attributed to electrical shock, according to BLS CFOI. Because many worker
fatality incidents that are initiated from electrical shock but ultimately are classified under a different cause of death, such as a worker who falls
from a ladder after being electrically shocked, the number of workers who die each year from electrical shock is most likely significantly higher
than the BLS data reflects.
Many factors affect the current’s ability to pass through the Unfortunately, this ability to let go (and thus break from the
body, and it only takes about 6 mA (for the average female) electrical current) will often make the difference between
and 9 mA (for the average male) to reach the “let-go life and death. Alternating current (ac) repetitively stimulates
threshold,” which when the current causes the muscles to nerves and muscles that cause sustained contraction onto
uncontrollably contract and renders the victim unable to let the muscles, which will continue as long as there is contact
go and break from the current on their own (see Figure 1). with the object. When a person’s muscles contract, their
grip tightens, which renders them powerless to disconnect
the electrical current from their body.
20,000
40
level that the body can tolerate without causing significant
risk of death. Blood does not travel to the brain during
a ventricular fibrillation cardiac arrest. Therefore, even if
30 Difficulty Breathing the person receives defibrillation treatment in time and
survives, but does not immediately receive CPR before the
defibrillator becomes available, then they will likely become
20 Respiration brain damaged with lifelong disabilities.
Class C, D, E
SPGFCI Trip
Level Most victims, however, do not survive. Due to factors that
9 Let-Go Threshold (Male Body) impede rapid access to emergency medical care, CPR and
6
Class A GFCI
Let-Go Threshold (Female Body) defibrillation, reported survival rates range from 3 % to
Trip Level 10 % [3].
1 Perception
A B C1 C2 C3
10,000
5,000
AC-4.1
AC-4.1
Duration of current flow in ms
2,000
1,000
500
AC-1 AC-2 AC-3 AC-4
200
100
50
20
10
0.1 0.2 0.5 1 2 5 10 20 50 100 200 500 1,000 2,000 5,000 10,000
Current (mA)
FIGURE 2. The effects of different ac levels flowing through the human body, according to IEC 60364-4-41.
Most DE-ENERGIZE
Elimination
Effective EQUIPMENT
Substitution
Engineering
GFCIs
Controls
Administrative
SAFETY TRAINING
Controls
The longer the current lasts, the greater the injury. A person
who has passed the let-go threshold is physically incapable
Prevention through Design: GFCI
of breaking from the current on their own. At this point, the Electrical Shock Prevention
current will not stop traveling through their body until it is
interrupted by a GFCI or similar device. Prevention through Design is the best way to protect
workers from serious injuries and death. While human-
GFCIs limit the human body’s exposure to shock by based safety measures (PPE and safety training) are
interrupting the circuit before the magnitude of current and important components of occupational safety, these
its duration poses the risk of ventricular fibrillation. The area methods are prone to error and are unreliable on their own,
shown as AC-2 (see Figure 2), indicates where the threat which is why NFPA 70E, Standard for Electrical Safety in the
of ventricular fibrillation is unlikely. GFCIs operate according Workplace, stresses that they must never be used as the
to a curve that is faster, and more sensitive than the lagging sole safety method unless the company has no other choice
edge of AC-2. If there is a 50-milliampere fault, then the (see Figure 3).
GFCI will trip in 100 ms or less, keeping the person safe
from heart fibrillation. Most industrial sites require employees to wear PPE.
However, standard-issue PPE (such as general-purpose
While duration is one of the most significant factors that gloves, which often provide heat protection) does not
determines the severity of an injury, it is not the only one. protect from electric shock and electrical workers might be
The amount of moisture in the body (resistance) is also an lax in properly wearing electrical PPE. Additionally, workers
important contributor. Tissue density (ratio of fat to muscle), often complain electrical gloves make it difficult to get the
body mass, the presence of moisture in the environment, job done because they are cumbersome or bulky. This often
the victim’s sex, and the type of current are all variables causes many workers to perform work without wearing
which can affect the severity of the shock injury. their PPE when required.
