Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cibse Lighting Commissioning
Cibse Lighting Commissioning
The Society of
Light and Lighting
The rights of publication or translation are reserved.
ISBN 1 903287 32 4
Authors
Hilary Graves (BRE Environment; consultant)
Peter Phillipson (Future Group Lighting)
Co-ordinating editor
Dr Hywel Davies
Editor
Jonathan David
Acknowledgements
This work was part funded by the Department Trade and Industry (DTI) under the
Partners in Innovation Scheme, and the CIBSE Research Fund. This document is
published with the Department’s consent, but the views expressed are not necessarily
accepted or endorsed by the DTI.
Contents
L0 Introduction 1
L0.1 Scope 1
L0.2 Purpose 1
L0.3 Definitions 1
L0.4 The importance of commissioning 4
L0.5 Electrical safety 4
L0.6 Lighting commissioning 4
L0.7 Lighting controls 5
L3 Commissioning 7
L3.1 Interior lighting 7
L3.2 Emergency lighting 7
L3.3 Exterior lighting 7
L3.4 Lighting controls 7
L3.5 Relationship between lighting and shading 8
L3.6 Measurement of illuminance 8
L4 System handover 8
L4.1 Witnessing arrangements 8
L4.2 Commissioning documentation 9
L4.3 Operator training 10
L5 Post-occupancy checks 10
References and Bibliography 11
Appendix LA1: Hypothetical examples of lighting commissioning 12
Appendix LA2: Checklists for the commissioning of lighting systems 14
Appendix LA3: Example commissioning method statement for lighting
system with automatic controls 19
Appendix LA4: Sample completion certificates 20
Appendix LA5: Safety issues 22
Appendix LA6: Notes concerning the design of lighting and
lighting control systems 23
Index 24
1
Lighting
A control unit controlling a significant area of a building A document specifying the processes required to achieve
into which one or more local control units may be commissioning and those responsible for completing those
connected. processes.
2 Lighting
The temperature of a full radiator (black body) which Similar to ‘corridor link’ but used where the linked
emits radiation having a chromaticity nearest to that of lighting is required for comfort or environmental reasons.
the light source being considered, expressed in kelvins.
Handover
Corridor link The process of handing the building over from the
contractor to the client following practical completion.
Facility that relates office lighting to circulation lighting so
that exit routes are kept lit while any office lighting is on. Hard and soft points
Points in the system where hardware (hard) or software
Critical path analysis
(soft) can be checked during the commissioning process.
A method for defining the time-critical processes in a Hard-fired
project.
Term used to describe certain solid-state dimmer circuits.
Design criteria
HID lamp
For numerical information, the specified numerical Abbreviation for high-intensity discharge lamp
quantities together with allowable deviations; otherwise
the specified requirements in qualitative terms. In the High-frequency control gear
latter case it is essential that subjective terms be avoided.
For fluorescent or high-intensity discharge lighting,
Design intent electronic control gear which operates at a frequency
significantly above the normal mains frequency, and
A written specification of the whole lighting and control usually well above the audible range.
system prepared by the lighting designer giving the design
Intelligent luminaires
criteria, control strategy and other system requirements,
as appropriate. Luminaires with in-built sensors and control circuitry.
Introduction 3
Type of dimmer that ‘chops’ the leading (or rising) edge of Operating and maintenance manual (O&M manual)
the mains sine wave to reduce power delivered to
A series of documents detailing the design intent, mode of
luminaires.
operation and maintenance requirements of building services
systems.
Lighting connection unit
A unit that connects a luminaire to the low-voltage power Operator workstation
supply. A device used to provide a central monitoring facility for a
BMS . Also referred to as a ‘central station’, ‘head end’,
Lighting controller ‘host’ or ‘BMS supervisor’.
Any control unit for a lighting circuit.
Outstation
Lighting designer (LD) A device capable of control and monitoring functions to
The person responsible for the detailed design of the which sensors, actuators and other controls are connected.
lighting scheme. Outstations are linked by means of a communications bus.
buildings. Following the detailed advice in this Code written on the sheet and not left blank. This will
(CIBSE/SLL Commissioning Code L) would be one ensure that every aspect of the commissioning is
method of demonstrating compliance with AD L2. considered.
The lighting industry has developed a declaration of — It is important to identify an overall designer of
conformity for Parts L1 and L2 which should in due the lighting scheme. The lighting designer (LD)
course be available from the Lighting Association(4) and should represent the client’s needs and overview
Lighting Industry Federation(5) websites. This form may the lighting design in its entirety. The LD may be a
be offered to building control bodies as evidence of the separate lighting designer/consultant or may be
compliance of completed lighting systems with Part L1 or the M&E consultant.
L2 as relevant. Building control bodies will need to be — At the start of a commissioning project the various
satisfied, as in other cases, as to the credentials of those parties should agree on communication ‘path ways’.
who sign these declarations and that the technical
information conveyed in them is satisfactory as evidence — A framework for a communication network should
for the purposes of establishing that the works meet the be drawn up to aid the smooth flow of information.
requirements. The installation and commissioning of a control
system is frequently let on a subcontract basis. This
can impede the flow of information between the
L0.7 Lighting controls control system designer/specifier and the control
system vendor. To help address this problem, it is
The purpose of commissioning the lighting controls beneficial in many projects if the control system
includes ensuring that automatic control systems work contractor can have a direct line of communication
correctly, realising the aesthetic quality of the lighting, with the system designer along with other relevant
ensuring that end users can use the systems and suppliers and subcontractors. However, such a
minimising wasted energy. This Code advises on these framework must take into account any contractual
matters. Further guidance is available in CIBSE obligations and responsibilities.
