Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ajaegbo African Historiographical Traditions
Ajaegbo African Historiographical Traditions
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Transafrican Journal of
History
Introduction
The peoples of Africa, like all other peoples of the world, had a long tradition
history, the African was deeply conscious of his past and often felt the need t
give meaning and significance to this past. To him, the past activities an
experiences of man could largely influence his present and future actions in th
society. African cosmology, for instance, upheld strong belief in the communi
of the gods, the dead, the living and generations yet unborn. The gods and the
ancestors were highly reverred and harmonious relationship with them w
fostered through elaborate ritual ceremonies. Their influence on the liv
became even more evident and important as their spirits and memories w
invoked from generation to generation. Thus African historical consciousn
recognised continuity and change, order and purpose within the framework of
man and his environment man and the gods, man and his ancestors.1
Owing to the peoples' consciousness of the past and their concern for th
relevance of this past for the present and future, they originally tried to preser
some of their historical traditions jn oraj forms. After the invention of writing in
the continent about 3000 B.C., these traditions began to be recorded. African
traditional historiography was subsequently intluenced by other traditions of
written historiography from the Middle East and the Western world. The Second
World War (1939 - 1945) marked a watershed in African historical writing. This
paper is essentially a study of the emergence and development of
historiographical traditions in Africa up to 1945. It also seeks to assess the impact
of the interaction of all the various traditions and influences on historical
scholarship in the continent up to the Second World War.
Oral Tradition
Betöre the advent of written culture, African societies had developed a
tradition of history and culture. Oral tradition was employed to explai
origins of communities, their culture, why things happened the way they did
the relationship between the communities, the ancestors and the gods. Acco
to Dike and Ajayi, 'tradition was part of the philosophy of the community,
of its own peculiar way of life '.2 These various traditions of origin and ways o
were transmitted from one generation to another in the process of whic
people developed a consciousness of the past. Oral tradition was therefor
earliest method of recording and transmitting oral history. This source of his
in the words of David Henige, is:
the recollection of the more distant past that has been transmitted
several generations and has become more or less the commçm property
society. In order for anything to be regarded as a tradition, it shou
widely practised or understood in a society and it must have been hand
down for at least a few generations.3
Professor Allagoa has added that oral tradition also refers to aspects of mate
and symbolic culture transmitted informally and unconsciously.4 The ty
oral traditions include myths, songs, proverbs, legends, riddles, poetry,
and oral history.
The transmission of oral history was usually executed by kings, pri
diviners, elders and men of intelligence generally. Such transmission usually
place during ritual ceremonies, festivals, title-taking, puberty and marriage r
initiation into secret societies or age-groups, story-telling sessions and festi
the full moon when people stayed up late. These were occasions when memb
of a kin-group came together for entertainment, to spell out the boun
acceptable behaviour in the social, political and economic life of the commun
or to reaffirm their relationship with the sacrèd realm. The king, for insta
was regarded as the intermediary between the ancestors and the living. He w
considered a symbol, the centre around which the society turns;
140
The myth relates a sacred history, that is, a primordial event that took place
at the beginning of time, ab initio. But to relate a sacred history is equivalent
to revealing a mystery, for the persons of the myth are not human beings;
they are gods or culture heroes, and for this reason their gesta constitute
mysteries; man could not know their acts if they were not revealed to him.
The myth, then, is the history of what took place in illo tempore, the recital of
what the gods or the semi-divine beings did at the beginning of time. To tell
a myth is to proclaim what happened ab origine. Once told, that is, revealed,
the myth becomes apodictic truth; it establishes a truth that is absolute.9
141
riddles, poems and music. They were therefore preserved in fixed forms and
could also be chanted, sung, spoken or drummed during rituals, family
discussions, dancing sessions, festivals and other ceremonial occasions. For
instance, the griots of the western Sudan recount their traditions to the
accompainment of the balafon while the Igbo of Nigeria used various musical
instruments such as the ubo (thumb piano) igba (drum) and oja (flute) to recreate
their past.10
Monuments and statues were also established to ensure ancestor worship and
preserve knowledge of the past. These constitute some aspects of material and
symbolic culture which, as we have earlier noted, could be transmitted informally
and unconsciously. Among the Niger Delta people of Nigeria, for instance,
Professor Allagoa observed that:
There were special buildings erected to the memory of rulers and founders
or lineages in which memorabilia were kept and libations poured. In some
cases, priests were appointed. Such practices served the purposes of
museums in other societies and preserved knowledge of the past."