For more information about the contributing factors of PPE (such as rubber-insulating gloves) are considered the
severe electrical shock incidents and their prevalence least effective safety method under NFPA 70E hierarchy of
among U.S. workers, read the Littelfuse electrical shock controls due to the high level of human error that must be
survey report. overcome for them to effectively work. While absolutely
important, electrical gloves are the last line of defense.
Electrical gloves must maintain their dielectric properties,
physical strength, flexibility and durability for them to remain Class A GFCIs are governed by UL 943, which applies to
effective. Whether the worker ultimately wears them is a Class A, single- and three-phase GFCIs in accordance with
different story. the NEC, the Canadian Electrical Code (CE Code), and
ANSI/NFPA 70. Class A GFCIs provide let-go protection and
To learn more about why PPE and safety training are do not require equipment ground conductor monitoring.
dangerous mitigation methods to rely upon, read The State
of Electrical Shock Safety survey report. Class C, D, and E GFCIs (Special-Purpose GFCIs)
2 There are also Class B GFCIs, but they are rare—if not obsolete—because they are only for use in pool light fixtures installed before 1965.
A good EGFPD will have an adjustable sensitivity, which against electrical shock. Ground-fault relays do not open
is usually between 6 mA and 100 mA. This enables the the affected circuit themselves. Instead, they send a signal
sensitivity to be adjusted to the lowest sensitivity level upstream to a breaker.
that is above the base leakage current. Doing so creates
the safest possible conditions for workers in environments While the ground-fault relay reacts from 8 to 10 ms,
where worker protection at 20 mA is not possible. Littelfuse the upstream circuit breaker may take 30 to 50 ms to
EGFPDs can also monitor the ground conductor, which— open—which is enough time for an electrical shock to
though not required by UL 943C—provides an additional stop a human heart. A GFCI or an EGFPD contains its own
layer of protection. interrupting device (a relay, contactor, or circuit breaker) to
interrupt power, and it interrupts power much more quickly.
EGFPDs are not covered by UL 943C (nor UL Listed as Per UL 943C, a GFCI must open the circuit to interrupt
GFCIs) because the standard does not allow adjustable power in less than 20 ms for higher currents. This time is
trip levels for GFCIs. Therefore, EGFPDs are considered fast enough to prevent shock injury.
for equipment protection only. Littelfuse EGFPDs will still
provide protection against ventricular fibrillation (and other High-Resistance Grounding Systems
severe shock injuries) for any leakage currents greater than High-resistance grounding (HRG) systems do not reduce
the user-selected setting. electrical shock hazards. In HRG systems, which are
no more than 10 A, the neutral point of the three-phase
How to Apply Industrial GFCIs electrical supply is not directly connected to ground, but
instead through a high-value resistor. When one of the
Industrial GFCIs can be used on equipment subject to phase conductors shorts to ground, the system continues to
wash-down cleaning, process equipment that handles operate with the fault current limited to a low value by the
wet material, such as large pumps, mixers, wet saws; grounding resistor.
equipment that comes into frequent contact with workers,
such as arc-welding stations; and portable electric Although HRG systems can dramatically reduce the risk of
equipment used outdoors, where long power cords and less an arc flash and maintain an electrical system’s operations
robust temporary connections may be exposed to rain and in the event of a ground fault, they do nothing for shock
moisture. hazards. The system’s grounding resistor will still permit
the flow of more than enough current to kill a person, so
Industrial GFCIs may be integrated by the original touching a live conductor can still be fatal.
equipment manufacturer or the panel builder, or they may
be installed in an electrical cabinet such as a motor control
center. They are also available with their own enclosures, for
mounting to the side of a machine or a wall.
Industry-Specific Challenges and
The wiring is simple: attach source power on one side and
the load circuit on the other side. In addition, there may be
Solutions
signal wiring for optional alarm communication.
