585e5d4905ef5 1

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 133

 

         

Treatment of Cultural Issues in Jordan Dailies

 

 
 #  " !  : 

$



 "&
&'  % &" 

0 
&"  
/ . * & - '&"  "
 (%) *+ ,

0 0", /0 '

"  2
  

2011
‫ب‬
‫ج‬

 &
'

*
& *8 7% "  2
    0 % &"# 6
 "&
&'  % &"   0 &# . 34 ! 

6>  " :4


= 6
' :& <&  '  ; &- 08
'
 6 
  (%)   / : 
9


 ' 7% &"#
 3
'%# #  - ' .B  %) A   ?@
  6+  :& 8 6
  :

6   0 : E "# 6


D .'  ! (A 6
 .  >  
 6 C< .# &

.
  

67
+" 
&'  % &"  ) ,   >%& "F  &-
 &
' 2 3@# 0 &# #  "

 &
' .' 0< 6:&,  B  %) 0&  '
 / <&  6  # +
&'  % &" 

.>  " 0<4


=  0<& 8 /  &- 08

      & 6


  H&  GA *A G  08
 &
' .'

   H


'# .*  7 A&  0<&, 
I  D  0 % 6 <   0 ", 
4    


.
 24  *  /  < <+ " % 6"  2
  

J  2  6  6B+


K L 2  7
+ # MK / 
,# 6&L
' ) ;N D O  6
D= P
' / 

6"" +  <&  &   %   6  < :  / *& 7% 6" 0"
&' 

! :8T ..   - R  GS  6*% 3


'  3
 ' 3D# 6* & .
  '  6 3 3 " 6: @ # *&

. 3"
 : #

662 &  !

‫د‬


:

 

    


   



     

!     

"# $%  &




* & U
<

# ...................................................................... 

 .................................................................... VT&

W .......................................................... ,  



,

..................................................................
 &
'

( ....................................................................... G )

 ............................................................. * & 4 ,

 ............................................................... .  4 ,

Y ...................................................... 
 X ND

 .................................................. A- X ND

"
 +  :.  .T

1 ................................................................ <&1Z1

2 ...................................................... "
 ' 2Z1

‫و‬
3 ....................................................... "
 4"#3Z1

4 ....................................................... "
 $ )#4Z1

5 ......................................................"
 )# 5Z1

6 ................................................... "
 * 6Z1

 +" * "
 7
8
 :  .T

9 ..............................................'  ( !) & * 

16 ............................................)- .-  ! , * 

23 ........................ .  /


 :, /0( !*, * 

36 ..........................$ &  ,  3 )  !2  * 

*G
 
 :B  .T

66 ............................................/- *  5  143

67 ..................................................-  2 243

68 ....................................................-   ) 343

69 ......................................................-  67 443

70 ................................................ 8 ( ( 543

76 .........................-   /- 83 ( /3 643

‫ز‬
77 .......     @ 
     :"
 C4 & :H 
 .T

101 ............................................ * & C4 & ,  :U D .T

112 .......................................................................... 2  4 ,

‫ح‬
 9 : 

T .  0[[[" .  0,

45 U+" Y <   >


 
   * 
  1

51
01967 – 1952 0   > & 
    * 
  0)# 2

56 3
01989 – 1967 0   
  *
 & * 
  0)#

62 4
(   –01989 0   
  >
   * 
  0)#

69 5
"
  $  # ]
&

78 O@ "     @ 4 " 



'& * A& 6

80  @ / > 


 O
#    7 ' H

&D C4 & 7

82      


 4 " 

'& * A& 8

T

83   
 / > 

#    7 ' H

&D C4 & 9

84  T  D  @  " 4 " 



'& * A& 10

  

85    "  / > 



#    7 ' H

&D C4 & 11

‫ط‬
86    @ * ) &- 4 " 

'& * A& 12

87   @  &' * ) & / > 



    7 ' H

&D C4 & 13

 

89
 < "    @ 4 " 

'& * A& 14

 
X

90    @ ) / > 



#    7 ' H

&D C4 & 15

91 V
   D&"   . 'F 4 " 

'& * A& 16

   @

93   . '- / > 



#    7 ' H

&D C4 & 17

94
  D  
^ &
  4 " 

'& * A& 18

95  @ 
 0 D&" _  / > 

#    7 ' H

&D C4 & 19

 

96   D  
^ &
  4 " 

'& * A& 20

*


97 *
    0 D&" _  / > 

#    7 ' H

&D C4 & 21

   @ 

98    D  


^ &
  4 " 

'& * A& 22

99  @    0 D&" _  / > 



#    7 ' H

&D C4 & 23

 

‫ي‬
"
 ND

 
         

9#  0 $ A, $ ?@# )  )  &  3 % )
 ;< -  => .

$B    C
 $ ;< .  . - '7  : $  $
 3 $ B

9#  67 /9- 


93  5 9 ;# -  . D .83 < #  .8 

 % .  .
 .8
 $ %  C # A-8 .8 2- ;# .    $ B

.2009 /% - 8 @%  % -    /)  $
 3 $ E $ @ % 7 $

.91.5 ., - .# F-


2 *  F /D G #  -  6& ., $ C  /) 

"-9  .   A-  83 ( "-& $ E .  #   *  /-

:H  ;# .  A58  $ # -  .  D .' 2    8

9 A) 39 .  A) (  "- ;# ( @  )3 / I- .1

., . B 

>9  E  7   2 , $M@# ( - A'7 ) $


 3 % "-7 J0 .2

.$M@

.$
3# , C 0  @  /   -   .3

*9 $ A $, $ # $B ;# $


 3     ?- )
# ,M .4

.= - ;# ( @  "#

‫ك‬
. ), C 0 $B  F383 $
 3  ,M .5

P -9 ;9# , $ ?@ 3 $ 3  7 /


3  A & "3  "O N # $ .6

./% I 

P -9 ;#  & "  ;# , $ ?@ $B   ##  " #-&  .7

P -9 ;9#  ,    ' - " #-&  $  .$
 3 #  A/%

;# '   ' ( " #-&   *, "   '   " #-& 
Q   ./%

.6 &  

98 .#3 !(# A  A#- A<)   .8 2 7  " .   % .8

./% P - ;#   ;# <

"  ;# .#3  - ( P - ;# , $ B   $7   58 . 7 .9

.  P - F% A % #D( /, A#  P - % A &

P -9 ;# A; &   . , $M@  &   $7 58  $ $) .10

.$
 3 "  2 /%

9   6  6 3 $- - '7  $7 3 /-   RB .11

$9 9,7 /9- 7 . ,    3 /- / 8 . $  .; &

.
%B "-  .  6 3

:* &

2-  .= S $    "&  / A %   & , @ % C 2-  41

.,  8 -  - #@ $


 :, P & , $  -

‫ل‬
$  A"& .T  A"O N  . @  
T / .5  6  / A&   
 42

.)0( )#% / A.  A' U   $7

 
 & :  $ .BD  .0T $   &  
 .T- J, 43

. H '7  /7  R A)0 B V  AC 0 .


3  
#

7 ..$
, &  ;# @    / A6 /0D& /7  R A-&  44

.$, "ON 

J % $ # 6 8 $B @  # ;# $


, & $   6 -  < 45

.),  3  @ ;#   A), ")##@"    ...D0%

‫م‬
Abstract

Treatment of Cultural Issues in Jordan Dailies

by
Abdallah S. Abu Romman

Supervisor
Prof. Tahseen Mansour

The aim of this study is to investigate the treatment media for cultural affairs in the
Jordanian daily press through content analysis of daily newspapers (Addustour and Alrai).
It also aims to demonstrate the differences between them in all categories of content and
statistical analysis. The study adopted the descriptive approach using content analysis tool,
which contained seven categories of major extension with many sub-categories. The
sample consisted of journalists have been selected by simple random sampling for the year
2009 and have been verified the tool by another analysis done by the researcher himself and
the percentage of consistency was 91.5.
The researcher used in the analysis of the data number of statistical methods such as
frequencies and percentages and Chi square test. And the study comes out with the results
which were as follows:
1. An increasing share of creative publishing and topics in culture at the expense of
publishing news coverage and Investigative journalism.
2. Different methods of treatments of the journalists in (Addustour, Alrai) cultural
issues with convergence in most cases in this regard.
3. The existence of stability in the volume of publishing in the cultural supplements
for the journalists.

‫ن‬
4. The impact of the background of the official editors of the two newspapers on the
content of the two cultural attaches. Interims of giving priority to creative
publishing than others.
5. The impact of the public of the two newspapers in the contents and
characteristics of their two supplements.
6. The writers had the largest share as they were totally the first source of the
cultural affairs.
7. The analytical method in writing in the contents of the cultural affairs occupied
the first ranking in the general level. While the narrative style come in the
second. The dialogue style was the third and the reported news style was the last
in the general level.
8. After determining the trends of the book in four sub-categories (positive,
negative, neutral, mixed). The positive got the highest rank in the overall level.
9. The results of the tables highlights that the identity of cultural content on the
humanitarian level was placed first followed by the local level.
10. The results show that the literary material in cultural level with convergence in
the results in both newspapers.
11. In the use of photographs .It was found that both (Alrai and Addustour). The use
of one photograph in the two news papers was in the first place, and the class
which not to use images was in the second place, while the use of more than one
picture was the ratio weak.

The recommendations:
1. Expanding the treatments of the Jordanian and Arab cultural scene and not
reducing it to just the literature and criticism and increasing the other cultural
fields such as fine Arts, cinemas, theatres and Heritage.
2. Stimulating literary criticism, Assessing the quality of the product, and not only
to publish the writings of the Authors in literature without critical discussion,
dialogues which serve the media process.

‫س‬
3. Intensification of the intellectual talks which comes out from the difference in the
literature and thoughts schools and open the way to the other opinions.
4. Renewing the names .and opening the way for the new writers and not
monopolizing the publication to the senior writers and journalists or the fixed
writers.
5. Ending the control of number of writers and intellectuals in the publishing
within a circle of relations and over taking the cultural lobbies from the cultural
scene in the daily press.

‫ع‬
.+  .T

"
 + 

<& Z#

8@  . 7 $ 67 , @ . 7 $ --7 67 @    6 3%  3 
Q  

.@  6 < 6 , @  T D    ,7    3 .>7  .  @ ,

 #   , X @  I D  $  3  7 $ , PM  !,  


." -" F 7 ;# 


,  3   3  A# /0( 8-  "-  . 

 .  D  %  3 6M@ 


Q % ., $ ?@ 2- @  %  3 .  

 H .  '7   3  %  3#   6M@  .#, * !)&  3 3&

.-  . 
 & B , $ ?@  ; &   A & $ ,7 JD 

.B $  $  & J3     &  3 6M@ AX> A.) 

##  A" -" "'7 " 


 3 #,   &    3 / 3 -  =>   

  '7     , 


3   $ B #  0 $ A, $ ?@ %3 ;#

> /T /   ;# J %  


 # % 7 $ I B  > Y ! (

$ ?@ .T  J 3#    .-- /   % / /7 A 3 $  

.,

1
"
 ' Z

!, 6  ;# .-%  %- 3D -- .T  $ 3  $% 0 $ & @

 ., 0( .  C I- $ F 7      -    7

%     .--  -%  P ,  3 JD  #  ;< Z  '> &

.   A)# D  "-7 $ )   B  A , 


3 $B

..  $  B F
3  B% ;< [ $ A  )  B A), ) 3 .0# 

( & Z  @    \ 3 F ;#   &  3 E   3 '?

3 P < . 37  A& , C 0 0 $ #   - ;#   '> ' 

T
E  $H . C 0 => $7  .$B $% 0 $ &  '  & Z # -8 

 &      


 !$,  .T "B  T E % A" $- # E3

.)  & , &   6 - $ E  :% - ;# '    7  A$ &

;# , @     A$ $ $ 3 $  " -" "'7 " 
 3 .#  

 /% I , -   X> !)-  JD  , 7 , "'7 " 
 3 !#  %3

"-7 J 
 3 )
#  A"#S& A('7 )   & 
3 --? 6 < :# 

. 3  /D & ;#   #   - ;# E%  E @  J 3 ,7  .; & M@

$7 $ .   !)  )  &  3  C & /D& ) %  A  " -" 
 3 7

D3 2  J 3 $ A % )  ;# A. 37 .#  J 3 $ 6    

6  -   $ /S  A    D  )0-T $  D ;# .  A  

.-)-? 6 < :#  : A-7  A)/% I#

2
"'7 " 
 3 #,   &    3 / *  ;< -  => ;%- !F#

J 3 => $ B #  0 $ X> !   % #  , $ ?@ " -"

 3 %     .-- R0 $ J@ A   P  # % .- ;<  3 #

$ ?@#    3 7 $ $ %   , B $ ?@ %   

.,

  ,  3    ., @  . 7 $ --7 67   &    3 ,

8
 / !  '7  6D P /% '7  @ . 7 $ 67  > .
, "  P D  

., .-- F   % .@  6 <   ,M ,&

/0(   A6 , Z < 8- $ 0( -  6M   B 

, 2#- Z ( , @ # 6  . < $ . #% .@ .  F   A T

. #  ,  3 JD   % 6 B 7  ! 

"
 4"# ZW

:M    -  #8-7 $] A/  ED0 

 ^ B  ^-  


 3 / .  , . B  $B  -1

^$B =>  $


 3 $ (0.05) P -   E83 <  C   

  E83 <  C     ^-  


 3  , B $ ?@ 3  -2

^ 3 =>  $


 3 $ (0.05) P -

3
  E83 <  C     ^, B $ ?@ @  - "-&  -3

^"-& =>  $


 3 $ (0.05) P -

 C     ^6 @  , $ ?@ $ -  


 3  " .  -4

^.T =>  $


 3 $ (0.05) P -   83 <

C     ^$
 3   (% )  % # ) , $B    -5

^, $B =>  $


 3 $ (0.05) P -   83 < 

B# B    ( - '7 ) -  


 3  - 
3 @&  -6

@& =>  $


 3 $ (0.05) P -   83 <  C     ^,

^
3

A/ -  A 3 :* $ , B   -  S  3 %  -7

$
 3 $ (0.05) P -   83 <  C     ^$  % $ & A. (

^ 3 % => 

"
 $ )# Z

:#  ;< J) % C  -  J

.-  
 3 / .  , . B  $B 4

.-  
 3    --& , B 4

.-  
 3  , B $ ?@ 3 4

4
., B $ ?@ @  - "-& 4

.6 @  , $ ?@ $ -  


 3  " . 4

.$
 3   (%  % # ) , $B   4

., B# B    ( - '7 ) -  


 3  - 
3 @& 4

A. ( A/ -  A 3 :* $ , B   -  S  3 % 4

.$  % $ &

.- J&   $


 3 $ 83 ( C
 < 4

"
 +)# Z[)

:  $ -  => 7 2 

C -  I B   ,  6 


 #  $ - # #% & M A )  :-3 #

#% .-  6   B  * !- .-  .& %  -  #@ .) 

$ /S  ;# A  &  3  , $ ?@ *   6  # . 7 5  .- 

- /   '> & !0( #% 5 # .  T .- .-   

.-  =>    $7 $  #%

V03( $ & @  3DT -- .T   B  A& + )  : 3 

'7  F     /0< 8-   A   S   #D< J  7   

# 6 3  6 , / $     & $ % ,  3 "%# ./%

5
* #  #3& , /Y  $   P 7 E  7 "#%  .( T ,

 7   .%   B @ 7  ,  3 $7  %  A( 

.   T # 

   3  , $ ?@ 2D -  % & M A.)  =>  B 

.- => D0 P J@ ! .%  0 - ;# J %  <    A  &

 3 $ $ $    -  .$ &  , 2     -T  M

#%  
 , $ ?@#  3 $   6   ;# J %  <   &

 *  . B $   .30 ;<  3    %  !/ @ 0(

.$ &    ,  3  

:"
 *  Z

. ,H $) % *  .  7 . #% 


3 %  3 :  

3 3 &   % @ ..  7 . #% => @ ;# "  

._ 
3 $
 D A   C   $ )
3 $
 D C   (

.    &  3  , $ ?@#   #  $ -

 @   %  % #  , $ ?@ ; %  $B  :   Z

A.0#  .#% '7     ( . '  ;#   &    3 %

.
 ' 
 & Z ( .>   , @ & X>  

6
$ 
 3 3< $ .(  & 
3 --?) $ A1971 / '7  . 3 :7#
 T Z

E  %@ 7 $7 $) 


[ .X> G  % D& J#    $ #, A- C     D

   .D A1986 /  !\ I# 


 3 2 A1974 /    .D $ . E

6    -  @ .D  X> >  . 37 


 3  # 2-  % ,M

.(230 :19966:
 #)

P '7  . I )   9,& % "'7 " 9


 3 $] A/1986 / . 7 9-  E9

Z81 :19886/[") .#% .0#  & $   $B .D . 6& "

 ;9# .> 9 - 9D "'7 9" 9


 3 $7 $9) A/1992 /9 . 97 9-  9 (110

9 9 9  & 9 3 9 . 0a 933 9# 9 - $ (`58.5) F9-

.(10 :19936 (

 ) ""9%@ . 93" " 9-9" "'7 9" J9 3 .#@ 9

% A/1967 / @   3# )  &  @ $ . 3   7   


 3 :
&"  T Z

) % A)  - J7 90 470 $ A7 2  )% V   ."  " A"$-#" 
 3 5

A/2004 !$ G 6  3) . 3 A #% )D3 2  )  & )  J 3  7 $

.(1607 \

:"
 * +  ZA

: .  ;# -  => 3

'7 " $7 ;<  - X> A$  - '7  
 3 $ -    4

< .D A   , C 0   3 $# $  $


 3  " -

7
B% $ P &   &   J 3 $< >< .   % $B - 

.. B 7 .
D  - /   , C 0 3<  " 

$B   , .