Commissioning Code C: Automatic controls(6).
— The particular requirements for the commissioning
of the control system can be kept to the fore by the
regular attendance of the commissioning engineer at
L1 Commissioning project/site meetings.
project management
L1.2 Commissioning activities
L1.1 Forming a commissioning
An example of a general checklist of activities required for
management team a successful commissioning process is included as
Appendix LA2. The ‘person responsible’ for each activity
For large installations a commissioning management team will depend on the contractual arrangements but should
should be formed to co-ordinate and oversee the be inserted as early as possible in the process. It is
commissioning process. Further guidance is available in essential that responsibility for the completion of any task
CIBSE Commissioning Code M: Commissioning be assigned before the task is started. Recommendations
management(7). for issues to consider in the design process for ease of
commissioning, ease of maintenance and energy efficiency
The formation of a full commissioning management team
are given in Appendix LA6.
may not be appropriate for projects with relatively simple
automatic control systems and small project teams, but
commissioning management should not be ignored just
because the project is small.
L1.3 Commissioning
method statements
The following procedures should be followed:
— It is important to decide who will have overall A commissioning method statement should be produced by
responsibility for the lighting commissioning. the person with overall responsibility for commissioning
This person should develop a commissioning activities (or their nominated deputy). An example of a
checklist (Appendix LA2 can be used as a basis for commissioning method statement for a generic mixed
this checklist). The checklist should be distributed manual and automatic lighting system is included as
to the lighting designer (LD), the architect, the appendix LA3. In practice, responsibilities between parties
interior designer, the mechanical & electrical will vary depending on the contractual framework.
( M & E ) consultant, the main contractor, the
electrical contractor and subcontractors and
suppliers associated with commissioning their own L1.4 Commissioning plan or timetable
equipment supplied to a project, for example a
control system programmer. These people should The person designated with responsibility for managing
meet on a regular basis. the commissioning process should:
— A name should be placed against each of the — Make sure that the main contractor includes
activities in the list of Appendix LA2. If a lighting commissioning dates on the time lines
particular item is not relevant, then this should be issued to contractors and clients.
6 Lighting
— Use a tool such as critical path analysis to plan the — All luminaires should be in the correct position (as
pre-commissioning, commissioning and handover defined by the system drawings) and be in the
tasks, their duration and interdependencies with correct orientation.
each other and other M&E services.
— All luminaires should be clean and undamaged
— Consider the critical points in the process by
with the correct lamps fitted (i.e. manufacturer,
which time certain tasks must be completed for
the next task to start – strategic co-ordination rating, phosphor and electrical type).
points (e.g. electrical power must be available — All lamps in emergency luminaires should be
before luminaire function can be tested). checked for damage and wear caused during the
— Identify where tasks may be completed early (i.e. construction phase.
during the construction phase) or off-site.
— All channel dials and function switches (as
— Consider whether phased completion, if feasible, appropriate) should be set to the specified settings.
will help to reduce the overall commissioning time
scale and plan accordingly. — All sensor levels should be set to the specified levels.
— Continue to monitor progress against timetable, — All items should be uniquely and clearly labelled,
warn project management if deviations in other particularly control panels.
schedules are likely to have a significant effect on
the commissioning schedule. — Alignment of all luminaires (especially flood
lighting) should be checked to avoid glare and
— Ensure that the client’s representative is involved, unwanted over-spill and a check should be made
particularly with regard to any programming
requirements. that any conditions attached to planning
permission have been complied with.
— All cover plates should be fitted and electrical
segregation complete.
L2 Pre-commissioning
(preliminary) checks — All raise and lower gear should be checked.
— All safety chains, safety cords and filter holders etc.
on luminaires should be securely mounted;
L2.1 General associated control gear should be fixed securely on
All pre-commissioning checks should be recorded on a lighting trusses, booms, barrels and bars, or placed in
pre-commissioning checklist. As many of these checks as a secure position.
possible should be carried out off-site. Tasks suitable for
off-site commissioning include software applications and L2.2.2 Electrical checks
control panel testing. Speculative office buildings may
have two separate lighting designs. The initial design may — All luminaires, switches and sensors should be
be a simple system with mainly manual controls. The final wired according to the wiring diagrams provided.
user specification will be developed at the fit-out stage,
which may be a separate project from the original build. — All lights or track circuits should be wired to the
The fit-out commissioning process should be planned in specified control switch or dimmer.
the same manner as a new-build commissioning process — All mains wiring has been tested and certified as
and the relevant changes made to the design and
complying with the recommendations of BS
commissioning record.
7671(1).
— Appropriate power has been provided to the
L2.2 State of the system systems to be commissioned. The voltage and
All lighting system components should be installed frequency should be stable and within the limits
according to the system design drawings and an appropriate, laid down in the Electricity Safety, Quality and
stable power supply should be available. All lighting system Continuity Regulations(8) and within the voltage-
components should be those specified in the original drop limits specified in BS 7671(1).
design. Specification ‘breaking’ may have a serious adverse
effect on total lighting efficacy, efficiency and the
aesthetic quality of the design and on the time required L2.3 Pre-commissioning certificate
for commissioning. Substitutions should only be made
with the agreement of the lighting designer, and a written It is recommended that the person responsible for
change record should be made. commissioning management produces a pre-commissioning
certificate (see Appendix LA4).
L2.2.1 Mechanical checks
This certificate can include a checklist of pre-
— All luminaire positioning that requires co-operation
with other installers (such as air conditioning commissioning tasks and the person responsible for the task.
contractors, installers of girders and plasterers) Those responsible for the tasks should sign the completed
should be co-ordinated early in the building checklist to signify that the checks have been completed
contract. satisfactorily.
