Professional Documents
Culture Documents
US11268984 Fibre Optic h2 Sensor
US11268984 Fibre Optic h2 Sensor
US11268984 Fibre Optic h2 Sensor
( 12 ) Sun
United
et al .
States Patent ( 10 ) Patent No.: US 11,268,984 B2
(45 ) Date of Patent : Mar. 8 , 2022
( 54 ) LOW - COST FIBER OPTIC SENSOR ARRAY ( 58 ) Field of Classification Search
FOR SIMULTANEOUS DETECTION OF None
MULTIPLE PARAMETERS See application file for complete search history.
( 71 ) Applicant: United States Department of Energy , ( 56 ) References Cited
Washington , DC ( US )
U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
( 72 ) Inventors : Chenhu Sun , South Park , PA (US );
Ping Lu , Sewickley, PA (US ) ; Ruishu 6,205,276 B1 * 3/2001 Anelli GO2B 6/4494
Wright , Pittsburgh, PA (US ); Paul R 385/100
Ohodnicki , Allison Prk , PA (US ) 8,411,275 B1 * 4/2013 Ohodnicki, Jr. GOIN 21/554
356/445
( 73 ) Assignee : United States Department of Energy , 9,568,377 B1 ** 2/2017 Ohodnicki, Jr. GO1K 11/12
Washington , DC ( US ) 2008/0272311 A1 * 11/2008 Egalon GOIN 21/6428
250 / 458.1
2009/0034901 A1 * 2/2009 Takabayashi GO1F 23/292
( * ) Notice : Subject to any disclaimer, the term of this 385/12
patent is extended or adjusted under 35 2009/0129721 A1 * 5/2009 Chen GO1F 23/292
U.S.C. 154 ( b ) by 0 days. 385/12
2011/0069316 A1 * 3/2011 Chau GO2B 6/02052
( 21 ) Appl. No .: 16 /387,359 356/445
Au /sio PO
12
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 1 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
1
?
es
r. r.i.
Fig . 1
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 2 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
3224
**
PRIOR ART
Fig. 2
U.S. Patent Mar , 8 , 2022 Sheet 3 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
? ??
Fig . 3
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 4 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Fig . 4
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 5 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Fig . 5
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 6 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Fig. 6
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 7 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
103
20 °C
30 C
.
110 ° C
Transmi o 101
**
Fig. 7
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 8 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Transmi o 30 ° C
50 ° C
100 120
Time (min )
Fig. 8
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 9 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
herheit
dengan tentang
parehe
95
Wavelength (nm)
Fig . 9
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 10 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
100
Ann when
Transmio 98
97
100 ppm
1000 ppm
96 2000 ppm
100 200
Time ( min )
Fig . 10
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 11 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
PC #1 (79.97 % )
Fig. 11
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 12 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
MAN
Transmio
???????
Wavelength ( nm )
Fig . 12
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 13 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
103
Ww ..w w www.
www.
dan penting Mala
ww
500 33? -2
Fig. 13
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 14 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Ny, 20 °C
100 - 2000 ppm
Ha at 110 °C .
7
PC
2
#
6.662
(
%
) 0 .
1000 ppm Hy 3
Temperature, 2
30 - 110 ° C
PC # 1 (81.18% )
Fig . 14
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 15 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
ded
… 2 3 60
Fig. 15
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 16 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
alebo
Fig. 16
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 17 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
103
Transmio 100
08
N , 20.00
1000 ppm H , 20.00
1000 ppm M , 30 ° C
1000 ppin H , 50 °C
1000 pom H , 70 ° C
97
w
650 750
Wavelength ( nm )
Fig. 17
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 18 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
ho
Fig . 18
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 19 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Fig. 19
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 20 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
99.5
Walthe
500 pom H2 SOC 1000 ppm H2500 ........ 2000 pom H2 500
Fig . 20
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 21 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
302
w
V2 800
Fig. 21
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 22 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Fig . 22
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 23 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
0.038
032
?
Fig. 23
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 24 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
0.25
**********
Fig . 24
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 25 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
* 100 ppm
wing
500 pont
* 1000 ppm
1 m 2000 ppm
*********
80
Temperature (C)
Fig . 25
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 26 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Transmi o
450
Wavelength (nm )
100pomA2 200
Fig . 26
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 27 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
(b)
wy
We WS
ww
.
www
www w
wo w0e w
wan
.