Locations Where GFCIs are Required by
Some models are equipped with built-in overcurrent
NEC 210.8(B) (Nonresidential)
protection (usually a fuse), which allows for a high
interrupting rating (50 kA in some cases). This protects GFCI requirements for nonresidential applications are
the internal contactor from damage and does not require outlined in NEC 210.8(B):
the user to install a current limiting device upstream of the
industrial GFCI. Some models also offer undervoltage and All 125-volt through 250-volt receptacles supplied by
single-phase branch circuits rated 150 V or less to
chatter detection.
ground, 50 A or less, and all receptacles supplied by
three-phase branch circuits rated 150 V or less to ground,
Mitigation Methods Commonly Confused 100 A or less, installed in the locations specified in
210.8(B)(1) through (B)(12) shall have ground-fault circuit-
with Shock Protection Devices
interrupter protection for personnel.
Ground-Fault Relays
This update applies to most receptacles in the locations
Ground-fault relays are not to be confused with GFCIs.
listed below, which includes receptacles on 240-volt circuits
Whereas ground fault relays protect equipment, GFCIs
and three-phase receptacles on 208Y/120-volt three-phase
protect human life. Furthermore, ground-fault relays are
circuits.
not specifically designed to provide complete protection
The non-residential locations that NEC 210.8(B) requires In 2017, the NEC began to RESIDUAL-CURRENT
GFCI protection include: require GFCI protection for
CIRCUIT BREAKERS
circuits up to 100 A. For
Bathrooms commercial kitchens, this
AND GROUND-
posed a challenge because FAULT RELAYS ARE
Kitchens or areas with a sink and permanent
large appliances, such as a NOT APPROVED TO
provisions for either food preparation or cooking
60-ampere 208-volt fryer, PROTECT PEOPLE
Rooftops require GFCIs that are rated FROM ELECTRICAL
for at least 60 A. Traditional
SHOCK, AND THUS
Outdoors GFCIs, however, were
unavailable in this range.
MUST NEVER BE USED
Sinks—where receptacles are installed within IN LIEU OF A GFCI.
1.8 m (6 ft) from the top inside edge of the bowl of According to the NEC, a GFCI
the sink is required for cord-connected
equipment. While hard-wiring equipment means the
Indoor damp and wet locations equipment is not required to be connected to a GFCI, doing
so makes it difficult to meet health and sanitation codes.
Locker rooms with associated showering facilities
Doing so requires the large appliance to be hard-wired to
Garages, accessory buildings, service bays, and the wall, which makes it difficult to clean the surrounding
similar areas other than vehicle exhibition halls and area. When these appliances are not portable, workers
showrooms usually cannot efficiently (if at all) access those areas which
are required to be kept clean per health and sanitation
Crawl spaces at or below grade level codes.
To electrical
panel
SB5000
Class A
GFCI
2 5
1 Drop-Down Receptacles for Prep 2 Meat Grinder 3 Electric Oven/Pizza Oven 4 Dishwasher 5 Electric Range 6 Deep Fryer
FIGURE
FIGURERESTAURANT
5. The SB5000, a Class A GFCI, allows restaurants to meet new NEC requirements without making it difficult to also
meet health and sanitation codes.
A lack of proper ground conductors GFCIs Designed for the Entertainment
Improperly protected conductors (i.e., lack of
Industry and Temporary Installations
conduit) There are three different types of rental shock blocks that
are designed to provide protection in temporary installations:
Worn conductors on portable and mobile equipment
“ A third-party
engineering firm
fault protection for equipment
that is subject to wet
D special-purpose GFCIs, respectively. The engineers,
however, did not have a GFCI appropriate for these
independently conditions, moisture, and worn environments that was specified and approved for use with
evaluated the cable insulation. both of these voltages.
performance of three
The SB3000 monitors leakage The company wanted to make the safest conditions for their
special-purpose workers, and contacted Littelfuse to help them achieve this
current to eliminate potential
GFCIs. The Littelfuse within the specific conditions of their system.
electrical hazards caused by
Shock Block SB6100 wet equipment.
performed well and To determine the appropriate special-purpose GFCI that
was the only product Because the SB3000 does not would comply with the UL 943C, their environmental health
that met all our test provide GFCI shock protection, and safety department hired an independent consultant
”
criteria. it should be used in conjunction to identify a suitable product. The consultant selected
with either the SB100B, products from three manufacturers for evaluation. One of
SB250B or the LB100 Shock the products selected for testing was the Littelfuse Shock
EHS ENGINEERING MANAGER
Blocks. Block SB6100 special-purpose GFCI, Class C and Class D.
