Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fisiologi Aging
Fisiologi Aging
Physiology of Aging
George E. Taffett
Aging, from maturity to senescence, results in an appar- physiologic deviation from normal using the APACHE
ent depletion of physiologic reserves that has been severity of illness scales.2 Acute physiologic assessment
termed homeostenosis. This term suggests a narrowing of points are generated by increased deviation from home-
homeostatic reserve mechanisms. Homeostenosis leads ostatic values for 12 variables, including vital signs,
to the increased vulnerability to disease that occurs with oxygenation, pH, electrolytes, hematocrit, white count,
aging. Primary aging changes, upon which we focus here, and creatinine. A normal person at homeostasis will have
are those that occur as a result of the passage of time and a zero score. A greater departure from homeostasis is
are independent of disease state, although there may be measured by a greater point total.
overlap between disease and these changes. The age Figure 3.2 shows young and old patients who experi-
changes may be accelerated or slowed by lifestyle but are enced a cardiac arrest. The younger group (mean age, 59
usually evident by the fourth or fifth decade and are years) had significantly higher (by 20%) acute physio-
gradual and inexorable. Overall, primary aging changes logic assessment scores than the older group (mean age,
result in little change in function when the older individ- 75).3 The data represent the worst values available in the
ual (or animal) is assessed in the unstressed state, but 24 h prearrest. These data support the concept that the
these age changes become readily evident when the older threshold, in this case being “sick” enough to have a
individual is stressed or moved away from homeostasis. cardiac arrest, is closer to homeostasis for the older than
Because disease produces such stresses, the impact, pre- for the younger group. In practice, the creators of the
sentation, and natural history of diseases are modified APACHE II or III scales recognized that advanced age
with age because the substrate, perhaps more than the adds to risk of physiologic impairment with intercurrent
disease pathophysiology, has been modified. illness. Another way to say this is that age reduces reserve
The concept of homeostenosis—the characteristic, pro- capacity and makes us less resilient. APACHE scales give
gressive constriction of homeostatic reserves that occurs “bonus points” for age so that the total scores are not
with aging in every organ system—was recognized by the different between the younger and older groups.3
famous physiologist Walter Cannon in the 1940s.1 Figure Despite the summative evidence, there is high vari-
3.1 graphically displays the traditional thinking about ability in these processes. Variation in the age effects on
homeostenosis. With aging, the capacity of older persons any parameter is large, and the variability appears to
to bring themselves back to homeostasis after a chal- increase with age. These variations are present from indi-
lenge becomes smaller. All challenges to homeostasis are vidual to individual at the same age, within a given indi-
movements off the baseline, and larger challenges require vidual from organ system to system, and even from cell
greater physiologic reserves to return to homeostasis. to cell isolated from the same person. For example, inves-
Aging itself brings the individual closer to the precipice tigators of the Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging
or threshold by the loss of physiologic reserves. The performed serial measurements of glomerular filtration
“precipice” may be defined, for example, as death or ill rate (GFR) measured as creatinine clearance in healthy
enough to have a cardiac arrest or for hospital admission. people. Overall, the mean GFR decreased 1 ml/year;
The precipice may also be the appearance of common however, almost 30% of patients showed no decrement
and protean symptoms, such as confusion, weight loss, in function in repeated studies over as long as 30 years.
sleep disorder, or weakness. Others showed decreases in GFR of 2 ml/year or more.4
Although empirically this paradigm is true, direct evi- Similarly, when lymphocytes are isolated from an older
dence for this model may be derived from studying the person and then studied in vitro, some of the cells func-
27
28 G.E. Taffett
Increasing Age
tion as well as those from a younger person5; of course, physiologic reserves have not “disappeared,” as sug-
others function poorly, and it is the relative ratio of the gested in Figure 3.1, but they remain unavailable to
two groups that impacts overall function. Therefore, as counter additional challenges. I focus on examples from
opposed to the pediatrician who can within a few weeks the cardiovascular system, such as heart rate, cardiac
anticipate when a baby will start to walk, the geriatrician hypertrophy, and diastolic function, because the data in
has a much harder time predicting when senescent this area provide an ample molecular, biochemical, and
changes will become clinically evident. physiologic foundation to reinterpret the traditional
Another reason for the variability in the physiologic approach to homeostenosis.
changes associated with aging is the contribution of Although resting heart rate in unchanged with age,
behavioral factors such as exercise and diet, both of maximum heart rate attained with exercise or pharma-
which are strong influences on healthy aging. Epidemiol- cologic manipulation decreases with age. Baltimore
ogists describe the growing rate of obesity, especially Longitudinal Study data, obtained from healthy, highly
among older men, as an increasingly sedentary existence screened individuals, give a regression equation of
of most people beyond 30 years of age. For many of the
variables listed in Table 3.1, exercise or other choices are
known to attenuate but not totally abrogate aging effects.
