Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Air Pollution Potential: Regional Study in Argentina: Mari A I. Gassmann Nicola S A. Mazzeo
Air Pollution Potential: Regional Study in Argentina: Mari A I. Gassmann Nicola S A. Mazzeo
1007/s002679910029
Air pollution may be defined as ‘‘the presence in the ported and/or transformed in the atmosphere. The air
atmosphere of pollutants or combinations of them in pollution concentration at the receptor depends on the
such quantities and of such duration as may be or may location of the receptors in relation to the sources, on
tend to be injurious to human, plant, or animal life, or the source height, and on the emission rate. Further-
property, or which unreasonably interferes with the more, the sensitivity of the receptors towards pollutants
comfortable enjoyment of life or the conduct of busi- in conjunction to its concentration will determine the
ness.’’ One of the objectives of society is to have an effects.
appropriately clean atmosphere, obtained at an appro- Once polluted, the atmosphere can only be cleansed
priate cost. To reach this goal, there are different air by natural processes. Thus, knowledge of atmospheric
pollution control philosophies: emission standards, air processes is useful in the management of the atmo-
quality standards, emission taxes, and cost–benefit stan- spheric environment. Meteorological information and
dards. The implementation of these philosophies re- knowledge can contribute to establishing the bases for
quires different control methodologies. Some of them decisions regarding the control of emissions. In this way,
consist in obtaining better pollutant dispersion in the high air pollution potential can be related to the
lower atmosphere (high stacks, intermittent emission atmospheric conditions, which, given the existence of
controls, placing industrial plants far from populated sources, are conducive to the occurrence of high
areas), reducing emissions by changing industrial pro- concentrations of pollution. This definition is in terms
cesses, or installing control devices. of atmospheric conditions only and a high air pollution
The improvement of natural dispersion and self- potential may occur even through the air quality is
purification conditions of the atmosphere requires the good.
knowledge of the lower atmosphere’s characteristics. An important meteorological variable for air pollu-
Air pollutants reach the receptors after they are trans- tion potential is the mixing height. This height is
defined as the thickness of the atmospheric layer near
the ground in which relatively vigorous convective and
KEY WORDS: Atmospheric boundary layer; Mixing height; Air pollu-
tion potential; Transport wind; Low ventilation condi-
turbulent mixing take place. This height can range
tions from virtually zero at night to several kilometers in the
afternoon. Some authors in different countries have
*Author to whom correspondence should be addressed. evaluated and analyzed mixing height (Popovics and
Environmental Management Vol. 25, No. 4, pp. 375–382 r 2000 Springer-Verlag New York Inc.
376 M. I. Gassmann and N. A. Mazzeo
applicable. Table 1 shows the location of the meteoro- They give a description of the turbulent structure of the
logical stations, their identification number, their height ABL using an extension of the similarity theory devel-
over sea level and their surface roughness length (z0 ) oped for the surface layer (Monin and Obukhov 1954),
(see Panofsky and Dutton 1984). which employs the local fluxes rather than the surface
values as scaling parameters for the boundary layers’
parameters.
Methodological Aspects Integration of equation 1 with the windspeed profile
Mixing Height obtained by Ulke (1993) yields the following transport
wind equations:
The diurnal changes in solar radiation amounts set
For neutral atmospheric conditions:
up a cycle of cooling and heating of the lower layer of
3ln 1z 2 ⫺ 24
the atmosphere. After sunrise, due to the heating of the u*0 z 3
ground by solar radiation, a diurnal atmospheric bound- UT ⫽ (2)
k 0
ary layer (ABL) adjacent to the earth’s surface is
developed. This layer is known as the mixing layer since where u *0 is the surface friction velocity (Panofsky and
its turbulence of thermal origin is often sufficiently Dutton 1984), k is the von Karman constant, z is the
vigorous to mix pollutants. Movements inside this layer height, z 0 is the surface roughness length, and H is the
are dominated by updrafts, called thermals, that origi- depth of the mixing layer.
