Professional Documents
Culture Documents
12 Efficacy
12 Efficacy
Abstract
This open-label randomized study compared the effects of two combined oral contraceptives (OCs) containing 3 mg drospirenone
(DRSP)/30 lg ethinyl estradiol (EE) with 150 lg levonorgestrel (LNG)/30 lg EE on the prevalence and changes from baseline of
premenstrual symptoms after six cycles. The symptoms were measured using the Women’s Health Assessment Questionnaire. Subjects
receiving DRSP/EE had fewer prevalence of premenstrual symptoms than those receiving LNG/EE after six cycles. A significantly lower
score of negative affect category in the premenstrual phase was demonstrated in those receiving DRSP/EE more than LNG/EE. The DRSP/
EE group showed a greater improvement of mean scores from baseline in the premenstrual phase compared with those who received LNG/
EE on negative affect as seen in the items on anxiety, irritability, feeling sad or blue and weight gain in the category of water retention. In
conclusion, OCs containing DRSP have beneficial effects in reducing the prevalence of premenstrual symptoms especially the symptoms of
negative affect and weight gain, particularly when compared to LNG/EE. Hence, it should be recommended for women who are susceptible
to these adverse symptoms.
D 2005 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Oral contraceptive; Drospirenone; Levonorgestrel; Premenstrual symptoms
study, we chose an OC containing LNG which is widely cycles by using the Women’s Health Assessment Question-
used in Thailand to compare to an OC containing DRSP naire (WHAQ), which was a subset of items selected from
regarding premenstrual symptoms. the Menstrual Distress Questionnaire [2,5,6]. The WHAQ
The primary objective of this study was to compare the was translated from English to Thai and tested for reliability
prevalence of premenstrual symptoms at six cycles in those with a Cronbach’s a of .80. This self-report questionnaire
who used EE 30 lg and DRSP 3 mg (DRSP/EE) with EE 30 included six categories that contained a total of 23 items.
lg and levonorgestrel 150 lg (LNG/EE) as a contraceptive The six categories composed of three main categories, that
method. is, negative affect, water retention, impaired concentration,
The secondary objective was to compare the effect of and another three additional categories, that is, increased
both preparations on premenstrual symptoms at six cycles appetite, feelings of well-being, and undesirable hair
after treatment. changes. The negative affect category contained eight items,
the water retention category contained four items and the
impaired concentration category contained eight items, as
2. Materials and methods shown in Table 1. Each item was graded using a five-point
2.1. Study design and population scale from 0 to 4 (0 = absent, 1= mild, 2 = moderate,
3 = strong, 4= severe/very strong). The WHAQ assessed
This study was an open-label, randomized, comparative the patient symptoms at three different phases of menstru-
study performed at the family planning clinic of King ation, premenstrual (4 days before menstrual flow), men-
Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital, Bangkok, Thailand, strual (during menstrual flow), and postmenstrual (the
from February to September 2003. The study protocol was remainder of the cycle) phases.
approved by the Ethics Committee of the Faculty of The primary measured outcome was the prevalence of
Medicine, Chulalongkorn University. premenstrual symptoms at cycle 6, which was determined by
One-hundred and four women who were willing to take subjects who had symptoms in the premenstrual phase which
oral OC pills for contraception were randomly assigned to disappeared during their menstrual and postmenstrual
two groups: one used the preparation of EE 30 lg and phases. Secondary measured outcomes were the mean scores
DRSP 3 mg, and the other used the preparation of EE 30 lg and the mean score changes from baseline of WHAQ
and LNG 150 lg. categories (mean of the difference between the score at
The inclusion criteria included women who were of baseline and at cycle 6) between the two OC preparations.
child-bearing age (18–35 years), who requested OCs for at
least six cycles (both new users and switchers) and had 2.3. Statistical analysis
regular menstrual cycles lasting between 21 and 35 days, as Descriptive statistics (mean, SD, percentage) were used
well as had not used an injectable hormonal contraceptive to analyze the demographic data. The prevalence of
within 6 months or an OC within 3 months before the study. premenstrual symptoms at cycle 6 between each preparation
Women who previously used implantable contraceptives or was compared by chi-square test. We compared mean
intrauterine devices had to have three consecutive normal WHAQ scores and mean WHAQ score changes from
menstrual cycles after these contraceptives were removed. baseline after using either preparation at cycle 6 by
Post-abortion and postpartum patients were eligible if they
had had three consecutive menstrual cycles before the study.
