Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 12

Vol. 117 No.

6 June 2014

Multiple simple bone cysts of the Jaws: Review of the literature


and report of three cases
Seo-Young An, DDS, MS,a,1 Jae-Seo Lee, DDS, PhD,b,1 Erika Benavides, DDS, PhD,c Alireza Aminlari, DDS, MS,d
Neville J. McDonald, DDS, MS,e Paul C. Edwards, MSc, DDS,f Min-Suk Heo, DDS, PhD,g
Hong-In Shin, DDS, PhD,h Jin-Woo Park, DDS, PhD,i Jae-Kwang Jung, DDS, MS,j Karp-Shik Choi, DDS, PhD,k
and Chang-Hyeon An, DDS, PhDl

Objectives. This study contributes three well-documented cases of multiple simple bone cysts (SBCs) of the jaws and reviews
previously published cases.
Study Design. A comprehensive literature search of multiple SBCs was conducted using the PubMed database. Synonyms of
SBC were used as search key words in combination with “mandible or jaw,” “bilateral, multiple, multifocal, atypical, and
unusual.”
Results. A total of 34 cases of multiple SBCs (including two asynchronous cases) were identified, including the three new
cases reported here. Multiple SBCs primarily occurred in the second decade (52.9%) and bilaterally in the posterior mandible.
Lesions demonstrated female predominance (1.8:1) and were frequently accompanied by bony expansion (44.1%) and a
multilocular radiolucent appearance (20.6 %). Recurrence was reported in three patients (mean age: 39.3 years old).
Conclusion. Knowledge of the clinical and radiographic features of multiple SBCs is important in the diagnosis and
management of this entity. (Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol 2014;117:e458-e469)

Financial support: This research was supported by Kyungpook First referred to as traumatic bone cysts by Lucas,1
National University Research Fund, 2012. the simple bone cyst (SBC) is a single bone cavity,
1
These authors contributed equally to this paper.
a
Assistant Professor, Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radi-
generally fluid-filled, lacking epithelial lining.2 In
ology, School of Dentistry, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, 1947, Hansen et al. suggested that the term SBC should
Republic of Korea. be restricted to those cases presenting as an empty
cavity that might contain some fluid and/or small
b
Assistant Professor, Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radi-
ology, School of Dentistry, Dental Science Institute, Chonnam amounts of soft tissue occasionally.3 Since it lacks
National University, Gwangju, Republic of Korea.
c
Clinical Assistant Professor, Department of Periodontics and Oral
epithelial lining, the SBC is not a true cyst. In addition
Medicine, School of Dentistry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, to the term simple bone cyst,4 a variety of other de-
MI, USA. scriptors have been used for this entity, including
traumatic bone cyst,3 hemorrhagic bone cyst,5 solitary
d
Adjunct Lecturer, Division of Endodontics, University of Michigan,
Ann Arbor, Michigan and Specialist Endodontic Private Practice, bone cyst,6 idiopathic bone cyst,7 extravasation
Farmington Hills, Michigan, USA.
e
Clinical Professor, Division Head and Graduate Program Director,
cyst,8 progressive bone cavity,9 and unicameral bone
Endodontics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA. cyst.10
f
Professor, Department of Oral Pathology, Medicine and Radiology, While most SBCs present as solitary lesions, in one
Indiana University School of Dentistry, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA.
g
review of the literature,11 Eleven percent of SBCs
Professor, Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology and presented as multifocal lesions, with the first case being
Dental Research Institute, School of Dentistry, Seoul National Uni-
versity, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
described by Hankey12 in 1947.
h
Associate Professor, Department of Oral Pathology, School In the present study, we systematically reviewed all
of Dentistry, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, Republic of previously recorded cases of multiple SBCs of the jaws
Korea. and described three additional cases of multiple SBCs
i
Assistant Professor, Department of Periodontology, School affecting the mandible that were evaluated by cone-
of Dentistry, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, Republic of
Korea.
beam computed tomography (CBCT).
j
Assistant Professor, Department of Oral Medicine, School
of Dentistry, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, Republic of MATERIAL AND METHODS
Korea. The present study was based on a literature search of
k
Professor, Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, School
articles published in English, conducted using PubMed,
of Dentistry, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, Republic of
Korea. a database created by the National Center for Biotech-
l
Associate Professor, Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radi- nology Information (NCBI:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.
ology, School of Dentistry, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, gov/). The term “simple bone cyst” and its synonyms
Republic of Korea. (traumatic bone cyst, haemorrhagic/hemorrhagic bone
Received for publication Dec 9, 2013; returned for revision Feb 18, cyst, solitary bone cyst, idiopathic bone cyst/cavity,
2014; accepted for publication Mar 9, 2014.
Ó 2014 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. extravasation cyst, progressive bone cavity, and uni-
2212-4403/$ - see front matter cameral bone cyst) were searched in combination with
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.oooo.2014.03.004 “maxilla or mandible or jaw” and “bilateral, multiple,

