More Create Blog Sign In

2020/12/07

OSR: Review: Acid Death Fantasy About Me

Skerples
I bought Acid Death Fantasy to patch a gap in in Ultraviolet Grasslands game. The d40 "Who Is This Hero" table (UVG pg. 7) is great, but in a high-
View my
lethality game it can lead to duplicated concepts or lack of impact. More backgrounds are always handy, and, like most Troika! supplements, ADF complete
promised to have at least 36. Other material would be a nice bonus. profile

Search This Blog

Search

Books I Sell

NEW - The Monster

Overhaul - PDF
Magical Industrial
Revolution - via IPR
(US/NA)
Magical Industrial
Revolution - via
SoulMuppet (UK/EU)
Magical Industrial
Revolution - via
DriveThruRPG
Magical Murder Mansion
Kidnap the Archpriest
Epochrypha - A Book of
Speculative Ages
Tomb of the Serpent
Kings - Deluxe Print
Edition

The Index

Become a patron
Full Disclosure
The usual disclaimer. Because I'm fussy, peevish, and peculiar, and stuck in an endless miserable global pandemic, this review also has an
enormous negative bias. I usually review books by listing problems or issues and then saying "but it's still very good." This review is no different. Or donate directly.
You've been warned.

I also haven't playtested the book, but considering the content, I'm not sure playtesting would provide too many new insights.

Tags
I try to review books I a) like, b) intend to use, and c) have more interesting things to discuss than points a) and b). Anything not specifically listed as
a concern can be read as "good". Not much point in saying it over and over.
OSR worldbuilding
table session writeup
Art Magical-Industrial
It's lovely. Colourful, elegant, evocative. David Hoskin knocks it out of the park. Revolution classes
review Veinscrawl meta
The PDF is not layer-enabled. You cannot turn off art or gradient backgrounds, making home printing very costly. wizards feudalism species
adventure seeds 40k sci-fi
The Monster Overhaul
Content pirates Tomb of the Serpent
Kings UVG dungeon design
The book contains 36 backgrounds, 36 monsters, and around 3 pages of setting notes and concepts. The table of contents is hyperlinked. More GM Exercises generator
details on the contents here. star wars gimmick dungeon
Iron Gates film notes Steam
Hill mercenary medieval travel
The backgrounds are just a cleaned up version of this post. I say "just"; obviously it takes a ton time and effort to format, revise, and fix a blogpost for
one page dungeon boss fight
publication, and it looks like most backgrounds were revised or improved, but that post is more-or-less half the book.
the bright conference currency
medieval illustrations
I think it's fair to say that the book is carried by the art. The text and concepts are good on their own, but they might not "pay real-world $$$" good. Community Project Flame
Elevated and supported by the art, the book crosses into the hallowed territory of "a real proper book." Pomerium HamWarmer 24.5
Kill Team Monster Menu-All
Is this style over substance? Flash and colour over utility? A triumph of art-driven social media hype over detached analysis? microfiction poem thinking
medieval Epochrypha Kidnap
the Archpriest Magical Murder
Mansion Primogenitor
beginners imperial
megadungeon party games
fantasy flight games fate core
force and destiny islandcrawl
Indefinite Train Magical Math
Mysterious Menagerie of Doctor
Orville Boros art canon
elderstone haida index public
domain riddles starting group
tyranid world of rust

Blog Archive

► 2023 (23)
► 2022 (43)
► 2021 (29)
▼ 2020 (65)
▼ December (7)
10 Stupid yet Robust
Games for Video
Calls
OSR: Magical
Industrial
Revolution -
Loxdon Colleg...
OSR: Magical
Industrial
Weaponry
40k: Building a Space
Hulk, Part 4
OSR: Review: Acid
Death Fantasy
Conceptual Density OSR: Massive
After spending some time fiddling with Troika! backgrounds for a cancelled Space: 1977 PDF, I'm starting to think that tying Advanced Skills to Community
Backgrounds is superfluous. Hexcrawl - New
Updates

Consider this example from ADF: 40k: The Moribundan

1st Armoured
Regiment
41 Sha’ir
You weave words into poetry and spells alike. You are greatly respected by ► November (4)
the Thousand Sultans, who often pay heavily to be your patron. 
► October (5)
Possessions ► September (7)
• Unfinished Epic Poem. ► August (4)
► July (5)
What advanced skills would you assign to this background? In Troika!, Advanced Skills are rated from 1 (can do it a bit) to 4 (very, very good). Spells ► June (6)
work the same way. Typically, 6-10 skill points are assigned.
► May (2)

