Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dialect Variation in Korean
Dialect Variation in Korean
Dialect Variation in Korean
‘kaoliang’ a7) |
ernally and it ‘ZU (Ch'éngju), BAe heat itup’ 42
ser south: 24° 2-72] (Vongdong) i
|
er.” Again, itis
I dialect which 2.2. Northwest (P'yéngan, Hwanghae provinces)
2.2.1. Ptyongan dialects
‘There is widespread agreement that North and South P'y6ngan together form a
coherent dialect grouping, with the exception of Chasing and Huch’ang in the |
northeast comer of North P*yéngan, which belong linguistically to the northeast or |
‘bs of standard :
‘Hamgydng grouping.268, Korean Language in Culture and Society
Phonological ~ phonetic features
P'yongan dialects have 8 vowels (i, ¢, ae, &, 3, a, u, 0). Corresponding to standard
2 this dialect has wae, oi, o, e, and we: # ($1) ‘unit of weight,’ }™+ (21°) ‘bask,’
Be] (SEH ‘coagulate,’ 2.211 (13) ‘left side,’ Ze] (4) ‘raw fish.”
Corresponding to standard ii 7] this dialect has wi and u: 7] (74) ‘ear,’ AE AEH
‘rest,’ "SUF (S44) “donkey,” BEF (HHI) ‘wheel,’ AHF (A) ‘son-in-law.”
P'ydngan dialects have 10 diphthongs: ye, yd, ya, yu, yo and wi, we, wae, w0, wa.
Earlier yV and wV lose their glides (y or w) after -, 2, A, %, %, Moreover,
standard yd is realized as e: ¥) (#4) ‘rice plant,’ 7}¥144 (724) ‘while going,’ SRE
(CE FUE A) ‘yanghan, gentleman,’ Y's (2% #74) ‘order,’ A
(QF — it) ‘current, first class,’ 2 (7B (7) ‘completion,’ 7F504 PHL —
FAITH ‘went’ (honorific), 8A] CHA) — 8) 8} 0} 41) “rubs and,’ 271)
(S4]A] — $9] 0 4) ‘melts it and,’ AEF BH) “lost.”
Pydngan dialects are virtually unique in that they never underwent the wave of
palatalization which came out of the south and swept over most of Korea starting in
the eighteenth century. (The Yukchin dialects in northernmost Hamgyng were also
spared from palatalization.) Thus, P’yOngan dialects show neither the t-palatalization
that has affected even the standard language, nor the k- and h-palatalizations
prevalent in southern and northeastem dialects. Whereas most dialects of Korean
pronounce %, *, % as ch, ch’, tch, respectively, P'ySngan dialects pronounce 1s, is",
1s’, Historically, -, ©, %, © did not palatalize before i, y, either, nor did initial n
before i, y drop as it did elsewhere in Korea: 4} (°]"} — MK 4%) ‘forehead,’
AN (AR) ‘hunting,’ 3% (BZ — 3 — YZ) ‘elderly gentleman,’ +O G4
<— WR — SA AA) Tune! BQ) ‘straw,’ BS (AA] — AC] Kt) sheaven
and earth,’ $2} (S8} — Fe +8 ‘middle school,” Ct (standard FT — MK
tyohta) ‘good, 7] (71 — C71) ‘over there,” ES CE — ai)
“schoolmaster.”
‘As one might expect in light of these palatalization facts, Pyéngan dialects also
preserve # after coronal consonants: 44" (31H) ‘bland,’ SC+ (TH) ‘mushy,’
2a (17) Yeh) “dizzy, confused.”
P'ydngan dialects have distinctive vowel length (although the length is not marked
in the orthography).
Verb morphophonemics and/or other peculiarities
‘The shape of the standard infinitive vowel -d/-a -01/-°} is here just -a -°F, regardless
of the quality of the preceding vowel: kaniirasd mot ssiiganniinde 7°} &
2BKE0] HEA BE AABVEE) ‘it’s too flimsy to use," peaeji-ril kaduara
32) S EOF (1 THF] eh ‘put the pig away.”
In addition to the subject marker ©], P'yéngan has another subject particle, #/#l.