Commissioning 7
Carry out commissioning steps as defined by the Where possible, the calibration of the light sensor should
commissioning method statement. The checklists in take place at the lighting controller or operator workstation
Appendix LA2 may help to define the steps required. The (via configuration software). Direct manual calibration at the
specific checklist in Appendix LA2 (Figure LA2.2) can be sensor itself may result in calibration being adversely affected
modified to suit the particular commissioning project, or be as the person performing the calibration will block some of
used in its entirety, in which case ‘not applicable’ should be the light which would otherwise fall on the sensor. When
written in the check boxes that are not appropriate for that local calibration cannot be avoided, care must be taken to
project. minimise any adverse effects by the person commissioning,
e.g. by the use of remote-head portable light meters.
Carry out measurements of illuminance if defined in the
commissioning method statement, see section L3.6. Calibration of the light sensors should take place when the
building is fully furnished. See also Section L3.6. Ensure
It is important that the aiming and focusing of adjustable that luminaires do not dim to a point where flicker is
luminaires are adequately addressed. If all other lighting detected. Ensure appropriate time-delay settings to reduce
needs to be switched off during this process, project nuisance dimming caused by transient conditions, e.g.
schedules must allow the site to be free from other workers passing clouds.
requiring light.
L3.4.4 Occupancy sensors
Safety method statements must allow those aiming and
focusing the luminaires to use appropriate access gear
Ensure that:
belonging to, or hired by, the installer. If it is intended that
the luminaires be adjusted by the end user after practical — The zone occupancy sensor is located and
completion of the project, this must be indicated in the orientated correctly in relation to the occupants.
commissioning method statement (see section L1.3).
— The occupancy sensor sensitivity is appropriate by
adjusting the detector sensitivity to ensure that
L3.2 Emergency lighting occupant movement is detected throughout the
occupied zone. Note that too low a sensitivity will
Commissioning of emergency lighting should be carried result in seated occupants not being detected, while
out with reference to BS 5266 Emergency lighting(2). too high a sensitivity may result in movement
outside the controlled zone activating the lights.
— The time delay setting is representative of the
L3.3 Exterior lighting occupant work/movement patterns. Ideally, the
time delay settings should be assessed when the
Lighting attached to a building providing access building is occupied.
lighting or security lighting near the building is covered
by this Code and shall be commissioned according to
the design specification. Carry out measurements of L3.4.5 Manual dimming
illuminance if defined in the commissioning method
statement – see section L3.6. Ensure that the upper and lower limits of the dimming
range are as specified.
L3.4.1 General Ensure that the start and stop times along with the
override control (e.g. occupant or security staff override)
Ensure that any specified fail-safe/emergency control are as specified.
routines operate correctly.
L3.4.7 End user-operated systems
L3.4.2 Manual controls
Occupant overrides range from simple set point adjustment
Ensure that manual switches switch the correct zone of and push button overrides to PC and telephone-based
luminaires as labelled. systems. The following general procedures should be
followed. Ensure that:
L3.4.3 Daylight-linked/lumen maintenance — The physical location of occupant control devices
and intelligent luminaires is correct.
— Each occupant control device is linked to the
Ensure that the light sensor is located in a representative
building control system communications network.
location. Calibrate the light sensor to give the specified
light levels at the specified positions. The calibration — Each occupant control device controls the correct
should be performed using a certified, calibrated portable lighting zone.
8 Lighting
— The control band of the occupant control is as — The speed of communications is at least that
specified. specified. It is important that this is assessed when
the network is under ‘normal’ operating
— The default control settings for each occupant
conditions in order to reflect the in-use level of
control device are correct.
network traffic.
— Any specified automatic override function
operates correctly. — Data communication is error free, i.e. there is no
data corruption at the level of the control system.
For IT-based occupant controls (PC or telephone-based (Communication errors may occur but these
systems), ensure that each occupant command relates to should be resolved automatically by the network
the correct luminaires or lamps and operates in the communication devices.)
specified manner. — No cross corruption of data occurs when the
building control system shares a network with
Ensure that the database containing occupant details can other IT-based systems.
be easily accessed and amended in order to reflect future
changes in occupancy patterns. — All network devices such as routers and bridges
operate correctly.
— The number of random points to be witnessed will L4.2.3 O&M manual/handover report
depend on the size of the complete system. For
example, the following rules of thumb may be Responsibility for producing and checking the O & M
helpful: if less than 300 points witness all the manual will have been assigned at an earlier stage.
points, between 300 and 1000 points witness 50%, Responsibility for providing some of the information will
and if more than 1000 points witness 20% (with a almost certainly fall to the commissioning engineer as
minimum of 500 points witnessed). defined by the terms of the specific contract. The
— If the failure rate is greater than 5%, then the following list is useful for compiling the O&M manual.
lighting designer (or equivalent party) should — Check that an initial draft of the O&M manual has
reserve the right to witness 100% of the points. been submitted to the lighting designer or
— If there are several identical lighting sub-systems, equivalent party for approval prior to
one can be witnessed in detail, with the others commissioning (when required under contract).
witnessed on a random basis. — O&M documentation should be produced as the
— Logs should be used (if available) when witnessing work proceeds and updated when necessary. This
points in order to monitor the performance of any work should commence at the start of the contract
control actions. and be added to/updated as the contract progresses.
— Verification of handover of all operating manuals — Ensure that approved final copies of the O&M
and system documentation (see section L4.2). manuals are provided at handover.
— Verification of handover of backup copies of — The O&M manual should be properly indexed.
software. Terminology and references used must be
consistent with the physical identification of
— Verification of system operator training requirements. component parts.