Some, such as the decrease in maximum heart rate
attained with exercise, appear to be more predictable.
Table 3.1 summarizes many of the major changes in
systems receiving further elucidation in respective sec-
tions of this volume. Data from the cardiovascular system
are expanded here because the data in this area provide
ample rationale to justify the necessity to reinterpret the
traditional approach to homeostenosis. This reinterpre-
tation helps one understand the phenomenon of frailty, a
central concern of geriatrics. Frailty is the state when
physiologic reserves are reduced to the point at which
susceptibility to disability is increased. Frailty is, there-
fore, the clinical manifestation of the later stages of
homeostenosis, an intolerance of homeostatic challenges.
Additionally, the reinterpretation of homeostenosis
makes those caring for the elderly appreciate and under-
stand the complexities they face.
In the elderly, as in youth, maintaining homeostasis is
a dynamic, active process. The reinterpretation of Figure
Figure 3.2. Age decreases the level of physiologic derange-
3.1 shown in Figure 3.3 is based on the concept that older ment associated with cardiac arrest. Acute physiologic assess-
persons are actively employing some of their physiologic ment (APA) scores (from the APACHE II severity of illness
reserves just to maintain homeostasis. Their available scale) are shown from patients who subsequently experienced
reserves appear depleted because they in are already in cardiac arrest and a resuscitation attempt. The data show the
use by the old heart (or other organ or system) to com- APA scores were significantly higher in the younger patients
pensate for primary age-related or other changes. The who arrested than the older ones (p < 0.05; Beer et al. 19943).
3. Physiology of Aging 29
208 - (0.95 ¥ age) for maximum heart rate attained with rate (the heart rate in the absence of sympathetic and
exercise. It is likely that women have lower maximum parasympathetic stimulation), as well as invokes
heart rates at age 30 and a more gentle fall with aging reserves just to maintain resting heart rate. Data from
than this equation predicts. This decrease in maximum Jose,6 although regretfully including only a modest
heart rate responsiveness results from a combination of number of elders, show a decrease in intrinsic heart rate
factors. First, primary aging decreases the intrinsic heart from 120–130/min to less than 80. There is no difference
“The Precipice ”
Physiologic
Reserves
Figure 3.3. Revised schematic of homeostenosis. Available
In comparison to Figure 3.1, this diagram shows
that maintaining homeostasis is a dynamic process. Physiologic
The older person employs or consumes physiologic Reserves
reserves just to maintain homeostasis, and therefore Already In Use
there are fewer reserves available for meeting new
challenges. Increasing Age
32 G.E. Taffett
Figure 3.5. Decreased response to pressure stimulus in the old natriuretic peptide (ANP), a marker for myocyte hypertrophy,
heart. After aortic banding in the young and old rat, there is a is increased in the control and old hearts, suggesting prior invo-
decreased elaboration of RNA for “early immediate response cation of the hypertrophic response (Takahashi et al. 19927 with
genes” (fos and jun) in the old heart, followed by decreased con- permission.)
tractile protein response (skeletal actin). Ventricular atrial
3. Physiology of Aging 33
In contrast, atrial natriuretic peptide (ANP), a marker in decreasing vulnerability. To date, evidence for this
for myocyte hypertrophy when it is expressed by the opportunity to increase reserves remains unproven.
ventricular myocyte, is increased significantly after Older persons are frailer, more likely to cross a given
banding in the young heart. The ventricular ANP is not “precipice” after a stress, not only because they have lost
detectable in the control young heart. ANP is signifi- some reserves because of aging, but because they are
cantly elevated in the ventricle from both the banded and already utilizing other reserves to compensate for those
control older hearts, providing evidence that the old heart lost just to maintain homeostasis. Older people are more
has already invoked the hypertrophic response even likely to drown when thrown a brick, not because they
before the banding is applied. cannot swim but because they are already treading water.
