Professional Documents
Culture Documents
University of Gujrat, Hafiz Hayat Campus BS Final Research Project Attestation of Authorship
University of Gujrat, Hafiz Hayat Campus BS Final Research Project Attestation of Authorship
ATTESTATION OF AUTHORSHIP
We hereby solemnly state that this Final Project Report entitled “The Impact of loss
aversion, greed, and fear on the individual investors’ investment decisions” is our work and
that, to the best of our knowledge and belief, it encompasses no material previously published or
written by another person. This final project report is not submitted already and shall not be
presented in the future for obtaining a degree from the same or another University or Institution.
Suppose it is found to be copied / plagiarized at the later stage of any student enrolled in the
same or any other university. In that case, we shall be liable to face legal action before Unfair
Mean Committee (UMC), as per UOG rules and regulations, and we understand that if we are
Authors’ Signatures,
1. Signature _______________
2. Signature _______________
CERTIFICATE
This research work is entitled “The Impact of loss aversion, greed and fear on the
And have been completed under my guidance and supervision. I am satisfied with the quality of
____________________
Signature
Date: ______________________
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
All praises and thanks to the Almighty Allah, the Merciful, the only Creator of the
universe and the Source of all knowledge and wisdom, who blessed us with health, thoughts,
We feel highly privileged to express our gratitude to our sincere and honorable
Gujrat, for his keen interest, untiring guidance, creative criticism, and sympathetic attitude
throughout the study. Without his enthusiastic scholarly guidance, this manuscript would not
ABSTRACT
This study has investigated the impact of loss aversion, greed, and fear on individual investors'
investment decisions in Pakistan. This study has considered loss aversion, greed, and fear as
independent variables and investment decisions as to the dependent variable. In addition, this
study has finalized the individual investors of the stock market and brokerage houses of twin
cities (Islamabad and Rawalpindi) of Pakistan to investigate the impact of the aforementioned
variables. The sample size of this study is 250 respondents. To prove the impact of variables, a
survey has been conducted through an adopted structured questionnaire regarding the literature,
in which the individual investors in the stock market and brokerage houses of twin cities
(Islamabad and Rawalpindi) of Pakistan have been requested to share their experiences by filling
the questionnaires. To identify the results of the data gathered from the respondents, statistical
instruments have been used. Some of them used in this study include descriptive statistics,
reliability, and regression analysis. Results derived from statistical tools with the help of SPSS
software have shown a significant positive relationship between the variables. The study's
findings are that loss aversion, greed, and fear substantially impact individual investors'
investment decisions.
Key words: Loss Aversion, Greed, Fear, Investment Decisions, Stock Exchange, and Brokerage
Houses etc.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION...........................................................................................8
1.1.2.2 Greed..............................................................................................................10
1.1.2.3 Fear.................................................................................................................11
Introduction..........................................................................................................................17
2.2 Greed.........................................................................................................................20
2.3 Fear............................................................................................................................23
Introduction..........................................................................................................................37
4.1.1 Reliability...........................................................................................................37
5.1 Discussion..................................................................................................................42
5.4 Conclusion.................................................................................................................44
REFERENCES.......................................................................................................................46
APPENDIX A.........................................................................................................................49
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
Several biases affect the individual investors' investment decisions. Those biases include
overconfidence, greed, regret aversion, anchoring, fear, representative, herding, loss aversion,
etc. According to some researchers, a study can be carried out to determine their influence or
effect on individual investors' investment decisions in the Pakistan stock market. The stock
exchange plays a dynamic role in trading in every country. Numerous variables have been
studied in the past when it comes to Pakistan. Still, certain variables or biases can be learned and
influence the individual investors’ investment decisions. Among them are loss aversion, greed,
and fear. This study will find the influence of these three variables on the individual investors'
investment decisions.
