Professional Documents
Culture Documents
30111-Article Text-56475-1-10-20200127
30111-Article Text-56475-1-10-20200127
Hepatology
Author’s contribution
The sole author designed, analysed, interpreted and prepared the manuscript.
Article Information
Editor(s):
(1) Dr. Syed Faisal Haider, Associate Professor, Department of Basic Medical Sciences, King Saud Bin Abdulaziz, University
for HealthKing Abdulaziz Medical City, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
Reviewers:
(1) Nain Taara, Agha Khan University, Pakistan.
(2) Manoharan K. Pillai, National University of Lesotho, Lesotho.
(3) M. E Makgatho, University of Limpopo, South Africa.
Complete Peer review History: http://www.sdiarticle4.com/review-history/52956
ABSTRACT
Invasive Salmonella infections are responsible for a significant burden of morbidity and mortality
worldwide. There has been increase in resistance to anti-typhoid prescription drugs medicinal
plants have gained popularity among both urban and rural dwellers in the treatment of not only
typhoid fevers but also to treat various ailments. The present study was undertaken to investigate
the anti-Salmonella activity of Gossypium hirsutum leaf extract on Salmonella typhi (clinical
isolates) using fresh lime juice as an extraction solvent. Extraction of lime juice, bioactive
components of the plant leaf and in vitro anti-Salmonella activity of extract were all carried out
using standard microbiological methods. Salmonella typhi ATCC 14028 (Type isolates) was used
as control. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectrophotometer (FTIR) was used to identify the functional
groups in the extract. The result revealed that clinical (mean diameter of inhibition zone 35.10±0.45
mm) and typed (mean diameter of inhibition zone 36.71±0.32 mm) isolates showed highest
susceptibility to ciprofloxacin. The crude extract showed an inhibition zone ranging from 24.63±0.11
to 1.43±0.04 mm for clinical and 25.11±0.62 to 1.18±0.31 mm for typed isolates at 600 and 200
mg/mL, respectively. Fourier Transform Infrared Spectrophotometer (FTIR) indicated the presence
of various functional groups in the extract such as 1,2,4-trisubstituted arenes, sulfoxide, vinyl ether,
phenol, carboxylic acid, conjugated alkene, α, β-unsaturated ester, allene, isothiocyanate and
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
alcohol. The overall results indicated that the extract obtained from G. hirsutum leaves using a lime
juice has the potential for an effective treatment of salmonellosis, including typhoid fevers.
However, it is necessary to ascertain the safety of this extract in vivo in further studies.
28
Omoya; IRJGH, 3(1): 27-36, 2020; Article no.IRJGH.52956
plant is “ewe owu” by Yoruba‘s’ in the South isolates were confirmed based on cultural,
western part of Nigeria. morphological and biochemical characteristics
following standard methods of identifying
2.2 Selection and Extraction of Lime Salmonella typhi [11]. The bacterial strain was
Juice grown in nutrient broth for 12-18 hours at 37ºC
on rotary shaker. Cells were grown at 37ºC for
Lime that was free of decay and mold was taken. 18 hours and the cultures were kept at 4ºC.
It was washed with distilled water several times
to remove soil and other extraneous matter and 2.5 In vitro Antimicrobial Susceptibility
then surfaced sterilized with 70% ethanol. The Tests
fruits were then halved (using a presterilized
knife) and the juice squeezed with presterilised Standardization of the inoculums: The
juice extractor aseptically (sterile gloves worn inoculum was prepared by inoculating colonies of
during operation) into sterile 100 mL conical fresh test cultures into sterile distilled water. The
flasks. In order to determine that the lime juice is turbidity was compared to 0.5McFarland
not contaminated with microorganism, the lime standard, which was prepared according to
juice was filtered with Millipore membrane filter method reported in literature Cheesbrough [11].
facilitated with vacuum pump after which a loop-
full of the lime juice was inoculated on nutrient Antibiotics susceptibility test using
agar and potato dextrose agar plates to confirm commercial antibiotics: Antibiotics sensitivity
the sterility. The presence of zero microbial loads test of the bacterial isolates were determined by
indicates that the lime is sterile. The fresh lime disc diffusion method as described by
juice was kept at -4ºC for further use. Cheesbrough [11]. Standard inoculum of 18
hours broth was spread on Muller Hinton agar
2.3 Preparation of Plant Extract using sterile swab in triplicate. The antibiotic
discs were placed on the plate at equidistance.