2
w
Wavelength (mm )
wddoos ZH 207
Fig . 27
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 28 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
( c)
S.VO:IQISvel
98.5
mal
97.5
Wavelength (oral
pop0000000
Fig. 28
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 29 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
101.5
Transmi o
WW
200
Wavelength (nm )
1500ppmH2 200 1100
Fig. 29
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 30 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
.VOIS ue
Wavelength ( m )
2000ppmH2 200 304
Fig . 30
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 31 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Wavelength (mm )
200ppm
Fig. 31
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 32 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
W
015Sus w
98.5
Wavelength ( nm )
N2500
Fig . 32
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 33 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Ww .
www 0903
VOSjuister
550
Wavelength ( 0 )
500ppm
, uddoos
Fig . 33
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 34 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Transmi o
Wavelength (no
200000
1000ppist 1900pom 2000ppin
Fig . 34
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 35 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
0.08
0.07 ww
Mod
0.02
Wavelength ( nm )
Fig . 35
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 36 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
0.3
?? 30 °° C
50 ° C
75 ° C
w1100
Score
PC
1
#
0 2000
Concentration ( ppm )
Fig . 36
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 37 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
wwwww wwwwwwwww
..001 udd
mm500 ppm
me 1000 ppm
2000 ppm
2*****
Score
PC
1
# scaricanismecriteri tristeise
sigartiritnou štaises tarecerdasanitatzearistiaegsetestitzri
Temperature (C )
Fig . 37
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 38 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
U.OISsuel 28W
wow
Wavelength (non )
Fig . 38
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 39 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
ws
Transmio ** .
ww 000
w
Fig. 39
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 40 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
300
350 342 58
352
35
Fig . 40
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 41 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
(a ) 0.03875? ?
4
Voltage
)
V
(
003458 100 ppm
500 ppm
Bom !
1000 ppm
1500 ppm
2000 ppm H2
Fig . 41
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 42 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
(b ) 10090
7500
50 ° C
0.0310 200C
***
Time ( s )
Fig . 42
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 43 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Fig. 43
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 44 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
3 %
Fig. 44
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 45 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
30
Transmi o w Sow*.*
co
***
** 2
***...W SS
...
** w
WS 20.
w
Wavelength (nm )
20 pm $ 0 poin
Fig . 45
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 46 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Fig . 46
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 47 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
120
Concentration ( opm )
Fig . 47
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 48 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Fig . 48
U.S. Patent Mar. 8 , 2022 Sheet 49 of 49 US 11,268,984 B2
Scihgangle
20 80
Fig. 49
US 11,268,984 B2
1 2
LOW - COST FIBER OPTIC SENSOR ARRAY increase the overall temperature . Under certain conditions ,
FOR SIMULTANEOUS DETECTION OF the temperature rise can become runaway ultimately leading
MULTIPLE PARAMETERS to a catastrophic failure of the transformer. It is therefore of
significant value to monitor the temperature under various
This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional 5 ambient and loading conditions to identify incipient failures
Application No. 62/ 658,869 filed on Apr. 17 , 2018 , the before they result in significant damages, economic and
disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference otherwise .
A variety of sensor-based technologies that are currently
GOVERNMENT INTEREST under development exhibit great potential for continuous
10 monitoring of dissolved gases and temperature in real - time
The United States Government has rights in this invention without disrupting the transformer operation. Particularly,
pursuant to the employer -employee relationship of the Gov- sensors using the fiber optic platform has become very
ernn nt to the inventors as U.S. Department of Energy intriguing because of its low cost , multiplexing capability
employees and site -support contractors at the National and ideal compatibility with the electrified environments . A
Energy Technology Laboratory. 15 wide range of sensing materials have been developed,
among which noble metal nanoparticles embedded nano
FIELD OF THE INVENTION composites are emerging as novel functional materials for
enhanced optical response.