It is thus clear that African communities had a rich fund of oral traditions. The
oral categories are interwoven and each of the genre in some way nourishes the
other. They contain much historical value and when carefully used, can yield
abundant and reliable data for the reconstruction of African history. Even during
the Classical Age, scholars made use of oral evidence in writing histories. For
instance, Herodotus (C.484-425 B.C.) who has been dubbed the 'father of
history', wrote historical works based on oral testimonies.
Wrote Daniel F. McCall;
I went as faT as Elephantine (Aswan) to see what I could with my own eyes,
but for the country still further south I had to be content with what I was
tola in answer to my questions.13
Mnemonic devices, shrines and grave sites, the commitment of the community to
integrity, the sanction imposed by tradition, custom and community law, social
and political institutions and formal ceremonies — all contributed greatly
towards guaranteeing continuity as well as preserving the essential ingredients of
oral traditions.
142
143
used system of writing called the nsibidi. The nsibidi took the form of formalized
pictograms and it was not only a written script but also a closely guarded secret
language used in recording the activities and mysteries of various secret societies.
Initiation rituals into such secret societies as the Ekpe, among the Cross River
peoples, was conducted through the medium of the nsibidi language. Admission
involved careful instruction in and mastery of the challenging signs of the
language and members identified themselves by making these signs with their
fingers, head movements and other body gestures. A non-initiate was
intimidated and exposed by the mysterious talks and questions from the initiates.
The nsibidi language was originally a secret language of secret societies. It later
served as an identity labél, public notice, private warning, declaration of taboos,
amorous messages, recording of goods and money, keeping of records and
decorations.19 Rev. J.K. Macgregor, the missionary from whom we have the
earliest and best account of nsibidi recorded ninety-eight signs of the language.
He also observed that the writing served a variety of functions including
recording the proceedings of a court. According to him;
Although the nsibidi was not as developed as the Roman, Arabic or Chinese
scripts, it played a vital communication role in the political, economic and socio
cultural life of the Igbo and their Cross River neighbours.
The period of early Christianity in Africa marked another important stage of
historical writing. In Egypt, the bishops and monks of Alexandria made notable
contributions towards the recording of contemporary history. In about 547 A.D.,
for instance, an Alexandrian monk called Cosmas Indicopleustes wrote The
Christian Topography of Cosmas, an Egyptian Monk. Cosmas Indicopleustes had been
a merchant in the Mediterranean, Red Sea and the Indian Ocean, hence his
name of Cosmas Indicopleustes.
Christian scholarship reached its pinnacle of glory in the work of Saint
Augustine of Hippo (354 - 430 A.D.) titled De Civitate Dei (The City of God). In
this book, Saint Augustine saw the church as the visible kingdom of God in
contradistinction to the earthly city symbolized by historic states and empires. It
was also a treatise on man's nature and destiny, an evaluation of government and
society, a critique of traditional religion and philosophy and an exposition of
christian philosophy of history and religion. St. Augustine's other works included
144
The Confessions, On Rebuke and Grace and On the Trinity.21 St Augustine's excellent
exhibition in all his works of the enviable qualities of intellectual ardour and
power, capacity for original and independent thought and his sound exposition of
religious and philosophical ideas greatly influenced his successors and the later
religious thought of Latin Christendom. In the apt words of Professor W.G. De
Burgh;
Both during the Middle Ages and at the epoch of reformation, St.
