BOMBAY HIGHCOURT

WEEKLY MAIN - 2 CAUSELIST

For the period: 12-06-2023 To: 13-06-2023
COURT NO. 52
DIVISION
AT 10:30 AM
HON'BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANDEEP V. MARNE

Sr. CASE NO. PARTIES ADVOCATES

FOR DIRECTION

201 APP/162/2010 M/S.SANJAY TRADE CORPORATION, M/S. KHAITAN and JAYAKAR

[Original] MUMBAI. M/S. KHAITAN AND JAYAKAR
VS RESP. NO 1
1.M/S. ITOCHU CORPORATION, RES.NO.3
JAPAN and 2 ORS. KOCHHAR AND CO
KAMNI AHUJA and SHABANA
RAIKAR 1
In
ARBP/19/2007
REMARK : == FOR CIRCULATION AS PER PRAECIPED TD., 03/3/16 == COMPILATION OF DOCUMENTS
FILED BY ADVOCATE FOR APPELLANT ON 30/03/2010. (U/OBJ.)

202 APP/172/2010 SANJAY PRATAPRAI MEHTA WADIA GHANDY AND CO

[Original] VS M/S. KHAITAN AND JAYAKAR
ITOCHU CORPORATION AND ORS. RESP NO.1
KOCHHAR AND CO
KAMNI AHUJA and SHABANA
RAIKAR 1
In
ARBP/19/2007
REMARK : == FOR CIRCULATION BY PRAECIPE DTD., 04/4/2017 OF KOCHHAR & CO., ADVOCATE FOR
THE RESPONDENT NO.1 ==

FOR DISPOSAL

203 APP/174/2010 MRS. BINA SAHNI MAHESH MENON AND CO

[Original] VS M/S.PUROHIT and CO.
M/S. PORECHA GLOBAL SECURITIES PUROHIT and CO.
PVT. LTD. MAHESH MENON and CO
In
ARBP/2/2002
REMARK : == FOR CIRCULATION BY PRAECIPE DTD., 04/4/2017 OF KOCHHAR & CO., ADVOCATE FOR
THE RESPONDENT NO.1 ==

09/06/2023 20:48:39 1/8

 WEEKLY MAIN - 2 CAUSELIST COURT NO 52-FOR MONDAY THE 12TH JUNE 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 2 -

204 APP/200/2010 VENTURA SECURITIES LTD. PUROHIT AND CO

[Original] VS PUROHIT AND CO
APEKSHA R. BOTHRA RASHMARANI . NATHANI
In
ARBP/392/2009
REMARK : **** NOT BEFORE HONOURABLE SHRI JUSTICE ANOOP V. MOHTA, ORDER DTD. 30/01/2017
****

WITH

APP/1085/2010 RAJENDRA KUMAR BOTHRA RAVINDRA R. CHILE

[Orignal] VS RESHMARANI J. NATHANI
VENTURA SECURITIES LTD. PUROHIT and CO.
In M/S PUROHIT and CO
ARBP/89/2009

FOR FINAL HEARING

205 APP/47/2011 AMIT S. LANAVAT SAVINA S. BANGERA

[Original] VS SAVINA S. BANGERA
KOTAK SECURITIES RESPONDENT
SUBRA KARMAKAR
V. K. RAMABHADRAN
In
ARBP/1018/2009
REMARK : **** NOT BEFORE HONOURABLE SHRI JUSTICE ANOOP V. MOHTA, ORDER DTD. 30/01/2017
****

