Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Buying Advice NetPerformanceMonitoringTools
Buying Advice NetPerformanceMonitoringTools
Buying Advice:
Network Performance and
Monitoring Tools
Peer Reviews
Inside!
E-guide
In this e-guide
In this e-guide:
Essential network monitoring
When it comes to selecting network performance management and
system features for the
enterprise p.2 monitoring tools for your organization, you literally have dozens of
products to choose from.
How to select the best
network monitoring tool p.7 But instead of drinking directly from the fire hose, it's better to come
to the product investigation and evaluation stage of the purchasing
The business case for process with a good idea of what specific features matter to you
deploying network monitoring
most.
systems p.11
Page 1 of 28
E-guide
In this e-guide
Essential network monitoring system features
Essential network monitoring for the enterprise
system features for the
enterprise p.2 Shamus McGillicuddy, Senior Analyst | Enterprise Management Associates
Network availability monitoring systems are often the first line of defense that network
How to select the best managers rely on when applications go down. In the ensuing blame game that occurs
network monitoring tool p.7 among different teams in the IT organization, the network availability monitoring
system can prove essential.
The business case for In fact, with the right system in place, the blame game doesn't even have to happen.
deploying network monitoring With good alerting and fault isolation functions, the availability monitoring tool can
systems p.11 allow the networking team to adopt a proactive posture toward service problems.
The network availability monitoring system market offers a wide variety of tools,
TechTarget survey results: ranging from open source technology that is limited in functionality and scale, to large
Network Performance enterprise products from venerable enterprise IT management vendors like IBM and
Management and Monitoring HP Enterprise. When shopping for a monitoring system, the procurement team must
p.15 map the needs of their enterprise to the network monitoring system features of the
dozens of products currently available.
TrustRadius Reviews p.18 When assembling a request for proposal (RFP) from vendors, there are several
essential things to consider: ease of deployment, usability, compatibility with existing
infrastructure, scalability and integration options with the broader IT management tool
About SearchNetworking p.28 set.
Page 2 of 28
E-guide
In this e-guide
Deployment model
Essential network monitoring When looking at how a network availability monitoring system is deployed, the first
system features for the question to ask is about licensing models. Vendors vary widely in their licensing
enterprise p.2 approaches. Some sell separate licenses for different types of monitoring capabilities,
while others charge based on how many devices or how many logical objects or
interfaces an enterprise wants to manage. Examine this closely to determine how
How to select the best costly the system is and how complex it will be to maintain.
network monitoring tool p.7
The next consideration is the actual deployment model. The procurement team
should determine if the vendor offers best practice guidelines for configuring its
The business case for system. Additionally, some monitoring systems are deployed as a single software
deploying network monitoring package, while others require separate installations and separate servers for each
systems p.11 component, including the database, the polling engine, the analytics engine and the
front-end console. Vendors that offer a deployment with multiple components
typically do so to enable maximum scalability and flexibility for their customers, but
TechTarget survey results:
this approach also adds complexity that not all enterprises want.
Network Performance
Management and Monitoring
p.15
Ease of use
TrustRadius Reviews p.18 A procurement team may assume the existing need for a network availability
monitoring system will guarantee the system it chooses will be used productively. This
is not always true. Research by Enterprise Management Associates revealed the
About SearchNetworking p.28
prevalence of enterprise shelfware -- tools that cost significant time and money to
acquire and install … that is never used.
Page 3 of 28
E-guide
The layout and flow of the management console is one of the most important network
In this e-guide monitoring system features for networking staff to evaluate. Do the charts and graphs
presented in the system make logical sense to the typical administrator? Are the
commands intuitive enough? How much training will the system require? In this
Essential network monitoring context, a proof-of-concept evaluation, where network management personnel
system features for the actually interact with the system, will help ensure it gets adopted and provides value to
enterprise p.2 the enterprise.
