Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10 1002@lsm 23341
10 1002@lsm 23341
effects. However, its treatment response is variable de- compared before and after photos in chronological order,
pending on patients. The non‐ablative 1927 nm fractional separately conducted clinical assessments. The clinical
thulium fiber laser (TFL), which was used for the treat- response was measured based on a quartile grading scale
ment of Riehl's melanosis in this report, results in high (Grade 1, <25%, minimal to no improvement; Grade 2,
absorption of water, conferring greater ability to target 26%–50%, moderate improvement; Grade 3, 51%–75%,
superficial layers of the skin such as the epidermis and marked improvement; and Grade 4, >75%, near‐total
papillary dermis without epidermal ablation [6]. There- improvement) [7]. To assess the severity of dermal
fore, we hypothesized that TFL could be applied for the pigmentation objectively, dermal pigmentation area, and
treatment of Riehl's melanosis, as the histopathologic severity index (DPASI) was evaluated by two blinded
findings of Riehl's melanosis are similar to those of PIH, dermatologists [8]. The melanin index from Mexameter®
such as basal pigmentation, melanin incontinence, and (Courage+Khazaka electronic, Köln, Germany) was in-
dermal melanophages in the papillary dermis, which is vestigated as an objective measurement for improvement
the main target layer of TFL in the skin. This report in two patients (Case 1 and Case 5), whose melanin index
suggests that TFL can be an alternative and/or additive was available at the initial visit. In addition, skin his-
treatment modality for Riehl's melanosis. tologies were compared before and after 7‐session treat-
ment in one patient (Case 1). Lastly, the patients were
asked about their overall rates of satisfaction along a
MATERIALS AND METHODS
scale of very satisfied, satisfied, slightly satisfied, and
A total of nine patients (eight women; aged 47–65; Fitz- unsatisfied (Table 1).
patrick skin type III or IV), who were diagnosed with
Riehl's melanosis due to diffuse reticular hyper- RESULTS
pigmentation of the face and neck after the hair dyeing
event and underwent more than three sessions of TFL Nine patients received at least three sessions of TFL
were retrospectively examined to evaluate the safety and treatment (three to seven sessions every month) de-
efficacy of TFL for Riehl's melanosis. All information pending on its response. After the last treatment of each
including clinical images were collected after receiving patient, the DPASI score decreased from 9.55 to 5.25 on
patient consent. This study has been approved by the average. Also, the mean grade of clinical improvement
Institutional Review Board of Severance Hospital (IRB was 2.89 based on the physician's clinical assessment
no.4‐2020‐0049) and was conducted according to the Dec- using the quartile grading scale (Table 2). Six of nine
laration of Helsinki. The pigmentation was mainly located patients (67%) demonstrated marked clinical improve-
on the face for seven patients and the neck for two patients. ment of 51%–75% (Figs. 1A, B, 2A, B), one (11%) showed
Only one patient (Case 5) received a patch test to identify significant improvement of 76%–100% (Fig. 3A, B). Two
allergens, but the result was negative. If patients pre- patients who received treatment for neck lesion showed a
sented with obvious erythema of the face and neck along moderate improvement of 26%–50%, which was slightly
with gray to dark pigmentation on the initial visit (n = 5) lower than those of the patients with a facial lesion.
or the skin biopsies showed active inflammatory cell in- Moreover, two patients (Case 1 and Case 5) showed a
filtration (n = 2, the biopsy was performed in five patients), significant decrease in the melanin index after TFL
oral prednisolone (10 mg per day) was prescribed for 2–8 treatment (Table 2). The patients' degree of satisfaction
weeks before the start of laser treatment. All nine patients revealed that 8 of 9 patients were very satisfied or sat-
showed little improvement with various treatment options isfied and one was slightly satisfied. And as shown in
such as bleaching agent with Kligman formula, IPL, low Figure 4A, B, the skin histology after the last session re-
fluence QS‐Nd:YAG laser, and pulsed dye laser (PDL). vealed a marked decrease in epidermal melanin and
The entire face was completely cleansed using a mild soap dermal melanophages (Case 1).
