Factors Underlying Cialdini's Six Principles

23.06.
2023, 08:21 Factors Underlying Cialdini's Six Principles
How we change what others think, feel, believe and do
| Menu | Quick | Books | Share | Search | Settings |
Factors Underlying Cialdini's Six Principles

Techniques > General persuasion > Cialdini's Six Principles > Factors Underlying Cialdini's Six Principles
Common forces | Principles | Summary | See also

Robert Cialdini's six principles of influence are long established and widely used. However, it is
possible to dig deeper into these and look for factors and needs on which these are based. This
gives another lens to understand them and also a way to explore further principles of persuasion.
Common forces
Underlying Cialdini's principles are common human forces that act on us and drive how we think
and behave. In particular, we have deep needs that drive us and much of what we do is intended
to either satisfy these needs or avoid the discomfort felt when the needs are negatively affected.
The following factors were hence derived by looking backwards from the six principles to basic
needs, in particular through the lens of the CIA Needs Model, and triangulating on social factors
that seem to be of particular significance. They can be further grouped into three sets:
Control and identity as key underlying needs

Social dependence, conformance and comparison as critical social forces that affect multiple
principles
Trust as key factor within several principles
Control: The need to understand and predict

The need for a sense of control leads us to seek to understand the world around us through the
development and adoption of beliefs and models that help to explain how the world works. With
this knowledge, we can predict the future, and what we can do to change things.
When predictions and consequent expectations are not met, we feel cognitive dissonance and a
loss of control.
Social dependence
We do not have time to learn everything through experience (which may also be hazardous). We
also may lack the power to effect control by ourselves.
We hence depend on others for knowledge and support. This provides a key lever that is used in
influence. For example, disturbing a person's sense of control creates fear of harm and leads
them to seek help.
Identity: Our sense of who we are

We all have a need for a sense of identity, which includes our beliefs and models about ourselves
and the values we believe we follow. We also see ourselves through the eyes of others, as well as
the groups to which we belong, along with the esteem given to us by others and our consequent
social status. In this way, we socially construct our selves.
When there is a lack of alignment between these factors, we feel dissonance and a confusion of
identity.
https://changingminds.org/techniques/general/cialdini/underlying_factors.htm 1/9
23.06.2023, 08:21 Factors Underlying Cialdini's Six Principles
Social conformance
Evolution has taught us that living in groups with others is more effective than living alone.
However, for groups to survive, we must cede control and follow the rules of social norms in order
to sustain membership.
Key social rules include those for fairness (including helping the vulnerable and repaying debts)
and obedience.
When people do not follow these rules, they create a sense of betrayal and may well be punished,
for example by being socially criticized or ostracized. This leads to a loss of identity, which is so
horrifying a thought, most people work hard to stay within social rules.
While we may prefer the control given by independence, there are situations where conformance
becomes more important. Some persuasive methods act to increase pressure to conform to rules
that the persuader implies are critical.
Social comparison
We identify our position in society and hence our sense of identity by comparing ourselves with
others.
In this comparison, we decide whether we are cleverer, superior or otherwise better than other
people. This affects both our sense of identity (eg. I am higher status) and our sense of control
(eg. I can command rather than obey).
Trust
One of the key factors that enables us to work with others is trust, which is a great social
lubricant and reduces transaction cost.
We trust people who are honest, reliable, fair and caring. But in the short term we have little
evidence for this, so we base decisions on similarity, including similarity to ourselves and
similarity to other people we trust, from friends to people in authority.
Principles
Reciprocity
Principle: We feel obliged to give back to people who have given to us.
Factors: obligation, fairness, trust, social conformance
Needs: identity, control, belonging
Reciprocity is based on the social conformance of obligation, the requirement to fulfil the promises
that we make and the duties that social norms dictate.
Reciprocity is also driven by the common social norm of fairness, that in living together, we
practice equality, where each has the same share. Hence if you give me something, I feel obliged
to give you something in return.
Consistency
Principle: We seek to align what we do, say, think, and believe
Factors: models, alignment, social conformance
Needs: control, predictability, identity, belonging
If we act in ways that do not align with our sense of identity, then we feel conflicted and out of
sorts. We may think 'I am the sort of person who does not...' and when we actually do it, we feel
the inner tension of dissonance.
This leads us to try and keep our inner system in alignment with what we do. We cannot change
the past, so we may feel we should change what we think about ourselves.
We also seek to conform with social norms and align with explicit expectations. In this, it can
seem better to change how we think and who we are rather than face the wrath resulting from
social non-conformance.
Social Proof
Principle: We copy what others do, especially when we are unsure
Factors: control, confusion, social dependence, identity, social conformance
Needs: identity, belonging, control
We build our sense of control through models and patterns, many of which we get from other
people. When we are not sure about something, it is natural to turn to others to see things from
their viewpoint. We hence become more dependent on others in situations of uncertainty.
Our sense of identity is tightly connected with others and conformance to social norms. When we
are uncertain we fear that we might act in ways that leads to social criticism. This also acts to
Liking
Principle: We tend to agree with people we like
Factors: trust, similarity, social conformance
Needs: identity, connection
Within social systems we build closer social ties with people we like as we create the closer
relationships of friendship. A key element of this is the value of trust in reducing transaction cost.
In the short term, we use similarity (to us or people we trust) to assess the likeability of people,
along with indications that they mean no harm and may actively help us. This is used in influence
by people who smile and act in friendly ways before making their requests.
Authority
Principle: We must agree with, and do what we are told by those in authority
Factors: social conformance, trust, social dependence
Needs: control
A benefit of society is division of work, where individuals can develop deep skills in certain areas.
This means depending on others who are more knowledgeable than us in other fields. We hence
learn to defer to experts.
Another aspect of society is hierarchies of control, where people higher up the chain of command
must be obeyed by those lower down. Again, we conform with
We identify authorities by indicators including their dress, attitude and speech. These factors are
often used by people who seek to create the appearance of authority in order to influence others.
Scarcity
Principle: We want what we might not be able to get in future
Factors: control, social comparison
Needs: control, identity
When we have the opportunity to acquire something, we consider both current and future need. If
we do not need it now, we consider future availability and experience anticipated regret should it
not be available. This discomfort can lead us to seeking to acquire the item, even if we are unsure
if we will ever need it.
We also consider the scenario of other people having the item when we do not and the
consequent status impact. The though of this social imbalance can amplify our desire to acquire.
Summary
We can now compare the impact of needs and social factors on Cialdini's influence factors (by
simple observation).
Inner needs
In the table below, the number of 'X's indicate the perceived strength of the factors identified.
Principle Control Identity