nate near the surface. The thermals penetrate the air For unstable atmospheric conditions:
layer over the atmospheric boundary layer, making
k(H ⫺ z ) 5
H ln 1 2 ⫺ (H ⫺ z )
u*0 H
possible a rapid growth of the mixing layer during the UT ⫽ 0
first morning hours. Once the maximum surface tem- 0 z 0
3
The thermals are surrounded by downdrafts of lower (3)
velocity, but covering a greater horizontal area. The ⫹ 2 ln (1 ⫹ µ0 ) ⫹ ln (1 ⫹ µ02 )
result is a mixing of the air that is so strong in this layer
that the vertical air temperature gradient is about
⫺0.01°C/m. To obtain the daily maximum mixing ⫺ 2 tan⫺1 0 ⫺
2 L 3
µ
33 H 0 46
height (H ), Holzworth (1967) developed a method
using the air temperature observed at different heights
at 12 UTC (Universal Time Coordinate) and the daily where
maximum temperature observed at surface. The maxi- A(µ) ⫽ [1⁄4 (1 ⫹ µ) 4 ⫺ (1 ⫹ µ) 3 ⫹ 3⁄2 (1 ⫹ µ) 2
mum mixing height is then estimated constructing a
curve with a slope of ⫺0.01°C/m starting at the maxi- ⫺ (1 ⫹ )] ln (1 ⫹ )
mum surface temperature up to the height at which the B(µ) ⫽ ⫺ 1⁄16 (1 ⫹ µ) 4 ⫹ 1⁄3 (1 ⫹ µ) 3 ⫺ 3⁄4 (1 ⫹ µ) 2
vertical temperature variation is intersected.
⫹ (1 ⫹ )
Transport Wind C(µ) ⫽ 1⁄4(µ4 ⫺ 1)[1⁄2 ln (1 ⫹ µ2 ) ⫺ tan⫺1 µ]
3 4
The transport wind (UT ) is defined as the average 1 µ4 µ3 µ2 L µ7
value of the windspeed through the mixing layer. The D(µ) ⫽ ⫺ ⫺ ⫺ ⫹µ ⫺
4 4 3 2 33H 7
available amount of windspeed data observed at differ-
3 1H2 1 L 24
z H 1/4
ent heights at each meteorological station was not
µ ⫽ 1 ⫺ 22
enough to evaluate the transport wind. For this reason
µ ⫽ 31 ⫺ 22 1 2 1 24
we estimated the transport wind using the following z H 1/4
0
expression: 0
H L
兰
1 H
UT ⫽ u(z) dz (1) and L is the Monin–Obukhov length (Monin and
H ⫺ z0 z0
Obukhov 1954).
where u(z) is the wind profile and z is the height. The atmospheric stability at the hour of maximum
The wind profile functions used in equation 1, surface temperature was determined using the classifica-
proposed by Ulke (1993), are based on considerations tion suggested by Turner (1964). We obtained the
developed by Yokohama and others (1977a,b, 1979). surface roughness length (z0 ) using the topographic
378 M. I. Gassmann and N. A. Mazzeo
Figure 6. Isopleths of the summer low ventilation conditions Figure 7. Isopleths of the autumn low ventilation conditions
(⌬ ⫽ 3%). (⌬ ⫽ 5%).
Summary
Acknowledgments
One of the aspects to take into account in air
pollution control is the self-cleansing capacity of the The University of Buenos Aires supported this re-
atmosphere. This capacity can be determined by evalu- search under subsidy TX-03/98. The National Weather
ating two atmospheric parameters: the mixing height Service of Argentina provided the data for this study.
(H ) and the transport wind (UT ). A criterion usually
applied to determine conditions of low ventilation or
high air pollution potential is given by H ⱕ 1500 m and Literature Cited
UT ⱕ 4.0 m/s. This paper presents a statistical analysis Crivelli, E., and M. Pedregal. 1972. Cartas de radiación solar
that includes temporal and spatial distributions of the global de la República Argentina. Meteorologica 3:80–97.
mean seasonal values of the mixing height and the Dobbins, R. A. 1979. Atmospheric Motion and Air Pollution.
transport wind in Argentina. The regions of the country John Wiley & Sons, New York, 323 pp.
with low or high air pollution potential are also deter- Golder, D. 1972. Relations among stability parameters in the
mined. surface layer. Boundary Layer Meteorology 3:45–58.
In general, in Argentina the mean seasonal maxi- Gross, E. M. 1970. The national air pollution potential forecast
mum mixing height shows a maximum in summer and a program. Technical memorandum WBTM NMC-47. United
minimum in winter, with the exception of Salta. The States Department of Commerce. Environmental Sciences
Service Administration. Washington, DC.
spatial distribution of this variable shows a relative
minimum in the region located between the northeast- Hoffmann, J. A., A. M. T. Gómez, and S. E. Nuñez. 1987. Los
campos medios anuales de algunos fenómenos meteorológi-
ern and the central–eastern region of the country. In cos. Pages 13.23.1–13.3.5 in Proceedings II Congreso Inter-
addition there is a relative maximum in Neuquén. Both americano y V Congreso Argentino de Meteorologı́a, 30
the minimum and the maximum values persist during November–4 December 1987, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
382 M. I. Gassmann and N. A. Mazzeo
Holzworth, G. C. 1967. Mixing depths, wind speeds and air Rutllant, J. 1981. Subsidencia forzada sobre la ladera andina
pollution potential for selected locations in the United occidental y su relación con un episodio de contaminación
States. Journal of Applied Meteorology 6:1039–1044. atmosférica en Santiago. Tralka 2:57–76.
