Impact of Financial Stress On Working Students' Academic Performance

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 33

Republic of the Philippines

Department of Education
Region IV-A CALABARZON
Division of Rizal

VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.


J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN,
RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

IMPACT OF FINANCIAL STRESS ON THE ACADEMIC


PERFORMANCE OF GRADE 11 WORKING
STUDENTS OF VALLEY HIGH
ACADEMY

A Research Study Presented and Submitted


to theFaculty of the Senior High School
Department of Valley High Academy
Inc., Rodriguez, Rizal. In Partial
Fulfillment of the Requirements
in Research in Daily Life 1.

DAGARAT, NELISA ROSE B.


DANDAN, JENREE T.
RABAGO, AHRON L.
MANUEL, YUMI ANNE R.
LAGUILLES, GABRIEL A.
SALINAS, SHYREN R.
RAMOS, STEFANNY JANE B.

Researchers

STEM 11-H
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

APPROVAL SHEET

This research titled IMPACT OF FINANCIAL STRESS ON THE


ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF GRADE 11 WORKING STUDENTS OF
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY prepared and submitted by Dagarat, Nelisa Rose B.,
Dandan, Jenree T., Rabago, Ahron L., Manuel, Yumi Anne R., Laguilles, Gabriel A.,
Salinas, Shyren R., Ramos, Stefanny Jane B. In partial fulfillment of the SeniorHigh
School requirements in Valley High Academy, Inc. the subject Research in Daily
Life 1’s has been examined and is recommended for approval and acceptance.

MR. JOED A. ALAGAO, LPT


Research in Daily Life 1 Teacher

Approved for the subject of Research in Daily Life 1’s by the committee
on oral examination onJune , 2023 with grade of .

Member Member

Chairman

Accepted and approved in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the


subject of PR1.

DR. MARK G. FABELLA, PhD


Principal
MS. REGINA S. QUIMNO, LPT., CLSSYB
Associate Principal

ii
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The following people provided significant assistance and input to the


researchers in the creation of this paper. We wish to extend our gratitude for the
success of the completion of this study.

We, the researchers, express our deep sense of gratitude to the School
President of Valley High Academy, Mrs. Iluminada S. Quimno, who willingly
allowed us to conduct this study to achieve its smooth completion.

To Ms. Regina S. Quimno, LPT., CLSSYB, our Senior High School


Associate Principal for her empathy, patience, and knowledge that she imparts
unto us.

To Mrs. Christine M. Sunga, LPT., our Thesis Adviser for all of her help,
patience, and support.

To Mr. Joed A. Alagao, LPT., our Research in Daily Life Adviser for his
generous help, assistance, information, expertise, and efforts in reviewing this
manuscript andproviding suggestions to further our work. We will not be able to
complete the paper without them. They provided important comments,
oversight, and input that served as the study’s foundation.

Participants, for spending their important time, and effort to complete


the survey. They gave us the information we requested for the study.

Above all, we are grateful to our Heavenly Creator for granting the
researchers the courage, fortitude, and enlightenment necessary to complete
this research study.

iii
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

DEDICATION

We deeply and wholeheartedly dedicate this research to our families,


especially our loving parents who gave us all the courage and support to make
this research possible. Who continually provided and cheered us on, physically,
morally, mentally, emotionally, and financially.

To our friends and partners who did nothing but support us.

To all the Grade 11 Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics


(STEM) Students and beyond.

To our classmates in STEM 11-H and our class adviser, Mr. Emmanuel
M. Magno.

To our thesis adviser, Mrs. Christine M. Sunga, for providing us with


guidance and feedback that further improve our research paper.

To all the teachers and staff of the Valley High Academy, particularly our
Research in Daily Life Adviser, Mr. Joed A. Alagao for the fatherly love and
support he showed throughout our research.

To our beloved school, Valley High Academy, Inc. who provided us


with education that we can use in the future.

And most of all, to our Almighty God, we thank you for the guidance,
strength, and life that you gave us. All of these, we offer to you.

iv
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

ABSTRACT

Managing finances is particularly challenging in the Philippines, where

half of Filipino families consider themselves poor. This drives several

households into financial stress, which then trickles down to the children,

compelling them to work. However, juggling their employment and academics

would eventually affect their academic performance. Hence, this study is

conducted particularly to focus on the various impacts of financial stress on

working students’ academic performance. This is conducted at Valley High

Academy, Inc., during the school year 2022-2023. Ten participants were

selected among the Grade 11 working students using a purposive sampling

technique based on the pre-screening interview. This study employed a

qualitative design and a phenomenological approach. The lived experiences of

the participants were used to determine whether the academic impacts of

financial stress are beneficial or detrimental to the performance of the Grade

11 working students at Valley High Academy.