The Pakistan stock exchange was founded on September 18, 1947, and formally inaugurated on
March 10, 1949, as a guaranteed limited company under the name ‘Karachi stock exchange’. The
Lahore stock exchange was founded in October 1970 to satisfy the demands of the local stock
exchange. In October 1989, the Islamabad stock exchange designated target investors in the
country's northern parts. Because the three interchanges had different administrations, trading
positions, indicators and had no joint structure, the stock interchanges (privatize, demutualize,
and incorporate) under the Act, 2012 that the government of Pakistan promulgated. It eventually
led to the three companies merging their activities on January 11, 2016, under the new name
Pakistan Stock Exchange Limited (PSX). About 443 PSX-listed firms with a combined market
value of PKR 8,736 billion ($52 billion) were listed in January 2021. On September 8, 2021,
MSCI designated the PSX as the frontier market. A total of 1,886 international institutional
investors and 883 domestic institutional investors, as well as nearly 220,000 individual investors,
participated in the exchanges. In addition, there are over 400 PSX brokerage houses and 21 asset
management firms. The Karachi stock exchange, one of the PSX's constituent stock exchanges,
was named one of the top performing frontier equity markets between 2009 and 2015, with an
average annual return of 26%. PSX sold 40 percent of its strategic interests to a Chinese
organization for the US $ 85 million in December 2016. PSX's mission is to create a secure,
trustworthy, efficient, and consistent marketplace for investors to purchase and sell listed
company common stock and other securities. The exchange has been promoting financial growth
for more than 60 years, benefiting a wide range of participants, including individual and
Several variables have been studied in the past, but certain variables or biases can be learned and
influence the individual investors' investment decisions. There are loss aversion, greed, and fear,
The inclination to avoid losses over gaining equal benefits is known as loss aversion. Loss
aversion was firstly introduced in 1979 by two psychologists, Daniel Kahneman and Amos
Tversky. Loss aversion is a behavioral finance phenomenon in which investors are more
concerned with avoiding losing money than with making money. Loss aversion is a characteristic
of investment behavior in which investors would rather avoid a loss than obtain a similar return.
According to psychologists, loss aversion is innate in all humans and is a result of appraisal and
Greed is an insatiable need for more of anything, generally more than you require. Greed is an
essential economic motive. On the other hand, it has been linked to various economic activities.
Psychological greed is defined as a disordered desire for more than one deserves, for one's own
selfish benefit at the expense of others and society as a whole, rather than for the greater good.
desire for more wealth or power than one requires at the expense of others. Greed may (and will)
induce you to accept more risk in your portfolio than you are normally comfortable with, as
1.1.2.3 Fear
Fear is the threat of danger, discomfort, or injury as it causes an unpleasant emotion. Fear is
lower prices during the trading session. In psychology, fear is a basic, common, and powerful
human emotion. Fear is an emotion that we certainly need in moderation, but it can hinder us
There are several works on fear and greed, but not much in Pakistan. If there is some work
related to these variables' they are mainly from Karachi and Lahore stock exchange, so the focus
of this research data collection will be from the Pakistan stock exchange in twin cities
According to Chaudhary, (2013) loss aversion occurs when an investor is faced with the chance
of losing money, but also occurs when the investor is faced with the opportunity of making
money. Investors are loss averse, according to Kahneman; this 'loss aversion' means that people
are willing to take greater risks to avoid losing money than to make a profit. The prospect theory
is based on the idea that individuals do not always act logically. In times of uncertainty, a variety
So, the purpose of this study is to study these two emotions, i.e., fear and greed, and find out how
they impact the investors’ and their investment decisions. This study will significantly help
understand all three variables, i.e., loss aversion, greed, and fear, and how they impact investors'
investment decisions.
Developed countries like the U.S, Canada, New Zealand, and developing countries like China,
India, Bangladesh, and other Asian countries have done a lot of loss aversion, fear, and greed.
The impact of these variables on investors' decisions, their work is beneficial in studying the
investor behaviour, and behavioural biases impact investor decisions. In Pakistan, some of the
researchers worked on these variables. Still, excessive data is not available, and in Pakistan, there
is a need for research in the variable of this studyThe data from the markets in Pakistan will help
According to traditional finance, investors are rational. Their decision concerning investment is
involved a careful understanding of information on the market. Some investors make irrational
decisions, and if they become familiar with the factors behind this sort of decision, then there is a
possibility that they can make rational decisions. Still, it is unattainable for every investor to
make investment decisions rationally because behavioral finance has shown that investors are apt
to behavioral bias. Several biases affect investors' decisions and this study will cover some of the
variables, i.e., loss aversion, greed, and fear, which influence investment decisions. Compared to
Pakistan, other countries like India, China, Bangladesh, and other Asian countries have done
more work in these variables. This study is carried out through the PSX market and will find the
influence of loss aversion, greed, and fear and their impact on investors' investment decisions.
R1. What is the impact of loss aversion on individual investors’ investment decisions?
