Professional Documents
Culture Documents
03 MYousef
03 MYousef
29-44, 2007
ABSTRACT
Link of fats to chronic disease in Europe and North America is well established. Overconsumption of high en-
ergy-dense foods may contribute to energy imbalance and lead to increasing incidence and prevelance of obesity as
well as the risk of chronic diseases.
Fat replacers are used to provide some or all of the functional properties of fat while providing fewer calories than
the fat being replaced. They are either fat substitutes or mimetics. Fat substitutes are lipid-like substances intended to
replace fats on a one-to-one basis. Fat mimetics are protein or carbohydrate ingredients which function by imitating
the physical, textural mouth feel and organoleptic properties of real fats.
Carbohydrate-based fat replacers are derived from cereals, grains and plants, these ingredients include both
digestible and indigestible complex carbohydrates. They include starch and fiber-based fat mimetics. The former in-
clude maltodextrins, and modified starches, while the latter include microcrystalline cellulose methylcellulose, gums,
pectins, hydrocolloid gums and polydextrose. Protein-based fat replacers such as microparticulated whey protein pro-
vide structure, viscosity, creaminess and opacity, a clean flavour base with only one-thrid of the calories in fat.
The majority of fat-based fat replacers are emulsifiers or lipid analogs. They are neither hydrolyzed nor absorbed
by the body in the same manner as normal fat and thus contribute substantially fewer calories.
Numerous applications of fat replacers have been discussed. The main food commodities being targets in this
respect include bakery products (cookies, pound cakes), meat products (beef burger and frankfurter type sausage)
dairy products (cheeses, yoghurt and ice-cream) and other products (human milk fat substitute, low-calorie structured
lipids and mayonnaise).
Keywords: fat substitutes, emulsifiers, structured lipids, fat mimetics, microparticulated proteins, microparticulated
carbohydrates, cookies, biscuits, cakes, frankfurters, milk fat, cheese, yoghurt, ice-cream, mayonnaise.
29
Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007 Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol.
snacks eaten away from home were associated with (flavour, texture, lubrication, volume/bulk, or heat
higher fat intake and obesity (Gillis & Bar, 2003). transfer) to produce an acceptable product. With
Thus, awareness of these patterns is helpful in de- the aforementioned effects, it is easy to see why fat
termining for which foods and in which situation replacement is challenging and may require a com-
fat replacers might have a role in reducing total fat, bination of ingredients and changes in processing
saturated fat, and energy intake. Furthermore, fat to produce a product that approximates the full fat
replacers were developed in response to consumer product (Grossklaus, 1996, ADA, 2005).
concern with quantities of dietary lipid and its pos- Fat replacers: definition and classification
sible link with obesity (Owusu – Apenten, 2005).
A fat replacer is an ingredient that can be used
Functional role of dietary fat to provide some or all of the functions of fat yield-
ing fewer calories than fat. Fat replacers need to
Dietary fat is a major energy source, essential
be able to replicate all or some of the functional
for growth and development, and provides essential
properties of fat in a fat-modified food (Schwenk
fatty acids needed for maintaining structure of cell
& Guthrie, 1997). It is worth to mention that the
membrane and for prostaglandin synthesis. Also, term of fat replacer implies that a substance has
fat aids in the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins certain desirable physical or organoleptic attributes
and other phytochemicals (Giese, 1996). of fats which it replaces without any of the unde-
Fat in food has multiple functions during cook- sirable properties of fats (Hassel, 1993, Martin,
ing process. Its heat transfer properties enable rapid 1999). There are several categories of fat replacers,
heating and attainment of very high temperatures. and there is often confusion regarding how the cat-
High temperatures achieved by frying and deep-fat egories are defined. Fat replacers are either fat sub-
frying create many browning (Maillard Reaction) stitutes or mimetics. Fat substitutes are lipid-like
taste components that have positive sensory at- substances intended to replace fats on a one-to-one
tributes. Fats absorb many flavour compounds and basis. Fat mimetics are protein or carbohydrate in-
round the flavour by reducing the sharpness of acid gredients which function by imitating the physical,
ingredients. In meats, fat carries the flavour and textural, mouth feel and organoleptic properties of
contributes to the juciness and tenderness, key to real fats (Owusu-apenten, 2005).
the difference in taste of the various kinds of meat Fat substitutes are ingredients that resemble
and poultry (Grossklaus, 1996, Jones, 1996). conventional fat and oils and can replace fat on a
Functionally, fats affect the melting point, vis- gram-for-gram basis. Because they are fat based,
cosity and body, crystallinity, and spreadability of they are often stable at cooking and frying tem-
many foods (Drewnowski, 1998, Sandrou & Arvan- peratures and provide all the functions of fat while
itoyannis, 2000). Fat imparts a velvety mouth feel yielding <9 kcal/g, which could be zero calories if
to products such as ice-creams, desserts, and cream non is absorbed.
soups. Smoothness in ice-creams and some candies Fat analogs are compounds with many of the
is due to fat preventing the formation of large wa- characteristics of fat but have an altered digestibil-
ter or sugar crystals. Fats are responsible for the ity and altered nutritional value.
aroma and texture of many foods, thereby affecting Fat extenders optimize functionality of fat,
the overall palatability of the diet. Although fat in thus allowing a decrease in the usual amount of fat
food may increase acceptance, high-fat foods and in the products.
