TODAY'S PAPER | NOVEMBER 29, 2020

Sacked workers
Editorial | Updated 29 Nov 2020    

THE move was not unexpected. The government had made clear its
intentions of sacking over 9,300 remaining employees of the Pakistan
Steel Mills in June — despite all the pre-election promises of the PTI to
revive the entity with the help of the existing workforce and through
improvements in the company’s management.

Friday’s service termination orders to 4,544 PSM workers indicates just the start of
the implementation of a new government plan to ‘reform and restructure’ SOEs in
order to cut financial losses. The remaining workers will be sent home in the next
few months if everything goes according to script. What will follow is the
‘downsizing’ or ‘rightsizing’ of staff in other public-sector businesses such as PIA. At
least half of the workers of the national flag carrier face the prospect of losing their
jobs in the near future.

All this is in line with the recommendations made by the reforms committee headed
by Adviser to the Prime Minister on Institutional Reforms and Austerity Ishrat
Husain to reorganise state-run businesses before they are sold to the private sector,
or revived under public-private partnership by hiring ‘competent’ overseas
Pakistanis in key managerial positions, or through infusing new capital in their
operations.

Most public-sector businesses have become a huge financial liability for the cash-
strapped government, which is forced to spend billions of rupees every year to keep
them operational as is the case with PIA and the railways and to pay workers’
salaries at PSM. The argument for the need to cut down on the number of excess
staff in SOEs, who are often recruited because of political and other reasons, may
have some merit, but the question remains: is it right to abolish jobs in the public
sector at a time when the government and the State Bank have doled out subsidised,
soft loans amounting to billions of rupees to help private businesses maintain their
payroll in view of the Covid-19 crisis? Even some of those inside the power circles
will disagree with such arbitrary removals when the working classes are struggling
to cope with the harsh economic situation caused by the pandemic.

ARTICLE CONTINUES AFTER AD

With Covid-19 infections resurging and the fragile economic recovery facing serious
risks, there could not have been a worse time to sack the PSM workers. Indeed, the
move is an admission of the government’s own failure; like its predecessors, it has
been unable to devise a viable programme to resurrect the country’s largest
industrial enterprise at a time when the private sector is investing in new steel
manufacturing capacities and technologies to take advantage of growing domestic
needs amid rising steel demand. Had it taken timely action to restart production at
the mill, perhaps through the infusion of capital, it could have saved a national asset
and spared thousands of PSM workers the agony of losing their jobs.

Published in Dawn, November 29th, 2020