— Write up (or print out from the control system’s
L4.2 Commissioning documentation memory) the settings of each scene in terms of
fade time, the lighting channels that are invoked
per scene and the level per channel. Note that
L4.2.1 Checklists
different manufacturers of control systems use
the terms ‘control channel’, ‘dimming channel’,
Checklists are an important means of monitoring and
recording the progress of the commissioning process. ‘circuit’, ‘pre-set’, ‘state’ and ‘scene’ in various,
Checklists serve a variety of functions and can help provide and sometimes inconsistent, ways that are not
the following: always clear to end users. The terms must be
defined for each type of system.
— a record of tasks to be performed
— Ensure that the O & M manual includes the
— a means of monitoring the commissioning process following and is included in the site health and
— a record of completed work safety file:
— a means of measuring the quality of the installation — written description of system operation
— a record of commissioning data for inclusion in the — control strategy/logic diagrams recording
operating and maintenance manual (O&M manual); the version of configuration software
this should include records of final changes/fine installed at handover
tuning updates. — details of system application software
configuration
Checklists should be used throughout the pre-
commissioning and commissioning stages. — points list including hard and soft points
(all points should have a unique
mnemonic) – unless this is clearly
L4.2.2 Commissioning completion certificate incorporated in the system software, in
which case make appropriate reference to
It is recommended that the person responsible for this element.
commissioning management produces a commissioning
completion certificate. An example of a possible form for — description of user adjustable points
this certificate is given as appendix LA4. The certificate — commissioning record details
may include a checklist of commissioning tasks. The
commissioning certificate should be signed by the — detailed data sheets for all control
commissioning engineer and witnessed by the lighting components and equipment wiring circuit
designer and a user/client representative. details including origin, route and
destination of each cable
In some projects it may be necessary to perform a phased — comprehensive instructions for switching
completion programme in which the lighting system is
on, operation, switching off, isolation,
completed and certified in sections. However, if a certified
fault finding and procedures for dealing
section is altered in any way during the rest of the
with emergency conditions
construction programme, it should be re-certified before
handover. It is recommended that such alterations be — instructions for any precautionary
avoided if at all possible. measures necessary
10 Lighting
The successful operation of a lighting control system Facilities managers and maintenance personnel are likely
to need to know the following properties of the
depends very much on the skill and knowledge of the
illumination systems:
system operator. As such, adequate training of system
operators is therefore essential. It is advantageous if the — the types of luminaires used
intended system operator can be present during at least
— the correct types of lamps to be used for each
part of the commissioning stage. This will allow the
luminaire type
operator to become familiar with the system and develop
experience while commissioning staff are on site. The — advised maintenance cycles
degree of beneficial interaction between the operator and — access for maintenance
the commissioning personnel will depend on the ability of
the operator and the terms of the commissioning contract. — the location of spares
— the location of switches.
The requirement for operator training will depend on the
complexity of the control system and the client’s intended These lists are indicative and not intended to be
approach to operating the system, along with the degree to exhaustive.
which reliance will be placed on external support and
operational services.
— call up and view point data from schematics and/or The extent and frequency of post-occupancy checks
points lists should be included in the control system specification as
part of the contract between the building owner and the
— acknowledge system alarms
construction supply chain and will depend on the nature
— view trend logs. and complexity of the control system. It is also important
Post-occupancy checks 11
that lease documents support any contractual 8 Electricity Safety, Quality and Continuity Regulations 2002 SI
requirements for post-occupancy evaluation and ensure 2002 No. 2665 (London: The Stationery Office) (2002)
that the leaseholder is required to provide reasonable 9 BS 667: Specification for illuminance meters (London: British
access for their performance. Standards Institution) (1996)
10 Code for Lighting (London: Chartered Institution of Building
Post-handover checks can comprise a continuation of
Services Engineers/Society of Light and Lighting) (2002)
functional checking relating directly to the lighting
control system. Where a central control system is 11 Guide to ownership, operation and maintenance of building services
implemented, use should be made of its logging functions (London: Chartered Institution of Building Services
once it is confirmed that these are operating accurately. Engineers) (2000)
This feature along with the ability to display trend logs is 12 Building energy log books — A guide and standard template for
invaluable when performing operational checks. preparing log books for non-domestic buildings CIBSE TM31
(London: Chartered Institution of Building Services
Engineers) (2003)
13 The visual environment for display screen use CIBSE/SLL Lighting
References Guide 3 (London: Chartered Institution of Building Services
1 BS 7671: Requirements for electrical installations. IEE Wiring Engineers/Society of Light and Lighting) (1996 including
Regulations (London: British Standards Institution) (2002) addendum 2001 and declaration of conformity 2002).