System scalability
About SearchNetworking p.28
Network availability monitoring systems vary widely in terms of the size of the
networks they can manage. While some vendors can monitor hundreds of devices,
Page 4 of 28
E-guide
others can monitor tens of thousands. Furthermore, while some systems can monitor
In this e-guide only a single location, others can span an entire enterprise.
It is important to determine the maximum size and level of distribution that a network
Essential network monitoring monitoring system can support -- and, more importantly, how the vendor achieves
system features for the that scalability. One vendor might monitor a large distributed network with thousands
enterprise p.2 of devices using a single server. Others might deploy multiple servers across the
enterprise and tie them together with a front-end console. These variations will
influence the usability and complexity of the system.
How to select the best
network monitoring tool p.7
Interoperability
The business case for
deploying network monitoring In all likelihood, this network monitoring system will be part of a larger IT management
systems p.11 system. The procurement team should evaluate whether the enterprise will require
integration with other management products. For instance, the network engineering
team may use the availability monitoring system to monitor and manage the network,
TechTarget survey results: while the network operations team might use a higher level service assurance system.
Network Performance Integration between the two will encourage collaboration.
Management and Monitoring
p.15 Other potential network monitoring system features include network performance
management, log analytics, application performance management, network change
and configuration management, reporting capabilities and much more. In fact, many
TrustRadius Reviews p.18 network availability monitoring vendors offer a broad suite of IT management tools
with varying degrees of integration among them. For third-party platform integration,
About SearchNetworking p.28
however, the procurement team should evaluate the technology partner ecosystem
of vendors and the types of certifications and joint support these integrations ship
with.
Page 5 of 28
E-guide
In this e-guide
Conclusion
Essential network monitoring Each of the above network monitoring system features should form the outline of the
system features for the RFP, underpinning the procurement of an availability monitoring system. There is a
enterprise p.2 large amount of variability in the market, and many vendors will promise more than
they can deliver. It is important for the networking team to fully understand
requirements for a monitoring system and to map those needs to the capabilities of
How to select the best the products they evaluate. The procurement team should get answers to all of these
network monitoring tool p.7 questions and fully test those answers in a product evaluation before making
commitments to any product.
The business case for
deploying network monitoring
Next article
systems p.11
Page 6 of 28
E-guide
In this e-guide
How to select the best network monitoring
Essential network monitoring tool
system features for the
enterprise p.2 Ed Tittel, Writer, Trainer, Internet Consultant
An important part of any network administrator's job is to monitor the network for
How to select the best performance, traffic usage, faults and availability, and to respond quickly to issues. A
network monitoring tool p.7 network-monitoring tool is a software-based or a software-hardware combination
that watches the network from end to end, collecting data on hundreds of
performance metrics, among them bandwidth, latency, responsiveness and CPU use
The business case for of hosts. A comprehensive network monitoring foundation tracks the network's
deploying network monitoring behavior and issues alerts when it exceeds a performance threshold -- whether that
systems p.11 means dipping below an acceptable level or when network traffic spikes.
Most network-monitoring products work well for typical small to midsize networks,
TechTarget survey results: whether wired or wireless. But more complex networks -- enterprise networks and
Network Performance distributed environments -- need a comprehensive platform that offers visibility into
Management and Monitoring physical and virtual servers, wide area network (WAN) links, a software-defined
p.15 network (SDN) architecture, cloud-based services, network-based applications and
the increasing number of mobile devices that connect to the network.
Page 7 of 28
E-guide
capability can also save money over the long term by enabling an enterprise to reduce
In this e-guide repetitive troubleshooting issues.
All kinds of built-in and open source network-monitoring tools are freely available. The
The business case for Ping utility, for example, is adequate for diagnosing simple host connectivity issues.
deploying network monitoring Microsoft Network Monitor provides network packet capture and analysis, which a
systems p.11 network admin might use to troubleshoot network problems. Nagios is a popular open
source network-monitoring tool; it isn't easy to set up but it provides accurate data on
many metrics. However, free tools also tend to be narrow in focus or require add-ons
TechTarget survey results:
or plug-ins for expected or additional functionality, such as auto alerts.
