Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 6 - Other Treatment Modalities Di - 2002 - Contemporary Chinese Medicin
Chapter 6 - Other Treatment Modalities Di - 2002 - Contemporary Chinese Medicin
PAULETTE MCMILLAN
iet therapy in Chinese medicine, as in allo- Application of Chinese diet therapy is based on the
lj) pathic medicine, can be used to prevent dis-
ease and promote longevity or it can be used
traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) system of differ-
entiation. Differentiation of the chief complaint is de-
to treat an already existing disease. The medicinal diet termined by the presenting signs and symptoms ob-
is usually an adjunct to acupuncture, herbal treatment, tained through questioning, overall appearance of the
or both modalities. Diet can enhance or interfere with patient and the tongue, pulse diagnosis, body smells,
the action of the treatment. For example, a patient who quality of voice, and breathing. For example, a chief
needs a treatment plan "to clear the heat and soothe complaint of migraine headache according to TCM
the Liver Qi" should avoid Liver-heating foods and bev- can be differentiated into several syndromes such as
erages such as coffee, cola drinks, alcoholic beverages, Liver-YangRaising, Liver-Fire, Dampness, Blood Defi-
and red meat; otherwise the diet will interfere with the ciency, Stasis of Blood, and others. Accordingly, diet
corrective treatment. Therefore diet therapy means in- therapy for migraine headaches must vary in concert
cluding as well as excluding specific foods based on with the specific differentiation. This is an illustration
their properties and the presentation of the disease. of the case in which one disorder requires different
104
CHAPTER 6 Other Treatment Modalities 105
Four Natures and salty to the Kidney. A balance of the five tastes
promotes health. Too much of anyone taste will cre-
The two most important properties are the four na- ate an imbalance and damage the corresponding Zang
tures and the five flavors. The four natures of the food Organ. Overconsumption of salt weakens the bones
refers to the temperatures of cold, cool, warm, or hot. because salt has an affinity for the Kidneys, which
The nature of a food is determined by its effect on the oversee the health of the bones according the TCM.
body. For example, if it has antipyretic action, it is This is interesting, as osteoporosis is most prevalent
defined as cold, whereas if it promotes circulation and in industrialized nations where the salt intake from
warms the body, it is considered warm or hot. Some processed foods is very high. Research supports that a
foods are classified as neutral. The nature of the food high intake of sodium promotes loss of calcium in the
helps balance the yin and yang of the body, and over- urine, possibly contributing to osteoporosis."
consumption of extremely hot or cold foods promotes
disease. For example, ice cream or other frozen
desserts, consumed habitually, weaken the function of Channel Propensity
the Spleen and Stomach (digestion). Poor digestion
eventually leads to disease. Each food and herb has a propensity toward specific
channels. Propensity is determined by the action of the
food on different systems of the body. For example,
Five Flavors many fruits such as lemons, tangerines, and pears can
clear heat from the lungs to stop cough. Thus it is said
The five flavors or tastes are sour, bitter, sweet, pun- that these fruits go to the Lung channel. Most foods go
gent, and salty. Different tastes have different actions to at least two channels; for example, tangerines also
on the body. Sour (includes astringent) "retains and ar- treat nausea and loss of appetite, so they also go to the
rests," meaning it can control such signs of loss or Stomach channel. By knowing the nature, taste, and
openness as diarrhea and excessive sweating. Sour can channel propensity of a food, the food's action and clin-
also generate fluids, which is helpful in promoting ical usefulness can be understood.
proper digestion. Foods that are sour include lemons
and hawthorn berries. Some fruits are a blend of
slightly sour and sweet such as grapefruit, apricots, Four Directions
and cherries. The bitter taste is drying and purging.
Therapeutically these actions are good for treating Once a food has been digested it can also have an im-
constipation, moving perverse Qi downward as in acid pact on the direction of Qi. The four directions are as-
regurgitation, and relieving some types of cough. cending, descending, floating, and sinking. Therapeu-
Foods that are bitter include bitter melon and dande- tically, foods with ascending action can treat diarrhea
lion greens. Sweet can tonify or strengthen the body, and prolapsed organs; foods with descending action
help replenish fluid and blood, help harmonize the ac- can treat belching, hiccups, nausea, and vomiting;
tion of the Spleen and Stomach, and relieve spasms foods with floating or dispersing action can promote
and pain. Sweet foods include many fruits, root veg- perspiration to treat the common cold; and foods with
etables, chicken, chicken eggs, and mutton. The pun- sinking action can relieve constipation or treat mania
gent taste expels pathogens and helps promote the nor- and hypertension related to upward movement of
mal flow of Qi and Blood to relieve stagnation. Yang Qi. The general law in TCM is that leaves and
Pungent foods include ginger, cayenne pepper, chilies, flowers are light and tend to move upward; roots, seeds,
and Chinese spring onion. Salty taste softens and re- and fruits are heavy and tend to move downward."
solves masses. Salty foods include kelp and seaweed.