3  / , C 0 ;# -    3D /)  4

.-   

8
  .T

 " * "
 7
8


4: *  % 7 $ - .-  '  ( $ % 3


 > $ 

.'  ( : & * 

.- .-  : , * 

..)  /


 A, /0( :*, * 

.$ &  ,  3 )  :2  * 

;7
8
 .+  B 

., 3T  ;# .  & "  7  <  $  ;# A-  => %

.B $  $ A.) %-  .  !(Agenda setting Theory)" <" ) -1

'7  @  6  6)  2 A


# /0( 8- $M   ;< A)  =>  -

AB => V  / 0 $ " !> .2    B  A/%

$7 )  => P  ."  / ,-[ /0( 8-  A#  B #-

  A ) % BD ;#   0 $ A   ,M ;# 6 D /0( 8-

V  "-  ,M A  JD   > !/0( 8-  $# :  ( 


  ) ;#

!#  B& #- / AP & B b%  $] A . F-
/0(

:  " )    A < ) $7  B  . /T $ :  %

9
   *   A
# B# .    /   0 $ A") 

.(2009:2036 /")

   ;< 3   /0( 8-  / % ;< 3T     8  P7 

6< ;#   7 6 - 7 /    -   ;< $# ;# ,M  

./)   B "   / 


   @c / < P /  7 " 

8- $  D0% -  A".  & " " 7 " 2B "  .-  . 

3DT -- , B .  7    8-  X# b %   A/0(

2 /)  $7 2- T /0( 8- $7 B  ;#   => /  .2 /  T

. B  b% 8-  => ;# $ 8   < A2    B . B 

( McCombs, & Shaw, 1972).   %  /  6@ #   / 

  X> !6  % B 2 b   /0( 8-     %3# X>  %

 < B X# $ $     . B  ;# 8-  =>  3T ;# $ 8

'> &    ,< % / 


    7 .> . B  X# R3 AX>  . B

"   "$ -  $


-" J )    $ (McCombs, & Shaw, 1972).  ;# :% 

  C - A)  BD  7 ;#  % BD /0( 8-     #% : M .  &

A/ 7 $B   7 .> R3 *  B X# /  /  6 ,< 0 $    

B  -  c  F < J)  J - A b ) %  0< #- ;# % '> 
 $7

.#-  X#   V  /T / AB  = C  @  B  #-  X#

(Kosicki , 1993)

10
,M D0   .-  .,7  !  /0( 8- $  $  ,M # 

:%  )  A  F /  $   /0( 8-    :  A$  . $ 

"   ,?  .  $ ) %  P B 7 $] AF# ./0( 8- 6 7 ;#

.(289: 20066 " 7 ')./0( P .  &

3    - /0( 8- $7" P  '> "$  "   => '   ) /7 $

% .     
8 .8 8-  => / $ & $ ,  .  P  >

"$ " *  7 D ."2 /  B / 0 $ /% '7  $  ;# /0( 8-

$ 
 J  d0<  8 R  T" /0( 8- $7 / $ $   <

:20066 " 7 ') .(. #%) F  


 $7 " )  /S0<  8 R    A(.T)

.(289

/T F
)    /0( 8- $7 " 2B " .-  $ %- -#- .7 AC- 

/   & F 


 $7   '>  V  A. B  V    A % BD

.F  %@ $7   '>  A=  % $7   '>  A   B7

 (    - 7 .D  / % \3 /0( 8-  $ F 7 !X> ; %

  P P 3D ) 7 "- J - B => $] !-- 7  7 , B

$] ! G , I B  ;# X> % /0( 8- "  $   $ >< .8-  X# b %

.F  7 F  


   ,     J - B =>

A/0( 8-    B .  7 $ D0% -  " 2B "  .-  / 

0 $   $  D0% A  . 


 @  B .  7

./0( 8-     ( B . B 

11
.  . 2B       7  <  " @" ": " ;< B
 2 

A.T 6@ 7 I ;#    ,M /0( 8-  $  D  "  -  -8  B


;# ,M 8-  X# $  A-- .0 # .  &   /0( 8- /  $7 b 
 F 7 T<

.(McCombs, & Shaw, 1972)."6 , -- B .T 6@

 . B  $   / * A.  & 2B "  .-  ;# E8- =T >  D

O# 
# "$ " " @"  A. B  X#  X < $ A/0( 8-  

4: (Show and Martin 1992: 2004-212)  6*   &


& U 

/0( 8- . .  7 A  . .  7 :D ;#   Z>  Z1

.% . #% ;# 

'> # P - $ #  6   $ AB $   ;#   Z>  Z2

.'
 P - ;< % . #% ;# %

6  $ D0     A/0( 8-  6  BD -  ;# % Z>  Z3

. H .D $ J# ,M $7

.# # 6  
 $ C#  A6  BD :  Z>  Z4

Z:(Show and Martin 1992: 2004-212) ) *   H@  &" "#  &&
&" &

7 6    6  ;#    /0( 8-  68- B   -  Z1

.$ 

.6 -  '7 A


#   .  ;# 6  BD -  Z2

12
$7 B& $ ./0( 8- # ?  . B  3  P   #  " #-7 /-

$,  $7 S .$ 
#   .0 J 3 :, /0( 8-  P   #  @

. ,& ;# $#- 7 6  #- ;# ES $  

Z: <)# * & >  *   &


& 
8 *@
+ & ,

./0( 8- ,    % 


S< Z1

BD . B  ;#    A.-        :-& "S Z2

 CB ;< B( :   /)   . B   \  $ T A33

..-  => F X  '>

. & $      AV B   ;# ,M 3 .-  )  / 43

 B  Z < $  % 6 c B( 2  


 ,  

  % 3 $-- ,M 6 7     3T ,M 6  2 A8 $ 

 % => /- * A0( - # B< 3 /0( 8-  
S< $ 

.(291 :20066 " 7 ')  ,M 3 F 

#  6 - 0 $ A.8


 $  Z ] A-   )  => J - AX> ;#   

 ) B-  .8


 => .), $B    )   3  $ J@ J A$ B

A) 3  & A  "-& A" = A #% 3 A. B  ! A6 -T

.) S  3 % , *  I D $

13
:  . &- .D  Z2

 % >< !, /0( 8-  /


      7 , 3T  ) %

$    -  .,# 6 %  % 7 6   ,  ,  %  , 3T

:> ) .,# 6  T C- &    
# --7   .C
e # ;< - 

. (5 :1971

   , & -   -8     7 , 3T  $] AJ %  

-
 %  %   6 3% 0( .-  .
- * !3T I /#

A > $ B7    X# 7 /0( 8- #   , . % , "

 ,   .  3T ,7   AT  /0( 8-  ; % '>

$  N 67 F  $ ED0  A  


#  AT C- &  , T

 .  /
 E <  > /- D .(5 :1971 6> ):  $  %    0

.% $ 3T  .  => #  T 3DT 2 / ;# 7 

,M ,M  % 3T !6 3% /0( 8- -7 ;# 6% . M B%  

/ $    ;< 3 /  - # .%   3 ., "-T

/% 2 3T  . )  /,   ;# % .  6 , .% X  ..T J# 

 *  *  AP 7 .% F '>    #% / $ .


- A 

.  /% .% / %

/ D ., J , @ T , X T /


 , 3T   

'> , # %)


 #-  :/  %   A, X T -  $    , &

, .#% =>  --&  /0( 8-  , $ B "%# * A3T $ 5 

14
I0T \  %  A, X T $  P -   /0( 8- $7 )- . 

.3T    0 , @%

 J)  # C  $ E - 


 X #- "-7 I  / F  , ) %

 7 ! 3 % $ $ $  ;# , @ .@%  % J  2  - (

  7 $>7  6    % &  , AX #- "-7 '7 #%
 28D  .- 

A  &  3  , B %  *  > I B  $  .(356Z355 :19826:)

& $ 6% ED- 7 , ) % '> =T >&  % > AE) E- @ , $7 

 b% $ % X #- .#%


 .-  28D  '7 .X #- "-7 . 3 ,  %

8- $  2 C
   . @  E 7 E-%  $   6  % & '  

$  % & ;# J % , 


# -  #-  @  3   /0(

.3T #% J 7

IT /# :)-? "> A 3 3  '>  % - ,  $7 J % $

 / .% C- 2 D- P E   AB 7  % 6   D $M   ;< (/ )

28D  0 $ !'7 .E   T & $ JD  $7  % > .2 ,

.  2    J3  .6 .-  


 JD  $7 * A > : .- 

 , B -  7   >  .(133 :19826:) .6 - , T

.
3 $B -%

  $7 * ." %@ $    % % ? !James Dons   : 7

. G ;<  $ .0T b% $ # T A)--7 .  R0


  A"%@ '&  (

15
7 ? '> & .(8962 " H
)$ H /% $ 3 F 3 2  $7 !; %

.#,7  7 $  - %  " %@ $ 3T X T .#   % % 3 3

 & $ T .D0%  :-& $7 !Simmel  Z   & IT / P 

/  %  % => /%  . H \@ $  % $ @ F \@  $7 '7 . % 

T  A H $ \@ 6  -


 "    % =>   .
 $ I '
) 7 /D  <

    %  C .D0% J# . B  7 D3  % $  $7   @

JB R8- D0 7 %   D3 ,   $ D0% %   

.(359: 19966  )

% A, J# )  / 


 $ ED0  A, J / 
 3T .-  . )  D

3 *    /     X# '7 ., 30 E *    /?0 .#

. => #3& ,  7  .  $ X> ;# "   A


# , . $ @

.(15 :2002 7 )


Q  F  * .F7 *  % / '> # '  ( ;# *  > % A>

./80 #% ##  ( /  !, 3T  5  2B  $

; +" * "


 :  B  Z

  ,0, ;# - .-  b %-   &    3  , $ ?@ -  "#

 
 '> & ! @ @ -  I B  .      & .-  6   B  A--7

.  -  #@ $ - .-  $ ,  6 
  

16
. * "
:-+#

"'7 " 
 3 #, (,    &  3 \83) .   !(1988 A;- ) - 

.   @ 
 3 C  P  % ;<  3 # 
 3 $   $ B #  0 $

;#   P   3  


3 $B  I  7 ,   3

.(1988 6/") . 0( @ $ > 


T P # 

(%5.1) 2D  
 3 . $ :- "  .#  , $B $7 ;< -  .#3 

 >7  >< (%5.15) :- "  .#    


 $B 
 3 $B  $

% *, "  @  ] A, $ ?@ $B .   
 & . B 

.(97: 19886/") -- . B    . 0(

T >< A,   / 2   ##D  ] !, .0# # #    P - ;# )7

.(%0.18) P - &    #  P - ;# .0#  => @

$ ?@   &  3 / P 


3 $B  I )  2D -  :% A/ @

.$ @% $  $ .  ,    ,

  7 -   !(.TT /D 7 $ &   3 "7) $ % (1991 6T) -  )7

, C 0 #,  ) 0 $ A$)  - '7  


 3  &   3  


.$
 3 

'7   E # (49) .# #  - 6 


 3  , C 0 3 ;# -  .#@

    3  , $ ?@ /T / *  )  . -  E # (48) 

* !6 3 3 "> ,  3  " / $7 ;< -  3 .(%5.3)

.(1961:44 6T) E3 (12)  - A  / 0 6 3D 3D (68) $
 3 . @

17
"N  B7     A
3 , @   $&  "S F@ 58  :%

I  $ (%70) /- @ ><    3  , @   -& "3 $  &

.(45 :1991 6T) @  , Z (

T I  "- A -  ;#    3  @  , Z ( *  3 

"N  @ 6 (317)  , 6 (39) * ( . F @  I  $ * !"#

.(50 – 49 :1991 6T)

.
 * "
 :  

 -  A,     3  3 ) $ % (1989 A.  )  7 - 

*  /- D .(1987 ;< 1982 $ 6 


    / & J 3  '7  .
3 ;#

A. B  $B $ /T   6 @  6 F B  ;# J %# A$ B #  " #-7

  #3    ;# % J 3 -  58 .  7 .F / '> 
3 @  %

$7 !F37 2 )> $ 2    , 3 V  A % = - D  A$  P

!F   '> , $ B #  V @  ,  % , J7 ;# . '7    b%

/ #% - #% 


 "-7   !,  @# $   6   ?B

.  "   % . #3


# , 8@    
&  3) $ % -  (1993A-< $-   ) P 7

. #% # A%38.5 -  ; &   .#  D , . #% $7 8 .  7 .(' 3

)   . #% => $< AE


%B E -- 3DT . #% /T $ .#%

18
.8@  => ;# " . #% I ;  
# , 8@  ;# - 
& $

A"  : T -


 .  ;# . D  \3 $7 ;< X> -  .#3 

.  T  A  M $& A ( A3  AI0-T A %

A( -     J 3  , .


3) :$ % (1994 A B "7) - 

5  E- A - *% 6 , $ @ J 3  ,  # $  2D  \@ J

A6  B 3@ ;< *0, , .


3  ;< F-  58 .#3  .$ B # 

#S AB 7    $ ,7 *   A# F  6    ;<  

. < P - b


  A  ( 
3 I & - I
  A# ' ( 2

    /   ;# , 2D  ,M) $ % (1997 /) # $   -7 - 

$ 0) # = @   ##  


3 3 ;<  3  ;< -  J .(
&  3

 / "  $    D0 X  $7 -  58 .  7 .( %- /-) ( 3

"  $    D0 X  $7  .($ 0) #  / "  ' 3 , 2D 

%  % /%  


& .0 $< .(/-) #  / "  ' %- , 2D   /

.  . $ 6  - ;#

;   * "
 :  

-  .   ."  0(  (  3 ," $ % (Snowakar, 2001) -  *

;# -G C @ "   0<   Z <    /0( 8- 
  , . )  

..) ,& $& #  .#    ,   3 Z < 6<    P -

19
!E  (-G " ) /% C  ,7 $ 6   A/0( , $ D0% ;# -   

-8      J 3 "%# * ! )  3 ,    .E3D E  E [-

, #  .- $ 2 J# ,  @  --&  8B
 $ 
# .@

., - #    -  3 .     /#D( .-  

-G "    , B C#    0(   R0 /) 7 -  b %-

  .>7  
# .@ . %- 2# >   .-
Y .> J 3 #-#- @ < 0 $

.( NGA , ZEE) , -G " S -G " 

.   "-  3  , . #%" $  .# .(Canclini, 2003) -  *

. ,M % .T )   B     , @ 6<  6 3% -  3 

   & $ - ;# , &   \  *  $ "#  !#  .T   %

#  . - ;# E , A S B  T -- 3DT . B  2

.(Canclini, 2003, 43) A%   

EL- Universal, La Jornala )  --   J 3 *0, $ .  #  *  /D

(120) ;< J7 (70) J 3 => $ 


 3  I  * 1999 / 7 $ (and Reform

  , .
3 I -&     , C 0 % @  AE  - J7

.(Canclini, 2003, 44)

 3  , $ ?@# $ )     # 6 ;< -  58 .#3
) 


3   $7 J 3 $ , /- #  @7 * A   , B#   -

  ;#  ,  J 3  ;#&     P - ;# BD .    ,

20
. $  .(25 A129 A48)   ;# .  ! & ,   )7 .(45 A139 A59)

(36 A53 A21)  & 3 (154 A357 A204)   ;# ;#&  %@ ,

.(Canclini, 2003, 46)

   % #  .T $ C   ##  -  => .  7  A 

3DT /-D&  , . #% /T  *  0   .- .> ,

Canclini, 2003 )  % P   .> . 3 , . 3 /T 0 $ J 3#

.(50

.  B . @? / ;< 3 T 58  $7 ;< *  3 !30 

. F   '> .D   ., $ ?@  3 .  % #  $ 

. #% $   C /  #  , ;#    $  $ 

.(Canclini, 2003, 50-52)

=> .   ."$, -  " % $ 


3" $ % (Noha Mellor, 2008) -  *

@ '> A % /0( 8-  


3#  
  , -  / 
 %  - 

)% ,  ,  ;# 


 7 ,   :   3T /8 '#  ;#

.(Mellor, 2008: 471) FD 2 , , $

:0( /  ,N  6 3%  % /0( 8- $ Z> % 7 -  b %-

2 )  0( /  A  0( . # $ 


3  
  #-  @

8    $ 


3 F 2 '> *, Z>   A  \83 b%   $ #

,    # 6 % 7   /0( 8- E% A.  $        

21
$ 0(  2  A ( 8B
 .  7 Z   6 3   J 3 Z> 

480) #  $ ?@  ; 7        B  %- .    

.(Mellor, 2008:

C   " % $


3# , \83 -  b %- A/
 =>  B 

.#  % (Mellor, 2008: 477 –476 ) T , .


# /#% . @?

  & .#  % , .