Highlight the text below for the canonical answer. ► April (8)
► March (6)
Advanced Skills
► February (3)
4 Poetry
2 Spell—Random ► January (8)
2 Spell—Random
► 2019 (93)
Were you close? ► 2018 (144)
► 2017 (168)
That's an issue. The conceptual density of Troika! Advanced Skills lists is often low. "You are a Goat-Jouster. Skills: 2 Goat-Riding, 2 Jousting". "You
are a Spy Skills: 2 Disguise, 2 Sneak, 1 Dodge." There are some surprises, but not many.
Further Reading
The space is wasted. You could ask players to assign a fixed number of points to a skill list, in the style of Fate Core. Results would be very similar, if
The Alexandrian
not identical, and you'd save a ton of space in your book and a lot of tedious skill point assignment during writing. A lot of backgrounds in ADF call for Running Mysteries:
an Advanced Skill "of your choice" or a random spell anyway. It might lead to optimization problems (e.g. players always putting a few points into a Enigma
fight-based skill), but there are a few ways around that. 22 hours ago

Elfmaids & Octopi

Compare this to Electric Bastionland's backgrounds, which (despite being entirely item-based) have 2 d6 tables per background. More variants, more Current Campagn Log
evocative details, more cool concepts and hints, and very little a GM could guess or condense. The density of ideas per page in EB is low due to the 1 day ago
table and art format chosen... but I liked the backgrounds enough to make a personal-use artless 3-backgrounds-per-page reference document.
tenfootpole.org
Fangs in the Dark
If you take the Advanced Skills out of a Troika! background and move to an all-in-one select/roll-your-own system, you can go from 2-3 backgrounds 2 days ago
per page to 4-5, or add a d6 table to each background. You're saving several short lines on a one-column page. That adds up quickly.
Into the Odd
Edit 2020/12/07: Some of these concerns are less related to ADF and more about Troika! in general, but core Troika! has fewer skill MAC Attack -
Assassination
lists that feel like a bullet point summary of the background's text. A function of revisions and tests? The limitations of the genre?
2 days ago

Advanced Skill lists are a tradeoff. They can be boring and waste space, but alternative methods require other trades. Part of the joy of The Graverobber's
Troika! is rolling a character with 2 in Squid Farming and figuring out how to make it work. If you switch to an "assign # points to a skill Guide
list" system, your skill list needs to be enormous, or you need to allow freeform skills and trust that your players will use them. Will they Combo Encounters
voluntarily put 4 points into Philosophy? I suppose you could stipulate that at least 1 point must be assigned to an Advanced Skill that's 2 days ago

not on the skill list. Throne of Salt

MSF: The Beloved
Then again, the ADF Desert Mutant background which has 5x "2 Skill of your choice" entries as its only Advanced Skills, is already a Student and the Dog
point-assignment system, so the concept clearly works. Knight
3 days ago

Back to ADF. The Miens (i.e. "What is this creature doing?") table for enemies is good idea taken too far. Because it's Troika!, every enemy needs a Numbers Aren't Real
d6 table of Miens. How many possible moods can a lizard have? "Basking" for 2/6 entries and "Stalking" for 2/6 entries feels like more wasted space. Fire Kills (New System for
Why not make it a d3 table? Why not have one general Reaction Roll table, or one split by beast size? Break the template when it would add utility. a New Setting)
4 days ago

False Machine
Edit 2020/12/07: A d6 table with repeated results (e.g. 5 "stationary" 1 "migrating") does provide extra info, but I'm a big fan of non- Zootopia was accidentally
repeated, non-null results. How many times will you roll on this table? Will weighting results become relevant? If you roll on a table 20 Fascist
times a session, you'll get a distribution of results. If you roll once per campaign, any clever weight tricks are hidden. Mien tables fall 4 days ago
somewhere in between; you might roll on them once, at the start of an encounter, or you might roll on them repeatedly as players
The Things We Do for
monitor a creature, or you might use them as a schedule. XP
Exeunt - shuttering this
Even if you're using repeated results, you can add extra details (table size permitting). "Basking belly-up", etc. blog (...for now?)
1 week ago