Interestingly, these foods in ancient China were used
to treat goiter. Today we know that some of these EXTERNAL AND INTERNAL
foods contain iodine, which treats simple goiter by ENVIRONMENTS
providing this missing mineral.s
Each of the five tastes has an affinity for each of Diet is prescribed on the basis ofTCM differentiation
the five Zang Organs. Sour goes to the Liver, bitter to and the properties of foods. However, other factors are
the Heart, sweet to the Spleen, pungent to the Lung, also considered including the patient's external envi-
CHAPTER 6 Other Treatment Modalities 107
ronment and physiological status. The external en- time to consume a nourishing and invigorating diet.
vironment refers to the seasons, indoor milieu, and Beef and mutton are often used because they are sweet
geographical location. and nourishing. Beef, in particular, can strengthen the
Spleen. "To tonify the Spleen means to tonify all"
(Fundamentals in Compiling Medical Works by Wang Fu,
Seasons the Qing Dynasty).'
warmer and the Liver Qi is strong. "In spring man doors, the indoor environment is 70 F. Many people
0
should eat more sweet food than sour food to nour- become easily chilled in air-conditioned environments.
ish the Spleen Qi" (Treatise on Health Preservation and One dietary intervention combines a light summer
Cultivation by Qiu Chuji, the Yuan Dynasty). Accord- diet of fruits and vegetables with some warming foods
ing to the Five Element theory, the Liver can invade or to protect the Spleen Qi and Wei Qi. Wei Qi is the Qi
harm the Spleen. The above quote suggests that too that protects the exterior layer of the body, preventing
much strengthening of the Liver may damage the invasion of pathogenic external factors (i.e., Cold,
Spleen; thus by nourishing the Spleen, a balance be- Wind, Heat, or in biomedical terms, viruses or the
tween the Liver and Spleen Qi is maintained. A com- common cold). In cool seasons, heated environments
mon misunderstanding, using Five Element charts, is at home and at work tend to dry the body. To counter
that because sour corresponds to Spring and Liver this, winter dietary tonification programs typically in-
that sour foods should be consumed in the Spring. Ac- clude moistening foods.
tually sour has the action of retaining and drawing in-
ward, which is the opposite of the desired action of
dispelling and moving outward. This latter and de- Geographical Location
sired action complements the natural Yang movement
in the body during the spring. The natural climate also affects the health of the body.
In summer, the weather is hot and the gastroin- For example, people living in unusually damp climates
testinal tract slows. The diet should be light and e~y have a tendency to develop Damp syndromes, whereas
to digest. The diet principle for the summer is to clear those living in deserts tend toward Excess Dry Syn-
heat and generate fluids. This is accomplished by con- dromes; the damp tendency may be exacerbated in late
suming fruits and vegetables regularly while decreas- summer, while the dry worsens in autumn.
ing intake of foods that are difficult to digest such as To complete the treatment plan, the patient's
animal meat and greasy foods. physical and emotional status must also be consid-
In autumn, the Yang-Qi or the energy of the body ered. Important physical characteristics include the
is weakening while the Yin-Qi or the substance of the patient's age, gender, and strength of constitution.
body is growing. The weather is cool and dry, so avoid-
ing cold foods to protect the Spleen's function (diges-
tion and absorption), and avoiding hot foods to prevent Age
excessivedrying is recommended. It is best to consume
foods moderate in nature at this time of the year. Age is particularly important when addressing the
Generally in winter, the Yin Qi is in excess and the young and the elderly. Children and infants have un-
Yang Qi is deficient. After the Winter Soltice, the Yang derdeveloped Spleen and Stomach Qi and as a result
Qi begins to rise again. This is the best time for people often have digestive difficulties. Weak Spleen Qi also
with weak or deficient constitutions to tonify and to allows fluids to accumulate, which leads to internal
rebalance the Yin and Yang. In general, it is the best Damp syndromes that manifest as nasal congestion
108 CONTEMPORARY CHINESE MEDICINE AND ACUPUNCTURE
and runny nose, asthma, and ear infections. Good Qi. In all cases of emotional distress, the patient
foods for children are root vegetables, well-cooked must be encouraged to consume meals when the
grains, and small amounts of animal protein. Cold mind is calm, and to eat in a leisurely fashion so as to
and moist foods such as dairy products can aggravate promote optimum digestion and absorption. With-
Damp conditions. out proper Spleen function, the body cannot trans-
The elderly also have a weak Spleen and Stomach form food into Qi and Blood, which are the essential
function (weak digestive systems), in this case caused by elements of health."
wear. They should have small frequent meals that are
warm, well-cooked, and easy to digest; soups and stews
are particularly recommended in Chinese medicine. FOOD SELECTION
AND PREPARATION
Lifestyle and Gender Chinese medicine acknowledges that the quality,
freshness, and cleanliness of food is essential to main-
Women of child-bearing age have different physiolog- taining its health-promoting properties. Foods are se-
ical needs than men. Pregnant women, in particular, lected according to color intensity, freshness of flavor,
have special needs. During pregnancy, according to and fragrance. Food preparation includes proper
TCM theory, the fluids collect in the Ren and Chong cleaning and preparing so that it is easy to digest and
meridians leaving the other meridians relatively dry, assimilate. Most importantly, attention is given to re-
so drying foods must be avoided. Examples of drying taining the nutritional value of the food.