# #% 3   b %- 0 $ X> A &

.(Mellor, 2008: 477) E  ,& " % $0( $  

> 7 A$, -  " % $


3  ;< = T 7 M ;< -  3

   c  -


 
  $B    A2  6    /-  

0 . (Mellor, 2008: 482) $@)   


 $ %-  T  # E  A2#

8-  " % $


3 X #- JD     , .%  ,  %  , 

#  & $ A    0( .D0&  % $ B ;# > D 

.(Mellor, 2008: 480)     &  

* # '
h  b
e  / ;< . ."   ,  3" $ % (Golin, 2009) - 

  >  @ '> , " 3T   ,  3 .    #%

6 D   6< 7 $
 ,   3    ,H $ ED0  A\3 
3

.(Golin, 2009) C,  ,

A3  $ #  ,  3 .    #% *  %  ;# -   

.(Golin, 2009), & /D  3 $   > P  @D 

22
* "
 "
 (%) O@    >T 0 ?@& 6 " * "
 / O- 

 B  * # * < 2 & /   _  ?@ *   (%) V


&" # ' . "

.>
  
       B / >
 

* +  0) T ;  0 :B  B 

;0   0<T Z


3 ,    , &  
3 IT /#    /
  7 , / 
 %

    F#,  "  ;< A6%  % .T / 


 >    B  A3

6% .
 % T / #% .D * A%3    % / 
 > J % $  @ . 

.(2002 6D)   6 B   % , /


  

/- # . 37 A   % (cotere )  0 %


 $ (culture) , # 37

 0 (civis) # $ .@  ( civilization) 6 B  # 7 A/ &   $ %#

FB  2D  :%  #  (Knowledge)  % 7 A %  #- 6 3  $   %

.(2005 6 . ") 6  X0 I0T    % A - ( 


 

/
 $ = , / 
   . 3 $ % T / #%  /D

  A% ;# 6 -#  - (    6 B  $7 ;< (weber)  "> * AP &

   $ % 6 B  $7 '7 A2  -  D0&   6     ,

. (Landis, 1978) ' % % $ % , 7    /

23
(primitive culture) 8 , -0 F  @ '> ( #   ) J % %

$
 J % $ "   X>" : 7 ;#   , / 
 . 7  .
 % /7 %

F
3  F% $ $- ( -  .% $& 
-#
  C0& $   .%

.(Landis, 1978)."F E B

A  : "- .(Landis, 1978) ' S ' $ ,# $7 ;# # 

H  7 '>  J0T > ./& " %@ $ .0T "- E   , $]

.(Landis, 1978)   8 F,   F " #-7 F FD  J#

:H 3 % ;< @ , / 


 3M $] AT / #%  C

.$ $ #      /  '7 A  P ;#    .> , $< .1

.T 8@    ;<  $   .2

.#  < 
# 3 
3 .-  7 '7  % .> .3

 3T C  ;<  8-  $   F 3 . ( :  A/0( 7

  B < & '7 @ F  ( J  B  J % . #%

(1978 .   0 6)

 #3   ,   7 /D   , , $7 RB /


 => 0 $

.  BD '7  / '7 @ J & =>  #-  /0( $< $  A&

 $ .()   3T 8- 6 , D) C-  /0(  .  , $7 A /B% P 

A'
  
) 6  /% /-  P D7 #- /0a R37 A, /
 .%- $7 .,

.(2010/ 7/ 27 Z  . 
A '  6  0  , . '  

24
"%3 0 0 $ & $ ,   , /0( J $7  A.
 % => 0 $

3  J C   --7   / 3T :    .= ; 7 AF#3

;<  3  $ F  ) @ , .)  $  /0< T    $ d0< $  , 0 A #%

.U @ $  A ,M $ =  C  #

. &
 # 60   Z

#-  : > .  ;< 3< 0(   2 3 


# /0( 8- / 

* < b  X> " #-7 $ ;< Z  0< " , .T S3 $< >< !; & # #

.= G F
D  % 0( -  ,M D # > $] A .#    -T

. (129/2009 .D  /") D0<  ,M T D

#-   /0( $ H 30 $ $   , /0( $ 0
E  $] AF#

 D0% =>   - $] AX> . => 3D& C   , $]  AI -&

  2 , J $7 $  .   # #3  D0% !2   - ;< '?

.#)  8-  @  C - 5  /-  6   /0( $] # 2 

, A%  , :   


 ,# I 7 6 X )   , $] AC- > 

/  #37 S ,  !(134/2009 .D  6/"


8) %@ ,  ##
 A. ,M

;#   R   <  % - , 2B  A  . # $ 3 S3 ;#

. 

25
 -  E  E  /0( 8-  $] !#  3 , $ I  > ;< 

$7 P  C  $ !2-  F  '> I B   .#- 7 < $  b

T
E  /  :  C >7 -< ;< '? * , $ I  >  E#- E  "%# /0( 8-

'> , $ I  > ( ,H $7 P  G C  $ A% $ ?@   @# /
$

8-   %    , $] A:% ;# .#- ,H C
 /0( 8- F) 

   &  V - .   X> ;#  .  6
-T $ /0(

(136/2009 6.D  6/") .# D(

 & # 60  


b& Z

3T /0( 8- , $  Z  X  3 !F- A  #%  B


.33  3 $ 


# >( :, - ;# .@7 J#

$7 A#% /7 .  7 2 R8 @ J# ;<  3  ;# 6 D  M A  >( 

   2 ; 
 ,   0 $ /% '7  , 2 3  E--7 E  "%#

. ,0,  #   .>( .- D .>( /0(   = ,M 


Q  '> )) &

 , ;#& J  .0( Z ( #  /- .  


# , .
 . % &

 X> !  5  $  . / / #% J % @    F 

$3   $# $   8  J & P   % /#% 5   >( .-

.(2010/1356  0 60   #)

 ,7 %- $7 $- a $ >< !b) %# \ )  2B 7   > ;< Z  T >( $7 

6 D -  % 6 


# . ,? %- $ A    $ .P & c F- 

26
3 %D F# 
B  A  3T $ F   >( /0( $7  A ,M

.(2009/140.D  ./")

$  - !  J $  b A, 5  C -  67 R37  A$ 
# 7

: $ $ 7 ;# F  $ )  T 3 >  . % . 7 /   /7  

$  T D  #  , ) %  AT 7 , $ ><   


# 5      %3 : &

A  A-  A  AX  )  &   b% . 
#  3  G #  X>

. D   .33 $  A, ;-      7      T * !(#

0 .0   #) . ( >    7 8   5   ,   6 D  3  

.(2010/ 129  

$  ;#  ,7 X  * AJ % #% 5  . $ $ 


# F,  C#% : ,

:  S    .-   .  A2 7 . 0

$7 A; % .6 @ S    @ J %  :'7 A   41

-  $ T  @% 0 $ F < J 3 @# R- J % /07 6@

.%D 

.#   
% -
 6 ,( 6 2 '7 :  %   6 ,<  42

"#3 ;# % J %# :  6@  - $< '7 : 0 0 $ /#%  43

.6 " #-M J % -  ;<   6 % %@ 2   !J %

..D  /") .@   037 6   X #-  7 % '7 :%  44

.(2010/ 209Z 207

27
$   "  ; %   3  M A A
 % $ !33  3 C#% 

 < F# 2 7 %#  3 .-  .  6-T  % 2#    .

 ;# I  F < >< .33 I 7 3 "%3 $ .  $ $% ID ;# 6 3D 

(2004/12 .D&   6$ )  % I 

:#  =  $ A, /0( $ I  > #3 \


)  

 % 8 / 6)  . B   #3  D 6   . #% & / 41

33 .0 J 3 = @   . #% & $ I  >   .  $

.6 B  7 "  
 3 => /  $7 $ * A"& 
 / #%  

 3 ;< -  3 6


   .D  @ J,   ;# 6- 42

."@ 
&

* 7 @  /%  7 J#  F @% '> 3% J .     < 43

.\3   . T

6  $ /  /   $ " D0 $


, $33# 3
  < 44

.(2004/22 .D&   6$ ) .. #%

$ 
# >(   ) /0( 8- , $  # #3  D0% X# $B 

  $ 0( C ;# 2  => $ &  $] !, (33  3

:;# /  0(   /  $ ;-   . #-& 


 

S  $ ,7 J,  ;# 


#  . b  41

. B b   ()&) J,

28
;# - '> & .-8  5   @ & > 8  Z -T / 42

.0( 6 "  % 

9 ,   0( \@  D3 $  0 AX> ;# 6 0 44

.(2009/ 131Z 129 ..D  6/") .# :

  G
= 60  X&"& -   4

;< , /0( , $   % '>  :  A6)  A  AF-
V  '> ?-

I >  , $] !/0a 7 ,# 6% .


 % $ /S  F 7 AR 3 ^)  >

  @  /   3T /0( 8- $7 !; % .,# I > /0( /0a

: $         "JD," # $] $  .2# ,

, Z>   .  ;< '? 


# ., ' >  7 .  $ @  3 

.(2010/95.  0 60   #) # 7 $  P ] 3 ; &

:;# 8D $  $  D0% $] A:-& > ;#

/0<  * .. #% $ ;# 6  3T /0( 8-   - 41

>  .. #%# % - C  .  T  X> ;# A'# /0(  

 T< / T G ;<  $ # " %@ $ "JD," # $] ! - 3 3%

..D  6/").$ H 3T ;# $- ( 6 D $ JB '>  > $ 6
-T

.(2009/36

29
2-  ;< '?  A=  * 
, 
 I( @ ;# /0( % 42

$- 7  >< /0( % X> .F I( "  .T <  % 
 CG

.(2009/171 ..D  6/") F  /% C > I


 T ;# F0-

*    6(2009/206 – 203 ..D  6/") , :   "-  43

8- ,M ;#    D( , . @?  *  '>   Z   &

    # 2D C# ;# %   F ;# $ 


# $] !, 8 ;# /0(

>  .  2D  :% T AR 3 S $  D 2D  > $7 /S A:  F#

"- /   $  '> 2D     :  $ 3  & / & R3

:.B  - ;#   => /  .$ 


#     % ?   $ 
#

 < A      /0( 8-  $    J# $ 


# 47

. %  ; 6  


 #  >   -   F b %

2  7 $ >  A & 2# '  , I >  $ 
# 4"

. & F# $  $7 "  /? $ H   @ $7 $ :  S

$#    G . (   6 B .- $ 


# -   C8  $< 4Z

.    % <  $   

 $7 $ X> F %  A2  7 $ $  <  , $ 


## -8  
  $< 4

./8 /  '  ;< J T  


# /0( F

30
 % > .-  6   -D  0 $  ,  $ 
# .-< $< 49

  ,  ;< '?  - *  . ,M => $7 /S 8  ,M P D  7

. 

$ - $> X8 7 %- /# $  % 2 $7 P  AP 7  .  A 

/0( 8- $7 B7 P  ..


   -    => J % ./0( 8- ;#

>( .0-#- %@ ;-   /8 ;# % '>  :  2D ;# %

.(2009/206 ..D  6/")  


#

 -% 6  $7 6 3%   "  0 $ ., !,   % < 

  A -% S P 7 "-7 ;<  - / >< ,   C  2- T 

/-  $ E% ,7  JD, ,  , .  $7  .0( 8- 

/   < 6<  < ;< $   6  .T       :X> , .' -%

 < .  @  7  ./   0( 3T 8-  . 3 $7 % # 

.(2009/107 6  0 60   #) /0( 8- 6-  ##


 * 

X# .>7 * A 


# .  ;# 6   . %@ .   AX> ;< B(

 @ % $ .#% 0-( .  b% !.# , *  $  $   

A@   & # $ ., 3  


# 6  E-   . 3 $  A 

.(2009/6   0 60   #)  3 . D   E %@   /- 3

31
0 .4 "  
b& Z

    . % % 8 ;<   .- 3T /0( 8- $] A/ #%  

 >< 3 . S .  .T & . #- ., % C#  /7

:$ $ 7  0 .)

.. #% 3  3T /0( 8- /  6 : &

.  3%  /0( 8- %- /T  : ,

R#3   $)% J %    !/0( 8-  , ,M M-  b  D

I B  0 ,& F
3  AH J %   A6% .
 % 6) $ $ . ,M

. #% b% $- ( - $ 5  $- ( X #-  *  '>  " :  A* 

'> %#  (J 3 7 X #-) % /#  F%  % F  ;# ,? 

: ,M > $  D ."C-  F /  $7 

.$- ( #  . #% C#% '7 : % 41

.B  . #%# $- (  D '7 :# 42

6.D  /") ./0( 8- F  -T 


 P '7 : #- 4 3

(2009/ 159– 158

:/0( 8-  ) , . ,M =>  7 $ $

 #%  @ $ 0 R3 /0( 8- $ 6- , 7  % 41

.0, $ 
# 6@  C S( P % 6  $ ?@

.% B  /% '7     % 3 $  3 , /0( 8- 42

32
 $  @ /0( $ 6 3 8-  /% '7  6D D  >< 43

.= 0( 3 ;#  @ 3D  ) ,7 R3   $] !(: ) #

!8 /7 % - $7  -    @ ' ,M  /  /0( 8- $< 44

., :  = 2 7   ;-  ;# 6 D F 0< #-  0, $ 
#

7 6(2006/106 . AT& 6


'
)  % 3   , .  @

  .7 ) 6   % # 6   % ,  7 %


 : 

.(2002/33 '&

2  7  ,M  T  % , $ 3 /0( 8-   45

..D  6/") .%


 /  M / 2  & R ) (T 8@ )

(2009/170

.D  6/") F  /% C > I


 T , I( @ ;# /0( % 46

.(173 – 172

(,
)      
  Z

7 # 7 , 7 A) < .   - . #% $ 


# i  7    3 $B

AF X@ T )  .#3 7  @ 7  -7 7   !J 3 =>   J0 ;# ! 

'7  3T $>&   ;# % E 0


E  )% <  $  3 
 $7

$  $7  -
 # "% $7 * & & M $7 
3 ;# "   > ./%


8 2010/143 6  0 60   #) F  @ ( .% b  > $ =3D

.(2006/72 .0 6 <

33
8- $ J#  ! 
 
% ;# ,M 8- P < ) %   
 3 $7 

. 3 $ 
Q  , $  .
, # 87  P &  - 7 8  /0(

$  6  #-     


 3 $  A$ 
# >(  E E 3  6 3

7 6    -T ;# F D 0 $ @    )  7 .D    $7  #

.(2006/145 .0 6 <)   JD 

$ , 3D< #@ F -   (/7 "- ) /  $


, b% F   #@ $7 T<

# ' - 


3 P  . % $# b%  3 3    3 $ /0(

)  $ , 3D< "- $7 ( 2009  25 ]


& 14976  V 
 > 
) R# 3

/   .   6 7 5  $ , 2 @ "S  I -   0(

$  .  - I @< " 'M  % S .   => $7 ; A/0( 8- 

 3  2  $7 A 3 / & 6  $     - – ' 3 " P7

2D   /% 2  $  A% M-  % /0( 8-  ,# 33  -

8-  , -  .0@ $   X  $< :   F-


"  - . % J,

 V 
 > 
) 0( .--? => 6 < ;# 8 . #@   % /0(

( 2009  25 ]
& 14976

, C 0 
 $< X -    A  8  $ , 
3  

$  !  %    0-T  $ 2 /-  7  8  $ % $

14976  V 
 > 
) .  D T< .% => 5  $ 0- .% %

(2009  25 ]
&

34
 , C 0  6  A$ & "  AX     , .8 . A$ & 

/%  , % J%B #@ $  & $


, $ 3 $  0 $ AJ 3

'  P7 .# $8 ;# 6   B   , C 0 7 2  "-7  7 = 

$M ; %  , 8  $  C 0 $7 " -" 


 3  , 6 8  R3

k # I -&  -  /     .:  2


 b & ;# ; $7 $  @ 

.. 3< .  " $

$H C   $  B / ()  7 ) 3 8 ) :   - .7 A

:(  7 0< 7  3 ") -  /- *  D  ., C 0# - 

  ., $7 .- 6 & #  0 , . 7 $ &  ,  3 $<"

: 7 A%3 .)  -   "-   3 => F  X> 2 .", @ -

.(2007/ 5/ 14 ]
&  7#
 T) ."    6   A/ T

 $ A  &    3  & , C 0 .  7   A$ AE 

:H  ;# A) 3

.33 , .0 F  '> d


 ) - , C 0 41

2    M ;# & C 0 .- ,     8- 42

. % J 3

b A  &   # C @ F     & J 3  , C 0 42

. 3 % , $(    J%B $  %  $ 


3 %  . 37 A %  $< , / '7 @ ;# % C 0 => 4 4

.(2005 / 9/ 4 
 X T) ., $M@ $#

35

     
& :H 
 B 

<&

  &  3 )   A/ @  %  3      ) ,  3 
Q  

 3 F . '> 2-  B  ;<   &  3     @ >< !\ @

.  &  3     $ #    ),

! % , 3@ .    % $   "& #,  )  # E

,  
 $ #  .   / %  7 3  % ,  3 .3 

.)   X# ;# RB @? T< !  7 "& , / 


 3 A"&

    2 A   $  % ,  3 R0 b %- *  > @

  --7 R0 #   :% A   2 7 ;< - /)  * !  & ,  3

R0  % ##  #% (    A-- , 6   A  &  3

.383 #    ,  3

:
    
&   ?

6 ># 6     A - ( 6 B     


 I( $  /7 $  3 ) %

, *     8-  /7 $ J 3 . % ,   & 

 M  % ,   ,  3 J) % * ! G ;<  $ 7 '
) &  - (

" S I@( 3T 8-   ;#     % A   


3 3   . 

.(32 :2003 &) ..0 8  @  A6 3% * & = k  P I0-T

36
 "& I 7 $  ) % J 3 .  .E7  M@    %  3 . 