diets are also high in calories (Giese, 1996), which
may be problematic for the majority of individuals Fat mimetics are ingredient that mimic one or
struggling with energy balance. more of the sensory and physical functions of fat in
the food. They are based on carbohydrate, protein
In baked products, fat inhibits the formation or fat components used alone or in combination
of tough gluten strands, softens the crumb, imparts and provide from 0 to 9 kcal/g. They provide lu-
tenderness and delays staling. Crispines in cookies bricity, mouth feel, and other characteristics of fat
is due to fat in combination with some of the other by holding water. The four broad categories of fat
ingredients. In flaky products such as croissants replacers are shown in Fig. (1).
and pastries, fat’s ability to pool in layer and coat
gluten strands is crucial. Thus, fat replacers must Stern & Hermann-Zaidins (1992) described
be chosen with care to replicate the function of fat an ideal fat replacer by being safe, physiologically
30
Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol. Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007
inert, and nutritionally equivalent and creates the 9- Synthetic fat- substitutes, 10- Combination sys-
illusion of fat content. It should allow heat trans- tems. The aforementioned classification is based
fer since fat is heat exchange medium that enables partially on chemical composition and partially on
rapid cooking (Jones, 1996). functionality of the ingredients, and includes com-
Fat replacers can be also classified as: 1- Starch bination systems (i.e. blends) (Jones, 1996).
derived, 2- Fiber-derived, 3- Protein-based, 4- Tables (1, 2 and 3) give examples of fat substi-
Gums, gels and thickners, 5- Emulsifiers, 6- Bulk- tutes, fat mimetics and fat replacers used in various
ing agents, 7- Low calorie fats, 8- Fat extenders, food categories.
Name/group Composition
Emulsifiers
Olestra®, Olean® Sucrose esterified with 6-8 fatty acids
Sucrose fatty acid ester Sucrose esterified with 1-3 fatty acids
Sorbestrin® Carbohydrate + fatty acids
Sorbitol – fatty acid ester,
Alkyl glycoside polyester Alkyl glucoside + fatty acid
Span® and Tween®
Miscellaneous Sorbitan monostearate (Spans),
Polyoxyethylene fatty acid esters (Tweens)
Polypropylene fatty acid esters
Structured lipids
Caprenin® Medium chain trycyiglycerol (MCT)
C8:0, C10:0, C22:0
Neobee® Medium chain trycyiglycerol (MCT) from coconut oil,
plam oil
Salatrim/Benefat® MCT; C2:0 to C4:0. C18:0 fatty acids
Dialkyl dihexdecyl malonate
® : Registered. Source: ADA (2005)
31
Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007 Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol.
32
Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol. Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007
33
34
Table 4: Key physical and chemical properties of colloidal grades of Avicel® microcrystalline cellulose
Avicel® Avicel® Avicel® Avicel® Avicel® Avicel® MicroQuick MaltoQuick
Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007
Properties
RC501 RC581 RC 591F CL611 RCN30 AC815 WC595 MC230
MCC content (%) 91 89 88 85 75 85 22 22
Process Bulk-dried Bulk-dried Spray-dried Spray-dried Co-processed Co-processed Co-processed Co-processed
with with calcium with whey with
xanthan and alginate maltodextrin
maltodextrin
Equipment required to activate Homogenizer Homogenizer High speed High speed High speed
High shear or Low shear Low shear
mixer mixer mixer
low shear with
sequestrantes
Use levels in food (%) 0.5-3.0 0.3-0.8 0.3-1.0 0.2-2.5 0.5-1.5 0.4-2.5 2.0-4.0 2.0-4.0
Initial viscosity (cP*) 72-168 at 2.1% 72-168 at 1.2% 39-175 at 1.2% 50-151 at 2.6% 620 at 3% n/a 10-100 at 6% 50-150 at 5%
Set-up viscosity (cP**) 1025 at 2.1% 1125 1250 at 1.2% 1850 at 2.6% n/a n/a 1200 at 6%
Primary uses Whipped Frozen General Pourable Stabilizer, Stabilizer, dry Dry blended Dry blended
toppings, desserts stabilizer, systems frozen desserts blended or low foods foods
heat-stable thixotropic shear foods
emulsions gels
Note: MCC = Microcrystalline cellulose.
* Initial viscosity was measured at 120s, using a Brookfield RVT Viscometer No. 1 Spindle at 20 rpm.
** Set-up viscosity was measured at 24 h using a No. 3 Spindle at 20 rpm.
Source: Humphreys (1996).
Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol.
Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol. Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007
Methylcellulose gums such as methylcel- products of juice manufacture. The peel or pomace
lulose (MC) and hydroxypropylmethyl cellulose may be blanched after juice extraction in order to
(HPMC) are commercially significant polymers inactivate the endogenously located pectin esterases
used in a variety of food applications for more than followed by drying (Giese, 1996). There is a range
40 years. Like fats, MC and HPMC helps entrain of specially tailored pectins for fat replacement.
air in food stuffs to improve structure, stabilize air Commercial pectins are divided into low methoxy
or carbon dioxide bubbles to reduce volume loss (LM) pectins and high methoxy (HM) pectins ac-
and enhance moisture retention (de Mariscal & cording to the degree of estrification (DE). The DE
Bell, 1996). Chemical structures of MC and HPMC is defined as the percentage of galactuoronic acid
are given in Fig. (2). units that are methyl estrified. Pectins with a DE
The most important applications of MC and below 50% are designated as LM-pectins, whereas
HPMC include: fried foods, liquid foods, baked pectins with DE above 50% are designated as HM-
products, frozen dairy products and low-fat whipped pectins. The DE values for commercial LM-pectins
toppings. The main benefit from using MC and typically range from 20 to 40% and from 55 to 75%
HPMC in fried food products is the reduction in fat for HM-pectins (Nielsen, 1996).