2 BS 5266: Emergency lighting (London: British Standards 14 Lighting in the countryside, towards good practice
Institution) (seven parts) DETR/Countryside Commission (London: HMSO) (1997)
3 The Building Regulations 2000 Conservation of fuel and power 15 BS 5489 Road lighting (in the process of being replaced by BS
Approved Document L2: Conservation of fuel and power in EN 13201 but BS 5489 will be revised to form a UK application
buildings other than dwellings (London: The Stationary document)
Office) (2002)
16 Energy efficiency in lighting — an overview GIR 92 (London:
4 Declaration of conformity to the Building Regulations 2000: Action Energy) (2003)
Approved Document L1 Conservation of fuel and power in dwellings
and Approved Document L2: Conservation of fuel and power in
buildings other than dwellings (Telford: Lighting Association)
(2003), can be downloaded from www.lightingassociation.com Bibliography
5 Declaration of conformity to the Building Regulations 2000: Hospitals and health care buildings CIBSE Lighting Guide 2 (London:
Approved Document L1 Conservation of fuel and power in dwellings Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers) (1989, addendum
and Approved Document L2: Conservation of fuel and power in 1999)
buildings other than dwellings (London: Lighting Industry
Federation) (2003), can be downloaded from www.lif.co.uk Lecture, teaching and conference rooms CIBSE Lighting Guide 5 (London:
Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers) (1991)
6 Automatic controls CIBSE Commissioning Code C (London:
Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers) (2001) The outdoor environment CIBSE Lighting Guide 6 (London: Chartered
Institution of Building Services Engineer) (1992)
7 Commissioning management CIBSE Commissioning Code M
(London: Chartered Institution of Building Services Museums and art galleries CIBSE Lighting Guide 8 (London: Chartered
Engineers) (2003) Institution of Building Services Engineers) (1994)
12 Lighting
Every lighting installation needs commissioning, whether Task 2.5 was N/A as the high-intensity discharge lamps
it be a very simple project involving a client and one chosen were only available at one correlated colour
contractor or a multi-function public building with temperature. Tasks 2.9, 2.10, 2.11 and 2.13 were deemed
offices, walkways, hire out facilities and exhibitions. relevant but the rest of section 2 was thought N/A.
Below are some hypothetical examples of how a project
might be commissioned. They are not templates, as every Of section 3, only tasks 3.1, 3.2 and 3.3 were deemed
project has different parameters and different parties relevant with the rest filled in N/A. The commissioning
involved in the design and installation. manager signed tasks 3.1 and 3.3 but, crucially, it was the
client who completed task 3.2, because the midnight
In all cases, someone should be appointed as the switch off was the client’s decision not the contractor’s.
commissioning manager. The tasks defined in sections
1.1–1.7 of the Specific checklist (Figure LA2.2) in
Appendix LA2 always apply; the examples show how other LA1.2 Example 2
tasks may or may not apply.
A local business decided that its new office would be used
by VDT operators. It used a local building firm (a main
LA1.1 Example 1 contractor) which had its own electrical contractor. The
electrical contractor asked a VDT lighting equipment
A school wanted exterior floodlighting installed and supplier to make sure that the scheme complied with the
wanted an adjacent corridor to be re-lit. The only parties CIBSE/SLL Code for lighting(10) and LG3(13) and this service
involved were the client — the school’s representative — was paid for. The control system was commissioned by its
and a local electrical contractor. The brief was minimal manufacturer as a paid service and the control system
and stated that the car park needed to be lit at certain engineer carried out the task. The control system uses
times, but not all night, and in the most energy efficient passive infra-red and photocells with some switch .
way possible. Equipment had to be easy to maintain and
needed to match, where possible, other equipment. One The commissioning manager in this case is the main
local neighbour had previously complained about ‘too
contractor. However, since the main contractor does not
much light at night’. The corridor lighting was to be low
want to be involved in lighting matters, all he/she does is
energy use and comply with modern practice.
to assign the right person to the right task in the Specific
checklist (Figure LA2.2).
First, the contractor decided to not consult anyone else
and perform a design and build project. The contractor
He gives the electrical contractor responsibility for task 1 in
chose suitable new floodlights with characteristics
including long-life sources and good lumens/watt efficacy, the Specific checklist (Figure LA2.2). The electrical
and compact fluorescent interior lighting for the corridor contractor was also given responsibility for tasks 2.1 and
(some with an emergency facility) along with new exit 2.3, along with tasks 3.7 and 3.10. A part of the scheme used
signs to match others installed in a previous contract. wallwashing as a technique. The electrical contractor, being
unfamiliar with wallwashing, asked the luminaire
The electrical contractor worked out the quantity and manufacturer to take responsibility for tasks 2.2 and 2.6.
spacing and decided to use a time switch with two (On other projects the electrical contractor might do this
switching modes to allow for midnight switch off. Having task instead.)
worked out a plan and had approval from the client (and
their approved bodies), the electrical contractor installed The luminaire manufacturer signed for and checked tasks
the equipment and appointed its site manager to be the 2.13 to 2.18 with illuminance meters and recorded its
commissioning manager. Once all the equipment was findings. It was not surprised to be asked to do this as it
installed and working, the contractor aimed the had agreed to it at the time of the order of the equipment.
floodlights on to the car park, being mindful of the The manufacturer also carried out and signed tasks 3.5
complaint regarding glare. and 3.12, being the designers of the system. The control
system engineer carried out tasks 3.4, 3.6, 3.8 and 3.13.
The commissioning manager signed tasks 1.1–2.2 of the
Specific checklist (Figure LA2.2) in Appendix LA2 and All of the other tasks were marked N / A . The main
ticked them as the work was completed. The contractor knew who was doing what and it was sorted out
commissioning manager ticked task 2.3, as the phosphor in one meeting.
of the compact fluorescent lamps was chosen to match the
rest of the corridors. Task 2.4 was also ticked since the
floodlights were available in three beam widths and, LA1.3 Example 3
although it would not have mattered from an electrical
safety point of view, installing the wrong beam type would A museum opened and had a complicated multimedia
have lit the car park wrongly and perhaps caused glare to event together with architectural lighting and office
the neighbour. administration spaces.
Appendix LA1: Hypothetical examples of lighting commissioning 13
As well as a client, an architect, a main contractor and an lighting control system, and the architectural non-
electrical contractor, there is an interior designer, a museum-space lighting controls will be designed,
lighting designer and a multimedia subcontractor. The installed, focused and programmed by the same party.
building had a BMS that communicated with the This is unlikely to be the case.
multimedia museum control system twice a day. From
then on the multimedia system was stand alone. The checklist must be extended to incorporate all of the
subsystems. In complicated projects, the commissioning
To begin with, the client or the main contractor appointed will also involve site visits at various stages of the building
a commissioning manager. The list of tasks in the Specific construction to check that critical locations of lighting
checklist in Appendix LA2 (Figure LA2.2) was assigned niches, surface-to-luminaire offsets etc. are not altered
to the relevant professionals listed above. without consultation (see checklist, Figure LA2.2, task
1.1, for example).