206 APP/196/2011 M/S. KRISHNA KNITWEAR APPELLANT

[Original] TECHNOLOGY LIMITED Auris Legal
VS PARAS KUHAD AND ASSOCIATES
THE COTTON CORPORATION OF DHRUVE LILADHAR and CO.
INDIA M/S DHRUVE LILADHAR and CO
In
ARBP/92/2008
REMARK : SC ltr. D.No.1018/11/Sec.IX,dt.20/5/11-SLP Dismissed on12/5/11.SC ltr. dt.11/7/11-Interlocutory
applications disposed of. BANK GUARANTEE FILED BY ADV. FOR APPELLANT OF UCO BANK,
NO.1784IGFIN007611 FOR RS.5,00,00,000/- VALID UPTO 24/7/2014 AND CORPORATION BANK, B.G.
NO.2011/40 FOR RS. 7,50,00,000/- VALID UPTO 29/7/2018. ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENT, DHRUVE
LILADHAR & CO. HAS FILLED OBJECTION PREACIPE ON 29/06/2015. BG NO.2011/40 DT 29/07/2011 FOR A
SUM OF RS.7.50.00.000/- IS VALID UPTO 29/07/2019.PURSUANT TO THE ORDER DT 05/05/2015 THE
APPELLANTS HAVE FURNISHED THE CORPORATE BANK GUARANTEE DT 28/03/2016 FOR A SUM OF
RS.6,25,00,000/- VALID UPTO 28/03/2019 ACCEPTED & TAKEN ON RECORD ON 31/03/2016.===

with

NMA/3555/2010 M/S. KRISHNA KNITWEAR TEC PARASKUHAD AND ASSOCIATES

[Orignal] HNOLOGY LIMITED Auris Legal
VS APPELLANT
In THE COTTON CORPORATION OF DHRUVE LILADHAR and CO.
APP/196/2011 INDIA

REMARK: Praecipe dt. 08.02.2021

with

09/06/2023 20:48:39 2/8

 WEEKLY MAIN - 2 CAUSELIST COURT NO 52-FOR MONDAY THE 12TH JUNE 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 3 -

NMA/1598/2011 M/S. KRISHNA KNITWEAR TEC PARAS KUHAD and ASSOCIATE

[Orignal] HNOLOGY LIMITED S
VS Auris Legal
In THE COTTON CORPORATION OF APPELLANT
APP/196/2011 INDIA DHRUVE LILADHAR and CO.

207 APP/197/2011 M/S. KRISHNA LIFESTYLE -

[Original] TECHNOLOGY LIMITED PARAS KUHAD AND ASSOCIATES
VS DHRUVE LILADHAR and CO.
THE COTTON CORPORATION OF M/S DHRUVE LILADHAR and CO
INDIA
In
ARBP/93/2008
REMARK : SC lttr. D.No.1014/11/\ Sec.IX,dt.30/5/11-SLPs Dismissed on 12/5/11.ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENT, DHRUVE LILADHAR & CO. HAS FILLED OBJECTION PREACIPE ON 29/06/2015. PURSUANT
TO THE ORDER DT 05/05/2015 PASSED BY THE HONBLE COURT READ WITH THE ORDER DT 29/01/2016
PASSED BY THE PROTHONOTARY & SENIOR MASTER APPELLANT HAS FURNISHED SECURITY IN THE
FORM OF REGISTERED ORIGINAL SALE DEED DT 23/01/2006 ACCEPTED & TAKEN ON RECORD ON
29/01/2016.PURSUANT TO THE ORDER DT 05/05/2015 THE APPELLANTS HAVE FURNISHED THE
CORPORATE BANK GUARANTEE DT 28/03/2016 FOR A SUM OF RS.6,25,00,000/- VALID UPTO 27/03/2017
ACCEPTED & TAKEN ON RECORD ON 31/03/2016. BG NO.2011/40 DT 19/07/2011 FOR A SUM OF
RS.7,50,00,000/- ISSUED BY CORPORATION BANK, LOWER PAREL BRANCH VALID UPTO 29/07/2019.

with

NMA/1597/2011 M/S. KRISHNA LIFESTYLE TE PARAS KUHAD and ASSOCIATE

[Orignal] CHNOLOGY LIMITED S
VS -
In THE COTTON CORPORATION O -
APP/197/2011 F INDIA GEETA SHANKAR LUNDWANI
DHRUVE LILADHAR and CO.