J 3 .  .S0 %@ $ $ 


# . -   D  % # / $ F . 

& J 3 $7 ; .(81 :2004 6$ ) .7 J 3  M -


J3 $7 ;# \ 

$  .3 $  T7 A % ,  "& $  I @ < B] 6 


 X#  .-7

%
 . @  ; & % "  % .M@ ,   % 3 ! % "&  * - 7

.(445Z444 :1996 67%) . 3

2  ; @ 2- $  J3  $ 6 6 


  . 3   % J 3 / % $
l<

6 
 X# 0  %  3 " #-7 $ ! 3 7 6M@ .M@ D A$ @% $  $  &

2- ;#    $


3 " /  3 ;# "#S .J 3 & 2  

=> .   . 3% X>  & # \83 $ .   


# . 3 S0

D  ; "& 
3 $ $ D
 :  $ / X> .X> G 
3 . 7 /7 $ \83

  $
3 "#SM !6 
 X#  J 3 ;# & 6 -  > % .; & % " 

 &  $  37 J 3   -? "#S7 $  ."& C  $  3# $ M

/ < A/    A - /#-  - :  AC@ :   7 4:,7 3% X>

% * .3  J % A: - /#- A$ $  A$     " A

.( 443 – 442 : 1961 6>


) .  $G   3 "& /07 $ T?

Z ( m# ! % /%  &  3  A; & % "  .#  6 
 .@


n % ."& $  $   $ # ; % 3 7 .0 3< * .#  X#  F > ' 


     :8 "  " # : % /%   , % "  D  & .0 /7 $

@  3 .   " " # . %@# .33 A/1932 /%  6 3 '@ 7 

37
A    ""@" # A/1933 /%  6 3 . $-  & "- " # A\3

.(443 :1961, >


) .1939 $7  7    :8 "," #

"  -- M $ ) :  7 .& J 3 .%  A , % "   ,7 

% "    % .8@ 8@ "  & J 3 .7 ., "& 7 "- ;#

F = 3 ;# ,? A* 7 $ F '    % 


  6 /#% @  A ,

  %- F   % R37 % 3 A-- ;< "& $ " % =  )  ! 

./S / C  67  3 $ -  ? %- Z < " % /)  R37 A  FB &

.(450 :1961 6>


)

- 6 6   2 !>< AD .3)3  :&  3 2  "-7 /7 $

) %  3 $& .6  .T J#  D .33 .  A   / #% / /#%

.T .  A 3% .  A     3  7 "   - ( / #% $ #

.(3 :2004 ,$ ) .


 &          33

/ #% ,  #  %   F 37 '>  % $   .0 J 3  @

 .33 J#  .   $7 ;< A1988 /%  6 3  %   % %

40 ;# % > I ./% .  $ 3  %3.5 -  '7   2465 m#  % $ 

A0#D o %  > .  # 287 , "& .   m# ..T ;@ .#@ \3

2  C0( ;# ;#& ; F 7 T< !F /#% -  % $  $-  2  

6$ ) .  # 


 3 240  m#  3DT .   M ..33

.(42Z41 :2004

38

     
+ & .


-D E $ & @ >< ! % C @ D7  ,  .D   3 $ & J % /

. 3 * 7 $ 9  & 9 3 ) % .


3 $
 9 % $ F9  /  ,% % 

/ D    $ / $  #@   & 9  $7 ;< & >  % . % /% 

61991:>
)   &  3 _  7 6 ( :-M 2 $ & C @ 6 7 .--M * A/1920

.(346

-- J  .  #   A     2 7 ;< $ &  ,  3  /-

4:    => A#   3 /% . 3D

.01952Z1920     >b Z:-#

.  P & # #   A,    &   :-M 2   &  3 6M@ . 

       -  3     J 3 $7 ; .     J#  

@   &  3 6M@ J3  .  T 3DT -- .    &

/ %   '> & 2 .- -- J& . (, 4 --  3)  M /

. B

 
    3 7 ,    &   :-? $-  $   & X 7

$ 3  C  A/  - / /% '7  M @ F  0 $ A  $ 7 .,

  :-M  – $%    " #% C " 


 3 6 ( :-M C  !
#    7

.T ;# .   .( ,  )  %@ $ ./1920 / J    3< 7 –   &

39
$ % \@7 $ 6 3D 7 ;< B( -- IB & C#%  3  

.(211 :1996 6


  #) T /  /@ 

 -  A/1923 / 7 28  " % C @" 


 3 . 3 " #% C " 
 3 %

.  @ ;# 6   3 / .$ & D @    -  6  ;< /1926 /

"&    ;# J @7 #% & -- .T @  .     & $  

- R37 0-T % '7 /1946 /  /, $ .. #   F
3  @   @

.(9: 1996 6:   #) .  & ## -  6 

 7 < /)  A/1921 / $ & C @ 6 < :-M % J 3 %@ -  /0 E

# /, $ /1909 / 


  --7 D $ '> 3 #  ;# /1923 / 0# , %

3< ;  .(305 :1958 A.3) $ & 6  %  # 2 /1923 / $ ;<

($ & " % P3 A% @ A" % 6 )  6  %   7 J 3 2 7 . 3 J 3

.(231Z230 :1989 6/" ). 3 ;< \ I    A/1927 / @

  &  3 6M@ ;# & $-  $  & 3@ RB  ,& AC-  $

J 3  & F $ B% @  $ & $<  .B $  .  @ >   B

 %   & J 3 $ %  ( & F- X @ & $  !  &

"-- & " " 7 $" F


? . @  A  & "3    & 6  
 3 \
)  

B( #-#- .# @ ;# 


 C# T J3  &   # ; $>#

.(79 :2002 6). % D  #   ( F <  D .83 .T $ %

$ , @  #% B   2   @  $ &   3 .>7 

.   $   ;# . 2  )   %   &  3 .B % D .$  &

40
 3 2 T X>    .P &  % $#  3 $ M #%  !D%   &

  $ & ;< #7  ,7   $-# 6-M I D ;   $ #D - T< $ & 

3  J 3 . 3M A/1950  $


B 6 % 3 AD @ 
B ;< /% /
3

>     &  3 . !.T J#    & $M@      7 E


3 : 

6>
).   3 P - ;# 
3 %      # %- .  


.(346 :1961

B $  . - ; A/1920 /%  ; & M@ >    &  3 .- 

J 3 @  % .   %@   .@  A B    & , 2

A.B % @ J % . %@   A'  %@ P - J % $ / J 3 @  

3   .  A  &  3  &   ' ,  I( 6 
 :
   

!
3 ;# %  % "&    $   & J 3 
p  /  .#  6 3 #@

J 3 @7 $ .& / <     -@ % $- F $ 6 .T @ /

; A  # 6  


 3 6 
 =>    & , 6    .-7 .D 

6)."& ,#  - $    .33 !6 


 X#  #D ;# , S J 3

.( 285Z141Z85 :2002

$M@ ; % .    & J 3 "#SM !  33  3 $ )  & $ & J 

 37 6 3 #   7 #  " " # 6 


 X#  7 $ ., &

/1927 /  . 3 "" % 6 " 6  A/1924 /  7   S 7     & "&

A 7 # 0-< #  /1932 /  6 3 " " # A,  -7 

  , #  A/1949 /%  $ #  <  , $ 3 .   " . 3" #

41
A @ # 7 0-< # => A/1950 $  . 3 "  " # A

#   @ 6  3  -7 # %@   .  A/1952 /  " /#" #

" 
  " # A % "& B  /- #  7 B C# $7 .    7

 
 "&  $   B  /B , $ ?@ ; % % $ . 3 D

.(125 – 98 :1997 6/"). 7 #  @ # $ &

   " T 3    & -- $ 6M@ 7 A.)  6% 9#  => . 

%-0 9 % 9   %  A$-#   93 ' %-T @  9

/& 3 6M@ 9 , 9% "  " @ 9#  => .@ A% P - ;# . 

  D $%    / 1920  - " #% C "  $ &  .  9


 3  7 .  .6 

 ) : %@ $ A7 % 7 $%    3 * A$ ;< $-  $   &

$B  $9  $     . 3 . @ J#  - &     ( ,

B( A.D  X> 9 68- #   % 9-- IB & .     .T .  

-   -T % .(23 : 1982 6 0


) % /@  $ % \@7 $ 6 3D 7 ;<

9
 3 . 3 A$9 ;< $9-  $9   9&   6 9a 9--  & 

    :7  $ .( % C @) /9- .# /1923 /9 9 ;9 & 9- 

$ & C 9@ 9   9-  69  ;9 . 37 A/1926 /  A6 &  . 

20006:[
  #) .- 9 . 0( .9S0  & $9   9@ ;9# . 3D ><

.(54:

A/1923 / $-#


 
 9 T
E 7 . 3  "$ &" 9
 3 3 .  @%  @

"  ;< A/ 1949 /   


 3 ;< .  /, Ai  -7 3 /1927 9 - $ ;< .#  /,

42
 3  /   / E B J 3 => .@  .  @%  6 3 J 3  #D

.(29: 1984 60


)

9# 90-<  A/1932 /  (9 ) 9# . 3  A. ,0,   7

." $   /0D7 "- C  $ B  $ E C  $7 .- .9 97

9
 3 (--  -7) (C,) 
 3 % > 0 . 3  P & J 3 $

93D 97 9--) 9 (6 99) 9


 3 (9-- 9 -7) 9 (9 9)

.(55: 20006:
 [ #) (6 93 9

$ & @  9-- 6   7 9  & 9 3 .@ A. % & 9 

.$9-# 9 I D A/1946 /  0-T 9 , 9% "   7  .9 

/- 9  (C,) 9  & "%@ "9 /-   (8 ) 9#  => J 3 $ $

 #) (9 ) 9
 3 9 % 9B  " /- 9  ()  @T    " 

.(56 :2000 6:[




:7 \83 6% 6 


 => J 3 .- D

.--  "-& 3  /  T / 41

. . ( J%B 42

.  .-  -7 J 3  7 43

X#  3 ;# (&   A83 A  3) F@7 J# & Z ( 6 - 44

& $   (  --) , S .0 J 3  " "#S7 $7  .6 


--   .T ;# "#S  .$  $


3 7 $-- $  - $
,

.0#  .T .  A-- B# b %   .


   & 2

43
X#  "O  "#S7 $7 ;< X>  % .-- .
  $ %  3 7 # "

 % #  / -  3 /  ;#    A


e  # ? ' >   / # 

6 3% 0( .-   ,M D   / / ! 


 /-< /T  

A % # ;# 6 .


 < 6@  3
 2  ;< .7  ,    

."/0( " /  ;-   )   $ 2  '> &

  ,7 A& $ / 6 
 X#  .0 J 3 " 37   -? "#S7 45

AO  /7 6  6  " 3 $ - A % C @ 6    :8  @

." &" 6  " 3   ;


3

$> $   A  & J 3   -? E %   37 $> & T? $<

, .@D     %@ .  /   $-  $  & $   $ %

  A" ? /  .%  % , B    B ;@    %-

7  3 A   - A  /%   A  ;


3 A$ - A @

.(266 :1980 6VX). S

-- T ' 


    %- T%   F@7  "&  3 .%

$B ;# F 7 ;@ "& 6 - ! H  @   -    !  & 2#

& . ( 6  $   J@ %  6 J 3 @  ;< .7   & J 3

6 D ;#  D( $ /    6 .... .T /7  %@ .   - " T?

& "&   & "%@ $ 8@ %-   @ C#% ;< P7 $#% 7 6 J 3

. 
 /

44
4:(1951 –1921) U" Y < 6>
 
  *
 &   * 
 

 $ , $M@ 33 S 7  P 7 , .  !$-D ;< - /-

.6 @ S , .

(1)  

U+" Y < 6>


 
 +  * +
 

:(6 @) ,  3 47

  ]
&  ' 
  0 &) O 
    
  0"


  
 

 & $ , 7   7 # # 7  3    

1923  S

1950 $  7 , 8- #  6


 %  6

 /

:(6 @ S),  3 4"

  ]
&  ' 
  0 &) O 
    
  0"


  
 

1920 J  $%  ,   6    & 6 ( #% C 

1923 $ @9  .  - 6  6  6 8  % C @

;9
9< 9
9B( $  9
9 . 

45
& -- .T

$  $ 7 --   6  :  % @

1927     

1927 $ 7 # # $  , >#

1932   $ 7 # 0-< # V0 /  



1937 #-  , #  , -   ,  

#-

 & $ @ $ 3D 7 -- 6  $ - 6 

1939 

1939 $  , # $  , $  ,

1940   $    , # $  -  $  - 

1944 $  , #  , -   

$ 

$  $  7 -- # %@ 7 $7 8 

1945

 , $  $ 7  -- 6   'S 

1947

1947 "G $ 7 -- # $997 C99  $ % ,

 %D

46
 & $ @ $ 7 -- 6  % %- C 

1947

1948 : ,  -- 6  '    *%

: % 

1948  , # '  $#-  

$  $  7 -- # .@ C


@ C,

1949

1950 @ $ , -- 3D # $   $ &

' 

1950 >G   7  -- # #   # . 3

' %

1950 7 $ 7 -- 6  ' / 7 &

- '

1950 7  , -- # $%-  




# 6 

1950  #7 7 # 0-< # %    



47
.01967Z1952  &      
 :  

;#  @  - .   67 /7 .  A0  A6 


 X#   3 $7 F X@ T ) 

 B  8-  /7 $  3 .   .   :  @ ] -  /#%  2- 

0-T  '# ( " T   / > @  : "# .  !.D  X>

F
 - -0    %@ X>  B% -- .T $ = @   0 $ A/

.(14 Z13 :2001 6) .= @ 

$ ?@ $ 6% "   ;#    " 0 6 @ 6 - $ #  =>  $ & ; 

 %     # T B 3 " 0 $ A3DT  -% -- 0

 @  Z 7  " & .  #  X#  .$ &        B % J 3 $

.$ &    % 0     @  /#%   6 

A @T  % *% " :  &  - ;#      $  " &   $<

8%# E 0-  3 /- " & X# "#S7 .  &      " 7 A @ " 

$ % 3< ;< " & "#S7 . - AF% 8  .   " T B   &

!-- $B "  ;<   , $B J, @ - A- C   J 3

$ # $ A" " 


 3 $,%# $ A" %" "$ " "" J 3 $ @# $

 #)."C," 
 3  @T    "  A"0-( V
" $ a A"'7 " 
 3 " %

.(6Z5 :1986 6^

>< .  &  3 ;# , "& 6 -    AB $   . -  ) %

. 3D . , , .0 J 3 % . -     & ,  - $ "S

; % #  A/1961 /%  6 3 " C&" # 4:       ;#  -

48
# A/1963 /%  . 3 ,  -7 #  ""D " # A 
 , "&

6   3<  . - %  A/1966 /  $


 , 6 8 $ . 3  " 7"

D ." % $  & $ 


 & @& 83D .T @   @ , #  .,

.$D  P  -& $ 3  ,7 , "& /07 $ . 37 /0D7 0 $ . 

Z 59 :19966   #) ./0( ,     , /-   /  .  

.(80

.0 3 .@ #  => $7 ;< @ A  &  3 ;# "& 6 -   

 & .0  7 7 .$ &  & , 6     ,7  $ . 

: " % $  & $ 


 & .-   #  .DT $ &  . 3

  7 7 #  7 .  A'   ;- "c A1952  6 3  @ " /#"

$ D  @ "- C0Sa . B  7 S .E  E#  %-  @  C  33

# .#S7 $7 $ A% 0?  ?-   :8   $7 A1953 /% @  . 


 3 $ 6 3 " C&" # !# J @  J % "& '   $7 /S

$> "@ " $ 6   .-  280 .#  A. -   "  "

;< # $ 8 ;%-  .$ &   


 ( 6 -  D   2D  %   # 

 3 $  
 & .0 $  JD  F, 7 '> #   -  d
 -

& 7 # 3] $


 , 6 8 /D  B7 3 $ .
D   7 S A. -

  
 &   @   /  "% 6 & .#3  A/1966 /  @  


.(246 :1989 6/") .$ &

49
-- "-7 6% A#  =>  $ &  & ,  3 6 - 2    %

:) 7 

$-# 0 T .) 7  -% /8 $ % A$ &  B $ A% ) % D& b %

$  0  ;< .) 7  /1967 /  /, $ A/1948 /%  $ & ;< 8 7 6 

 3D    ,7 )  $ & ;< $ -#
 $   V    & B &

& 2  7 P --     $#% 7 6 ;< B( ! 7

D A$ & C @ ;<   


B $ 6  7 6  AD @   F@ $ &   

. B] /D A/1948 / $-# 0  / ,M ;<  % > .-- /T /# ;

"#S7   $ 0
E B A6 
 X#    6     " 0 /  A/1936 6 ,

3 !/ @   &  3 ;#  - P7 '> & $ ;< -- $-# J 3

JD    & J 3 2    )- T A


3 %    I  --?  3  7

% AX> ! @  #D  '    J%B  . ( J%B "-  %

-- B 2 "& /T 2  ;< P7 '> & $ &   #D( J 

 % $    .  :  -D J $  % & F     /c

  6  6 - A/1956 3 ;# ,0, $ % A %-   0-0  

6 /, A/1953 / 3  -8 # 3      >   % " %@ "#S7 ;#  %

      ;<  J  $ $-     & 2  B


)  -

.-- /  ;< P7  3DT  


 T /

50
(2) . 