Reciprocity X XX
Consistency X XXX
Social proof XXX
Liking XXX
Authority XXX
Scarcity XXX XX

There seems a roughly even amount of influence of the need for control and for identity across
the six principles, although these are divided such that:
Reciprocity, consistency and liking are more identity based.

Social proof, authority and scarcity are based more in the need for a sense of control.
Social forces
In the table below, the number of 'X's indicate the perceived strength of the factors identified.
Principle Dependence Conformance Comparison Trust

Reciprocity XXX XX
Consistency XX XX
Social proof XXX XXX XX
Liking XX XX XXX
Authority XXX XXX XX
Scarcity XXX

Here, there is also spread of factors across the principles. Observed similarities include:
Social proof and authority seem similar in their use of dependence, conformance and trust.
Reciprocity and liking are similar in their use of conformance and trust, although liking
includes some comparison.
Consistency and liking are similar in the use of conformance and comparison, although liking
has an additional trust component.
Scarcity is unique in being based firmly in social comparison (it can also have a significant
non-social element).
Other notes include:
Social dependence appears as significant only in two principles, but is highly important in
these.
Social conformance is common and often important in five out of the six principles, and
hence appears to be the most important factor.
Social comparison appears in half the principles and is hence important, though not the most
important factor.
Trust slightly different, in being a precursor to agreement, but seems very important in four
out of the six principles.
Other factors
Other factors that may affect how we are influenced include:
Self-image: If we define ourselves more internally than through others, then the social
power of Cialdini's methods is reduced.
Self-awareness: When we see ourselves being influenced, we may consciously block this
effect.
Concern for the views of others: How significantly we are concerned about what others think
will change how we decide.
In other words, the power of Cialdini's methods, while well-proven in the general case, may vary
significantly in efficacy across individuals, particularly where they are less influenced by other
people in their decisions. This can happen when they are more rational in their thinking and
where they are more self-oriented.
See also
Beliefs, Values, Needs, Models, Motivation, Personality

Cialdini, R. (1984). Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion, New York: Quill

Note: This article is a reasoned analysis based on experience, reading and understanding. It is not intended as an
academic paper. If you are interested exploring further in this area, please do contact the author.
Site Menu
| Home | Top | Quick Links | Settings |
Main sections: | Disciplines | Techniques | Principles | Explanations | Theories |
Other sections: | Blog! | Quotes | Guest articles | Analysis | Books | Help |
More pages: | Contact | Caveat | About | Students | Webmasters | Awards | Guestbook |