Network Performance
Management and Monitoring The free or patchwork approach may be affordable, but it's often inefficient.
p.15 Businesses need a robust network-monitoring product to ensure uptime,
uninterrupted access and ease of use.
TrustRadius Reviews p.18
Page 8 of 28
E-guide
implement and configure, and it should support multiple vendor devices. The product
In this e-guide you choose -- at minimum -- should include autodiscovery, node and device
inventorying, automatic and configurable trouble alerts and warnings, and they all
should be tied together through a Web-based centralized management interface. The
Essential network monitoring interface should include a dashboard with easy-to-read graphs and tables that
system features for the provide different views of network status; it should also have a network topology map
enterprise p.2 (or the ability to generate one), as well as commands for modifying network settings
and troubleshooting issues. Some interfaces provide viewing and reporting only.
How to select the best With the transition to IPv6 well underway, your choice of network-monitoring tools
network monitoring tool p.7 must also be able to detect and analyze Internet Protocol version 4 (IPv4) as well as
IPv6 traffic and protocols.
The business case for
Another feature to consider is whether to pursue an agent-based or agentless
deploying network monitoring
monitoring approach. A network-monitoring tool typically uses agents or sensors that
systems p.11 collect and transmit data to a management console for analysis. Agents require some
resources to run, which can affect performance. An agentless product, on the other
TechTarget survey results:
hand, is designed to have little to no impact on current processes.
Network Performance
Finally, many but not all network-monitoring approaches are application-aware, which
Management and Monitoring means they can detect and monitor all applications and services operating across a
p.15 network. This is an important benefit, because it enables administrators to understand
if a performance problem stems from either the network or the application itself. An
TrustRadius Reviews p.18
application-aware network monitoring tool lets IT staff track an application's response
time in detail, including server processing, network request and network response.
Page 9 of 28
E-guide
In this e-guide
Nice-to-have network monitoring features
Essential network monitoring The ability to spot trends -- both historical and what's expected -- can be a highly
system features for the useful resource for technical staff. Trend data lets an admin look back at network
enterprise p.2 performance data, whereas trend predictions provide a glimpse into the most likely
future of network performance, based on past behavior.
How to select the best Automatic capacity planning is a handy feature but not needed by every type of
network monitoring tool p.7 environment. It facilitates network-infrastructure management and optimization by
sending an alert to a network administrator whenever available memory, bandwidth or
network capacity is about to be exceeded.
The business case for
deploying network monitoring
systems p.11
The bottom line
TechTarget survey results: Look for a comprehensive network-monitoring product that meets your needs today
Network Performance and provides scalability for future network expansion. You have plenty of choices,
Management and Monitoring both open source and commercial. Open source is freely available and accessible, but
p.15 the commercial versions tend to provide all required features in an integrated
package.
Page 10 of 28
E-guide
In this e-guide
The business case for deploying network
Essential network monitoring monitoring systems
system features for the
enterprise p.2 Andrew Froehlich, President | West Gate Networks
It takes a significant amount of time and money to properly design and implement an
How to select the best enterprise-class network performance monitoring (NPM) foundation. And because of
network monitoring tool p.7 this, you need to understand not only what features are available within an NPM
package, but whether those features will actually be beneficial to your infrastructure
team.
The business case for
deploying network monitoring You may find that only the basic features are needed today, but you may want the
systems p.11 ability to add more complex tools in the future. Others might find it's best to deploy a
fully functional NPM on day one. Most, however, will likely fall somewhere in between.
In this article, we examine why these performance-oriented network monitoring
TechTarget survey results: systems bear watching and which features are most important.