01967 – 1952 0   > & 


    * 
  0)#

:(6 @) ,  3 -

]
&  ' 
  0 &) 
  O A &-   
  0"


 
 

1952  #7 7 # / < ;-  /#

'  

1960 7 7 . 3 # $   %@

" %  "

1961 , "7 #  %  C&



$ @ $  , # . %  -

1965  &   &

$  $ , # , 6 8 7

1966 $


51
:(6 @ S) ,  3 4"

]
&  ' 
  0 &) O A &-   
  0"


 
  
 

1953 $  , -- 6  J#  3 C 

-# 

 & $  , -- 7 6  F   7 '7 

1953

@ $  7 -- 6  $-    %

1954

7 $  7   # /% ' -  $




1954 -

7  / 3D -- # 6  ;  $ 

1954  

1955 $  7 # #   J-   


  

"G $ 7 # 0-< # $ 8@ 6 8 /0-( P

1956 0-(

1957 $  7 -- 6  , S  @ 

3D

1963 $ , -- #   / # "D 

1963 $ 8- 7  # V0 P 6 -&

$- $ B  , # #& '  #&

1964

52
.01989Z1967   W   
 :  

 3 6 .#@ F


 !  &  3 6 -   -  A/1967 / @ 

.#, %   , 6  ;# X> G   &    :8  


3 /D7 >< A  &  

A;-% ;-%   1930 / . 3  $-# 


 3 :2 &   : J 3 5 

 6 3  
 3 A/1933 /    @ C3 / < --7  I 
 3

 /1961 /%  6 3   


 3 AJ 7    J @ /#- :  A/1953 /%

5 /)  D ./1965 /%  $% .#  A % J @    J @  :

A$ $ " -" 


 3 3 @   3#   &  @ @ ] (   A$-# ) 
 3

. 3 @   3# :  @   T .M@ :  (I A) 


 3 5

.#  .% 3 J M- / A/1967 " "-  3 JD   ":" 
 3  

.(104Z103 :20066$
) .$ @  :7   @   

J 3  7 .  A  &    3  - ;# - 
 3 . - A6 
 X# 

T " BT  . ,M  ,7  @  %- 7 A/1967 " %  6   6 3  

AB $  . -   % -- 6  . B /B      & J 3

   .D7 A/1970 41967  $ $ & F@ '> --  - 0 #    %

6? 
 3 $  /1971 /%  ('7 ) 
 3   3   
 3 :-M ;#   &

 - % $ . @  %      & J 3 ,7 '7  R3 A    

  C  # 7 '>   &     T ;< A/1974 /%      % 

.(44 :1999 6 <'").  & J 3 3 %-

53
  & .    3 $ D0%  ">>  )  #  => .) 

 5  .J 3# --?    ;# ; 0-   ;# ,7  !D%

X0 ;M ! 3 = %- V


 -- A; & F     # F-8 %  

R  ;< V
T > 2 AJ 3 ;# D  ;7 /1975 /  A/1974  "'7 "9   

 - '7  :  A/1976 / "%@ 6  A/1975 / & 6  :-M \ 

  C  $7  , "- $7 -D $  "%@ 


 3 .-  !   3

,7 .# .B 6)% %  .B %   .  & I @ - 2  @ T  %-

-- 7 '> A$  B    ;# /1977 /%  3  " - / $7 ;< A6  $

6   F 7 T< .""%@"  < ;< B< A6 6 


 "'7 " % ! 3 ;# CB

6      # 7 J 3 . <  A/1988 /%     /D A , F-8

A'7  A"%@ . 3 *0, . @ 6 < 


Q /% >  '3DT $&   . D D .P 7

.(104Z72 Z53 :1999 6 <'") .$ - 6 D? 6 < $ $% A -

/%   -%  %   &  3   > T)  @  .  $ D * 7

$M@ ,7 ; %  @ .0  -&   J 3 . 37 A#  =>  ./1967

.& , $M@ ; %  .0 J 3 7   2  ;< P7  A0# --

6 3 %@ $
 # :7 A$ &  , .0 b% .  AX> $ /S  ;#

  A @7 ,0,  3 \3   #  A/1974 /  , $  @ 

6 3 #3
 /  $ # , 6   3<  . - $
 , 6 8  37

' $ 6 3 %7 # /1974 / $- @    /  $ #  ,  # $

P # !'   ,  #  3   S , #    & %  

54
# !' 2B  "-    P -   3 / A1983 /    6 3 ,

     :7  #3 #  /1983 /%    & % $ 6 3 ,

"   $ 6 3  @ , #    & " # !    --M

.(130Z95 :19966   #) ./1989 /  $  & &

/ ; /1968 / $ =? - '> #  =>  & $
3   @7 $

 X @ !  &  3 % J3 '> " 7  '  "  F ,  % /1994

 3 @ <  6  F-< ;< B( A  & , 6  $ &  
3 I

 C& #   6  @ <  /-7 A$H F#   ;< 3       &

R37 - 6  :-M  X @ A$


3  :-M  /-7  ./1961  - : 

  & 
3 --? 6 < ;  1974 /  .. - :    -8 /1968 /

/8 % S ; A' ( F# 0  $ 2  / .#3   @  ,T ('7 )

62003 6  ) ./1994 /%  , 6  F  , =  @ Z)  . - X#   B 

.(53Z9Z7

:H  ;# #  => 0   & ,  3  R0 /7 3 

. @ S @ , $M@  % 


3 .0 J 3 7  ) 2  4

.& $
, /7 %#   $ ,  3 F    )% 2  4

.6 3% 
3   / /T A, 
3 %  \3# :-M  4

.  J 3  3   -& , & 


3 C 0  4

, .  3<  ;# #- , .--?   & .%   4

.33

55
(3) . 

:01989 – 1967 0  


  *
 & * 
  0)#

4:(6 @ ),  3 47

]
&  ' 0 &) O A &-   
  0"


 
  
  
 

$  $ *  # , 6 8 $




1974  , %@ $


 %@

$- $ , # /  $ % /  $

1974  

1976 $ ,   #   ' %7

  & %

1978 $ , # $  7 $

 , $    , #  7 J , P

1983

 #7 $ , #   & % , #

1983

1989 $ , # "   "

$  & &   &

4:(6 @ S) ,  3 4"

56
]
&  ' 
  0 &) 
  O   
  0"


 
  A &-

1986 $ , # #  "H # "H

%

  &

 7 T< ! 0     @ @ , $M@ ; %  .0   $ /S  ;#

 7   "-7 6% A. - . % & #   & .0 $  @   ,M D7 . 

 .-   & $ 6   8 3  % 8 "  % , 8  $ 3

. 

.
  7 & >
    
 :  

 -8   T     ;#  3 7 Z


 ;< .)7 6 #  A1989 /% @

6 <'").$ & #    6 - "      &  3  A @ $

.(122 :1999

 ,M   -- * 7 $ X> 0  A$ & ;<   6  6  A1989 %

 , 5# " C-  -  T   $ !27 /% - & C @ /#D< ;< $ &

D
 A/1991 / - & C @  /0- #     ? /, A. # C % 0 

F  . )    & , @ ;# . ,7  % =>  !/1994 /%    '

$# , % 2   -7 ;# 6 /


 F< .B7 A,  3

6 ,M A  & ,  - ;# -


.B  7 , . <  ;< P7  ! 3

57
, @ ;# -- . - !'7 . - /7  %@ /7  , X> $  - -- * &

 6 (   $  : ;# A-- * & $B , & "#S7 .

.--  3 ;# , "& $ -- @ ;# , . - * A. -

 . 3 :7 #  X#  , $M@  33 .0 b% X   F 7 T<

=> 2B  / % .  A/1993 /  . 3  @ #  , 6  $ 6 3

%@ 7 . B  6 ;< B( F@7 J# %@ ##
 *   .0

.> T .  ."& ,  .T %B  ;# "#S  .   #@ $


 #).F@7 J#   & , @  ;#   . 6 7 $ 7 .

.(130Z95 :19966 

:  A"-7 6%  % > . 3< JD  #SM %- .  C  $7 2- / A 

.  A, J 3 @  J%B A$ &  


3 C - ;#   J 3 6 -

, . $ 3  7  .2 $  % 8 "  @ 7 #3 33  3

=> .  A   3  2  X# --?  . D  : 3
) 3 ) #

3    . 0( "- @ T I-T  A 0-T  -T J 3

:-7 ;# 3 


3 .--?  !      D %  A%
  0 )  

$< >< AP & J 3 : ;# 6


 .> 33 
3   0T B( A 

.--? %  , .0 J 3 "#S7 : ;# A$33 S 6     "#S7

:  C
(    $   T A#  .33    F@ 7  

.P & J 3

58
$       %@ "&  /T $     &  3 .% 

A/%   & 
3 @ $M@  M@ A@  ;#  "& ; >< A0-T D B

- '7  6    J 3 7  & $B# 33  -   T . 3M

.(96 :1988 6/") %5.1

>& d
 > - P    J 3 .  A$ &  &  3 2   

, $ ?@#  - $  \3 A0  & , .@   6  /

., $M@ ; % 3  -7 C 0 3< /, $ A&

 $ % /   2 I  .'7  


 3  , 6 8 $ , '7  C # 3

$ 
3 6 @  , $ C # $  * A/  J# '> & .$
3  7 '> I -7

 ,(     A -  ;# (  


 "   C # > ; % .% 
 3 2D

' 
  # -  I(   @   ;# >  R $ &  , @

@  X> $ $
, $ 2- ID  @ F
3 , C # R
  .
 &

"  ;#  B (  - A&  # %- T \3  A/, 7 /-  Z

6    @ ; % F  ;< B< A&  -  - .-   X# A@   &

.(2006 67#
  >
  >
) . % , /07 F " ><   - ;#

 ;< 3 , 3 .%


  - '7  
 3  -& , C 0 3 %

J 3 . D .  $   .-D >< %B    -  A


 3  $ %11 F-

 6 3 I -& 7 J 3 => $ , C 0 3] .  ,  6 3  -&

 -&   J 3 C 0 ;# ; D ./1972 /%  6 3  # 
 3 A/1959

7  <  - .    A , /  6 3 3 ' %  %@ @

59
, Z ( $ %709 $  & "O   B7 ,M-  AV B  C 0 - 6

.(46 – 43 – 42 N :1991 6T) . - '7  


 3  @ 

B     P & $ 


#   .  "'7 " " -" 
 3 $ 0 $<

"-  .
3# # /-   5  - 
 3 ! \  #  <

' $ 7  R3 '  D  ,7 A" $ % , 6M 
 T 2 . B 

.-  J# , $    /   - C #   A %% -  D # ' 

.   :H  ;# " &   A'7  C #  6 @  % 


  .  7

V  @D  C # .
3  F33 '7  C #   .% "& .-   

C # A # .- # /201046425 C # \3 / 0, A3 .-   6  BD

b% , . -  7 C # $7  .$ $ 


 & $ $#  # /20104141

$%- / < .  ' :   - .0D  %- , , $M@  $3)3 "

.(6Z5Z4 : 2010 67 ) ./ S 6 B J-  3 7

/   -T  S      


 3 6 @ 2 7 $B $ "'7 " .%DO 

;# R#3  3(   -    2   


3 , D
  7 A1995/11/27

A >  F $  & F   /)  , I @ > \# ."6   "" F-

D $   ,  & $ 7  % *  $ )< )   % \ 3   7  / * 

 A @ F# C
 A  /   ( % > @ ;< 3[ /) , A" @ ;# . 3

C # @ ;# A @   %  & % & /   !C


T ;# %D   % J 3

A,  % "  3  - /  A" 6   "" /- .  6  2 I   

C 0 => . 3 D . % 2  - & J# P  % , /%  /-

60
.  .8 J# $ < %   D0  A1997  & $ @ @ >  /    @

.(2006 67#
  >
  >
)

4:)7 \83 6% " -" "'7 " 


 3 $   , C 0 .- D

, $ 8- < .= S $    "&  %   & , @  46

.,  8 -  - #@ $


 4:, P &

 
 & :  $ .BD  .0T $   &  
 .T- "S 47

$- F % $  .   .T-  -     AC 0 .


3 $ 
#

."& 
 /07 $ / S

'?  $, "  ;# @  3D .   T< 63 @ "  O  / 48

." #-& :
$ #  #

., C 0  @  8-  Z ( # A,    67  /-< J%B 49

./  $& 3 C 0   $ , $M@  $3)3 " "S 410

.
 "M C#% 2B  @ < .    BD V  / 411

 % C  < C 0 .


3 ;# $  3 $   , & $ 412

# "&   & k   ;< P7 '> & .   T< A % "  5# P &

.$  3  , "&  %  I@(   3 $   

;# $
, & $   6 - !'7 .)##@   J 3  , C 0 / 413

..D0% J % $ # 6 8 $B @  #

61
 / !  & , -   , C 0 F#  '> '   $ /S  ;#

 % .% J 3  , C 0 F 2 '> \3   $ P - ;< C 0

.  % /   $ 6% .0@ $

(4) . 

4: (   –01989 0   


  >
   * 
  0)#

, C 0 47



&"- 
  0 &)- T 0" 2 0"

- :  -7 '  7 '7  , '7 

% I  ,

- : -7 '  7 - -

% I  , ,

JD   -7 '  , /  " % , C #

I 

JD  : -7 I  , /  " % 2- / 

,0,

JD  : -7 '  ,  J @

% 7

62
4:(6 @ ) , .  4"

]
&  ' 
  0 &) 
  O A &-   
  0"


 
 

1993 $ 7 , # , 6   . 3

1994 $ ,   # $ ?@ % 6  

##   

1994 C
 , 0< # . G %  



 < , # X   % X  

U  , # U  % , U 

? , # ? % , ?

$  - , # 3%  7 

$ , # "  C 7

$ , #   & % 6 /0D&

$ , # 3%  7 , $

$ , # , 6  $ 

63
:(>
 
^)   Z

]
&  ' 
  0 &) 
  O   
  0"


 
  A &-

@ C
  , # G %  

1994 .

$ , # # 


0 % 83

$ , 0< # C @  @ C @

0( 0(

$ 0<  @ # -  @ -

, --

$   , # 6  

#- 0< , # # % #

$ ,   ,G # ,H 6 8 ,G

%

C 0 \83 AP M 7 6 3 A-% ,  3  $  @ R0 /7 $<

/   /% 7 
D    # 5    J 3 >M  A  J 3  ,

 3 ;#       7 # /D7 " 7" # %)  A, .0 2D  . 3

'> #  , @  3( > $ '  J .1966 /   7 3 $7 > 

64
# , .D  X>  3 .   3 $ .%   .0 b% ;< 
 $

.(2009 6 ) '   ;- -7  $ P 7 #  @ $7 -7  '> " C&"

>   /0D7 "- $ &  ( , @   < ;# , 6  -- / 

$ 8 $,0, : ;<  3 6%   .8 # .D% D . 7 # 6  \#

$7 A.#% => %
 2D  , .0 3 .#% 3< / A2010 / ;  3

%
 .G /  "  ;< A, X#- , 5  $ , .0  s /  /

. 3 #  & 


 .0 A 7 , , 6   3  .0  ,

.(2009 6 ) $  # 

6 % ., @ "   $ < "  ; %  B #- .0 => $ # 

A$ - 6 . -  .%  A$H  1966 / >  3 3  $7 .-  7 A" 7"

X  B7 .  @  $  #  @  .     / , @ %  /S

.   : # ;# A  " 7 0 $  & ., ;# V


.) -
[ .P  $  7 $ 3 A' -  I( ; % #3 , #  " " 7

 .  -   $ G :, A )#  -& "-  A &  /- #

   -8 ;  1998 /  &   % 3 @7 ,0,  6  3   #

.(2009 6. @  )$ @   ? 3 . .$   X> G

3 D A1993 / . 3  "$ #" 3%  & , 6 8 $ 3 X>

P 7 .0 "  ;< -    @ $ # .2010 / ;  165 ;  

.(2009 6
") ., $ F  <  A/   ,

65
B  .T

*G
 


B  < Z#

\83 .- % J3 ;#   " A


3  *  $B -  => 

*  /- *  $ I  > <  ."  7  7 A$% JD  7 A$% 2

:$ $ 

. #% ;#  3   - AE  E# E =  : - 5  -1

" #-7 *  /- = <  ."-  2B " 6   C#%  \83

#  2 - 0 $ $  "-& "- 7 F  $ B # 

.6    6 


 0 -  J 3  , . B 

" -" "'7 " 


 3 $    < J F- /)  D :$  5  -2

., $ ?@# J 3 $ 


 3     /T   ;# J %#

66
:"
 H& Z

  & J 3 $ $ , $ A% A/2009 / 6 3 & $ -  2 $ ) 

$
 3 $  /)  D " -" "'7 " : A/   $ &  3   

: . 0

 A   $  $ 3 A" -" "'7 " 
 3 0  •

   -     , A$


3     .-- $

.P & 2 $

/  #- D0% # % C  # -   $


3 , •

!0( -- A  " " D& "'7 " 


 3 % * .--

#,   B7 :%  


 3 #  /% I 3   


 3 #  %   .  & 
3 --? 6 < :#  /% I

.)0< )0- ,7   A/% I \ I ;< " -"

3 # #- .--?     & J 3 I B / $ /S  ;# •

 $
 3 $7 #  J % $ F  T< A @ T 2  $ C 

.    &  3 C -   @  ,&

.@  ;< % , ; % .


