Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

U

'F
iI
43 Demolition
Organization and planning 43/3

43.1 Introduction Where original drawings exist an allowance must be made for
alterations and additions which have not been formally
The demolition industry has its origin among those small recorded.
contractors who specialized in the removal and resale of archi- Parts of the premises which are inaccessible should be care-
tectural items, building materials and structural components. In fully opened up. It should not be a prospective contractor’s
the past, their operations were labour-intensive and time-con- responsibility to survey below the surface; indeed, the practi-
suming and often the salvaged items remained on their hands cality of a number of such contractors bringing equipment on to
for considerable periods. a site which is not formally in their responsibility normally
Development over the years has determined that demolition precludes this.
contractors organize their work and equip themselves to meet The likelihood of toxic or hazardous material either being
critical programmes. The size of firms undertaking demolition built in to the structure or arising from previous use should be
and associated fringe activities, such as excavation and tempor- assessed and the information forwarded to tenderers. It may be
ary works, varies from organizations offering a complete pack- prudent to decontaminate premises prior to the start of demoli-
age, through to small firms undertaking specialist works such as tion works or carefully phase a programme so that demolition
concrete-cutting or demolition blasting. does not produce a hazardous environment by scattering resi-
The capability of contractors varies from those thoroughly dues. The discovery of toxic and hazardous material at a late
organized with managerial and technical facilities backing up a stage can have the serious result of closing down work until
skilled labour force, down to those who work in excess of their residues are removed.
capacity to the detriment of their clients in particular and the The specification should state, and drawings should clearly
industry in general. indicate, the levels to which buildings are to be demolished. If
It is important that demolition contracts or the demolition ground slabs and foundations are to be removed, approximate
phase of major projects, should receive the same careful con- quantities with provisional sums for excesses, or a schedule of
sideration as those for rebuilding and civil engineering. rates, should be included for an item which is basically excava-
Much can be done to eliminate delays to works by ensuring tion. Any architectural features or sections of the building which
that obligations to third parties and statutory undertakings are are to be retained should be defined clearly and removed early in
negotiated before commencing work. the job if possible.
Details of the buildings or structures to be demolished or Once the decision to demolish has been taken, there are many
altered, together with a careful assessment of the restraints matters that can be put in hand alongside preparation of
imposed by location, should be discussed by clients and pros- contract documents.
pective contractors at an early stage to permit realistic and fair The so-called party wall awards, with their very specific
tendering. details of what can and cannot be done to adjacent properties,
‘Demolition’ embraces a wide spectrum of activities - from need considerable time for practical assessment and preparation
simple cottage demolition to the dismantling and removal of of documents. Whilst it may be impossible to agree fully the
industrial complexes. No broad boundaries are found between extent of the party wall award prior to opening up and exposing
demolition styles in different localities. Certain types of struc- an adjacent property, it is better to have made some progress,
ture lend themselves towards a preferred method, but of the thus allowing a demolition contractor to work normally and
many techniques available few can be applied individually and logically rather than be prohibited from approaching a site
most successful jobs employ a combination of one or more boundary.
methods. The removal of statutory undertakings’ equipment should be
organized as soon as the premises become vacant, in order to
avoid delays to the works and accidents caused by live services.
43.2 Organization and planning Demolition work may involve the diversion or protection of
services where there is a wayleave across the site and such
The person inviting tenders or negotiating for demolition work matters should be considered early, as sometimes extremely
should ensure that it will be undertaken by experienced contrac- complex planning has to be done to avoid disconnecting adjoin-
tors who have an awareness of the problems likely to be ing premises.
encountered on and off the site. In industrial premises which have existed harmoniously with
Forms of contract normally used for building or civil engi- their neighbours, demolition, even over a short time, can cause
neering may consist of documentation made unnecessarily com- concern to residents, or hazards to adjoining premises. There
plex by alterations, omissions and additions. A simple form of needs to be liaison between the client and concerned neighbours
contract such as that published by the National Federation of in order that prospective contractors are aware of restraints
Demolition Contractors in London may be acceptable. upon their methods of work.
The specification should be as simple as possible while
adequately defining the work required. Items such as shoring,
weatherproofing and accommodation works may be impossible
to determine until parts of the redundant building or structure 43.2.1 Insurance
have been removed and assessments made with the professional Clients and their professional advisers should make certain that
adviser(s) appointed by owners of the adjoining premises. specified insurance requirements are adequate, but at the same
Where this is the case, ‘provisional sums’ should be included. time realistic, for the risks arising from their projects.
In partial demolition or refurbishment, the structural detail Policies on behalf of the client, the contractor and sometimes
may have a critical effect on the proposals. Even though original jointly, should be in force prior to commencement of the works.
drawings may exist, it is prudent to open up relevant parts of the The amount of cover required can vary considerably, depen-
superstructure to confirm what has, in fact, been built. This dent upon location. Demolition work on an active mainline rail
preliminary work will often be needed by the consulting engi- terminal, for example, would require considerably more cover
neers charged with modifying the structure, but in any event the than work on a remote and disused factory premises.
structural survey should be done prior to inviting tenders for Employer’s liability insurance is a statutory requirement, the
demolition in order that prospective contractors may have the premium reflecting the hazardous nature of demolition work
benefit of seeing the structural detail. and the record of the contractor.
43/4 Demolition