The evaluation consisted of three tests:
The SB3000 is used on the
main higher amperage connection to the generator. The 1. Trip level at a sustained current level
SB100 or SB250B are used on the branch circuits that go to
2. Inverse time trip characteristic for high currents
individual loads, which is where the GFCI protection will be.
3. Cable imbalance test for a nuisance tripping
The Lunchbox has hospital-grade duplex receptacles with
condition
recessed circuit breakers and indicator lights to provide
GFCI protection for single-phase 120 volt equipment. The inverse time curve is important as it requires the GFCI
device to trip quickly on high fault currents but allows a
longer time to trip on low level currents creating a safe
system with reduced nuisance trips.
The Littelfuse Shock Block SB6100 was the only device that
passed all three tests. According to the consultant’s tests,
the Littelfuse Shock Block SB6100 was the only one of the
three manufacturers’ devices that they found to be capable
of working in their system while still providing true GFCI in a standard plug (see Figure 4). On the load side, they
personnel protection trip levels. Additionally, the Shock added 200 feet of electrical cable connected to the portable
Block SB61000 was the only one of the three devices that welder. The cables included a ground wire and pilot wire
was actually UL Listed and therefore the only device that used for ground continuity verification.
could be considered a true GFCI.
The maintenance manager’s workers said it was
The company says they are planning to replace all of their lightweight, and easy to use and test. Moreover, the
600 volt GFCIs made by other manufacturers with the maintenance manager is happy knowing that their workers
Littelfuse Shock Block SB6100 Class D GFCI. The EHS are protected.
department is planning to install SB6100 systems in all of
the company’s facilities throughout Ontario, Canada.
Submersible Pump Applications
A large municipal water utility company needed to protect
Heavy-Industry Manufacturing
their workers who clean water tanks from electrical shock
A brick manufacturing plant in the western United States while the submersible pumps are in operation. Because
processes clay into bricks and other building materials for many dewatering applications are temporary, this was
residential and commercial projects. The process involves difficult to do without a GFCI that was capable of being
wet saws that operate at 480 volts. moved from one installation to the next.
In this type of application, there will always be some The utility company used the Littelfuse GFCI cart with the
amount of leakage current. Therefore, the company installed SB61000 Shock Block EGFPD, which enabled their workers
the Shock Block SB6100 EGFPD, which allowed them to to safely work in temporary installations without putting
adjust the trip level to be above the nominal leakage current. their lives at risk.
Since they installed the SB6100, the company has not Technological advancements have also enabled GFCIs to be
experienced any shock incidents. easily implemented in applications where they traditionally
might have caused unwanted tripping. To learn about how
GFCIs or special-purpose GFCIs can protect the personnel
Mine Extends GFCI Protection to 480-Volt in your specific application, contact one of our Littelfuse
Portable Equipment experts.
A coal mine in the southern United States operates a
machine repair shop, where workers use portable 480-volt
stud-gun welders. The maintenance manager installed the
Littelfuse Shock Block SB6100 GFCI so that they could
improve worker safety while keeping their process running.
Definitions concerned.
Additional Resources
Shock Block GFCI and EGFPDs (800) 832-3873 (U.S. and Canada only)
relays@littelfuse.com
Shock Block SB6100 product information
Shock Block SB6100 case studies
Product Purchasing and Support
Shock Block SB6100 manual
Shock Block SB6100 datasheet (800) 227-0029 (U.S. and Canada only)
Shock Block SB6100 brochure PG_CSG@littelfuse.com
Shock Block SB6100 FAQ
Shock Block SB6100 video Shock Block Rental Units
Disclaimer Notice – Information furnished is believed to be accurate and reliable. However, users should independently evaluate the suitability of and test each product selected for
their own applications. Littelfuse products are not designed for, and may not be used in, all applications. Read complete Disclaimer Notice at www.littelfuse.com/product-disclaimer.
FORM PF805
© 2022 Littelfuse, Inc.
Rev: 031822