Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Closure of Oroantral Fistula With Buccal R Vs M
Closure of Oroantral Fistula With Buccal R Vs M
Department of Oral Surgery, Royal Dental College and Department of Oral Surgery and Oral Medicine.
University Hospital (Rigshospiwlet). Copenhagell, Denmark
Several recent studies have dealt with the fistula 204 •9.23 . This condition has to be treated
clinical and the radiographical aspects of before closure of the oroantral fistula. The
oroantral communications\-~9. Experimental treatment of choice for closure of oroantral
studies lO •22 have confirmed the clinical finding fistulae appears to be a buccal flapI-3,5,6,9-'9.~3'2'.
that a maxillary sinusitis is present when an However, there are still some controversies
untreated oroantral communication has per- concerning the preoperative management.
sisted for more than 48 h (i.e. an oroantral The purpose of the present follow-up study
fistula). The inflammation in the antral mucosa is: (I) to compare the results after clos1.lre with a
in most cases is localized to the floor of the buccal flap according to the techniques sug-
maxillary sinus and in relation to the gested by RehrmclI1ll and by MVezar ; (2) to
Group Variable n P
No-PP 7 31 38
pp 19 33 52 >0.05
Total 26 64 90
Total 39 51 90
Location of molar
oro-antral P,-region region total
fistula
No-PP 2 36 38
>0.05
PP 3 49 52
Total 5 85 90
No-PP 14 24 38
>0.05
PP 30 22 52
Total 44 46 90
Total 40 50 90
Changes in the vestibular height both comparisons. The findings regarding the
The comparative statistical analysis (Table 4) occurrence of a permanent reduction of the
showed that there were no significant dif- vestibular height after the two types of flap
ferences in the distribution of dentate- could therefore be compared.
/edentulous cases and cases with and without Table 5 shows the findings at the t-l year
buccal bone loss between the Rehrmann and the follow-up of the 52 cases in the PP group. These
M6czar flap cases in the PP group, as P>O.05 in findings were identical with the findings at the 2
160 VON WOWERN
Table 2. Results after surgical closure of 52 oro-antral fistulae by the Rehnnann and M6czar techniques in the
group with preoperative procedure; numher of patients (n), level of significance (P)
Uneventful
primary
Surgical repair 95% confidence Breakdown
technique n (~~) limits n (~~) Total P
Rehrmann 31 97 84-100 I 3 32
>0.05
M6czar 20 100 83-100 0 0 20
Total 51 52
Table 3. Results after surgical closure of 90 oro-antral fistulae in the group without preoperative procedure
(no-PP) and the group with preoperative procedure (PP); number of patients (n), level of significance (P)
Uneventful
primary
repair 95~~ confidence Breakdown
Group n (%) limits n (%) Total P
No-PP 30 79 63-90 8* 21 38
1** <0.001
PP 51 98 90-100 2 52
Total 81 9 90
* No primary repair
** Primary repair, but breakdown after powerful sneezing after a fortnight
Table 4. Comparison of the distribution for the state of dentition and the position of the vestibular bone crest in
relation to the muco-gingivaljunction at the operative site, between the Rehl'llwl1Il and the Moczar flap cases in
the PP group; number of patients (n), level of significance (P)
Dentition
Surgical Dentate Edentulous Total
technique II 11 II P
Rehrmann 21 II 32
Moczar 9 20 >0.05
II
Total 32 20 52
Rehrmann 7 25 32
>0.05
M6czar 5 15 20
Total 12 40 52
OROANTRAL FISTULA 161
Table 5. Reduction of the vestibular heigh t after surgical closure of 52 oro-antral fistulae by the Rehrmann and
M6czilr techniques at the !-I year follow-up; these results were identical with the findings at the 2 months
follow-up; number of patients (II), level of significance (P)
Rehmlann 15 47 17 53 35-7\ 32
<0.00\
M6czilr 20 100 0 a 0-17 20
Total 35 17 52
months follow-up. All the cases showed a M6czltr flap. At the 2 months follow-up, 15 of
reduction of the vestibular height immediately the Rehrll1C1flfl flap cases (47~-;;) showed a
after the surgical closure, which was more normalized vestibular height, while 17 cases
pronounced after the RehrlllClfltl than the (53~~) showed a permanent reduction of the
vestibular height, corresponding to the exten-
sion of the flap (Fig 3). After the Mocza!" flap,
the vestibular height was already normalized at
the 4-week follow-up in all the 20 cases (100%).
