Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 21

CHAMBERS GLOBAL PRACTICE GUIDES

Technology
M&A 2023
Definitive global law guides offering
comparative analysis from top-ranked lawyers

Vietnam: Law & Practice


Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui
LNT & Partners

practiceguides.chambers.com
VIETNAM
Law and Practice
Hanoi
Laos

Contributed by: Thailand

Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui Vietnam


Cambodia
LNT & Partners see p.19

Contents
1. Market Trends p.4 6. Acquisitions of Public (Exchange-Listed)
1.1 Technology M&A Market p.4 Technology Companies p.8
6.1 Stakebuilding p.8
2. Establishing a New Company, Early-Stage
6.2 Mandatory Offer p.9
Financing and Venture Capital Financing
of a New Technology Company p.4 6.3 Transaction Structures p.9
2.1 Establishing a New Company p.4 6.4 Consideration; Minimum Price p.9
2.2 Type of Entity p.5 6.5 Common Conditions for a Takeover Offer/
Tender Offer p.10
2.3 Early-Stage Financing p.5
6.6 Deal Documentation p.10
2.4 Venture Capital p.5
6.7 Minimum Acceptance Conditions p.10
2.5 Venture Capital Documentation p.5
6.8 Squeeze-Out Mechanisms p.10
2.6 Change of Corporate Form or Migration p.6
6.9 Requirement to Have Certain Funds/Financing
3. Initial Public Offering (IPO) as a Liquidity to Launch a Takeover Offer p.10
Event p.6 6.10 Types of Deal Protection Measures p.11
3.1 IPO v Sale p.6 6.11 Additional Governance Rights p.11
3.2 Choice of Listing p.6 6.12 Irrevocable Commitments p.11
3.3 Impact of the Choice of Listing on Future M&A 6.13 Securities Regulator’s or Stock Exchange
Transactions p.6 Process p.11
4. Sale as a Liquidity Event (Sale of a 6.14 Timing of the Takeover Offer p.11
Privately Held Venture Capital-Financed
7. Overview of Regulatory Requirements p.12
Company) p.7
7.1 Regulations Applicable to a Technology
4.1 Liquidity Event: Sale Process p.7
Company p.12
4.2 Liquidity Event: Transaction Structure p.7
7.2 Primary Securities Market Regulators p.12
4.3 Liquidity Event: Form of Consideration p.7
7.3 Restrictions on Foreign Investments p.12
4.4 Liquidity Event: Certain Transaction Terms p.7
7.4 National Security Review/Export Control p.13
5. Spin-Offs p.8 7.5 Antitrust Regulations p.13
5.1 Trends: Spin-Offs p.8 7.6 Labour Law Regulations p.14
5.2 Tax Consequences p.8 7.7 Currency Control/Central Bank Approval p.14
5.3 Spin-Off Followed by a Business Combination p.8
8. Recent Legal Developments p.15
5.4 Timing and Tax Authority Ruling p.8
8.1 Significant Court Decisions or Legal
Developments p.15

2 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM
9. Due Diligence/Data Privacy p.16
9.1 Technology Company Due Diligence p.16
9.2 Data Privacy p.16

10. Disclosure p.17


10.1 Making a Bid Public p.17
10.2 Prospectus Requirements p.17
10.3 Producing Financial Statements p.17
10.4 Disclosure of Transaction Documents p.18

11. Duties of Directors p.18


11.1 Principal Directors’ Duties p.18
11.2 Special or Ad Hoc Committees p.18
11.3 Board’s Role p.18
11.4 Independent Outside Advice p.18

3 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

1. Market Trends terms of both deal volume and value: deal vol-
ume doubled, whilst the aggregate transaction
1.1 Technology M&A Market value increased more than threefold to nearly
In the first half of 2022, Vietnam’s overall M&A USD1 billion. Notably, the biggest home-grown
deal value reached approximately USD4.97 bil- market winners were VNG, VNPay, Sky Mavis
lion, nearly equal to the value for the entire year (Axie Infinity’s developer), Momo and Tiki. These
of 2021, with strong growth of investment from corporations have been attracting funding of
private equity and venture capital. hundreds of millions of dollars, giving them well-
deserved unicorn status.
The social distancing necessitated by the COV-
ID-19 pandemic called for the increased applica- Prominent recent transactions include:
tion of digital technology in daily life in Vietnam.
Sharing the global trend in technology M&A, • the AIA Insurance-led injection of USD258
M&A activities involving technology companies million into Tiki;
doubled in transaction volume and tripled in • the USD152 million investment in Sky Mavis,
value, reaching approximately USD963 million led by Andreessen Horowitz; and
as of October 2021. However, the Vietnamese • the Warburg Pincus-led USD100 million
market is not immune to headwinds from major investment in Momo.
economic and geopolitical disruptions. By mid-
year, as investors switched to a more conserva- The recently announced USD15 million invest-
tive stance in the face of turmoil, M&A activity ment by Mekong Capital in Gene Solutions, a
in the entire market, including the technology health-tech start-up pioneering genetic testing
sector, slowed down and only returned to pre- in Vietnam, is small yet also worth mention-
pandemic levels recently. ing. This investment will help Gene Solutions
develop new gene-testing technology, aiming to
Nonetheless, technology M&A is expected to be make the process more affordable and acces-
among the most dynamic M&A sectors in Viet- sible, which will play a pivotal role in the future
nam. In compound with an above-average GDP of healthcare in Vietnam.
growth forecast for an Asia-Pacific country and
supportive policies from the State, Vietnam is
attracting more and more attention from foreign 2. Establishing a New Company,
investment funds. Early-Stage Financing and Venture
Capital Financing of a New
Key Trends
Technology Company
Historically, M&A activities were mainly driven by
foreign investors, specifically those from Thai- 2.1 Establishing a New Company
land, Singapore, Japan, South Korea and Tai- The start-up community in Vietnam includes
wan. However, domestic investors are becoming roughly 4,000 companies, 11 of which are val-
more and more engaged in M&A in Vietnam. ued at over USD100 million. Four such start-ups
have attained “unicorn” status (VNG, VNLife,
In the first ten months of 2021, the tech-related MoMo and Sky Mavis). Most of these start-up
M&A landscape in Vietnam saw a big boost in companies are incorporated in Vietnam; Sky