This research is very beneficial for the policymakers working in the Pakistan stock exchange,
brokerage houses, the agents, the shareholders, the share issues, the corporations, organizations,
the government that make policies for the financial markets, and the financial advisors. After
studying this research, those who can be able to advise the investors in their investment decisions
and protect them from making irrational decisions, the policymakers who can understand these
psychological factors will ensure that the market is running smoothly. These students are willing
to study these variables and conduct future research related to these variables or in these
variables' perspectives. After reviewing this research, these finance teachers can teach the
students more efficiently about these variables and their impact on investors' investment
decisions. This research will help researchers better understand investor behavior characteristics
from the Pakistan stock exchange of twin cities (Islamabad and Rawalpindi), such as loss
aversion, greed, and fear. The recommendations of this research are defined onwards in the
study.
The scope of this study is limited to a sample size of 250 respondents from the Pakistan twin
cities' population (Islamabad and Rawalpindi). This study analysis can cover the scenario
related to loss aversion, greed, and fear that lies in the hearts of the investors. Those investors
are either willing to invest all their life savings to make millions or are afraid to take a more
significant risk in fear of losing everything they have in the Islamabad stock exchange. As the
sample size of this study is not fixed, the various variables and factors were taken from the
questionnaire results from 250 investors in Islamabad stock exchange. This research will
determine the reason behind the actions of investors that are currently investing there. This
research will also find the trends of investments in the Islamabad stock exchange with the
research charts based on analysis of distributing questionnaires among the investors. Through
this research, those who do the study after this research will have the capability to read the
mindset of investors of residents of Islamabad and Rawalpindi and the investors’ residing in the
area of Attock Chakwal, Murree, WahCantt, Jehlum, Texila, etc. The scope of this research
project is to find such kinds of people who have greed and fear on investment and researchers
looking towards to get the answer that is why people invest their money on the stock market
while they have a problem of greed and fear of losing their money. After reviewing that, the
researchers will try to overcome this habit among people, and after that, they will not fear
investing money in the stock market. In this research, the scope is limited because of the limited
area. The study results can be generalized for the economies that resemble the economic
conditions of Pakistan. Individual investors' decision-making processes are significantly
influenced by the behavioral characteristics highlighted in this study. The findings of this study
can be utilized to push the frontiers of behavioral finance literature in terms of application,
Introduction
This chapter is about the literature review that the authors of this study looked at. It provides an
overview of the key research factors as well as a review of the literature. Firstly, the literature or
the authors' articles regarding the study variables had read cited below. Afterward, the theoretical
framework given in this chapter and the hypothesis statements related to the theoretical
framework are listed below. The theories used in this research or related to this study are
The Rwanda stock exchange was the setting for Mahina, Muturi, and Florence, (2017) research.
Self-serving bias, over-optimism bias, loss aversion, self-attribution bias, confirmatory bias,
investment, and the Rwanda stock exchange were the study's primary factors. Individual
investors’ were the target audience for their research. The study's sample size was determined
through random sampling, which yielded 374 respondents. The goal of their research was to see
how behavioural biases affected investment in the Rwanda stock exchange. According to
Mahina, Muturi, and Florence, (2017) confirmatory bias plays a positive and substantial impact
in the frequency of stock market trading. Investors should examine these aspects when making
investment decisions, according to the authors. They argued in their study that stock market
investors should be intelligent enough to recognise the nature of self-serving bias, which might
help them make the correct investment selections and behave rationally while doing so. (Mahina,
KHAN, AZEEM, and SARWAR, (2017) focused their research on the investors of the Islamabad
and Lahore stock exchanges, as well as brokerage houses. The main variables of their study were
overconfidence, loss aversion, investment decision and risk perception. A total of 250
questionnaires were circulated, and 160 investors answered, 90 percent of whom were males and
10 percent of whom were women. KHAN, AZEEM, and SARWAR, (2017) used risk perception
as a moderator to examine the influence of behavioural biases such as overconfidence and loss
investors were affected, loss aversion bias has a major impact, as does overconfidence bias.
Their research reveals that when investors are afraid of losing money, they invest less.
Overconfidence and loss aversion biases harm investors, according to the findings, which are
valuable for policymakers, financial advisers, stock investors, finance lecturers, and finance
Nalurita, Leon, and Hady, (2020) examined their study in Indonesia stock exchange (IDX) in
Jakarta. Loss aversion, regret aversion, market factor, and investment choice were the primary
variables in their study. Individual investors were the target audience for their research. The
sample size of their study was 281 respondents. The outcomes of their study revealed that
cautious investing by IDX investors enhances loss aversion, regret aversion, and market factors
behaviour. Their study results found that the direct association between variable loss aversion,
regret aversion, and market conditions had a substantial impact on investment decision making.