foods are wine and hot spices.! Medicinal food preparation includes cutting food
Workers who are sedentary have different nutri- into proper shapes and sizes, and using appropriate
tional needs than physical laborers. As in allopathic cooking methods and condiments. Steaming, brais-
diet therapy, it is best to give more food during the day ing, stir-frying, stewing, roasting, and quick boiling
than at night because this is the time the greatest are among the common cooking methods. Condi-
amount of energy is being expended. This is particu- ments frequently added to foods include ginger, Chi-
larly important for the physically active patient." nese spring onion, mustard, salt, garlic, chilies,
Patients with a deficiency syndrome need to use cilantro, and peppers. The medicinal diet can be dis-
herbal treatments and make dietary alterations for ex- pensed in the form of teas, decoctions, fruit juices,
tended periods to fully recover. Typically, those with medicated wines, gruels made of rice and millet,
deficiency conditions include people recovering from soups, pancakes, cooked dishes, .,candied frui.ts, and
chronic illness, chemotherapy, radiation therapy, peo- more.
ple with eating disorders, and the elderly. Once food is properly selected and prepared,
proper dietary habits are also important. Patients are
encouraged to eat regularly, avoid overeating, to eat
Emotions only when hungry, and to chew food well. Patients
with weak constitutions are instructed to eat smaller
In addition to factoring in the external environment meals more frequently.
and the physical state of the patient, the practitioner As in allopathic diet therapy, some foods are con-
making dietary recommendations must also consider traindicated based on the patient's condition. For ex-
the emotional state of the patient. Stress-whether ample, in biomedicine, it is not enough to consume
physical, emotional, or from time pressure-hinders more beans, fruits, and vegetables to lower serum cho-
the proper function of the Spleen and Stomach (di- lesterol; it is considered equally important to decrease
gestion). Patients with histories of chronic worry typ- the intake of fats, especially saturated fats, to achieve
ically present with deficient Spleen function and the desired outcome. In the same way, the Chinese sys-
need a diet that is easy to digest and tonifies the tem instructs a patient with an Interior Cold syn-
Spleen. In contrast, patients who are angry, are dis- drome not only to consume foods with warming prop-
appointed by life, or feel constantly pressured are erties, but also to avoid foods with cold properties to
likely to be prescribed a diet that soothes the Liver achieve the desired outcome.
CHAPTER 6 Other Treatment Modalities 109
Treating with our hands is a natural, instinctive hu- rubbing painful areas to make them feel better. In
man response to pain, injury, and sickness. For as long China, the theory and practice of medicine was devel-
as we have been able to feel, human beings have been oped by treating through touch, and the practices of
110 CONTEMPORARY CHINESE MEDICINE AND ACUPUNCTURE
acupuncture and herbology grew alongside bodywork By the fifth century of the Common Era, manual
treatment. * therapy had evolved into a discipline in its own right.
Mastery of bodywork was required of traditional A doctoral degree was created for it at the Imperial
Chinese physicians. Viewed as integral to improving College of Medicine in Xian, the ancient capital of the
their sensitivity, it helped them learn the refined pal- Tang Dynasty.' During the Ming Dynasty (1368-1644)
pation skills necessary for competent diagnosis and the term Tuina (push and pull) was added. Documents
practice of all aspects of Chinese medicine. Today in of the time reveal that one of the specialties of Tuina
China, Tuina-Anmo is a doctoral discipline and requires was in treating some illnesses of small children.
5 or 6 years of medical training depending on the par- As China sent trade missions to open routes of
ticular specialization. commerce, Chinese medicine spread to the Korean
In the United States more than a dozen styles of peninsula and the Japanese archipelago. In each coun-
Oriental bodywork base their practice on medical the- try these manual therapies were adapted and inte-
ory first written in the original medical texts of China. grated into the local culture. In Japan this bodywork
Although each is a full bodywork practice in its own became known as Anma and in Korea it became
right, two-acupressure and shiatsu-are so well known known as Amma. There are today perhaps hundreds of
that practitioners of European massage use them to forms of Oriental bodywork specialties in Asia.
indicate that they have incorporated aspects of Orien- Styles of Oriental bodywork recognized in the
tal bodywork into their practices. United States and Europe come primarily from China,
Although the origins of Chinese bodywork predate Japan, Thailand, and Korea; the American Organiza-
written records, written sources from the Qin Dynasty tion for Bodywork Therapies of Asia (AOBTA) recog-
in the third century BCE call manual therapy Moshou nizes a dozen forms. To simplify, these are described
(hand rubbing). (The phrase "manual therapy" is used as six broad styles: Tuina, Shiatsu,lin Shin, Noad BoRom
to indicate treatment where the hands are used as the (ThaiMassage), Amma, and Acupressure. Although there
primary interventive tool.) A century later (Han Dy- is some overlap among these styles, they range from
nasty, 206 BCE-221 CE) it was called Anmo (press and very specific treatment for common disorders to
rub), a term still used today. Palpatory techniques for whole-body treatments that can profoundly shift the
diagnosis and manual techniques for treatment are receiver's state of being. Self-treatment by the patient
described in the HuangDi Neiling (The Yellow Emperor's to support the body's healing process is also taught as
Classic on Internal Medicine). Sadly, although we know part of Oriental bodywork practice.
that a considerable portion of the Huang Di Nei ling Oriental bodywork developed within a number of
consisted of the "ten classics of Qi Bo's massage,"t all different social environments. Some styles, such as Noad
of these books have been lost. Nevertheless, the fact Bo Rom, evolved as part of monastic traditions to help
that so much attention was given to this subject shows the receiver practice sitting meditation. Other styles,
how important bodywork was at that early time in the such as aspects of Tuina, have come from the martial
practice of Chinese medicine. . arts lineage. Here bodywork was used to heal traumatic
injury and correct structural misalignments, as well as
to keep the martial artist fit and healthy. Finally, prac-
titionership was often learned through a family lineage
"In his keynote address to the 1994 National Convention of the
AOBTA, Professor Wang]in-Huai spoke about the earliest known of healers. Throughout Chinese history, nutritional
medical record in China. It is a prescription written by a practitioner support through diet and the art of bone setting also
for a woman of high social standing who was ill. The prescription de- formed part of the bodyworker's set of skills.