Plant extract was prepared as per the method The plates were then incubated for 18 hours at
reported in the literature (Tomassini et al. 2009). 37oC and diameter of zone of inhibition were
The fresh leaves were washed with sterile measured and recorded in millimeter (mm). The
distilled water and air dried until they turned following commercial antibiotics discs (Fondoz
brittle and fully crispy. The dry leaves were Laboratories Ltd, Nigeria) were used;
crushed manually using clean mortar and pestle, Chloramphenicol (CH) 30 μg, Zinacef (SP) 20
then pulverized into fine powder by a blending μg, Ciprofloxacin (CPX) 10μg, Amoxicillin (AM)
machine (Philips HR 2001). They were 25μg, Ampiclox (AMP) 30μg, Gentamycin (GEN)
separately kept in an airtight container to avoid 10μg, Pefloxacin (PEF) 5μg, Tetracycline (TET)
the absorption of moisture. The powdered 5μg, Streptomycin (S) 10 μg and Septrin (SXT)
samples were soaked for 72 hours in fresh lime 30μg.
juice in ratio of 1:10 each (i.e. 50 g of the
powdered sample in 500 mL of lime juice) as 2.6 Antibiotics Susceptibility Test of
solvents used for the extraction of the bioactive G. hirsutum Leaf Extract
compounds from the plants. After 72 hours, it
was sieved using muslin cloth and then filtered Agar well diffusion test: The extracts were
using Millipore filter paper. The filtrates were dissolved and diluted using 30% volume/volume
vaporized to dryness using rotary evaporator (v/v) dimethylsulphoxide (DMSO) to obtain
(Union Laboratories England). The extracts were different concentrations 200, 300, 400 and 600
preserved in a sterile bottle at -4ºC ready for use mg/mL. Surface of solidify Muller Hinton agar
[10]. was aseptically streaked with the standerdised
(0.5McFarland turbidity standard) inoculum of
2.4 Test Organism test organism. The 200 mg/mL, 300 mg/mL, 400
mg/mL and 600 mg/mL of the extracts of G.
The clinical bacterial strains (Salmonella typhi) hirsutum (100 µL) leaves were introduced into
were obtained from the culture collection bank, the wells earlier bored with sterile cork borer on
Department of Microbiology, Federal University Muller Hinton agar plate. The plates were
of Technology Akure and the source of the incubated aerobically at 37ºC and examined after
clinical isolate was human stool. Clinical isolate 24 hours. The plates were examined for
of Salmonella typhi and typed (ATCC 14028) microbial growth inhibition and the Inhibition
Salmonella typhi was used as control. The Zone Diameter (IZD) was measured to the
29
Omoya; IRJGH, 3(1): 27-36, 2020; Article no.IRJGH.52956
nearest millimeter and compared with those analysed using One-way ANOVA. The new
produced by the commercial antibiotic Duncan Multiple Range test was used to
ciprofloxacin which was used as control. All compare means of different groups. A P-value
experimental procedures were performed in of < 0.05 was considered statistically
triplicates. significant.