Network Performance
Management and Monitoring
p.15
Downtime is becoming increasingly unacceptable
TrustRadius Reviews p.18 One obvious trend driving NPM is the need to quickly resolve downtime issues that
arise. While the ideal solution would be to create a fully redundant network from end to
end, in many cases this isn't possible. This can be due to limitations in the architecture
About SearchNetworking p.28 itself, an inability to provide physical redundancy, or budgets that preclude a fully
redundant approach. When automated failover isn't possible, the next best thing is to
develop and deploy an advanced network monitoring system platform to identify and
Page 11 of 28
E-guide
alert staff when an outage is occurring -- or about to occur. The faster a problem can
In this e-guide be identified, the faster it can be fixed.
In some cases, this simply means implementing tools to monitor network devices and
Essential network monitoring individual links. Alerting based on collected log messages is another common tool. In
system features for the other cases, monitoring all the way to the application layer is required. The vast
enterprise p.2 majority of network monitoring systems today offer the ability to monitor network-only
functions or monitor and alert on both network and application issues that arise.
Additionally, deep packet inspection appliances can rapidly find performance issues
How to select the best at critical points on the network.
network monitoring tool p.7
Page 12 of 28
E-guide
on the other hand, have QoS analysis capabilities, using NetFlow or sFlow, to
In this e-guide automatically identify ineffective or incorrectly configured QoS policies.
Page 13 of 28
E-guide
Many network monitoring systems offer added intelligence to collect and analyze
In this e-guide various network and application events. By doing so, reports can be created that
correlate -- or at least isolate -- the origin of the initial problem began. When properly
configured and tuned, this significantly reduces root cause investigations by helping
Essential network monitoring the administrator focus on the problem and verify the correlated information. And
system features for the since modern NPMs collect data up to the application level, many root causes that
enterprise p.2 previously went unnoticed can now be identified and properly remediated.
Next article
TrustRadius Reviews p.18
Page 14 of 28
E-guide
In this e-guide
TechTarget Survey Results: Network
Essential network monitoring Performance Management and
Monitoring
system features for the
enterprise p.2
First, we asked them what was driving them to purchase new network
The business case for
performance management and monitoring tools. The top 5 drivers are
deploying network monitoring
reported in the first chart below.
systems p.11
Page 15 of 28
E-guide
You will see that the top driver was the need to provide real-time network
In this e-guide analytics (50%). This was followed by the need to monitor increasing
number of users and devices (40%), extend visibility into the virtual network
Essential network monitoring
(28%), accommodate more complexity in the network (25%), and link
application performance to the underlying network infrastructure (23%).
system features for the
enterprise p.2
We then asked what features are most important when considering network
management and monitoring tools for purchase.
How to select the best
network monitoring tool p.7 As you can see in the chart on the next page, the most important feature is
bandwidth monitoring (33%), closely followed by network configuration and
management (31%). Rounding out the top 6 are firewall monitoring and
The business case for management (25%), integrated network monitoring and security features
deploying network monitoring (24%), real-time packet monitoring (20%), and integrated wired and wireless
systems p.11 network analytics (15%).
Page 16 of 28
E-guide
In this e-guide
Next article
Page 17 of 28
E-guide
In this e-guide
TrustRadius Reviews
Essential network monitoring
TrustRadius, the most trusted review site for business technology, helps buyers make
system features for the better product decisions based on unbiased and insightful reviews. Below are reviews
enterprise p.2 on network management and monitoring solutions, from vendors like CA, LANDesk,
and HP.
How to select the best
network monitoring tool p.7
CA Unified Infrastructure Management – Great
The business case for Monitoring Tool
deploying network monitoring
systems p.11 An Engineer in Information Technology specializing in Investment
Management (1001-5000 employees) submitted this review.
Page 18 of 28
E-guide
Pros
In this e-guide
• The architecture is quite scalable. It can support monitoring of
thousands of servers and network devices.
Essential network monitoring
system features for the • Key performance indicators through probes like cdm, processes, etc.,
enterprise p.2 are useful for troubleshooting purposes.