208 APP/227/2011 THE UNION OF INDIA SURESH KUMAR

[Original] VS SURESH KUMAR
M/S SUBRAHMANYAN AND CO. ROOP M VASUDEO
ROOP M VASUDEO
In
ARBP/136/2009
REMARK : == FOR CIRCULATION BY PRAECIPE DTD., 12/03/2020 OF ROOP M. VASUDEO, ADVOCATE ==

209 APP/335/2011 N. JAYALAXMI -

[Original] VS M/S. THAKORE JARIWALA and
HATHWAY CABLE AND DATACOM P. ASSOCIATES.
LTD THAKORE JARIWALA and
ASSOCIATES.
M/S. RUSTAMJI and GINWALA
In
ARBP/606/2008
REMARK : == FOR CIRCULATION BY PRAECIPE DTD., 12/03/2020 OF ROOP M. VASUDEO, ADVOCATE ==

09/06/2023 20:48:39 3/8

 WEEKLY MAIN - 2 CAUSELIST COURT NO 52-FOR MONDAY THE 12TH JUNE 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 4 -

210 APP/548/2011 BHAGYASHREE ENTERPRISES AND PREM S. GIDWANI

[Original] ENTERTAINMENT LTD. PREM S. GIDWANI
VS SUNANDA KUMBHAT
LADDHA BROS. FILMS PVT. LTD. SUNANDA R KUMBHAT
SUNANDA R KUMBHAT
In
ARBP/1306/2010
REMARK : AYNOPSIS DT 27/07/2016 AS PER SHRI JUSTICE ANOOP V MOHTA & SHRI. JUSTICE
G.S.KULKARNI DT 28/07/2016 FILED O 29/07/2016.. LIST OF JUDGEMENTS RELIED BY THE APPELLANT AS
PER SHRI.JUSTICE ANOOP V.MOHTA AND SHRI.JUSTICE G.S.KULKARNI DT.28/07/2016 FILED ON
29/07/2016 =

with

NMA/120/2014 BHAGYASHREE ENTERPRISES A MR. PREM S. GIDWANI

[Orignal] ND ENTERTAINMENT LTD. PREM S. GIDWANI
VS SUNANDA KUMBHAT
In LADDHA BROS. FILMS PVT. L
APP/548/2011 TD.

211 APP/586/2011 MICROSEC CAPITAL LTD. AJAY KHANDHAR AND CO

[Original] VS AJAY KHANDHAR AND CO
HARISH M. KALRA PUROHIT and CO.
PUROHIT and CO.
In
ARBP/1187/2010
REMARK : A PAPER-BOOK DATED 16/08/2011,TENDERED IN THE DIVISION BENCH ON 25/04/2012 BY THE
ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONERS IN THE ABOVE MATTER.THE SAME IS TAKEN ON FILE.

212 APP/609/2011 KIN SHIP SERVICES (INDIA) PVT. V.K. RAMABHADRAN

[Original] LTD. MESSRS. BHATT AND SALDANHA
VS BHATT and SALDANHA
SEALAND SHIPPING AND EXPORT V.K.RAMABHADRAN
PVT. LTD.
In
ARBP/178/2007
REMARK : A PAPER-BOOK DATED 16/08/2011,TENDERED IN THE DIVISION BENCH ON 25/04/2012 BY THE
ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONERS IN THE ABOVE MATTER.THE SAME IS TAKEN ON FILE.

213 APP/610/2011 INEOS ABS (INDIA) LTD. Khaitan

[Original] VS Khaitan
IMC LIMITED DUNMORR SETT
In
ARBP/619/2011
REMARK : == BY PRAECIPE == PURSUANT TO THE ORDER DT 09/02/2015 READ WITH THE ORDER DT
01/04/2015 PASSED BY THE HONBLE DIVISION BENCH RESPONDENT HAS FURNISHED BANK
GUARNATEE NO.005115IGFIN0014 DT. 18/06/2015 FOR A SUM OF RS. 16,68,89,752/- ISSUED BY UNION
BANK OF INDIA (FORMERLY KNOWN AS ANDHRA BANK), FORT BRANCH, MUMBAI VALID UPTO
17/06/2023.