Greed, according to Mussel and Hewig, (2019) is described as an overwhelming need for more,
emphasizing an insatiable condition associated with the pursuit of sought things. LO, REPIN,
decision-making using a different sample of people and a new technique for evaluating
emotional reaction. A total of 80 people participated in the study, which were part of a five-week
online training program for day-traders sponsored by Linda Bradford Raschke, a well-known
professional futures trader. Investors are irrational in general, showing a number of predicted and
Chaudhary, (2013) investigated the influence of behavioral finance on investment decisions and
strategies. The main variables of the study were irrational emotions, over-confidence, and
cognitive dissonance. The study revealed that emotions like fear and greed often play a pivotal
role in investors' decisions, which is also a cause of irrational behavior. It was observed that
stock prices fluctuate every day without any change in economies' fundamentals. Chaudhary,
(2013).
Breda and Berlamont, (2014) studied the secret of fear and greed behind financial decision-
making. Three hundred sixteen respondents in the sample ranged from 18 to 70 years old. They
described greed as an excessive desire to get more worldly possessions. Every investor desire to
experience the dizzy exhilaration that comes with success. Their findings confirmed that as
people get older, they take fewer risks. However, younger individuals are more ready to take
financial risks than older ones, according to Breda and Berlamont, (2014) research. And
experienced individuals are more likely than inexperienced persons to take financial risks. When
investors watch others getting money, they grow greedy. They want to attain profit on the
growing market before it fades. When greed is the prevailing emotion in the stock market, stock
prices begin to rise. Massive buying, which is encouraged by greed, causes prices to rise.
Overconfidence, which stems from miscalculations of risks and irrational levels of desire, is one
of the defining factors in greed. Greed in financial markets manifests itself in more asset
purchases, higher prices, and increased trading activity. (Breda & Berlamont, 2014)
2.3 Fear
According to Breda and Berlamont, (2014) fear is the feeling that keeps us from doing
potentially dangerous things. Fear is an emotion that we certainly need in moderation, but it can
LEE and ANDRADE, (2011) looked at the influence of accidental fear on the choice to sell.
Negative emotions in general and dread in particular, impact risk perception. When faced with
vague and uncontrollable threats, people sense fear. As a result, people who are fearful take
cognitive and behavioral actions to minimize their anxiety and dread. Fearful persons pay extra
investors sell their shares earlier than non-fearful ones. The sole decision to be made is whether
to hold (uncertain outcome) or sell (certain product) a stock. (LEE & ANDRADE, 2011).
Chaudhary, (2013) investigated the influence of behavioral finance on investment decisions and
strategies. Fear, according to the study, has a significant effect in investors’ decisions and is also
a source of irrational behavior. Fear of regret may make investors either risk cautious or
motivate them to take a risk in investing. Breda and Berlamont, (2014) studied the secret of fear
and greed behind financial decisions. They described fear as an uneasy feeling towards
situational control. There were 316 respondents in the sample, who ranged from 18 to 70 years
old. Their findings confirm that as people get older, they take fewer risks. According to the
study, younger people are more willing to take financial risks than older people. The findings
reveal that experienced people are inclined to take more financial risks than inexperienced
people. Investors, according to Breda and Berlamont, (2014) are prone to repeat the same
mistakes over and over. Despite the fact that they lose money, securities are bought high out of
greed and sold low because of fear. Fearful people make risk-averse decisions and sell their
stocks earlier, whereas greedy people make risk-seeking decisions. Greed and fear can lead to
illogical behaviors such as purchasing high and selling low. (Breda & Berlamon, 2014)
Jausen and Nikiforov, (2016) discovered in their study that in a market with numerous greedy
and fearful investors, aggressive buying or selling can cause an overreaction. Afraid to go
through the corresponding losses, the individual investors will push the price down even further.
Without the right amount of fear, we would reveal ourselves to unreasonable threats, and
without the right amount of greed, we would refrain from opportunities to secure the resources
we need to live. However, too much of either fear or greed is usually harmful. An individual
overwhelmed by fear will not pursue opportunities that will permit him to secure the resources
INDEPENDENT DEPENDENT
VARIABLES VARIABLE
Loss Aversion
This theoretical framework has three independent variables and one dependent variable. Loss
aversion, fear, and greed have been considered as independent variables. However, investment
decisions have been considered as the dependent variable. Loss aversion (independent variable)
has been adapted from Parker and Decotiis, (1983), fear (independent variable) has been adapted
from Howland, Lachman, Peterson, Cote, Kasten, and Jette, (1998), and greed (independent
variable) has been adapted from Seuntjens et al., (2014). At the same time, investment decisions
Following are the underpinning theories which are related to this study.
Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman first proposed prospect theory in 1979, and later, it was
developed in 1992. The prospect hypothesis proposed that investors value gains and losses
differently, with perceived gains weighing more heavily than perceived losses. Kahneman and
Tversky, (1979) critiqued expected utility theory as a descriptive model of risky decision-making
and suggested prospect theory as an alternative model. Subjects (investors) are more inclined to
assess prospects or expected outcomes in terms of profits and losses compared to a reference
point rather than ultimate wealth states. Prospect theory is based on the assumption that
individuals do not always behave logically. When presented with uncertainty, people's judgments
are impacted by persistent biases triggered by psychological factors, according to this theory.
Preferences are treated as a function of 'choice weights,' which are thought not to always equate
to probability in prospect theory. Prospect theory suggests, in particular, that decision weights
When investors are handed over with the chance of loss aversion, prospect theory shows that
they are more likely to make riskier actions to avoid losing money (though they may sometimes
refrain from investing altogether). They tend to reverse or significantly alter their previously
reported risk aversion. Finally, this blunder in investing may lead to significant losses in a
biases affect the investor's decision, but loss aversion bias is the one that affects the decision-
making behaviour. The marginal utility of a loss is strictly greater than the marginal utility of a
corresponding gain, according to the prospect theory. Prospect theory describes that individuals
are more risk-averse when faced with possible benefits than losses. Risk aversion leads to a
dispositional effect, in which investors sell winning equities too soon and keep losing stocks for
too long. Prospect theory research indicates that there is a negative association between
Shareholders and financial investors are one of several groups that a business or organization
communities, environmental groups, governmental groups, and others are all considered
companies should aim to do the right thing by all of these stakeholders, and that by doing so;
The term ‘stakeholder' was first used in an internal document at the Stanford Research Institute
in 1963, and it is still in use today. A 'plethora' of stakeholder definitions and ideologies emerged
as a result. In 1971, Hein Kroos and Klaus Schwab produced a German pamphlet titled 'Modern
growth and prosperity, management of a modern firm must serve not only shareholders but all
stakeholders. In the 1980s, Edward Freeman popularized the word stakeholder and a more
comprehensive stakeholder theory, defining a stakeholder as "any group or individual who may
The goal of this study is to figure out how loss aversion, greed and fear of individual investors’
affect the stock market's result. On Wall Street, there is an old adage that the market is driven by
only two emotions: greed and fear. The majority of investors desire to make as much money as
possible in bull markets. They strive to acquire as much stock as they can in order to sell it all at
once at the opportune time. According to stakeholder theory, all the investors, governmental
groups, suppliers, etc., are a part of the stock market as they also have their stakes. Whenever the
investor buys shares in greed, the supplier and producer of the product get benefit from it along
sell because everyone else is doing it. The market, just as it may be overcome by greed, can also
be overcome by fear. When equities experience big losses over a long period of time, investors
may become frightened of more losses and begin to sell. It has the self-fulfilling consequence of
causing prices to drop even further. The stakeholder theory shows that every kind of stakeholder
weathers its employee or any group, is in development by the greed and fear in the stock market.
projected loss to be more psychologically or emotionally painful than an equivalent gain. The
anguish of losing $100, for example, is typically significantly higher than the elation of
discovering the same amount. The stakeholder theory of the stock market demonstrates that, just
as greed reigns supreme during a bull market, fear reigns supreme during a down market. To
limit their losses, investors sell equities fast and replace them with safer assets such as money
market securities, stable value funds, and principal-protected funds, which are all low-risk but
low-return investments. Whether it's a stockbroker or an individual investor, everyone tries to tell
themselves that their investment won't be lost until fully realized, or you can say they are sold at
The methodology used to assess the association between loss aversion, greed, and fear
chapter. This chapter covers the research methodologies, such as the study's population, sample
size, and sampling technique, etc. This chapter also covers technique for gathering and analyzing
data using quantitative or qualitative approaches, such as research design, research instrument,
population and sample size, data collection, data analysis, and so on.
As elaborated by Sekaran and Bougie, (2013) research design is the plan for data collection,
measurement, and analysis based on the study's research questions. Starting from the research
methodologies, which are of three types as discussed by Sekaran and Bougie, (2013). These are
qualitative, quantitative, and mixed research methods. This study uses primary data after going
through the definition of research design and many sorts of research methodologies. As a result,
the quantitative research method is used in this study. In the quantitative research method, the
nature of the investigation has the following types. These are quasi, experimental, causal, and
descriptive research designs. The nature of this study belongs to causal research design, as this
study explains the cause-and-effect relationship between the variables. Causal research design, as
highlighted by Sekaran and Bougie, (2013) is the scientific method of study relies heavily on
causal investigations. Such research examines if one variable influences the behavior of another.