and 70% alcohol before treatment. Topical anesthesia cream The treatment was well tolerated, without the need for
(Enkine™, Kolmar Korea, Sejong, Korea) was applied for systemic analgesics. Side effects were mild and limited to
1 hour before the procedure. Treatment with non‐ablative transient, mild erythema, which faded away within
fractional TFL (LASEMD™; Lutronic Corp., Goyang, Korea) 3 days.
was performed at monthly intervals. The treatment, with
settings of 5 W for the output power and 10–20 mJ for the DISCUSSION
pulse energy with a dynamic and random mode, was deliv- Riehl's melanosis is characterized by diffuse facial hy-
ered to the face and neck with multiple passes (3–5 passes) perpigmentation that is especially distributed on the
in each session. Patients were instructed to use a mild forehead and the zygomatic and temporal areas. Various
cleanser and moisturizer several times daily for the first few chemicals and natural substances are suggested to be the
days after each treatment session to promote wound healing causes of Riehl's melanosis. Efforts have been made to
and prevent dryness. accurately define the relevant entities, but the exact di-
Photographic documentation using identical camera agnosis criteria and the pathogenesis of Riehl's melanosis
settings, lighting, and patient positioning were obtained are not clear yet.
before each treatment session and every visit for a suc- Based on the unclear pathogenesis of Riehl's melanosis
cessive treatment. Two blinded dermatologists, who and the vague disease entity, various methods such as
TABLE 1. Baseline Characteristics and Treatment History Before 1927 nm Fractional Thulium Fiber Laser
Patient
number Age Sex Skin type Region Previous treatment Patch test Skin biopsy Oral steroid administration
1 51 F IV Face IPL 1064 nm Nd:Yag N/A Basal vacuolization upper dermal lymphocytic 4 weeks (PL 5 mg twice
infiltration scattered melanophages daily)
2 52 F III Face Kligman's triple combination N/A Melanin incontinence in the upper dermis 2 weeks (PL 5 mg twice
daily)
3 64 F III Face PDL Pico‐second 1064 nm Nd:Yag N/A N/A 2 weeks (PL 5 mg twice
daily)
4 48 F IV Face Kligman's triple combination PDL N/A Upper dermal melanophages 2 weeks (PL 5 mg twice
1064 nm Nd:Yag daily)
5 55 F III Face Kligman's triple combination Negative Upper dermal melanophages 2 weeks (PL 5 mg twice
daily)
6 47 F III Neck Kligman's triple combination N/A N/A None
7 65 F III Neck 1064 nm Nd:Yag N/A Superficial perivenular lymphocytic infiltration 8 weeks (PL 5 mg twice
with upper dermis daily)
8 49 F III Face Kligman's triple combination N/A N/A N/A
9 44 M III Face Kligman's triple combination N/A N/A 2 weeks (PL 5 mg twice
daily)
IPL, intensive pulsed light; Kligman's triple combination, 4% hydroquinone, 0.05% tretinoin, 0.01% fluocinolone; PDL, pulsed dye laser.
TABLE 2. Treatment Regimens, Parameters and Responses After 1927 nm Fractional Thulium Fiber Laser
Initial Final
Initial Final mexameter mexameter
Patient Treatment Energy DPASI DPASI (melanin (melanin Improvement Patients Adverse
number sessions (mJ) Passes score score index, Rt./Lt.) index, Rt./Lt.) Improvement (%) grade satisfaction event
satisfied erythema
2 4 15 5 7.8 3.8 N/A N/A 51‐75 3 Satisfied Mild
erythema
3 4 15 4 8.4 2 N/A N/A 76‐100 4 Very None
satisfied
4 3 20 4 15.3 9.2 N/A N/A 51‐75 3 Satisfied None
5 6 15 4 16 9.3 421/375 222/229 51‐75 3 Satisfied None
6 5 20 4 6.3 5.4 N/A N/A 26‐50 2 Slightly Mild
satisfied erythema
7 7 10 3 4.95 4.05 N/A N/A 26‐50 2 Very None
satisfied
8 3 15 6 7.2 3.5 N/A N/A 51‐75 3 Satisfied None
9 3 15 6 10.6 5.8 N/A N/A 51‐75 3 Satisfied None
3
Fig. 1. (A) Case 1: a 51‐year‐old female (upper) before and (lower) after seven sessions of
treatment with the fractional 1927 nm thulium fiber laser. The patient showed marked
(51%–75%) improvement in hyperpigmentation of the face. (B) Magnified photography from
Case 1, which shows the decreased reticular pigmentation on both cheeks (upper: before
treatment, lower; after seven sessions of treatment).