3 C 0 $ 3 $
 3 $< •

.  #  ,  

$
 3 $ C 0  @  ;< $ % $ &  $
, / % $< •

.E  E#  $


 3 $ @ T

67
:"
 + ZW

C 0 $  !2009 /   $


 3#  (730) m -  2 /  

:  ;#  %  ;<  # /  !/%  ;# % /  T< 3 T ,

@ *  .  2 7 ;< 2009 /  6   6 3 & /- :/  


 ,   @ A >G @  , $  : @7  6 3 & ; &  

  @ A #7 "G   : @7 ,,   @ A$  7 $- : @7

. & $   , $ @  & $ @ : @7 % 

@  $ 8 @ @ % /   /) , A2-7 % 7 ;< @  /- :  


A$ #  24 $ 


?  % $  !> .6    - $  12     %  

J) %# $
 3#   6 
   /)  D > .( -  % 52 37 $ 24). %46 -  '7

< 3  /  58  $    ( , $ ?@ %  .)  
 ;#

.-
6 
#

24 7 E 12 7 7 6 $ JM .   $7 ;< Stemple "-" @7  > 

 .-  C  [ % > ) % .   - 7 #   ;<  3  ;< '? A E

;Y 
)  -  2  :    $7 3 !$ B #  " #-7 .)

.(214 N 601989

."
  $  # HA& (5) .  + 

68
‫ول )‪( 5‬‬

‫&‪%‬ار‪ #$‬وأ!اد ا  ارا‬

‫ر(' اد‬ ‫ا‪%‬م ‪ /‬ا‪,‬‬ ‫ر(' اد‬ ‫ا‪%‬م ‪ /‬ا‪,‬‬ ‫ا)('‬


‫)ا‪%.‬ر(‬ ‫)ا)أي(‬
‫‪14921‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/1/30‬‬ ‫‪13963‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/1/2‬‬ ‫‪1‬‬
‫‪14942‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/2/20‬‬ ‫‪14012‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/2/20‬‬ ‫‪2‬‬
‫‪14977‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/3/27‬‬ ‫‪14040‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/3/20‬‬ ‫‪3‬‬
‫‪15005‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/4/24‬‬ ‫‪14075‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/4/24‬‬ ‫‪4‬‬
‫‪15012‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/5/1‬‬ ‫‪14082‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/5/1‬‬ ‫‪5‬‬
‫‪15068‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/6/26‬‬ ‫‪14131‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/6/19‬‬ ‫‪6‬‬
‫‪15089‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/7/17‬‬ ‫‪14159‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/7/17‬‬ ‫‪7‬‬
‫‪15131‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/8/28‬‬ ‫‪14194‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/8/21‬‬ ‫‪8‬‬
‫‪15152‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/9/18‬‬ ‫‪14229‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/9/25‬‬ ‫‪9‬‬
‫‪15165‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/10/2‬‬ ‫‪14236‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/10/2‬‬ ‫‪10‬‬
‫‪15208‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/11/13‬‬ ‫‪14285‬‬ ‫ا! ‪2009/11/20‬‬ ‫‪11‬‬
‫‪15247‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/12/25‬‬ ‫‪14299‬‬ ‫ا!  ‪2009/12/4‬‬ ‫‪12‬‬

‫ ‪"
 > # Z‬‬

‫‪67 9 .$


 3 7 #  ,  6M $ B #   /)  -  J7 C  .‬‬

‫‪9 9B 9 9@ 3T - #   P 9  J3 9 /9- *9  9#- 7‬‬

‫‪67 3T 6 J3  0# 67" F 7 ;# $ B #   $ .9‬‬
‫   ‪Q  /9‬‬

‫‪Z262: 1983 6   6 0 " 6 


 ) ."? # 67 3T 6 $  % b  T‬‬

‫‪.(263‬‬

‫‪69‬‬
4

 Z[)

:4
 * T
& .& * 4 ;-+#

$ B   E ] *  /  A83


 7 .
 3 $   .8
 => 3

$     ;#M F
 3 $ B > J3  -  A#  J A=  

. - - # " #-M 58  Z - #   < R  ! @  B 

 , C 0 $  ) % Pilot Study 0- -   ] *  /D A.8
 =>  

.8 (10) ;# .#@ 6 - S3 ;< 3


)  D .8 @ @ [  /)  A% /  3

: F# F7 *  #@  .    ;< ;%- -8

; % '7 3T    


 . B   3 :   @  @ 4 41

:H  ;#   8 (11)  $B   *  /D ."^D >"

 - , * & , @ & C#%  . B   :, * & @ & 4 1\1

. <   7 '7   . 

A %@) 
 & ( , Z ( % @7  @ :( & Z ( 4 1\2

.(.. V - A  A3

, C 0  @   . B   @ :6 3% , B ' 
 Z ( 4 1\3

.6 3% %  
 , B @D  ' 
 Z ( .T 

#3 .>  
 , B UD   . B   @ :,  , B 4 1\4

. B 7   JD  $ ,  8-

70
#  .   , C 0  @  
3 .% . B   :&   4 1\5

.  "7 $  % , Z ( 

 , C 0  @  


3    :(.0 ") 6 . 3( 4 1\6

. 3(  '7     (   @ #%  


 & , . 3(

.6 . @ 

 7  @   $ #@ $
# 
3 % : A$  ;# @ :#@ $ 4 1\7

.P 7   $B 7 - @  - 


 . # @ H "   

.> @ & * &     .% $B  @ : 3 $
  - 4 1\8

. 3 $
  - BD    '> #    A 3 $
  - #3

  @ & * &     .% $B  @ :>( $ 
# /0( 4 1\9

.(.  T)  /0( >( $ 


# /0( #3 .> # 

#    @ & * &     .% $B  @ :6 % ,H 4 1\10

. S  ,& "  .# U   ,H 6 % $


 #3 .>

.    , C 0  @  .% $B  @ :8& $
 4 1\11

.  S 7 b   S \D $ 8& $
 #3 .> . B 

.- .8
 J 3  6   S , . B   :P 7 4 1\12

 8
 => .) A-  
 3  , $ ?@ 3    3 :
 4 42

:H 3

.
  , . B  $
 3 $   $> '7 :" 4 2\1

71
.
 3 "-  $ #% $    $ #  $ 
3 '7 :$ 
3 $    4 2\2

.( )   &  &  4 2\3

. %  & .T 4 2\4

. &  & .T 4 2\5

       A 3 ;< 6 @( $  @   , . B  '7 . 3 $  4 2\6

. 7   .0 J 3 $

2B  $ B =  7 "  7 B % 7 M 8


 => R)B  :( &- 4 43

:@ F  B . B  7 B 7 JD # -  # 

.T % = .> $B  :< 4 3\1

.#- =T .> $B  :#- 4 3\2

.#- =T .> $B  :  4 3\3

 #- "   6   6     .T # $B  :# 4 3\4

..D  :
 6 

=>   / ., B $ ?@   .-  C  8-  '7 : "  4 Z4

: "-&

.'   7 ' < " #-M .D  $B :'   ' ( " #-& 4 4\1

2 F '  7 33D @ !'7 .' - " #-M .D  $B :' - " #-& 4 4\2

.* &

. -
     B  . #% / ##  " #-M .D  $B :## 4 4\3

.'  " #-M . 7 .  @ ;# .D  $B :'   4 4\4

72
  V - 7 A*  I D V - !E 
 A$  % :   
X
 # < 4 Z5

:@ B 7 6  

;# #  #3 F P      7 5%  , $B  @ :#  P - 45\1

.  & P -

#3 F P      7 5%  , $B  @ : % #D( P - 45\2

. %     '7 #D( 7  %   (

.  P - ;# , .% $B  @ :  P - 45\3

. - ( P - ;# .% $B  @ : - ( P - 45\4

AF % $ .#  , 6 $ B F /)D '> @ 8


 => C#% :T .' * 4 Z6

:$B

. & 4 6\1

.   4 6\2

.' ( C  4 6\3

..,   46\4

. 46\5

.* & ;9# C#% 7 #  46\6

.  46\7

.7   46\8

..9  46\9

73
..9-  46\10

: 
^ &
  4 Z7

= %@< k  ;# . ,M * ( /- , 0( 6#  %  3

:;< I
 A I B  M

;# J %# AI B #  3 6 3   / 7 6 3    3 : 3 47\1

. S /7  -
 /7 3@ /7    3 .   - AP  # 
 3 7  &

. (  , $ B 2B  3 :. ( 47\2

 - & $ E F8< A= ( I B  ;# $ & <  3 :$ & 47\3

. 3# 7 $  %# 7 $# $ & . 

A, B $B  ( .-  $  % I ;# J %  3 :$  % 47\4

.' , '  .    -8 $ %   /

U  "# :  

*  /   # 0( 6   3 .0( 6# % 6  *  /-

7 $%- 7 A)   ;<  )0( 6) 5  -  6   .## 

;"
") .   C  AJ 3 A)3 A/#
 A" :#,7 $ .0 $ $@

 ), . B   .)   7 .   -  =>  6   % .(262 N 02006

._< AAA    :, A" -" A"'7 " :
 3  A- ) 3  &

74
.@ .& >
&"- *  2  
&D :  

:2  Z

#  6 - 6 D P '7 !: $7 "  :D $ F  *  F- '>O : $7  %

:H . ( / /)  A-  J7 C  ;#

.    B 8 < .


 % / D #  .8   /)  41

/0( 3T  $33   $   ;# $ B #  6 - b  /l  42

'7 ('   C3) C  R-   03 ;# /  6 -T \


 **  5  ,

$) A$)3   . 0 # % .F- .%B  /80 @ : 6& $7 $ C 

.83 ( # #  3 6 -T $7

:*  4

  -


c #   >< '7 .: . 7 $ . #% 0- :D F 3

6 A58  => $  % C- -    6  -    58  $  $7   A>

!H  ;# -  =>  *   >< AC  $ ,M ., $ C  /

*  $ .,   C  (Doob) "  F   C  ., 7   C-T 4

>  % #  $ -7 % ##  /D $ B $    *  /D >< AF-

.%91,5 F- .#3 .58   T


E  E  ED- 

:"
  0 D&" & 4  0& Z

.(spss) C 
.D  *    .& C4 & / .   "    "
 * D&"

75
.
3   #  8 "-  .   4

.   0 $ $


 3 $ C
 $ (Chi Squire) ' 2   Z

. 83 ( -  #8-7   8 "- 

76
H 
 .T

 @ .& "


C4 &


    

<&

"'7 " 
 3  3  , C 0 $B #  58 b %- 3
 > $B

% * !-  #@ .  # -  #8-7 C 58  b  /- ." -"

.-8    , $B  8 "-     .%  ;# --7 @ 58  b %-

.
       * @   @ :-#

$7 ;9< (6) /9D  9  #  58 @ A-  #8-7 $  & ?- $ a

-9  $9  ;9#   A#  6  0 , 0< - 541 . ) B , C 0

X  $7 ;< @ > . -  E   (267) % 49.4 -  "'7 "  E   (274) %50.6

.$
3  , C 0  @  /  E  - X  $7 A$ # $  B  

77
(6) . 

O@ "     @ 4 " 



'& * A&

O
&"  7#
 O@ &
&

%

'& %

'& %

'&

3.5 19 1.8 5 5.1 14 , * & @ & 1

42.0 227 42.3 113 41.6 114 ( & Z ( 2

18.1 98 19.9 53 16.4 45 6 3% , B ' 


 Z ( 3

6.1 33 .7 2 11.3 31 ,  , B 4

14.2 77 17.6 47 10.9 30 &   5

0.9 5 .4 1 1.5 4 6 . 3( 6

5.5 30 6.7 18 4.4 12 #@ $ 7

4.4 24 7.1 19 1.8 5  3 $


  - 8

0.4 2 .0 0 2.6 7 >( $ 


# /0( 9

1.3 7 0 0 2.5 7 6  ,H 10

1.8 10 1.1 3 2.6 7 8& $


 11

1.7 9 1.9 5 1.5 4 P 7 12

100 541 100 267 100 274 I 

$B $ $ ; &   .#  D & ( Z ( BD $7   58 $ $)

6  .D
 AJ 3 P - ;# ./% I  P - ;# ( % 42.0) -  , $ ?@

78
B => .#, .( - % 1.8  %501 '7 ) "  > @  " -" ;# "'7 "

./- . >   A - A< \ 3 A %@ A $ 3 A6 3 3 :

;# (% 18.1) -  6 3%  


 B ' 
 Z ( BD  , "   .

=> @  '7  6  ;# - 6  .D


 AJ 3 P - ;# ./% I  P -

2 D0% H A,  B : B => .#, ."  ;# (16.4 A% 19.9) B

BD AC   .  BD A' B  2  J# BD A/ B  BD A" 

T   BD A H :  2 D0% T I  BD A'3DT T 

.--

% 17.6 -  $


 3 ;#   (% 14.2 )-  &   BD . A*, "  

.'7   %10.9 - 

.D
 J 3 P - ;# .(% 6.1 ) -  %    .#   A,  , B )7

.%10.6 F- C 
  >  - 6  ;# '7  6 

-  / @ B  7 #@ $


 .  $B . A: "  

.('7  %4.4  - %6.7) @  -  '7  ;# - 6  .D
 .(%5.5)

 , $B ,H 6 % $


 , @ & A 3 $
  - $B 7

"   .  A$ 


# ><  3 $ /0( 8-  #3 .> , C 0   

.%85.9 F-  .#@ $B -  7 2   ##D  8 -  T

   @  @ .' 2  &T     @  4  2


T   

.Y% ?@ (7) 0,


.  &D  ' >  +  7 ' H
 0 D&" 0+ & 6


79
(7) . 

 @ / > 


 O
    7 ' H

&D C4 &

_&" 
H
 ,  @ &
&

-  
 7 '

*.038 1 4.263 , * & @ & 1

.947 1 0.004 ( & Z ( 2

.419 1 0.653 6 3% , B ' 


 Z ( 3

*.000 1 25.484 ,  , B 4

.052 1 3.753 &   5

.179 1 1.800 6 . 3( 6

.273 1 4.263 #@ $ 7

*.004 1 8.166  3 $


  - 8

*.008 1 7.000 >( $ 


# /0( 9

*.008 1 7.000 6 % ,H 10

.206 1 1.600 8& $


 11

.738 1 0.111 P 7 12

$B .8  (0.05) $ D7 P -   83 < T > D  X  $7   58 $ $

: 
 , $ ?@

80
.  83 <   4.263 8
 => ' 2  D .# >< !, * & @ & •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3 C




.  .83 <   25.484 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< !,  , B •

- 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3 C




.  83 <   8.166 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< ! 3 $
  - •

.'7  6  .   $ ;#7    $& - 6  R3 C




.  .83 <   .7.000 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< !>( $ 
# /0( •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3 C




C
 .  .83 <   .7.000 8
 => ' 2  D .# >< !6  ,H •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3

2  /D $& X> 83 < C     /# A, $ ?@ $B  
 .8
 D ) 7

.(0.05) P -   83 <  S  .)   / $ 7  -  '

"
 &T     @  
 :  

(8)     .8 :    /  ! 3 C#% A-   , ?- $ a

.X> $

81
(8) . 

T      


 4 " 

'& * A&

O
&"  7#

 0

%

'& %

'& %

'&

88.0 476 88.8 237 87.2 239 "O N  1

8.9 48 10.5 28 7.3 20 $ 


3 $    2

0.2 1 .0 0 0.4 1 ( )   &  &  3

0.2 1 .0 0 0.4 1  &  & .T 4

2.8 15 0.8 2 4.7 13 3 $  5

100 541 100 267 100 274 I 

: 58    .  RB 

/% I  P - ;# , $ ?@ 3 $ 3  ) 7 /) 7 /  "N   •

/# T - .# >< !"  @ $


 3  # T  .%88.0 - 

.%87.2 '7   %88.8 - 

%10.5 -  $  ;#   %8.9 -  $ 


3 $      ,    •

3 I  $ %96.9 F   $0@ $-  $ .'7   %7.3 -

., $ ?@

82
T "-  .  3 $  .8 A &  & .T A( )   &  &  7 •

., $M@  $


 3# 3 
%B "-  A%3.1  

H
 0 D&" 0+ & 6
 .' 2  &T    
  4  2
T   

.Y% ?@ (9) 0,


.  &D  ' >   7 '

(9)0,
. 

  
 / > 

#    7 ' H

&D C4 &

-  _&" * 
H
 ,
 0,



 7 '

.926 1 0.008 "O  1

.248 1 1.333 $ 
3 $    2

.317 1 1.000 ( )   &  &  3

.317 1 1.000  &  & .T 4

*.004 1 8.066 3 $  5

$ ?@ 3  (0.05) $ D7 P -   83 < T > D  X  $7   58 $ $) 

: ,

C
 .  83 <   .8.066 8
 => ' 2  D .# >< ! 3 $  8 •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3

83
A & 3  7 .  &  & .T $
3 $   "O  #, •

.83 <  S ' 2  /D .  * C     /#

.  


   D&"  "  :  

   /  , $ ?@ @  - "-& C#% *, ?- $ a

!X> $ ( 10)   A  .8 2 7

(10) . 

    T  D  @  " 4 " 



'& * A&

I  - '7  " #-& /D 

%   %   %  

14.6 79 19.5 52 9.8 27 '   ' ( " #-& 1

29.2 158 22.5 60 35.8 98 ' - " #-& 2

36.9 200 38.2 102 35.8 98 ##  3

19.2 104 19.8 53 18.6 51 '   4

100 541 100 267 100 274 I 

"  ;# 3 D , $ ?@ $B   ##  " #-& $7   58 $ RB

-  - 6  ;# E)  A"-&  $ $ /% I  P - ;# %36.9 -   &

.%35.8 -  '7  %38.2

84
> O   ;#& '7  6  .  A%29.2 -  ' - " #-&  A , "  

"  ;# 3  A'   " #-& 7 . - 6   %22.5  %35.8 -  " #-&

- %19.8) $  " #-& >    $   -  .  A%19.2 -  *,

.('7  %18.6

 " #-& >   .%14.6 -  '   ' ( " #-&  A & 2  "  

.'7  6   %9.8  %19.5 -  - 6 

0 D&" 0+ & 6"# .' 2  &T      @  "#  4  2
T   

.Y% ?@ (11) .  &D  ' >   7 ' H


(11) . 