The disclosure provides a system and method for sensing For example, palladium (Pd) based thin films have been
multiple parameters. More specifically, one or more embodi- 20 applied to optical hydrogen sensors . In the presence of H2 ,
ments relate to a low cost optical fiber sensor array that both the real and imaginary part of the Pd - complex refrac
monitors multiple parameters using multi -wavelength inter- tive index changes and produces optical signals . Pd and
rogation combined with multiple sensor elements along a AuPd alloy nanoparticles embedded silica films have been
single optical fiber. A primary example of interest to us , is deposited on optical fibers for the detection of H2 as an
for low cost temperature and dissolved gas analysis appli- 25 evanescent wave absorption spectroscopy sensor and tested
cations for electrical asset monitoring ( such as transform- under a range of temperatures and gas environments. More
ers ) . In this application it is desired to monitor local tem- recently, a double -layer structure consisted of aa Pd - SiO2
perature of oil as well as the chemical composition of a sensing layer and a zeolite nano - blocks filter layer has been
number of key chemical indicators (H2 , CO , CH4 , C2H2 , constructed on optical fiber for sensitive and selective mea
H2O , etc. ). 30 surement of H2 at room temperature. Gold (Au) nanopar
ticles based sensing material showing a localized surface
BACKGROUND plasmon resonance ( LSPR) absorption peak has also been
explored in various sensing applications. For example , the
The disclosure relates to a system and method for sensing LSPR absorption peak of Au — TiO2 film has been moni
multiple parameters. More specifically, one or more embodi- 35 tored as a function of temperature up to 850 ° C. The shift of
ments relate to a low cost optical fiber sensor array that the LSPR peak and change in the absorbance peak height
monitors multiple parameters using multi -wavelength inter- and full -width at half maximum has also been demonstrated
rogation combined with multiple sensor elements along a by simultaneous gas and temperature sensing of Au - SiO2
single optical fiber. plasmonic nanocomposite deposited on optical fibers.
Power transformers are among the most essential com- 40 It has been recognized that the multiplexing capability of
ponents of electrical transmission and distribution networks . fiber optic sensors enable the monitoring of multiple sensing
In order to avoid the substantial financial and social points with a single interrogation unit . For example, fiber
expenses caused by catastrophic failures, there is a growing optic sensors have been developed for spatially resolved
need to developing low - cost and real - time analytical tech- monitoring of temperatures as well as other parameters
niques and instruments to detect and diagnose fundamental 45 through distributed interrogation methodologies. The real
changes in the operating characteristics of transformers . time monitoring of energized transformer core temperature
Certain key parameters , such as dissolved gases content and has been demonstrated using a distributed fiber optic sensor
oil temperature, provide valuable information for assessing and a distributed interrogation system was incorporated into
the condition of transformers as this usually the first avail- a single -mode fiber optic sensor for measuring the spatial
able indication of the transformer health. The dissolved gas 50 distribution of temperature in the presence of hydrogen in
analysis ( DGA ) identifies the electrical or thermal faults solid - oxide fuel cells , which also has the potential for dual
based on the composition , concentration and evolution trend H2/ temperature sensor development moving into the future.
of the gases in oil . Optical sensor arrays can also be fabricated by connecting
Hydrogen (H2 ) is generated in most faults and thus is the a series of sensors using optical fibers. When several of these
most informative key gas in DGA . Based on the fault types , 55 sensors are cascaded one after the other, an overlap of the
a wide dynamic range from 100 ppm to 1800 ppm or higher peaks or dips may occur. However, the unique wavelength
could be monitored to determine the risk conditions. The dependences of optical sensors can potentially enable the
normal operating temperatures of the top oil in power deconvolution of these effects to allow simultaneous moni
transformers are from ambient temperature to 110 ° C. If the toring of multiple signals with the sensor array . Due to the
temperature exceeds 90 ° C. , the aging rate of paper insula- 60 costs of many advanced optical components utilized for the
tion and tensile strength grows rapidly, resulting in a dra- interrogation of optical fibers in conventional sensing appli
matic deterioration of transformer life expectancy. The heat cations, a key technical challenge remaining with the optical
generated by energy loss in the corresponding parts of the fiber platform lies in the ability to creatively develop multi
transformer is transferred to the insulation oil by convection functional and low - cost sensors that are economically viable
and then to the cooling medium . When the top oil tempera- 65 yet retain critical advantages of the technology platform .