43.2.2 Surveys and method statements attendant difficulties of preparing the foundation block and
The object of a demolition survey is to establish sufficient detail handling the sections in confined spaces.
about the premises to allow a decision on the method of When a free area of land is required, and where there is a
demolition and to identify any restraints affecting proposed convenient support, a flying shore can be connected horizont-
activities on the site. ally to an adjacent and sufficiently robust premises, provided the
Problems may arise due to characteristics of the building or owner of the supporting building agrees.
structure, or to the previous use of the premises or the location. On flying shores of long spans a central prop may be
Drawings of the building are not always available, and even necessary and, although this to some extent defeats the object of
where they are, the survey should be comprehensive enough to obtaining a clear area, it can be less inconvenient in the centre of
determine the extent of alterations from, and additions to, the a site, where it may interfere only with floor construction, than
original plan. raking shores at the edge, interfering with walls.
The sequence of building or erection, together with an Raking and flying shores are inserted to prevent a sideways
assessment of any temporary works or equipment used, can be movement of a wall. It is sometimes necessary to effect vertical
usefully compared with the proposals for demolition. support to a wall, either because its foundations have failed, or
The need to provide shoring either on adjacent premises or it is to be underpinned, or is to have additional openings made
within the structure being demolished should emerge from the in it.
survey; also, the need for weatherproofing either temporary or In these circumstances, needle shores, in which short hori-
permanent (see sectiohs 43.2.3 and 43.2.4). zontal members are placed through a wall and given their own
On any type of building or structure, the condition can, to a support, are used. Vertical support is referred to as ‘dead
greater or lesser extent, determine the method of demolition to shoring’.
be used. The loading on the shoring must be assessed and the system
Traditional brick, masonry and timber structures left unat- designed and detailed in a manner which takes into account the
tended and open to the atmosphere, may have deteriorated to circumstances of its erection and later dismantling.
the extent that they cannot be relied upon to provide safe access. Shoring was traditionally of timber, but examples from
Industrial uses producing corrosive atmospheres and long- scaffold tubes and fittings, and from fabricated steelwork are
term lack of maintenance may have affected structural steel- more common today, with the use of traditional carpentry skills
work, particularly connections, to the extent that preweakening becoming uneconomical.
of a structure would be hazardous. For dealing with dangerous structures, say a building which
Persons undertaking demolition surveys should be aware of, has been hit by a vehicle or suffered a severe fire, shores made
and experienced in, finding such conditions. from scaffolding are normally used, often erected not by the
In addition to surveying the building, the adjoining buildings demolition contractor but by scaffolding companies who have
should be assessed in terms of structure and equipment con- arrangements with the authorities for rapid turnout to deal with
tained to determine any restraints. For example, in urban areas such emergencies.
the increase in use of computers, which are very sensitive to For retaining facades, scaffolds may be used, but fabricated
vibration, has added to the problems traditionally arising from steelwork providing quick erection and a compact design is
dust and vibration. popular, particularly in congested city areas.
Following the demolition survey, a detailed method state-
ment should be prepared prior to the start of work. 43.2.4 Weatherproofing
The presentation of this statement has been widely debated:
BS 6187:1982 Code of practice for demolition‘ recommends that Walls previously protected by buildings which are being demol-
a programme should be drawn up in which the proposed ished, will quickly absorb moisture and deteriorate if weather-
sequence and the method of operation is indicated clearly. The proofing is not provided.
Health and Safety Executive Guidance Note GS29/1* goes Walls exposed on a long-term basis can be rendered or
further by advising that a detailed method statement should skimmed with brickwork if this is desirable from a visual
identify problems and their solutions and form a reference for viewpoint. Walls in good condition can be treated with water-
site supervision. repellent compounds. c