Augustine's writings were the mine wherein theologians, both Caltholic
and Protestant, delved for gold. No other of the Fathers left so deep and
enduring an impression on the fabric of Christian thought. This was
due. . . to his learning, his power of exposition, his wide range of
intellectual interests, and, above all, to the distinctive impress of his many
sided personality.22
The development of the Indian Ocean trade between the Arabian peninsul
and the East African Coast, and of the western Sudan led to t
Islamization of local societies in both regions, to the increasing use
Arabic as the language of a growing educated class, and ultimately to
appearance of written Histories.24
145
The Negroes (the people of Mali) are seldom unjust, and have a greater
abhorrence of injustice than any other people. Their Sultan shows no
mercy to anyone guilty of the least act of it. There is complete security in
their country. Neither traveller nor inhabitant in it has anything to fear
from robbers or men of violence.25
Ibn Khaldum (1332 - 1406) was also a great Arab historian and philosopher
from a country now called Tunisia. He wrote extensively about Africa and his
monumental History of the Berbers has given us a lot of information about the early
Arab and Berber history in North Africa. He also recorded that Mansa Musa of
Mali (1312 - 1337) established diplomatic relations and exchanged gifts with the
contemporary king of Morocco, Sultan Abu Al-Hassan, and 'that high ranking
statesmen of the two kingdoms were exchanged as ambassadors'.2f> In his book,
the Muqaddimah or Introduction, he made his most original contribution to general
historiography and sociology. In the words of Dike and Ajayi;
He sought to study the past not only in terms of the actions of individuals
but also by an analysis of the laws, customs, and institutions of the different
peoples as well as the interaction of the state land society.27
With the coming of Islam to Africa south of the Sahara, muslim centres of
learning sprang up in places like Timbuktu, Gao, Jenne, Kano, Katsina, Borno
and Kilwa. These centres of learning produced a number of scholars, tarikhs and
chronicles. The Sankore University flourished at Timbuktu and produced two
great historians, Mahmoud Kati and Abderrahman as Sadi who wrote the
Ta 'rikh at-Fattash (chronicle of the Searcher) and the Ta 'rikh as-Sudan (chronicle
of the land of the Sudan) respectively. These two works are still in use and on
them do we rely for the reconstruction of the history of Songhai in particular and
the Western Sudan in general. The Kano Chronicle of the Central Sudan and the
Kilwa Chronicle of the East African Coast were outstanding works which contained
a lot of oral traditions collected from the Islamic scholars and people of the
Central Sudan and the Swahili coast.
Finally, we may mention Ahmad ibn Fartuwa, the Borno historian who
compiled accounts of the wars and achievements of the greatest king of the
Kanem-Borno empire, Mai Idris Alooma (1571 - 1603). Another Borno
historian, Muhammed Salih ibn Isharku, wrote a history of Ngazargamo, the
capital city of Kanem-Borno empire in 1658. The leader of the Sokoto Jihad,
Uthman dan Fodio, his brother Abdullahi dan Fodio and his son Mohammed
Bello together made up the triumvirate responsible for the great resurgence of
Arabic literary activity in Hausaland of modern Nigeria in the early nineteenth
century. They were well versed in classical Islamic sciences, including theology,
law, exegesis, mysticism, grammar and literature. This learning manifested itself
146
m their writings which reached a total of two hundred and sixty-seven books and
pamphlets.28 There is no doubt that Islamic scholarship contributed immensely to
the development of African historiography.
In 1668, for instance, the Dutch geographer, Olfert Dapper, published his
travellogues on Africa. John Barbot and William Bosman were Dutch trading
agents who wrote extensively on Africa. Many other literary Europeans like
Heinrich Barth, Hugh Clapperton, Rene Caille, David Livingston, Friedrich
Hegel, Lord Lugard, Reginald Coupland, Arnold Toynbee, etc were either
explorers, missionaries, scholars or administrators who wrote travellogues and
works of historical and general ethnographic descriptions about Africa. These
works had greatly influenced African historiography.
Although Western historiography made a tremendous impact on African
historiography, it must be emphasized at once that most of the late nineteenth
147
and twentieth western historians did not build on the historical traditions of the
African peoples. These scholars equated history with written records and
therefore concluded that Africa had no past worthy of record. Hegel, for
instance, advanced the view that Africa was no 'historical part of the world' while
the late Sir Reginald Coupland affirmed that up to the middle of the nineteenth
century 'the main body of Africans had had no history, but had stayed for untold
centuries sunk in barbarism. . .'3I. Professor Trevor-Roper in attempting to scale
down the importance of African history notoriously asserted that:
Maybe in the future there will be some African history, but at the moment
there is none. . . . There is only the history of Europeans in Africa. . . The
rest is darkness, and darkness is not a subject of history.32
14«
The history of A fricarTh is tonography from the earliest times to 1945 was a
Analysis: you’re
history of the interaction of the various historical traditions of the period.
lookingTheat the
relevant
root of historical consciousness in all parts of Africa throughout this period had
information.
been the oral traditions. African written traditions began in Egypt about 3000
what is it saying?
B.C. and Egyptian and north African scholars from Manetho to St. Augustine
and Ibn'Khaldun wrote for the whole civilized world of their time. African
Devaluing and
historiography was further developed with the introduction of Islam indismissing
Africa it asand
the concomitant rise and flowering of Islamic literary tradition in something
the that is
continent.
unimportant
A lot of literature poured out from Islamic scholars, preachers and jihadists.
African indigenous histoiography was subsequently influenced by the western
tradition. The western historians sought to destroy oral tradition which was the
root of Africa's historical consciousness. When they failed, they neglected it.