Morphologic evidence of myocyte hypertrophy in It is well known that the mortality associated with
aging is provided by examining myocyte size. Myocytes myocardial infarction (MI) increases dramatically with
from the ventricles of older persons and animals are age. Although absolute death rates have improved with
larger than those from young adults, consistent with treatment for all ages, the 10-fold increase in mortality
ongoing myocyte hypertrophy in response to uncertain after MI from ages 40 to 80 has not been modified. This
stresses. Various investigators report 25% increase in age-related increase in mortality has been variously
myocyte length and 50% or more increases in myocyte attributed to increased infarct size in the old, comorbid
width.8 There is likely a maximum size for the myocyte; conditions, less aggressive therapy for the old, noncom-
therefore, myocytes in the old heart may be unable to pliance with medical regimens, or increased existence of
hypertrophy further because they have already multivessel coronary artery disease. Some of the points
responded to prior or ongoing challenges. may be true, but in studies where all these factors are con-
With aging in animals and man, there are impairments trolled, the mortality is still much higher in the older
in early cardiac relaxation, largely caused by alterations groups. Age is the key component, and I hypothesize that
in cellular calcium flux. The increased dependence on it is the age-related inability to respond to challenge,
transsarcolemmal calcium flux (in and out of the cell) homeostenosis in the cardiovascular system, that results
seen in the old rat heart maintains adequate calcium in the increased mortality.
availability for contraction. This adaptation appears to be A similar set of implications can be made relevant to
a compensation for decreased transsarcoplasmic reticu- the increased frequency of falls in response to challenge
lum calcium flux. Therefore, the compensation comes at in the elderly. Decreases in baroreceptor sensitivity, arte-
a cost, the lengthening of contraction by both slowing the rial compliance, cardiac compliance (and greater depend-
development of force and slowing cardiac relaxation. ence on cardiac filling to maintain cardiac output),
Using gene therapy, a key sarcoplasmic reticulum calcium renal sodium conservation, plasma volume, vasopressin
pump can be restored in old rats to levels found in the response to standing, and renin, angiotensin, and aldos-
young heart, and cardiac relaxation improves signifi- terone levels all contribute to the propensity to fall with
cantly.9 One manifestation of the impaired relaxation is postural change. Many of the problems with medications
the decreased effectiveness of early diastolic filling of the in the elderly, once attributed to altered pharmaco-
left ventricle. As a compensation to maintain ventricular dynamics, may be explained by this apparent depletion
filling, contribution of atrial systole to diastolic filling of physiologic reserves.
increases from 10% to 15% at age 20 to almost 50% at Data from the MacArthur Study of Aging support the
age 80.10 In addition to explaining why atrial fibrillation concept that healthy elders are actively compensating
(and the loss of atrial systole) becomes so devastating in just to maintain homeostasis and that the presence of
the elderly, the ability to augment the atrial contribution invoked compensation is associated with poor out-
to further increase cardiac output is limited. Therefore, comes.11 Only 7% of those aged 70 to 79 had no evidence
the Frank–Starling mechanism is invoked; filling pres- of such compensation, and the lack of compensation was
sures increase to augment cardiac output. associated with highest level of function. Seeman refers
There are numerous other changes in the cardiovascu- to this activation as “allostatic load,” and while some of
lar system (CVS) that follow the paradigm just described, the markers, such as elevated cholesterol and systolic
and the pattern is not at all limited to the CVS, such as blood pressure, are known risk factors for CV events and
the limited heat shock protein elaboration in response to death, others reflect the activity of sympathetic nervous
certain stimuli. These changes support rethinking the system or the hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal axis.
concept of frailty. Frailty is not a static state of increased Those patients with high allostatic load had decreased
vulnerability to stressors; rather, it is a dynamic state in physical and cognitive function at 2-year follow-up.
which the older person tolerates additional challenges There is some evidence that the inverse may also be
poorly because reserves are already engaged in battles, true. Masoro believes that one mechanism by which the
seen or unseen. From a therapeutic standpoint, this beneficial, life-prolonging effects of caloric restriction
suggests that efforts to disengage reserves may result occur is precisely that the decreased availability of calo-
34 G.E. Taffett
Physiologic
Reserves
Already In Use
Increasing Age
ries is a low-intensity stress.12 The beneficial effects of low- age 60, indicating the rate of loss increases with increas-
dose radiation may also be via this mechanism. Persistent, ing age. Strength follows mass in this pattern. It is likely
harmless stresses, such as caloric restriction or radiation, that most age-related physiologic changes are not linear
may be good for us; larger stresses may be harmful. functions of age.