uptake achievable during the frying step. This con- Slendid covers a range of special pectins tai-
tributes to a lower caloric value and improved cook- lor-made for fat replacement. It offers a range of
ing economy from reduced oil losses. Also, reduced properties including: stability of heat, pH, shear
fat-baked goods have benefited from their use as and salt, neutral taste, fat-like dissipation, virtually
they compensate for fat removal by enhancing air no calories and relatively low usage levels i.e. 0.2
entrainment, promoting uniform fine cell size in the to 1.5%. It may be used in a wide range of food ap-
crumb structure (de Mariscal & Bell, 1996). plications such as: spreads, mayonnaise and salad
Pectin is a hydrocolloid consisting of partial dressings, processed meats, ice creams, processed
methyl esters of polygalacturonic acid. Pectin is cheeses, soups and sauces, desserts and bakery pro-
found in all fruits and vegetables and is obtained duction, in which fat may be partly or fully replaced
by aqueous extraction of citrus peel and apple by- (Nielsen, 1996).
(a)
(b)
35
Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007 Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol.
36
Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol. Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007
onnaise-type products, baked goods, coffee cream- the time it takes for the molecule to move through
er, soups and sauces (Owusu-apenten, 2005). the digestive tract. The sucrose center is where the
Dairy Lo® is a protein-based ingredient which breakdown of the substance for absorption into the
produces 4 kcal/g. It is manufactured via thermal body would take place (Giese 1996, FDA, 2003).
denaturation of proteins from sweet whey. It im- Olestra was approved in 1996 by FDA as a
proves the texture, flavour stability of low-fat foods. direct human food additive in salted snacks and
It provides the mouth feel of fat and has GRAS sta- crackers. It is also used to substitute 100% of fats
tus by FDA (Owusu-apenten, 2005). and oils in the preparation of savory snacks (chips,
3- Fat based fat replacers (fat-substitutes) crisps, extruded snacks and crackers). These uses
include the substitution for fat for frying as well as
These are either triacylglycerols with tailored sources of fat in dough conditioners, oil sprays and
configurations to reduce their caloric content, or flavour (Owusu-apenten, 2005).
they have chemical structures similar to triacylg-
lycerols but reduced or zero caloric content. The Sobestrin is produced by attaching a hydro-
fat substitutes are intended to replace the function- phobic fatty acid to hydrophilic sugar alcohols
ality of natural fats on a one-to-one weight basis mainly sorbitol. Other polyols used for sugar-fatty
(Owusu-apenten, 2005). acid esters include tetrahalose, raffinose and stach-
yose (Owusu-apenten, 2005).
Emulsifiers
Structured lipids
These are partial esters of fatty acids with chain
lengths from C12 to C22 and polyvalent alcohols Structured lipids (SLs) are triacylglycerols
like glycerol, sorbitol / sorbitan, and sucrose or or- (TAGs) that have been modified to change the fatty
ganic acids like lactic acid. Partial esters may also acid composition and/or their positional distribu-
be estrified with organic acids such as acetic, citric, tion via interestrificatin in glycerol backbone. The
diacetyl tartaric or succinic form a wide range of SLs provide an effective mean for producing tailor-
esters (Flack, 1996). made lipids with desirable physical and chemical
properties and/or nutritional benefits. The SLs are
Emulsifiers possess many of the properties of produced either by chemical or enzymatic inter-
fats and oils as exemplified in the fatty consistency, estrification or via genetic engineering (Iwasaki &
lubricity, and the texture and cohesiveness of fat, Yamane, 2000, Osborn & Akoh, 2003, Nielsen et
they form films or spread on surface, build or in- al., 2004, Agyare et al., 2005).
crease viscosity through hydration, and soften or
weaken structures created by polysaccharides or The medium chain triacylglycerols (MCTs)
proteins (Flack, 1996). differ from natural fats by their relative absence of
long chain fatty acids. The MCTs can be synthe-
Because of their use restrictions and also be- tized by interestrification process. They have lower
cause they have the same caloric values as fat, their melting points, high solubility in water and are re-
role as fat replacers is in stretching the functionality sistant to oxidation. They are not transferred to the
of low fat levels and in replacing the functionality body’s store of adipose tissue but are metabolized
of fat when used in combination with other ingredi- directly in the liver. There are two products belong-
ents (Giese, 1996). Typical examples of products in ing to MCTs, namely Salatrim and Caprenin.
which proportions of fat can be reduced significant-
ly by 30% or higher, include yellow fat spreads, Salatrim, is a structured lipid (short and long
biscuits, cakes, baking emulsions, ice cream and acyl triacylglycerol rearranged molecules) pro-
salad dressings (Flack, 1996). duced from a mixture of short chain (C2:0 – C4:0)
and a long chain fatty acid (C18:0). The short chain
Olestra, is an emulsifier produced by reacting acid are esterified at positions 1,3 of the glycerol
sucrose with 6-8 moles of C12–C22 fatty acids in molecule. Whereas, the long chain acid is estrified
the presence of a catalyst. The chemical configura- at position 2. Salatrim is also called Benefat, pro-
tion of Olestra accounts for its indigestibility and vides approximate 5 kcal/g because the short ac-
why it does not provide calories. It replaces the ids provide few calories whilst stearic acid is only
glycerol molecule with sucrose and has either 6- partially absorbed in the body. It is usable at pH
8 fatty acids attached. With this many fatty acids, 3-7.5 and under cold conditions. The suitable prod-
digestive enzymes can’t get to the sucrose center in uct categories for salatrim include confectionery,
37
Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007 Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol.