The statistical analysis showed that the
number of cases with a permanent reduction of
the vestibular height was significantly higher
after the Relll'lnatln flap than after the MtJc::cir
flap (P<O.OOI).
In the Rehrll1{l11/l flap cases (PP group) the
position of the vestibular bone crest in relation
to the mucogingival junction was found to be
independent of the state of dentition (Table 6, P
> 0.05). Therefore. the comparative analysis of
the relation between the occurrence of vesti-
bular height reduction and (1) the state of
dentition and (2) the extension of the loss of the
buccal crest could be performed. This analysis
(Table 7) showed that the occurrence of
vestibular height reduction after use of the
Rell/"ll1ol1n flap was independent of the state of
dentition and the position of the vestibular bone
crest in relation to the mucogingival junction
(P> 0.05).
Fig. 3. Reduction of the vestibulur height after closure Marginal g;llgh'(f {(iter Moc::;(rr flClp
of an oroantral fistula with a Rehrlll(/Illl flap, even
though a careful excision of the attaching muscles at In all the 11 dentate cases of the lv!oc:::lt,. flap
the inner side of the flap W~\s performed before (l OO~/:') a permanent occurrence of scar tissue
closure. was observed in the marginal gingiva cor-
162 VON WOWERN
Table 6. Comparison of the position of the vestibular bone crest in relation to the muco-gingivaljunction and the
state of dentition in the Relzmumn flap cases of the PP group; number of patients (n), level of significance (P)
Dentate 4 17 21
:> 0.05
Edentulous 3 8 II
Total 7 25 32
Table 7. Analysis of the 32 Rehrmann flap cases of.the PP group: comparison of the occurrence of permanent
reduction of the vestibular height with (I) the state .of dentition, and (2) the position or the vestibular bone ridge
in relation to the muco-gingivaljunction at the site of the flap; number of patients (n), level of significance (P)
Dentition
Vestibular dentate edentulous
height n n Total P
Reduced 9 8 17
:> 0.05
Normalized 12 3 15
Total 21 II 32
above below
/l n Total P
Reduced 4 13 17
:>0.05
Normalized 3 12 15
Total 7 25 32
Discussion
In the present study the sex and age distri-
butions of the patients and the location of the
oroantral fistulae corresponded to those found
in previous studies 2 ,J,.,I,.12.27. The present ma-
terial did not include acute or severe cases of
Fig. 4. Scar tissue in the anterior part or the marginal
maxillary sinusitis as these cases (most likely
gingiva after closure of an oroantral fistula with a primary) are sent to the ear, nose and throat
M6czar flap. specialist instead.
OROANTRAL FISTULA 163
A previous study has shown that the occur- sinusitis before or after the occurrence of the
rence of failure after closure of oroantral oroantral fistula, to secure that the maxillary
listulae with a buccal flap is independent of the ostium is in function and to eliminate an active
presence of neighbouring teeth or the size of the maxillary sinusitis.
osseous defect". In conclusion, the present analysis, cor-
The present analysis shows that the failures roborated by previous studiesll-14.2J, underlines
may occur independently of the surgical tech- that the risk of failure after closure of oroantral
niques, Rehrmal1ll versus M6c:ar, applied in the fistulae with a buccal flap is very small, if a
PP group (Table 2, P>O.05). In order to avoid careful pre-, per- and postoperative regimen is
failures, it is essential that the patients observe observed. The present 1-1 year follow-up study
the rules of careful postoperative regimen. This indicates that an uneventful, primary repair for
is illustrated by the results in the PP group 2 months can be interpreted as a permanen t
(Table 2), where the only case of failure was repair, and that a flattening of the vestibulum at
caused by tremendous sneezing after primary the operated site at the 2-month follow-up is a
uneventful repair had been observed. persistent condition.