30
Omoya; IRJGH, 3(1): 27-36, 2020; Article no.IRJGH.52956
45
Fig. 1. Comparative antibiotic susceptibility patterns of clinical and typed (ATCC 14028)
isolates of Salmonella Typhi (disc diffusion assay)
CHL= Chloramphenicol, ZIN= Zinacef, CPX= Ciprofloxacin, AMX=Amoxicillin, AMP= Ampiclox, GEN=
Gentamycin, PFX=Pefloxacin, TET= Tetracycline, STR= Streptomycin, SP= Septrin
35
30
Mean zones of inhibition (mm)
25
20
15 Clinical
10 Typed
0
CPX (5
200 mg/ml 300 mg/ml 400 mg/ml 600 mg/ml DMSO
mg/ml)
Clinical 1.43 6.72 19.14 24.63 0 21.07
Typed 1.18 6.6 20.02 25.11 0 27.86
Fig. 2. Comparative susceptibility patterns of clinical and typed (ATCC 14028) isolates of
Salmonella Typhi to G. hirsutum extract using agar well diffusion
CPX= Ciprofloxacin, DMSO= dimethylsulphoxide
31
Omoya; IRJGH, 3(1): 27-36, 2020; Article no.IRJGH.52956
500
Mean Bacterial Cell Counts (cfu/ml)
450
400
350
300
250 Clinica
l
200 Typed
150
100
50
0
200 300 400 600 CPX (5
DMSO
mg/ml mg/ml mg/ml mg/ml mg/ml)
Clinical 283.11 84.05 0 0 439.91 19.62
Typed 234.66 71.31 0 0 449.11 18.31
Fig. 3. Comparative bactericidal effects of clinical and typed (ATCC 14028) isolates of
Salmonella Typhi to G. hirsutum extract using broth dilution assay
CPX= Ciprofloxacin, DMSO= dimethylsulphoxide
32
Omoya; IRJGH, 3(1): 27-36, 2020; Article no.IRJGH.52956
Table 2. FTIR spectral peak values and functional groups obtained for leaf extract of G.
hirsutum
-1
S.no Peak values (cm ) Functional group Interpretation
1 879.7 C-H bending 1,2,4-trisubstituted arenes
2 1043.7 S=O stretching Sulfoxide
3 1200.2 C-O stretching Vinyl ether
4 1326.9 O-H bending Phenol
5 1394.0 O-H bending Carboxylic acid
6 1617.7 C=C stretching Conjugated alkene
7 1714.6 C=O stretching α, β-unsaturated ester
8 1912.1 C=C=C stretching Allene
9 1986.7 C=C=C stretching Allene
10 2087.3 N=C=S stretching Isothiocyanate
11 3339.7 O-H stretching Alcohol
C= Carbon, O= Oxygen, S= Sulphur, N= Nitrogen, H= Hydrogen
3.5 FTIR Spectra of G. hirsutum Extract 1200.2, 1326.9, 1394.0, 1617.7, 1714.6, 1912.1,
1986.7, 2087.3 and 3339.7 cm-1 respectively.
The results presented in Fig. 4 and Table 2
showed the FTIR spectra and spectral peak 4. DISCUSSION
values and functional groups obtained for leaf
extract of G. hirsutum respectively. Fig. 4 Typhoid fever could cause serious health
revealed the peaks generated at different problems although it is treated with antibiotics,
wavelengths (cm-1) and Table 2 showed that however the increase in resistance of S. typhi to
there were eleven (11) different peaks generated conventional antibiotic therapy, has raised the
which represents the following functional groups; need to search for alternative therapeutic
1,2,4-trisubstituted arenes, sulfoxide, vinyl ether, methods of treatment [2].
phenol, carboxylic acid, conjugated alkene, α, β-
unsaturated ester, allene, allene, isothiocyanate Many organic solvents have been used as
and alcohol at wavenumber vmax 879.7, 1043.7, extraction solvent to assay antibacterial efficacy
33
Omoya; IRJGH, 3(1): 27-36, 2020; Article no.IRJGH.52956
of different medicinal plants, however, it is a Salmonella typhi. The result of the antibacterial
common practice among the ‘Yoruba’ tribe to screening in vitro of G. hirsutum extracted with
extract bioactive components from leaf, root and lime juice in this study justified the traditional use
stem of ethno-medicinal plants with lime juice. of this plant for the treatment of gastroenteritis
Based on information provided by both the and other bacterial infections [20,21].
traditional healer and the in vitro antibacterial test
results, in vivo study shall be undertaken in a FTIR spectra showed that there were eleven (11)
view to verifying the therapeutic efficacy of the different peaks generated which represents the
extract. In vivo model could be employed for this following functional groups; 1,2,4-trisubstituted
study because it takes into account a possible arenes, sulfoxide vinyl ether, phenol, carboxylic
prodrug effect and possible involvement of the acid, conjugated alkene, α, β-unsaturated ester,
immune system in the eradication of infections allene, allene, isothiocyanate and alcohol at
-1
[15]. different wavelength (cm ). The presence of
sulfoxide, phenol, carboxylic acid and alcohol
Salmonella typhi, clinical and typed isolates had could be responsible for the high anti-Salmonella
varying susceptibility to antibiotics used, efficacy of the plant extract in vitro. The
ciprofloxacin inhibited clinical the isolates more presences of sulfoxide group is unexpected in
than other antibiotics while chloramphenicol had natural extracts, however, it may have originated
least inhibition against clinical isolate. from the lime juice used for the extraction. Sulfur
Comparative susceptibility patterns of clinical and compound has previously been reported in citrus
typed (ATCC 14028) isolates of Salmonella typhi [22,23].
