Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mckenzie 1989
Mckenzie 1989
bidity rate is lower than for cattle and the virus is less (each 500 ml) and concentration of the combined organic ex-
pathogenic. Reports of buffalo infected in the field tend to tracts gave a dark-reddish-coloured gum (4 g). The latter was
support these results. A widespread BEF epidemic which dissolved in 50% aqueous ethanol and applied, in 5 lots, to a
swept through south east China in September-October 1987 fractionating column (30 cm length, 50.8 mm diameter) filled
caused severe disease with 80 to 90% of the cattle in each herd with reverse phase silica gel'.
being affected (Chang Zeji, personal communication). The components of the mixture were eluted from the col-
However, the prevalence of disease in buffaloes was con- umn with 40% aqueous methanol at approximately 7 ml/min.
sidered to be much lower and the clinical signs were milder. The eluate was continuously monitored with a refractive index
The results reported here are in contrast to the experiments detector. Bryotoxin A eluted from the column at approximate-
described by Young (1979) in which clinical disease could not ly 800 to 1100 ml. Concentration of this fraction under reduc-
be induced in 3 buffaloes infected with BEF. The reasons for ed pressure from the 5 lots gave 341 mg (0.017% of the star-
these differences are not known although differences in virus ting mass) of pure bryotoxin A, identical in all respects by
strain or infectivity may play a role. chromatographic (thin layer chromatography on silica gel and
We wish to thank Mr Huang Junyao, Director, Foshan City reverse phase silica gel) and spectroscopical (proton nuclear
Animal Husbandry Bureau and his staff for the use of their magnetic resonance) comparisons with authentic material sup-
facilities. This work was partly supported by the Australian plied by RJ Capon, Australian National University.
Centre for International Agricultural Research, Project No The preparation of bryotoxins B and C (as a non-separable
8455. mixture) required 2 chromatographic steps. Extraction with
aqueous ethanol, filtration, concentration and extraction into
ethylacetate were carried out as described above. The residue
References
Bai W , Tian F, Wang C, Jiang C and Zhang Z (1986) - Proc 4th was dissolved in 60% aqueous methanol and applied, in 5 lots,
Symp Arbo Res Aust. Ed by TD St George, BH Kay and J Blok, p to the reverse phase column. The components of the mixture
279 were eluted with 60% aqueous methanol. The first 800 ml
Cybinski DH and Card G P (1986) - Proc 4th Symp Arbo Res Aust. were discarded and the following 500 ml collected, which con-
Ed by TD St George, BH Kay and J Blok, p 289 tained all of the bryotoxins B and C. This fraction was concen-
-
Cybinski DH, St George TD and Paul1 NJ (1978) Aust Vet J 5 4 1
trated under reduced pressure and the residue (491 mg from 5
Mackerras IM, Mackerras MJ and Burnet FM (1940) - Bull Counc
Sci Ind Res 136 lots) dissolved in ethylacetate and chromatographed on silica
Malviya HK and Prasad J (1977) - Indian Vet J 54: 440 gel 60 (70-230 mesh, 32 cm length, 40 mm diameter) with
Mohan RN (1968) - Vet Bull 38: 567 ethylacetate as eluent. Fractions, each of 10 ml,were collected
St George TD, Standfast HA and Cybinski DH (1978) - Aust Vet J
54: 558 and checked for content and purity of bryotoxins B and C by
St George TD (1981) - In: Virus Diseases of Food Animals a World high performance chromatography. Fractions containing
Geography of Epidemiology and Control Ed by Gibbs EPJ these were combined and concentrated yielding 103 mg
Academic Press, London, p 541 (0.005vo of the starting mass). Identity with authentic
Tian F, Jiang C, Zakrzewski H and Davis SS (1987) - Aust Vet J 6 4
159 bryotoxins B and C was again established by chromatographic
Uren MF and Murphy GM (1985) - Vet Microbiol 10: 505 and spectroscopic comparisons.
