Philosophy and Ethics Moral Dilemmas

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3

PHILOSOPHY AND ETHICS Ethics

Philosophy • derived from the Greek word ethos –which


means “characteristic way of acting”
• Greek term: Philo (friend or love) and Sophia
(wisdom) = “love for wisdom” • “The most important human endeavor is the
striving for morality in our actions. Our inner
• The Big Questions
balance and even our very existence depend on
Pythagoras (c. 580-497 B.C.) - Greek thinker. He has it. Only morality in our actions can give beauty
coined the term Philosophia and dignity to life.” – Albert Einstein.
• “Ethics is a normative philosophical science that
• is a human search for meaning
deals with the goodness or badness, the
• it is man’s act of intellectual quest that
rightness or the wrongness of human acts”
transcends the limits of the positive sciences
• it goes beyond the boundaries of concrete The Scope of Ethics
knowledge
1. Man and fellow man.
• it is searching the truth
• It deals with the “oughts” or “shoulds” of human
Metaphysics – The branch of philosophy that studies the
existence in relation to others.
nature of reality.
• “How should I treat other people?"
Epistemology – The branch of philosophy that studies
2. Man and his society.
the nature and scope of knowledge.
• It investigates how a man should relate to his
Value Theory
community and vice versa.
• ETHICS: the branch of philosophy that studies • "Does my action benefit society in general?"
and evaluates human conduct.
3. Man and other Sentient Being.
• AESTHETICS: the branch of philosophy that
studies the nature of beauty. • The proper attitude toward the sentient being
that are capable of feeling the pain.
Logic
• "Do we see them in their instrumental value or
• An eye opener for the knowledge necessary in intrinsic value?"
the study and understanding of higher
4. Man and his natural environment.
philosophical filed.
• Helps to develop and sharpen our natural gift of • It deals with how man treats his natural
human reasoning. environment.
Natural Logic in Man • "Is it ethical to sacrifice the environment for the
sake of progress and development?"
• Man is rational, and the fact that he thinks and
Importance of Ethics
reasons out does not guarantee that he is
already an accomplished logician. 1. Satisfying Basic Human Needs – Being fair,
• What is rational? – Rational- having the ability to honest, and ethical is one of the basic human
reason out or understand. needs.
• Mind is mature enough to make rational 2. Creating Credibility – An organization that is
decisions, people act with logical thinking believed to be driven by moral values is
remains subject to error. respected in society even by those who may
have no information about the working and the
businesses or an organization.
3. Uniting People and Leadership – The common
thread that brings the employees and the
decision makers on a common platform.
4. Improving Decision Making - A man’s destiny is A situation in which, whatever choice is made, the agent
the sum total of all the decisions that he/she commits a moral wrong
takes in course of his life.
• Something Morally Right -> Bad Outcome
5. Long-term Gains – Organizations guided by
ethics and values are profitable in the long run. • Something Morally Wrong -> Good Outcome
6. Securing the Society – Often ethics succeeds law Key Features of Moral Dilemma
in safeguarding the society.
• the agent is required to do each of two (or more)
"Ethics is important not so that “we can understand” actions;
philosophically, but rather so we can “improve how we • the agent can do each of the actions, but the
live” (Lafollette, 2007). agent cannot do both (or all) of the actions

MORAL DILEMMAS 3 Levels of Moral Dilemma


Non-Moral Standards
1. Personal Dilemmas
Rules that affect the choice of a person but are not • Judgment is based on self-chosen principles,
linked to moral or ethical considerations, similar to and moral reasoning is based on individual
ethics people use in value judgment in dealing with rights and justice.
these aspects.
Example: The most common ethical dilemmas
Examples: involved when you are taking someone to the
hospital for an emergency treatment by car. The
• Aesthetics law states that speeding and running red lights
• Rules in games are illegal. However, this person might die if not
• Laws treated quickly and they are in your vehicle.
• Personal experiences and principles
• Etiquette
• Recipe or formula 2. Organizational Dilemma
• Religion • A puzzle posed by the dual necessities of
social organization and member self-
• Traditions and norms
interest.
Moral Standards • Depending on members' definitions of
self, the organizing dilemma may exist
Rules or sets of guidelines that affect the choices of a
between personal interests and
person and his or her belief system and decision-making
organizational welfare, or between
process in problems and situations beg the question of
group interests and organizational well-
what is morally right and wrong.
being.
Characteristics of Moral Standards Example: The mission of Catholic Schools is to
serve the poor by giving quality education. It is
• Welfare of being
torn between the obligation to charge low
• Reliance on reasoning and not on authority tuition to help the poor and to pay better salaries
• Overriding or hegemonic to keep quality teachers. The example of the
• Impartial, fair, and just Catholic School shows the dilemma between
• Emotions and vocabulary the goal of the school to give quality education
Moral Dilemma to the poor and so must charge the lowest
tuition fee possible and yet to keep the quality
A moral (ethical) dilemma is a situation that involves a the school must raise their salary and
choice, decision, act/action, or solution that may include consequently, must raise tuition.
an unpleasant problem or situation where you feel you
simply do not know what to do or which way to turn.’’ 3. Structural Dilemma
• is a conflict of perspective of sectors,
groups, and institutions that may be
affected by the decisions.

Example: A principal ought to welcome and


encourage parents and community participation in
school affairs. Based on her experience, parents and the
community are passive and so the principal always ends
up deciding and doing things just the same. She is obliged
to observe patient and community participation which
does not give any input at all at the same time she is
obliged to accomplish things on time. The case of the
principal whether to be participatory or non-
participatory in school affairs but due to her not-so-
favorable experience of attempting to be participatory
ended up with one woman the rule is an example of a
structural dilemma.

You might also like