214 APP/618/2011 BODY THIRST MULLA and MULLA and C.B. and C.
[Original] VS THAKORE JARIWALA AND
IMPEX ENGINEERS ASSOCIATES
VAISHALI CHOUDHARI
VAISHALI CHOUDHARI

09/06/2023 20:48:39 4/8

 WEEKLY MAIN - 2 CAUSELIST COURT NO 52-FOR MONDAY THE 12TH JUNE 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 5 -

In
ARBP/1098/2010
REMARK : == BY PRAECIPE == PURSUANT TO THE ORDER DT 09/02/2015 READ WITH THE ORDER DT
01/04/2015 PASSED BY THE HONBLE DIVISION BENCH RESPONDENT HAS FURNISHED BANK
GUARNATEE NO.005115IGFIN0014 DT. 18/06/2015 FOR A SUM OF RS. 16,68,89,752/- ISSUED BY UNION
BANK OF INDIA (FORMERLY KNOWN AS ANDHRA BANK), FORT BRANCH, MUMBAI VALID UPTO
17/06/2023.

215 APP/640/2011 MOATILAL OSWAL SECURITIES LTD RAHUL KARNIK

[Original] VS RAHUL KARNIK AND A.SHARMA
IDEA INTERNATIONAL PVT LTD Khaitan
NANU HORMASJEE and CO. (1 TO
5)
In
ARBP/406/2007
REMARK : AS PER THE ORDER DATED 26/03/2012, PASSED BY THE COURT IN THE ABOVE MATTER, THE
ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANT FILED TWO SETS OF COMPILATION OF DOCUMENTS ON BEHALF OF
THE APPELLANT ON 04/04/2012.

WITH

APP/759/2011 MOTILAL OSWAL SECURITIES RAHUL KARNIK

[Orignal] LTD M/S NANU HIORMASJEE AND
VS CO
In IDEA INTERNATIONAL PVT.LT Khaitan
ARBP/144/2007 D. KHAITAN SUD & PARTNERS
RAHUL KARNIK / G K TRIPAT
HI

With

NMA/2773/2016 MOTILAL OSWAL SECURITIES RAHULKARNIK

[Orignal] LTD RAHUL KARNIK
VS 0
In IDEA INTERNATIONAL PVT.LT Khaitan
APP/759/2011 D. KHAITAN SUD & PARTNERS

WITH

APP/760/2011 MOTILAL OSWAL SECURITIES RAHUL KARNIK

[Orignal] LTD. M/S. NANU HORMASJEE AND C
VS O.
In ANIL AGARWAL INDIAN Khaitan
ARBP/194/2007 KHAITAN SUD & PARTNERS
RAHUL KARNIK, FOR RESPOND
ENT

216 APP/649/2011 Upakar Infra Projects Pvt. Ltd. and NEGANDHI SHAH AND
[Original] Anr. HIMAYTULLA
VS M/S.NEGANDHI SHAH AND
Tata Motors Finance Ltd. HIMAYATULLAH.
KMC LEGAL VENTURE
MOHIT GADKARI and CO., U/OBJ
MOHIT GADKARI and CO.

09/06/2023 20:48:39 5/8

 WEEKLY MAIN - 2 CAUSELIST COURT NO 52-FOR MONDAY THE 12TH JUNE 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 6 -

In
ARBP/1158/2010
REMARK : AS PER THE ORDER DATED 26/03/2012, PASSED BY THE COURT IN THE ABOVE MATTER, THE
ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANT FILED TWO SETS OF COMPILATION OF DOCUMENTS ON BEHALF OF
THE APPELLANT ON 04/04/2012.