cookies, cakes, brownies and pie crust (Owusu-ap- in two types of bakery products (oriental cookies
enten, 2005). “Gourayeba” and pound cakes). The fat replacers
Caprenin, the second product belonging to were applied at 25, 35 and 45% for the former and
MCTs, the glycerol back bone is substituted by 40, 50 and 60% for the later. Results revealed that
caprylic acid (C8:0), capric acid (C10:0) and be- the addition of P-SA2 at all levels did not affect the
henic acid (C22:0). This fat replacer yields 5 kcal/g sensory scores and products were highly scored as
as compared to 9 kg/g for normal fat. The caloric the full-fat control samples. The mechanical prop-
reduction is apparently due to the less efficient me- erties of the tested bakery products as measured by
tabolism of C8:0 and C10:0 fatty acids within the the structograph showed that replacement with P-
body. The functional properties of Caprenin are SA2 for both cookies and pound cakes exhibited
similar to those of cocoa butter. The useable tem- lower breaking strengths than the same products
perature for Caprenin is <132°C and it is especially with S100 (Shaltout et al., 2004).
suited for confectionery products (Giese, 1996 and Wekwete & Navder (2005) investigated the ef-
Owusu-apenten, 2005). fect of avocado pureé as a fat replacer on the physi-
Some applications of fat replacers: cal, textural and sensory properties of oat meal
cookies. Results indicated that cookies with 50%
Bakery products replacement with avocado pureé had significantly
The physical and sensory properties of choco- reduced spread and water activity as compared to
late-chip cookies made with vegetable shortening control. Texture analysis showed avocado substitu-
and protein-based, lipid-based and carbohydrate- tion to significantly decrease cookie hardness and
based fat replacers at 50 and 75% replacement brittleness. Sensory evaluation indicated that the
have been studied by Armbrister & Sester (1994). fat-reduced avocado were found to be more soft,
Results indicated that all shortening-reduced cook- chewy and had rounded contours with considerably
ies had significantly less surface cracking, fewer less surface cracking, less accepted than control
surface protrusions, more uniform but larger cells but had room for improvement. The 50% replaced
and more mouth coating. cookies with avocado pureé provided 35% less fat
Sanchez et al. (1995) prepared low-fat short and 13% fewer calories compared to control.
bread cookies using combinations of carbohy- Agyare et al. (2005) showed that the addition
drate-based fat substitutes at different levels. Data of shortening to soft wheat flour dough resulted in a
indicated the presence of higher moisture content, significant (P<0.05) decrease in dough resistance to
greater toughness and lower specific volume with deformation (P), dough extensibility (L) and dough
minimal differences in cookie breaking strength as baking strength (W), suggesting a less developed
compared to control samples. gluten network. The Salatrim (SL) substitution for
Three carbohydrate based-fat replacers were shortening did not affect (P) and (W). The cookies
used in biscuits while shortening was reduced at incorporating SL at 50 and 75% substitution were
33, 66 and 100%. The results showed that the fat re- significantly similar (P<0.05) to the shortening con-
placer usage produced significant increase in mois- trol cookies in both baking and textural qualities.
ture content, light crust colour, variation in volume Bubble and pore formation of a high-ratio cake
and crumb firmness (Conforti et al., 1996). formulation with polydextrose as a sugar-and-fat-
Swanson (1998) used three carbohydrate-based replacer were investigated by Kocer et al. (2007).
fat replacers to replace 75% of the butter in three The physical properties were studied by the Imag-
peanut butter cookies formulas. Data showed that all ing technique. Results indicated that polydextrose
reduced fat cookies were rated significantly less ac- substitution in the high-ratio cake system had supe-
ceptable but not rejected compared to control cook- rior properties in distributing the gas phase into the
ies, but there was a trend towards greater acceptabil- cake batter as indicated by decreasing the average
ity of the cookies prepared with polydextrose. bubble sizes and increasing bubble size uniformity
as the level of polydextrose increases. A decrease
Two selected types of carbohydrate-based fat in the average pore size and pore size uniformity of
replacers derived from potato starch and citrus peel the cake crust due to the combined effect of reduced
known respectively as Paselli SA2 (P-SA2) and batter stability and interference with the gelatiniza-
Slendid 100 (S100) were used to replace shortening tion mechanism was also observed. The resulting
38
Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol. Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007
high cake system exhibited 22% reduction in calo- The effect of a short chain fructooligosaccha-
rific value based on total sugar and fat content. rides on the sensory properties of conventional and
Fat replacers including amylodextrin gels, reduced fat cooked meat sausages has been stud-
Simpless® 730 and soybean paste effectively re- ied in products in which a fat reduction of close
placed fats up to 75% in cupcakes and 50% in Sablé to 40% was obtained. The fibre assayed was used
type cookies without affecting both keeping quality in sufficient amounts to constitute between 2 and
and sensory properties. Moreover, the bioassay ex- 12% of the final product. The results showed that
periments evaluating total cholesterol, HDL-cho- the sensory and textural properties and the overall
lesterol and triacylglecerol level showed positive acceptability were very good, which indicated that
effects for rats fed the aforementioned products this fiber can be considered a promising fat replacer
(Abd-El Khalek, 2007). in meat products thus a reduced calorie product en-
riched with soluble dietetic fiber may be obtained
Meat products (Cáceres et al., 2004).