Invoking compensatory mechanisms has the additional In summary, there is an apparent loss of physiologic
effect of constraining the complexity of many variables. reserves that leads to an intolerance of challenges to the
Heart rate variability decreases with aging, and this con- homeostasis of older persons. One should appreciate that
striction of heart rate may be due to decreased parasym- this frailty is, in part, present because the older person
pathetic tone and possible activation of the sympathetic is continually expending reserves to compensate for
nervous system while at rest.13 A similar constriction is primary age changes and other unseen processes absent
seen in blood pressure variability. The decrease in vari- or trivial in the younger individual.
ability may correspond with the ongoing activation of
compensatory reserves.
The concept of threshold is also useful in understand- Bibliography
ing the altered presentations of disease in the elderly. The
extent that any threshold from Figure 3.1 or Figure 3.3 Knaus WA, Wagner DP, Draper EA, et al. The APACHE III
approaches homeostasis may determine whether that prognostic system. Risk prediction of hospital mortality for
threshold is crossed by a given challenge. For example, critically ill hospitalized adults. Chest. 1991;100:1619–1636.
Masoro EJ, ed. Handbook of Physiology, Section 11, Aging.
delirium is a very common atypical presentation of a wide
American Physiological Society. New York: Oxford Press;
variety of illness in the elderly, a marker of the uneasy 1995.
truce that the old brain maintains with its environment.
The precarious balance is clearly evident but is not
limited to the cholinergic pathways. While it seems References
strange that a given older person may have the same
presentation (confusion) for a urinary tract infection, gas- 1. Cowdry EV, ed. Problems of Ageing: Biological and Medical
trointestinal bleeding, and a myocardial infarction, this Aspects, 2nd Ed. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins; 1942.
phenomena may be relatively common because the sys- 2. Knaus WA, Draper EA, Wagner DP, Zimmerman JE.
temic responses to these differing illnesses may be APACHE II: a severity of disease classification system. Crit
similar, involving cytokines, catecholamines, etc. In these Care Med. 1985;13:818–829.
patients, at homeostasis their “anticonfusion reserves” 3. Beer RJ, Teasdale TA, Ghusn HF, Taffet GE. Estimation of
may be exhausted so the distance from homeostasis to severity of illness with APACHE II: age-related implica-
tions in cardiac arrest outcomes. Resuscitation. 1994;27:189–
the “precipice” becomes minimal and is easily crossed
195.
(Fig. 3.6).
4. Lindeman RD, Tobin J, Shock NW. Longitudinal studies on
Finally, the lines on these schematics (Figs. 3.1, 3.3, 3.6) the rate of decline in renal function with age. J Am Geriatr
are straight for convenience’s sake, not because any of Soc. 1985;33:278–285.
the processes described in Table 3.1 are necessarily linear. 5. Ghia P, Melchers F, Rolink AG. Age-dependent changes in
For example, the loss in muscle mass approaches 40% as B lymphocyte development in man and mouse. Exp Geron-
one ages from 30 to 80, yet most of that loss happens after tol. 2000;35:159–165.
3. Physiology of Aging 35
6. Jose AD. Effect of combined sympathetic and para-sympa- 10. Swinne CJ, Shapiro EP, Lima SD, Fleg JL. Age-asociated
thetic blockade on heart rate and cardiac function in man. changes in left ventricular diastolic performance during iso-
Am J Cardiol. 1966;18:476–483. metric exercise in normal subjects. Am J Cardiol. 1992;69:
7. Takahashi T, Schunkert H, Isoyama S, et al. Age-related dif- 823–826.
ferences in the expression of proto-oncogene and contrac- 11. Seeman TE, Singer BH, Rowe JW, Horwitz RI, McEwen
tile protein genes in response to pressure overload in the BS. Price of adaptation—allostatic load and its health con-
rat myocardium. J Clin Investig. 1992;88:939–946. sequences. MacArthur studies of successful aging. Arch
8. Lakatta EG. Cardiovascular regulatory mechanisms in Intern Med. 1997;157:2259–2268.
advanced age. Physiol Rev. 1993;73:413–467. 12. Masoro EJ. Commentary. Hum Exp Toxicol. 2000;19:340–
9. Schmidt U, del Monte F, Miyamoto MI, et al. Restoration 341.
of diastolic function in senescent rat hearts through aden- 13. Lipsitz LA, Goldberger AL. Loss of “complexity” and
oviral gene transfer of sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca(2+)- aging. Potential applications of fractals and chaos theory to
ATPase. Circulation. 2000;101:790–796. senescence. JAMA. 1992;267:1806–1809.