4 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

Mavis, which was incorporated in Singapore, is Depending on the scale and complexity of the
a rare phenomenon. capital raising transaction, documentation of an
early-stage financing may vary in form. Venture
Establishing a company in a country other than capital and private equity firms usually docu-
Vietnam is a foreign concept for most entrepre- ment their investment in the form of a joint ven-
neurs in Vietnam, and is usually on the costly ture agreement (JVA) for target companies that
side. Under Vietnamese laws, the regulatory are LLCs, or a share purchase agreement (SPA)
time for incorporating a limited liability company for target companies that are JSCs; both JVAs
(LLC) or a joint stock company (JSC) is three and SPAs are usually accompanied by a share-
business days. While there are minimum charter holders’ agreement (SHA).
capital requirements by law, business lines that
are usually registered for start-up companies Loan financing is not common because lend-
in technology sectors are not subject to such ing is a relatively restrictive business line, and
requirements. the loan provides the lender no control over the
target company. A loan financing should also
2.2 Type of Entity include security measures such as a mortgage
The most common types of companies are JSCs of shares in the target company or a guarantee
and LLCs. from the founders.

Both come with limited liability. An LLC requires 2.4 Venture Capital
only one member to incorporate, while a JSC By law, the venture capital for start-ups may
must have at least three founding shareholders include start-up venture capital firms, local and
at incorporation. However, a JSC provides more foreign institutions and individuals. In practice,
flexibility in terms of the transfer of shares and venture capital in Vietnam usually comes from
capital raising. venture capital firms (local and foreign), govern-
ment-sponsored funds and public-private ini-
Both types of companies are subject to registra- tiatives (ie, initiatives in which the government
tion requirements for any change in the owner- collaborates with private institutions).
ship structure that involves foreign investors.
Vietnamese venture capital firms mostly invest
2.3 Early-Stage Financing in local start-ups due to there being stringent
Pre-Series A funding or seed investment in Viet- requirements for offshore investment. In com-
nam for start-ups can come from a wide range bination with increased activity among foreign
of sources, from acquaintances (eg, family or venture capital firms (even top-tier Silicon Val-
friends or network connections) to local venture ley venture capitalists), Vietnamese start-ups
capital funds to foreign investors. Government- received a total of USD2.1 billion in terms of
sponsored funds and initiatives, such as Vietnam venture capital in 2021.
National Innovation Centre (in collaboration with
Asian Development Bank), are also a prominent 2.5 Venture Capital Documentation
source of early-stage financing. There is no standard for venture capital docu-
mentation under Vietnamese laws and regula-
tions. Depending on the structure of the venture

5 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

capital investment, documentation may greatly subject to a plethora of stringent legal require-
vary. Generally, the documentation of a venture ments, which are unappealing to entrepreneurs
capital investment includes: and investors alike.

• an SPA or capital contribution purchase Therefore, sales of shares or capital contribu-


agreement; and tions remain Vietnam’s most popular exit strat-
• a shareholders’ agreement and JVA, which egy.
are sometimes used interchangeably.
3.2 Choice of Listing
2.6 Change of Corporate Form or A company’s choice of exchange for listing
Migration depends on a variety of elements – eg, the com-
Change in the nationality of the start-ups them- pany’s directions and objectives, and the feasi-
selves is not a practice that has occurred in Viet- bility of such listing. Listing on Vietnamese stock
nam. exchanges, such as HOSE or HNX, is simpler,
more straightforward and manageable, while for-
However, through several tranches of invest- eign exchanges allow for greater accessibility to
ment, and upon the foreign ownership in the capital resources.
company reaching a certain threshold, a start-
up company established under Vietnamese laws In Vietnam, conglomerates have been known
may be treated as a foreign investor, and thus to establish elaborate plans for listing in foreign
have to satisfy investment conditions and follow exchanges, most commonly NASDAQ. However,
the investment procedures applicable to foreign to date, no Vietnamese company has success-
investors only. fully listed on a foreign exchange, partly due to
the difficulties in navigating between the require-
ments under Vietnamese laws and under the
3. Initial Public Offering (IPO) as a jurisdiction of the exchange.
Liquidity Event
3.3 Impact of the Choice of Listing on
3.1 IPO v Sale Future M&A Transactions
In Vietnam, liquidity event provisions in the SHA A Vietnamese company listing only on a foreign
or JVA may provide exit mechanics in the forms exchange may affect the feasibility of a future
of an IPO or a sale process, or both simulta- sale.
neously. Investors and founders tend to lean
toward having as many options for their liquidity While listing on a foreign exchange, the Viet-
events as possible. namese company is still subject to a number of
requirements under Vietnamese laws involving
In reality, however, most exits in Vietnam occur the transfer of shares in said company, such as
in the form of a sale process. Sales of equity foreign ownership limitations and compliance
(shares or capital contributions) are more attrac- with Vietnam’s foreign exchange control regime.
tive to investors as a way to exit because they In addition, any international IPO of a Vietnam-
are more straightforward and provide a higher ese company must obtain a pre-approval from
level of confidentiality. Meanwhile, IPOs are the State Security Commission (SSC).

