Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Research and Interview B
Research and Interview B
Signature:
Contents
Introduction..........................................................................................................................................1
1. Leadership Style.............................................................................................................................1
Literature review - Description.........................................................................................................1
Empirical study - Comparison of leaders...........................................................................................2
2. Leadership Development Capacity................................................................................................3
Literature review - Description.........................................................................................................3
Empirical study - Comparison of leaders...........................................................................................4
3. Communication Style.....................................................................................................................4
Literature review - Description.........................................................................................................4
Empirical study - Comparison of leaders...........................................................................................4
4. Teamwork Development...............................................................................................................5
Literature review - Description.........................................................................................................5
Empirical study - Comparison of leaders...........................................................................................6
5. Conflict Resolution Skills................................................................................................................6
Literature review - Description.........................................................................................................6
Empirical study - Comparison of leaders...........................................................................................7
6. Leader’s Balance of Family, Devotion, and Ministry......................................................................7
Literature review - Description.........................................................................................................7
Empirical study - Comparison of leaders...........................................................................................8
7. Loyalty to their Organization.........................................................................................................9
Literature review - Description.........................................................................................................9
Empirical study - Comparison of leaders.........................................................................................10
Conclusion...........................................................................................................................................10
Bibliography........................................................................................................................................11
Appendix.............................................................................................................................................13
Introduction
“Leadership is essential to effective pastoral ministry. I has the power to direct people
towards good or evil, success of failure”(Arrais, 2011: 33).
In this paper, I will discuss the different Leadership styles, Leadership development,
Communication styles, Teamwork development, Conflict resolution skills, how to Balance family,
devotional and ministry life, and how to display Loyalty to the Organization. Within each of
these concepts, I will define and describe each concept followed by my reflection on two
interviews conducted with leaders within the Southern Africa Union Conference. The two
leaders were Pr. Potgieter, who is a district pastor in Cape Town, and Rev. De Klerk is the
chaplain at the South African Police Service in Somerset West, but also serves part-time as the
Minister of the local Dutch Reformed church.
1. Leadership Style
Page | 1
According to Reddin (1970) leadership roles are different from leadership models. He
provides eight models as follows:
1. Deserter – uninvolved and passive.
2. Missionary – primarily interested in harmony.
3. Autocrat – shows no confidence in others, feels unpleasant and is interested only
in the immediate job at hand.
4. Compromiser – means a poor decision maker, which is over-influenced by
pressures of work, whom minimizes immediate pressures and problems rather
than maximizes long-term production.
5. Bureaucrat – primarily interested in rules and procedures for their own sake,
which wants to maintain and control situations by their conscientious
enforcement.
6. Developer – will trust people, and is concerned with developing them as
individuals.
7. Benevolent Autocrat – knows what he wants (from people and situations) and
how to get things his way without causing resentment.
8. Executive – a good motivator who sets high standards, treats everyone differently
and prefers team management.
Page | 2
2. Leadership Development Capacity
But when one considers mentoring or coaching in term of leadership development, the
Center for Health Leadership & Practice (2003: 3–5) listed four key mentoring skills in a
publication from the University of Michigan as follows:
1. Listening actively
2. Building trust
3. Determining goals and building capacity
4. Encouraging and inspiring
Deans and Oakley (2006: 21–25) found seven key factors in successful coaching and
mentoring as follows:
1. Individual commitment and interest
2. Resources and organisational support
3. Taking a holistic, personal approach
4. Embedding the process in the organisational context
5. Skills and experience of coaches/mentors
6. Ability to work across cultures
7. Working within an enabling external environment
Thus one can conclude that leadership development occurs over a long period of time and
involves mentoring or coaching.
Page | 3
Empirical study - Comparison of leaders
Both leaders do not currently serve in mentor roles, but they did serve as mentors in the
past. For Rev. De Klerk, mentorship (in the Church) focused on providing the intern with
exposure to different elements of the ministry and advises afterwards how and where are
potential areas for improvement. For Pr. Potgieter, mentorship extended to the laity.