The exclusion criteria included women who were Table 1
pregnant or suspected of being pregnant, who were breast- WHAQ (six categories, total 23 items)
feeding, who smoked and who were contraindicated for Negative Water Impaired Three
using OCs according to WHO categories 2, 3 and 4 [26]. affect (8) retention (4) concentration (8) additional
All subjects were required to sign written informed categories
consent forms before being recruited into the study. Loneliness Weight gain Insomnia Increased
appetite
2.2. Study protocol and data collection Anxiety Painful or Forgetfulness Feelings of
tender breasts well-being
Subjects who met the study criteria were randomly given Mood swings Breast and Confusion Undesirable
a blister pack which contained 21 tablets of either 3 mg abdominal hair changes
DRSP/30 lg EE or 150 lg LNG/30 lg EE for six cycles. swelling
They were instructed to take one tablet a day from the first Crying Skin blemishes Poor judgment
or disorders
day of their menstruation for 21 consecutive days followed
Irritability Difficulty
by a 7-day pill-free interval. The recommended dosing concentrating
interval was not longer than 24 h. Compliance was assessed Tension Distractibility
by pill count from the blister packs. Feeling sad Poor motor
Both groups of subjects were evaluated on the premen- or blue coordination
Restlessness Minor accidents
strual symptoms at baseline and at the end of six menstrual
M. Sangthawan, S. Taneepanichskul / Contraception 71 (2005) 1–7 3
Table 4
Mean WHAQ scores of premenstrual, menstrual and postmenstrual phases at baseline and cycle 6
Categories Baseline Cycle 6
DRSP/EE LNG/EE p-value 95% CI DRSP/EE LNG/EE p-value 95% CI
Premenstrual phase
Negative affecta 4.5F4.7 4.5F3.8 .926 1.80, 1.64 2.5F3.3 4.2F4.9 .046a 3.39, 0.03
Water retention 2.8F2.7 3.0F2.2 .722 1.16, 0.81 1.9F2.3 2.1F2.0 .551 1.13, 0.60
Impaired concentration 3.3F4.3 4.0F4.0 .404 2.38, 0.96 1.9F3.2 3.2F4.1 .083 2.78, 0.17
Well-being 1.4F0.8 1.7F1.1 .129 0.70, 0.09 1.8F0.9 2.0F1.0 .335 0.60, 0.20
Increased appetite 1.3F1.2 1.2F1.0 .636 0.34, 0.55 1.2F1.2 1.2F1.2 .779 0.55, 0.41
Undesirable hair change 0.2F0.5 0.2F0.6 .807 0.27, 0.21 0.3F0.8 0.5F1.0 .287 0.56, 0.17
Menstrual phase
Negative affect 3.7F4.0 4.8F3.9 .147 2.76, 0.42 2.6F3.5 3.8F4.9 .175 2.87, 0.53
Water retention 2.0F1.9 2.5F2.0 .241 1.26, 0.32 1.8F2.2 1.6F1.6 .619 0.56, 0.95
Impaired concentration 2.9F3.5 4.1F3.3 .108 2.49, 0.25 2.2F2.9 3.2F4.1 .153 2.45, 0.38
Well-being 1.3F0.9 1.6F1.1 .081 0.76, 0.04 1.9F1.0 2.2F1.1 .155 0.72, 0.11
Increased appetite 0.9F0.9 1.0F0.9 .406 0.54, 0.22 0.9F1.0 1.1F1.6 .347 0.80, 0.28
Undesirable hair change 0.3F0.5 0.2F0.5 .666 0.18, 0.28 0.3F0.7 0.4F1.0 .395 0.52, 0.20
Postmenstrual phase
Negative affect 1.9F3.0 2.8F3.3 .115 2.28, 0.25 1.6F2.7 2.2F3.7 .296 1.95, 0.61
Water retention 1.0F1.8 1.7F2.2 .062 1.55, 0.04 1.2F2.0 1.3F1.5 .886 0.76, 0.65
Impaired concentration 2.0F2.5 3.2F3.7 .052 2.46, 0.01 1.4F2.4 2.2F3.4 .172 1.98, 0.36