The degree of difficulty in the work must determine the detail It is more usual for bitumen or polythene sheeting to be used
on the method statement, but in any event, it must be in terms on a temporary basis to stand until the new adjacent walls
that can be understood by the supervisor and labour force. It provideprotection. Such sheeting must be fixed to the wall with
may be written with annotated drawings, or instructions may be vertical and horizontal battens in a regular pattern and in a
painted on to the structure. workmanlike manner if it is not to be torn by the wind and
become ineffective. It is both annoying and costly to have to
return to repair small areas of weatherproofing as the access
43.2.3 Shoring from the original building may not be available and scaffolds or
elevating platforms will have to be obtained. The sheeting must
The need for shoring-up adjacent buildings or, on occasions, the be overlapped and horizontal faces must be weatherproofed to
temporary shoring of the structure being demolished, should be ensure that the arrangement is completely watertight.
investigated prior to the start of demolition. In cases where this
is not possible a procedure for checking the requirements as the
job progresses should be formalized. 43.2.5 Hoardings
The simplest approach is to leave parts of adjacent walls or It is usual for the contractor to provide a hoarding, sometimes
part of the structural frame as buttresses if they are in an to his own design, sometimes to that of others.
acceptable condition - provided their retention would not As a precaution against trespassers, it is in the contractor’s.
hinder subsequent building. best interests to secure the site at all times, but this may not be
If it is decided that raking shores are necessary, it is some- practicable, particularly during the early stages of work.
times acceptable to erect them after demolition, but if the The provision of a hoarding can be a substantial item.
durability of the exposed wall is suspect in the short term, the Erection should be done by experienced personnel in order to
- shores may have to be inserted prior to demolition, with all the ensure that it will resist overturning by the wind, and be robust
. -
preliminary to wire%pe-puUing, but mo
explosives has involved preweaL

on.*gntrr,roof
43.4.2 Hydra& excavators and tractor shovels
Most demolition sites will eventually reach the stage where a
hydraulic excavator
out basements or 10

-A Ri& teoth at&w&~&kan,dq sired @drag,dowg &+w-


level stdwork aod~indurtrklp W ,
r d W k l W W h , UlzrOibs**to stspt BB
the structure before the b u i m hiuF hecm pro&~r strip& out,
t$n mvlt binmtixab &brk Gcopraiaias brickwrks rmsroary,