Holzworth, G. C. 1972. Mixing heights, wind speeds and Smedman, A. S., and U. Högström. 1983. Turbulent character-
potential for urban air pollution throughout the contiguous istics of a shallow convective internal boundary layer. Bound-
United States. US Environmental Protection Agency, Office ary Layer Meteorology 25:271–287.
of Air Programs. Publication No. AP-101, Research Triangle Stackpole, J. D. 1967. The air pollution potential forecast
Park, North Carolina, 118 pp. program. Weather Bureau Technical Memorandum NMC-
Lyons, W. A. 1975. Turbulent diffusion and pollutant transport 43. National Meteorological Center, Suitland, Maryland.
in shoreline environments. Lectures on air pollution and Tuna, T. 1972. A synoptic-climatological study of air pollution
environmental impact analyses. American Meteorological potential for Ankara. Chapter XI in Proceedings of the third
Society. Boston, Massachusetts, pp. 136–208. meeting of the expert panel on air pollution modelling, No.
Minetti, J. L., and W. M. Vargas. 1983. Comportamiento del 14. NATO Committee on the Challenges of Modern Society,
borde anticiclónico subtropical en Sudamérica. Parte I. Brussels, Belgium.
Meteorológica 14:645–656. Turner, D. B. 1964. A diffusion model for an urban area.
Monin, A. S., and A. M. Obukhov. 1954. Basic laws of turbulent Journal of Applied Meteorology 2:83–91.
mixing in the atmosphere near the ground. Trudy Akademy Ulke, A. G. 1993. Difusión y depósito de contaminantes
Nank SSSR Geophysics. Institut 24:151. emitidos en la capa lı́mite atmosférica. Vol. 1. PhD Faculty of
Myrick, R. H., S. K. Sakiyama, R. P. Angle and H. S. Sandhu. Sciences. University of Buenos Aires, 213 pp.
1994. Seasonal mixing heights and inversions at Edmonton, Ulke, A. G., and N. A. Mazzeo. 1998. Climatological aspects of
Alberta. Atmospheric Environment 28:723–729. the daytime mixing height in Buenos Aires city, Argentina.
Panofsky, H. A., and J. A. Dutton. 1984. Atmospheric turbu- Atmospheric Environment 32:1615–1622.
lence. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 397 pp. van Loon, H. 1964. Mid-season average zonal winds at sea level
Popovics, M., and D. J. Szepesi. 1970. Diffusion climatological and at 500 mb south of 25 degrees south, and a brief
investigations in Hungary. Paper No. ME-20B in Proceed- comparison with the Northern Hemisphere. Journal of
ings of Second International Clean Air Congress. Washing- Applied Meteorology 3:554–563.
ton, DC, 24 pp. Venkatram, A. 1977. A model of internal boundary-layer
Portelli, R. 1977. Mixing heights, wind speeds and ventilation development. Boundary Layer Meteorology 11:419–437.
coefficients for Canada. Climatological studies 31. Atmo- Yokohama, O., M. Gamo, and S. Yamamoto. 1977a. On the
spheric Environment Service, 87 pp. turbulence quantities in the neutral atmospheric boundary
Prohaska, I. 1976. The Climate of Argentina, Paraguay and layer. Journal of the Meteorological Society of Japan 55:312–318.
Uruguay. Pages 13–72 in W. Schwerdtfeger (ed.), World Yokohama, O., M. Gamo, and S. Yamamoto. 1977b. On the
survey of climatology 12. Elsevier Scientific, Amsterdam. turbulence quantities in the atmospheric mixing layer.
Raman, C. R. V., and R. R. Kelkar. 1972. Urban air pollution Journal of the Meteorological Society of Japan 55:182–192.
potential over Bombay, India, derived from mixing depths Yokohama, O., M. Gamo, and S. Yamamoto. 1979. The vertical
and mean layer wind. Proceedings of conference on urban profiles of the turbulence quantities in the atmospheric
environment. American Meteorology Society, Boston. Massa- boundary layer. Journal of the Meteorological Society of Japan
chusetts, 317 pp. 57:264–272.