Feedback | Sitemap | Changes |
Settings: | Computer layout | Mobile layout | Small font | Medium font | Large font | Translate |
Search

You can buy books here
More Kindle books:
And the big

paperback book
Look inside
Please help and share:
Quick links
Disciplines Principles
* Argument * Principles
* Brand management
Explanations
* Change Management
* Coaching * Behaviors
* Communication * Beliefs
* Counseling * Brain stuff
* Game Design * Conditioning
* Human Resources * Coping Mechanisms
* Job-finding * Critical Theory
* Leadership * Culture
* Marketing * Decisions
* Politics * Emotions
* Propaganda * Evolution
* Rhetoric * Gender
* Negotiation * Games
* Psychoanalysis * Groups
* Sales * Habit
* Sociology * Identity
* Storytelling * Learning
* Teaching * Meaning
* Warfare * Memory
* Workplace design * Motivation
* Models
Techniques
* Needs
* Assertiveness * Personality
* Body language * Power
* Change techniques * Preferences
* Closing techniques * Research
* Conversation * Relationships
* Confidence tricks * SIFT Model
* Conversion * Social Research
* Creative techniques * Stress
* General techniques * Trust
* Happiness * Values
* Hypnotism
* Interrogation Theories
* Language * Alphabetic list
* Listening * Theory types
* Negotiation tactics
And
* Objection handling
* Propaganda – About
* Problem-solving – Guest Articles
* Public speaking – Blog!
* Questioning – Books
* Using repetition – Changes
* Resisting persuasion – Contact
* Self-development – Guestbook
* Sequential requests – Quotes
* Storytelling – Students
* Stress Management – Webmasters
* Tipping
* Using humor
* Willpower
| Home | Top | Menu | Quick Links |
Выбрать язык
Технологии Переводчик
Search
© Changing Works 2002-2023
Massive Content — Maximum Speed
Site Menu
| Home | Top | Quick Links | Settings |
Main sections: | Disciplines | Techniques | Principles | Explanations | Theories |
Other sections: | Blog! | Quotes | Guest articles | Analysis | Books | Help |
More pages: | Contact | Caveat | About | Students | Webmasters | Awards | Guestbook |

Feedback | Sitemap | Changes |
Settings: | Computer layout | Mobile layout | Small font | Medium font | Large font | Translate |
Search

Please help and share:
Quick links
Disciplines Principles
* Argument + Principles
* Brand management
Explanations
* Change Management
* Coaching * Behaviors
* Communication * Beliefs
* Counseling * Brain stuff
* Game Design * Conditioning
* Human Resources * Coping Mechanisms
* Job-finding * Critical Theory
* Leadership * Culture
* Marketing * Decisions
* Politics * Emotions
* Propaganda * Evolution
* Rhetoric * Gender
* Negotiation * Games
* Psychoanalysis * Groups
* Sales * Habit
* Sociology * Identity
* Storytelling * Learning
* Teaching * Meaning
* Warfare * Memory
* Workplace design * Motivation
* Models
Techniques * Needs
* Assertiveness * Personality
* Body language * Power
* Change techniques * Preferences
* Closing techniques * Research
* Conversation * Relationships
* Confidence tricks * SIFT Model
* Conversion * Social Research
* Creative techniques * Stress
* General techniques * Trust
* Happiness * Values
* Hypnotism
Theories
* Interrogation
* Language * Alphabetic list
* Listening * Theory types
* Negotiation tactics And

* Objection handling
– About
* Propaganda
– Guest Articles
* Problem-solving
– Blog!
* Public speaking
– Books
* Questioning
– Changes
* Using repetition
– Contact
* Resisting persuasion
– Guestbook
* Self-development
– Quotes
* Sequential requests
– Students
* Storytelling
– Webmasters
* Stress Management
* Tipping
* Using humor
* Willpower
| Home | Top | Menu | Quick Links |
Search
© Changing Works 2002-2023
Massive Content — Maximum Speed

Factors Underlying Cialdini&#39;s Six Principles

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Factors Underlying Cialdini&#39;s Six Principles

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

23.06.

2023, 08:21 Factors Underlying Cialdini's Six Principles

How we change what others think, feel, believe and do

| Menu | Quick | Books | Share | Search | Settings |