Young P (1979) - Aust Vet J 55: 349 Four weaned calves, 3 females and 1 male, 3 to 4 months old
(Accepted for publication 14 June 1989) and with a mean weight of 74 kg (range 64 to 83 kg) were used
in a dosage experiment in accordance with national guidelines
for the care and use of experimental animals (Anon 1985). The
techniques of husbandry, clinical examination, heart rate
The toxicity for cattle of bufadienolide cardiac monitoring, electrocardiography, clinical pathology, necropsy
and histopathology employed were those used previously
glycosides from Bryophylrurn tubiforurn flowers (McKenzie and Dunster 1986, 1987).
The calves were injected through the left flank into the
rumen. For dosing with bryotoxin A , 250 mg was dissolved in
Queensland Department of RA McKENZlE 6 ml ethanol and injected into a female calf weighing 64 kg
Primary Industries, the late FP FRANKE (3.9 mg/kg). A male control was injected with 6 ml ethanol
Animal Research Institute, P J DUNSTER alone. For dosing with bryotoxins B and C combined, 280 mg
Yeerongpilly, Queensland 4105 was dissolved in 1 ml dimethylsulphoxide (DMSO) and in-
jected into a female calf weighing 73 kg (3.8 mg/kg). A female
Three bufadienolide cardiac glycosides, named bryotoxins control was injected with 1 ml DMSO alone. DMSO was used
A, B and C, occur in the flowers of the poisonous plant as the solvent for bryotoxins B and C because of their limited
Bryophyllum tubiflorum (mother-of-millions) (Capon et al solubility in ethanol. The doses of bryotoxins used were
1985, 1986). These bryotoxins also occur in flowers of other estimated from the data of McKenzie and Dunster (1986) and
species of Bryophyllum and in leaves, stems and roots of these McKenzie et al (1987) to be those likely to be present in a
plants (McKenzie et a1 1987). The syndrome resulting from in- fatally-toxic dose of whole B. tubiforurn.
gestion of B. tubiflorum by cattle is consistent with cardiac The calf given bryotoxin A became lethargic and developed
glycoside poisoning (McKenzie and Dunster 1986). However, inappetence, ruminal atony and diarrhoea by 10 h after dos-
it is unclear if the diarrhoea and omasal lesions noted by ing. These signs persisted for the rest of the experiment. The
McKenzie and Dunster (1986) are also due to cardiac faeces were mucoid with occasional flecks of blood. From 3
glycosides or whether there are other toxins causing these ef- days after dosing, both heart block, which was manifested by
fects. Consequently we sought to determine if the known missing beats on auscultation, and a jugular pulse were noted
bryotoxins from B. tubiflorum were capable of reproducing occasionally. On the tenth day after dosing, drooling of saliva,
the effects produced by the plant itself. If these compounds tachycardia and dyspnoea occurred. The calf was weak and
were shown to account for the disease, the need for further very lethargic and was killed with intravenous pentabarbitone.
searching for toxins and the subsequent animal experiments Changes noted in electrocardiograms with time after dosing
would be reduced o r removed. were lengthened PR intervals (first degree atrioventricular
B. tubiflorum flower heads collected in 1985 in the Moreton block), shortened QT intervals (Figure l ) , reversed T wave
region of south-eastern Queensland (Queensland Herbarium polarity and depressed S T segments (both persistent from day
Voucher BRI 361717) were frozen and stored at -2OOC. 4 onwards) and intermittent second degree atrioventricular
Frozen plant material ( 2 kg in 200 g lots) was macerated for 5 blocks (types 1 and 11) on days 3 , 4 , 7 , 8 and 9. Plasma concen-
min in a blender with 50% aqueous ethanol (10 x 1 litre). The
resulting slurry was filtered with suction and the filtrate con-
~~ ~
10 1
,&
a m-
0 I w’
s1
€ 6
-i0n
f
c
- 4
c)
w
0
-__T
x
0
0 m loo 180 24 m
0 H m after do- (houn)
0 50 100 150 200 250
Time after dosing (hours) Figure 2. Changes in the plasma concentrations of urea,
creatinine, calcium and total bilirubin of a calf given bryotoxin
Figure 1. Changes in PR (0) and QT (X) intervals of the elec- A. The first datum point on each curve represents the mean
trocardiograph of a calf given bryotoxin A. The first datum value of 3 daily samples taken before dosing. The horizontal
point on each curve represents the value obtained before dos- lines represent the margins of the normal range of these values
ing. in cattle of similar age.