6 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

Once the company has listed its shares on a for- In certain deals, venture capital investors may
eign exchange, any future sale must comply with consider staying as shareholders in the com-
the laws of the host country, and the company pany, if the buyer, as the new shareholder, has
will likely have to navigate conflicts between the the appropriate strategy and potentially benefits
requirements of foreign laws and those of Viet- them. In that case, the transaction is typically
namese laws. structured as a share deal to ensure that venture
capital investors continue to hold their shares.
With regards to a share deal where they opt to
4. Sale as a Liquidity Event (Sale remain at the target company, venture capital
of a Privately Held Venture Capital- investors are advised to have measures in place
Financed Company) to at least maintain the shareholding ratio at the
pre-sale level.
4.1 Liquidity Event: Sale Process
The sale of a company is more commonly run 4.3 Liquidity Event: Form of
as a bilateral negotiation with a chosen buyer Consideration
than as an auction, especially when the potential Most transactions for a sale of the entire com-
buyer has already been identified. pany are done for cash due to the cash demand
or change of invested objects.
Auctions are required for certain state-owned
enterprises. For private enterprises, due to the The authorities may be conservative toward
sophisticated process and unfamiliarity, auc- transactions with unusual details, such as a
tions are not yet popular, although they have stock-for-stock transaction, and thus refuse to
potential to become so as they would be ben- approve or register them. The licensing proce-
eficial to sellers. dures required for a stock-for-stock transaction
may be heavier and not consistent, because
4.2 Liquidity Event: Transaction Structure such transactions involve changes in both the
The cycle of an investment from a venture capi- target company and the purchasing company.
tal investor usually ranges from three to seven Thus, stock-for-stock transactions or a combi-
years, depending on the requirements involved. nation of stock and cash are not yet common
In practice, venture capital investors prefer both practice in Vietnam.
approaches, exiting along with the founders or
by themselves. However, once the founders, 4.4 Liquidity Event: Certain Transaction
playing an essential role in technology compa- Terms
nies, especially start-ups, sell all their shares, As the direct managers of the companies, found-
venture capital investors usually prefer to tag- ers are commonly requested to provide their rep-
along on such sale. Venture capital investors resentations and warranties after closing. Such
also exit if the buyer fails to meet their invest- representations and warranties may be related
ment strategy and expectations. In that case, to certain business and responsibility aspects in
the transaction may be structured as a company relation to the target company. Venture capital
share deal, asset deal or restructuring. investors may also be subject to similar require-
ments to ensure the buyer’s maximum interest,
but in certain cases they may provide fewer rep-

7 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

resentations and warranties, which are directly inspection at the headquarters of the original
related to themselves. company and the newly established company.

Although not yet common, representations and 5.3 Spin-Off Followed by a Business
warranties insurance is starting to penetrate Combination
the Vietnamese market. On the other hand, the While there is no requirement for a spin-off to
escrow or holdback mechanism may be used in be followed immediately by a business combi-
a certain period after closing, especially in the nation, the general obligations during an M&A
sale of the entire company, in addition to the transaction must be fulfilled – ie, obtaining pre-
indemnification and penalty terms. approval for investment, filing a tax declaration
for the transaction, submitting antitrust merger
control documentation, applying for business
5. Spin-Offs registration procedures, etc.

5.1 Trends: Spin-Offs 5.4 Timing and Tax Authority Ruling


Even though Vietnam has seen a number of uni- There is no prior ruling from tax authorities
corns in the technology industry, most Vietnam- required before a spin-off.
ese technology companies are small and private,
which makes it hard to identify the movements From a licensing perspective, it takes around five
in the M&A market involving these companies. working days to:
Spin-offs are also more common in the real
estate and consumer goods industries, where • register changes in the business registration
there is conglomerate involvement. of the original company due to the spin-off;
and
The key incentives of a spin-off include: • obtain incorporation certificates for the newly
established company (or companies).
• the ability to concentrate resources into core
businesses;
• flexibility in decision-making; and 6. Acquisitions of Public
• separation in terms of liabilities, which makes (Exchange-Listed) Technology
it easier to raise capital or facilitate future Companies
M&A.
6.1 Stakebuilding
5.2 Tax Consequences Acquiring a stake in a public company prior to
The law appears to be silent on the income tax making an offer is legally feasible, although it
aspect of a spin-off. In principle, before filing for is not common practice as there can be both
a spin-off, the original company must fulfil all regulatory and financial consequences. Moreo-
of its tax duties incurred up to the time of the ver, stakebuilding at a certain level will trigger
spin-off. Otherwise, the original company and the disclosure and reporting and mandatory
the newly established companies shall be jointly offer obligations.
liable for any residual tax duty. In addition, after
the spin-off, the tax authority may conduct a tax