scribes rubbing down over the flanks to generate heat and flow in the
lower abdomen. Then the patient was instructed to hold her hands
there and breathe into the area until she could feel heat rising up to THE THEORY OF ORIENTAL
her shoulders. This remains an effective treatment even today, incor-
porating elements of both bodywork and Qi Gong. Professor Wang BODYWORK
]in-Huai was featured in Bill Moyers' documentary Healingand the
Mind. Oriental bodywork is guided by much the same theory
tWang]in-Huai in his key note address to the 1994 national con- as other modalities in Oriental medicine. Because touch
vention of the AOBTA.Also in the Han ShuYi WenZhi (Han's Book of
Arts and Scholarship), it states that "during the reign of the Yellow
is primary to this modality, Oriental bodywork focuses
Emperor, Qi Bo has written ten classics of An Mo ..." cited in Chinese on treating via the rivers of energy, the Meridians, that
Qigong Massage: General Massage, by Dr. Yang]wing-Ming, 1992. can be accessed at the surface of the body. Because the
CHAPTER 6 Other Treatmenr Modalities 111
Meridians relate to Organs that in tum control the func- body. This can be evidenced by, among other phe-
tion of all the tissues, internal health is reflected in these nomena, the presence of heat or cold, the firmness or
pathways and can be affected by bodywork. In a very lack of tonicity of the tissues, the presence or absence
basicway,the goal of Oriental bodywork treatment is to of moisture, and the different qualities of pain.
help the body achieve and maintain balance between With this information and the patient's report, a
areas that are in excess and areas that are deficient. practitioner is able to estimate the etiology of the pa-
The skilled practitioner's touch can both assess tient's condition and to formulate a course of treat-
and treat at the same time. This is a kind of "loop" in ment. To assess whether health is being restored, the
which the practitioner is using his or her hands both practitioner seeks signs such as increased strength and
to listen to (assess) the tissues being treated and to pliability in the muscles near the Channels, reduction
treat based on that assessment. Because Oriental of pain, increase in functionality, a fuller flow of Qi
bodywork is an energetic art, sensing Qi and its move- where Qi was deficient, or a more appropriate flow of
ment is an important aspect of knowing how to treat where Qi was excessive. In essence, better health reveals
and to gauge the ongoing success of treatment. itself physically in improved energy, posture, skin,
muscles, nails, hair, and membranes along the merid-
ians affected, and in a brighter psychological outlook.
DIAGNOSIS
another technique to open and encourage the ener- the shoulder, continues to correlate pain and dys-
getic flow through the area, limbs and joints may be function to Meridian and Organ theory, and remains
rotated to their full range of motion. responsive to ongoing changes as they occur in the pa-
When doing bodywork, diagnosis and treatment tient. Then, to facilitate the balancing of excess and
become almost indistinguishable. For example, sup- deficiency in the shoulder area, the practitioner may
pose a patient complains of a shoulder problem. Even choose to work further down the Meridian, or use
when treating the local area, the practitioner contin- techniques to shift the flow of Qi and Blood and en-
ues to sense where the energy is full or empty around hance healing (Figures 6-1 and 6-2).
Figure 6-2 A variety of movements are used on different parts of the body to improve the flow ofQi
and Blood. Here a practitioner kneels by a patient and uses her body weight judiciously to stretch
and stimulate a patient's back. (From Beresford-Cooke C: Shiatsu theory and practice: a comprehensive
text forthe studentand professional, Edinburgh, 1996, Churchill Livingstone.)
CHAPTER 6 Orher Trearmenr Modaliries 113
Adding Energy via Bodywork was developed for the treatment of traumatic injury
and for use in pediatric care, whereas Anmo was di-
An idea in Oriental medical theory that is often better rected toward the treatment of internal disease. Amma
developed in bodywork (and moving meditation prac- is the same system coming to the United States from
tices)than in acupuncture and herbal care is that treat- Korea, where Chinese medicine has been practiced
ment can "add" energy to the system, thus offering an- since the sixth century CEo
other way of balancing those suffering from deficiency. Patients with orthopedic problems may benefit
This technique, called Qiprojection, combines Qi gong from Tuina and Amma. These modalities are specific
and manual treatment techniques. After developing a for treating joint and injury problems, chronic condi-
personal abundance of Qi, a practitioner may focus Qi tions, and back problems. Because these modalities
into points or an area of a patient's body. can affect the functioning of the body's internal or-
gans, they are appropriate for internal medicine, gy-
necology, and trauma. They can affect the health of
Self-Care the fivesense organs and help a person feel more alive.