The commissioning manager must be aware of the subtle
distinction between checking that a system works and If the lighting designer is overruled about such matters, it
checking that it is programmed correctly. may mean that the aesthetic intent of the installation
cannot be realised later at the programming stage. The
It is easy to assume that the office lighting control system, task list will allow the client to know who will check these
the BMS , the show controller with its linked museum matters in good time before completion of the project.
14 Lighting
Pre-construction phase:
Appoint commissioning manager (CM) or assign
specific responsibilities for commissioning process C
Construction phase/pre-handover:
Have there been any equipment substitutions from original design? Tick if yes. K
If yes above, does substitute equipment meet the design requirements? Tick if yes. K
Install and wire hardware as per design and/or instructions and certify completion K
Post-handover phase:
Notes:
1 The person(s) responsible for each task should be assigned at the initial contract stage.
2 For some lighting control systems the commissioning engineer may be a representative of the manufacturer.
3 The RIBA stages are included in this checklist for information only about the stage at which each task might be addressed; it is not intended that
they should form part of an actual checklist. A flowchart showing the construction process and the RIBA stages of work is included in this Appendix.
Commissioning to ensure:
1.1 Critical offset distances of luminaires or structures have been achieved Note 1
1.6 Groups of luminaires are assigned to the correct positions in grid switch
or grid single circuit dimmer Note 4
2.1 Luminaires and remote control gear are of the correct make and type Note 5
2.2 Fixed luminaires have been installed at the correct orientation Note 6
2.4 Spot lamps are of the correct make, beam angle and rating Note 7
2.5 Discharge lamps have the correct correlated colour temperature (CCT) Note 7
2.6 All lamps are the correct wattage and voltage ratings Note 7
2.8 Surface removable luminaires have been installed on tracks and trusses Note 9
2.9 Surface removable luminaires have been aimed/focused on tracks and trusses Note 10
2.10 Focus notes have been drawn up to allow for re-aiming after maintenance Note 10
2.11 Exterior floodlights have been aimed to drawing and according to terms of
planning permission (particularly relevant for sports installations) Note 11
2.12 Mains voltage, line and lamp currents have been checked at the control
gear on exterior floodlighting schemes, particularly for sports Note 11
3.1 Time switches have been installed and are working Note 18
3.2 Time switches have had their operating times chosen Note 18
3.3 Time switches have been programmed properly with the chosen times Note 18
Commissioning to ensure:
3.5 Illuminance trigger levels have been chosen (on adjustable photocell systems) Note 19
3.6 Illuminance trigger levels have been set (on adjustable photocell systems) Note 19
3.7 PIR detector systems are installed and working correctly Note 20
3.8 PIR detector systems are programmed and operate correctly Note 20
3.9 FM radio switches have been configured to the relevant receivers Note 21
3.10 Control signal cables have been wired between dimming fluorescent ballasts,
without cross-over, allowing all ballasts to dim when DC voltage is applied. Note 22
3.12 Lighting levels associated with control signal voltages have been chosen Note 22
3.13 Lighting levels associated with control signal voltages have been programmed Note 22
3.14 Preset rack control system has data cables installed between plates
and racks but not terminated Note 23
3.15 Preset rack control system has control plates fitted and data cables terminated Note 23
3.16 Preset rack control system: main ‘dimmer rack’ mounted to wall mains
cabling marked and terminated but data cables not terminated Note 23
3.17 Preset rack control system: data cables terminated in dimmer rack Note 23
3.18 Preset rack control system: control cables installed between luminaires
and control devices but not terminated Note 23
3.20 Preset rack control system: settings of states, times and levels chosen Note 23
3.21 Preset rack control system: settings of states, times and levels programmed Note 23
3.22 Ethernet and digital multiplex (DMX) systems: termination resistors have
been fitted where necessary and screened cables have been used Note 24
3.25 Timed show control system designer has instructed programmer Note 25
3.28 BMS lighting levels and switching times have been chosen Note 26
3.29 BMS lighting levels and switching times have been programmed in Note 26
3.30 Combined BMS and preset rack control systems work together properly Note 27
Figure LA2.2 Specific checklist for the commissioning of lighting systems (continued)
Appendix LA2: Checklists for the commissioning of lighting systems 17
B: Strategic brief
C: Outline proposals
1.1 Appoint commissioning manager if required
D: Detailed proposals
1.2 Check design for commissionability and ease
of maintenance (designer to alter if necessary)
E: Final proposals
F: Production information
G: Tender documentation
H: Tender action
K: Construction to practical
completion:
Note: This is an example of a possible commissioning — Provide technical advice and assistance with the
method statement. In practice, the responsibilities of the setting up of the lighting system and agree suitable
parties will vary depending on the contractual framework. programs (where appropriate).
The installer shall certify that the following checks have The commissioning engineer shall:
been completed prior to commissioning by the — Ensure that all lights are working and that all
commissioning engineer (a signed checklist is switch labels are correct.
recommended showing completion date of check):
— Check the manual and automatic operation of
— All luminaires installed as per design and with the automatic switching units, lighting connection
correct orientations units and presence detectors, including end-user
controls — on larger projects this can be done on a
— All automatic switching units and lighting
sampling basis sufficient to prove the correct
connection units fitted and signal bus wires operation of controllers and switching units.
connected (if appropriate) with necessary labelling
— Program area control units (if not already
— All channel dials and function switches set programmed by the manufacturer on or off-site)
correctly and prove their operation.