to G. hirsutum extract using agar well diffusion
showed that the anti- Salmonella activity of the 5. CONCLUSION
crude extract is concentration dependent and
This study revealed that the extract of G.
compare favourably with antibiotic (ciprofloxacin)
hirsutum proved more effective than ciprofloxacin
using agar well diffusion and broth dilution
when used in vitro and the efficacy is
method. This antimicrobial action may be due to
concentration dependent using agar well and
the synergistic action of different chemical
broth dilution method. This justifies the acclaimed
constituents, [16,10,12]. The higher activity by
method of using lime juice for the extraction of
the extract may be an indication that the
bioactive components in medicinal plants
phytoconstituents in the plant leaves are more in
traditionally. The study provides the basis for use
lime juice solvent than the organic solvent
of lime juice as solvent to extract the leaf of this
extracts [17,18]. Presence of little traces of lime
plant in the development of drugs for
juice used for extraction could also be
management of typhoid fever.
responsible for high antimicrobial efficacy. It has
been reported that different phyto-constituents
have different degrees of solubility in different CONSENT
types of solvents depending on their polarity. In a
traditional setting, water is the solvent largely It is not applicable.
used to prepare these concoctions [19] but lime
is being used occasionally. ETHICAL APPROVAL
The MIC of extract against both isolates is 100 Animal ethic Committee approval has been
mg/ml while the MBC is 150 mg/ml, the higher collected and preserved by the author.
value of MBC than MIC indicates that the extract
could have bacteriostatic effect at lower COMPETING INTERESTS
concentration and bactericidal at higher
concentration. The finding of Cheesbrough [11], Author has declared that no competing interests
stated that the level at which crude extracts exist.
inhibit test organisms is used to investigate the
efficacy of chemotherapeutic agents under
REFERENCES
standard conditions.
This corroborates the finding of Omojasola and 1. Zhang X, Jeza VT, Pan Q. Salmonella
Awe [18], which stated that the leaves extract of Typhi: from a Human Pathogen to a
Anacardium occidentale and Gossypium Vaccine Vector. Cellular and Molecular
hirsutum show antimicrobial activity against Immunology. 2008;5(2):91-99.
34
Omoya; IRJGH, 3(1): 27-36, 2020; Article no.IRJGH.52956
2. Kirk MD, Pires SM, Black RE, Caipo M, 13. Anibijuwon II, Udeze OA. Antimicrobial
Crump JA, Devleesschauwer B. World activity of Carica papaya (Pawpaw Leaf)
Health Organization estimates of the on some pathogenic organisms of clinical
global and regional disease burden of 22 origin from South-Western Nigeria.
foodborne bacterial, protozoal and viral Ethnobotanical Leaflets. 2009;13(7):850-
diseases, 2010: A data synthesis. PLoS 864.
Med. 2015;12(100):19-21. 14. Ashokkumar R, Ramaswamy M.
3. Ao TT, Feasey NA, Gordon MA, Keddy Phytochemical screening by FTIR
KH, Angulo FJ, Crump JA. Global burden spectroscopic analysis of leaf extracts of
of invasive nontyphoidal Salmonella selected Indian Medicinal plants.
disease, 2010. Emerg Infect Dis. 2015; International Journal of Current
21(6):941–9. Microbiology and Applied Sciences. 2014;
4. Kraft K. Complementary/Alternative 3(1):395-406.
Medicine in the context of prevention of 15. Hilou A, Nacoulma G, Guiguemde TR.
disease and maintenance of health. Prev In vivo antimalarial activities of extracts
Med. 2009;2. from Amaranthusspinosus and
5. Modi AA, Wright EC, Seeff LB. Boerhaaviaerecta in mice. Journal
Complementary and Alternative Medicine Ethnopharmacol. 2006;103:236–240.