Keywords: financial stress, financial problems, academic performance,

working students, coping strategies, negative impacts, positive impacts

v
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Title Page

Acknowledgement……………..………………………………………... ii

Dedication……...………………………………………………………… iii

Abstract…………………………………………………………….......... iv

I. INTRODUCTION………………………………………………… 1

Background of the Study.………………………………. 2

Statement of the Problem...………….…………………. 3

Research Assumption.….…….…………………….…… 4

Scope and Delimitations of the Study……...……...……. 4

Significance of the Study…………………………... …... 5

Definitions of Terms……………………………………… 5

Theoretical Framework………………………….……... 6

II. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES……… 9

Foreign Literature………………………………………… 9

Local Literature…………………………………………… 11

Foreign Studies…………………………………………… 13

Local Studies ……………………………………………… 15

Synthesis…………………………………………………… 17

vi
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

III. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY……….………………………... 18

Research Design ………………………………………… 18

Population and Sampling Procedure…………………… 18

Data Gathering Procedure ……………………………… 19

IV. BIBLIOGRAPHY…………………………………………………. 21

References……………………………………….……….. 21

vii
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Chapter 1

THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND

This chapter contains a brief introduction, following the background of

the study, the statement of the problem, the research assumption, the

significance of the study, the scope and limitations, the operational definition of

terms, and the theoretical framework of the study.

Introduction

A study by Harvard, Princeton, and Warwick University discovered that

financial difficulties directly influence an individual’s cognitive ability. More

intriguingly, the scientists found a correlation between poverty and low cognitive

ability and concluded that financial stress influences the disparity in IQ between

a low-income individual and a high-income individual. (Medina, 2013)

Financial stress can be defined as a state of anxiety regarding a money

shortage that is a result of the inability to pay financial obligations. This could

lead to depressive symptoms such as insomnia, loss of appetite, lack of

presence of mind, isolation, suicidal attempts and/or thoughts, and many more.

It is a common stressor and, therefore, can be experienced by everyone.

However, it is most prevalent among those below the poverty line.

In the Philippines, where 51 percent of families consider themselves

poor and 30 percent consider themselves borderline poor (Pinlac, 2023),

financial difficulties inevitably drive low-income families into financial stress.

1
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Unfortunately, when it comes to finances, adults are not the only ones that are

affected. The study by Iqbal, N., Iqbal, S., Nadeem, Perveen, and Malik (2022)

has proved that the financial stress of families trickles down to their children

and similarly affects them. The researchers believe this to be true, particularly

for working students since it is impossible to rely solely on the patriarchs for

income when living in poverty. According to Widener (2017), there are two ways

in which a financial problem could have a detrimental impact on the student's

academic performance which are health problems and the need to engage in

employment. To overcome financial problems, most students opt to work part-

time and even work long hours. Thereby, taking away their time to concentrate

on their academics and putting their academic grades at risk.

On the other hand, numerous papers suggest that working students who

know efficient methods of managing financial stress would experience a

different and most likely positive impact of financial stress. Moreover, several

studies have discovered a beneficial aspect of stress, wherein it inspires

individuals rather than detrimentally influences their lives. Assuming all working

students can manipulate the impact of financial stress to their benefit, juggling

school and work may not be entirely negative. This prospect could lead them

toward success in both their professional and academic pursuits.

Background of the Study

According to a Social Weather Stations (SWS) survey, 27 percent of the

population, experiences stress regularly, with financial issues as the

2
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

predominant stressor. The aforementioned survey shows that stress is common

among people between the ages of 18 and 24, which is primarily students

(Culili, Mercado, Sabila, and Cu Chiam, 2021). Consequently, the number of

working students in the country continues to increase. As a matter of fact,

according to the Commission on Higher Education (CHED), approximately

216,000 students in the country are currently juggling school and work. (Galleto,

2022)

Working demands time and effort from students, so a problem arises

when it is time for the students to attend school since fatigue from work might

affect their concentration and performance in their academics. Along with the

constant anxiety regarding their financial obligations at home and school.