e458
OOOO CASE REPORT
Volume 117, Number 6 An et al. e459

multifocal, atypical, and unusual.” Multiple SBCs observed in 15 patients (44.1%). A multilocular radio-
associated with florid osseous dysplasia and cases with graphic presentation was noted in seven patients
solitary and large SBC misusing “bilateral” in their title (20.6%), five of whom also presented with bony
were excluded. The parameters that were examined and expansion. Four of six multiple SBCs involving the
collected are: Patient demographic, clinical, and radio- mandibular ramus area revealed both a multilocular
graphic data, including age, gender, chief complaint at pattern and bony expansion. Multiple SBCs occurred
presentation, history of trauma, vitality of the involved asynchronously in two patients with underlying condi-
teeth, contents of the cavity (soft tissue and fluid), tions, osteogenesis imperfecta and idiopathic thrombo-
treatment, histology, outcomes of treatment, number of cytopenic purpura respectively.
lesions, location, radiographic findings (scalloped
margin, multilocular pattern and bony expansion) and CASE REPORTS
imaging modalities. Additionally, three new cases of Case 1
multiple SBCs with CBCT imaging are presented. An 11-year-old girl was referred to the Department of Or-
thodontics, Kyungpook National University Dental Hospital
RESULTS for orthodontic treatment. She was subsequently referred to
A PubMed search yielded 384 articles, of which 16 the Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery for evalu-
cases from 14 publications met the requirements for the ation of two incidentally noted unilocular radiolucencies
involving the left mandibular canine area and symphyseal
search. Fifteen additional cases were identified from the
region (Figure 5). The left mandibular canine was mesially
references of these articles. Including the 3 new cases
impacted and the lamina dura of the adjacent teeth were intact.
described here, a total of 34 cases5-7,12-37 were analyzed Her medical history was unremarkable and she could not
(Tables I and II and Figure 1). Two asynchronous recall any history of trauma to the mandible. Physical exam-
bilateral SBCs were included in this study. ination was likewise unremarkable, with no evidence of
An exact age was reported in 30 patients. Eighteen swelling, asymmetry or lymphadenopathy. Intraoral exami-
(52.9%) of the 34 cases of multiple SBCs were found in nation disclosed no soft tissue abnormality in the area of the
the second decade of life and eight cases (23.5 %) anterior mandible except for an impacted left mandibular
occurred in patients greater than 30 years of age canine. Several carious teeth were noted in the posterior areas.
(Table I and Figure 2). Among the 28 patients in which The vitality of the anterior mandibular teeth was confirmed by
gender was reported, a female predominance of 1.8:1 electric pulp testing.
CBCT images were acquired with a CB MercuRay (Hitachi
was noted (Figure 1). Twenty-two (64.7 %) asymp-
Medico, Tokyo, Japan) using a 10 cm field of view at 120
tomatic cases were detected after routine radiographic
kVp and 15 mA. The presence of two separate and distinct
examination. Swellings were noted in six patients moderately defined unicystic lesions was confirmed. Buccal
(17.6%). Only two patients had a documented history expansion and slight thinning of the lingual cortex was
of a traumatic event (a high-speed water-skiing spill and evident. The contents of the lesion were homogenously dense,
a blow to the mandible). Vitality of involved teeth was similar to or slightly less dense than the adjacent soft tissue
reported in 20 patients, with loss of vitality reported in (Figure 6). The radiographic impression for both lesions was
only one patient, representing one of our cases. SBC. The proposed treatment included surgical exploration
Fluid was aspirated in 7 of 11 patients (13 of 23 and incisional biopsy of both lesions with extraction of the left
SBCs in this group). Of these 11 patients, fluid was also mandibular canine to confirm the diagnosis and to promote
identified at surgery in only one patient (representing 2 bone regeneration. Both lesions were approached surgically
under general anesthesia and were found to be empty, without
of 23 SBCs). Fluid was discovered in the cavity during
evidence of lining or fluid content. The lesions were curetted
surgery in 8 of 23 patients (34.8%), while the cavities
in an attempt to obtain tissue for histopathologic analysis.
were empty in 15 of 23 patients (65.2%). Despite several attempts, no soft tissue lining was found and
Most multiple SBCs were treated surgically, with a no tissue could be obtained for histopathologic examination.
single case reporting spontaneous resolution of the A diagnosis of multiple SBCs was established surgically. The
lesion after 4 years and 5 months. Multiple SBCs postoperative course was uneventful. A follow-up panoramic
recurred in the three oldest patients in this cohort (mean radiograph at 24 months shows adequate bony healing of both
age: 39.3 years of age) who had been managed by lesions (Figure 7).
incisional biopsy or surgical curettage.
The presence of two SBCs per patient was the most
Case 2
common presentation, with seven patients presenting
A 17-year-old male patient visited a dental private clinic for
with three SBCs. Most lesions were located in the treatment of a carious tooth. Large unicystic radiolucencies
posterior mandible (Figures 3 and 4). Maxillary lesions were noted bilaterally in the body of the mandible; a uniloc-
in combination with mandibular SBCs were noted ular radiolucency in the left mandibular premolar area and a
in two patients. Radiographically, scalloping was re- scalloped unilocular radiolucency in the right mandibular
ported in 21 patients (61.8%) and bony expansion was body area. Loss of the lamina dura of the adjacent teeth was
Table I. Characteristics of multiple SBCs. Results of a systematic review including our three cases

e460
ORAL AND MAXILLOFACIAL RADIOLOGY
Case Chief History Vitality Soft tissue Fluid in cavity
no. Year Author Age Sex complaints of trauma of teeth in cavity (aspiration/surgery) Treatment Histology Healing check

An et al.
1 1947 Hankey12 15 M RR  NS  NS/ Surgical intervention e 6 months
2 1954 Hutchinson15 23 NS RR  NS NS NS/NS NS NS NS
3 1963 Thoma16 15 F NS  NS NS NS/NS Surgical intervention SBC 15 months (Pano.)
4 1966 Szerlip14 15 F RR NS þ NS NS/NS Self healing e 4 year 5 months
5 1969 Grasso et al.17 35 F RR  þ þ Reddish-brown Surgical curettage Sclerotic bone 7 months
(Rt.)/ (autogenous venous
blood injection-Rt.)
6 1970 Morris et al.18 21 F RR NS þ  NS/Sanguineous Surgical intervention e NS
7 1971 Huebner and 11 F RR  þ  NS/Clear fluid Surgical opening e 4 months (Pano.)
Turlington19
8 1973 Stewart et al.20 17 M RR  NS  Light, reddish, Surgical curettage Lamellar bone, loose 6 months (Pano.)
watery/ erythrocytes
9 1974 Schofield13 20 F RR þ þ  / Surgical curettage trabecula bone, connective 4-5 months (Pano.)
tissue (multinucleated cells
& histocytic stromal cells)
10 1975 Ruprecht and 17 M Pain NS þ  NS/ Surgical intervention e 7 months (Pano.)
Reid21
11 1978 Heimdahl22 16 M Swelling  þ  Serosanguineous/ Surgical curettage e 3 months
Serosanguineous
12 1978 Pogrel6 18 F RR  þ þ /Serosanguineous Surgical intervention Bone, fibrous tissue 1 year
13 1979 Markus5 13 F RR NS NS NS NS/ Surgical intervention Lamellar bone, fibrous tissue 6 months (Pano.)
14 1979 Raibley et al.23 13 F RR  NS  Serosanguineous/NS Open and close Granulation tissue, 2 months (Pano.)
hemorrhage, cholesterol
clefts associated with
foreign body giant cells
15 1980 Kuroi24 36 F RR  þ79%  Serosanguineous/NS Surgical curettage e 1st: Recurrence, 3
months
2nd: 9 months
16 1981 Patrikiou et al.25 15 NS Pain NS þ NS NS/Serosanguineous Surgical intervention e 16 months (Pano.)
(Lt.)
17 1988 Forssell et al.26 NS NS NS NS NS þ NS/NS Open and close cancellous bone (osteoblast þ
rim), lamellar compact
bone (basophilia around
Haversian canals)
18 1991 Brannon and 21 F RR  NS þ NS/ Surgical curettage reactive bone, fibrous, and NS
Houston27 granulation tissue
19 1992 Saito et al.28 <30 NS RR NS þ NS NS/NS Surgical intervention NS þ
20 1992 Saito et al.28 >30 NS RR NS þ NS NS/NS Surgical intervention NS þ
21 1992 Saito et al.28 >30 NS RR NS þ NS NS/NS Surgical intervention NS þ
Prakash et al.29 þ 