The effect of fat content and carbohydrate Cengiz & Gokoglu (2005) studied the changes
fat-replacers on the release of volatile odour com- in energy and cholesterol contents of frankfurter
pounds from beef burgers salami and frankfurter type sausage with fat reduction and fat replacer ad-
has been investigated (Chevance et al., 2000). Data dition. Fat content of sausages were reduced from
exhibited that the reduction in fat content in any of 20 to 10% and 5%. Citrus fibers (CF) and soy pro-
the aforementioned three meat products resulted in tein concentrate (SPC) were added at the rates of
a tendency towards an increase in the quantities of 2% as fat replacers. The addition of fat replacers
volatiles released in the head space. Thus, the ad- content by 38.6% and 45.7%, respectively with no
dition of carbohydrate fat-replacers such as tapioca significant differences between sausages treated
starch, maltodextrin and oat fiber to low-fat meat with CF or SPC.
product could assist the flavour qualities of these
products by slowing down the release of odour Dairy products
compounds. Functionality of modified tapioca starch and
The effects of fat level (5, 12 and 30%) and lecithin as fat mimetics in feta cheese was studied.
maltodextrin on emulsion stability, cook loss, col- Cheeses were made with no fat mimetics, 1% mod-
our, texture and sensory characteristics of frank- ified tapioca starch, 0.2% lecithin, and a combina-
furters were investigated by Crehan et al. (2000). tion of 0.5% tapioca starch and 0.1% lecithin. Low-
Results showed that maltodextrin addition caused fat feta cheeses (9-16% fat) were prepared from
a significant decrease in cook loss of the frankfur- bovine 1.6-2.2% fat milk. Cheeses were ripened for
thers but also decreased the emulsion stability. No 45 days before chemical, sensory, Scanning Elec-
significant difference in hardness, gumminess and tron Microscope (SEM) and texture evaluations.
chewiness values when maltodextrin was present The results indicated that the combination of modi-
in the reduced fat (5 and 12%) frankfurters were fied tapioca starch and lecithin improved flavour,
observed. Saltiness, overall flavour intensity, over- texture and overall acceptability of reduced – fat
all texture and overall acceptability were unaltered and low-fat feta cheeses (Sipahioglu et al., 1999).
by maltodextrin. The results indicate that malto- Aime et al. (2001) used sensory and instrumen-
dextrin can be used as a suitable fat replacer since tal analysis to evaluate the texture of regular (10%),
it offset some of the changes brought about by fat light (5%), low fat (2.5%) and fat free vanilla (0.4%
reduction, decreasing cook loss and maintaining a ice-creams. The light low-fat and fat-free ice-cream
number of textural and sensory characteristics of were prepared using a modified pea starch as the fat
the frankfurters. replacement ingredient. Two processing trials with
Hoffman & Mellett (2003) observed that continuous commercial-like process conditions
trained taste panels could not distinguish between were undertaken. The trained sensory panel rated
ostrich meat patties containing either 10% pork the low-fat and fat-free ice-creams to have lower
lard or 10% of a modified starch/protein isolate (fat viscosity, smoothness and mouth coating proper-
replacer) mixture. It was concluded that fat replac- ties. Instrumentally determined apparent viscosity
ers can be used successfully for the production of data supported the sensory data. The use of modi-
low-fat ostrich patties without any negative quality fied starch as a partial fat replacer in vanilla ice–
attributes being perceived. cream was highly acceptable.
39
Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007 Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol.
Koca & Metin (2004) examined the textural, cept for Nutrim II cheeses. For flavour attributes,
melting and sensory properties of low-fat fresh the low-fat control cheeses were significantly less
Kashar cheese (70% fat reduction) produced by bitter, more buttery and less starchy than the Nu-
using two protein-based fat replacers (1% w/w trim cheeses which were less acceptable but not
simplesse®-D-100 and 1% w/w Dairy-LoTM) rejected (Konuklar et al., 2004).
and a carbohydrate based fat replacer (5% w/w Kavas et al. (2004) manufactured full-fat and
Raftiline® HP)- during the storage period for 90 low-fat white pickled cheeses by the traditional
days. Results showed that Simpless® D-100 cor- procedure from bovine milk. Results indicated that
rected all appearance defects determined in low fat the moisture and total nitrogen values of the low-
cheese. Both simplesse® D-100 and Raftiline® HP fat white pickled cheeses significantly increased
produced an improving effect on flavour, texture whereas total solids, salt, pH and acidity values
and overall acceptability of low-fat cheese un- of cheese were not affected by the fat-replacers in
til the 30th day of storage. The use of Raftiline® the cheese milk used. Sensory properties of cheese
HP caused a slight increase in meltability. These were adversely affected by the use of fat replac-
results indicated that both simpless® D-100 and ers in cheese making. From the rheological point of
Raftiline® HP can improve the texture and sensory view, all the low-fat cheeses containing fat replac-
properties of low-fat fresh Kasher cheese. ers were different from the full-fat cheeses, but no
The physical, chemical, textural and sensory off-flavour or bitterness was noted in any full or
properties during storage of strained yoghurt, a low fat cheese.
semisolid product made from yoghurt by remov- Zisu & Shah (2005) studied the influence of ex-
ing some part of its serum, made from milk with opolysaccharides (EPS), pre-acidification and use of
0.5% and 2% fat and including Dairy-LoTM and two fat replacers FR1 and FR2, on the textural and
Simpless® were analyzed at the first, 7th and 14th functional characteristics of Mozzarella cheeses.