Page 19 of 28
E-guide
Page 20 of 28
E-guide
• SLM - This helps keep track of your software usage and licenses and
TrustRadius Reviews p.18
works well in conjunction with data analytics to provide data on how
often a piece is being utilized or underutilized and can automate the
About SearchNetworking p.28 harvest process of underutilized software to save on license purchases.
Page 21 of 28
E-guide
Cons
In this e-guide
It would be great if the SLM feature would work in both Chrome & IE.
Currently only supported in IE due to the use of Silverlight.
Essential network monitoring
system features for the
Return on Investment
enterprise p.2
Not having to constantly chase machines/users to check on the health of
the machines this has freed up more time for other initiatives as I can
How to select the best
manage multiple machines at the same time.
network monitoring tool p.7
Alternatives Considered
The business case for
deploying network monitoring I've used SCCM prior but not as extensively LDMS.
systems p.11 Mainly was to push software & image machines and in that aspect the both
function admirably
Page 22 of 28
E-guide
with less than 50 network devices to monitor would find HP NNM is too
In this e-guide expensive and too feature rich for their needs. Generally we find smaller
organizations just need up/down monitoring. NNM does MUCH more than
Essential network monitoring
that.
system features for the
Any organization with 100 or more network nodes would find NNM to be a
enterprise p.2
valuable solution for their network monitoring needs.
About SearchNetworking p.28 • Simple polling architecture. NNM has a single polling source allowing
the customer to keep simple ACL rules allowing NNM access to devices
across the enterprise. It also supports a hierarchical structure with
multiple instances if needed by the user.
Page 23 of 28
E-guide
• Out of box content. There are multiple dashboards available out of box
In this e-guide with the different modules that can be added onto NNM. Key
Performance Graphs include Top 10 device CPU utilization, Top 10
Essential network monitoring
Interfaces with Errors, Top 10 Interfaces with packet drops, Top 10 QoS
system features for the
violators.
enterprise p.2
• Layer 2 and Layer 3 network mapping. NNM is very good at
automatically creating network topology maps. It allows the user to
How to select the best group nodes together showing small parts of the topology to entire
network monitoring tool p.7 regions for trouble shooting or NOC monitoring.
Cons
The business case for
deploying network monitoring • Most customers would like to see NNM get away from using some Java
systems p.11 applets.
Page 24 of 28
E-guide
Page 25 of 28
E-guide
Cons
TechTarget survey results:
Network Performance • Searching multiple devices of different IP ranges or hostnames
Management and Monitoring simultaneously.
p.15
• Setting manual maintenance mode on a device to use current time as
start time.
TrustRadius Reviews p.18
• Report generation.
About SearchNetworking p.28
Page 26 of 28
E-guide
Return on Investment
In this e-guide
• Compared to competitors, CA Spectrum leverages affordability and
effectiveness.
Essential network monitoring
system features for the • Proactive solution to get a head start on Mean Time To Repair (MTTR).
enterprise p.2
• Outages can be prevented. Ex) A network switch connected to a UPS
How to select the best
(to protect from blackouts and power surges) on a failed battery will
notify net techs thru Spectrum to replace the battery before it is
network monitoring tool p.7
depleted and causes an outage to users.
Next article
Page 27 of 28
E-guide
In this e-guide
About SearchNetworking
Essential network monitoring
SearchNetworking.com is one of the largest and most active online
system features for the
communities dedicated to the enterprise network.
enterprise p.2
IT professionals in almost every industry rely on SearchNetworking.com for
How to select the best industry news, technical tips and valuable best practices on topics like
network monitoring tool p.7 routing, switching, network security, network/systems management,
convergence/VoIP and wireless LANs, so they can keep their networks up
to date and cope with constant change.
The business case for
deploying network monitoring
systems p.11
For further reading, visit us at
TechTarget survey results:
http://SearchNetworking.com
Network Performance Images; Fotalia
Management and Monitoring
©2017 TechTarget. No part of this publication may be transmitted or reproduced in any form or by any means
p.15
without written permission from the publisher.
Page 28 of 28