F g u n 48.2 A b a l l i machine working in a confined (yo8


,

I
I

I
43/8 Demolition

43.4.12 Hydraulic bursting arches which, if demolished by hand, should be in strips parallel
to the rings forming the span of the arch. Likewise, reinforced
Mass or lightly reinforced concrete can be broken by drilling a
concrete floors should be demolished in strips parallel to the
series of holes near an open face and inserting a burster from
main reinforcement.
which plungers are forced out by hydraulic pressure, thus
When working on a filler joist floor, it should be tackled
cracking the concrete.
progressively by releasing individual filler joists, whilst ensuring
A more recent application of this technique is the removal of
that the workmen have the protection of a well-secured tempor-
a core into which a small hydraulic jack is placed. When the jack
ary deck spanning the main floor beams.
is operated, the concrete will crack from the core to the open
The principle of removing as much deadload as possible also
face.
should be applied to bridges, bearing in mind that temporary
Bursting techniques are relatively quiet, but tend to be slow.
support may be necessary to support the skeleton before re-
In an effort to speed the process, large areas of concrete may be
moval by crane or dropping on to a prepared area.
broken out, but their subsequent removal, particularly if in
The procedures for demolishing chimneys by explosives re-
awkward areas inside the building, may be a problem.
volve around leaving the chimney standing on pillars created by
taking 'windows' out of the base in a pattern arranged to
encourage a particular .direction of fall when the pillars are
43.5 Demolition blasting blasted clear. If chimneys are to be demolished by hand, access
must be provided to the top. This is normally by a laddered
The use of explosives for demolition attracts a great deal of scaffold on the outside. It is normal for material to be dropped
publicity, but it should be considered as another demolition inside the chimney and removed through a doorway cut in the
method requiring careful selection based on suitability, location, side of the base. The debris must be cleared to avoid pressure on
competent practitioners and careful planning. the walls of the chimney, and regular checks must be made to
For all demolition blasting, good protection and carefully ensure that material has not arched inside the flue.
selected clear zones must be achieved. Brick, masonry or mass Brick or reinforced concrete chimneys can be treated as
concrete, when drilled and charged with explosive, will rupture described, but in prestressed and post-tensioned structures,
or disintegrate when detonated. The effect will vary and be expert advice from engineers should be sought to deal with the
dependent upon the amount and type of explosive, the weight of particular problems.
material charged in relation to the amount of explosive, the On sites in confined spaces it will be necessary to dismantle
pattern and position of the charges in relation to open faces and pylons and masts by hand, but in open areas, these can be felled
the integrity of the material. accurately by preweakening the legs against the direction of fall,
Taking these many variables into account, successful blasts cutting the rear legs and pulling over the structure with a
can be achieved and used to remove key parts to fell structures previously secured steel-wire rope.
or simply fracture banks of material to allow removal by For steel flues, the guylines at 45" on plan against the line of
mechanical excavation. fall should be maintained or, if absent, provided and made taut
With reinforced concrete, the problem becomes more com- prior to cutting the remote guys and severing the base of the flue
plex. It is easy enough to disintegrate the concrete but bursting in a pattern which allows it to hinge over.
open the steel and thus allowing the debris to disperse is not Above ground, storage tanks must be free of fire and explo-
quite so simple. The firing of test shots may be necessary, and sion risks before structural dismantling takes place. If the tank is
the manual cutting of reinforcement will (subject to advice from too large for the roof to be lifted clear as one piece, then the
engineers) assist towards a successful demolition. plates should be removed exposing the structural steel 'spider'
Recent years have seen more use of explosives on the demoli- which should be removed in a regular pattern until a simple
tion of steel structures. The cutting of steelwork was done cruciform exists which finally can be cut down.
traditionally by using substantial charges to blast a section apart Some tanks have roofs which float on the contents. Such
-a procedure which tended to have a limited application due roofs should be lowered to their supports and removed once the
to noise and the risk of shrapnel. However, the development of tank shell has been dealt with. Tank shells should be removed in
linear or cutting charges, previously well established for military horizontal bands rather than vertical strips as the behaviour of
or underwater operations, with the proviso that proprietary plateqcut down vertically is unpredictable.
products are available, has meant that such charges, coupled British Standard 6187: 1982' includes a guide to typical meth-
with the careful use of delay detonators and propellant charges ods of demolition from which it can be noted that on the more
to shift cut sections, are now regularly used to fell substantial widely found buildings and structures, more than one method
steel structures. may be applied successfully.
With all types of demolition blasting, no matter what type of There is little experience to date with the demolition of
structure, it is essential that those personnel involved under- prestressed concrete. There is, however, a recognition that
stand or have access to advice concerning the 'mechanism of uncontrolled release of stressed wires, cables or bars may
collapse'. A structure which has failed to respond to the use of provoke the ejection of anchorages, particularly if the stressed
explosives, or has partly collapsed, can be extremely dangerous member is unbonded or the bonding is faulty.
with all the attendant problems of safe access for completion of Pretensioned members are rarely a problem during demoli-
the task. tion. This is not the case with post-tensioned members, which
are sometimes incrementally tensioned as successive loading is
applied. Most post-tensioned members are bonded by grouting,
but some unbonded examples must remain and it is difficult to
43.6 Preferred methods of demolition identify the difference other than by physically exposing the
stressing wires. Expert engineering advice should be sought
Some types of structures lend themselves to particular methods when dealing with such members, as uncontrollable release of
of demolition, subject, of course, to local restraints. The basis of the tension can lead to catastrophic collapse and/or ejection of
these methods is that the sequence of work retains the stability debris from anchorages which will fly a considerable distance at
of the remaining part of the structure. great speed.
Simple examples of preferred demolition methods concern Incorrect unloading of incrementally tensioned beams with-
,o!q :
I, -> r