For example, We} LHASA (H7} L5RO}.A) ‘I did it.’ For standard future-
presumptive -2, P'ySngan has -21/-7}4] and ~@/-%: SPCb (8b2RTH) ‘will do,”
EAS. (7FRVR) “will go,” ACE (AEH ‘will eat,’ "| 7b) 2 (2 Ae 2)
will eat’; HAE, BBUF (BHE] CH ‘will do,’ WAT, BOB (Yee H ‘will
a
a
Dialectal Variation
take charge of.’ Fi
Both Sk
past -2 combine 1
and -@1? respectiv
(someone) eat?” 4
dialects, P*yongan
P'ydngan dialect »
Standard
opel] ‘gran
ohH A) ‘unch
D4 ‘red peppe
3 ‘black pep
AACE ‘cheap’
]¢} ‘expens
BY Sjust now’
THA) ‘again’
2.2.2. Mwanghi
Scholars have bee
them with P*yéngi
them (somewhat 1
aside as a special t
Phonological ~ ph
Hwanghae dialects
yae, Ya, yt, yo and
the first syllable, :
others. Hwanghae
P*yongan dialects:
‘Standard
1 7]-2} “by fee
*87]-1 ‘by pu
‘The Hwanghae dia
H-palatalization ¢
K-palatalization is,‘ure and Society
to standard 6
(AH “bask,”
) ‘raw fish.”
“ach aeh
on-in-law."
wae, w6, wa
%, Moreover,
= going,’ SNE
“order, U5
BORE
and,’ AIA}
it the wave of
rea starting in
ng were also
-palatalization
galatalizations
21s of Korean
‘nounce ts, ts",
ve did initial n
) “forehead,”
weeded
ith) ‘heaven
Th < MK
— WIE)
1 dialects also
1h) *mushy,”
is not marked
©}, regardless
aeoby &
rit kaduara
article, 2/3]
dard future
=) ‘will do,’
LAS)
2.217) ‘will
i
Dialectal Variation in Korean 269,
take charge of.’ For standard past tense -91/-Si, P’yongan has -3/-2, oT:
APLC} CEH) ‘caught,’ WHA .L (ANOVA) ‘caught.’ When the future 2 and
past -2 combine wit the iterrogative endings in -=14? and -U1? they produce 24?
land -C'? respectively: 82+? (844142) ‘will (someone) do?” "1222 (AAY ‘will
Gomeone) eat?” $7 (SHU “did (Someone) catch?” Like some other Korean
dialects, P’yingan has just three speech levels: low, equal, and respect.
P'ydngan dialect vocabulary examples
Standard Pryongan Standard Pryongan
go} 2] ‘granddad’ + Zo}A|¥), eh] 712]7} eh take along’ m7
Aowia), au) ‘UES ‘dumplings’ = EE
gop) a} OWS 2 ‘kids’ shoes’ EF
Sopa) ‘uncle’ Boh} _ AAS ‘almost ae
ated pepper’ Y7H1, B,D WA together” OS
3% black pepper” SFE FE ‘mostly” Ae}
ALC} ‘cheap’ st} & ‘always” Be
HARE} expensive’ AFCh #4) ‘terribly’ Ash
PY justnow’ aE E ‘right away" 4
T}A] ‘again’ aH 2] ‘quickly’ aay
2.2.2, Hwanghae dialects
Scholars have been divided over how to classify Hwanghae dialects; some include
them with P'yéngan province dialects as part of the northwest group, others include
them (somewhat uncomfortably) with the central dialects, and yet others set them
aside as a special transitional group between central dialects and northwest dialects,
Phonological ~ phonetic features
Hwanghae dialects have 9 vowels (i, ¢, ae, [5], %, 6, a 0), and 10 diphthongs: ye,
yae, ya, yu, yo and wi, we, wae, W0, wa, However, ¢ and ae are only distinguished
the first syllable, and 6 is unstable, appearing as such in some words and as we in
others. Hwanghae dialects treat the so-called infinitive suffix -6 -©} differently from
P’yéngan dialects:
Standard Hwanghae P*yongan
2} 7]-0] “by feeding’ aA all
*§7)-21 “by pulling’ BA gal
‘The Hwanghae dialects have undergone t-palatalization just like the Kyénggi dislects
VEpalatalzation can be found in regions other than Hwangju and Pongsan, and
kcpalatalization is not found at all.270 Korean Language in Culture and Society
In its suprasegmental features, Hwanghae is somewhat unusual in that it is
virtually the only dialect area (besides Cheju Island) to lack both distinctive vowel
length and pitch accent.