Well-being 1.8F0.9 2.0F1.2 .410 0.59, 0.24 2.2F1.1 2.6F1.1 .077 0.83, 0.04
Increased appetite 0.5F0.7 0.7F0.9 .070 0.64, 0.03 0.7F1.0 0.8F1.0 .675 0.50, 0.32
Undesirable hair change 0.2F0.5 0.3F0.7 .390 0.36, 0.15 0.2F0.7 0.5F1.0 .150 0.60, 0.09
a
Statistically significant difference at cycle 6.
4 M. Sangthawan, S. Taneepanichskul / Contraception 71 (2005) 1–7
4. Discussion
The prevalence of premenstrual symptoms at baseline of
both groups was about 60%, this is in corroboration with
previous studies [1– 4]. This study demonstrated that DRSP/
EE OC reduced the prevalence of premenstrual symptoms
by half whereas LNG/EE OC did not alter the prevalence of
premenstrual symptoms at cycle 6. Foidart et al. [27] studied
Fig. 1. Mean score changes from baseline of six categories in premenstrual, Fig. 3. Mean score changes from baseline in items of water retention
menstrual and postmenstrual phases. category of premenstrual phase.
M. Sangthawan, S. Taneepanichskul / Contraception 71 (2005) 1–7 5
Fig. 4. Mean score changes from baseline in items of impaired concentration category of premenstrual phase.
the incidence of premenstrual symptoms by comparing generation progestogens such as LNG or desogestrel on
DRSP/EE with an OC containing desogestrel for 26 cycles the decrement of premenstrual symptoms prevalence.
and reported that the incidence of premenstrual symptoms Significant improvements of mean scores and changes
prior to treatment was higher in the DRSP/EE group, but from baseline scores were revealed with DRSP/EE com-
became lower during treatment than OC containing des- pared to LNG/EE only in negative affect during the
ogestrel (18% vs. 20%). These results showed the consistent premenstrual phase, on items of anxiety, irritability and
benefit of DRSP/EE OC over other second- or third- feeling sad or blue. Numerous hypotheses have been
proposed to explain the mechanisms of mood, behavioral
or psychological changes in the premenstrual phase of the
cycle, as related to neurotransmitters (i.e., serotonin,
endogenous opioids, c-aminobutyric acid, cathecho-
lamines), fluctuation of female hormones, testosterone, etc.
[7,28 –32]. However, these mechanisms are not yet clear.
Progesterone is known to exert direct sedative effect on the
central nervous system, as reflected in slowing electroen-
cephalogram in humans and alteration of arousal threshold
stimuli in the hypothalamus of various animals [7,29]. Thus,
its deficiency would increase nervous excitability, irritabil-
ity, tension, anxiety and aggression. The possible reason on
the benefits to negative affect of DRSP may be due to the
similarity of DRSP to progesterone on these effects rather
than LNG. Some investigators have demonstrated abnor-
mally elevated plasma testosterone in women with premen-
strual symptoms and aggression [31,33]. Therefore, it was
possible that the improvement of negative affect in women
who were receiving DRSP compared to those receiving
LNG was related to the antiandrogenic property of DRSP.