4u . '7

"5

Figure 43.4 Example oi temporary stsetwork supporting 8


five-storey fa@e

out partial release of the stressing can lead to hogging and/or 43.8 Health'and safety
bursting with unpredictable results.
The technology for dealing with prestressed concrete exists,
but it is important to recognize the problem at the outset. It is
also important to realize that, complex as the problems may be,
the actual method for destressing and removing prestressed
concrete beams, say, may pall into insignificance in comparison
with the problems posed by their location (which is likely to be
permanently encapsulated in working structures). red- the risks from premature collapse, falling materials and

43.2 Gatwagnand rsey~ling


, "
0s sglac pzqab, paqtic;larly t& diistm&interest:orcbi-
tectural items, such as weathercocks, clocks, door portioee awl
boundary marks may have to be recovered ahead of the
demolition work for restoration and later repositioning.
Internal fittings, staircases and banisters m y ,* &?@f

-
I
interest, particularly in listed buildings. The demolition contrac-
t@ h&a&~ieOnlly bees interatadinmet& beit d m o m or
ferrous scrap. During demolition, &tse da*eed to ba @ed &<tandad 'af &&at03 pibactirm during bumhg of
intetypeawMzeforini&dngtogrocaesorsfetittmAringor 'hd-pinted saelwdirt br Clcanitig of tta$ dost 'wilt d w d on
expoh. "he'terhaval d d resak!%F'Wil&i%' items, debrs, the n h t v&tilation g w W ~ ~ 9 t k - m . ?he use d e n a&-
window frames, flooring and china is no longer attractivr:as it is nasal mask may be df&!kdt'i$'* apcli &, @ fall
time-consuming and prohibited by tight schedules. ~bw whh
i ah ie- f ~ r a 03
r mep aifini tmdiing
The practice of recycling debris to produce a single-size app?+us &y be needed iddiadidis. me dFtcmna iti tomfbtt
crushed concrete or an all-in material has developed in reccnt hhCie a Wdenq to
years. Although it has proved difficult to maintain a specific
grading because of the variable raw material. these materials are fuk dpii-atory protection
often acceptable as backfill, subgradc for estate roads or car and the decontamination procedures required for asbestos
parks. removal have to be maintained stringently; most workmen take
Research aimed at producing a specification for crushed seriously the publicity given to the risks from this material.
concrete and subsequently a wider acceptance of its use is Apart from these two welldocumented hazards, the demoli-
currently being undertaken. In the UK this is at an early stage, tion contractor often encounters others associated with the
but in Europe it is more advanced, boosted in part by a lack of structure or its previous use. Timber used for building m a y be
acceptable landfill sites and in some areas by a lack of roadmak- treated with preservative requiring its removal to a licensed tip,
ing aggregate. as burning will produa a toxic smoke. Heavy metals such as
The recycling of timber as a fuel has been developed in The cadmium or mercury may be found mgrained in slabs or even
Netherlands where charcoal is obtained with some gas produc- the subsoil of factory premises. Sometimes these contaminants
tion. Such plants are extremely expensive and do not, as yet, surface from processes used many years prior to the final use of
exist in the UK. the premises.
43/10 Demolition

