RESEARCH METHODS FOR SERVICE INDUSTRY (HRS20803) 202209

ASSIGNMENT 1
TOPIC: JOURNAL ARTICLE CRITIQUE

INSTRUCTION:
1. Report MUST contain minimum pages of 5 and maximum of 10.
2. Mode: INDIVIDUAL
3. Submission in the form of written report only
4. Date of Submission: Week 4

**Marks will be deducted for any late submission.

REQUIREMENT:
Every student required to find ONE latest Journal Article (2018-2022) which related to their
area of study or associated with hospitality and tourism industry. Student is required to critique
the journal article from various perspectives such as title, relevancy, literature review,
methodology, findings, and so on. In the end of the report, student need to provide one copy of
the journal article referred as an appendix (full page).

FORMAT: Font: Arial (11); spacing (1.5); report cover: GREEN

** Please attach rubric at the end of the report.

Report will be evaluated based on the rubric attached.
 RESEARCH METHODS FOR SERVICE INDUSTRY (HRS20803) 202209

RESEARCH METHODS FOR SERVICE INDUSTRY

(HRS20803)

ASSIGNMENT 1: JOURNAL ARTICLE CRITIQUE

Group: A/B/C/D

PREPARED BY:

Your picture NAME:

[COMPULSORY) MATRIC NO:

PROGRAM:

PREPARED FOR:

DR. NORAIHAN BINTI MOHAMAD

 RESEARCH METHODS FOR SERVICE INDUSTRY (HRS20803) 202209

OUTSTANDING EXCELLENT GOOD AVERAGE NEEDS IMPROVEMENT SCORE

CRITERIA
(5) (4) (3) (2) (1)
There is a well-focused Introduction clearly Introduction clearly states Introduction is somewhat Introduction does not
statement that states the main topic, the main topic, but clear, but elements discussed address the topic and the
INTRODUCTION
introduces the topic and and elements discussed elements discussed are are inadequate. elements discussed. /5x5
(5)
clearly addresses all are adequately. inadequate.
elements discussed =
perfectly.
Explores a complex Explores some depth Shows an effort to explores May lack focus or Shows lacks focus and
idea thoughtfully and in and complexity of ideas. May treat the idea demonstrate confused or coherence and may fail to
depth. thought. simplistically. simplistic thinking. communicate the idea.
CONTENT
Purely own words OR 50% of assignment is 70% of assignment is copy 90% of assignment is copy 100% of assignment is /5x30
ANALYSIS
REPHRASED from the copy paste from the paste from the referred paste directly from the copy paste from the
(30)
referred sources; <10% referred sources; <30% sources; >30% similarity referred sources; >50% referred sources e.g. =
similarity similarity. similarity underline, italic fonts,
color, page, etc. not
removed.
Demonstrates a Demonstrates an Demonstrates some Demonstrates poor Demonstrates very poor
DISCUSSION thorough critical accurate understanding. understanding. understanding. understanding.
(35) understanding. /5x35

=
Is coherently organized Is adequately organized Is satisfactorily organized Is poorly organized and Has very weak
and developed and developed. and developed developed. organization and
ORGANIZATION development, lacks ideas /5x15
(15) without any support or
justifications. =
The conclusion is strong The conclusion is The conclusion is logical The conclusion is lack of The conclusion is illogical
CONCLUSION and logical as well as logical and adequately but does not summarize logical and does not and does not summarize
(10) provides clear summary summarizes the topic. the topic. summarize the topic. the topic. /5x10
of the topic.
=
Sources used Sources used Sources used Sources used Sources used
(books,journals, (books,journals, (books,journals, magazines (books,journals, magazines (books,journals,
magazines and magazines and and newspaper etc) are not and newspaper etc) are not magazines and
REFERENCES
newspaper etc) are well newspaper etc) are really well cited and lack of well cited and no variety. newspaper etc) are poorly
(5)
cited. No mistake in cited. Minor mistake in variety. Many mistakes in Some materials are cited. All the references /5x5
citing the sources. citing the sources. Most citing the sources. misquoted or out of context. are not according to APA
All references are of references are Half of references are Most of references are not style. =
according to APA style. according to APA style according to APA style. according to APA style.
GRAND TOTAL /100