Furthermore, financial stress influences the students’ perspective on life, and

they tend to place grave importance on money. This could affect their priorities

and put working over their academics. Which might result in poor grades and

poor academic success.

Previous studies that were equally concerned about the financial stress

of students provided the factors and root causes. Nevertheless, there is a lack

of perspective from a working student suffering from financial stress. Which is

already difficult to experience, yet, working students have the added burden of

earning an income. Hence, the researchers believe that there is a need for

further study to better understand the impact of financial stress on academic

performance with working students as the primary subject.

3
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Statement of the Problem

This study aims to determine the impact of financial stress on the

academic performance of Grade 11 working students at Valley High Academy.

Specifically, this seeks answers to the following questions:

1. What are the positive impacts of financial stress on working students’

academic performance?

2. What are the negative impacts of financial stress on working students’

academic performance?

3. What is the leading impact of financial stress on working students?

4. What are the challenges encountered by working students?

5. What could increase the academic success of working students?

Research Assumption

In this study, the assumption was made that there are financially

stressed Grade 11 working students at Valley High Academy whose financial

stress impacts their academic performance. These impacts differ from person

to person; however, it is further assumed that those without a strategy to

mitigate the impact are bound to have poor academic performance, which

results in lower grades. Additionally, their pressing financial difficulties can also

lead to health problems, which can also lead to poor academic performance.

4
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Scope and Delimitations of the Study

The general intent of this research is to determine the impact of financial

stress on the academic performance of working students including their

productivity and concentration. Moreover, the study briefly covers the well-

being of the working student for it directly impacts their focus during class.

The primary subjects of this research will be the Grade 11 students

enrolled in the academic year 2022-2023. The participants will be limited to 5-

10 Grade 11 students of Valley High Academy at Rizal St. Manggahan,

Rodriguez, Rizal.

This study does not consider aspects of students' personal information

such as their parent’s educational background and their household’s annual

income. The purpose of this study is simply to find out how financial stress

affects students' academic performance and how they deal with it.

Significance of the Study

The study aims to know the impact of financial stress on the academic

performance of Grade 11 working students. This study may help the following

people:

Working students. This would help working students be aware of the

detrimental impacts of financial stress and the importance of having the right

coping strategy.

Parents and Guardians. This provides the challenges their children

5
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

face, enabling them to offer more effective guidance.

Future researchers. This provides them with the perspective of a

working student suffering from financial stress and how it affects their academic

success.

Definition of Terms

The following terms are conceptually and/or operationally defined for a

better understanding of this study.

Academic success is the outcome of a working student’s performance.

Coping strategy refers to strategies or tactics that help students to

lessen their financial stress or problems.

Working student or student refers to a Grade 11 that studies at Valley

High Academy and has a job outside school.

Theoretical Framework

To account for individual differences in the stress response, this study

was anchored on Lazarus and Folkman’s Transactional Model of Stress and

Coping (TSC), published in 1984. This theory was created to help individuals

better understand how stress affects their physical and psychological well-being

and how they cope with stressors or stressful events. The relevance of this

theory to the study lies in the fact that it explains and highlights the complexity

and importance of a comprehensive understanding of stress. The theory

classified stressful circumstances into two types: challenging and threatening.


6
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Challenging circumstances are those that are considered to provide an

opportunity for improvement, proficiency, and benefit (for example, excelling in

an exam). Threatening circumstances are those that are considered to have the

potential for damage or loss (for example, underperforming in an exam)

(Putwain et al., 2021). This demonstrates that the impact of stress depends on

the cognitive judgments of the meaning of a situation and the response of an

individual. Moreover, it suggests that financial stress can directly affect an

individual's cognitive functioning, which is relevant to our research

Furthermore, to better understand the influence of employment on a

student’s academics, the study is based on a more relevant theory cited in the

study by Buendicho et al. (2022) which is John von Neumann’s theory of the

zero-sum game. It was stated that Warren et al. (2007) used the

aforementioned theory in their investigation of the correlation between a

student’s employment and academic outcome. Originally, a zero-sum game is

when an individual’s gain is equivalent to their counterpart’s loss. This is

relevant to the study since a working student’s time is divided and it is safe to

say that there is a different persona at work and school, thus, it cannot be

avoided when there are instances wherein, they would have to prioritize one

and sacrifice the other. Doing well in academics might have an impact on their

efficiency as a worker. Meanwhile, working long work hours to gain more

income would have an impact on their academic performance.