217 APP/699/2011 HINDUSTAN PETROLEUM VYAS AND BHALWAL

[Original] CORPORATION LTD RAVAL SHAH AND CO
VS RAVAL-SHAH and CO.
M/S. NANDI CYLINDER PVT. LTD. RUSTOMJI and GINWALA
In
ARBP/105/2011
REMARK : AS PER THE ORDER DATED 26/03/2012, PASSED BY THE COURT IN THE ABOVE MATTER, THE
ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANT FILED TWO SETS OF COMPILATION OF DOCUMENTS ON BEHALF OF
THE APPELLANT ON 04/04/2012.

218 APP/708/2011 M/S. PUYVAST CHARTERING B.V. ASHWIN SHANKAR

[Original] VS ASHWIN SHANKAR
KEC INTERNATIONAL LTD. LEGASIS PARTNERS
LEGASIS PARTNERS
LEGASIS PARTNERS
In
ARBP/200/2007
REMARK : AS PER THE ORDER DATED 26/03/2012, PASSED BY THE COURT IN THE ABOVE MATTER, THE
ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANT FILED TWO SETS OF COMPILATION OF DOCUMENTS ON BEHALF OF
THE APPELLANT ON 04/04/2012.

219 APP/742/2011 M/S. K.N. RAI SURESH KUMAR (APPELLANT)

[Original] VS M/S RAJESH KOTHARI AND CO.
AIRPORTS AUTHORITY OF INDIA RESPONDENT
M. V. KINI and CO.
SHILPA KAPIL
In
ARBP/338/2007
REMARK : ** FOR PRAECIPE DTD., 29/11/2018 OF SURESH KUMAR., ADVOCATE ** == By Praecipe dtd.
13/2/16 ==

220 APP/93/2012 INDUS ENGINEERING CO. THAKORDAS and MADGAVKAR

[Original] VS M/S THAKORDAS AND
INDIAN OIL CORPN. LTD AND ANR MADGAVKAR
DSK LEGAL, R-1
DSK LEGAL (1)
In
ARBP/79/2005
REMARK : ** FOR PRAECIPE DTD., 29/11/2018 OF SURESH KUMAR., ADVOCATE ** == By Praecipe dtd.
13/2/16 ==

221 APP/133/2012 OIL AND NATURAL GAS LITTLE AND COMPANY

[Original] CORPORATION LIMITED LITTLE AND CO.
VS RESPONDENT
JAGSON INTERNATIONAL LIMITED RAJESH HIRANAND
MIRCHANDANI
NANKANI and ASSO.
In

09/06/2023 20:48:39 6/8

 WEEKLY MAIN - 2 CAUSELIST COURT NO 52-FOR MONDAY THE 12TH JUNE 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 7 -

ARBP/493/2006
REMARK : SHIRALKAR AND CO.ADVOCATE DISCHARGE AS PER ADDL.PROTHONOTARY AND SR.MASTER
DTD.02/05/2019 ====

with

NMA/1168/2012 OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPO LITTLE AND COMPANY

[Orignal] RATION LIMITED LITTLE AND COMPANY
VS RAJESH HIRANAND MIRCHANDA
In JAGSON INTERNATIONAL LIMI NI
APP/133/2012 TED RESPONDENT

222 APP/165/2012 PARK SYNTHETICS AND ANIEL MADHUR R. BAYA

[Original] MEHRA CRAWFORD BAYLEY AND CO.
VS CROWFORD BAYLEY and CO.
NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY MADHUR R BAYA (1)
MADHUR R BAYA (2)
In
ARBP/400/2007
REMARK : AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE DATED 22/02/2012,FILED BY THE ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANTS IN
APPL/7/2012 IN ARBP/400/2007 ON 22/02/2012.