Verb morphophonemics and/or other peculiarities
Like P'yéngan dialects, in addition to °1/7F for the subject marker, Hwanghae also
has 2}, #, #]. Some typical Hwanghae question endings are: -U47f, -*] 7, -71,
-7)24, -©]. Example: 217] Zhe} 940]? (0}¢] 3k} 8442) “Where have you been?”
Hwanghae dialect vocabulary examples
Standard Hwanghae Standard Hwanghae
what ‘side dishes’ 171) ‘Gal bridle’ sa
GL ‘red pepper’ a7) ¥# ‘black pepper’ a=
EH “pouch? — 7A SAIC} ‘fling down’ 87}E1C}
t= ‘evening glow’ 2712) Each “ainty* each
23. Northeast (Hamgyéng)
‘The body of published research on Hamgyéing dialects (including Yukchin dialect) is
not substantial, but it is common to distinguish north and south Hamgyong sub-
dialects. T’aegyun Kim (1983) recognizes three sub-areas within North Hamgydng:
the Musan region, the Salip region, and the Yukchin region in the extreme northeast.
Some scholars (¢.g., Zhio and Xun 1986) are of the opinion that the region should
be classified as a new, seventh independent dialect, while others prefer to view it as a
conservative dialect island within Hamgy®ng.
Phonological ~ phonetic features
There is a great deal of disagreement in the literature about vowel inventories for both
the North Hamgyéng (including Yukchin) and the South Hamgydng dialect,
depending on when and where the data was collected. According to both Ramsey
(1978: 58) and Kidong Yi (1993: 22-4), South HamgyOng Pukch’dng dialect has 10
vowels (i, ¢, ae, 6, i i da, u, 0), and 11 diphthongs (ye, yae, ¥%, ya, yu, yo and wi,
we, wae, wé, wa). But Ch’unggu Kwak (1998) reports an ‘unstable 8-vowel" system
for a recent defector from Hamju,
By contrast, the traditional Yukchin dialect has an 8-vowel system, replacing
and ii with we and wi, respectively. Earlier Yukchin materials maintain a clear
distinction between e and ae, as do living speakers of this dialect in the former USSR,
but North Korean scholars claim these vowels have merged in contemporary Yukchin
dialect. Ch'unggu Kwak (1998) writes that Yukchin speakers from China have a 9-
vowel system, and have innovated ii, whereas dialects from further south are moving
toward an 8-vowel system by moving > iand — e.
j
=
Dialectal Variation it
Diphthongs in 1
absolute word-initi
before y, as well :
mel) CS) ‘f
Yukchin dialect all
(@P ‘short,’ tyol
wae, w6, wa lose tt
‘Umilaut is ram
Hamgyéng dialects
due also to an earli
their citation form
original ito i afte
}e1P14) ‘mothe
= is pronounce:
positions, except t
feature was first n
(1987) for Soviet 1
MK -z- is usua
FAL GHP) ‘m
‘dandelion,’ #7]
“evening glow,’ %
and ‘p-irregulat’
(CLEP ‘was hot
South and Not
and pronounce 7
(He) "bad harve
(A) ‘road,’ ete.
pronounces *, 7
its refusal of tp
Moreover, Yukch
Vi vs. Isy + Vi,
(2.2) ‘by hance
North and Sot
before i, y and na
“bean” whereas,
negative particle
only ng.
‘A major featu
is distinctive pite
South have just I
distinctive H pit
Songjin, and Tar
least in first sylla
Hamgyong di
those dialects wure and Society
1 in that it is
stinctive vowel
Awanghae
1, AVA, ~
e you been?”