day. The sample with lower fat content exhibited Control cheeses made with EPS producing Strep-
higher titratable acidity, ash, viscosity, and colour tococcus thermophilus 285 had the lowest moisture
(L and a-values) than the samples with higher fat (52.84%) and yield, while hardness and melt prop-
content. Dairy-LoTM added samples had higher ti- erties of these cheeses improved with storage. Ad-
tratable acidity, fat, ash, viscosity, a-value, flavour, dition of FR1 exhibited the greatest stretch and melt
appearance and colour than simplesse® added than FR2. Pizza bake performance was improved
samples (Yazici & Akgun, 2004). with FR1 than FR2. Coating cheese shreds with oil
Calleros et al. (2004) determined the flow and was necessary for adequate browning.
creep compliance properties of reduce-fat youghurt Other products
containing whey protein concentrate (WPC), mi-
croparticulated whey protein, or a blend of both Yang et al. (2001) applied enzymatic synthesis
fat-replacers and compared to those exhibited by a of low calorie structured lipids (ex. Salatrim) in a
full-fat yoghourt (FFY). The results indicated that solvent-free system. The process was undertaken
yoghurt made with WPC showed flow and viscoe- by transesterification between triacetin and stearic
lastic properties that resembled more closely those acid using immobilized lipase. Stearic acid (C18:0)
of the FFY. was incorporated mainly into the sn-1 and/or sn-3
position of triacetin by lipase–catalyzed reaction.
The textural and sensory properties of 3- However, when C18:0 was located at the sn-2 posi-
month-old low-fat cheddar cheeses manufactured tion on traiacylglycerol (TAG), the resultant sn-2
with a β-glucan hydrocolloidal composite denoted monostearin after hydrolysis by pancreatic lipase
as “Nutrim”, a nutracceutical fat-replacer, were was well absorbed. On contrary, the free fatty ac-
studied. The low-fat control cheeses (11.2% fat) ids released from the sn-1 or sn-3 position on TAG
were compared with Nutrim I (6.8% fat) and Nu- tended to be poorly absorbed. These suggest that
trim II (3.47% fat) cheeses. The hardness, fractur- the stereo-position of long-chain saturated fatty ac-
ability, and melt-flow index time values of Nutrim ids is important in calorie intake.
cheeses were significantly lower than the low-fat
control cheeses. The elasticity and the cohesivness Nielsen et al. (2004) produced a human milk-
fat substitute from lard and soybean oil fatty ac-
values were similar for all cheeses. Most textural
ids by enzyme technology. Structured lipid human
attributes from the sensory panel were similar, ex-
40
Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol. Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007
milk–fat substitute (SL-HMFS) was compared to Armbrister, W.L. & Sester, C.S. 1994. sensory and
commercial human milk fat–substitute (HMFS) physical properties of chocolate chip cookies
regarding fatty acids composition content of anti- made with vegetable shortening or fat replac-
oxidant and oxidative stability. Fats were stored at es at 50 and 75% levels. Cereal Chem. 71:
6°C for four days and the oxidative stability was 344-351.
evaluated. Results indicated that the SL-HMFS Astrup, A., Grunwald, G.K., Melanson, E.L., Saris,
had a lower oxidative stability than did commercial W.H. & Hill J.O. 2000. Int. J. Obes. Relat.
HMFS products or lard, probably due to a lower Metab. Disord 24: 1545-1552.
level of tocopherol in SL-HMFS.
Be Miller, J.N. 1993. Starch-based gums. In: Indus-
Worrasinchai et al. (2006) investigated the trial Gums. Whistler, R.L. and BeMiller, J.N.
application of β-glucan prepared from brewer’s (Eds.). Academic Press, San Diego,.
yeast as a fat-replacer in mayonnaise. Fat was par-
Cáceres, E., Garcia, M.L., Toro, J. and Selgas, M.D.
tially substituted by β-glucan (RF) at levels of 25,
2004. The effect of fructooligosaccharides on
50 and 75% which were referred to as 25β, 50β
or 75β formulations, respectively, together with a the sensory characteristics of cooked sausag-
control sample (FF) containing 100% oil without es. Meat Science, 68: 87-96.
β-glucan. Data indicated that all RF mayonnaise Calleros, C., Torrijos, O.M., Castilla, S.O., Orozco,
had significantly lower energy content, but high- P.J.P. & Carter, V.E.J. 2004. Flow and creep
er water content than their FF counter part as the compliance properties of reduced-fat yo-
level of β-glucan increased. The pH values of the ghurts containing protein-based fat replacers.
RF samples decreased as the level of substitution International Dairy J. 14: 777-782.
increased, after 2 months storage. The 50β and Calorie Control Council (CCC), 1996. Fat Reduc-
75β formulations showed similar firmness and ad- tion in Foods. Calorie Control Council, At-
hesiveness values as those of the FF sample. The lanta, Ga.
microstructure assessed by Scanning Electron Mi- Cengiz, E. & Gokoglu, N. 2005. Changes in energy
croscope (SEM) revealed close packing structures and cholesterol contents of frankfurter-type
of large droplets for the FF and 25β. Both FF and sausages with fat reduction and fat replacer
RF mayonnaises exhibited thixothopic shear thin-
addition. Food Chemistry, 91: 443-449.
ning behaviour under steady shear tests. The RF
mayonnaise exhibited higher storage stability than Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDCP).
FF sample. Sensory evaluation demonstrated that Chronic Disease Prevention 2000. Fact sheet:
up to 50β formulations were accepted. Actual causes of death in the United States.