In a causal investigation, the researcher is looking for the elements that are causing the problem.
The population, according to Sekaran and Bougie, (2013) is the total group of individuals,
events, or items of interest that the researcher desires to explore. The researcher tries to draw
sample statistics). In this study, the researchers have chosen individual investors of twin cities
(Islamabad and Rawalpindi) of Pakistan as the population of this study. These individuals have
been asked to complete the questionnaire in order to obtain the necessary information. The
population size chosen has been the 250 individual investors of Pakistan's twin cities (Islamabad
and Rawalpindi).
According to Sekaran and Bougie, (2013) the process of picking a sufficient number of the
correct elements from the population such that a study of the sample and comprehension of its
(2013) there are two primary sampling approaches in statistics and these are random and non-
random sampling techniques. This study is using a non-random sampling technique. The
following are the several sorts of non-random sampling methods; these are purposive, quota,
snowball, and convenience sampling techniques. This study follows the purposive sampling
technique. As predicted by Sekaran and Bougie, (2013) the purposive sampling is a non-
probability sampling approach in which the needed information is acquired on a reasonable basis
from individuals or specified targets or groups of people. Majority of the researchers who have
already researched this literature have used the questionnaire technique to gather the data.
Therefore, the major procedure used to collect the data within this research has been a structured
According to Sekaran and Bougie, (2013) the sample is analyzed as a subset of the population. It
is made up of members who have been chosen from among them. In other words, the sample
contains some, but not all, aspects of the population. The sample size was determined based on
the recommendations of top scholars such as Sekaran and Bougie, (2013) who claimed that the
sample size is the actual number of participants chosen as a sample to represent the population
characteristics. Hair. et al., (2005) suggested that if you are to use advanced multivariate models
like structured equations modeling, the minimum sample size should be 250. In that case, 250
questionnaires were distributed amongst the individual investors’ and all were reliable for the
data analysis. A sample of 250 respondents (individual investors’) working in the Pakistan Stock
Exchange (PSX) and the brokerage houses have been taken to represent the entire population.
The data gathering instrument in this study was a survey questionnaire. The structured
questionnaire items have been adopted from various researchers who conducted their study
previously. The table below shows the study's variables and the things and their source.
Jette, 1998)
The respondents' data was collected using an accepted questionnaire as a research tool
gather data from the respondents and analyze data to evaluate the link between loss aversion,
greed, fear, and investment decisions in Pakistan, similar to the bulk of research studies
completed on this literature issue. The structured questionnaire utilized in this study was built on
five liquid scales for capturing responses (strongly disagree, disagree, neutral, agree, and
strongly agree).
The questionnaire was designed with great attention and made as basic as possible to guarantee
that the procedure of replying is simple enough to obtain trustworthy replies from the
participants in the data collection. The factors of ambiguity and suspension were immediately
eliminated with such a simplified questionnaire. The information was gathered from the Pakistan
individual investors’ using a standardized questionnaire that was individually given. The
gathered questionnaires are synced suitably to help in the study's plausible results and
conclusions.
After the data was collected, it was evaluated using a variety of tests to complete the analytic
method. Various statistical methods such as reliability and regression have been used to prepare
data for analysis after it has been collected. The magnitude and direction of the link between the
independent and dependent variables were determined using these statistical methods and SPSS
software. These statistical tools have demonstrated the significant relationship between loss
The items that make up the scales may be evaluated using reliability analysis, which is a
statistical tool that exposes the properties of measuring scales. The reliability analysis tool
generates a number of regularly used scale reliability indicators as well as information on scale
item correlations. Intraclass correlation coefficients can be used to create inter-rater reliability
estimates.
Regression analysis is a sophisticated statistical tool that allows you to investigate the connection
between two or more variables. Regression analysis is a reliable tool for evaluating which factors
have an impact on a particular issue. Regression analysis allows us to pinpoint which aspects are
most important, which ones may be overlooked, and how these factors interact.
Introduction
In this chapter, data has been collected from the individual investors of the stock market and
brokerage houses of Pakistan's twin cities (Islamabad and Rawalpindi). Based on the collected
data, reliability, descriptive statistics, and regression analysis have been applied to analyze the
data.