There are also specific applications for self-massage
Another important characteristic of bodywork is that and massage for athletes.
some components can be performed by patients on
themselves, outside the practitioner's office; it can be
put to excellent use in daily life in the home. Practi- Shiatsu
tioners often give homework to patients so that they
can sustain or enhance their progress at home. Lessons Literally meaning "finger pressure," shiatsu originated
may also be given in the treatment of family members. in Japan. Using the thumbs, palms, elbows, knees, and
In fact, this is how many Asian practitioners first learn. feet, the practitioner applies direct holding pressure
Many of myJapanese clients say, "Oh yes, I learned shi- sequentially to acupoints along meridians. Other tech-
atsu treating my Grandmother when I was young." niques include stretching meridians to open and stim-
Finally, it is worth mentioning that in most, if not ulate the circulation of Qi, and rotating joints to open
all styles of Oriental bodywork, the patient receives the , the range of motion and move Qi blockages. Although
treatment clothed. On the first visit, practitioners typ- there are many styles of practice, typically shiatsu
icallydo an Intake Interview (patient's health history, practitioners treat whole Meridians as opposed to
living situation, diet, and so forth) and perform phys- specific points. Diagnostic assessment focuses on
ical diagnosis. In subsequent visits, practitioners do identifying which Meridians are deficient (kyo) or in
follow-up interviews and assess the changing state of excess (jitsu); treatment aims tohelp the body achieve
the body and health as described previously. balance between the two.
Patients who can benefit from opening and facili-
tating flow of Blood and Qi within the body benefit
FIVE ORIENTAL BODYWORK from shiatsu because this treatment facilitates circula-
PRACTICES tion in the body. One of the most influential shiatsu
therapists in Japan, Shizuto Masunaga, was also a psy-
Tuina/Anmol Amma
I , chologist and outlined treatment based on psychologi-
cal temperament in addition to physical conditions. The
Tuina (push and pull) and Anmo (press and rub) are general ideas concerning psychological temperaments
the most ancient and most Chinese of the bodywork are first mentioned in Chapter 8 of the Huang DiNeiling.
systems, and their principles permeate all of the rest
of the styles. Commonly combined under the single
term Tuina, they provide a good example of the broad Jin Shin
range of a practitioner's scope of practice. Indeed, a
fully trained practitioner combines skills that in the ]in Shin]itsu is also from Japan and has numerous vari-
West would usually be divided into massage, physical ations in America. For this text, the common body of
therapy, and chiropractic. A practitioner may also these practices is called Jin Shin. This style of treat-
know and incorporate the use of Chinese herbs, plas- ment uses gentle pressure on two or more acupressure
ters, bonesetting, and Qi projection. Originally, Tuina points to facilitate the movement of energy. The point
114 CONTEMPORARY CHINESE MEDICINE AND ACUPUNCTURE
system is different from that of acupuncture, and the ian Qi and bone Qi meet. ZB releases energy held in
treatment is not directing, it is allowing. People who the body and helps the body to realign both pattern
like active moving touch, or are hyperactive, may pre- and function. CST is derived from osteopathic prac-
fer one of the other therapies. The receiver is encour- tice. Working the meningeal system of the central ner-
aged to go inward and participate in the release as vous system, CST can release the stresses held there
fully as possible. This treatment has an affinity for fa- and clear restrictions in the craniosacral system.
cilitating movement at the levels of emotion and
spirit, as well as at the physicalleve!.
CONTRAINDICATIONS
Noad Bn-Rnm/Thai Massage Contraindications for treatment vary according to the
hand techniques used. The fluid-mobilizing techniques
Noad Be-Rom is the traditional name for the form of of European massage and Meridian treatment are con-
Thai massage that once flourished in the sequestered at- traindicated in conditions such as thrombophlebitis;
mosphere of Buddhist monasteries. This form of Ori- however, other techniques can be used if affected local
ental bodywork is influenced by the ayurvedic tradition areas are not directly stimulated. During pregnancy
of India and the medicine of China; it also includes certain sites on the body must not be treated. In addi-
components that are purely Thai. Because it emphasizes tion to predictable locations near the pregnant uterus,
stretching and extending the range of motion of the re- such sites include several points on inside of the lower
ceiver's body, it looks somewhat like an assisted Yoga. leg, LI 4 (hand), and GB 21 (top of shoulder).
However,it is a Yoga combined with the traditional tech- Oriental bodyworkers are also acutely conscious of
niques of Oriental bodywork that treats the Meridians conditions that cannot be appropriately treated by
and acupoints. Like shiatsu, this therapy is able to open bodywork. Lists of such conditions (and how to iden-
the body and stimulate circulation. Another character- tify them) are included in the curriculum of schools
istic of Noad Be-Rom is that it is practiced slowly- certified by the AOBTA. Most practitioners develop
because the practitioner is seeking to induce a height- working relationships with biomedical doctors and
ened or meditative state of consciousness in the receiver. seek advice when there are questions about appropri-
ateness of treatment. For example, in work with cancer
patients, some oncologists say to "do whatever makes
Acupressure the patient feel better," whereas others express concern
about "moving cancer" via the lymphatic system. In
Acupressure employs stimulation of a single acupoint, the latter cases, treatment can berestricted to areas
or a combination of acupoints, to effect a specific ther- away from areas near the tumor.
apeutic aim. Acupressure is a part of each previously
mentioned Oriental bodywork practice, as well as a treat-
ment modality in its own right. Stimulation of points is CERTIFICATION AND CALLING
done primarily with the fingers and thumb, and the se- A PRACTITIONER
lection of points aims to create a specific shift in the
body's physiology or condition. The National Council for the Certification of Acu-
puncture and Oriental Medicine (NCCAOM) certifies
practitioners of Oriental bodywork with the designa-
OTHER BODYWORK IN tion of Diplomate of Oriental Bodywork Therapy
AMERICAN PRACTICES (Dip!' OBT). In addition, the AOBTA, founded in Ker-
hoset, New York, in August 1989, is part of an
Many practitioners of Oriental medicine have learned international network of practitioners, schools, and
other bodywork modalities that are not Oriental organizations that have developed international stan-
bodywork.i These might include Zero Balancing (ZB)3 dards for the study and practice of Oriental manip-
and Cranio-Sacral Therapy (CST), among other ulative healing arts.
