301166924

Project 1 – Assembly
Description Grade Comment
1 Assy Drg – 3 views, + Exploded 4
2 Production part clearly shown 4
3 Sandwich jig submitted 4
4 Clearance above part 4
5 Clearance under part 4
6 Jig plate clamped 4
7 Jig plate located 4
8 Part clamped 4
Looks like production part is drawn slightly wrong, But location
9 Part located – Long ref. Side 4
seems OK
Looks like production part is drawn slightly wrong, But location
10 Part located – Short ref, side 4
seems OK
11 Part error proofed 4
12 Modular construction 4
See rules for drill bushings and purchased parts. Drill bushings
13 Drill Bushings correctly defined 2
are not “stock” items.
14 B.O.M. Exists 4
15 B.O.M. All parts Ballooned 4
16 B.O.M. All Manuf. parts I.D. & Mat'l 4
17 B.O.M. All Purch parts I.D. 4
18 B.O.M. All Quantities shown 4
19 B.O.M. Format correct/notes 4
20 General formatting – title block 3 Initials & Dwg No. – see rules

Project 1 – Parts
Description
1 Misc. Manuf parts drawn if reqd
2 Purchased parts NOT drawn
3 All parts Det#,Qty,Mat'l on dwg
4 Manuf misc parts dimns
Grade Comment
4
4
Support blocks (Note: 17Cr3 is a foreign (European) standard
special steel. CRS would be fine here. I doubt if you could
purchase European special steels easily in North America. If
you must specify the steel for this project AISI 1018 or 1020
3
would be a much better choice. Many years ago I specified
EN31 (a British high strength alloy steel) and found out no one
locally had any idea what it was.)
Support Block 1 is identified as Det 19, but is really Det 18.
Support block 1
1. Hole sizes missing. Clearance frill for #10 screws is #9 drill
or #7 drill.
Support Block 2
3 1. Clearance drill for 1/4” thread is 17/64” Dia.

Note:- In North America, for inch size drills we specify drills in

5 Manuf misc parts tolerances
6 Top plate Det#,Qty,Matl on dwg
7 Top plate dimns from ref.
8 Top plate other dimns
9 Top plate ref tols
10 Top plate other tols
11 Base plate Det#,Qty,Matl on dwg
12 Extrusions NOT used
13 Base plate dimn from ref.
14 Base plate other dimns.
15 Base plate ref tols
16 Base plate other tols
fractions of an inch or as standard number or letter sizes.
Charts are readily available on the internet
0 Tolerance block – See rules.
4 Best not to use European material standards in North America
0 See Content/Extras/Tolerance and Location – also 50% rule
4 We do not normally specify tap drill sizes for toolmakers.
0 See Content/Extras/Tolerance and Location – also 50% rule
0 Tolerance block – See rules.
4 Best not to use European material standards in North America
4
0 See Content/Extras/Tolerance and Location – also 50% rule
Defining countersink causes extra machining. Better to just add
a note “REMOVE ALL SHARP EDGES UNLESS OTHERWISE
4
STATED.” works. There are hand held deburr tools for holes
that are very quick and easy to use.
0 See Content/Extras/Tolerance and Location – also 50% rule
0 Tolerance block – See rules.

0, 10, 20 ,30, 40 or 50 Penalty %

Grading scheme Grade

Non-compliant 0
25% compliance 1
50% compliance 2
75% compliance 3
100% compliance 4

Page 1