June 2014
22 1992 32 M Pain, NS NS/Serous Surgical intervention Bone fragments, chronic 4 months

OOOO
Swelling (gelfoam packing) inflammatory granulation
tissue
Table I. Continued

Volume 117, Number 6


OOOO
Case Chief History Vitality Soft tissue Fluid in cavity
no. Year Author Age Sex complaints of trauma of teeth in cavity (aspiration/surgery) Treatment Histology Healing check
23 1992 Fielding30 15 F RR e þ  / Surgical curettage Dense cortical bone 1.5 years (PA)
24 1993 Jones and 23 F Pain,  NS NS NS/ Surgical intervention Bone trabeculae (rimmed by NS
Baughman7 Swelling osteoid and osteoblasts),
fibrous connective tissue
25 2002 Oda et al.31 12 M Swelling þ þ NS NS/NS Open and close Granulation tissue 8 months (Pano.)
26 2003 Kraut and Robin32 43 F NS NS NS NS Red (Rt.), Straw- Incisional biopsy Fragments of bone, 1st: recurrence,
colored (Lt.)/ granulaiton tissue, 18 months
osteoblastic rimming 2nd: 14 months
(Pano.)
27 2008 Mupparapu et al.33 39 F Pain, NS þ þ Serosanguineous/ Incisional biopsy bone trabeculae, fibrous 1st: recurrence, 2 year
Swelling connective tissue, rims of 2months
(Rt.) osteoid acute and chronic 2nd: NS
inflammatory cells
28 2010 Kuhmichel and 32 F RR  þ  NS/ Excisional biopsy NS 12 months (Pano.)
Bouloux34
29 2012 de Oliveira et al.35 22 M RR  NS  /NS Surgical curettage NS 2 years
30 2012 Martins-Filho 10 M NS  NS NS NS/Serous-bloody NS NS NS
et al.36
31 2012 Mathew et al.37 15 F Swelling  NS  NS/Clear, yellowish Surgical intervention NS 4 months (Pano.)
32 Our case 1 11 F RR  þ  NS/ Surgical curettage NS 2 years (Pano.)
33 Our case 2 17 M RR  þ  NS/ Surgical curettage NS NS
34 Our case 3 18 M RR  þ/  NS/ Surgical intervention Viable bone, dense 3 months (CBCT)
fibrovascular connective
tissue
RR, routine radiographic examination; NS, not stated; Pano., panoramic radiography; CBCT, cone-beam computed tomography; PA, periapical radiography; SBC, simple bone cysts, Rt., the right side; Lt., the
left side.

An et al. e461
CASE REPORT
ORAL AND MAXILLOFACIAL RADIOLOGY OOOO
e462 An et al. June 2014

Table II. Characteristics of multiple SBCs. Results of a systematic review, including our three cases
Case No. of
no. Year Author lesion Location (ADA system) Radiographic findings Image modality
12
1 1947 Hankey 3 #18-20, #25-26, #30-31 scalloping Lat. view
2 1954 Hutchinson15 2 #18-19, #28-30 scalloping, loss of lamina dura15 Lat. view
3 1963 Thoma16 2 Both Mn. Post. Areas NA Lat. view
4 1966 Szerlip14 2 #18-20, #30 scalloping Peri., Occ., Lat.
view
5 1969 Grasso et al.17 3 Both Mn. Body-ramus, Lt. scalloping, multilocular, Pano., Occ.
condyle, Symphyseal region expansion
6 1970 Morris et al.18 2 NA NA NA
7 1971 Huebner and 2 #23-26, #21-Lt. Mn. angle scalloping Pano., Peri.
Turlington19
8 1973 Stewart et al.20 2 #17-20, #30-32 scalloping Lat. view, Mn. PA
9 1974 Schofield13 3 #21-24, #19-20, #18-Lt. Mn. scalloping, multilocular, buccal Pano., Peri., Occ.
ramus erosion
10 1975 Ruprecht and Reid21 2 #20-22, #30-32 NA Peri.
11 1978 Heimdahl22 2 #30-22, #26-31 scalloping, expansion Pano., Occ.
12 1978 Pogrel6 2 #20- Lt. Mn. Ramus, #30-Rt. scalloping, expasion Pano., Mn. PA
ramus
13 1979 Markus5 2 #19-23, #25-29 multilocular, tooth displacement, Pano., Occ.
loss of lamina dura, root
resorption, expansion
14 1979 Raibley et al.23 3 #29-signoid notch, #24-25, scalloping, multilocular, Pano.
#19-20 expansion
15 1980 Kuroi24 NA All Mn. teeth NA Pano.
16 1981 Patrikiou et al.25 2 #19-22, #29-30 scalloping, expansion Pano.
17 1988 Forssell et al.26 2 #19-20, #29-31 scalloping NA
18 1991 Brannon and Houston27 2 #17, #32 (-) Pano.
19 1992 Saito et al.28 2 #17-18, #22-26 NA NA
20 1992 Saito et al.28 2 #18-19, #27-32 NA NA
21 1992 Saito et al.28 2 #10-11, #17-18 NA NA
22 1992 Prakash et al.29 3 #3-4, Mx. Ant. Region, #18-22 scalloping, expansion Pano.
23 1992 Fielding30 2 #19-22, #28-29 scalloping, expansion Pano., Peri.
24 1993 *Jones and Baughman7 3 Mn. Ant. Region, #20-ramus, expansion Pano., Occ.
#28-ramus
y
25 2002 Oda et al.31 2 #31-ramus, #27-Lt. ramus multilocular, tooth displacement, Pano.
loss of lamina dura, root
resorption, expansion
26 2003 Kraut and Robin32 2 #18-19, #29-31 scalloping, tooth displacement Pano.
27 2008 Mupparapu et al.33 3 #19-20, #17-18, #31-32 multilocular, loss of lamina dura Pano.
28 2010 Kuhmichel and 2 #30, #24-27 scalloping, expansion Pano., CT
Bouloux34
29 2012 de Oliveira et al.35 2 #21-25, #28-29 scalloping Pano.
30 2012 Martins-Filho et al.36 2 #18-21, #28-31 scalloping, expansion Pano.
31 2012 Mathew et al.37 2 #30-ramus, #19-20 scalloping, multilocular, Pano., CBCT
expansion
32 Our case 1 2 #22, #23-27 loss of lamina dura, expansion Pano., CBCT
33 Our case 2 2 #20-21, #28-30 scalloping, loss of lamina dura, Pano., CBCT
root resorption
34 Our case 3 2 #24-27, #29-30 scalloping, loss of lamina dura, Pano., CBCT
root resorption
ADA, American Dental Association; Pano., panoramic radiography; Occ., occlusal radiography; PA, periapical radiography; NA, not available; Mn.,
mandible; Mx., maxilla; Post., posterior; Ant., anterior; Lat., lateral; CT, computed tomography; CBCT, cone-beam computed tomography.
*Associated with osteogenesis imperfecta; asynchronous multiple SBCs (interval of 4 year 9 months).
y
Associated with idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura; asynchronous multiple SBCs (interval of 1 year 10 months).