(CAM) for the treatment of chronic 16. Shahina N, Samia A, Sheikh AR. In-vitro
Hepatitis B and C: A review. Antiviral antimicrobial activity of the extracts derived
Therapy. 2007;12(3):285-95. from Terminaliacatappa. Res. Journal
6. Moquin B, Blackman MR, Mitty E, Flores Microbiology. 2007;2(2):180-184.
S. Complementary and Alternative 17. Marjorie MC. Plant products as
Medicine (CAM). Geriatr Nursery. 2009;3: antimicrobial agents. Clinical Microbiology
196-203. and Review. 1999;12(4):564-582.
7. Omoya FO, Momoh AO, Olaifa AO. (In 18. Omojasola PF, Awe S. The antibacterial
vivo Effect of Cassava Flakes Mixed with activity of the leaf extracts of the leaf
Euphorbia heterophylla against Salmonella extracts of Anacardium occidentale and
typhi. European Journal of Medicinal Gossypium hirsutum against some
Plants. 2015;7(1):38-45. selected microorganisms. Bioscience
8. Egharevba RKA, Ikhatua MI. Research Communications. 2004;60(1):
Ethnomedicinal uses of plants in the 25-58.
treatment of various skin diseases in Ovia 19. Ologun O, Dada EO, Ajayi KO. In vitro
North East, Edo State, Nigeria. Nigerian Study on Anti-salmonella Activities of
Tribune. 2008;1-4. Boerhaavia diffusa (L. syn) Leaf Extract.
9. Ene AC, Atawodi SE, Ameh DA, International Journal of Pathogen
Kwanashie HO, Agomo PU. Locally used Research. 2019;3(1):1-10.
plants for malaria therapy amongst the 20. Njau EA, Alcron J, Ndakidemi P, Chirino-
Hausa, Yoruba and Ibo communities in Trejo M, Buza J. Antimicrobial and
Maduguri, Northern Nigeria. Indian Journal antioxidant activity of crude extracts of
of traditional Knowledge. 2010;9(3):486- Rauwolfia caffra var. caffra (Apocynaceae)
490. from Tanzania. International Journal of
10. Ogoti P, Magiri E, Magoma G, Kariuki D, Biology. 2014;6(4):156.
Bii C. In vitro anti-Salmonella activity of 21. Srinivasa MKM, Narayanappa M. In-vitro
extracts from selected Kenyan medicinal study of antibacterial activity of leaf and
plants. Journal of Medicinal Plants root Extract of Rauwolfia serpentina
Research. 2015;9(8):254-261. against Gram positive and Negative
11. Cheesbrough M. District Laboratory bacterial strains. International Journal of
Practice in Tropical Countries. 2nd Ed. Recent Research in Interdisciplinary
Cambridge University Press, United Sciences. 2015;2(3):33-37.
Kingdom. 2014;480. 22. Shaw PE, Ammons JM, Braman RS..
12. Marcelin U, Bharathidasan R, Prince L. Volatile sulfur compounds in fresh orange
Antisalmonella Activity of Selected and grape fruit juice: identification,
Medicinal Plants. World Journal of quantification and possible importance to
Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Sciences. juice flavor. Journal of Agriculture and
2016;5(4):2512-2519. Food Chemistry. 1980;28(4):778-781.
35
Omoya; IRJGH, 3(1): 27-36, 2020; Article no.IRJGH.52956
23. Cannon RJ, Kazimierski A, Curto NL, Li J, Sulfur-containing volatile compounds from
Trinnaman L, Janczuk AJ, Agyemang D, the in-depth analysis of Lisbon lemon
Da Costa NC, Chen MZ. Identification, peels. Journal of Agriculture and Food
synthesis and characterization of Novel Chemistry. 2015;63(7):1915-1931.
_________________________________________________________________________________
© 2020 Omoya; This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,
provided the original work is properly cited.
Peer-review history:
The peer review history for this paper can be accessed here:
http://www.sdiarticle4.com/review-history/52956
36