— All sensor level switches set correctly — Ensure that all devices and area controllers are
— All luminaires wired or plugged into correct loaded into the central system (if appropriate) and
circuits and automatic switch units (where can be identified.
appropriate) with appropriate labelling and correct — Program central controller (if not already
lamps fitted programmed on or off-site) and prove correct
operation of both time and solar operation.
— All local override switches, PIR and solar detectors
etc. plugged into local control units (if appropriate) — Ensure that all time and seasonal operations that
cannot be checked directly e.g. daylight-saving
— All area control units (if any) installed and area settings, calendars (including leap years), seasonal
switches wired and labelled variations etc. appear to be set correctly.
— Mains supply is available to all lighting control — Schedule and perform additional post-handover
units and area controllers and mains voltage is checks where required (e.g. seasonal checks).
stable and fit for regular use.
— Explain the system and demonstrate operation to
The pre-commissioning checklist should be passed to the maintenance personnel and end users as required
by prior agreement with client representative.
commissioning engineer and can form part of the O&M
manual. In addition: — Ensure that maintenance personnel are conversant
with access equipment required.
— The designer shall provide building plans to
installers, manufacturers and commissioning
engineers as required. LA3.3 Witnessing, certification and
— The designer shall produce a sheet detailing the handover
assumptions made as part of the design, including
the method used for calculating maintenance The commissioning engineer shall:
factors, for inclusion in the O&M manual.
— Arrange for the designer and a client
— The designer shall provide details of access representative to witness a representative sample
equipment and precautions to be taken for safe of the system operation.
access. Risk assessments may be required for — Hand over specified spare lamps and accessories.
maintenance.
— Complete a system commissioning completion
— The client representative shall ensure that certificate and have it witnessed by the designer
information regarding daily time programmes is and client (user) representative and include in the
available. O&M manual. Note: The installer should also sign
this certificate or a separate pre-commissioning
The commissioning engineer shall: certificate to certify that installation is complete.
— Generally examine the wiring and bring any faults — Complete as-installed diagrams and include in the
to the attention of the installer. O&Mmanual.
20 Lighting
Project number:
Phase/area:
The (name or describe) system installed in the above building has been fully installed and is ready for
commissioning. It has been installed in accordance with the previously agreed specification and/or functional
description of the system and design intent (add reference if available)
The items indicated below were checked and found to be installed to specification: OK N/A
Headings: Items:
Installer:
Company: Date:
Company: Date:
Notes:
Project number:
Phase/area:
The (name or describe) system installed in the above building has been fully commissioned and checked to be
operating in accordance with the previously agreed specification and/or functional description for the operation
of the system and design intent (add reference if available)
The items indicated below were checked and found to be installed to specification: OK N/A
Headings: Items:
Commissioning engineer:
Company: Date:
Company: Date:
Notes:
Appendix LA6: Notes concerning the design of lighting and lighting control
systems
LA6.1 Design for commissionability — Complexity of the system: systems whose mode of
operation is not intuitively obvious are likely to be
It is important that a system specifier is aware of the used at less than their optimum operational efficiency
requirements to ensure that a control system is inherently when new staff are responsible for their operation.
commissionable. The involvement of a commissioning
engineer/designer at the design stage should be considered — Accessibility: luminaires in difficult to reach
where in-house experience is not sufficiently comprehensive. positions (e.g. on roofs of atria, external fitments
not at ground level) should be designed with long-
Issues that impinge on the commissionablity of a control life lamps and have a well thought out and
system include the following: documented procedure for re-lamping.
— Appropriate control strategies and set points: — If directional luminaires are used to create an
control strategies should reflect the work patterns effect, attention must be considered as to whether
and needs of the users. Set points should take into the user has the personnel to maintain the
account the task lighting requirements. installation. In some cases a maintenance contract
— Packaged systems: a number of ‘packaged’ should be considered.
systems, e.g. so-called intelligent luminaires, are
available that may be pre-configured and pre- — Stock efficiency: a complex lighting scheme with
commissioned. However, consideration will have many different lamp types (and especially unusual
to be given to interfacing issues should packaged lamp types) will require a large stock storage
systems use control equipment supplied from facility — or long intervals with failed lamps
different vendors. Also, off-site co-ordination before replacements are sourced. Where possible
issues must be addressed. and practical, the number of different lamp types
— Interaction with existing or other control should be kept to a minimum.
equipment: manual override, fire, emergency.
— Sensor type and location: it is important that the LA6.3 Design for energy efficiency
correct type and accuracy sensor is used for the
intended application. Particular attention should and user satisfaction
be paid to ensuring that sensors are located in
positions that allow a representative measurement In order to minimise energy consumption it is important
to be made. Photoelectric lighting sensors should that lighting systems do not provide more lighting than is
not be placed such that direct sunlight can fall on needed for the task and visual amenity, and that they are
them. A sufficient number of sensors should be controlled properly. This requires that the set-up and
used so that zones of roughly similar daylight operation of a control system is checked in order to avoid:
levels are controlled from one sensor. Passive
infrared occupancy or presence sensors should be — Unnecessary periods of lighting operation
have a ‘line of sight’ to all areas lit by the
— Poor control of set points.
luminaires they control (this is not needed for
acoustic or microwave sensors).
However, too frequent switching of lighting by automatic
systems, or too large an illuminance difference after
LA6.2 Design for maintenance switching, are both detrimental to user satisfaction.