Hwanghae
a
iL
areeh
each
chin dialect) is
lamgyong sub-
‘th Hamgyong:
‘eme northeast
region should
to view it asa
tories for both
zyOng dialect,
both Ramsey
dialect has 10
yu, yo and wi,
vowel’ system
ny, replacing &
vimain a clear
former USSR,
orary Yukchin
hina have a 9-
ith are moving
Dialectal Variation in Korean mn
Diphthongs in Hamgydng dialects, as in Kyéngsang dialects, can only occur in
absolute word-initial position. This is due partly to the palatalization of =, tw, =
before y, as well as to the sound change 2 — 4}, as in Al, A") (81) “tongue,”
wel7] CHS) ‘flea, A, AS (1S) ‘winter,’ 173 CF) “viewing.” But
Yukchin dialect allows combinations like ©}, Ti, 3, 77 and UF, Vi, 2, Ht: r'yaniida
(AED ‘short, tyohta (ETH) ‘good,’ nyaegi (01°F?) ‘story,’ ete. The diphthongs we,
‘wae, w6, wa lose their w after consonants
‘Umlaut is rampant in Hamgydng dialects, thanks in large part to the fact that
Hameyéng dialects until recently had only °l (and no 74) for the subject marker, and
due also to an earlier process whereby many nouns in Hamgyéng incorporated °} into
their citation forms, Whereas Hamgysng dialects other than Yukehin have fronted
original # to # after 2, ©, *, Yukchin dialect keeps the original vowel: ~2.F4
(2}e} 244) ‘mother-in-law,’ ®1& (74 2) ‘several days.”
s pronounced as a tap, or (more often) as a tilled [1] (two or three taps) in all
positions, except before another ©: irtsiigi (QL) ‘early,’ targi (Bt) ‘chicken.’ This
feature was first reporied by Yéngsun Han (1967: 148), and was described by King
(1987) for Soviet Korean (which has its origins in Hamgyong dialects)
“MK -2-is usually feflected as -5-, MK -G- as -f-, and MK -W- as -p-, Examples:
PA) (GR) ‘manger’ UA] (Bel) ‘shepherd's purse,” Seed sa)
‘dandelion,’ “$71 (Ed << MK kumki) ‘hole,’ 2273 (1) ‘shelf, eRe] (eS)
‘evening glow,’ 4)3] (4) ‘cold, 8427, & 422} (Z}) ‘alone.’ The ‘s-irregular’
and ‘p-irregular’ verbs of standard Korean are regular in HamgyOng dialects: 10b6-tta
(€) CH ‘was hot,’ pus-ds6 (34014) ‘pours and so/then.”
South and North Hamgyong dialects have undergone t-, h-, and k-palatalization
and pronounce % and % as ch and ch’, respectively, as in standard speech: $a
(Ha) “bad harvest,’ 4B (BA) “older sibling,” chirtymi (7B) ‘oil; butter,’ chiri
() ‘road,’ ete. But Yukchin dialect has only sporadic. h-palataization and
pronounces %, % a8 ts, ts’. Thus, Yukchin dialect patterns with P'yongan dialects in
ite refusal of epalatalization (but, unlike P'yéngan dialects, retains earlier /Cy/).
Moreover, Yukchin preserves the MK distinction between syllables of the type /s +
Vi vs. Isy + Vi eg, syubagi (PYF < earlier syupak) ‘watermelon,’ but sonillit
(&2.B) ‘by hand’ (see Xuan et al. [1990] for more on this).
North and South Hamgydng dialects have a pervasive rule which drops» and ng
before i, and nasalizes the preceding vowel. Thus, 'di (= MK k’ong —» %) means
“bean” whereas k’oi (~ MK koh —>52) without nasalization means “nose.” The
negative patticle is ai ( MK ani ~ ©}+). In the Yukchin dialect, this rule affects
only ng.
"s major feature of Hamgyéng dialects which they share with Kyongsang dialects
is distinctive pitch accent. Most dialects in the North (including Yukchin) and the
South have just H and L surface pitches, and Hamgydng preserves the MK locus of
distinctive H pitch. Ch'unggu Kwak (1991) has shown that the Kilchu, Haksong,
SOngjin, and Tanch’én regions of North Hamgydng preserve the MK rising tone, at
least in first syllables.