evident (Figure 8). The patient was referred to the Department swelling, asymmetry or lymphadenopathy. Intraoral exami-
of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Kyungpook National nation disclosed no soft tissue abnormality or bony expansion
University Dental Hospital for further assessment and treat- involving either side of the mandible. Electric pulp testing of
ment. His medical history was unremarkable. He could not the adjacent teeth was within normal limits. CBCT imaging
recall any history of trauma to the mandible. Physical exam- using a 15 cm field of view at 120 kVp and 15 mA exhibited
ination was likewise unremarkable, with no evidence of the presence of bilateral moderately defined unilocular lesions
OOOO CASE REPORT
Volume 117, Number 6 An et al. e463

Fig. 1. Summary of 34 cases of multiple SBCs of the jaws. (A ¼ absent; F ¼ female; M ¼ male; NS ¼ not-stated; P ¼ present;
ts ¼ tissue.)

mandibular second premolar, was confirmed by electric pulp


testing. Periapical and occlusal radiographs revealed two
distinct unilocular radiolucencies involving the right
mandibular symphyseal region, extending from the left
mandibular central incisor to the right left canine, and the right
body of the mandible, extending from the distal aspect of the
area of the first premolar to the mesial aspect of the
second molar tooth (Figure 10). The right posterior mandib-
ular lesion was associated with root resorption of the second
premolar and mesial root of the first molar, loss of lamina
Fig. 2. Age distribution (N 30 patients). dura, and buccal-lingual bone expansion. The radiographic
impression was suggestive of SBC for the anterior lesion and
a suspected odontogenic cyst or benign odontogenic neoplasm
(Figure 9). Slight thinning of the lingual cortex was noted on for the right posterior mandibular lesion. The proposed
the right side; however, any other effects on surrounding treatment included incisional biopsy of both lesions with
structures were absent. The contents of the lesion were endodontic therapy of the right mandibular second premolar
homogenously dense, similar to or slightly less dense than with Ca(OH)2 medication, apical Collaplug and Mineral
adjacent soft tissue. Both lesions were interpreted as most Trioxide Aggregate. Both lesions were approached surgically
likely representing SBCs on the basis of the radiographic under local anesthesia and were found to be empty, without
findings; although the low possibility of bilateral keratocystic evidence of a distinct lining or fluid content (Figure 11).
odontogenic tumors (KOTs) could not be ruled out. The Histopathologic examination of the right mandibular lesion
proposed treatment included exploration and incisional biopsy revealed thin fragments of fibrovascular connective tissue
of the both lesions. The lesions were approached surgically without cyst lining, suggestive of simple bone cyst, and viable
under general anesthesia and noted to be empty without evi- bone consistent with the wall of simple bone cyst in the
dence of a lining or fluid content. No tissue was available for anterior mandibular lesion (Figure 12). The postoperative
histopathologic examination. A diagnosis of bilateral SBCs course was uneventful. A follow-up CBCT image (i-CAT
was established surgically and radiographically. Imaging system, Next Generation, Imaging Sciences Inter-
national, Hatfield, US) at 3 months shows peripheral bony
healing of the right mandibular lesion (Figure 13).
Case 3
An 18-year-old black male was referred to Graduate End-
odontics at the University of Michigan School of Dentistry for
DISCUSSION
endodontic therapy of the right mandibular second premolar.
The purpose of this study was to review previously
His medical history was noncontributory and he could not
recall any history of trauma to the mandible. Physical exam- published cases of multiple SBCs of the jaws and
ination was unremarkable, with no evidence of swelling, include three additional cases of our own in order to
asymmetry or lymphadenopathy. Intraoral examination dis- analyze the characteristics of multiple SBCs. Suei et al.
closed no caries, periodontal disease or restorations in the reported that SBCs of the jaws have an equal preva-
area. The vitality of the mandibular teeth, except for the right lence in both genders,13 with most occurring in patients
ORAL AND MAXILLOFACIAL RADIOLOGY OOOO
e464 An et al. June 2014

Fig. 3. Distribution of multiple SBCs N ¼ 33 patients, Case no. 6 and maxillary anterior lesion of case no. 22 were excluded due to
unspecified information. (R ¼ right; L ¼ left; CC ¼ condyle-coronoid process; UR ¼ upper ramus; LR ¼ lower ramus;
MA ¼ mandibular angle; 8 ¼ third molar area; 7 ¼ second molar area; 6 ¼ first molar area; 5 ¼ second premolar area; 4 ¼ first
premolar area; 3 ¼ canine area; 2 ¼ lateral incisor area; 1 ¼ central incisor area.)