3. Communication Style
Page | 4
4. Teamwork Development
Maxwell (2005: 64, 65) said that there is seven great challenge that leaders face, but for
the pastor (and most definitely myself) the 6th challenge may be the greatest which deals with
“Championing the vision is more difficult when you didn’t create it”. The reason he provides is
that “leaders don’t like the change any more than followers do – unless, of course, it’s their
Page | 5
idea”. He suggests that the key to successfully navigating the vision challenge is that “The more
you invest in the vision, the more it becomes your own”.
Aggressive Approaches
1. Confrontation – the goal is to find a solution, even though it may involve a direct
fight
2. Compromise – the conflict is not necessarily solved, but a middle way is
accepted
3. Arbitration – an acceptable solution is determined by a third party
4. Negotiation – both parties explore the solutions while confronting the problem
Page | 6
Empirical study - Comparison of leaders
Pr. Potgieter is often asked by the conference to deal with conflict issues outside his
district. He prefers to use Six Thinking Hat model (De Bono, 2000) when dealing with conflict.
But as a precaution measure, he suggested that a formal structure needs to be followed in
meetings which allow the chair to keep order and avoid potential conflict.
For Rev. De Klerk experience conflict (at the Church) mainly in meetings; when people
come together in one room. His approach is to know when to defuse the issue, or when to ignore
it in order for it to cool down in its own time. At the SAPS his conflict diffusion is closely linked
to teamwork development and teambuilding where diffusion techniques are discussed.
Lastly, he discusses how to find a balance between spiritual life and advise the following
three solutions:
1. Never do spiritual things in a secular way
2. Have only one boss but plenty of partners
3. Give daily devotions highest priority
Page | 7
Kidder (2015) took a more practical approach. He suggests that the minister needs to find
balance through effective time management and provided seven tips for finding a balance as
follows:
1. Meet God every morning
2. Take time to dream
3. Take stock of your current reality
4. Prioritize and make productive choices
5. Focus on building resources
6. Slow down to get ahead
7. Take time for critical thinking
He then suggests that time allocation is crucial in order to maintain a balanced life and
suggests five guidelines on how ministers could allocate their time as follows:
1. Praying for the church: 5–7 hours a week
2. Preaching/teaching preparation: 12–15 hours a week
3. Discipleship formation: 5–10 hours a week
4. Leadership/administration: 10–15 hours a week
5. Miscellaneous: approximately 5 hours a week
Page | 8
7. Loyalty to their Organization
Page | 9
Thus Branson (1933) concludes with the statement that “Orthodoxy, in the sense of
loyalty to this message, is not a sign of weakness, but of strength”.
Conclusion
I have found that leadership is most definitely essential to effective ministry; whether that
ministry is pastoral ministry or chaplaincy in the South African Police Service.
In this paper, I have discussed the different Leadership styles, Leadership development,
Communication styles, Teamwork development, Conflict resolution skills, how to Balance family,
devotional and ministry life, and how to display Loyalty to the Organization. Within each of
these concepts, I have defined and described each concept followed by my reflection on two
interviews conducted with leaders within the Southern Africa Union Conference, Pr. Potgieter,
and Rev. De Klerk.
Page | 10
Bibliography
Arrais, J. 2011. Wanted: A Good Pastor. Silversprings, MA: General Conference Ministerial
Association.
De Bono, E. 2000. Six thinking hats. Rev ed. London: Little, Brown and Company.
Deans, F. & Oakley, L. 2006. Coaching and Mentoring for Leadership. [Online], Available:
http://www.hiproweb.org/fileadmin/cdroms/Biblio_Renforcement/documents/Chapter-2/
Chapter2_2/Chap2_2Doc4.pdf [2018, August 09].
Hall, J. 2013. 12 Simple Things A Leader Can Do To Build A Phenomenal Team. [Online],
Available: https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnhall/2013/01/29/team-building-leader/ [2018,
August 09].
Limbare, S. 2012. Leadership Styles & Conflict Management Styles of Executives. Indian
Journal of Industrial Relations. 48(1):172–180.
Maxwell, J.C. 2005. The 360-degree leader: Developing your influence from anywhere in the
organization. Nashville, TN.: Thomas Nelson.
Maxwell, J.C. 2007. The 21 irrefutable laws of leadership: Follow them and people will follow
you. 10th Anniversary ed. Nashville, TN.: Thomas Nelson.