IPL, QS‐Nd:YAG laser, and topical bleaching agents combined with PDL or IPL before introducing treatment
have been proposed as therapeutic modalities. As a light‐ with fractional TFL, but repeated treatment did not result
based treatment modality, IPL, and low/mid fluence in sufficient therapeutic response. One previous study
QS‐Nd:YAG laser have been used with evidence of mod- using a low fluence QS‐Nd:YAG laser for Riehl's mela-
erate improvement, and repeated treatment sessions were nosis suggested that 10–18 treatment sessions were
required for obtaining improvement [9,10]. To date, sev- needed to demonstrate sufficient efficacy [11]. Another
eral reports of laser treatment for Riehl's melanosis have study using a mid fluence QS‐Nd:YAG laser showed
described application of repetitive treatments using low/ moderate efficacy after above six times of treatment ses-
mid energy. In our study, four of nine patients previously sions [12]. As this low/mid energy approach requires
received low/mid fluence QS‐Nd:YAG laser treatment several treatment sessions, and current treatment
Fig. 2 . (A) Case 2: a 52‐year‐old female (upper) before and (lower) after four sessions of
treatment with the fractional 1927 nm thulium fiber laser. The patient showed marked
(51%–75%) improvement in hyperpigmentation of the face. (B) Magnified photography from
Case 2, which shows the brightened tone due to decrease of the reticular, slightly yellowish
pigmentation.
FRACTIONAL LASER ON RIEHL'S MELANOSIS 5
Fig. 3. (A) Case 3: a 64‐year‐old female (upper) before and (lower) after four sessions of treatment
with the fractional 1927 nm thulium fiber laser. The patient showed significant (76%–100%)
improvement in hyperpigmentation of the face. (B) Magnified photography from Case 3, which
shows the decreased reticular pigmentation on both temporal areas. Lentigo‐like
postinflammatory hyperpigmented patches on both cheeks showed faint color.
modalities have limited efficacies, new modalities for melasma and PIH [14]. For example, it has been reported
management of Riehl's melanosis are required. that 1550 nm erbium‐doped fiber laser is a safe and ef-
Based on the theory of fractional photothermolysis (FP), fective treatment for PIH. Meanwhile, the 1927 nm frac-
which was first introduced in 2004 [13], a fractional laser tional TFL has a higher absorption coefficient for water
divides the ray of the laser, creating a microscopic column than the 1550 nm wavelength, which allows for more
of thermal injury called a microscopic treatment zone precise targeting of the epidermis and superficial dermis
(MTZ). By producing such a precise column of thermal without ablation [14,15]. In addition, the maximum pen-
injury, it has the advantage of rapid recovery of skin etration depth of TFL is 200 μm, which can more effec-
tissue after laser treatment [13]. tively target the melanin pigmentation in dermoepi-
Various fractional lasers have been reported to have dermal junction through MTZs than a 1550 nm
efficacy for various acquired pigment diseases including wavelength with a penetration depth range of
Fig. 4. Histopathologic findings in Case 1 (left) before and (right) after seven sessions of
treatment with the fractional 1927 nm thulium fiber laser. A prominent decrease of
melanophages in the upper dermis is noted (hematoxylin and eosin stain; ×100).