43.8.1 Fire and explosion risks Vibration may be impossible to avoid; indeed, efforts to
Flame-cutting through structures and within buildings can eradicate it by changing methods may produce other problems.
create a serious fire hazard if precautions are not taken to isolate However, the intermittent use of a demolition ball may be more
areas and clear burnable debris from underneath working areas. acceptable to neighbours than the constant noise of pneumatic
When bonfires are lit they should be carefully sited, of modest breakers.
size and be extinguished before the end of the shift. The demolition method quite obviously must take into ac-
At the other end of the scale is the devastation caused by count the susceptibility of adjacent or neighbouring structures
explosions due to the ignition of vapours from small quantities to damage from vibration, and the increasing use of sophisti-
of residues in closed vessels. cated office equipment - which is highly susceptible to vibration
Residues in petroleum, oil, gas or chemical tanks, pipes and - means that work must be organized to provide as early as
vessels remain almost indefinitely after the tanks have been possible a gap between occupied buildings and the building
drained and abandoned. Even when containers have been being demolished. Even then, there may be a problem if office
degassed, pockets of residues may remain and vaporize. equipment is in basements, picking up vibration from falling
If it is proposed to dismantle such containers using flame- debris or moving plant and vehicles.
cutters or tools which produce sparks, such as abrasive disc The major problem is dust. Sheeting and dampening down
cutters, the contents must be made inert. can reduce the inconvenience but not eliminate it completely.
Water can be used to fill a tank to exclude vapour, but it does Contractors face an increasing number of complaints about
not render the contents inert; indeed, flammable liquid may blocked filters which purify the air circulation to computer
float on top of the water. Nitrogen, an inert gas, is recom- rooms; air-conditioning units are also affected. Much can be
mended in BS 6187:1982' for purging tanks. Nitrogen is, how- done to relieve this problem if the contractor allows for the time
ever, an asphyxiant and should be handled carefully by special- and cost of additional sheeting or occasionally the use of a
ists. 'Dry ice' - frozen carbon dioxide - can also be used as an prefilter at the installation.
inhibitor. In general, the contractor can do much to prevent environ-
As well as the problems of neutralizing fuel tanks, contractors mental difficulties by good housekeeping around his sites,
are increasingly involved with the dismantling of factories which responding to complaints from the authorities and individuals,
have used chemicals in their working processes. On some and keeping local people informed of the reasons for temporary
occasions, the plants which produce or convert such chemicals inconviences.
are themselves demolished.
Notwithstanding the operator may have purged the process
equipment, pipework, tanks and vessels, they may nevertheless 43.10 Future developments
have accumulated volatile residues over a considerable period
which present health risks from toxicity or irritants. The demolition industry, as conservative as any section of the
These problems will be anticipated by experienced contrac- construction industry, watches new techniques and machinery
tors who will know where to seek the necessary expert advice. with interest as it continues to move toward greater mechaniza-
tion, encouraged both by economics and legislation, effectively
bringing about methods which allow a reduced workforce.
On a broader front, contractors recognize that their manager-
43.9 Environmental matters ial and supervisory skills will be assessed thoroughly prior to
obtaining a share of the markets becoming available, e.g.
The demolition contractor's activities will attract the attention decommissioning offshore oil installations and nuclear power
of the authorities required to look after the interests of the stations. Many governmental policy decisions will affect the
public both physically and environmentally. Local authorities
procedures .
will be concerned particularly about: ( I ) noise; (2) vibration;
and (3) dust.
Restrictions on working hours, e.g. placing limits on early
starts or imposing early finishes, or the enforcement of silent
References
periods through the day, can seriously affect site production. I British Standards Institution (1982) Code ofprac'tirefor demolition,
The level of noise acceptable at a site boundary may be settled BS 6187. BSI. Milton Keynes.
in advance by agreement with the local authority, but few 2 Health and Safety Executive, Health and sufetJ in demolition work,
developers opt for this procedure, preferring to leave the nego- Part I: 'Preparation and planning'. Guidance nole. GS29/1, HSE,
tiations to the contractor once the job has started. London.
The careful siting of diesel-driven. plant, shielding of static
items and use of electrically driven equipment (if mains power is
available) can reduce noise considerably. Good maintenance of
engines and bodywork, and the avoidance of unnecessary
dropping when loading, can also contribute to this.

You might also like