Hamgydng dialects are usually described as lacking distinctive vowel length, but
those dialects which preserve the MK rising tone have long vowels, and other272 Korean Language in Culture and Society
dialects, even if they do not preserve original MK length, nevertheless have numerous
long vowels as a result of complex compensatory lengthening processes at the
boundaries between noun and particle and between verb stem and ending. The
southernmost areas of South Hamgydng, in the transitional region, show different
reflexes of pitch accent. Thus, Yénghiing and Anbyén both have distinctive vowel
length (but no pitch accent), whereas Koan and Munch’n, like the Hwanghae and
Cheju dialects, have neither vowel length nor pitch accent (Sanggyu Yi 1995: 390).
Verb morphophonemics and/or other peculiarities
Hamgyong dialects preserve a number of alternations in both nouns and verbs which
can be traced back to MK. In the case of nouns, one finds, for example,
UF (MK namk-) ‘tree’: 87) (subject), 'F=2 (object; possessive), ‘t7il
(dative), ‘SFE (instrumental), ‘S24 (topic),
U-#7} (comitative), 7-7} = (like), UF-bAN7]
‘tree branch’
‘As mentioned earlier, for the standard subject marker °1/7}, Yukchin and North
Hamgyéng have just ©] (or its reflexes via umlaut), but other Hamgyong dialects
further south also show °1/7. Corresponding to the standard object marker
Hamgyong dialects have 2. (7 after rounded segments) alternating with £
‘Note that this shape is also found in Myongju and Samch’dk in Kangwon province.
Some of the Hamgydng connective endings are different from the standard ones;
for (2)U7}, one hears -(2)47Y, 2474, (2)U7FE). Negation in
compounds behaves differently from standard; for the standard negative an VI-0 V2
one finds, e.g., mdgd ai passo (% 80} Yk) ‘didn’t try eating it,’ mar ara mo tiirsso
(2 E WoEA) ‘can’t make out what is said,” etc. Like many other dialects,
Hamgyéng has just three speech levels: high, equal, and low.
Hamsying dialect vocabulary examples
Standard Hamgyong Standard Hamgyong
% ‘earth’ B71 (hargi) ZS ‘chimney FA
AP] ‘frog’ ate) PE ‘parents’ oAeel)
1 ‘fox’ 7, 7, B71 RUA ‘side dishes’ Be), BA
13 tangs? Fen AS ‘winter’ sare]
24, Southwest (Cholla)
Both North and South Cholla dialects have 10 vowels: i, e, ae, ti, 6, i, 6, a, u, 0, Some
regions in the center and to the west in South Cholla have neutralized ¢ and ae,
yielding a 9-vowel system. Diphthongs in North Cholla are subject to certain
restrictions within morphemes; thus, yV diphthongs lose their glide after n and r, and
Dialectal Variation
WV diphthongs |
following diphthc
In South Chil
nouns like: 4
BF (BI) ‘mo
earlier i t0 i aft
“bead,” 714) (7F
post.” This. fron
boundaries.
In some cases,
an earlier date, «
board,’ 3-5-4 (
Cholla has just a
UF (BH) ‘whe
‘Umlaut operat
50) (EB) ‘sm
‘rabbit’; but 41a
‘fly,’ 12] (not *
‘There are many
widespread acros
Maw’ (subject),
Tensification
and South Chol
(E712) ‘plot,”
‘corn,’ $7) (F
K- and h-pala
(QU) ‘endure
(BEF) ‘tongue
MK -z- rema
(2) “fox,”
(13) ‘wild grap
In terms of su
Verb morphopho.
Cholla dialects 1
25 (48, 2b
"JO for stance
‘since,’ and -22
One of the
HONEY, eg
appears in parts
function, it corm
perhaps slightly
questions, commture and Society
have numerous
cesses at the
d ending. The
show different
itinctive vowel
Hwanghae and
1995: 390).
id verbs which
sessive), ‘dal
sin and North
zydng dialects
marker 2/3,
with 2%),
nn provines
standard ones;
Negation in.
re an VI-6 V2
ara mo tio
other dialects,
Hamgyong
za
lal (Sel)
go), a4
SH]
4, u, 0. Some
ved ¢ and ae,
ict to certain
r mand r, and
Dialectal Variation in Korean m3
wV diphthongs lose their glide after any labial consonant. South Cholla has the
following diphthongs: yae, v3, ya, yu, yo and w9, wa
In South Chilla one finds final u corresponding to standard i after m, p, k ng in
nouns like: UA2 (31) ‘buterfly, ASF (AP) ‘spider,’ 2 (271) ‘strainer,’
25 (12.71) ‘mosquito,’ etc. Like Kydngsang dialects, South Chélla dialects front
earlier if to i after coronals (typically 4): "142 (P1<) “farmband,”
“bead,” 7H (7) ‘chest,’ HAG C22) ‘swelling,’ B12 (=) ‘government
post’ This fronting process occurs both inside morphemes and at-morpheme
boundaries.