Software Used
41
42
43
4.1.1 Reliability
The reliability of the structured questionnaire has been tested through Cronbach's alpha to
investigate the level it is being consistent with what it is supposed to be measuring. The
questionnaire is more reliable if it has lesser variations upon repeated interval measurements.
How dependable the questionnaire is, how consistent its questions are, and how related it is to
measuring the instruments' reliability. Below is the result of Cronbach's alpha reliability test of a
.706 21
The closer the coefficient of reliability is to 1, the higher the internal consistency reliability will
be. The value of Chronbach's alpha shown by reliability statistics is 0.706, which is 70.6%
(>50%), and it is acceptable in this study. This value of Cronbach's alpha has indicated the
maximum level of reliability and consistency possessed with the questionnaire used primarily the
research conducted within the study. The value of Chronbach's alpha is 0.706, which is close to
1, demonstrating the reliability of the questionnaire used and the respondents' reliable responses.
The responses received through the study instrument are internally consistent. Thus, the tool is
Descriptive Statistics
Std.
N Minimum Maximum Mean
Deviation
Valid N 250
(listwise)
The table above shows the descriptive statistics, including the mean values and standard
deviation of all variables. The mean values of loss aversion, fear, greed, and investment
decisions, are 3.3624, 3.1693, 3.3656, and 3.5245, respectively. No mean value is closer to +ve
or -ve extreme. Whereas, it shows in the table above that the mean value for investment
Regression indicates the relationship between dependent (investment decisions) and independent
(loss aversion, fear, and greed) variables and the extent of the connection between them. In
addition, regression highlights the fitness of the theoretical framework model used in the
research study to develop hypothesis. Below is the regression analysis results, which is another
term used for the analysis of the data. This is a significant step in calculating the type of the
relationship between the variables, whether they are dependent or independent variables, the
relationship between variables exists or not, and finding the relationship is significant. When
derived from this whole process, such results can give the most relevant and reliable data.
Coefficients
Unstandardized Standardized
The above table shows dimensions that have a positive influence on investment decisions. In the
model, the significance value of t-stats should be more than or equal to 1.96, and the probability
of t-stats should be less than or equal to 0.05. The significance value of loss aversion, fear, and
greed are less than 0.05 showing the positive or significant relationship between them. To find
the nature of the relationship of variables, whether there are statistically significant or not, it will
be defined through beta, and beta tells the definition of regression and shows the dependence of
dependent variable (investment decisions) on independent variables (loss aversion, fear, and
greed). Loss aversion (b=0.284) is significant (p=0.000), and the coefficient is positive, which
indicates that loss aversion is related to investment decisions which suggest that with the change
in one unit in loss aversion, the investment decisions changes by 0.284 (or 28.4%) in the same
direction. Fear (b=0.098) is significant (p=0.47), and the coefficient is positive, which indicates
that the fear is related to investment decisions which demonstrates that with the change in one
unit of fear, the investment decisions change by 0.098 (or 9.8%) in the same direction. Finally,
greed (b=0.300) is significant (p=0.00), and the coefficient is positive, which indicates that the
greed is related to investment decisions which suggest that with the change in one unit of greed,
the investment decisions changes by 0.300 (or 30%) in the same direction.
Model Summary
The Adjusted R-square value represents variance percent in the dependent variable that is
accounted for by variations in the predicting variables (loss aversion, greed, and fear). The R
Square value in the model is the coefficient of determination or explanatory power. It indicates
that all the independent variables (loss aversion, greed, and fear) explain the changes dependent
variable (investment decisions) by 0.336, which is 33.6%. However, 66.4% changes independent
variable, investment decisions are explained through other factors like risk aversion, regret
aversion, etc., which are not illustrated or described in this study. The R-square value in the
model shows that loss aversion, greed, and fear accounted for a 32.8% variance in the investment
decision.
ANOVA
Sum of
Model Df Mean Square F Sig.
Squares
The table above shows the model fitness or combined significance of variables. In F-stats, the F
value should be more than or equal to 4, and the probability of F-stats should be less than or
equal to 0.05. The F-value in the model is greater than 4 (41.584), and the significant value is
less than 0.05 (0.000), representing the model's fitness. If the considerable value is more than
0.05, the model could not fit the data. The table above shows that the probability of F-stats
obtained in results is significant (p=0.000), the model is fit. In other words, all the independent
variables (loss aversion, greed, and fear) are relevant to the dependent variable, investment
decisions.