223 APP/187/2012 IQBAL AHMED HUSSAIN KHATRI LEGAL VENTURE

[Original] VS M/S S.K. JAIN
ABDUL MANNANCHOTEKHAN NILESH SUDHAKAR PARTE
S.K.JAIN and ASSOCIATES
NILESH S PARTE 3
SANJEEV S HARIAKAR [ 1 ]
H P PANDEY [ 1D,1E,1F]
NILESH S. PARTE (1(AI TO 1(AV) &
1B AND 1C
KHATRI LEGAL VENTURE (2)
In
ARBP/281/2008
REMARK : AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE DATED 22/02/2012,FILED BY THE ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANTS IN
APPL/7/2012 IN ARBP/400/2007 ON 22/02/2012.

224 APP/204/2012 AXIOS NAVIGATION CO. LTD. SUBRA KARMAKAR

[Original] MARSHALL ISLANDS. V.K. RAMABHADRAN
VS MULLA and MULLA and CRAIGE
INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LTD. BLUNT and CAROE
M/S MULLA and MULLA CBC
In
ARBP/132/2009
REMARK : AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE DATED 22/02/2012,FILED BY THE ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANTS IN
APPL/7/2012 IN ARBP/400/2007 ON 22/02/2012.

WITH

APP/273/2012 INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LT MULLA and MULLA and C.B.a

[Orignal] D. nd C.
VS V.K. RAMABHADRAN
In AXIOS NAVIGATION CO.LTD., SUBRA KARMAKAR

09/06/2023 20:48:39 7/8

 WEEKLY MAIN - 2 CAUSELIST COURT NO 52-FOR MONDAY THE 12TH JUNE 2023 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 8 -

ARBP/132/2009 RESPONDENT
M/S MULLA and MULLA CBC

With

CROL(L)/5/2013 INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LT V.K. RAMABHADRAN

[Original] D MULLA and MULLA and C.B.a
VS nd C.
In AXIOS NAVIGATION CO LTD. SUBRA KARMAKAR
APP/273/2012 RESPONDENT

225 APP/237/2012 GWL PROPERTIES LTD. Gagrats

[Original] VS Gagrats
JAMES MACKINTOSH AND ANIL D'SOUZA, YASHPAL JAIN
COMPANY PVT. LTD. ANIL P D'SOUZA and YASHPAL
JAIN
In
ARBP/272/2010
REMARK : THE ADVOCATE FOR THE APPELLANT FILED;THE CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
16/03/2012 PASSED BY THE DIVISION BENCH IN THE ABOVE MATTER ON 10/05/2012. B.G.FURNISHED BY
ADV. FOR RESPONDENT B.G.NO.45/81 (NEW NO. 0383IGPER000712) DT. 08/09/2012 FOR RS. 92,95,848/-
ISSUED BY BANK OF BARODA, BALLARD ESTATE BRANCH VALID UPTO 07/09/2023.

226 APP/244/2012 MANGILAL G. BIYANI PUROHIT AND CO

[Original] VS M/S PUROHIT AND CO.
JSB SECURITIES LTD. UDWADIA and UDHESHI
UDWADIA and UDESHI
In
ARBP/80/2007
REMARK : ***** FOR CIRCULATION BY PRAECIEP DTD., 30/07/2018 OF UDWADIA & CO., ADVOCATE *****
(NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 502-12 DISPOSED DTD. 10/04/12) Appeal Admit. (Expedited).

227 APP/321/2012 UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE T.J. PANDIAN

[Original] DEPUTY CHIEF ENGINEER NORTH SURESH KUMAR
CENTRAL RAILWAY UDAYA SANKAR SAMUDRALA
VS UDAY SANKAR SAMUDRALA
M/S BHAVNA ENGINEERING
COMPANY
In
ARBP/509/2008
REMARK : ***** FOR CIRCULATION BY PRAECIEP DTD., 30/07/2018 OF UDWADIA & CO., ADVOCATE *****
(NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 502-12 DISPOSED DTD. 10/04/12) Appeal Admit. (Expedited).

09/06/2023 20:48:39 8/8