The emergence of a new class of indigenous African professional historians
following the end of the Second World War led to the adoption of a new
orientation to the study of African history. Oral tradition was accepted as a valid
material for historical reconstruction. Its special problems were appreciated but
these had to be solved not only through a rigorous and scientific method of
collecting, sifting, analysing and synthesizing oral data and supplementing them
with written records but also through interdisciplinary research. The
decolonization of African history, the documentation of an authentic Africa past
Devaluing
historiography was a 149
When contextualising, refer to the works of Franz fenon(he talks
The highlighted parts are
part of the colonial about how history is dustroreted and ereased as a way of devlauaing
the explainers of the
agenda precolonial past so that we can make way for colonial rule) and
objectives
Richard reid
and the use of the positive experiences of this past to build truely independent
African states constitute the highest aims of the new African historiography.
D.I. Ajaegbo is currently with the Department of History, College of Education, Nsugbe, P.M.B.
1734, Onitsha, Anambra State, Nigeria.
Notes
1. Olaniyan, Richard (1982) 'African History and Culture: An Overview', in African History and
Culture, ed. Richard Olaniyan, London: Longman, p. 2.
2. Dike, K.O. and Ajayi, J.F.A. (1968) 'African Historiography,' in International Encyclopaedia of the
Social Sciences, Vols. 5 & 6, ed. David L Sills, USA: The Macmillan Co. and the Free Press of
Glencoe, p. 395.
3. Henige, David Oral Historiography, London: Longmans, 1982 p. 106, p. 2.
Miller, J.C. (1980) The African Past Speaks: Essay on Oral Tradition and History, England: Dawson
and Archon Ltd., p. 2.
4. Allagoa, E J. (1984) 'Towards a History of African Historiography', being a paper presented at
the 30th Annual Congress of the Historical Society of Nigeria, University of Nigeria, Nsukka
(March 26 - 29, 1984), p. 7.
5. Eliade, M. (1963) Aspects du Mythe Paris: Gallimard, p. 54.
6. Dike and Ajayi, op. cit., p. 396.
7. See for example the view of Lowie, R.H. (1915) 'Oral Tradition and History', in American
Anthropologist, 17, p. 598.
Eliade, Mircea (1959), The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion, New York: Harcourt,
Brace & World, Inc., *959 nn. 107 - 110.
9. ibid, p. 95. See also, Phillips Stevens, Jr. 'The Uses of Oral Traditions in the Writing of African
History' in Tarikh, Vol. 6 No. 1 (eds) Asiwaju & Crowder, London: Longman, 1978, pp.
21-25.
10. Echezona, W.W.C. 'Ibo Music' in Nigeria Magazine No. 84 (March 1965), pp. 45
Lo-Bamijoko, Joy Nwosu (1983) Classification of Igbo Musical Instruments' in Nig
No. 144, pp. 38-58.
Edwards, Paul, (1980) (ed.) Equiano's Trqvels, London: Heinemann, pp. 3-4.
11. Allagoa, E.J. ( 1972) ^4 Short History of the Niger Delta, Ibadan: Ibadan University Pr
12. McCall, Daniel F. (1969) African in Time-Perspective: A Discussion of Historical Recons
Unwritten Souces New York: OUP, p. 4.
13. Davidson, Basil (1966) The African Past: Chronicles from Antiquity to Modern Times,
Penguin Books Ltd., p. 63. See also David Henige, op. cit., pp. 7-8.
14. Durant, Will (1954) The Story of Civilization, (New York: Simon and Schuster, p. 1
15. ibid, p. 178.
16. de Burgh, W.G. (1961) The Legacy oj the Ancient World Harmondsworth: Penguin
17.
17. Burn, A.R. & de Selincourt, Aubrey (1972) Herodotus: The Histories Harmondsworth: Penguin
Books Ltd., p. 187.
18. de Burgh, op. cit., p. 17.
19. Kalu, O.U. (1978) 'Writing in Pre-colonial Africa: A Case Study of Nsibidi' in Afriran Culture
150
Crowder, Michael (1973) West Africa Under Colonial Rule London: Hutchinson, Chapter 4, pp.
482 - 507.
Hahn, Lorna (1954) North Africa: Nationalism to Nationhood Washington: Public Affairs Press.
Rotberg, R.I. (1966) The Rise of Nationalism in Central Africa (Oxford: University Press.
Mcwewan, P.J.M. (ed.)(1968) Twentieth Century Africa Oxford: University Press.
151