Lighting control strategies must balance energy efficiency
A number of issues affect the ease of maintenance of a requirements with human factors. See also GIR 92 Energy
lighting system. These include: efficiency in lighting — an overview(16).
24 Lighting
Light meters — see Illuminance PIR — see Passive infra-red detection Specification ‘breaking’ 6
measurement Plan, commissioning 5 Specifications, commissioning 1, 2
Light trespass 12 Planning permission 6 Specific checklist 15
Live working 22 Plans, building 19 Speculative office buildings 6
Local control unit (definition) 3 Plasterers 6 Speed of communication networks 8
Location changes, proposed 14 Point data (definition) 3 Spill light 6
Log book, building 1, 10 Points list 9 Sports lighting 15, 17
Logic diagrams 9 Portable light meter 7 Spot lamps 15
Low voltage (definition) 3 Post-handover phase 14 Stability of mains supply 19
Low voltage controllers 17 Post-occupancy checks 10 Stages required to commission 1
Lumen-maintenance systems 7 Post-occupancy evaluation 10 State of the system 6
Luminaire manufacturer 12 Practical completion 3, 7 Statutory requirements 1, 22
Luminaires 4, 6, 8, 14, 15, Pre-commissioning 2, 6 Stock efficiency 23
16, 19 Pre-commissioning certificate 6, 19, 20 Street lighting 15, 17
Luminances 15 Pre-commissioning checks 6, 14, 19 Sub-contracts, disadvantages of 5
Predictive occupancy control 3 Substitutions, equipment 6, 14, 17
M&E consultant 5 Programming, control system 4, 13, 17 Surface removable luminaires 15
Main contractor 5, 12, 13, 14 Pre-handover 14 Surface-to-luminaire offsets 13, 15
Mains-borne signalling 3 Preset rack control system 16 Sweep-off 7
Mains wiring 6 Project management 5 Switches 6, 15, 17, 19
Maintenance 4, 10, 12, 14, Project meetings 14 Switching, ON/OFF (definition) 4
15, 23 Purpose of the Code 1 Switching frequency 23
Maintenance contract 23 Push button controls 7 Switching times 16
Maintenance factor 3, 19 Radio frequency (definition) 4 System back-up 10
Maintenance staff 14, 19 Raise and lower gear 6 System handover 8
Management of Health and Safety at Work Ramp speed (definition) 4 System integration (definition) 4
Regulations 1999 22 Rating, lamp 6 System operator 10
Manual controls 7 References 11 System upkeep, instructions for 10
Manual override for blinds 8 Regulation (definition) 4
Manufacturer, specified 6 Re-lamping, method of 23 Technical advice, provision of 19
Marshalling box (definition) 3 Relationship between lighting Telephone based controls 7
Mechanical checks 6 and shading 8 Termination resistors 16
Method statement — see Commissioning Remote control gear 15 Testing 4, 22
method statement Report generation software 8 Third party management software 8
Miniature circuit breaker (definition) 3 Responsibility, overall 5 Threshold increment 15
Modular wiring (definition) 3 Responsible person 22 Time-delay settings 7
Multimedia contractor 13 RF (radio-frequency) (definition) 4 Time programmes, changing 10
Multimedia equipment 12 RIBA stages of work 14, 18 Time schedule 4
Museum lighting 12 Risk assessment 14, 19, 22 Time switches 12, 15, 17
Routers, network 8 Timetable, commissioning 2, 5, 6, 14
Network resilience 8 Rubber mats 22 Time taken for commissioning 6
Niches, lighting 13 Track, lighting 6, 15
Safety chains and cords 6, 17 Trailing-edge dimmer (definition) 4
Occupancy detection 3, 7 Safety, electrical 4, 22 Training 10, 14, 19, 22
Occupancy programmes, changing 10 Safety issues 22 Trend logs 10, 11
Office buildings, speculative 6 Scene setting 4, 8 Trigger levels, illuminance 16
Office lighting 12, 17 Scene settings, record of 9
Off-site tasks 6, 14, 23 Schedules, construction 4 Uniformity 15
Operating and maintenance Schematics, building 8 Unitary control devices 4, 8
manual 3, 9, 14, 17, 19 Scope of the Code 1 Update instructions 10
Operator training 10, 16 Seasonal variation 10, 19 User-adjustable points 9
Operator workstation 3, 8 Second fix 17 User satisfaction 23
Orientation, luminaire 17 Security lighting 7 Verification of handover of back-up
Outstations 3, 8 Security staff override 7 copies of software 9
Override functions 3, 8, 19 Segregation, electrical 6 Verification of handover of
Sensors 6, 7, 19, 23 operating manuals 9
Passive infra-red detection 3, 12, 16, 17, Servicing, instructions for 10 Verification of lighting installation
19, 23 Set points 10, 23 performance 8
Packaged systems 23 Shading and lighting 8 Verification of system operator
Passwords, software 8 Show controller 4, 13, 16, 17 training requirements 9
PC-based controls 7 Signal bus 2, 19 VDT lighting 12
Performance testing (definition) 3 Signature 12, 13, 14,
Permit to work system 22 15, 16 Wall washing 12, 18
Personal protective equipment 22 Site visits 13 Warning notices 22
Personal Protective Equipment at Work Soft points 2 Wiring 19
Regulations 1992 22 Software pre-commissioning 6 Wiring diagrams 6
‘Person responsible’ 5 Software release, correct 8 Witnessing arrangements 8, 9, 14, 19
Phased completion 6, 9 Solar detectors 19 Working Time Regulations 1999 22
Phosphors 6, 15 Specific checklist 12, 13 Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare)
Photocells 3, 12, 16, 23 Specification (definition) 4 Regulations 1992 22