Further, the present analysis shows that the Further, this analysis (Table 5) shows that a
frequency of failure was significantly higher in permanent reduction of the vestibular height
the no-PP group than in the PP group (Table 3). may occur in abollt half ohhe cases after thc use
This finding indicates that a preoperative of the Rehl'man/l flap, while the risk of this
elimination of an active maxillary sinusitis is complication after the use of the Mlie.ar flap is
essential for the prognosis of the surgical negligible. These findings are corroborated by
closure. the findings ill previous studies of the
The follow-up study of the 9 cases of failure RehrnWI1I1 27 and the Moc::.al'28 flaps.
(Table 3) which underwent the described Subsequently, the 32 Rehrmmm flap cases in
preoperative preparation before rec!osure with the PP group were analysed in order to clarify
a Relzrmann flap, revealed primary uneventful whether there was a correlation between the
repair in all cases. This finding also underlines occurrence of a vestibular height reduction ancl
the importance of a careful preoperative the presence of neighbouring teeth or a large
preparation. bone loss of the vestibular crest. These analyses
A previous radiological study29 (comprising showed that a pronounced vestibular bone loss
the PP group) showed that clinical examination, may occur in relation to an oro antral fistula,
including antral irrigation, gives very reliable independent of the state of dentition (Table 6);
information concerning the presence or absence the occurrence of a vestibular height reduction
of maxillary sinusitis and is superior to is independent of the state of dentition and the
radiographical examination. The present study position of the mucogingival junction in re-
shows that cases of oroantral fistulae without lation to the vestibular bone crest (Table 7), i.e.
signs or symptoms of maxillary sinusitis on the it is not possible to anticipate when a RehrmclIln
day of admission also show normal conditions flap may cause a permanent reduction of the
at the oto-rhino-Iaryngological examination vestibular height.
and at the antral irrigation, as the 24 cases from Finally, the follow-up analysis of the PP
the PP group without previous signs and group revealed that all the present 11 dentate
symptoms of maxillary sinusitis showed nOlmal cases of the M Oczar flap showed a permanent
conditions at the preoperative preparation in all scar corresponding to the marginal part of the
cases. This indicates that the preoperative anterior incision of the flap. This finding
preparation described is only required in cases indicates that the risk of scar tissue in the
with clinical signs and symptoms of maxillary marginal periodontium is high after the use of a
164 VON WOWERN
M6czar flap. From this point of view, the II. HAANAES, H. R. & GILHuus-MoE, 0.: A
Mik=ar flap does not seem to be well-suited for histologic study of experimental oro-paranasal
communications in monkeys. Int. J. Oral SlIrg.
dentate cases.
1972: I: 250-257.
In conclusion, the ReJll'lnal1ll flap seems to be 12. HAANAES, H. R. & PETERSEN, K. N.: Treatment
best suited for dentate cases, as it is essential to of oroantra! communications. Int. J. Oral Surg.
reduce marginal gingiva damage to a minimum. 1974: 3: 124-132.
13. HAANAES, H. R., PETERSEN, K. N. & AAS. E.:
However, the Moear flap may be used in
Oral antrostomi. Inl. J. 01'01 Surg. [975: 4: 55-60.
edentulous cases, as it is essential to avoid a 14. KILLEY, H. C. & KAY, L. W.: The maxillary sinus
reduction of the vestibular height in denture- alld its demalimplicalions.Wright&Sons.Bristol
wearing individuals. 1975, pp. I-53.
15. JUSELlUS, H. & KALTIOKALLlO, K.: Closure of
antroalveolul' fistulae. J. Laryngol. 1971: 85:
387-393.
16. LEE, F. M. S.: Management of the displaced root
in the maxillary sinus. Int. J. Oral Surg. 1978: 7:
References 374-379.
1. CHRISTENSEN, O. & GILHuus-MoE, O. : Surgical 17. NEUMAN, K. &PAESSLER, L.: Das Vestibulum oris
treatment of chronic hyperplastic sinusitis and nach Verscgluss oroantraler Kommunikationen
maxillary sinus empyema of oral/dental origin. durch die Rehmannsche Plastik. Zallll-. MUlld-
lilt. J. Oral Surg. 1979: 8: 276-283. Kieferlleilk. 1974: 62: 674-677.