8 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

The acquisition of an interest in public compa- 35%, 45%, 55%, 65%, 75% of the voting
nies is subject to disclosure and reporting obli- shares.
gations to the public company (SSC) and the
relevant stock exchange in the following cases: 6.3 Transaction Structures
The three common M&A structures for the acqui-
• any person or group of affiliated persons sition of a public company in Vietnam are:
becoming or no longer being the company’s
major shareholder (major shareholding means • acquisition of shares;
holding at least 5% of the company’s total • acquisition of assets; and
voting shares); and • merger.
• a major shareholder’s shareholding changing
by more than 1% of the company’s total vot- Share acquisition is the most common structure
ing shares. in the Vietnamese market, as certain types of
assets (ie, land use rights, assets attached to
The reporting and disclosure obligation must be lands, and workforces) may not be transferrable
met within five working days from the date of or can only be transferred upon the satisfaction
the relevant person becoming/no longer being of certain regulatory approvals. Moreover, cer-
a majority shareholder or the date of change in tain types of assets may not be sold to foreign
holding. investors, and foreign investors need to set up
a new company to acquire the target company’s
The buyer in a stakebuilding transaction does assets.
not need to state the purpose of the stake acqui-
sition or any other information. In the tender offer 6.4 Consideration; Minimum Price
registration, however, the buyer is required to Acquisitions of public companies in the tech-
state the purpose of the tender offer, the tenta- nology industry in Vietnam are more typically
tive operation and business plan after the ten- structured as cash transactions. Although
der offer. Vietnamese law does not stipulate a stock-for-stock transactions are permissible
specified period of time for a buyer to make a under Vietnamese law, they are not common in
proposal or state that it will not do so (the “put practice.
up or shut up” requirement).
No stock-for-stock transactions have been seen
6.2 Mandatory Offer for mergers or takeovers. In a tender offer, the
A tender offer is a mandatory offer when: minimum offering price must not be lower than:

• the acquisition results in the investor and their • the average reference price in the 60 trad-
related persons directly or indirectly owning ing days before the tender offer registration
25% or more of the target company’s voting application is submitted; and
shares; or • the highest offering price of all tender offers
• the acquisition results in the investor and the target company received during the same
their related persons, who already own 25% period.
or more of the target’s voting shares, now
directly or indirectly owning or exceeding

9 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

To bridge value gaps, the Vietnamese private does not reach the minimum acceptance condi-
market has seen both contingent value rights tion, the bidder can withdraw its tender offer. The
and earn-outs being used, especially in sectors threshold is different case by case, but the main
with high valuation uncertainty. However, contin- purpose is to ensure the bidder and its related
gent consideration is not as common for public persons in the target gain the following:
companies.
• the voting threshold to pass regular resolu-
6.5 Common Conditions for a Takeover tions of the general meeting of shareholders
Offer/Tender Offer (GMS); and
While regulators do not restrict the use of offer • the veto right to resolutions of the GMS
conditions, the following terms and conditions regarding the reserved matters.
must be specified:
6.8 Squeeze-Out Mechanisms
• the number of shares intended to be pur- Article 35.1.c of the Law on Securities 2019
chased; stipulates that, within 30 days of reaching an
• the bid price and payment method; ownership of no less than 80% of the total
• termination/withdrawal of the tender offer; existing shares via the tender offer, the person
• the effective term of the tender offer; and that conducted such tender offer must offer to
• solutions in case the number of shares reg- buy out the remaining shareholders in the target
istered to purchase is lower than the actual company, at the same offered price and with the
shares offered. same payment method in the tender offer.

6.6 Deal Documentation However, Article 35.1.c does not impose any
A written agreement is a “must” for both takeo- obligation to sell on the remaining shareholders.
ver offers and business combinations. Depend-
ing on the specific transactional structures and 6.9 Requirement to Have Certain Funds/
details, as well as the positions of the transac- Financing to Launch a Takeover Offer
tional parties, a target company (including public To launch the offer with payment in cash, “cer-
companies) may undertake different obligations. tain funds” are required. The offeror must include
either of the following in the registration dossier,
Representations and warranties are common or submit them to SSC before SSC issues a con-
in Vietnam, although for public companies, the firmation on the receipt of a full and valid dossier:
specific representations and warranties may dif-
fer from private companies. • a written confirmation on payment guaran-
tee from a credit institution in favour of the
6.7 Minimum Acceptance Conditions offeror; or
A bidder may establish minimum acceptance • a written confirmation that the bank
conditions in the registration dossier and offer account(s) of the offeror with sufficient funds
announcement, usually a minimum threshold for the tender offer has been frozen.
of shares held by shareholders accepting the
tender offer – eg, if the number of shares held The buyer then officially makes the offer by
by shareholders who accepted the tender offer sending the tender offer registration dossier to