Available at: http:// www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/
factsheets/death _cause 2000.html. Accessed
REFERENCES May 6, 2006.
Abd El-Khalek, M.H. 2007. Effect of Fat Replacers Cheung, I., Gomes, F., Ramsden, R. & Roberts,
on the Physical, Sensory and Nutrional Qual- D.G. 2002. Evaluation of fat replacers: Avi-
ity Characteristics of Some High Fat Bakery cel, N., Lites and Simplesse in mayonnaise.
Products. Ph.D. Thesis, Faculty of Agricul- Int. J. Consumers Studies 26: 27-33.
ture, Ain Shams University. Chevance, F.F.V., Farmer, L.J., Desmond, E.M.,
Aime, D.B., Arntfield, S.D., Malcolmson, L.J. and Novelli, E., Troy, D.J. & Chizolini, R. 2000.
Ryland, D. 2001. Textural analysis of fat re- Effect of some fat replacers on the release of
duced vanilla ice cream products. Food Re- volatile aroma compounds from low-fat meat
search International 34: 237-246. products. J. Agric. Food Chem., 48: 3476-
Agyare, K.K., Addo, K., Xiong, Y.L. and Akoh, 4384.
C.C. 2005. Effect of structured lipid on al- Clegg, S.M. 1996. The use of hydrocholloid gums
veograph characteristics baking and textural as fat mimetics. In: Rollers, S. and Jones,
qualities of soft wheat flour. J. of Cereal Sci., S.A. (Eds.). Handbook of Fat Replacers. CRC
42: 309-316. Press, Boca Raton, New York, pp. 191-212.
American Dietetic Association (ADA) 2005. Posi- Conforti, F.D., Charles, S.A. & Duncan, S.E. 1996.
tion of the American Dietetic Association: Evaluation of a carbohydrate-based fat re-
Fat Replacers. J. Am. Diet. Assoc, 105: 266- placer in a fat-reduced baking powder bis-
275. cuit. J. of Food Quality, 20: 247-256.
41
Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007 Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol.
Crehan, C.M., Hughes, E., Troy, D. J. & Buckley, Iwasaki, Y. & Yamane, T. 2000. Enzymatic synthe-
D.J. 2000. Effects of fat level and maltodex- sis of structured lipids. Journal of Molecular
trin on the functional properties of frankfurt- Catalysis, 10: 129-140.
ers formulated with 5, 12 and 30%. Fat. Meat Jones, J.M. 1996. Fat substitutes: nutritional prom-
Science, 55: 463-469. ises or potential disaster. Chemistry & Indus-
de Mariscal, P. & Bell, D.A. 1996. Fiber-based fat try, July 494-498.
mimetics: Methyl cellulose gum. In: Roller, Kavas, G., Oysun, G., Kinik, O. & Uysal, H. 2004.
S. and Jones, S.A. (Eds.). Handbook of Fat Effect of some fat replacers on chemical, phys-
Replacers. CRC Press, Boca Raton, New ical and sensory attributes of low-fat white
York, pp. 161-174. pickled cheese. Food Chemistry, 88: 381-388.
Drewnowski, A. 1998. Energy density, palatability Koca, N. & Metin, M. 2004. Textural, melting and
and satiety implications for weight control. sensory properties of low-fat fresh Kashar
Nutr. Rev. 56: 347-353. cheeses produced by using fat replacers. In-
Flack, E. 1996. The role of emulsifiers in low-fat ternational Dairy J. 14: 365-373.
food products. In: Roller, S. and Jones, S.A. Kocer, D., Hicsasmaz, Z., Bayindirli, A. & Katnus,
(Eds.). Handbook of Fat Replacers. CRC S. 2007. Bubble and pore formation of the
Press, Boca Roton, New York, pp. 213-234. high-ratio cake formulation with polydex-
Food and Drug Administration, 2003. FDA Talk Pa- trose as a sugar and fat replacer. J. of Food
per. FDA changes Labeling Requirement for Engineering, 75: 543-550.
Olestra. Available at: http://www.fda.gov./ Konuklar, G., Inglett, G.E., Warner, K. & Carriere,
bbs/topics/ANSWERS/2003/ANSO1245. G.J. 2004. Use of β-glucan hydrocolloidal
html. suspension in the manufacture of low-fat
Giese, J. 1996. Fats and fat replacers: balancing the Chedder cheeses: textural properties by in-
health benefits. Food Technol. 50: 76-79. strumental methods and sensory panels. Food
Gillis, L.J. & Bar, O. 2003. Food away from home, Hydrocolloids, 18: 535-545.
sugar-sweetened drink consumption and ju- Martin, K., 1999. Replacing the fat. Food Engineer-
venile obesity. J. Am. Coll. Nutr. 22: 539- ing International, June, 57-60.
545. McCory, M.A., Fuss, P.J., Hays, N.P., Vinken,
Glicksman, M. 1991. Hydrocolloids and the search A.G., Greenberg, A.S. & Roberts, S.B. 1999.
for the oily grail. Food Technol. 45 (10): 94- Overeating in America Association between
103. restaurant food consumption and body fat-
ness in healthy adult men and women ages
GrossKlaus, R. 1996. Fat replacers: Requirement
19 to 80. Obes. Res. 7: 564-571.
from a nutritional physiological point of
view. Fett/Lipid 98: 136-141. Mitchell, H.L. 1996. The role of the bulking agent
polydextrose in fat replacement. In: Roller, S.