McCoxaughey, J.L. 1947. Loyalty to God and the Brethren’. Ministry Magazine. 20(6):5–7.
McLean, S. 2012. Business Communication for Success. Electronic ed. San Francisco, CA:
Saylor Academy. [Online], Available: https://saylordotorg.github.io/text_business-
communication-for-success/index.html [2018, August 09].
McNeal, R. 2000. A work of heart: Understanding how God shapes spiritual leaders. Revised
and updated ed. San Francisco, CA: Jossey- Bass.
The Center for Health Leadership & Practice. 2003. MENTORING GUIDE: A Guide for Mentors.
[Online], Available: http://www.rackham.umich.edu/downloads/more-mentoring-guide-
for-mentors.pdf [2018, August 09].
Page | 11
White, E.G. 1882. Early Writings. Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald Publishing Association.
Page | 12
Appendix
The following tables are compiled from Mary Saphiro’s (2014) Communications Styles on Team Dynamics.
Page | 13
Communication style
Connector Seeker Planner Driver
The Connector combines people and The Seeker combines the people and The Planner combines task and present The Driver combines task and future
present behaviors. As one you tend to: future behaviors. As one you tend to: behaviors. As one you tend to: behaviors. As one you tend to:
prefer working with people and in prefer leading people in new prefer working independently on prefer leading people towards task
teams rather than working alone ventures tasks and projects completion
prefer a collaborative, friendly, and prefer an energetic, multi-focused, prefer an orderly and efficient work prefer an efficient, fast-paced work
polite work environment fun and fluid environment environment with clear roles, environment with clear authority
prefer verbal communication; one prefer verbal communication in authority, responsibilities, and prefer written communication that is
person at a time; use a chatty groups; emails are short, pithy, metrics of success concise; emails are brief, in bullet
informal email style informal. prefer written communication; format
look at the details, and gather look at the big picture and see the emails tend to be textually dense look at the top level detail and data
perspectives from multiple people “forest, not the trees” with many attachments make decisions based on data,
make decisions by consensus as a make decisions based on intuition, look at details, data quickly, with objective criteria;
means of building agreement and spontaneously, often with subjective make decisions based on analysis, a prefer to make decisions unilaterally;
ownership; often with subjective criteria; rely on persuasion to build systematic deliberation of data with intent on besting past records or the
criteria agreement objective criteria competition
look at the impact on people when look at the impact on reputation as look at the impact on how work is look at the impact on the bottom line,
making decisions innovator and change agent done; how the work process is more and speed to results
prefer incremental change, with the prefer the sweeping innovative error-free, efficient prefer whatever change is necessary;
full participation of all affected change, first of its kind prefer incremental change with thorough and deep so change only
parties in the planning process appreciate others who are risk complete plans and contingency needs to be made once
appreciate others who are diplomatic, takers, willing to try new things, plans; keep what works, slowly test appreciate task completion on time,
accommodating, willing to speak quickly, and energetic and implement solutions on budget, according to
compromise prioritize action over people and appreciate accuracy, thoroughness, specifications
prioritize people over the task task details punctuality, compliance with plans prioritize the task over people; focus
enjoy solving people’s problems and enjoy taking the initiative, taking prioritize task over people on the outcome versus how you got
conflicts, harnessing synergy within a the lead, taking risks enjoy being creative inside a there
group structured process enjoy being in charge, in urgent
situations that require decisive action
take charge of situations in a vacuum
of leadership
Connectors tend to gravitate to those Seekers gravitate into sales, public Planners tend to gravitate into Drivers tend to gravitate into operations,
careers/functions which most likely relations, acting and broadcasting, engineering, accounting, estate planning, production, journalism, emergency
appreciate their skills: teaching, Human marketing, courtroom law. Many of our CPA, analyst, scientist, computer teams, any function where deadlines are
Resources, social work, arbitration, modern CEOs are seekers, creating a programming, tax law, research, critical (ie, publication, news
negotiation, team leaders, politics, vision for their organization and librarian. Their primary challenge is broadcasting), any function where the
customer service, therapy, public motivating others to follow that vision. moving from being a functional expert product has to get out the door by a
defence, fund development for non- Many of our top government officials and into management: leaving the functional specified time, cost, specifications. The
profits. These are people who "grease the policymakers are seekers. component of their job that they love, and prototypical American entrepreneur is
wheel", getting people to work together taking on the people-management aspect often a director.