10 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

the target company, and simultaneously submit- They are both civil transactions by nature,
ting to SSC and the stock exchange. based on the parties’ agreements. In Vietnam,
the enforcement of these commitments, along
6.10 Types of Deal Protection Measures with other shareholders’ agreements, may be
A bidder can seek the following types of deal uncertain.
security measures:
6.13 Securities Regulator’s or Stock
• exclusivity provisions; Exchange Process
• non-solicitation provisions; The offeror shall submit the registration dossier
• break-up fees; and for tender offer to SSC and the target company
• bank guarantees. prior to conducting the acquisition. SSC takes
15 working days from the receipt of the satisfac-
6.11 Additional Governance Rights tory application to review, and announces either
If a bidder cannot obtain 100% ownership of a the receipt of the satisfactory application on its
target, the bidder can obtain the following gov- website or the refusal of the application (in writ-
ernance rights by a shareholders’ agreement ing with an explanation).
with the target’s existing shareholders:
SSC shall review all information in the registra-
• veto rights on certain reserved matters; tion dossier to ensure its compliance with Viet-
• the right to nominate candidates for the namese law, including the price offer, duration
board; and payment method, expected numbers/per-
• the right to designate one or more of the centage of share acquired, termination of tender
target’s legal representatives, who may legally offer, etc.
take actions on the target’s behalf (under the
bidder’s instruction) in transactions and rela- By law, the effectiveness of a tender offer must
tions; be at least 30 trading days, and at maximum
• the right to compulsory reporting by the 60 trading days, from the date the offeror starts
board or general director prior to the execu- receiving registrations for sale of the tendered
tion of certain material agreements; and shares. If another organisation or individual is
• an information access right via periodical making a competing offer, the tender offer can
reports or persons designated by the bid- be withdrawn or changed, with no timeline
der, such as the chief accountant or general changes involved.
director.
6.14 Timing of the Takeover Offer
6.12 Irrevocable Commitments A tender offer can be extended within the per-
Irrevocable commitments to tender and support mitted time frame, as discussed in 6.13 Securi-
the transaction and an “out” for principal share- ties Regulator’s or Stock Exchange Process.
holders are not required to be disclosed or sub-
mitted in registration dossiers. Therefore, there If the tender offer constitutes an economic con-
is no study or research to show how common centration that reaches certain thresholds, the
they are in practice. offeror must submit, in the registration dossier
for the tender offer, a merger clearance from the

11 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

competent competition authority, which is cur- nications networks (issued by the Bureau of
rently the Vietnam Competition and Consumer Broadcasting and Electronic Information),
Authority (VCCA). which takes 15 working days from the receipt
of a satisfactory dossier.

7. Overview of Regulatory These timelines to obtain licences are regulatory.


Requirements In practice, certain timelines are sometimes pro-
longed. The recent delays in licensing timelines
7.1 Regulations Applicable to a for e-commerce procedures should be taken
Technology Company into account.
Setting up a company is subject to the Law on
Enterprises. Certain business lines are also sub- 7.2 Primary Securities Market Regulators
ject to specific regulations that require compa- The SSC is the primary securities market regula-
nies to obtain sub-licences or approvals from tor for M&A transactions of public companies in
regulatory bodies before conducting the busi- Vietnam. It mainly supervises public and listed
ness line(s), including but not limited to the fol- companies in Vietnam, along with their M&A
lowing: activities.

• financial: a licence to provide intermediary 7.3 Restrictions on Foreign Investments


payment services (issued by the State Bank Foreign investment in certain businesses is pro-
of Vietnam), which takes 60 days from the hibited in Vietnam but is allowed in principle in
receipt of a satisfactory dossier; other businesses, with some being conditional
• e-commerce: confirmation on notice of sales (ie, the investors must meet certain conditions).
e-commerce website or registration of e-com-
merce service website (issued by the Minister Foreign direct investment in Vietnam may be in
of Information and Communications), which the form of:
takes between three working days (for notice)
and seven working days (for regulatory time • a greenfield project whereby the foreign
of registration); investor(s) would incorporate a new company
• information: a licence to establish news web- to conduct the project; or
sites (issued by the Department of Informa- • an M&A transaction in the form of a share
tion and Communication), which takes five acquisition/subscription or a capital contribu-
days from the receipt of a satisfactory dos- tion purchase.
sier, and a licence to establish social network-
ing sites (issued by the Minister of Information Before incorporating a new company, foreign
and Communication), which takes 30 days investors are required to obtain an investment
from the receipt of a satisfactory dossier; and registration certificate (IRC) as a licensing
• telecommunications: a licence to provide approval for their investment project. It is not
telecommunications services (issued by the necessary to obtain an IRC when conducting
Minister of Information and Communications) foreign direct investment through an M&A trans-
and certificates of registration to provide action, but foreign investors may be required
information services on mobile telecommu-