ture rises above the ambient temperature, the transformer More specifically, there is an urgent need for sensors that
loading elevates which increases the loss and further detect temperature and hydrogen as well as other reducing
US 11,268,984 B2
3 4
gas species ( e.g. CO ) and hydrocarbons (e.g. CH4 , C2H2 ) . “ Distributed fiber - optic sensor for real- time monitoring of
Moreover, there is a need for sensors used in electrical energized transformer cores.” Proc . SPIE , 10194 , 101941S
transmission, distribution networks and other electrical grid 101941S - 13 ( 2017 ) .
asset health monitoring such as low cost dissolved gas Buric , M. , Ohodnicki, P., Yan , A. , Huang, S. , and Chen , K.
analysis systems that are capable of monitoring critical 5 P., “ Distributed fiber - optic sensing in a high -temperature
parameters in distribution transformers for example. solid - oxide fuel cell.” Proc. SPIE , 9977 , 997708-1-997708
The following issued documents and publications arein 11 (2016 ) .
corporated herein by reference in their entity: Cá rdenas -Sevilla, G. A. , Finazzi , V., Villatoro , J. , and
Sun , C. , Ohodnicki, P. R. , and Stewart, E. M. , “ Chemical
2 Pruneri , V., “ Photonic crystal fiber sensor array based on
sensing strategies for real - time monitoring of transformer 10 modes( 2011 ) .
overlapping , ” Optics express , 19 ( 8 ) , 7596-7602
oil : A review ,” IEEE Sensors Journal, 17 ( 18 ) , 5786-5806 Ando , M. , Kobayashi, T. , Iijima, S. , and Haruta, M. ,
( 2017) " Optical recognition of CO and H2 by use of gas - sensitive
Wang, M. , Vandermaar, A. , and Srivastava , K. D. , Au Co304 composite films , ” Journal of Materials Chem
“ Review of condition assessment of power transformers in 15 istry, 7 ( 9 ) , 1779-1783 ( 1997 ) .
service,” IEEE Electrical Insulation Magazine , 18 ( 6 ) , 12-25 Yang , R. T. and Foldes , R. , 1996. New adsorbents based
( 2002). on principles of chemical complexation: Monolayer -dis
“ IEEE Guide for the Interpretation of Gases Generated in persed nickel ( II ) for acetylene separation by Tr-complex
Oil - Immersed Transformers,” IEEE Std C57.104-2008 (Re ation . Industrial & engineering chemistry research, 35 ( 4 ) ,
vision of IEEE Std C57.104-1991 ) , 1-36 (2009 ) . 20 pp.1006-1011 .
“ IEEE Guide for Loading Mineral - Oil- Immersed Trans- Xie , Y. C. and Tang, Y.Q., 1990. Spontaneous monolayer
formers, ” IEEE Std C57.91-1995 , ( 1996 ) .
S
was established between the transmission intensity and 30 measurement, item , unit , or concentration , with preference
C2H , concentration as shown in FIG . 47. The sensor dem given to the percent variance . It should be understood by
onstrated excellent selectivity against 1000 ppm H and those of skill in the art who review this disclosure that these
1000 ppm CO , while 1000 ppm CH4 showed minor inter- terms are intended to allow a description of certain features
ference (FIG . 48). described and claimed without restricting the scope of these
Previous studies has reported that the weakly 35 features to the exact numerical ranges provided . Accord
chemisorbed C2H, on the surface Ni2 + ions can be repre- claims
2 ingly, the
andembodiments are limited
equivalents thereto only by the and
. All publications following
patent
sented by Ni2 + (C2H2)n with n in the range of 1-3 . As documents cited in this application are incorporated by
temperature increased, the average value of n decreased
from 2.4 at 25 ° C. to 1.6 at 45 ° C. , 1.2 at 60 ° C. , and 1.1 at reference in their entirety for all purposes to the same extent
70 ° C. The temperature dependence of C2H, was monitored 40 asindividually
if each individual publication or patent document were so
denoted .