Hidden in Shadows
On the other hand, some Mien tables are full of evocative detail. It's clear that in most Troika! products there are fun Mien tables and Mien tables
Things Better Left Alone -
included from commitment to the format. Vestigial tables. Junk RPG DNA. a Sad Review
1 week ago
How much time was wasted churning out slightly pointless tables or skill assignments? Forget space on the page; could this effort have been spent Show All
making better, more useful content? It's odd that people focused on the weird deep thought evocative side of RPGs want to spend time on boring
repeated lizard moods and telling me a Dirt Farmer has 2 points in Farm Dirt.
Miniatures and Wargaming

The setting content at the end of the book also feels conceptually light. Have adventures! How? Figure it out yourself. What is this, an RPG book? Death of a Rubricist
+ inload: Leg day on
It also suggests you "cut up and mix the pages with another chapbook—the planes are colliding", which, considering the physical book is an expensive Nocturne +
2 hours ago
hardcover and the PDF is difficult to print, seems impractical.
Tale of Painters

Final Notes Showcase: Disciples of

Tzeentch Cursling
The print book is £20. 1 day ago
The PDF is $14.
LEADPLAGUE
Traitor Command -
If you like collecting pretty RPG books, ADF fits the bill. Blackstone Fortress
3 days ago
For what you get, the price feels high. The PDF of Ultraviolet Grasslands is $25 and you get a hell of a lot more fantasy acid death for your buck, but Rust + Ru][n
they work together fairly well so why not get both. If ADF had been available when UVG was released there's a decent chance I would have run UVG WIP 2 – T][Tans –
using it, instead of writing a GLOG hack. SCYLLA +
4 days ago

Art is expensive, writing is hard, and I don't see Luke Gearing or Daniel Sell rolling around in a pit of money like some silicon valley tycoon, so clearly Magpie and Old Lead
it's not extortionate. Nobody's getting rich off indie RPGs. Things cost what they cost. WarFactory Ventolin
Pirates Squad 2
4 days ago
Maybe buying ADF is closer to supporting the Idea of the Work or supporting People Who Do Good Things than purchasing something of
unsurpassed utility. I don't know. Not a Collector
Iron Warriors. Sicaran
Anyway, I got what I wanted out of it, so I'm happy. Arcus. Part1.
5 days ago

Confessions of a 40k
Posted by Skerples at 07:13 addict
#BattleReport - 1,000pts
Imperial Knights v
Tyranids
Labels: OSR, review 6 days ago

Blog / Gardens of
Hecate
Verrotwood - a Folk
2 comments: Horror Skirmish Game
6 days ago

Ray Otus 07/12/2020, 09:11 Dr. Mathias's

Miniature
Great thoughts on Troika! They address some of the concerns I've had too. My remaining question - aside from does the math of the system simply
Extravaganza
break after several advancements - is "Is the problem that the advanced skills and miens wasted space or wasted opportunity." I guess the skills sort of
Turnip28 - Grand
have to take on that predictable mode. If you used more creative advanced skills to flesh out more of the character it would beg the question of whether Bombard
they are good at the things you expected them to be, and it would also make you want to write those skills back into the description. So they are going to 1 week ago
be slaved together. In a similar way, miens could really be rewritten as a few sentences after creatures talking about general behavior (when you have
something to say, and left off when you don't). Since they monster entries seem to "require" a miens table, authors have to supply them and sometimes The Empyrean
they half-ass it. So I wonder, what if they didn't half-ass it? But then would it look like creativity for creativity's sake? I think I am just thinking out loud and Sepulchre of S=I=N:
answering my own question here. Miens are not needed. Advanced skills are probably wasted space but they do quantify the description. You could Infuriata Abnegation,
Imperial Knight
probably write them like this: 41 Sha’ir - You weave words into poetry (4) and spells (2 x 2, random) alike. You are greatly respected by the Thousand
1 week ago
Sultans, who often pay heavily to be your patron. No need for a separate list then.
Show All
Reply

Replies

Skerples 07/12/2020, 16:33

"If you used more creative advanced skills to flesh out more of the character it would beg the question of whether they are good at the things
you expected them to be".
It's a fair concern. Creativity and purple prose for its own sake, just to make sure the skill list doesn't feel like a repetition of the background
text, would also be bad.

Miens (or similar tables) are really hard to make evocative for some creatures, given the size limitations (around 2 words). There's only so
much you can do with a lizard.

Integrating skill values into the text is an interesting idea. Might break the flow of ideas, might not. It's definitely worth exploring.

Reply

To leave a comment, click the button below to sign in with Google.

SIGN IN WITH GOOGLE

Newer Post Home Older Post

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Powered by Blogger.