modalities. ZB was developed by an osteopath who The AOBTA has different levels of membership
learned acupuncture and began working where Merid- from Student to Associate to Certified; the highest level
CHAPTER 6 Other Treatment Modalities 115
Qi gong (pronounced "chee gung") is the fifth major your arms above your head, as if they were the horns
modality within Chinese medicine and may be the of a deer, it stimulated the Qi circulation of the liver;
most comprehensive of all. Qi gong means the culti- when you stretched your arms out like a bird spread-
vation of Qi, the life force or human bioelectrical field. ing its wings, it was good for the heart and relieving
It has been called "acupuncture without needles" be- tension; rubbing and slapping yourself and moving
cause, using only movement or meditation, it can like a monkey was good for the spleen ... and bending
open the energy gates and keep the Qi flowing forward like the bear was good for the back and kid-
smoothly, as well as balance the body as a whole. It is neys."? Others also observed the natural movements
a broad term that encompasses virtually all of the Chi- and breathing of animals and used them as models for
nese movement arts. Most exercise systems that are human exercise. These traditions came to be known as
slow or still and that focus on breathing are called Qi Qi gong and continued to be followed for hundreds
gong in China. ! of years. During the Cultural Revolution, most of
Qi gong is the core of all self-care in the Chinese China's traditional culture, including Qi gong, was
health care system.' The concept of self-care and prohibited. When the Cultural Revolution ended, peo-
health maintenance goes back many centuries in ple again began to practice Qi gong freely. Since then,
China. About 4000 years ago, the people of China were enthusiasm for Qi gong has grown and it is again
known to have danced to rid themselves of damp and widely practiced.'
arthritis. "Dancing made them hot, and the heat ex- Indeed, self-care and health maintenance have
pelled the damp and poison from their veins and long been central to Chinese medicine. "In China, ill-
joints," remarks Michael Tse, in his book, Qi gongfor ness is regarded as natural, a normal part of life, like
Health andVitality. 2 During the Three Kingdoms Period a rainy day," states Mengda Shu, OMD. "Self-care is
(280-220 BCE), a famous Chinese physician, Hwa Tou, very important. Some people in America ignore ill-
created "Five Animal Play." He observed the move- ness, think it is terrible, think of it as the enemy. The
ments of wild animals, noting how they maintained Chinese believe that illness exercises the immune sys-
their balance. Thinking that people had lost this nat- tem. It makes you stronger."? After the Cultural Rev-
ural ability, he designed "Five Animal Play" to help olution, China experienced a severe shortage of bio-
them relearn this skill and strengthen their bodies. medical personnel. Half had been killed, fled the
Adds Tse, "Hwa Tou explained that when you raised country, or gone underground, while the general
CHAPTER 6 Other Treatment Modalities 117
population doubled. In response, the government viewed as a disharmony of the body's energy system.
mandated a national program of Taijiquan, which The function of both acupuncture and Qi gong is to
incorporated many Qi gong principles. Before ad- clear the energy blockage, allow the Qi to flow freely,
mittance to a hospital, nonemergency patients were and thus to reestablish a state of harmony and bal-
required to first practice Taijiquan or Qi gong ance. Qi gong relies on breath, intention, visualization,
for 3 months. "The system worked," explains B. K. and, in many cases, movement, to accomplish these
Frantzis. "Tai Chi and Chi Gung managed to keep alms.
health matters as stable as they could be kept given The movement forms of Qi gong consist of slow,
the poor sanitation and starvation diet most lived gentle, flowing movements, designed to cultivate and
with. For the Chinese to get through this incredibly gather the invisible energy of nature and bring it to
rough period, from the mid-1950s on, it is estimated various acupuncture points, or "energy gates," where
that between 100 and 200 million people practiced it can be taken in by the body. It is then circulated
Tai Chi or Chi Gung daily." throughout the body, where it flows through the en-
There are literally hundreds of forms and tradi- ergy channels and nourishes all the organs and tis-
tions of Qi gong. Over the years old forms have sues. To the novice, virtually all of the movement
evolvedand new ones have been developed. Not all lin- forms of Qi gong look like Taijiquan; the practitioner
eages of Qi gong are strictly concerned with physical is usually standing, raising and lowering the arms
health; many expand into systems of mental and spir- slowly, and occasionally bending backward or moving
itual development. Martial arts Qi gong deveiops the the legs. Unlike the aerobic exercise popular in the
"warrior," using the Qi to enhance the practitioner's West, this is a slow, quiet, focused, moving meditation.
strength and endurance. Confucian Qi gong aims at Instead of listening to loud music or being mentally
self-cultivation, personal refinement, and ethical de- detached, the Qi gong practitioner is fully involved
velopment. Some forms, such as the well-known Taiji- mentally. He or she visualizes the Qi, using intention
quan (Tai Chi Chuan), are hybrids of the martial arts and imagination, with the goal of bringing it to the
and healing traditions. Nor do all forms of Qi gong various body organs to nourish and strengthen them.