6 KIM ET AL.
1400–1500 nm, which can delay wound healing and more to treat Riehl's melanosis, due to the fact that there is no
likely cause PIH. Therefore, Riehl's melanosis, which is cure that shows an effect in a relatively short time while
represented by numerous upper dermal melanin par- increasing patient satisfaction to date.
ticles, might successfully be treated with the 1927 nm
fractional TFL. Also, similarly to PIH, pigmentation in CONCLUSIONS
Riehl's melanosis is closely associated with inflammation
This study, although not randomized or well‐
and injury in the dermoepidermal junction. The shallow
conditioned but a pilot study with a small number of
penetration depth of thulium laser minimizes additional
patients, is, at least to our knowledge, the first report
inflammation by targeting mainly epidermal cells, re-
regarding the effectiveness and safety of TFL on Riehl's
verses the disruption of the dermoepidermal junction
melanosis. The effectiveness and safety of TFL observed
(basement membrane), and induces neocollagenosis and
in this study provide sufficient justification for further
elastinogenesis in the upper dermis, that is, remodeling of
precisely designed clinical trials. The TFL does not di-
the pathologic dermis [16]. Therefore, 1927 nm thulium
rectly target melanin pigments, unlike QS‐Nd:YAG laser
laser could be also useful for postinflammatory hyper-
or light‐based devices such as IPL and PDL. Instead, it is
pigmentation including Riehl's melanosis, in which mel-
thought that numerous melanin pigments in the der-
anophages, the main pathology of pigmentation are
moepidermal junction and upper dermis, which are typ-
mostly located in the upper dermis.
ical histologic findings of Riehl's melanosis, can be effec-
Most studies regarding 1927 nm fractional TFL have
tively targeted by TFL. In conclusion, the TFL might be
focused on the treatment of melasma and PIH, sug-
an alternative and/or additive treatment option for in-
gesting it is a safe and effective treatment option
tractable pigmentation in Riehl's melanosis and also PIH
[7,17,18]. In particular, in PIH treatment, whose
caused by any other reasons, although the effects of TFL
pathogenesis and histologic features are similar to
on Riehl's melanosis and PIH need to be validated by
Riehl's melanosis, TFL was reported to show a prom-
well‐controlled, randomized clinical trials.
ising effect. Lee et al. [19] reported a case in which the
patient experienced marked improvement of PIH after
four sessions of TF with the use of 4% hydroquinone. A ACKNOWLEDGMENT
retrospective study that enrolled 61 patients with PIH We thank Dr. Won Seok Roh for his help in preparing for
showed that the mean percent improvement after the photographs.
treatment evaluated by the two dermatologists was
43.24%, and treatment sessions ranged from 2 to 5 [16].
Also in our study, a relatively small number of treat- REFERENCES
ment sessions (three to seven sessions) of TFL achieved 1. Serrano G, Pujol C, Cuadra J, Gallo S, Aliaga A. Riehl's
considerable clinical improvement (more than 50% in melanosis: Pigmented contact dermatitis caused by fra-
grances. J Am Acad Dermatol 1989;21(5 Pt 2):1057–1060.
quartile grading scale) in six of nine patients with 2. Mikhail M, Sceppa J, Smith BL, Chu P, Marghoob AA. Four
Riehl's melanosis (67.7%), which had shown minimal or views of areolar melanosis: Clinical appearance, dermoscopy,
no response to previous treatments. In the aspect of an confocal microscopy, and histopathology. Dermatol Surg
2008;34(8):1101–1103.
objective assessment, melanin index from two patients 3. Sugai T, Takahashi Y, Takagi T. Pigmented cosmetic der-
whose melanin index was available at their initial visits matitis and coal tar dyes. Contact Dermatitis 1977;3(5):
showed a marked decrease. Also in histologic evalua- 249–256.
tion, though the biopsies before and after laser treat- 4. Perez‐Bernal A, Munoz‐Perez MA, Camacho F. Management
of facial hyperpigmentation. Am J Clin Dermatol 2000;
ment were performed in only one patient (Case 1), a 1(5):261–268.
marked decrease of melanophages in the upper dermis 5. Fabi SG, Friedmann DP, Niwa Massaki AB, Goldman MP.
was evidently observed. However, residual dermal pig- A randomized, split‐face clinical trial of low‐fluence Q‐
switched neodymium‐doped yttrium aluminum garnet
mentation was still observed although significant re- (1,064 nm) laser versus low‐fluence Q‐switched alexandrite
duction of pigmentation was achieved by TFL. Despite laser (755 nm) for the treatment of facial melasma. Lasers
the advantage of TFL targeting epidermis and/or upper Surg Med 2014;46(7):531–537.
