These ancient writers provide differing perspectives on gladiatorial games:
- Seneca describes games as "mere butchery" where spectators demanded fighters be killed in increasingly brutal ways. He advises others not to attend.
- Cicero mentions his ownership of gladiators who "fight superbly" and notes the financial gains that could be made by renting them out to perform.
- Dio Cassius recounts games involving hundreds of lions and elephants fighting armed men, though some elephants were spared by sympathetic crowds. He also describes Julius Caesar putting on lavish games with huge numbers of wild animals and gladiators.
These ancient writers provide differing perspectives on gladiatorial games:
- Seneca describes games as "mere butchery" where spectators demanded fighters be killed in increasingly brutal ways. He advises others not to attend.
- Cicero mentions his ownership of gladiators who "fight superbly" and notes the financial gains that could be made by renting them out to perform.
- Dio Cassius recounts games involving hundreds of lions and elephants fighting armed men, though some elephants were spared by sympathetic crowds. He also describes Julius Caesar putting on lavish games with huge numbers of wild animals and gladiators.
These ancient writers provide differing perspectives on gladiatorial games:
- Seneca describes games as "mere butchery" where spectators demanded fighters be killed in increasingly brutal ways. He advises others not to attend.
- Cicero mentions his ownership of gladiators who "fight superbly" and notes the financial gains that could be made by renting them out to perform.
- Dio Cassius recounts games involving hundreds of lions and elephants fighting armed men, though some elephants were spared by sympathetic crowds. He also describes Julius Caesar putting on lavish games with huge numbers of wild animals and gladiators.
Seneca
(b.4
BC/1
CE-‐d.
65
CE):
I
turned
in
to
the
games
one
mid-‐day
hoping
for
a
little
wit
and
humor
there.
I
was
bitterly
disappointed.
It
was
really
mere
butchery.
The
morning's
show
was
merciful
compared
to
it.
Then
men
were
thrown
to
lions
and
to
bears:
but
at
midday
to
the
audience.
There
was
no
escape
for
them.
The
slayer
was
kept
fighting
until
he
could
be
slain.
"Kill
him!
flog
him!
burn
him
alive"
was
the
cry:
"Why
is
he
such
a
coward?
Why
won't
he
rush
on
the
steel?
Why
does
he
fall
so
meekly?
Why
won't
he
die
willingly?"
Unhappy
that
I
am,
how
have
I
deserved
that
I
must
look
on
such
a
scene
as
this?
Do
not,
my
Lucilius,
attend
the
games,
I
pray
you.
Either
you
will
be
corrupted
by
the
multitude,
or,
if
you
show
disgust,
be
hated
by
them.
So
stay
away.
Cicero,
Letter
to
Atticus
(Returning
from
Epirus)
Antium,
April,
56
BCE
It
will
be
delightful
if
you
come
to
see
us
here.
You
will
find
that
Tyrannio
has
made
a
wonderfully
good
arrangement
of
my
books,
the
remains
of
which
are
better
than
I
had
expected.
Still,
I
wish
you
would
send
me
a
couple
of
your
library
slaves
for
Tyrannio
to
employ
as
gluers,
and
in
other
subordinate
work,
and
tell
them
to
get
some
fine
parchment
to
make
title
pieces,
which
you
Greeks,
I
think,
call
"sillybi."
But
all
this
is
only
if
not
inconvenient
to
you.
In
any
case,
be
sure
you
come
yourself,
if
you
can
halt
for
a
while
in
such
a
place,
and
can
persuade
Pilia
to
accompany
you.
For
that
is
only
fair,
and
Tulia
is
anxious
that
she
should
come.
My
word!
You
have
purchased
a
fine
troop!
Your
gladiators,
I
am
told,
fight
superbly.
If
you
had
chosen
to
let
them
out
you
would
have
cleared
your
expenses
by
the
last
two
spectacles.
But
we
will
talk
about
this
later
on.
Be
sure
to
come,
and,
as
you
love
me,
see
about
the
library
slaves.