involve movement. Some forms, known as Jing Gong, (See Figures 6, 7, and 8 on pp. 197-198.)
or passive Qi gong, are done while lying or sitting very Visualization is thus central to both the movement
still. These use only breath, intention, and visualiza- and meditative forms of Qi gong; indeed, the medita-
tion to cultivate and enhance the Qi. Indeed, all forms tive forms of Qi gong rely solely on breath, intention,
of Qi gong have breath and intention in common, and visualization. Whether standing, sitting, lying
with the cultivation of the Qi as the primary focus. It down, or perfectly still, the Qi gong practitioner visu-
could be argued that Qi gong is a form of meditation, alizes the gathering and circulating of the Q'i and the
whether a moving meditation, such as the familiar nourishing of the tissues. Jahnke! remarks:
Taijiquan, or a still, strictly internal one. In his book,
The Most Profound Medicine) Roger Jahnke, OMD, de- The Qicirculates in theenergy channels by virtueofthe
scribes the range of Qi gong practice': breathing, the movementand the visualization ofQigong.
Thereisan intricatenetwork ofbio-electrical circuits (71
There are many systems and traditions ofQigongranging namedchannels) and an endless number ofminor channels
from simplecalisthenic type movements with breath that administerthe Qi to everyorgan, tissue and cellofthe
coordination to complex auto regulatory typeexercises where body.
brain wavefrequency) heartrateand otherorganfunctions
arealteredintentionallyby thepractitioner. In extremely
advanced levels ofpractice the Qigongpractitioner can TAIJIQUAN
transmitQi or energy across distances and through sub-
stances. Thereare cases wherethepractitioner can manipu- Taijiquan is a martial art, developed from and based
latethe limbsofa subjectfrom a distance and diagnose on Qi gong. 4 Both use slow, flowing movements that
physiological disturbances withoutconversation orpalpation. relate to acupuncture points and serve to strengthen
the internal organs. Both involve relaxation, visualiza-
The principles underlying Qi gong are the same as tion, and controlled breathing. Both build health
those of acupuncture. In Chinese medicine, disease is through the cultivation of Qi. The distinction between
118 CONTEMPORARY CHINESE MEDICINE AND ACUPUNCTURE
Qi gong and Taijiquan is a subtle one. Stuart Kenter, the cultivation and development of the Qi, Qi gong
in his foreword to B. K. Frantzis' book, OpeningtheEn- creates an inner strength, an internal power, that can
ergy Gates ofYourBody) explains": neutralize an opponent's force and protect the practi-
tioner against attack. Frantzis," Qi gong master and
Tai Chi. . . isan ancient Chinese system ofmovementsbased teacher, states: - .
uponthedevelopment ofthechi(lifeforce) within thebody.
Cultivated chican beusedto rejuvenatethe body) healillness ChiGungisthe basis ofthepowerofthe Chinese martialarts,
and injuries) maintain health, and enhancespiritual whetherKung Fu,or the moresubtleinternalforms, such as
capacities. Tai Chimay alsobeusedasa highly effective Tai Chi, HsingI, and Ba Gua.It isalmostimpossible to
system ofself-defense. . . . Chigung... is theart andpractice determinefrom an externalviewhowtheseemingly gentle,
ofinternal energydevelopment. smooth movementsoftheinternalforms enabletheadvanced
practitioner to defeatthe mostviolentstreetfighter. This
Taijiquan movements include some Qi gong; Qi capability is basically derivedfrom thepractice ofChiGung,
gong is an integral part of Taijiquan. "Tai Chi Chuan which develops chiand internalpower.
without Chi Kung is no longer Tai Chi Chuan; it
becomes a form of gentle exercise that may provide Jahnke agrees, "It is Qi gong in the martial arts
some benefits in terms of blood circulation and recre- that supplies the abundance of Qi that makes the
ation but is unlikely to give the type of vitality and practitioner seem to fly, absorb tremendous blows,
mental freshness commonly ascribed to Tai Chi and knock down opponents with what look like mi-
Chuan training.i" nor punches."! Without Qi gong, Taijiquan would be
Indeed, it is Qi gong that gives the Chinese mar- merely an engaging and graceful dance, without the
tial arts their incredible strength and power. Through power or strength needed for combat.
CHAPTER 6 Other Treatment Modalities 119
EXTERNAL QI GONG but we can feel it ... Everybody has an aura. We can see
it. From the aura we can see whether the body is healthy
External Qi gong, also known as "medical Qi gong" or or unhealthy. We can see each organ's aura." When
"Qi healing," is the most challenging to Western no- asked how, once diagnosed, the blockage is removed, he
tions of reality. Unlike the internal self-care forms of replied, "We just think about it."7 (See p. 119.)