6. Kwon IH, Bae Y, Yeo UC, et al. Histologic analyses on the
dermis with a minimal side effect, the shallow pene-
response of the skin to 1,927‐nm fractional thulium fiber
tration of TFL can be the limitation of the treatment for laser treatment. J Cosmet Laser Ther 2018;20(1):12–16.
Riehl's melanosis if Riehl's melanosis also exhibits 7. Polder KD, Bruce S. Treatment of melasma using a novel
pigmentation in the deeper skin layer and not only in 1,927‐nm fractional thulium fiber laser: A pilot study. Der-
matol Surg 2012;38(2):199–206.
the superficial layer. 8. Kumaran MS, Dabas G, Vinay K, Parsad D. Reliability as-
In this study, no patient experienced side effects such as sessment and validation of the dermal pigmentation area
scarring or PIH. A low possibility of PIH after TFL in and severity index: A new scoring method for acquired
dermal macular hyperpigmentation. J Eur Acad Dermatol
Riehl's melanosis could come from its fractional system, Venereol 2019;33(7):1386–1392.
relatively shallow penetration depth, and intact coagu- 9. Li YH, Liu J, Chen JZ, et al. A pilot study of intense pulsed
lation zone without ablation. By these pieces of data, in- light in the treatment of Riehl's melanosis. Dermatol Surg
cluding efficacy results and safety profile, it can be an- 2011;37(1):119–122.
10. On HR, Hong WJ, Roh MR. Low‐pulse energy Q‐switched
ticipated that the 1927 nm thulium fiber laser may be a Nd:YAG laser treatment for hair‐dye‐induced Riehl's mela-
promising alternative and/or additive treatment modality nosis. J Cosmet Laser Ther 2015;17(3):135–138.
FRACTIONAL LASER ON RIEHL'S MELANOSIS 7
11. Kwon HH, Ohn J, Suh DH, et al. A pilot study for triple 16. Bae YC, Rettig S, Weiss E, Bernstein L, Geronemus R.
combination therapy with a low‐fluence 1064 nm Q‐switched Treatment of post‐inflammatory hyperpigmentation in
Nd:YAG laser, hydroquinone cream and oral tranexamic acid patients with darker skin types using a low energy
for recalcitrant Riehl's melanosis. J Dermatol Treat 1,927 nm non‐ablative fractional laser: A retrospective
2017;28(2):155–159. photographic review analysis. Lasers Surg Med
12. Cho MY, Roh MR. Successful treatment of Riehl's melanosis 2020;52(1):7–12.
with mid‐fluence Q‐switched Nd:YAG 1064‐nm laser. Lasers 17. Kurmuş G, Tatlıparmak A, Aksoy B, Koç E, Aşiran Serdar Z,
Surg Med 2020;52(8):753–760. Ergin C. Efficacy and safety of 1927 nm fractional Thulium
13. Manstein D, Herron GS, Sink RK, Tanner H, Anderson RR. fiber laser for the treatment of melasma: A retrospective
Fractional photothermolysis: A new concept for cutaneous study of 100 patients. J Cosmet Laser Ther 2019;21(7‐8):
remodeling using microscopic patterns of thermal injury. 408–411.
Lasers Surg Med 2004;34(5):426–438. 18. Niwa Massaki ABM, Eimpunth S, Fabi SG, Guiha I, Groff W,
14. Dunbar S, Posnick D, Bloom B, Elias C, Zito P, Goldberg DJ. Fitzpatrick R. Treatment of melasma with the 1,927‐nm
Energy‐based device treatment of melasma: An update and fractional thulium fiber laser: A retrospective analysis of 20
review of the literature. J Cosmet Laser Ther 2017; cases with long‐term follow‐up. Lasers Surg Med 2013;
19(1):2–12. 45(2):95–101.
15. Cho SB, Zheng Z, Kang J‐S, Kim H. Therapeutic efficacy of 19. Lee SJ, Chung WS, Lee JD, Kim HS. A patient with cupping‐
1,927‐nm fractionated thulium laser energy and poly- related post‐inflammatory hyperpigmentation successfully
deoxyribonucleotide on pattern hair loss. Med Lasers treated with a 1,927 nm thulium fiber fractional laser.
2016;5(1):22–28. J Cosmet Laser Ther 2014;16(2):66–68.