12 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

to submit an application to obtain M&A pre- (c) bred, reared or artificially propagated
approval if: specimens of species prescribed in the
CITES appendices and lists of endan-
• the foreign ownership in the target company gered, precious and rare forest plant and
conducting conditional business lines is animal species and aquatic species; and
increased; (d) relics or antiques other than those under
• the foreign ownership in the target company the ownership of the state, political organ-
is increased to more than 50% of the charter isations or socio-political organisations.
capital; or • The export of civil cryptographic products
• the investment is made in a business requires a permit under Article 34.1 of the
organisation that is located on islands or Law on Cyber Information Security 2015.
in coastal or frontier areas of Vietnam that Only civil cryptographic products listed in
affects national defence and security (see 7.4 Appendix II of Decree 53/2018/ND-CP can be
National Security Review/Export Control for exported.
more details). • Goods under the management of Ministry of
National Defence listed by Circular 173/2018/
7.4 National Security Review/Export TT-BQP are banned from export.
Control
National Security Review 7.5 Antitrust Regulations
The acquisition of foreign investors in local com- Takeover offers or business combinations, and
panies has to ensure national defence and secu- transactions in which one participant obtains
rity. If the local company is located on islands control over the other participant(s), are deemed
or in coastal or frontier areas of Vietnam, the to be economic concentration for antitrust pur-
foreign investor must obtain M&A approval from poses in Vietnam. Companies participating in an
the Department of Planning and Investment for economic concentration have to jointly file an
national defence and security reasons. There is application for the notification of an economic
no other specific restriction for investors/buyers concentration to the National Competition Com-
based in any particular part of the world. mission (NCC) before carrying out the economic
concentration if any of the following thresholds
Export Control is met:
Under Vietnamese laws, the export controls
regulations are as follows. • the total assets in the Vietnamese market
of the enterprise or the group of affiliated
• According to the list of conditional business companies in which the enterprise is an affili-
lines in Appendix IV of the Law on Investment ate reach VND3,000 billion (approximately
2020, certain goods require conditions when USD120 million) or more in the preceding
exporting them, including: fiscal year;
(a) rice; • the total sales or purchase volume in the Viet-
(b) natural specimens of species prescribed namese market of the enterprise or the group
in the CITES appendices and lists of en- of affiliated companies in which the enterprise
dangered, precious and rare forest plant is an affiliate reach VND3,000 billion (approxi-
and animal species and aquatic species;

13 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

mately USD120 million) or more in the pre- to be disclosed to the employees within 15 days
ceding fiscal year; of being approved, and shall be implemented
• the transaction value is VND1,000 billion by the current employer and the succeeding
(approximately USD40 million) or more; or employer.
• the combined market shares of the compa-
nies participating in the economic concentra- The employees who are laid off as a result of
tion is 20% or more of the relevant market(s) M&A activity shall be entitled to a redundancy
in the preceding fiscal year. allowance if they have worked on a regular basis
for the employer for at least 12 months. Each
These thresholds differ for credit institutions, working year will equate to one month’s salary,
insurance companies and securities companies and the total redundancy allowance shall be at
participating in economic concentrations. least two months’ salary.

Of note, the NCC has not yet been established, 7.7 Currency Control/Central Bank
and the VCCA is currently in charge of process- Approval
ing antitrust filings in Vietnam. Under Circular 06/2019/TT-NHNN, a company
with foreign direct investment (FDI company)
7.6 Labour Law Regulations must open a direct investment capital account
Under the Labour Code 2019, if the acquisition (DICA) at an authorised bank. FDI companies
of an enterprise affects the employment of a include:
large number of employees of said enterprise,
the employer must prepare a labour usage plan • foreign-invested companies that are required
that includes the following content: to obtain an IRC before incorporation; and
• foreign-invested companies whose foreign
• the names and number of employees to be investors own in total no less than 51% of the
retained, the employees to be retrained for charter capital.
further employment, and the employees to be
working on a part-time basis; All capital transactions (eg, capital contributions)
• the names and number of employees to retire; as well as the repatriation of proceeds from the
• the names and number of employees whose investment of the FDI company must be routed
employment contracts have to be terminated; through the DICA. The FDI company may open
• the rights and obligations of the employer, one DICA in the foreign currency that is used to
employee and relevant parties regarding the make capital contribution, and another in Viet-
implementation of the labour usage plan; and namese Dong.
• the measures and financial sources necessary
to implement the plan. Of note, the transfer of shares or equity in the
FDI company, between non-resident investors
During the preparation of the labour usage or between resident investors, shall not be made
plan, the employer has to obtain the opinion through the DICA.
of the grassroots labour union representing the
employees (Trade Union) if the enterprise has a
Trade Union. The labour usage plan is required

14 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

Vietnamese laws do not require any approval at a break-neck pace of technology and the sen-
from the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) for an M&A sitivity in nature of fintech business, legislators
transaction. seemed to have opted for a rather conservative,
and somewhat passive, stance, which resulted
in the draft decree being passed around the sys-
8. Recent Legal Developments tem for almost three years.

8.1 Significant Court Decisions or Legal Among the fintech businesses, P2P lending and
Developments mobile money are prominent. In 2021, the Prime
Vietnam has signed a number of multilateral trea- Minister issued Decision 316/QĐ-TTg approv-
ties, including the Comprehensive and Progres- ing a two-year pilot application of mobile money,
sive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership whereby mobile phone credit can be used to pay
(2018), the EU–Vietnam Free Trade Agreement for small-value goods and services at a quota of
(2019), the Regional Comprehensive Eco- no more than VND10 million per month for each
nomic Partnership (2020) and the UK–Vietnam mobile money account.
Free Trade Agreement (2020), which expand
free trade, promote the development of value P2P lending, on the other hand, has always been
chains, and facilitate manufacturing and accord- one of the most dynamic sectors in Vietnam,
ingly export markets, creating a foundation, pro- albeit one of the most under-regulated. Given
moting Vietnamese enterprises to restructure the status quo, SBV has taken a conservative
towards establishing value chains, investing in stance toward dossiers submitted to apply for
technology and improving competitiveness. the specific business line of P2P lending, which
are then usually pending or refused. This means
Within technology, the legislative bodies have that technology companies that have already
focused on the following sectors in recent years: been operating a P2P lending business are
becoming more and more ripe for M&A activities.
• fintech;
• cryptography; and Cryptography
• data privacy. In some surveys, Vietnam is one of the most
active countries when it comes to the crypto-
Fintech graphic economy, with the Vietnamese – espe-
Following the precedents of other countries in cially the younger generations – welcoming the
the world, especially the UK, Vietnam is working likes of Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana and even
to establish a pilot fintech sandbox, providing for Dogecoin with open arms. Problems arose once
a controlled testing mechanism (ie, a sandbox) again from a discrepancy between the pace at
for fintech activities in the banking sector by the which technology moves forward and the pace
State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) has been repeat- at which the government can dissect the techno-
edly consulted with ministries and branches. logical subject and establish a legal framework
A decree on the establishment of such fintech around such subject.
sandbox has been in the pipeline for quite some
time. Due to a number of reasons, including the At the moment, even though there have been
inability of the to catch up with the development a number of directives from the Prime Minis-