by recording the transmission intensity of 100 ppm C2H , at
various temperatures from 20 to 110 ° C. and relative signal
change to the N, baseline was plotted in FIG . 49. The trend What is claimed is :
matched well with the previous report and indicated a 1. An optical sensor array, the sensor array comprising :
decreased signal with increasing temperatures, which could 45 an optical fiber;
be ascribed to the accelerated desorption rate of C2H2 one or more multimode fibers in optical communication
molecules at high temperatures. with the optical fiber ;
All publications and patent documents cited in this appli- a first nanocomposite thin film along at least a portion of
cation are incorporated by reference in their entirety for all the optical fiber for interrogating a first parameter
purposes to the same extent as if each individual publication 50 having a first wavelength ; and
or patent document were so individually denoted . a second nanocomposite thin film along at least a portion
While the embodiments of the invention disclosed herein of the optical fiber for interrogating a second parameter
are presently considered to be preferred, various changes having a second wavelength different from the first
and modifications can be made without departing from the wavelength of the first parameter, wherein at least one
spirit and scope of the invention . The scope of the invention 55 of the first and second parameters is temperature .
is indicated in the appended claims , and all changes that 2. The sensor array of claim 1 further comprising one or
come within the meaning and range of equivalents are more nanocomposite thin films along at least a portion of the
intended to be embraced therein . optical fiber for interrogating one or more parameters, each
While the embodiments of the invention disclosed herein parameter uniquely correlated to signals at different wave
are presently considered to be preferred , various changes 60 lengths .
and modifications can be made without departing from the 3. The sensor array of claim 1 wherein the first nanocom
spirit and scope of the invention . The scope of the invention posite thin film is selected from the group comprising
is indicated in the appended claims , and all changes that Au / SiO2 , Pd /SiO2 and Ni doped porous SiO , thin film .
come within the meaning and range of equivalents are 4. The sensor array of claim 1 wherein the second
intended to be embraced therein . 65 nanocomposite thin film is selected from the group com
Having described the basic concept of the embodiments , prising Au /SiO2, Pd /SiO , and Ni doped porous Sio , thin
it will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the film .
US 11,268,984 B2
17 18
5. The sensor array of claim 1 wherein at least one of the analytics to extract independent information from the
first and second parameters is aa chemical composition of a sensor array for optimized wavelength selection of
chemical indicator. discrete wavelengths.
6. The sensor array of claim 5 wherein the chemical 9. The optical system of claim 8 wherein the optics system
indicator is selected from the group comprising H2 , CO , 5 comprises one or more filters.
CH4 , CH , and H.O. 10. The optical system of claim 9 wherein the one or more
7. The sensor array of claim 1 further comprising a filter filters comprises one or more lenses .
11. The optical system of claim 8 further comprising a
layer of zeolite nanoblock coating over at least one of the plurality
first nanocomposite thin film and the second nanocomposite 10 12. Theof optical sensor arrays connected in series .
system of claim 8 further wherein the
thin film .
8. An optical system for monitoring multiple parameters multi - variate data analytics comprises principal component
analysis.
of an electrical asset , the optical system comprising : 13. A method of monitoring multiple parameters of an
an optics system comprising one or more light emitting electrical asset , the method comprising:
diodes;
a sensor array in optical communication with the optics 15 determining a first wavelength with a signal correlated to
system , the sensor array comprising: a first parameter of the electrical asset to be monitored;
an optical fiber; determining a second wavelength with a signal correlated
a first nanocomposite thin film along at least a portion of to a second parameter of the electrical asset to be
the optical fiber for interrogating a first parameter 20 sensing monitored ;
correlated to a signal at a first wavelength ; and the first and second parameters using an optical
a second nanocomposite thin film along at least a portion fiber , one or more multimode fibers in optical commu
of the optical fiber for interrogating a second parameter nication with the optical fiber; the optical fiber having
correlated to a signal at a second wavelength different a first nanocomposite thin film along at least a portion
from the first wavelength of the first parameter ; of the optical fiber for interrogating the first parameter
further comprises a multimeter in communication with the 25 through a first correlated signal having the first wave
one or more photodiodes and an analysis portion in length and a second nanocomposite thin film along at
optical communication with the sensor array , the analy least a portion of the optical fiber for interrogating the
sis portion comprising one or more photodiodes, a second parameter through a second correlated signal ,
multimeter in communication with the one or more 30 wherein at least one of the first and second parameters
photodiodes and a computer in communication with the is temperature .
multimeter, the computer performing multi - variate data