Tn some cases, South Cholla words ending in a vowel appear to have suffixed -i at
an earlier date, causing umlaut: 1%) (LH) ‘shadow,’ EP} (SAH) ‘cutting
board,’ So (315-01) ‘mackerel,’ $4] (41) “trout.” But in other cases, South
Cholla has just « final simple vowel corresponding to final -Vy in standard Korean:
BEF (HER) “wheel,” BP (HA) ‘rock,’ Et CAA) “rake.”
‘Umlaut operates freely within words, but not usually across coronal consonants:
e]} CEU) “snapper, 2] (6}5)) “mother,” °F!) (8) “father,” 171 (E71)
“tabbit'; but ¥1€1- (not *24)'2-) ‘endure,’ 821- (not *#]21-) “fall,” 2] (not *silz])
‘iy 2) (not *72}) ‘head,’ 1 (not #91174) show,’ FH] (not CHA) ‘again.’
‘There are many exceptions, such as H2]™) (TL2] ™]) ‘iron.’ Umlaut is also quite
widespread across morpheme boundaries: "¥) (tel) ‘rice’ (subject), wy] CHL,
Slaw’ (subject), 7] 28t+ (847) 2bH) ‘don’t want to do it.”
"Tensification of originally lax word-initial consonants is widespread in both North
and South Cholla: 53: CFP) ‘tofu,’ Bet CCH “bathe, shampoo,’ 712}
(BAA) ‘plot’ 8 (2) ‘soju liquor,’ F221 (7124) “ring,” BBO] 7B)
Scorn,’ 817) (21471) ‘pigeon,’ RPE} CRP EH “smash.”
K. and h-palatalization are widespread in both North and South Chdlla: 2U) C+
(ATP) ‘endure,’ A (2) ‘road,’ W (41) ‘seaweed,’ 73 (%) ‘older sibling,” aa
(YF) ‘tongue.’ K-palatalization occurs only in word-initial position.
MK emains as -s- in many Cholla words: ¥412} (+°}2}) ‘pour!’ ae
(4-2) fox,’ 4 CFF) ‘daikon radish.” MK -G- can be found as -g- in
(®)) ‘wild grapes.”
Tn terms of suprasegmental features, Cholla dialects have distinctive vowel length.
Verb morphophonemics and/or other peculiarities
Chiila dialects have the following interesting pronouns: += (44 8}) ‘you-plural,”
27 (2S, 4718) ‘they,’ 22 (7471) ‘self.’ Other typical Cholla shapes are
wo] & for standard 2] ‘like,’ -J7ll, "37S, or ~8-7H for standard 4247
‘since,’ and --2}51 for standard - 2.2} 32 ‘intending,*
‘One of the most representative sentence endings of South Chdlla dialect is
-o} NEF, eg, TET ‘goes,’ UOlZt ‘puts on.’ Although the ending also
appears in parts of North Cholla, it is much more widespread in South Cholla. In
function, it corresponds closely to the @)2. style in standard Korean, though it is
perhaps slightly more polite, and, like the latter, it can be used in statements,
questions, commands, and suggestions. Some other typical South Chilla forms are:278 Korean Language in Culture and Society
EE] for standard -=4) ‘and, but’; BA), Bal, GA), Fell, FF for standard
‘WHEO] “because of; 4] for standard 2) ‘since,’ and -24 for standard -2 ‘may.’
Perhaps the single most stereotypical feature of South Cholla dialects is the
phenomenon whereby the element i (a nasalized i, usually represented in Korean
writing as %J) is appended to utterances to affirm cozy familiarity or solidarity, or
else to pose a request or favor: