Fieldbus Power July 1st 2005

Supply/Conditioner
Comparison

Description MTL P&F MTL Reference

Ag-181
Model F880 Power Hub: MB-FB-4R backplane with F600A
redundant HD2-FB-PS modules
Number of Segment/set 8 4 4
Technology Latest, evolution from old, combine previous KFD2 series onto proven with many installation
proven F600A, 3rd motherboard, PC concept is still same as worldwide with major end-users and
generation KFD2 version, passing FF-831 with warning Yokogawa CS3000R3
notice, 1st generation concept
Physical Size 151mm x 306.2mm 246mm x 221mm 200mm x 150mm
Power Supply Redundancy Redundant, hot swap Redundant, hot swap Redundant, hot swap
(PS)
Power Conditioner (PC) Redundant, hot swap Single, not hot swap Redundant, hot swap Para. 5.2.2
Terminator Smart Terminator external switchable terminator built-in into PS/PC
Single point of failure per None Yes on PC inside motherboard and not on PC but on surger suppressor,
segment terminator segment will continue to operate even
if component fails.
Current Load Sharing Yes only on non-isolated version? Yes Para. 5.2.2
Power Supply Unit Fail no effect to operation, no no effect to operation, no effect during no effect to operation, no effect during
Consequences effect during replacement replacement
replacement
Power Conditioner Fail no effect to operation, no affect particular segment, entire motherboard no effect to operation, no effect during
Consequences effect during has to be replaced and hence 4-segment has replacement
replacement to be down in order to replace one PC

Motherboard no component, no 4 x PC 'inside', 4 switchable terminators on

Current per Segment
terminator and surge suppression
external terminator board components to meet EMC
requirements
350 mA (enough for 16 x 500 mA (FF macrocycle limits more devices) 350 mA (enough for 16 x 20mA
20mA devices) devices)

MTL Instruments Pte. Ltd.

Singapore 1/ 2
 Description MTL P&F MTL Reference
Ag-181
Host redundant connection automatic detect, no manual switch on motherboard? automatic detect, no switching
detection switching
Heat Dissipation (it is 22.24 W for 8-segment Calculated from P+F data sheet 15.3W for 4- 20.3 W for 4-segment redundant.
always a good practice to redundant. Operating segments. This is exceedingly complicated Power module has a finned, radiating
provide sufficient cabinet temperature at 65C. as data sheet only states power dissipation black metal shell and is potted in
ventilation and heat for each module. Given that the units are in thermally conductive materials.
radiating mechanism) plastics case, with only small ventilation slots Operating temperature at 65C.
and a maximum operating temperature of
+60C, what is the maximum component
temperature inside the units. Mounting these
units on a vertical DIN rail is likely to lead to
very high temperatures in the modules.

Maximum sets per 2000H x 18 sets ( 144 20 to 26 sets ( 80 - 104 segments/cabinet) 22 to 30 sets ( 88 - 120
800D x 800W Panel at 63A segments/cabinet), segments/cabinet), 40 sets possible
bulk PSU limited by PSU rating
Diagnostic Yes Yes No
Fail Alarm contact Yes Yes Yes
Product availability Q3 2005 Q3 2005 ? since 2003
Diagnostic Module Yes Q3 for fail alarm Q1 2006 ? N.A
availability contact, full feature
diagnostic available Q1
2006 and can be just
plug into existing carrier
Aramco Approval Pending testing with not used in any major installation, not known Approved and used on Jeddah
Aramco by end July 05 running site Refinery. FPS-I used on Qatif, Zuluf
GOSP 2 + other Aramco projects
Installed base in Aramco N.A N.A Jeddah Refinery - 41 segments,
Qatif - 236 segments, Zuluf GOSP 2 -
145 segments
Design base on with Aramco not known Shell/Yokogawa
feedback/requirements

MTL Instruments Pte. Ltd.

Singapore 2/ 2