Dio
Cassius
(late
2nd/early
3rdc.
CE)
39.38.1-‐4
[translations
from
E.Cary,
Dio's
Roman
History
(Loeb
(1914)]
During
these
same
days
Pompey
dedicated
the
theatre
in
which
we
take
pride
even
at
the
present
time.
In
it
he
provided
an
entertainment
consisting
of
music
and
gymnastic
contests,
and
in
the
Circus
a
horse-‐race
and
the
slaughter
of
many
wild
beasts
of
all
kinds.
Indeed,
five
hundred
lions
were
used
up
in
five
days,
and
eighteen
elephants
fought
against
men
in
heavy
armour.
Some
of
these
beasts
were
killed
at
the
time
and
others
a
little
later.
For
some
of
them,
contrary
to
Pompey's
wish,
were
pitied
by
the
people
when,
after
being
wounded
and
ceasing
to
fight,
they
walked
about
with
their
trunks
raised
toward
heaven,
lamenting
so
bitterly
as
to
give
rise
to
the
report
that
they
did
so
not
by
mere
chance,
but
were
crying
out
against
the
oaths
in
which
they
had
trusted
when
they
crossed
over
from
Africa,
and
were
calling
on
Heaven
to
avenge
them.
For
it
is
said
that
they
would
not
set
foot
upon
the
ships
before
they
received
a
pledge
under
oath
from
their
drivers
that
they
should
suffer
no
harm.
Whether
this
is
really
so
or
not
I
do
not
know;....
[22]
So
after
completing
the
new
forum
and
the
temple
to
Venus,
as
the
founder
of
his
family,
he
[Julius
Caesar]
dedicated
them
at
this
very
time
and
in
their
honour
instituted
many
contests
of
all
kinds.
He
built
a
kind
of
hunting-‐theatre
of
wood,
which
was
called
an
amphitheatre
from
the
fact
that
it
had
seats
all
around
without
any
stage.
In
honour
of
this
and
of
his
daughter
he
exhibited
combats
of
wild
beats
and
gladiators;
but
anyone
who
cared
to
record
their
number
would
find
his
task
a
burden
without
being
able,
in
all
probability,
to
present
the
truth;
for
all
such
matters
are
regularly
exaggerated
in
a
spirit
of
boastfulness.
I
shall
accordingly
pass
over
this
and
other
like
events.....
[23]...As
for
the
men,
he
not
only
pitted
them
one
against
another
singly
in
the
Forum,
as
was
customary,
but
he
also
made
them
fight
together
in
companies
in
the
Circus,
horsemen
against
horsemen,
men
on
foot
against
others
on
foot,
and
sometimes
both
kinds
together
in
equal
numbers.
There
was
even
a
fight
between
men
seated
on
elephants,
forty
in
number.
Finally
he
produced
a
naval
battle;
not
on
the
sea
nor
on
a
lake,
but
on
land;
for
he
hollowed
out
a
certain
tract
on
the
Campus
Martius
and
after
flooding
it
introduced
ships
into
it.
In
all
the
contests
the
captives
and
those
condemned
to
die
took
part;
yet
some
even
of
the
knights,
and,
not
to
mention
others,
the
son
of
one
who
had
been
praetor
fought
in
single
combat.
Indeed
a
senator
named
Fulvius
Sepinus
desired
to
contend
in
full
armour,
but
he
was
prevented;
for
Caesar
deprecated
that
spectacle
at
any
time,
though
he
did
permit
the
knights
to
contend.
The
patrician
boys
went
through
the
equestrian
exercise
called
"Troy"
according
to
ancient
custom,
and
the
young
men
of
the
same
rank,
contended
in
chariots.
[24]He
was
blamed,
indeed,
for
the
great
number
of
those
slain,
on
the
ground
that
he
himself
had
not
become
sated
with
bloodshed
and
was
further
exhibiting
to
the
populace
symbols
of
their
own
miseries;
but
much
more
faith
was
found
because
he
had
expended
countless
sums
on
all
that
array....In
order
that
the
sun
might
not
annoy
any
of
the
spectators,
he
had
curtains
stretched
over
them
made
of
silk,
according
to
some
accounts.