Buendicho et al. further presented the alternative theory of Warren

7
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

(2007) which is the Primary Orientation Model that is devised due to criticisms

regarding zero-sum. It was stated that students who are primarily focused on

academics tend to perform well in school, regardless of their effort, whereas

students who prioritize employment struggle in school since it is only of

secondary importance to them.

The concepts of the Zero-Sum theory and the Primary Focus Model

demonstrate the circumstances of a working student and how it may potentially

affect their academic performance. The transactional model of Stress and

Coping is useful in assessing the impacts of financial stress since the way each

person responds to stress differs, thus proving that stress can trigger different

results depending on the person going through it. The present study will

examine the accuracy of these theories in relation to the diverse impacts of

financial stress on the academic performance of working students.

8
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Chapter 2

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURES AND STUDIES

This chapter presents the literature and studies relevant to the present

study. This analyzes both foreign and local materials from the internet to provide

sufficient background and information essential for the validity of this study. It

also includes the synthesis of the related literature and studies.

Foreign Literature

According to Mind (2022), in the article titled “What Is Stress?”. Stress

is an individual’s mental response when faced with situations over which they

have little to no control. It can be experienced as an individual, part of a group

or community, and as a society. In individuals, the usual cause of stress is

overwhelming obligations that they struggle to manage. There are occasions

when stress motivates an individual to be productive as it made them feel

energized. However, stress becomes a problem when it persists for a long time

and/or is severe. In certain instances, it detrimentally impacts the physical and

mental well-being of an individual.

The term “stress” has often been associated with an unhealthy outcome

of an experience. However, Rudland (2019), in the article “The Stress Paradox:

How stress can be good for learning” explicitly stated that the idea of stress

being detrimental to learning is a myth. Rudland identified two types of stress:

eustress and distress. Wherein the term “eustress” is said to be a positive

response and is beneficial (Selye, 1974, as cited by Rudland), while the term
9
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

“distress” represents a negative response with detrimental impacts. It was

emphasized that eustress and distress are two different responses to a

stressor. Therefore, stress could evoke various responses and outcomes in the

individual experiencing it. Furthermore, in the journal titled “From Vulnerability

to Growth: Positive and Negative Effects of Stressful Life Events”, Updegraff

and Taylor (2021) examined the reported positive outcomes from stressful

circumstances. It was found that severely stressful circumstances have a

detrimental impact; however, they also become an opportunity for other

individuals to transform their lives for the better.

There is ample evidence that stress does not equate to distress. In the

context of financial stress, which has been the most prevalent over the past

couple of years (Bennet, 2022), that is also the case.

An article by Indeed (2022) titled “8 Important Benefits of Working While

You're a Student” argues that working while studying gives students an

advantage. The author believes this counterintuitively improves students'

grades since their situation provides them with an opportunity to develop their

time management and organizational skills. This helps the students build better

study habits that allow them to work on their learning outputs despite only

having a short amount of time. Moreover, working students are technically

receiving paid hands-on training, which furthers their academic and

professional growth since they could utilize the concepts and information

gained inside the classroom on their jobs, and vice versa.

10
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

However, numerous official works of literature have found financial

stress to be associated with detrimental impacts on students’ academic

performance. According to an article by iGrad Financial Wellness (2022), a

finding from an Ohio State survey found that 32 percent of students who

experience financial stress tend to disregard their academic pursuits. The

findings show financial stress affects working students to the degree of a

change in priorities. As a result, their grades will suffer due to the lack of

engagement shown in their academic record. Perman (2019) further supported

this by citing that according to the Georgetown University Center on Education

and the Workforce, 59 percent of working students achieved a C-average in

school, or even less, for a job of 15 hours or more.

This implies that financial stress puts working students at a

disadvantage in school. According to Norazlan et al. (2020), affluent students

perform better in school than students from lower-income families. The

academic gap is due to the latter facing various challenges, including

insufficient educational resources, the inability to fulfill financial obligations in

school, an unstimulating academic environment, and a lack of concentration.

Whereas students from higher-income families are given more privileges and

are unfamiliar with the aforementioned situations. Which allows them to focus

on their academics, thus, climbing up the

Local Literature

ABS-CBN News (2010) reported the latest data from the Commission

11
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

on Higher Education (CHED) regarding working students. Apart from the usual

on-campus work of a working student, they are now commonly found in other

industries, particularly food, entertainment, and sales. With that being said, the

reported reason for this is due to the increasing prices of school expenses.

Among the 216,000 working students in the Philippines, CHED reported that

only half are able to finish college. While the other half are hindered by the

inability to cope and concentrate on their academics. The article highlighted

that balancing work and academics puts too much pressure on working

students.

According to the journal by Villahermosa et al. titled "Working Scholars:

Life as a Worker and an Academic Performer" (2015), working while studying

has various impacts on the student's academic performance. The authors

stated numerous benefits, such as becoming independent, responsible, more

confident, having adequate time-management skills, and satisfying their needs.

They added that these are advantages working students have against full-time

students, particularly their improved time-management skills, which instill the

importance of responsibility in students.

However, it was identified that the financial stress endured by working

students leads to substandard academic performance. This is due to the daily

lives of working students, who face financial problems that preoccupy their

thoughts. In the same journal, a statement by Charmaine (2014) was quoted:

"There are a lot of problems that have to be faced by the working students

12
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

without escapes. There are three major roles to be obligated: role as a student,

role as a worker, and role as human as per the life social issues". In situations

such as that, it is natural to feel pressured, which eventually adds to the level

of stress for working students.

Hence, the students used various coping strategies to manage their

financial stress, including seeking help from family and friends and cutting down

on expenses; however, these coping strategies had limitations and were not

always effective (Adajar et al., 2019). Therefore, Pasig City Representative

Roman Romulo advised the Commission on Higher Education (CHED) to

devise a “fast-acting financial aid program” for students who urgently require

support to cover their living and educational expenses. (Doyo, 2015).

Foreign Studies

Kyoshaba (2009) conducted a study to examine the factors influencing

the academic performance of college students at Uganda Christian University

(UCU). The findings revealed that the financial status of a student is an

important factor since it provides the psychological support necessary for good

academic success. The author emphasized that the execution of acquired

knowledge in exams, quizzes, and performance tasks is the key determinant of

a student's academic performance. These determinants enable the educational

institution to assess whether the students have learned. Therefore, a low grade

implies insufficient acquisition of knowledge.

Unfortunately, the thesis by Widener (2017) discovered that financially

13
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

stressed students had failing grades. The author stated that they are compelled

to work due to the burden of their financial problems. This further puts their

academic grades at risk, as their focus is divided between their jobs and

academics, which leads to poor academic performance. Nevertheless, they are

not able to quit their jobs because of their financial circumstances. Despite not

paying for household bills and daily necessities yet, there are still financial

obligations in schools, such as fees for tuition, exams, extracurriculars, books,

school projects, and a few more.

Working students' financial circumstances, according to Tesfaw and

Yitayih (2018), affect their dedication to learning, which, in turn, influences their

academic performance. The constant worry about money, debt, or financial

instability makes it difficult to remain motivated and focused on their studies.

Therefore, Usmam and Ameena (2019) recommend that students pursue

financial aid and scholarships to ease their financial burden and increase their

academic success. Additionally, students should also practice good financial

management skills such as budgeting and saving to avoid accumulating debt

and financial stress. This is somehow similar to a study by Britt et al. (2016)

who found that financial stress was not directly associated with academic

achievement, but was related to financial stressors, objective financial

knowledge, and financial resources. Therefore, seeking ways to improve their

financial situation would subsequently improve the student’s academic

performance.

14
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Local Studies

As mentioned in the study of Cayetano et al. (2022), several factors

affect academic success, and some of these may have a considerable impact

on students. A few individuals may excel and achieve great success, whereas

others may become mediocre.

Amaro et al. (2023) cited a study by a group of scholars at Harvard,

Princeton, and Warwick University (n.d.) that found financial problems have a

direct influence on an individual’s cognitive ability. Which is essential in

academics to comprehend, analyze, plan, and solve assigned tasks. Hence, it

is only natural that the academic performance of a student burdened with

financial problems is affected. The authors of the same study further analyzed

the long-term impacts of financial stress and found that the financial instability

of Filipino students was a hindrance to their future goals. Findings of the

Philippine Statistic Authority (2015) were cited, wherein 20 percent of Filipino

children were compelled to drop out due to the financial problems of their

families. With financial stress having the ability to impact a student’s personal

and academic lives to such an extent, it is no wonder that they turn to working

part-time and/or full-time to ease their financial problems.

Thus, Watanabe (2005), as cited by Abenoja et al. (2019), investigated

the impacts of employment on students' academic performance and presented

an unexpected discovery. The result of the study shows that the work of

students did not influence their academic performance. On the contrary, the

15
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

same study cited Pike in Lederman (2009), who found that work has a direct

impact on students' grades and indirectly affects their engagement in academic

activities. Working affects the grade of the students regardless of the type of

job; however, they emphasized that there is little difference between the grades

of working students and full-time students.

Buendicho et al. (2022) reason that, in contrast to pursuing full-time

studies, working while being a student is more helpful for developing skills.

Furthermore, financial stress encourages students to create a financial plan,

minimize expenses, improve their savings, and explore new financial

prospects. Overcoming financial stress leads to increased confidence and

independence, which inspires them to seek out new professional endeavors or

become entrepreneurs. Ultimately, the sense of self-accomplishment becomes

a newfound motivation for working students to study well.

However, those working students who are not able to adjust their

financial circumstances, according to Asuncion and Tullao (2018), can apply

for scholarship grants. Although many scholarships are aimed at high-

achieving high school students, there are programs particularly created for

working students, namely the Working Scholarship Program, the Working

Students and Financial Aid Program, the Unified Student Financial Assistance

System In Tertiary Education (UniFAST), and a lot more. These grants

acknowledge the difficulties experienced by working students and offer

financial assistance to enable them to continue their studies while juggling their

16
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

career obligations.

Synthesis

The reviewed literature and studies confirm that financial stress has an

impact on working students’ academic performance. More papers suggest that

financial stress can negatively impact the academic performance of students.

Since those who are financially stressed belong in poverty, they are burdened

with many responsibilities, not to mention their financial problems. Naturally,

their priority would shift from what should be their academics to finances.

This situation put the students at a disadvantage compared to their

classmates. As a result, there is an evident disparity between the academic

grades of students from low-income families and students from higher-income

families. Financially stressed students are compelled to work due to the burden

of their financial problems. This further puts their academic grades at risk, as

the division of focus leads to poor academic performance.

However, there are a few claims that financial stress might have led

working students to juggle work and academics; nonetheless, it eventually

became an advantage as it improved their academic performance. The reason

behind this is that the students are provided with a “paid opportunity” to improve

their soft skills while academics hone their hard skills. Ultimately, these papers

suggest that interventions to increase financial resources and knowledge and

reduce perceived stress may help mitigate this impact, which in turn would

improve academic outcomes.

17
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Chapter 3

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

This chapter explains various methodologies that were used in gathering

data that are relevant to the research. The methodologies include research

design, sampling procedure, and data-gathering procedure.

Research Design

The researchers used a qualitative design and a phenomenological

approach to collect the data for the study. The phenomenological approach

seeks to understand the overall nature of a phenomenon. Individuals with lived

experiences of the phenomenon are the source of data; therefore, this

approach provided the researchers with a genuine understanding of the

phenomenon. With this design, the present study can determine the diverse

academic impact of financial stress on the working student without any prior

assumptions or biases on the part of the researchers.

Population and Sampling Procedure

The participants of the study are the selected Grade 11 working students

enrolled at Valley High Academy. The researchers have sought ten (10) Grade

11 working students. The participants are limited to seventeen (17) years old

or older.

The sample from this study was selected through non-probability

sampling, wherein the samples are selected based on purpose. Purposive

sampling refers to a group of non-probability sampling techniques in which units


18
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

are selected because they have characteristics or experiences that are needed

in the sample. In other words, units are selected “on purpose” in purposive

sampling. The researchers used purposive sampling since it allowed them to

select participants who have specific experiences that are relevant to the

research question. This leads to a more focused and efficient data collection

process than trying to gather data from a random sample.