2. EHRL, P. A.: Oroantral communication. Int. J. 18. NORMAN, J. E. DE B. & CRAIG, G.: Oro-antral
Oral Surg. 1980: 9: 351-358. fistula. Oral Surg. 1971: 31: 734-744.
3. ERICSON, S., FINNE, K. & PERSSON, G.: A clinical- 19. PLATZ, H.: Uber eine neue Methode des primiiren
radiographic review of treated oro-antral com- Verschlusses von Mund-Antrum-Verbindungen.
munications.ln/. J. Oral Surg. 1973: 2: 185-195. Oesterr. Z. Sio/lla/ol. 1974: 71: 20-29.
4. ERICSON, S., FINNE, K. & PERSSON, G.: Results of 20. ROLFFS, J., SCHMELZLE, R .. SCHWENZER, N. &
apicoectomy of maxillary canines, premolars and NEUMANN, V.: Zur chirurgischen Therapie der
molars with special reference to oroantral com- odontogenen Sinuitis maxillaris -Ein Bericht
munication as a prognostic factor. Int. J. Oral iiber 397 Fiille. Disch. zulll/aerlzl. Z. 1979: 34: 3D-
Surg. 1974: 3: 386-393. 34.
5. GROSSENHELLEFORTH, A. & DOKER, J.: Paro- 21. SACHS, S. A., KAY, S. A., SPECTER, 1. & STERN,
dontalverhiiltnisse nach Kieferhohlenoperalion M.: Treatment of a persistent oro-antral fistula
im Fistelbereich. Dtsch. Zalmaer/z/I. Z. 1976: 31: with a posteriorly based lateral tongue flap. Inl. J.
244-245. Oral Surg. 1979:8: 225-228.
6. HACKMANN, G., MACHTENS, E. & BONING, K.: 22. VALDERHAUG, J.: Reaction of mucous mem-
Die Deckung des facialen Kieferhohlenfensters branes of the maxillary sinus and the nasal cavity
mit Iyophilisierter Dura. Dtsch, Zahnaerzll. Z. to experimental periapical inflammation in mon-
1976: 31: 265-267. keys. fill. J. Oral Surg. 1973: 2: 107-114.
7. HARRISON, D. F. N.: Diseases of the maxillary 23. WEIJERMAN, 1. E.: Odontogene sinusitis maxil-
sinus. In KAY, 1. W. (ed.): Oral Surgery, laris. N. V. Boekdrukkerij Dijkstra Niemeyer,
Transactions of the IVth International Groningen 1972, pp. 1-97.
Conference on Oral Surgery 1971. Munksgaard, 24. WINKLER, T., WOWERN, N. v. & BITTMANN, S.:
Copenhagen 1973, pp. 13-18. Retrieval of an upper third molar from the
8. HJORTlNG-HANSEN, E. & WOWERN, N. v.: infratemporal space. J. Oral Surg. 1977: 35: 130-
Acquired defects of the antrum. In KAY, L. W. 132.
(ed.): Oral Surgery, Transactions of the rVth 25. WOWERN, N. v. : Frequency of oro-antral fistulae
International Conference on Oral Surgery 1971. after perforation to the max.illary sinus. Scand. J.
Munksgaard, Copenhagen 1973, pp. 19-24. Dell/. Res. 1970: 78: 394-396.
9. HAANAES, H. R.: A radiographic and clinical 26. WOWERN, N. v.: Oroantral communications and
follow-up study of 150 oro-antral communi- displacements of roots into the maxillary sinus. J.
cations. Inl. J. Oral Surg. 1974: 3: 412-421. 01'01 Surg. 1971: 29: 622-627.
10. HAANAES. H. R. & GIUlUUS-MoE, 0.: 27. WOWERN. N. v.: Treatment arora-antral listulae.
Experimental oro-paranasal communications. Arch.OlolarY/lgol. 1972: 96: 99-104.
Ac/a Odontol. Scand. 1972: 30: 151-165. 28. WOWERN, N. v.: Correlation between the de-
OROANTRAL FISTULA 165