Fig. 5. Case 1. Panoramic radiograph from an11-year-old girl


Fig. 4. Number of lesions involving each region - N ¼ 33 reveals unilocular radiolucent lesions involving the left
patients, Case no. 6 and maxillary anterior lesion of case no. mandibular canine and mandibular symphyseal regions.
22 were excluded due to unspecified information. (R ¼ right;
L ¼ left; CC ¼ condyle-coronoid process; UR ¼ upper and multilocular radiolucent patterns were observed in
ramus; LR ¼ lower ramus; MA ¼ mandibular angle; 8 ¼ third 15 (44.1%) and 7 (20.6%) patients respectively, which
molar area; 7 ¼ second molar area; 6 ¼ first molar area; is less common than what is reported in single SBCs.41
5 ¼ second premolar area; 4 ¼ first premolar area; 3 ¼ canine Generally, SBCs have a tendency to grow along the
area; 2 ¼ lateral incisor area; 1 ¼ central incisor area.) long axis of the bone, causing minimal expansion;
however, expansion of the involved bone can occur and
in the second decade of life.38 They are usually is more common with larger lesions.40
asymptomatic and rarely expand the cortical plates.26,39 The differential diagnosis of SBC includes KOT.42
In the present study, we identified 34 cases of multiple KOTs affect the mandible 2:1 compared to the
SBCs, comprising 10 males and 18 females (1.8:1, maxilla,43 occurring primarily during the second and
female:male). The patient’s gender was not stated in 6 third decades.44 KOTs tend to grow through the med-
of the 34 patients. 52.9% of multiple SBCs cases were ullary space with very little expansion and often have
identified in the second decade of life, with 23.5% scalloped borders similar to those of an SBC40,42;
found in patients older than 30 years of age. however, the cortical boundary of the KOTs is more
The most common radiographic finding in multifocal defined, with adjacent teeth frequently resorbed or
SBCs was scalloping, consistent with what is tradi- displaced.40 Since nevoid basal cell carcinoma syn-
tionally described in single lesions.40 Bony expansion drome (NBCCS) shows multiple KOTs of jaws,45,46
OOOO CASE REPORT
Volume 117, Number 6 An et al. e465

Fig. 6. Case 1. (A) Panoramic reconstruction from CBCT shows moderately defined unilocular cystic lesions on the anterior
mandibular area. (B) Axial section of CBCT shows mild expansion of the buccal cortex and thinning of the lingual cortex.

Fig. 8. Case 2. Panoramic radiograph of a 17-year-old boy


Fig. 7. Case 1. Postoperative panoramic radiograph at
shows a unilocular radiolucency in the left mandibular pre-
24 months reveals bony healing.
molar area and a scalloped unilocular radiolucency in the right
mandibular body area.
multiple SBCs need to be differentiated from NBCCS.
While most multiple SBCs involve in mandible bilat- between magnetic resonance imaging and surgical
erally, the number of KOTs associated with NBCCS findings associated with the fluid in SBC cavities was
can range from 1 to 28 (mean 5.1).45 Other diagnostic also reported. Rapid fluid absorption or varying
criteria of NBCCS, such as basal cell carcinomas of the amounts of fluid within SBCs was proposed as a po-
skin, palmar or plantar pits, lamellar calcification of the tential explanation for this discrepancy.49 In this study,
falx cerebri and rib anomalies are helpful in differen- 7 of 11 patients reportedly presented with fluid at
tiating this from multiple SBCs.46 In addition, there are aspiration but at the time of surgery fluid was noted
some radiographic similarities between multiple SBCs within the cavity in only one patient. Fifteen of the 23
and cherubism; however, cherubism develops in early patients revealed an air-filled cavity at surgery. Like-
childhood, typically between 2 and 6 years of age. wise, our three cases presented as empty cavities at
Bilateral facial swelling, anterior displacement of teeth, surgery, even though the cavities were interpreted as
multilocular jaw lesions, and posterior epicenter in the being filled with cyst-like content in two cases based on
mandibular ramus are characteristic of cherubism.25 CBCT imaging. The reason for this discrepancy be-
SBCs are diagnosed based on clinical, radiographic, tween radiographic and surgical findings is not fully
and surgical findings showing an empty cavity in the understood. Although precise determination of the
bone without cyst lining.34,47 In this study, 64.7% of contents of the cavity may not be meaningful for the
multiple SBCs were asymptomatic, being discovered treatment of SBC, correct interpretation is necessary for
on routine radiographic examination similar to what is an exact diagnosis and could be helpful in elucidating
noted with single SBCs. Computed tomography the pathogenesis.41
generally allows distinction between solid/fluid-filled To date, the pathogenesis of SBCs is far from being
lesions and air-filled cavities. Suei et al.48 insisted that established conclusively.41,50 The numerous different
the presence of gas in the cavity of SBC during surgery proposed mechanisms give some insight into the lack of
has been erroneously interpreted. From their review of understanding of this unusual entity. A widely accepted
52 computed tomography images, they were unable to etiology invokes traumatic injury, which results in
identify areas of lower density indicative of the pres- intramedullary hemorrhage, followed by failure of the
ence of gas, whereas gas was reportedly confirmed at hematoma to organize and be replaced by hard tis-
surgery in 28 cases.48 Furthermore, a discrepancy sue10,51,52; however, no history of trauma could be
ORAL AND MAXILLOFACIAL RADIOLOGY OOOO
e466 An et al. June 2014

Fig. 9. Case 2. (A) Panoramic, (B) axial, and (C) coronal sections of CBCT reveal unilocular cystic lesion of the left mandibular
premolar and right mandibular body areas. Thinning of the right lingual mandibular cortex is observed on the axial plane section.