Data Gathering Procedure

This study used interviews as the primary data collection technique. By

conducting interviews with working grade 11 students at Valley High Academy,

the researcher aimed to gather valuable insights and form a conclusion based

on their data. Interviews provide in-depth understanding and allow for a detailed

exploration of participants' perspectives and experiences. The process of

conducting the interview is described in the narrative below.

First and foremost, the researchers asked for permission from the senior

high school principal of Valley High Academy Inc. to conduct the study. After

receiving approval, the researchers approached several sections of grade 11

students to determine whether there were any students that are currently

employed. When approaching the potential participants, we first briefed them

regarding the topic of the study and explained what would be expected of them.

The working students were asked a few questions that would help the

researchers determine whether they have experienced financial stress or not.

Then, when the participant quota was met, the researchers provided
19
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

each of them with an informed consent form discussing the purpose of the study

and their rights as participants. After signing the forms, the researchers

individually interviewed the participants during their free time to avoid

disturbances while purposefully not leading the participants to a specific

response.

Note that the questions that were asked to the participants have gone

through an examination and have been validated by the research and thesis

adviser to fix some errors and provide clarification before being given to the

participants. The questions were also made sure to be open-ended to generate

long responses from the participants. Moreover, the interviews focused on

factors influencing academic performance and the overall educational

experience.

After gathering data, the researchers collected it to classify whether it is

negative or positive and for a comprehensive understanding of the academic

impact of financial stress on working grade 11 students at Valley High

Academy.

20
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Bibliography

References:

5 Signs That Financial Stress Is Impacting College Students and How Financial

Wellness Can Help. (2019, November 25). iGrad Financial

Wellness. https://www.igradfinancialwellness.com/blog/five-signs-

financial-stress-is-impacting-college-students-how-financial-

wellness-helps

8 Important Benefits of Working While You’re a Student. (2022, August 17).

Indeed.com. https://www.indeed.com/career-advice/career-

development/working-student-benefits

ABS-CBN News. (2010, June 13). Only half of working students finish college:

CHED. ABS-CBN News. Retrieved July 1, 2023, from

https://news.abs-cbn.com/lifestyle/youth/06/13/10/only-half-

working-students-finish-college-ched

Abenoja, Accion, N., Aguilar, J., Alcasid, M., Amoguis, A., Buraquit, D., Mama,

A., Pacete, J., & Pame, J. (2019, March). The Experiences of

Working While Studying: A Phenomenological Study of Senior High

School Students.

Adajar, J. A., Cahucom, R. F., & Tolentino, L. R. (2019). Coping strategies of

senior high school students in response to financial stress. Journal

of Educational and Social Research, 9(3), 1-8.

21
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

Amaro, C. A., Bernabe, E. A., Centeno, B. K., Comendador , J. A., Dela Cruz,

J. F. B., Dela Cruz, K. F. A., & Sumalinog, K. S. (2023). The Impacts

of Financial Stress on the Academic Performance Among Senior

High Students in a Philippine University. Retrieved June 29, 2023,

from https://www.studocu.com/ph/document/national-university-

philippines/accountancy/group-6-final-paper/36460046

Asuncion, E. J. V., & Tullao Jr, T. S. (2018). Evaluation of Unified Student

Financial Assistance System In Tertiary Education (UniFAST) in

Addressing Capital Market Imperfection in the Philippines. Working

Paper Series 2018-02-049, Manila, Philippines: Angelo King

Institute for Economic and Business Studies, De La Salle University.

https://scholar.googleusercontent.com/scholar?q=cache:QjF7skvg

cJsJ:scholar.google.com/+students+financial+%2Bphilippines&hl=

en&as_sdt=0,5

Buendicho, J. C. M., Catalla, J. M. T., De Padua, Z. O., Llamas, C. F. C.,

Tolibas, C. N. L., & Tutor, J. H. (2022). The Impact of Student

Employment onGrade 11 Sto. Tomas Senior High School Students.