15 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

ter ordering relevant ministries to research and 9. Due Diligence/Data Privacy


establish a legal framework for cryptocurrencies
and other applications of cryptography, no draft 9.1 Technology Company Due Diligence
document of any legislation pertaining to these By law, there is currently no restriction with
matters has been made public. regards to the information to be provided dur-
ing a due diligence exercise (see 9.2 Data Pri-
Data Privacy vacy for further discussion on data privacy).
Recent incidents involving massive leaks in How much information is provided to a bidder
personal data have exposed the absence of a depends on the negotiation between the com-
much-needed legal framework on the protec- pany and such bidder.
tion of data and data privacy in general. In fact,
before these incidents, a draft decree on the With every bidder, the target company is advised
protection of personal data had been initiated to sign a non-disclosure agreement, or to incor-
yet stuck in the legislative procedures for almost porate a confidentiality provision into the letter of
three years, with numerous rounds of back-and- intent or memorandum of understanding.
forth comments from stakeholders without any
tangible progress being made. Generally, the scope of information to be pro-
vided is determined by the ownership (general
On 15 August 2022, the government issued meeting of shareholders) of the company rather
Decree 53/2022 (Decree 53), which took effect than the board of directors, even though it is not
from 1 October 2022 and guides the implemen- uncommon for the board to receive such power
tation of the Law on Cybersecurity, a piece of through delegation.
legislation that has been effective for almost four
years yet saw little to no practical implementa- 9.2 Data Privacy
tion until now. Among other things, Decree 53 Recent incidents involving the unlawful dis-
provides further details on the implementation of closure of personal information have certainly
the data localisation requirement, which states attracted the attention of both the public and
that both local and foreign companies (in data- the State. While the laws remain vague on com-
sensitive circumstances) providing telecommu- pliance in data privacy, with the draft regulations
nications services, internet services and value- being stuck in the legislative pipeline and there
added services in Vietnam’s cyberspace must being essentially no regulation on databases, the
store data related to the personal information of disclosure of personal information (for any rea-
Vietnamese people in Vietnam. How long local son, including due diligence) should be treated
companies, including foreign-invested compa- with great caution.
nies, must store such data in Vietnam remains
unclear. When obtaining personal data from customers,
technology companies should also obtain con-
sent from the customers for future disclosure
of the collected data, at least for due diligence
purposes. In addition, before disclosing informa-
tion for due diligence purposes, a binding non-

16 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

disclosure or confidentiality agreement should Upon SSC’s publication of its receipt of the bid-
be in place. der’s duly submitted dossiers, or an approval for
the bidder to issue additional shares for swap
with the target’s shares, the bidder must dis-
10. Disclosure close its approved prospectus on the websites
of the bidder, the tender offer agent and SSC.
10.1 Making a Bid Public
A bid is made public as per the bidder’s intention 10.2 Prospectus Requirements
– ie, voluntarily, or when the bidder falls into the A prospectus is required for the issuance of
categories that necessitate a mandatory tender shares in a stock-for-stock takeover offer or
offer. business combination.

Mandatory offer thresholds are only applicable The buyer’s shares need not be listed on a speci-
to public companies. Unless falling into excep- fied exchange in the home market or other iden-
tional cases, a tender offer (or bid public) is man- tified markets. The buyer’s shares can be those
datory when: of non-public companies (including a joint stock
company or a limited liability company).
• the acquisition results in the investor and their
related persons directly or indirectly owning 10.3 Producing Financial Statements
25% or more of the target’s voting shares; If bidders offer a cash consideration, they are not
• the acquisition results in the investor and required to produce financial statements in their
their related persons, who already own 25% disclosure documents.
or more of the target’s voting shares, now
directly or indirectly owning or exceeding If bidders intend to offer a share swap with
35%, 45%, 55%, 65%, 75% of the voting shares of unknown shareholders of the target,
shares; or they are required to submit:
• a bidder and their related persons, who have
just gained 80% or more (but not all) of the • the annual financial statements of the bid-
target’s voting shares from a tender offer, are der for the past two years, which must be
required under the law to reopen the tender audited by an approved auditor or, if the
offer to acquire the remaining voting shares latest one has not been audited in time, must
from existing shareholders within 30 days of be accompanied by two other annual audited
the previous tender offer, with the same terms financial statements of the two preceding
and conditions as the initial one. years; and
• the latest annual financial statement of the
A bid is first made public at the registration target, audited by an approved auditor.
stage, where a bidder must submit an applica-
tion dossier to the target and SSC, which must Financial statements must be prepared under
then publish their receipt of the dossiers on their the form of Vietnamese Accounting Standards
websites. (VAS).