Harkema, J. 1996. Starch-derived fat mimetics from
and Jones, S.A. (Eds.). Handbook of Fat Re-
potato. In: Roller, S. and Jones, S.A. (Eds.).
placers. CRC Press, Boca Raton, New York,
Handbook of Fat Replacers. CRC Press, Boca
pp. 235-250.
Raton, New York, pp. 119-130.
Nielsen, N.S., Yang, T., Xu, X. & Jacbsen, C. 2004.
Hassel, C.A. 1993. Nutritional implications of fat
Production and oxidative stability of a human
substitutes. Cereal Foods World, 38: 142-
milk fat substitute produced from lard by en-
144.
zyme technology in a point packed-bed reac-
Hoffman, L.C. & Mellett, F.D. 2003. Quality char- tor. Food Chemistry, 94: 53-60.
acteristics of low fat ostrich meat patties Nielsen, B.U. 1996. Fibre-Based Fat Mimetics: Pec-
formulated with either pork lard or modified tin. In: Roller, S. & Jones S.A. (Eds). Hard-
corn starch, soya isolate and water. Meat Sci- book of Fat Replacers CRC Press, N.Y., pp.
ence, 65: 869-875. 161-172.
Humphreys, W.M. 1996. Fiber-based fat mimetics: Osborn, H.T. & Akoh, C.C. 2002. Structured lipids
Microcrystalline cellulose. In: Roller, S. and novel-fats with medical, nutraceutical and
Jones, S.A. (Eds.). Handbook of Fat Replac- food applications. Comprehensive Review in
ers. CRC Press, Boca Raton, New York, pp. Food Science and Food Safety, 3: 93-103.
131-144.
42
Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol. Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007
43
Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 29-44, 2007 Alex. J. Fd. Sci. & Technol.
Êu�b�« „öN��« � ◊«d�ù« ÊQ� W�öF�« Ác� d�H�Ë ¨WM�e*« ÷«d�_«Ë Êu�b�« 5� W�ö� W� œu�Ë WO�ULA�« UJ�d�√Ë U�Ë—Ë√ � ·ËdF*« s�
iF�� W�Uû� W�“U:« q�U� …œU�“ r� s�Ë WML��U� W�Uù« …œU�“ �≈ ÍœR� Íc�« d�_« u�Ë W�UD�« � qK� ÀËb� �≈ ÍœR� W�UD�« WO�U�
ÆWML��U� WD��d*« WM�e*« ÷«d�_«
��« Êu�b�« tODF� U2 q�√ «dF��« s� œËb� —b� ÃU��≈ «c�Ë s�bK� WOHO�u�« UHB�« iF� vK� ‰uB(« WOG� Êu�b�« qz«b� Âb����
vK� U�ö�≈ r��Ë Êu�b�« t�A� UN�S� ‰ö�û� Âb���� ��« U��dLK� W��M�U�Ë Æ…U�U;« Ë√ ‰ö�û� ÊuJ� Ê√ U�≈ Êu�b�« qz«b�Ë ÆU�«b���« r��
…U�UC� vK� UN�—b� s� UNKF� v�Q��Ë WO�«—bO�u�d� Ë√ WOMO�Ëd� ÊuJ� Ê√ U�≈ wN� …U�U;« ÷dG� Âb���� ��« U��d*« U�√ ÆÊ“u� Ê“Ë ”U�√
ÆWO�(« UHB�« iF� «c�Ë rH�« � «uI�«Ë WOI�eOH�« UHB�« iF� q�� Êu�bK� WOHO�u�« UHB�« iF� …U�U� Ë√
WK�U� �� Ë√ WK�U� X�U� �¡«u�© W��d*« «—bO�u�dJ�« qLA� w�Ë ¨ U�U�M�«Ë »u�(« s� «—bO�u�dJ�« s� WI�A*« Êu�b�« qz«b� dC%Ë
UO�U� qL�A� 5� � ¨…—u;« U�uAM�«Ë UM����œu��U*« s� q� �Ë_« X% ×bM�Ë Æ·UO�_« s� Êu�b�« UO�U�Ë ¨UAM�«Ë ®rCNK�
UMO�Ë��« s� Êu�b�« qz«b� U�√ Æ®“Ë���œ w�u�© “Ë���b�« …b�b� W�ËdG�« ⁄uLB�«Ë ¨5�J��«Ë ¨⁄uLB�«Ë ¨“uKOK��« vK� ·UO�_« s� Êu�b�«
W&UM�« jI� «dF��« YK� wDF� UN�√ 5� � ¨W�u�d*« WNJM�«Ë ¨WO1dJ�«Ë ¨W�ËeK�U� UH V�J� w�Ë 6K�« ‘d� UMO�Ëd� vK� qL�A��
W�œUF�« Êu�b�« «—U�� WD�«u� r�'« � h�9 ôË qK��� ô w�Ë ¨Êu�œ UNO�� Ë√ U�K���� s� …—U�� Êu�b�« qz«b� WO��U�Ë ÆÊu�b�« s�
ÆW�UD�« s� q�√ —b� UNM� Z�M� r� s�Ë
Âu�K�« U��M� ¨®pOJ�« ¨eO�uJ�«© «“u��*« UNL�√ s�Ë ¨UNO� Êu�b�« qz«b� «b���« sJ1 ��« UIO�D��« s� b�bF�« „UM�
«dF��« WCH�M� «bO�OK�« ¨ÍdA��« 6K�« qz«b�© Èd�√ U��M�Ë ®ÍœU�e�«Ë ¨r�d� f�_«Ë ¨6'«© ÊU��_« U��M�Ë ®o���« ¨d���«©
Æ®eO�u�U*« –
44