Fig. 10. Case 3. (A) and (B) periapical radiographs from an 18-year-old black male reveal a unilocular radiolucent lesion of the
mandibular symphyseal and the right mandibular body. (C) Occlusal view shows buccal cortical expansion and lingual cortical
thinning.

incorporation of synovial tissue.56 Others have sug-


gested that SBCs might be the end result of numerous
initiating factors.57,58 In this study, concomitant lesions
seen in cases of multiple SBCs included osteogenesis
imperfecta7 and idiopathic thrombocytopenic pur-
pura.31 In both cases, the traumatic bone cysts occurred
asynchronously. Jones and Baughman7 raised the pos-
sibility that asynchronous bilateral SBCs simply rep-
resented fortuitous findings and were not associated
with the more generalized skeletal abnormalities seen in
osteogenesis imperfecta. Oda et al.31 reported that not
only hemophilia but also other hemorrhagic conditions,
such as idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura, can pre-
Fig. 11. Case 3. An empty cavity was encountered in the
dispose to the development of hemorrhagic bone cysts.
mandibular right lesion during surgical exploration.
There might be an underlying systemic component in
patients with multiple SBCs, such as predisposing to
elicited in many cases and the incidence of trauma in vascular issues. This might also explain why women
patients with SBCs does not appear to be greater than are more predisposed, who tend to have more condi-
that in the general population.11 With the exception of tions with vascular coagulopathies. This would be
two patients, no history of trauma could be elicited from supported by our observation that multiple SBCs
our review of 34 cases. Furthermore, the presence of occurred asynchronously in two patients with underly-
bilateral lesions would lessen the possibility of trauma ing conditions, osteogenesis imperfecta, and idiopathic
as a causative factor, since traumatic events seldom take thrombocytopenic purpura, respectively. Bleeding di-
place bilaterally. Other possible causes have been pro- atheses are a well-known feature in patients with
posed, including venous obstruction,53,54 faulty calcium osteogenesis imperfecta.59,60 There was no description
metabolism, low-grade infection,55 and intraosseous of underlying coagulopathies from our review, that’s
OOOO CASE REPORT
Volume 117, Number 6 An et al. e467

Fig. 12. Case 3. Histopathologic examination of the biopsied tissue. (A) Right posterior mandibular lesion. Photomicrograph
shows a thin strand of fibrous connective tissue with occasional chronic inflammatory cells, without epithelial lining. This made up
only a very small percentage of the contents of the lesion. Overall, the bony cavity was devoid of tissue (hematoxylin-eosin stain,
original magnification 30). (B) Anterior mandibular lesion. Histopathologic examination reveals dense viable cortical bone
devoid of underlying connective tissue or epithelial lining (hematoxylin-eosin, original magnification 40.)

good results.32,64 Spontaneous resolution of SBC has


been described by several investigators, with periodic
radiographic follow-up recommended when the patient
declines a conventional surgical approach to treat-
ment.65,66 Some studies reported a low recurrence rate;
less than 2%, although this included many cases
without follow-up after treatment.19,24 According to
Fig. 13. Case 3. Six months postsurgery. Panoramic recon- Suei at al.,4 the overall recurrence rate of SBCs of the
struction of CBCT reveals bony healing at the periphery of the jaws was 26%, similar to that of extracranial SBCs
right mandibular lesion. (29%).67 In the present study, 31 of 34 patients (91.2%)
were treated surgically and one patient exhibited reso-
because the clinicians might have no notation about it lution of the lesions in the absence of any therapeutic
and did not consider this as an underlying possibility; intervention at 4 years 5 months from the initial diag-
therefore they did not order the correct tests or ask the nosis. Recurrences after surgical intervention were
correct questions about medical history that might have evident in only three cases; representing the three oldest
allowed them to identify these vascular issues. patients in the study group. Even though conservative
In general, the mandibular body is by far the most opening into the lesion and careful curettage of the
common location for SBCs, with the maxilla repre- lining is generally sufficient for treatment, careful
senting an uncommon site.11,34 One explanation for this follow-up is necessary for the evaluation of recurrence,
lower prevalence in the maxilla could be related to the especially in older patients.
possibility that maxillary lesions are obscured by the Extracranial multiple SBCs were reported in the
overall radiolucent appearance imparted by the maxil- literature.68-70 In extracranial SBCs, four clinco-
lary sinus.3,11,61 Another possible explanation could be anatomic varieties could be recognized: Classic meta-
due to differences in the quality and amount of bone physeal, nontubular, epiphyseal, and multiple.70
marrow and vascularity in the maxilla compared to the According to Abdel-Wanis and Tsuchiya,70 extracranial
mandible.62 In this review, we noted that multiple SBCs multiple SBCs occur in the higher age group and show
were most commonly located in the mandibular body. very high male predominance. In their review of the
Maxillary lesions were noted in only two patients, both literature, 15 cysts (35.7%) were in nontubular bones
in association with mandibular lesions. and six cysts (14.3%) were epiphyseal. Chigira et al.68
Curettage of the bone walls is the most widely suggested that venous obstruction of the lesions play an
accepted approach to the management of SBCs of the important role in the etiology of multiple SBCs based
jaws, the goal being to promote the formation of a on their treatment result. In the present study, even
blood clot and subsequent bone repair.41,63 Addition- though multiple SBCs of the jaws demonstrated some
ally, application of Gelfoam,58 grafting of allogenic differences from a single lesion, such as female pre-
bone with platelet-rich plasma and intralesional in- dominance and higher incidence of bony expansion and
jections of a mixture of blood, porous hydroxyapatite, multilocular pattern, it is not sure that this is an another
and bone fragments have been reported to produce entity.
ORAL AND MAXILLOFACIAL RADIOLOGY OOOO
e468 An et al. June 2014

In conclusion, knowledge of the clinical and radio- 27. Brannon RB, Houston GD. Bilateral traumatic bone cysts of the
graphic features in cases of multiple SBCs of the jaws is mandible: an unusual clinical presentation. Mil Med. 1991;156:
20-22.
helpful in accurately diagnosing this entity. 28. Saito Y, Hoshina Y, Nagamine T, Nakajima T, Suzuki M, Hayashi T.
Simple bone cyst. A clinical and histopathologic study of fifteen
REFERENCES cases. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1992;74:487-491.
1. Lucas CD. Do all cysts of the jaws originate from the dental 29. Prakash H, Tiwari P, Goyal M. Multiple traumatic bone cysts of
system? J Am Dent Assoc. 1929;16:647-661. jaws. Report of a case. Indian J Dent Res. 1992;3:116-120.
2. Rushton MA. Solitary bone cysts in the mandible. Br Dent J. 30. Fielding CG. The traumatic bone cyst: review of literature and
1946;81:37-49. report of two cases. Mil Med. 1992;157:676-680.
3. Hansen LS, Sapone J, Sproat RC. Traumatic bone cysts of jaws. 31. Oda Y, Kagami H, Tohnai I, Ueda M. Asynchronously occurring
Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1974;37:899-910. bilateral mandibular hemorrhagic bone cysts in a patient with
4. Suei Y, Taguchi A, Tanimoto K. Simple bone cyst of the jaws: idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura. J Oral Maxillofac Surg.
evaluation of treatment outcome by review of 132 cases. J Oral 2002;60:95-99.
Maxillofac Surg. 2007;65:918-923. 32. Kraut R, Robin C. Idiopathic bone cavity. A report of recurrent
5. Markus AF. Bilateral haemorrhagic bone cysts of the mandible: a lesions and their management. NY State Dent J. 2003;69:30-33.
case report. Br J Oral Surg. 1979;16:270-273. 33. Mupparapu M, Milles M, Singer SR, Rinaggio J. Rare, simulta-
6. Pogrel MA. Bilateral solitary bone cysts: report of case. J Oral neous, multiple, and recurrent mandibular bone cysts. Quintes-
Surg. 1978;36:55-58. sence Int. 2008;39:331-336.
7. Jones AC, Baughman RA. Multiple idiopathic mandibular bone 34. Kuhmichel A, Bouloux GF. Multifocal traumatic bone cysts: case
cysts in a patient with osteogenesis imperfecta. Oral Surg Oral report and current thoughts on etiology. J Oral Maxillofac Surg.
Med Oral Pathol. 1993;75:333-337. 2010;68:208-212.
8. Davis WM Jr, Buchs AU, Davis WM. Extravasation cyst diag- 35. de Oliveira JF, Barbosa DB, Pereira LC, Gabrielli MA,
nostic curettement: a treatment. Report of 15 cases and suggested Sarmento VA. Mandibular simple bone cysts: a rare case of
treatment. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1979;47:2-7. bilateral occurrence. Braz J Otorhinolaryngol. 2012;78:134.
9. Whinery JG. Progressive bone cavities of the mandible: a review 36. Martins-Filho PR, Santos Tde S, de Araujo VL, Santos JS,
of the so-called traumatic bone cyst and a report of three cases. Andrade ES, da Silva LC. Traumatic bone cyst of the mandible: a
Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1955;8:903-916. review of 26 cases. Braz J Otorhinolaryngol. 2012;78:16-21.
10. Jaffe HL, Lichtenstein L. Solitary unicameral bone cyst. Arch 37. Mathew R, Omami G, Gianoli D, Lurie A. Unusual cone-beam
Surg. 1942;44:1004-1025. computerized tomography presentation of traumatic (simple) bone
11. Kaugars GE, Cale AE. Traumatic bone cyst. Oral Surg Oral Med cyst: case report and radiographic analysis. Oral Surg Oral Med
Oral Pathol. 1987;63:318-324. Oral Pathol Oral Radiol. 2012;113:410-413.
12. Hankey GT. Three cysts in the same mandible, not of dental origin. 38. Suomalainen A, Apajalahti S, Kuhlefelt M, Hagstrom J. Simple
Solitary cysts or osteitis fibrosa. Proc R Soc Med. 1947;40:723-726. bone cyst: a radiological dilemma. Dentomaxillofac Radiol.
13. Schofield ID. An unusual traumatic bone cyst. Oral Surg Oral 2009;38:174-177.
Med Oral Pathol. 1974;38:198-203. 39. Beasley JD. 3rd: Traumatic cyst of the jaws: report of 30 cases.
14. Szerlip L. Traumatic bone cysts. Resolution without surgery. Oral J Am Dent Assoc. 1976;92:145-152.
Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1966;21:201-204. 40. White SC, Pharoah MJ, eds. Oral Radiology: Principles and
15. Hutchinson ACW. Haemorrhagic, traumatic or solitary bone Interpretation. St. Louis, MO: Mosby-Year Inc.; 2009:361-364.
cysts. Dental and Oral X-ray Diagnosis. 1954:393-396. 41. Suei Y, Taguchi A, Tanimoto K. A comparative study of simple
16. Thoma KH. Bone cysts. Oral Surgery. 1963;4:897-903. bone cysts of the jaw and extracranial bones. Dentomaxillofac
17. Grasso AM, Demkee D, Finnegan J. Traumatic cyst of the Radiol. 2007;36:125-129.
mandible: report of case. J Oral Surg. 1969;27:341-344. 42. Ferreira Junior O, Damante JH, Lauris JR. Simple bone cyst
18. Morris CR, Steed DL, Jacoby JJ. Traumatic bone cysts. J Oral versus odontogenic keratocyst: differential diagnosis by
Surg. 1970;28:188-195. digitized panoramic radiography. Dentomaxillofac Radiol.
19. Huebner GR, Turlington EG. So-called traumatic (hemorrhagic) 2004;33:373-378.
bone cysts of the jaws. Review of the literature and report of two 43. Ahlfors E, Larsson A, Sjogren S. The odontogenic keratocyst: a
unusual cases. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1971;31:354-365. benign cystic tumor? J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1984;42:10-19.
20. Stewart S, Sherman P, Stoopack JC. Large bilateral traumatic 44. Brannon RB. The odontogenic keratocyst. A clinicopathologic
bone cysts of the mandible: report of case. J Oral Surg. 1973;31: study of 312 cases. Part I. Clinical features. Oral Surg Oral Med
685-688. Oral Pathol. 1976;42:54-72.
21. Ruprecht A, Reid J. Simple bone cyst. Report of two cases. Oral 45. Kimonis VE, Goldstein AM, Pastakia B, et al. Clinical manifes-
Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1975;39:826-832. tations in 105 persons with nevoid basal cell carcinoma syn-
22. Heimdahl A. An unusual case of “simple bone cyst” of the drome. Am J Med Genet. 1997;69:299-308.
mandible. Int J Oral Surg. 1978;7:32-35. 46. Sun ZJ, Liu B, Zhao YF. Radiopacity in syndrome keratocystic
23. Raibley SO, Beckett RP, Nowakowski A. Multiple traumatic odontogenic tumour. Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 2008;37:175-178.
bone cysts of the mandible. J Oral Surg. 1979;37:335-337. 47. Neves A, Migliari DA, Sugaya NN, de Sousa SO. Traumatic bone
24. Kuroi M. Simple bone cyst of the jaw: review of the literature and cyst: report of two cases and review of the literature. Gen Dent.
report of case. J Oral Surg. 1980;38:456-459. 2001;49:291-295:quiz 296-297.
25. Patrikiou A, Sepheriadou-Mavropoulou T, Zambelis G. Bilateral 48. Suei Y, Taguchi A, Kurabayashi T, Kobayashi F, Nojiri M,
traumatic bone cyst of the mandible. A case report. Oral Surg Tanimoto K. Simple bone cyst: investigation on the presence of gas
Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1981;51:131-133. in the cavity using computed tomography-review of 52 cases. Oral
26. Forssell K, Forssell H, Happonen RP, Neva M. Simple bone cyst. Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral Radiol Endod. 1998;86:592-594.
Review of the literature and analysis of 23 cases. Int J Oral 49. Eriksson L, Hansson LG, Akesson L, Stahlberg F. Simple bone
Maxillofac Surg. 1988;17:21-24. cyst: a discrepancy between magnetic resonance imaging and
OOOO CASE REPORT
Volume 117, Number 6 An et al. e469

surgical observations. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol Oral 63. Levin LS, Young RJ, Pyeritz RE. Osteogenesis imperfecta type I
Radiol Endod. 2001;92:694-698. with unusual dental abnormalities. Am J Med Genet. 1988;31:
50. Lokiec F, Wientroub S. Simple bone cyst: etiology, classification, 921-932.
pathology, and treatment modalities. J Pediatr Orthop B. 1998;7: 64. Dellinger TM, Holder R, Livingston HM, Hill WJ. Alternative
262-273. treatments for a traumatic bone cyst: a longitudinal case report.
51. Chapman PJ, Romaniuk K. Traumatic bone cyst of the mandible; Quintessence Int. 1998;29:497-502.
regression following aspiration. Int J Oral Surg. 1985;14:290-294. 65. Sapp JP, Stark ML. Self-healing traumatic bone cysts. Oral Surg
52. Magliocca KR, Edwards SP, Helman JI. Traumatic bone cyst of Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1990;69:597-602.
the condylar region: report of 2 cases. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 66. Damante JH, Da SGEN, Ferreira O Jr. Spontaneous resolution of
2007;65:1247-1250. simple bone cysts. Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 2002;31:182-186.
53. Cohen J. Simple bone cysts. Studies of cyst fluid in six cases with a 67. Schreuder HW, Conrad EU, 3rd, Bruckner JD, Howlett AT,
theory of pathogenesis. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1960;42-A:609-616. Sorensen LS. Treatment of simple bone cysts in children with
54. Cohen J. Etiology of simple bone cyst. J Bone Joint Surg Am. curettage and cryosurgery. J Pediatr Orthop. 1997;17:814-820.
1970;52:1493-1497. 68. Chigira M, Takehi Y, Nagase M, Arita S, Shimizu T,
55. Pogrel MA. A solitary bone cyst possibly caused by removal of an Shinozaki T. A case of multiple simple bone cysts. With special
impacted third molar. J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 1987;45:721-723. reference to their etiology and treatment. Arch Orthop Trauma
56. Mirra JM, Bernard GW, Bullough PG, Johnston W, Mink G. Surg. 1987;106:390-393.
Cementum-like bone production in solitary bone cysts. (so-called 69. Abdel-Wanis ME, Tsuchiya H, Minato H, Morinaga T,
“cementoma” of long bones). Report of three cases. Electron Yamamoto N, Tomita K. Bilateral symmetrical cysts in the upper
microscopic observations supporting a synovial origin to the tibiae in a skeletally mature patient: might they be simple bone
simple bone cyst. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1978:295-307. cysts? J Orthop Sci. 2001;6:595-600.
57. Howe GL. ‘Haemorrhagic cysts’ of the mandible. I. Br J Oral 70. Abdel-Wanis ME, Tsuchiya H. Simple bone cyst is not a single
Surg. 1965;3:55-76. entity: point of view based on a literature review. Med Hypoth-
58. Howe GL. ‘Haemorrhagic cysts’ of the mandible. II. Br J Oral eses. 2002;58:87-91.
Surg. 1965;3:77-91.
59. Edge G, Okafor B, Fennelly ME, Ransford AO. An unusual
manifestation of bleeding diathesis in a patient with osteogenesis Reprint requests:
imperfecta. Eur J Anaesthesiol. 1997;14:215-219. Karp-Shik Choi, DDS, PhD, Chang-Hyeon An, DDS, PhD
60. Mondal RK, Mann U, Sharma M. Osteogenesis imperfecta with Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology
bleeding diathesis. Indian J Pediatr. 2003;70:95-96. School of Dentistry
61. Moenning JE, Tawadros AM, Garrison BT, Graham LL. Multiple Kyungpook National University
radiolucencies of the mandible: a review of differential diagnoses 2177 Dalgubeol-daero
and a case report. J Indiana Dent Assoc. 1984;63:11-13. Jung-gu
62. Kahn MA. Clinicopathologic correlation quiz: unilocular peri- Daegu 700-412
apical radiolucencies. Traumatic bone cyst. J Tenn Dent Assoc. Republic of Korea
1997;77(24):35-36. ksichoi@knu.ac.kr; chan@knu.ac.kr

You might also like