17 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

10.4 Disclosure of Transaction 11.2 Special or Ad Hoc Committees


Documents It is not common for the BOM to establish spe-
No transaction documents are required to be cial or ad hoc committees in business combina-
disclosed in full. However, bidders must disclose tions. The BOM itself or the established com-
the main terms of the offer in the prospectus or mittees under the BOM – such as the strategy
registration form, including bid price, bid size, and investment committee – will handle relevant
sources of funding and the purposes of the offer. works in business combinations directly.

11.3 Board’s Role


11. Duties of Directors The board can be involved in negotiations, or
can defend the company in a proposed trans-
11.1 Principal Directors’ Duties action. However, the final prospectus or share
In general, Board of Management (BOM) mem- issuance plan must be approved by the GMS.
bers and managers bear the following principal
and fiduciary duties: It is uncommon to have shareholder litigation
challenging the board’s decision to recommend
• a duty to perform the delegated rights and an M&A transaction. Under the law, sharehold-
obligations in accordance with the law, the ers holding at least 1% of the company’s total
company’s constitutional document and the ordinary shares can only make a lawsuit against
GMS’ resolutions; BOM members or the director/general director
• a duty to exercise reasonable care, skill and to request the return of benefits damage com-
diligence to ensure the maximisation of the pensation if there have been breaches of fiduci-
company’s legitimate interests; ary duties and other violations. As such, there is
• a duty of loyalty to the interests of the com- no ground for shareholders to initiate litigation
pany and shareholders as a whole; and to challenge the board’s decision, unless such
• a duty of honesty to avoid conflicts of inter- decision shows a breach of fiduciary duties by
est. BOM members or the director/general director,
or violates the law or the company’s charter.
In a business combination, the above duties shall
also be applied to BOM members and manag- 11.4 Independent Outside Advice
ers when preparing a proposal for the transac- The BOM usually seeks independent legal, finan-
tion to be submitted to the GMS for approval, or cial, tax and commercial advice in relation to a
when implementing the transaction afterwards. takeover or a business combination. It is com-
In practice, the duty to exercise reasonable care, mon for a financial adviser or investment bank
skill and diligence may be deemed to have been to provide a fairness opinion to the seller’s BOM.
fulfilled by, among others, the director having
sought qualified professional services to help
them make well-considered decisions.

18 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

LNT & Partners is a major full-service inde- infrastructure and finance, as well as handling
pendent Vietnam law firm. The team is made up complex and high-profile litigation and arbitra-
of more than 70 highly qualified professionals, tion matters. With sound understanding of cor-
and clients include Fortune Global 500 com- porate and M&A in Vietnam, the firm’s corporate
panies as well as renowned Vietnamese listed advisory team provides expert corporate advice
companies. The firm provides advisory and and support to both listed and private compa-
transactional work in the areas of corporate and nies.
M&A, competition, pharmaceutical, real estate,

Authors
Hong Bui is a partner of LNT & Tri Tran is an associate of LNT &
Partners, and co-leads the firm’s Partners and a member of the
corporate and M&A practice corporate and M&A practice
group. He aids foreign investors group. Having practised law
in their commercial objectives in since 2018, focusing on the
all aspects of investment in corporate and M&A areas, Tri
Vietnam. Hong is sought for advice on M&A, has assisted in many M&A transactions for
joint ventures, deal structuring, company multinational companies and investors. He also
restructuring, contractual matters, advises clients on antitrust and tech-related
employment, corporate investigation and legal aspects. Before joining LNT & Partners,
dispute settlement. His experience includes Tri earned his LL.B. from Ho Chi Minh
the legal areas of manufacturing, trading and University of Law and spent two years working
retail, insurance, fintech, logistics, education, at another top-tier law firm.
media, healthcare and pharmaceuticals. He is
a regular speaker at conferences and seminars
on foreign investment, M&A and restructuring, Thi Bui is an associate at LNT &
contracts, employment and dispute settlement Partners and a member of the
in Vietnam. corporate and M&A practice
group. She advises clients on
corporate, M&A, commercial,
antitrust and contractual
matters. She has assisted clients in various
industries, including fintech, FMCG,
manufacturing, trading, logistics, healthcare
and pharmaceuticals. Thi earned her LL.B.
from University of Economics and Law,
Vietnam.

19 CHAMBERS.COM
VIETNAM Law and Practice
Contributed by: Hong Bui, Tri Tran and Thi Bui, LNT & Partners

LNT & Partners


Levels 21, Bitexco Financial Tower
2 Hai Trieu Street, District 1
Ho Chi Minh City
Vietnam

Tel: +84 28 3821 2357


Fax: +84 28 3910 3733
Email: hong.bui@lntpartners.com
Web: www.lntpartners.com

20 CHAMBERS.COM
CHAMBERS GLOBAL PRACTICE GUIDES

Chambers Global Practice Guides bring you up-to-date, expert legal


commentary on the main practice areas from around the globe.
Focusing on the practical legal issues affecting businesses, the
guides enable readers to compare legislation and procedure and
read trend forecasts from legal experts from across key jurisdictions.

To find out more information about how we select contributors,


email Katie.Burrington@chambers.com

You might also like