Bennett, R. (2023, June 26). Most Americans are significantly stressed about

money — here’s how it varies by demographic. Bankrate.

https://www.bankrate.com/banking/money-and-financial-stress-

statistics/

Britt, S. L., Mendiola, M. R., Schink, G. H., Tibbetts, R., & Jones, S. B. (2016,

22
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

January 1). Financial Stress, Coping Strategy, and Academic

Achievement of College Students. Journal of Financial Counseling

and Planning, 172–183(2). https://doi.org/10.1891/1052-

3073.27.2.172

Culili, Mercado, Sabila, & Cu Chiam. (2021, April 22). EFFECTS OF

FINANCIAL STRESS ON THE ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE OF

MAXIMOESTRELLA SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS. Course

Hero. https://www.coursehero.com/file/89847447/GROUP-2-ABM-

CHAPTER-1and2docxpdf/

Cayetano, A. G. E., Conde, A. M., Eliptico, J. M. B., Garcia, J. L. G., Dagarat,

L. R. B., Cabal, M. A., & Cureg, R. R. (2022). Effects of Sleep

Deprivation on Academic Performances of Grade 11 STEM

Students of Valley High Academy Incorporation, Academic Year

2021-2022.\

Doyo, M. C. P. (2015, March 26). Help for poor, despairing college students |

Inquirer Opinion. INQUIRER.net.

https://opinion.inquirer.net/83626/help-for-poor-despairing-college-

students

Galleto. (2022, March 21). Best Healthcare Provider for Working Students.

Maria Health. https://mariahealth.ph/resources/articles/best-

healthcare-provider-for-working-

students/#:~:text=The%20amount%20of%20working%20students,

23
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

currently%20juggling%20school%20and%20work

Iqbal, N., Iqbal, S., Nadeem, M., Perveen, A., Malik, A.A. (2022). Financial

Stress, Student’s Positivity and their Academic Achievement:

Mediating Role of Family Conflicts. Pak. J. Psychol. Res, 37(3), 399-

416. https://pjpr.scione.com/cms/abstract.php?id=360

Kyoshaba, M. (2009, December). FACTORS AFFECTING ACADEMIC

PERFORMANCE OF UNDERGRADUATE STUDENTS AT

UGANDA CHRISTIAN UNIVERSITY.

https://www.mak.ac.ug/documents/Makfiles/theses/Kyoshaba%20

Martha.pdf

Medina, M. (2013, September 18). Effects of financial stress on academic

performance. PantherNOW.

https://panthernow.com/2013/09/17/effects-of-financial-stress-on-

academic-performance/

Norazlan, N., Yusuf, S., & Al-Majdhoub, F.M.H. (2020). The financial problems

and academic performance among public university students in

Malaysia. The Asian Journal of Professional and Business Studies,

Volume 1(2).

Perman, C. (2019, November 21). Running out of money. Cancer. Divorce.

Many college students are facing serious financial crises. CNBC.

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/10/28/many-college-students-find-

24
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

themselves-in-a-serious-financial-crisis.html

Pinlac, B. (2023, May 9). 14 million Filipino families consider themselves poor

— SWS | Inquirer News. INQUIRER.net.

https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1766165/14-million-filipino-families-

consider-themselves-poor-sws

Putwain, D. W., Symes, W., Nicholson, L. J., & Remedios, R. (2021). Advances

in Motivation Science (Vol. 8) [Website]. Science Direct.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/bookseries/advances-in-motivation-

science/vol/8/suppl/C

Rudland, R. (2019, September 11). The stress paradox: how stress can be

good for learning. Wiley Online Library.

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/medu.13830

Tesfaw, A. A., & Yitayih, T. T. (2018, October 1). A Study on Financial Stress

and Coping Strategies among Students in Rift Valley University,

Ethiopia. Retrieved July 1, 2023, from

https://idosi.org/hssj/hssj13(1)18/1.pdf

Usman, M., & Banu, A. (2019, January 1). A Study on Impact of Financial Stress

on Students’ Academics. Journal of Business & Economic Policy,

6(1). https://doi.org/10.30845/jbep.v6n1p7

Villahermosa, M. E., Oba-o, W. C., & Bagabaldo, J. (2015). Working Scholars:

Life as a Worker and an Academic Performer. Retrieved July 1,

25
VALLEY HIGH ACADEMY, INC.
J.P RIZAL ST. MANGGAHAN, RODRIGUEZ, RIZAL

Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics

2023, from https://ejournals.ph/article.php?id=11767

Widener, K. N. (2017). Financial Management Issues of College-Aged

Students: Influences and Consequences (Thesis). Selected Honor

Theses.

https://firescholars.seu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1063&cont

ext=honors

What is stress? (2022, March). Mind. https://www.mind.org.uk/information-

support/types-of-mental-health-problems/stress/what-is-stress/

26

You might also like