   "  / > 



    7 ' H

&D C4 &

T P -     2  D " #-& /D 

'

*.004 1 7.911 '   ' ( " #-& 1

*.002 1 9.139 ' - " #-& 2

.777 1 0.080 ##  3

.844 1 0.038 '   4

85
$B "-7  (0.05) $ D7 P -   83 < T > D  X  $7   58 $ $)

: , $ ?@

83 <   7.911 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< !'   ' ( " #-& •

.'7  6  .   $ ;#7    $& - 6  R3 C


 . 

C
 .  83 <   9.139 8
 => ' 2  D .# >< !' - " #-& •

- 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3

.  $   83 <  C    /# !'   ##  $ #-& 7 •

    @  &' * ) & :  

$) (12)   .  .8 2 7  " .   /)   A?- > $ a

.X>

(12) . 

   @ * ) &- 4 " 



'& * A&

100 541 100 267 100 274 I 


I  - '7  =T /D 

%   %   %  

42.7 231 28.5 76 56.6 155 < 1

11.8 64 10.1 27 13.5 37 #- 2

8.7 47 12.7 34 4.7 13   3

36.8 199 48.7 130 25.2 69 # 4

86
: 58  ;<   .  @

 $ $ /% I  P - ;# A%42.7 -  ; &   ;# < 8 .#3 •

  A%56.6 -  '7  6    .T $ ., $ ?@ " . .8

.%28.5 -  .#

=> .  ./% I  P - ;# A%36.8 -  # 8 .  ,    •

.'7 # %25.2 -# %48.7 2D  $  ;# - 

 ,7 #- .T .  A%11.8 -  ,,   ;# #- .T 8 .#3 •

.%10.1 -  .#   %13.5 '7  6 

.(%8.7) .8
 D 2   #8B -  2  "     8 . AE 7 •

.'7  6   %4.7  %12.7 - 6     ,7 . 

R  7 ' H


 0 D&" 0+ &     @  &' * ) &  4  2
T   

;Y% ?@ (13) .  &D  ' > 

(13) . 

    @  &' * ) & / > 



#    7 ' H

&D C4 &

_&" 
 
H
 , "  0,


-  7 '

*.000 1 27.017 < 1

.211 1 1.562 #- 2

*.002 1 9.382   3

*.000 1 18.698 # 4

87
"O .  (0.05) $ D7 P -   83 < T > D  X  $7   58 $ $)

: , $ ?@ $B

.  .83 <   27.017 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< !( =T 8 •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3 C




C
 .  .83 <   .9.382 8
 => ' 2  D .# >< !  =T 8 •

.'7  6  .   $ ;#7    $& - 6  R3

.  .83 <   18.698. 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< !# =T 8 •

.'7  6  .   $ ;#7    $& ! - 6  R3 C




 S ' 2  D $& !$    83 <  C    /#   8 7 •

.0.05 P -   83 <

 &T <X& &    @ ) : " D

(14)   .  .8 2 7 ;# 8


 => .    A-  #8-7 $ : ?- $ a

.X> $) 

88
(14) . 

 
X
 < "    @ 4 " 

'& * A&

O
&"  7#
 < .  0,


%

'& %

'& %

'&

26.8 145 15.4 41 38.0 104 #  P - 1

26.2 142 34.1 91 18.6 51  % #D( P - 2

10.9 59 10.9 29 10.9 30   P - 3

36.0 195 39.7 106 32.5 89  - ( P - 4

100 541 100 267 100 267 I 

 & "  ;# .#3 D !" - ( P -" , $ B   $7   58 $ RB

.D
 ./% I  P - ;# %36.0 -  $
 3   , $B  $ $

F- C 
 '7  6  ;# "  >  - 6 

. - R3 %7.2

$ .  A/% I  P - ;# %26.8 -   , "  ;# #  P - 8 .#3

,& .  * !'7  6  R3 -  %15.4 '7   %38.0 -  '7  
 3

."  >   @

E @ ,& - .  .%26.2 -  ,,   .  ! % #D( P - 8 7

.'7  6  %18.6  %34.1 -   > , $ ?@#

.$
 3 #  % 10.6 -  %10.6 -    P - 8 . A & "  

89
7 ' H
 0 D&" 0& 6 &T <X& &    @ )  4  2
T   

;Y% ?@ (15) .  &D  ' >  

(15) . 

   @ ) / > 



#    7 ' H

&D C4 &

T P -     2  D " #-& /D 

'

*.000 1 27.372 #  P - 1

*.000 1 11.267  % #D( P - 2

.896 1 0.017   P - 3

.223 1 1.482  - ( P - 4

$B    (0.05) $ D P -   83 < T > D  X  $7   58 $ $)

: $
 3   ,

.  .83 <   .27.372 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< !#  P - 8 •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3 C




83 <   .11.267 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< ! % #D( P - 8 •

.'7  6  .   $ ;#7    $& - 6  R3 C


 . 

.83 < C     /#  - (   P - $8


 7 •

90
.   @ V
   D&"   . '  : " "

;# 8
 => .    A 3 @& C#% -  #@  :- ?- $ a

.X> R)B  A(16)     .8 6 @

(16) . 

   @ V
   D&"   . 'F 4 " 

'& * A&


D +  – #

O
&"  7#
 .' 0,


%

'& %

'& %

'&

0.4 2 0.0 0 0.7 2 & 1

0.0 0 0.0 0 0 0   2

0.1 1 0.4 1 0 0 ' ( C  3

4.3 23 2.6 7 5.8 16 .,   4

17.2 93 15.6 42 18.6 51  5

12.2 67 5.6 15 18.9 52 * & ;9# C#% 7 #  6

3.5 19 3.0 8 4.1 11  7

44.2 238 45.3 121 42.7 117 7   8

2.7 15 1.9 5 3.7 10 .9  9

15.4 83 25.6 68 5.5 15 .9-  10

100 541 100 267 100 274 O

91
: 58  ;<   .  @

P - ;# %44.2 -  ; &   ;# , $M@  '7 #   &   . •

=> .  ., B b   - 


3 @&  $ $ /% I 

.('7  %42.7 - %45.3) $  ;# - 

'7  6   @ > /- %17.3 -  


3 @    ,    •

.%15.6  %18.6 - 6  $ ,7

  3 @ .-  => .  %15.4 -  .-  . !*, "   •

.%5.5 '7  6   -  .#   %25.6 -  - 6 

6   @ >   %12.2 -  * & ;# C#% 7 #   2  "   •

.%5.6  %18.9 -  '7 

.$   - 


3 @& $ %89.1 F-  % & @& => @ •

A' ( C  A   A & : #, P & @& /- #D 7 "S    

_ ... .  A  

 7 ' H
 0 D&" 0& 6 &T < D&"& &   . '   4  2
T   

.Y% ?@ (17) .  .&D  ' > 

92
(17) . 

  . '  / > 



#    7 ' H

&D C4 &

-  _&" 
H
 , .' 0,



 7 '

.157 1 2.000 & 1

1.000 1 0   2

.317 1 1.000 ' ( C  3

.060 1 3.522 .,   4

.351 1 0.871  5

*.000 1 20.433 * & ;9# C#% 7 #  6

.491 1 0.474  7

.795 1 0.067 7   8

.196 1 1.666 .9  9

*.000 1 33.843 .9-  10

@&  (0.05) $ D7 P -   83 < T .> D  X  $7   58 $ $

: , B @  $


 3 -   3

  20.433 8
 => ' 2  D .# >< !* & ;# C#% 7 #  8 •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3 C


 .  .83 <

93
C
 .  .83 <   .33.843 8
 => ' 2  D .# >< !.-  8 •

.'7  6  .   $ ;#7    $& - 6  R3

.$
 3 $ 83 < T .> C     /#  3 @&  7 •

  2   
^ &
  :  "

A 3 /- * $ A S  B C#% -  #8-7  2- ?- $ a

.F# "   ,0, ;< ?- >   /- / !$  % $ & A. (


 0 D&" _  7/1

B  6 @  3 /- P  8 "-     .%  $ (18)  

., $B

(18) . 


  D  
^ &
  4 " 

'& * A&

O
&"  7#

 0,


%

'& %

'& %

'&

49.1 266 45.3 121 52.9 145 6  6 3 /- 1

4.6 25 4.1 11 5.1 14 6 3 $ ,7 /- 2

46.2 250 50.6 135 42 115 6 3 /- / 3

100 541 100 267 100 274 I 

94
%49.1 -  6  6 3 /- $
 3  6 @  ,   $7   58 $ $

6 3 /- / 8 7 . - 6   %45.3 '7   %52.9 -  A$  ;#  

3 /- /% ,&  - 6   .  A%46.2 -   , "   . 

-  *, "     6 3 $ ,7 /- 7 .'7    %42  %50.6 - 

./% I  P - ;# %4.6 ;< .#3  J%B

7 ' H
 0 D&" 0+ & ;  H@  @ 
 0 D&" _   4  2
T   

.Y% ?@ (19) .  &D  ' >  

(19) . 

   @ 
 0 D&" _  / > 

#    7 ' H

&D C4 &

-  _&" * 
H
 ,
 0,



- 7 '

.141 1 2.165 6  6 3 /- 1

.548 1 0.360 6 3 $ ,7 /- 2

.205 1 1.600 6 3 /- / 3

P  (0.05) $ D7 P -   83 < T .> C    T F 7 A  58 $ $

.8
  83 <  S ' 2  /D .  * !$
 3 $ , B  3 /-

.*0, - 




95
*
   0 D&" _  7/2

B  . ( $ & /- P  8 "-     .%  $) (20)  

., $B

(20) . 

*
    D  
^ &
  4 " 

'& * A&

O
&"  7#

 0,


%

'& %

'& %

'&

20.3 110 21 56 19.7 54 $ 7 /- 1

14.4 78 4.9 13 23.7 65 E  7 /- / 2

19 103 19.1 51 19 52 . < /- 3

13.7 74 13.5 36 13.9 38 $ 7 . < /- 4

4.1 22 4.0 1 7.7 21 . < /- / 5

28.5 154 41.2 110 16.1 44 E  7 . < /- / 6

100 541 100 267 100 274 I 

-  ; &   .#  A  7 . < /- /  , B $7   58 $ $

- %41.2) - '7    ;# -  => .  ./% I  P - ;# %28.5

.('7  %16.1

- 6  .- * A%20.3 -   , "  .#   E  7 /-  B 7

 .-  , B 7 .%19.7 -  '7  -   %21 -  $ &

:
 $   . ( /-  *, "  .#  %19 - .#  !. (

96
.2  "  .#  %14.4 - .#  A$ 7  /-N /  B 7 .  - 

 A -# %4.9  %23.7 .# -  $ & /- /  ,& 6  '7  . 

.%13.7 -  $ & . ( /-  , B . : " 

0 D&" 0+ & ;  H@  @  *


   0 D&" _   4  2
T   

.Y% ?@ (21) .  .&D  ' >   7 ' H


(21) . 

   @  *
   0 D&" _  / > 

#    7 ' H

&D C4 &

-  _&" 
 * 
H
 ,
 0,


7 '

.848 1 0.036 $ 7 /- 1

*.000 1 34.666 E  7 /- / 2

.921 1 0.009 . < /- 3

.816 1 0.054 $ 7 . < /- 4

*.000 1 18.181 . < /- / 5

*.000 1 28.285 E  7 . < /- / 6

$ & /-  (0.05) $ D P -   83 < T .> D  X  $7 A  58 $ $

: , B  . (

.  .83 <   .34.666 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< !E  7 /- / 8 •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& A'7  6  R3 C




97
.  .83 <   .18.181 8
 => ' 2  D .# >< A. < /- / 8 •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& A'7  6  R3 C




.83 <   .28.285 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< !  7 . < /- / 8 •

.'7  6  .   $ ;#7    $& A - 6  R3 C


 . 

.0.05 P -   83 < T .> C     /# !P & .8
 7 •

  0 D&" _  7/3

$B B  $  % /- P  8 "-     .%  $ A(22)  

.,

(22) . 

   D  


^ &
  4 " 

'& * A&

O
&"  7#

 0,


%

'& %

'& %

'&

16.5 89 16.5 44 16.4 45  :8 $  1

61 330 54.7 146 67.2 184   $   2

3.0 16 0.7 2 5.1 14  $   3

13.1 71 18.7 50 7.7 21 $  % $ $ /- 4

2.4 13 4.9 13 .0 0 $  % I 7  /- 5

4.1 22 4.5 12 3.6 10 P 7 6

100 541 100 267 100 274 I 

:$7   $ $)

98
P - ;# %61 -  ; &   ;# .#3 D 
 $  % /-  J 3 •

 %67.2 - .# >< !$  % => /-   & '7  .  ./% I 

. - 6   %54.7

"-  $
 3 F- %16.5 -   -8  $ % /-   , "   •

.'7   (%16.4 -  %16.5)  

 & - 6  .  .%13.1 -  $  % $ $ /-  A*, "   •

.'7  6   %7.7  %18.7 -  $  % $ I  > /- 

.P & ,0, I & 2   0#D - $ AP & 


 .8
 7 •

' 2  /- /)  A, 2B  B  $  % /- P  83 < C
 $

.X> RB  (23)   .$# $   6   %

(23) . 

   @    0 D&" _  / > 



#    7 ' H

&D C4 &

-  _&" 
 * 
7 ' H
 ,
 0,


.915 1 0.011  :8 $  1

*.036 1 4.375   $   2

*.002 1 9.000  $   3

*.000 1 11.845 $  % $ $ /- 4

*.000 1 13.000 $  % I 7  /- 5

.669 1 0.181 P 7 6

99
/-  A(0.05) $ D7 P -   83 < T .> D  X  $7   58 $ $)

: , B  $  %

C
 .  .83 <   4.3758
 => ' 2  D .# >< !
 $  % 8 •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3

.  .83 <   9.000 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< ! $  % 8 •

. - 6  .   $ ;#7    $& '7  6  R3 C




.83 <   11.845 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< !$  % $ $ /- 8 •

.'7  6  .   $ ;#7    $& A - 6  R3 C


 . 

.83 <   .13.000 8


 => ' 2  D .# >< !$  % I 7  /- 8 •

.'7  6  .   $ ;#7    $& A - 6  R3 C


 . 

.0.05 P -   83 < T .> C     /# !P & .8
 7 •

100
U D .T

* & C4 & , 

C4 & ,  ;-+#

M9 . - '7  


 3  3  , C 0 $B #  58  @D  => C#%

.-  #8-& E% @D 

  * @  @ 2& :.  ." *

:#   *

267 A'7 9     274 .# * $


 3 $ 6 3 0( 8-   "  41

A9), C 0 )  - %3 ;# A.0  -T ;< "  X> 2  . - 

 @ @ # $
 $ AB7 A)  $ )      A$
 3 # 

.T9 9 9  Ak   F * .$


 3 Z  $ A    

;9# '7 9 C) 9


  0 2 AP & J 3 $  $
 3 $ ;< AI( ,

.8B C   .   7 C 
  >  -

9 /% I  P - ;# ; &   & ( Z ( BD 0  \ 3 42

:;< P%[ X> $] !$


 3

 2 .$
 3  /< @ ;# I( , ) @ $ V ( "# 6 , -

@9  9%  A)  & ), 6   D     $ A$, $


 3  # F-

.$# ) 0 , # 7  7  @   

101
9 # $ 3)3 ), ) 3 .  ) ( . "S 7 A2  -
 -

9) ( .9 $7 RB9 A; &   ( @  R3 A$, $
 3

$  .3)3 .
3  AI -& /)7  /)  A,   H 2 >M ), $ ?@#

A .@ $B A, I(   A3)3 ,& B#  AC 0 $7

.) <   T

$ $
, /
3  A-  
) 
 3  A$D% A), C 0    :)  -

A% ),   AX> A - .)  & ) 6   $D $ ,? A; &  

;# , 2 "# !, ID  $3)3 $0] ) 3 /  , . 


 93  ), C 0   $B ;#   3 X> :%  A/  3 2

.- 

6 B  / B  BD ,  , ) BD  "'7 " ;# " -" /) -
 43

P  AT -- % BD T I  BD T  . 