Qi gong, where the individual plays an active role in
health maintenance, in external Qi gong an active
practitioner treats a quiescent patient. The practi- SAFETY
tioner of external Qi gong does not measure pulses,
observe the patient's tongue, or palpate reflexes. He Most Qi gong is safe to practice, even for novices.
seldom asks many questions. Instead, he or she relies However, some types of Qi gong are for specific health
on concentration, intuition, and his or her ability to problems; others are more general. B. K. Frantzis notes
"read" the patient's Qi, often through an off-the-body that there are also a few extreme forms and advises
scanning technique, to find the energy blockages and against them, such as sexual Qi gong exercises and "Qi
enable the energy to flow freely again. Master X. packing" techniques. He recommends weekly supervi-
(Shawn) Liu,6 a Qi gong master and martial arts in- sion with a competent and well-qualified instructor.
structor, who also practices external Qi gong, says: But, he adds, "Most Chi gung systems are actually
quite safe. Don't be afraid to practice Chi gung simply
People havelotsofblockages. Thecells sticktogether and because some techniques may be dangerous." Mengda
there aren't many whitecells. These people are toxic; theywill Shu, OMD and Taijiquan instructor, prefers Taijiquan
become malignant. I try toget the Qi circulating, to let the Qi practice to Qi gong for many people. Some patients,
flow and rechannel theblockage. You needto cleanyourself, because of age or temperament, do not have the pa-
togiveyourself o~gen, goodnutrients,cleanup thedebris, tience to learn Qi gong, in her opinion. "Tai Chi is
andproduce morewhitecells. Cells dieeveryday;you needto safer," she offers, "because it emphasizes body move-
clean up thedebris. ment.:" T. K. Shih, when asked about the safety of Qi
gong and Taijiquan, replied, "You must choose the
Liu's patients may be seated or lying down. He tells .right Qi gong," but added, "correctly done, Tai Chi is
them to relax and open their minds. Standing next to OK for everyone."?
them and using his hands, he feels for an increase in
body temperature and watches for a muscular re-
sponse, such as a twitch, as the channels open up. WHO CAN BENEFIT
"Sometimes they jump a little," Liu states. "Their skin
may change color. The atmosphere is different. Blood Because Qi gong affects all body organs and tissues, it
circulation improves." Liu describes the external Qi can treat a broad array of medical conditions. Certainly,
gong practitioner as a satellite, which receives Qi 'and all of the conditions generally ameliorated by acupunc-
transmits Qi. "It depends on the Qi you're born with," ture are good candidates for Qi gong. Qi gong or Taiji-
he says. "Some people can project Qi; others can't." quan should be considered in the following cases:
Communication also is important. Each patient has a • Those who might be helped by acupuncture, but
code, similar to a computer password. "You have to who fear or dislike needles."
break the code," Liu explains. "If the patient doesn't • Patients with chronic pain, particularly when bio-
want to open up to you, it is much, much harder.:" medicine offers little hope or when complex inter-
Another Qi gong master and Qi healer, T. K. Shih, ventions are out of reach because of financial re-
OMD, who founded the Chinese Healing Arts Center sources.
in Kingston, New York, teaches his students how to di- • Patients with acquired immunodeficiency syn-
agnose and correct energy blockages. Asked to describe drome (AIDS)/human immunodeficiency virus
how Qi healers do this, he explained, "We can see where (HIV) who are not too sick to embark on a pro-
there's a bad yin/yang balance, where the energy is too gram of gentle movement or meditation. Indeed,
strong." He does not need to touch his patients, he says, any patient for whom biomedicine offers little or
because he "can feel the body's energy. You can't see it, no hope.
120 CONTEMPORARY CHINESE MEDICINE AND ACUPUNCTURE
• Patients restricted to wheelchairs or bed rest or gap overwhelming, particularly as taught by Chinese
those who are paralyzed (sitting or lying down or instructors. Furthermore, Qi gong instructors and ex-
meditative Qi gong). ternal Qi gong practitioners cannot be found in all ge-
• Anyone who enjoys or could benefit from move- ographical areas; in contrast, acupuncturists and Tai-
ment. The slow, gentle movements of Qi gong and jiquan classes are much easier to find.
Taijiquan are wonderful for seniors or for younger Moving meditation is a safe and effective modality
individuals for whom aerobic exercise would be that offers tremendous healing potential for those pa-
too strenuous. Those who enjoy dance may also tients open to a new paradigm. As Qi gong and Taiji-
find the flowing movements appealing, particu- quan become better known and more widely accepted,
larly when set to music. more patients, particularly those for whom biomedicine
• Patients who prefer to play an active role in their offers little promise, are likely to seek their benefits.
health and healing.
• Virtually anyone who is receptive to new ideas and
ready for lifestyle changes."
References
Although the simpler Qi gong exercises are easily 1. Jahnke R: Themostprofound medicine, Santa Barbara, Calif,
learned, many Qi gong instructors teach lengthy se- 1991, Health Action Publishing.
quences of movements, which requires learning the 2. Tse M: Qi gongfor healthand vitality, New York, 1995,
name and location of many acupuncture points. This St. Martin's Griffin.
3. Shu M: Telephone interview, April 3, 1998.
style of Qi gong requires a commitment of time and
4. Frantzis BK: Opening the energy gates ofyour body, Berke-
energy to learn and practice. Indeed, it takes time to
ley, Calif, 1993, North Atlantic Books.
learn either Taijiquan or Qi gong, whether a moving 5. Kit WK: Thecomplete bookoftai chichuan: a comprehensive
form or a strictly meditative one. Patients anxious for guide to theprinciples andpractice, Rockport, Ill, 1999, Ele-
immediate improvement would be more inclined to- ment Books.
ward acupuncture, or acupuncture supplemented by 6. Liu X: Telephone interview, May 15, 1998.
a few simple Qi gong exercises. Some Westerners lack 7. Shih TK: Telephone interview.june 15, 1998.
the confidence to "feel the Qi"; others find the culture 8. PorvaznikM:Telephone interview, February 2, 1998.