Dio
on
Titus
1.
Most
that
he
did
was
not
characterized
by
anything
noteworthy,
but
in
dedicating
the
hunting
theatre
[The
Amphiteatrum
Flavium,
later
known
as
the
Colosseum]
and
the
baths
that
that
bear
his
name
he
produced
many
remarkable
spectacles.
There
was
a
battle
between
cranes
and
also
between
four
elephants;
animals
both
tame
and
wild
were
slain
to
the
number
of
nine
thousand;
and
women
(not
those
of
any
prominence,
however)
took
part
in
despatching
them.
2.
As
for
the
men,
several
fought
in
single
combat
and
several
groups
contended
together
both
in
infantry
and
naval
battles.
For
Titus
suddenly
filled
this
same
theatre
with
water
and
brought
in
horses
and
bulls
and
some
other
domesticated
animals
that
had
been
taught
to
behave
in
the
liquid
element
just
as
on
land.
3.
He
also
brought
in
people
on
ships,
who
engaged
in
a
sea-‐fight
there,
impersonating
the
Corcyreans
and
Corinthians;
and
others
gave
a
similar
exhibition
from
outside
the
city
in
the
grove
of
Gaius
and
Lucius,
a
place
which
Augustus
had
once
excavated
for
this
very
purpose.
There,
too,
on
the
first
day,
there
was
a
gladiatorial
exhibition
and
wild-‐beast
hunt,
the
lake
in
front
of
the
images
having
first
been
covered
over
with
a
platform
of
planks
and
wooden
stands
erected
around
it.
4.
On
the
second
day
there
was
a
horse-‐race,
and
on
the
third
day
a
naval
battle
between
three
thousand
men,
followed
by
an
infantry
battle.
The
"Athenians"
conquered
the
"Syracusans"
(these
were
the
names
the
combatants
used),
made
a
landing
on
the
islet
[i.e.,
Ortygia]
and
assaulted
and
captured
a
wall
that
had
been
constructed
around
the
monument.
These
were
the
spectacles
that
were
offered,
and
they
continued
for
a
hundred
days;
but
Titus
also
furnished
some
things
that
were
of
practical
use
to
the
people.
5.
He
would
throw
down
into
the
theatre
from
aloft
little
wooden
balls
variously
inscribed,
one
designating
some
article
of
food,
another
clothing,
another
a
silver
vessel
or
perhaps
a
gold
one,
or
again
horses,
pack-‐ animals,
cattle
or
slaves.
Those
who
seized
them
were
to
carry
them
to
the
dispensers
of
the
bounty,
from
whom
they
would
receive
the
article
named.
Ausonius
(4thc.
CE)
ECL.
23.33-‐7
=
Athenaeus,
4.153f-‐154a,
Loeb
trans
[quoting
Nicolaus
of
Damascus,
FGrH
90,
F78
=
FHG
iii.265]
The
Romans
staged
spectacles
of
fighting
gladiators
not
merely
at
their
festivals
and
in
their
theatres,
borrowing
the
custom
from
the
Etruscans,
but
also
at
their
banquets...some
would
invite
their
friends
to
dinner...that
they
might
witness
two
or
three
pairs
of
contestants
in
gladiatorial
combat...when
sated
with
dining
and
drink,
they
called
in
the
gladiators.
No
sooner
did
one
have
his
throat
cut
than
the
masters
applauded
with
delight
at
this
fight.
The Collected Works of Henryk Sienkiewicz (Illustrated Edition): Quo Vadis, In Desert and Wilderness, With Fire and Sword, The Deluge, Pan Michael, Children of the Soil, On the Field of Glory, Whirlpools, Without Dogma, In Vain
Jitse H. F. Dijkstra, Christian R. Raschle - Religious Violence in The Ancient World - From Classical Athens To Late Antiquity-Cambridge University Press (2020) PDF