Page | 14
across organizational silos, across which they would rather avoid
departments, across differences.
Identifying the Communication Style
Style\Identification Body language Decision making Writing Office appearance
Connector stands or sits close to you, slow, thoughtful moderate, comfortable and
touches you concern for informal, “homey”
hands are often open with palms people personal, chatty loveseat and/or
up prefers details roundtable
lots of gestures and animated consensus pictures of family,
face teams
appropriate eye contact candy dish
casual dress
Seeker moves around and rarely sit, fast, concise, brief, bold,
touches you spontaneous informal, chatty contemporary,
uses wide gestures concern for lots of graphics, futuristic
large gestures and animated future, photos colourful artwork
face innovation, flowers, play toys
eye contact upward or long on change pictures of them
you unilateral with important
stylish dress people
Planner sits with a barrier between you slow, calculated dense text, sparse or cluttered
doesn’t touch you concern for formal standard-issue
very minimal gestures and quiet process, lots of office furniture
body accuracy spreadsheets, PERT charts and
often writing down what you based on what tables, schedules on walls
say the data say appendixes
often averted eye contact
functional dress
Driver stands while you sit fast, concise, formal formal
doesn’t touch you spontaneous bullet format large, heavy dark
gestures often, arms crossed, or concern for the desk, furniture
Page | 15
pointing at you bottom line diplomas,
long direct eye contact unilateral certificates on
formal dress walls
How they interact with someone with a different Communication style
Connector Seeker Planner Driver
stop by daily (no catch them wherever you take as little face-time as take as little of their time as
appointment necessary) and can; meet “on the fly” possible possible
frequently meet away from the office make an appointment and make an appointment and
start with social/ personal to minimize distractions arrive/leave on time arrive/leave on time
topics talk fast; talk big picture keep emotions and get to the point/ keep the
ask about their personal life, give bottom line first and personal life out of the discussion focused on
and share yours let them ask questions conversation business
expect to spend a lot of time use graphics and charts to provide a regular reporting give them the bottom line
show emotions convey main points schedule/format up front and let them ask
stand in close proximity, allow them time to talk; give report first, then meet questions
touch them give opportunities to later to discuss/decide focus on results, bottom
spend time with them in contribute have most contact in line
social settings imbed message in writing bring solutions not
use face to face colourful graphics use attachments with e- problems
communication use face to face mail use executive summary
use voicemail or video communication; voicemail give them lots of lead time use e-mail to keep informed
conferencing as back up as backup for decisions (no attachments)
give them lots of lead-time keep writing concise with
for decisions bullets, one page
remember birthdays, etc.
Page | 16
How they gain their respect
Connector Seeker Planner Driver
Spend time with them; be Make efficient use of their Be patient with their slow Make efficient use of their
patient with their slow pace time; keep up with their pace; give long lead time time; keep up with their
Reveal who you are quick pace for decisions or advance quick pace
personally: share Ask questions about them: warming about changes Be willing to take risks and
information about who you both their work and Be accurate and do not assume responsibility and
are outside of work outside-work lives exaggerate leadership
Ask them about their Be energetic, fun Follow through on task Follow through on task
outside-work life Be willing to think outside responsibilities and meet responsibilities and meet
Handle conflict and the box, take risks deadlines deadlines
disagreement diplomatically Allow time for their Develop a track record of Develop a track record of
Listen, don’t interrupt creativity and “what if” functional excellence doing whatever it takes
Be willing to compromise thinking by temporarily Be punctual and prepared (including bending the
and collaborate suspending data and reality Follow the rules, policies, rules) to get a job done
Be supportive of others; Show appreciation for procedures…or have very Be punctual and prepared
develop a track record of their creativity objective reasons for Be willing to make
being “a team player” Give them opportunities changing or violating rules decisions quickly, without
for visibility Keep emotions out of full information or time for
conversations full deliberation
Be consistent and reliable
Page | 17