:  %# -8   * 

.$
 3 $     -- % -

A)9@( B9 $ A$ D %T A   & ;< '7  


 3 %  -

9  < A)/% J,  /)  $B ;# ,7   .)0  D 

.   @ AI( 


$B9 .98  (0.05) $ D7 P -   83 < T .> C    -  J@ 44

$ 9
# /0(  - ,  B , * & #% A
 , $ ?@

/09( 9,  B , * &  C


 .  * .6 % ,H >(

102
 -9 9 C 9
 .   "'7 " 6  R3 6 % ,H >( $ 
#

6 > .T  8 '7  /   :;#  > . - R3  3 $


9 /9 ;# RB  '7  \ A$


 3 $     -- J0T %

;# . ;<  $ *   AF,  2  $ T


E ?- F
3  A/0a '#

.  $ :-7

.&T     @ 


 :  ." *

P -9 ;9# 9, $ ?@9 3 $ 3  7 /


3  A & "3  "# $ 41

'7 9  /# T - .# * .$


 3 P - ;# %88 -  /% I 

! 7 A2D  > )-


 A6 -7 $7 *  P  .%88.8 - A%87.2

@  $7  ;# A$, $


 3  #  @  ;# A"O  lDY $ V ( /  -

)& A"  D  @ ;# D( 2  


Q  Ak  = @ 2 - C  

@9  39)3 . - 2-  ;< P)7   .  , .T  3)3 7

.P 7 . - "- ;# " .-

  F  /  AX @    $M , AT - X  A),  3  -

)3 $ ) > .F< F)   :


$ M . $] A .C# F@ )

.-  #8-7 / % ;# :% -   A"

9   < "%3 - . 37 AB . - P ;# A), ")##@" 6  .-)  -

.90< 9 9 9--   ,    2 3 3 A)  & ), - &

103
)9-- 4), .T 6 ) A  )  & J 3  ), C 0 . 3 A

.P 7 
 3 $ 
) - $ 2 A/7 CH R
 A Z)  A S $ 

6 
 3 "-[  A), - &  7 A)  P 6)   "O  $  "- -

.F @ 

A$ 9H $ 3 $ /) .-   " "- A  A)  &  3  -

9,    0 $ = S ;#  3 " /) .$ )  $#-  $   $

 93 ;9#  /) *  A),  3 ;# X> :%    .. T $

./ 6  . 3 A$  

29 "9#S $9  A)##  ) ? 7 AJD  7 '


) 7 " 3 F M A  A" /- -

..P & 3 ;# X> " -    A 3 ;# 6)  

  %8.9 -   ,    #  $> $


3 $   C#%  P 7  $ 42

$7 9 ?   => /S # $] !'7   %7.3 - %10.5 -  $  ;#

-98  F .- F  " #    


3 6 ;#  3  F) 
3 "  

$9 9@ m#   A6 , $ 7  A   . % BD  JD  7 #  7 '7 /

.  " 3 7 '7 8D : , B

-  .  A 3 $  .8 P &  & .T    &  &   -  7 43

:;<  % "- 
%B

9     $ ?@ "#S&  '> -    " O, A  &  &  -

  $   ES . <  ?@ , 6  .)% A)-  @ & #%

.-    $ % F & .#   E 3

104
C9 0 ;# "# $  . H ,  ' ( 2 AS A & .T . >M -

F9# @ T   A#    I( .T  3)3 B /T ),

. & .T 

A 3  B B   )7 "- T A[ 3 


 B $] A ( :
 -

. 
 ;#

.  


   D&"  "  :B  ." *

, $ ?@ $B F  ##  " #-&   A?- > #% 58  b  0 $ Z1

-  '7  %38.2 -  - 6  ;# E  A/% P - ;# %36.9 -   & " 

" #9-& A/% P - ;# %29.2 -  ,    ' - " #-&  $  .%35.8

-9  6 &   ;# '   ' ( " #-& A%19.2 -  *, "  ;# '  

:;< X> *  % .%14.6

)-9 7 A )-9


 A$B9 2 X@ * A) 3 6 ,( 
3 ##  2 "- 4

A9), ) #- R  " #-& > $] A# $8 C 0 % % .# F 0

.),  -  F C #      %

E  X  0 AF87 2 $ F


 , I B  $ #@ 6  % ##  " #-& 4

29 9
 ;9# F  # k  % /   F " #-7 > ." ;# F T<

:V  $M@ 7 
 3

. $  F ;# 


)  F & = S $ ;#7 D3 2 ##  " #-& 4

./& /% $M@ , F & % /0 ;7 ##  " #-& 4

! 4

105
.# S 67  #% % ' - " #-& –

:)  D .)# .T  A$ ) % \@7 7 \@     '   " #-& –

/  AE M@ #D7 A 3 % @7 -7   3   $7 )  &  3  I 

AI 9  > .)@ 2B  V  7 A)


 3
  -7 J@ 7 A) BD 6 ,]  

. S  3 % => $ E7 $)B  A/   / $l # AT< A$ &  #D AB


7 #9- 7 9< JD    $  , $ B 7 B /0<  ' ( " #-& –

.#


    @  &' * ) & :H 


 ." *

9 8 .#3 * !(# A  A#- A<)   .8 2 7  " .   /) 

%28.5 A'7 9# %56.6 J 39 P - ;# ./% P - ;# 42.7 -  ; &   ;#

:;< 58  => *  % . -#

A 9   9 $9  D ? X>  A(<) %56.6 ;# .   '7  
 3 4

$9 9D 9< ;9< ;%-9 .  $< A - 


 3 $< $  .-  F)  ;< " D&

)9@( B V  #  )    :% A%28.5  - $7 T< A  

;< :-&  % A'7  - $ # S C 


 > .)# S .T ;< = T .


$9 9 \ 9  *9 9, B %  A$


 3 #    -- J0

.  . 2 /-  A) ) -   ;# $


 3

106
.   @ ) :U D ." *

9D . - (   A % A#D( A#  : . - % 7 ;< $B   /- /)  41

-   & "  ;# .#3  - ( P - ;# , $ B   $7   58 $ $)

P -9 F% %26.2  % #D( /, %26.8 #  P - % /% P - ;# A%36.0

:X> *  % %10.6  

!9#D< 7   7 #   ) F#3 $ T A) ) - < % $- AI( , $< 4

. &  F3 .  AF# .P & .T  B A  - ( " 

/9T M9 $7 9- '7 9 


 3 $ "   - ( P - % % $ 4

. 
 $ /S  ;# %26.8 - ;# P - > 3 * .# $M@ #  P -

%15.4 -  .  $  %38.0 ;# '7  .#3 * - '7  


 3 $ RB 

;9# /89 /D 


 3     -- % ;< EB7 X> *  % - 

9 9-  9  " 2 


 3  /-   . 
 P - ;< ;# 2 A  

'7 9 ;9# - .D


 *   #D( P - ;# C    .   J#

J 9  29 X>  , $ ?@# %  '7 # %18.6 -  %34.1 . 

.  #D( #  . 

P -9 9 $


 3 $ 0.05 P -   83 < .TT .> C     ;< -  7 42

9 9- R39 27.372 #  P -  '7  R3   #D( P - # 

A$
 39 $9   $ )  .-- J0 ;# 
Q  > !11.267   #D( P -

..T =>  F A$


 3  J0 X>

107
.   @ V
   D&"   . '  :U " ." *

;# A%44.2 -  ; &   ;# . , $M@  &   $7 58  $ $) 41

:;<  % > .(%45.3 - A%42.7 '7 ) $


 3 "  2 /% P -

.)  )& $B .T )% .  , ;# "& l#uS
u 4

.$ & $ /  A  3 A)& A), C 0     ?- )


# 4

.$
 3 ) D  % 4

9 A(%12.2) *9 & ;9# C#% A(%15.4) .-  $ "-  "  $  42

   
3 @& => D& #
 ;# @? > ./% P - ;# A(%17.3)

 9 9% # => .  .    & X> ;< 
B7  >< .&

.$
 3 # )   --  )  7 6 B , T .
3 67 8% .T 

.8  A0.05 $ D7 P -   83 < .TT .> C  .   AC


 ;< -  43

* & ;# C#% 8  C


 .  * ..-  .8 * & ;# C#% # 

 C#% k  X  - 


 3 $7 X>  "- .20.433 .# * '7  R3

C) 9
 9 C
 => $ H "  )-
  > 
Q % .'7  $ 2- 7 ;# AF7 

*9 AE83 <   .33.843    .# * .-  8  '7  ;# -

.'7   )- 
Q    A, B =>  U 6 ,< '7 $  ;< - J

  2   
^ &
  : H " ."

.$  % . ( $ & ;< B< , C 0  3 /- P ;# ?- >  

-  ; &    6  6 3 $- - '7  $7 3 /-   RB 41

   3 /- / 8 . $  .( - A%45.3 '7  %52.9)   A%49.1

108
$9 9,7 /9- 7 .'7 # A%42  A%50.6 -  X>  ,&  - .  A ,

:;< X> *  % .


%B "-  .  6 3

)  # -  3   ;# :%  A.  . )3 ?B 2 A$B % 4

9 A9 ,& $B  A"& 7 " 6 3 


T /)    * A)  3

.$
 3

.I)  "- ;# .   .


3 /  4

9 9 9
T A6 , $ 7  . ) < )  .    / .
  J%B 4

.   7   

.> C 9   / $) A%0.05 $ D P -   ' 2   58 b %-   4

A6 93 $ ,7 /- " #-7 2 T J 3 => $] A 3 M /#% 2 .83 < FT

.E 
%B -  .%6.4 ;< 
3 @ > - .#3 *

9  83 < T .> ED  X  $7   58 $ $) !. ( $ & /-   42

R39 C
 .  * ., B  . ( $ & /-  A%0.05 $ D7 P -

$ $ 7 . < /- / 8 .  $  .. < /- / 8 $ 7 /- / 8  "'7 "


Q   A)&   u#S
u A$B %   $ & /-  "- 
Q % . - R3

.$ & . B %

9 A%67.2 -9  9


 $  %# '7  /- 6 , $ A$  % /- %3 ;# 43

%16.5) $
 39     -  )  :8  $ % /-  $  . -# A%54.7

109
-9  $ 9 % $9 $ 9 /-   &  - .   .( -# 16.4 '7 #

.'7 # %7.7  A%18.7

/-  A%05 $ D7 P -   83 < .TT .> C    $ C


  0   44

: $  % =>


 39 S X>  "- .'7  6  R3 C
 .  A 
 $  % 8 4

">9 3  ;< B< .  $   ;< I B  8  k # I D< 8- / 

.F# I B     - k 

7 ) 9 -8 $   - A 3 $  % $ $8 /- 8 .  A - 
 3 7 4

9) > % .$  % I 7  /- 8   3 C


 .  X> .' 7  

69 
39 @ I    & "-   6  , .'7  $ -  
 /-

.,

* & ;  

$  - 2-  .= S $    "&  %   & , @  / 41

.,  8 -  - #@ $


 :, P & ,

A"& .T  A" . @  


T / .5  6  / A&   
 42

.)0( )#% / A.  A' U   $7 $ 

 
 & :  $ .BD  .0T $   &  
 .T- J, 43

. H '7  /7  R A)0 B V  AC 0 .


3 $ 
#

110
..$
, &  ;# @    / A6 /0D& /7  R A-&  44

.$, " 7

)& )   $ 5 A) % 3  AC 0  ) S  3 % 2  45

. S )#@ $


83-T C  $ < A), B  3)3 ) 3 .  ;#   46

.I( "& , BD %  A), C 0#

.
 "M #% 2B  @ 6 47

A 3 /@ 0 C Z  AC 0 .


3  ) % ), .% C 2-  48

 % P - 2  /-  . % "  5# P &  % C  @

.  # "&   & k  P  

@  , A-& .   0 $  B A$


, & $   6 -  < 49

...D0% J % $ # 6 8 $B @  # ;# $ H "- ;# A 3&

.),  3  @ ;#   A), ")##@"   

.C 0 => $ /% '7  6


- P $) A3)3 )  .-  < 410

111
H

 4 ,


 X
 H
 (#

.-7  A$ A 1 A.  . A  0 4(2010 ) ./ A/  7 41

:$ ; & % A# *G


, 1996 Z1920 
    .(1996) .  A 3 7 42

."-  

." / :6  A


   T 08.(1986) .C  A 7 43

.' T  :$ A0 [   * "


.(2000) . - A  7 44

A
4    A  M@  -  6 3%   &  3 .(1996) . - A  7 45

.2444207 :\ A(1) A1#

f T' T ,* "D  


  "   
& .(1986). A S 7 46

.C8,   :.  A; & % ,"

 "
) ' 3 
# , 8@    
& J 3 .(1993) .$-    A-< 47

.(>
)    6>

^ 6
&" 

6  41 V03   0   A  * <  AT&(2006)..:  :   48

. %    .

.
3 ;#  -  :,     3  3  .(1989) .  A. 49

.( >
)    60 ' 6
&"   "
)1987Z1982   / & J 3  '7 

.2   :$ A


 
  
    T >  .(2004).$- A% 410

' #  
     '
  )
     .(1984).$- A% 411

.1994/8/26 '7  A 3%

112
@  6 A "H # # A   &- &% / 8 T A(1996) :  - A 412
.(2)% 6  % A#%
., 6  A$ A>
 <  
      .( 2002).$  ' @ A 413

. @  .- # $  --? ,   


&  >G
, :
    A A 414

  "
: 7  B
&
  V   & 8  _, ,(2002) :$ ,'   415

.6  % ,T .-  *    .  , 


   G A 

." / :6  A0 B : B  C)   * "


.(2006). - A$- 416

: -  A   417


.   A @  # ;
3  A IT /# ;<  2002

.  -T A% 


  A
 O & 0 A(1992) : A' 418

.('7 )   & 


3 --?  A'  A(1999)./ < /- A- 419

.  - 2 :$ A0   . _


.(2004).   AJ @ 420

A(1983Z1920)
 *   [ <& , 
   A(..).F7 A/ @ 421

.$)

.J %  : 3 A; & % A"  2


    ]
& .(1958).# A.3 422

/0( @   A"  


6  2" $ %  D .(2010).$  A'3 423

./ 201047426 _  # ,    6%  ,

." /:6  A[  B .(1992) .  A   424

2 :6 9 A * "


  @ .&.(1993).$ G AJ  A$   425

..9- 

.
 I%@( %  A; & % ,D&   .(2004).V03 AJ#  426

113
 A 3  D    -  : &-
X& . &-  "# A(1971) A   A6  427

. 3 AJ %

A 3 # &  62 &  


8    0 ( 1978) A#   :  % 428

.6 

A
' #  A.TT /D 7 :$ &   3 "7 .(1991A , $ @) ./ < A 
 429

.(, 6  : $ A51441:\ A(104 A 103) :$%

 A  @ 0) T :  


- O &- 0  T8 4   A(1982) :# A# 430

.6  A1AJ %

  :  4 3 A; & % A   .D  .(2003):%- G AO  431

. -(

.6   . @  :.  . )
& <&b 
  .(1961)."7 A6  432

, 6  .$ ,"  !  Y   


 '
.(1980).  Ab 433

."@

 3  :6  A>


  :& 
8 . &- .( 2006). ;# -  $- A'  434

.  #

% A(1946 Z1920) 6   


 
'T * ) &- .(1996) .- A'>0 435

.2  @ # " %  : - 4C@ A; &

./20104141 _  A'7  6   , C # 436

./201046425 _  A'7  6   , C # 437

114
. @  :$ 6(1997 – 1920 ) 
  
& .( 1998).$#- /3 A;-  438

.$ & _   

–1920    D    -  4:  &  3 .(1989).$#- /3 A;-  439

:\ A (1)% A5 # A " T  - ( / #% #-#- " Y


 B  #  A1988

.266 – 227

A  '7  


 3 #, ,    &  3 \83 .(1988) .$#- /3 A;-  440

.115481 :\ A(1)% A44 # A &-  " 0 "" :Y
 B  # 

" ,<" :$) A-- % .7


)  . &-  .D .(2009).$#- /3 A;-  441

.2  @ #

4:    6   A2006 A'7  $ 6 3 0( 6 @  442

.http://www.alrai.com/ftp/jpf/Jordan%20Press%20Foundation.html
5   .$ – 1 .  :& &
  0 ( 2006) /@  . :@ – 41

A , % A B  U"#  +  .(1998).J  AX   A  A  _ 42

. @ # / G  :$) A237 7 R3  

..  .%#  .  '&   (2002);  :'   _ 43

:$ (

2007/ 5/ 14 _    & – '7  


 3 47

2009/   / 25 _  14976 % b  


 3 4 "

115
2005 / 9 / 4 _    &  
 3 4Z

:0) "#  & +&D G


D / O
 0+ & (W

.- & C @ %  /0( >-7 3  $-  .7 4

.  % *   % "& >-7  )  .7 4

.0 $ $-  % G  % # >-7   # .7 4

.0 $ $-  % /0( - >-7 -  /- . 4

.I - 8  8 /  B  . 4

# T # 3 2  (

1. Canclini, Nestor Garcia,( 2003).


(Cultural Information in Mexican Newspapers) Television and New media vol. 4
no: February 2003, 43 – 54.

2. Carragee K. ,Rosenbalatt M and Michauud G (1987).


Agenda-setting Research: A critique and theoretical alternative.

3. Golin, Cida and Cardose, Ever ton (2009).


Cultural Journalism in Brazil: Academic research, visibility, editational News
Values. (Journalism, vol. 10(1) 69 – 89)

116
4. Kosicki, G. (1993)Problems and opportunities in agenda-setting research.
Journal of Communication, 43(2), 100-127.

5. Landis, p.(1978)Introductory of Sociology, The Ronald press, N.y, 1978.

6. McCombs M .E (1992) Explorers and surveyors: Expanding strategies agenda –


setting Research .journal Quarterly.36, Pp176-187 .

7. McCombs, M., & Shaw, D.L. (1972).The agenda-setting function of the mass
media. Public Opinion Quarterly, 36, 176-185.

8. Mellor, Noha (2008) Arab Journalists as Cultural intermediaries (The


international Journal of Press / Politics 2008,vol 13, 465).

9. Sonwalkar Prasanl,( 2001)India: makings of little cultural/media Imperialism,


(International communication Gazette vol. 63 (6): 505 – 519, London Tilousand
oaks and new De l III.

117

You might also like