Fig. 5. Mean score changes from baseline in categories of feelings of well-
Weight gain in the category of water retention was only
being, increased appetite and undesirable hair change of premenstrual significantly decreased from baseline in DRSP/EE than
phase. LNG/EE during the premenstrual phase while the effect that
6 M. Sangthawan, S. Taneepanichskul / Contraception 71 (2005) 1–7
[23] Parsey KS, Pong A. An open-label, multicenter study to evaluate [32] Woods NF, Lentz MJ, Mitchell ES, Shaver J, Heitkemper M. Luteal
Yasmin, a low-dose combination oral contraceptive containing phase ovarian steroids, stress arousal, premenses perceived stress and
drospirenone, a new progestogen. Contraception 2000;60:105 – 11. premenstrual symptoms. Res Nurs Health 1998;21:129 – 42.
[24] Apter D, Borsos A, Baumgartner W, et al. Effect of an oral [33] Eriksson E, Sundblad C, Lisjo P, Modigh K, Anderson B. Serum
contraceptive containing drospirenone and ethinyl estradiol on general levels of androgens are higher in women with premenstrual irritability
well-being and fluid-related symptoms. Eur J Contracept Reprod and dysphoria than in controls. Psychoneuroendocrinology
Health Care 2003;8:1 – 15. 1992;17:195 – 204.
[25] Freeman EW, Kroll R, Rapkin A, et al. Evaluation of a unique oral [34] Bisson DL, Dunster GD, O’Hare JP, Hamptom D, Penney MD. Renal
contraceptive in the treatment of premenstrual dysphoric disorder. J sodium retention does not occur during the luteal phase of the
Womens Health Gend Based Med 2001;10:561 – 9. menstrual cycle in normal women. Br J Obstet Gynaecol
[26] World Health Organization. Improving access to quality care in family 1992;99:247 – 52.
planning. Medical eligibility criteria for contraceptive use methods. [35] Janowsky DS, Berens SC, Davis JM. Correlations between mood,
Geneva7 World Health Organization; 1996. weight, and electrolytes during the menstrual cycle: a renin–
[27] Foidart J-M, Wuttke W, Bouw GM, Gerlinger C, Heithecker R. A angiotensin aldosterone hypothesis of premenstrual tension. Psycho-
comparative investigation of contraceptive reliability, cycle control som Med 1973;35:143 – 54.
and tolerance of two monophasic oral contraceptives containing either [36] Chesley LC, Hellman LM. Variations in body weight and salivary
drospirenone or desogestrel. Eur J Contracept Reprod Health Care sodium in menstrual cycle. Am J Obstet Gynecol 1957;74:582 – 90.
2000;5:124 – 34. [37] O’Brien PMS, Selby C, Symonds EM. Progesterone, fluid and
[28] Mortola JF. Issues in the diagnosis and research of premenstrual electrolytes in premenstrual syndrome. Br J Med 1980;280:
syndrome. Clin Obstet Gynecol 1992;35:587 – 98. 1161 – 3.
[29] Kane FJ, Daly RJ, Ewing JA, Keeler MH. Mood and behavioral [38] Olson BR, Forman MR, Lanza E, et al. Relation between sodium
changes with progestational agents. Br J Psychiatry 1967;113:265 – 8. balance and menstrual cycle symptoms in normal women. Ann Intern
[30] Tuiten A, Panhuysen G, Koppeschaar H, et al. Stress, serotonergic Med 1996;125:564 – 7.
function, and mood in user of oral contraceptives. Psychoneuroen- [39] Borenstein J, Yu H-T, Wade S, Chiou C-F, Rapkin A. Effect of an oral
docrinology 1995;20:323 – 34. contraceptive containing ethinyl estradiol and drospirenone on
[31] Dougherty DM, Bjork JM, Moeller G, Swann AC. The influence of premenstrual symptomatology and health-related quality of life. J
menstrual-cycle phase on the relationship between testosterone and Reprod Med 2003;48:79 – 85.
aggression. Physiol Behav 1997;62:431 – 5.