5.1 Discussion
This research study has aimed to investigate the relationship between loss aversion, fear, greed
have been chosen for data collection and investigation of the relationship between variables
mentioned above. An adoptive structured questionnaire has been used to gather responses from
the respondents that are individual investors in twin cities (Islamabad and Rawalpindi) of
Pakistan. However, a scale has been set, which ranges 5 percent of the significance level to test
the acceptance and rejection of hypotheses of this study. As significance level of loss aversion,
fear, and greed for investment decisions has been checked. H1, H2, and H3 have been accepted
and proved significant based on the significance level. Therefore, it has been established have a
positive relationship between loss aversion, greed, and fear (independent variables) and
44
45
46
5.2.1 Theoretical Implication
The behavioural factor identified in this study had a significant effect on the decision-making
process of individual investors'. This study will prove beneficial for the policymakers towards
understanding the relationship between independent variables (loss aversion, greed, and fear) and
dependent variable (investment decisions). In addition, policymakers and other think tanks will
continue this research study as a foundation to further explore the impacts of loss aversion,
greed, and fear on the individual investors' investment decisions in Pakistan. It is also helpful for
those who make policies for the financial markets, and the financial advisors who, after studying
this research, can be able to advise the investors in their investment decisions and protect them
from making irrational decisions, the policymakers who can understand these psychological
factors will be able to ensure that the market is running smoothly, the students who are willing to
study these variables and conduct the future research related or these variable perspectives, the
finance teachers who after studying this research can teach the students more efficiently about
Meanwhile, finance students of Pakistan will have sufficient evidence through this research
study concerning the significant role that loss aversion, greed, and fear impact individual
investors' investment decisions in Pakistan. Finance students will be able to enhance their
knowledge and understanding of the relationship between the variables of this study.
This study will prove practical in helping policymakers who are working in Pakistan Stock
Exchange (PSX), stakeholders associated with Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX), brokerage
houses, individual investors’, the agents, the shareholders, the share issuers, the corporation, the
organization, and the government, as this study will assist in developing their knowledge and
awareness about the role that loss aversion, greed and fear impact the investment decisions of
The limitation has consistently been recognized as a barrier that a researcher must face while
performing a research study. There have been numerous limitations experienced while
conducting this study. Some significant limitations were limited sample size, limited time frame,
or this research covering only two twin cities (Islamabad and Rawalpindi) of Pakistan. Although
the sample survey conducted in this study was based on a limited sample selected from a
particular area that genuinely represented the total population, it is also considered the limitation
of this study. On the other hand, in the Covid-19 uncertain situation, most of the factors
negatively affect financial decision-making, except for overconfidence, which shows a positive
effect. Though the limitation was a time constraint, limiting factors and Covid-19 is a stressful
environment, and people do not prefer to participate in interviews. However, the time frame
available for the completion of this study was insufficient because for gathering responses from
individual investors’ and brokerage houses of twin cities in Pakistan, there were a need for an
extended time frame. A time frame with additional time must be provided to conduct appropriate
research covering more responses of individual investors’ of twin cities of Pakistan and
belonging to different parts of twin cities. An increased time span is required for a study to be of
broad scope.
Additionally, the sample size was another constraint. For covering the individual investors’ and
brokerage houses of twin cities of Pakistan, a sample size of 250 was not enough, as a sample
size of 250 might not be sufficient to represent the individual investors’ decision-making of cities
of Pakistan in an appropriate manner. Hence, an overall sample size has been required for
Similarly, research studies on this literature have primarily focused on cross-sectional research,
as the nature of research preferred for this type of research has been cross-sectional. However,
the use of cross-sectional analysis could be another limitation that needs to be addressed. A
longitudinal study could be performed to address this literature topic in the future. In addition, it
has been recommended that a survey be conducted while considering SMEs as the targeted
audience to investigate the relationship between variables of this study. Finally, the future
research direction is to increase sample size and factors to understand the financial decision
impact on performance. It will help practitioners determine and avoid errors in their decisions
5.4 Conclusion
Based on the findings and results of this study, it has been concluded that loss aversion, greed,
and fear (independent variables) have a significant positive impact on the individual investors’
investment decisions (dependent variable). The prime objective of this study is to find the effect
of loss aversion, greed, and fear on individual investors’ investment decisions in Pakistan. To
investigate the impact of these variables, a structured questionnaire has been distributed amongst
the individual investors’ in the stock market and brokerage houses of twin cities (Islamabad and
Rawalpindi) of Pakistan for data collection, as the impact of each variable has been observed in
this study. The regression analysis and reliability test have been performed, and this analysis
revealed that loss aversion, greed, and fear have a significant impact on investment decisions.
Hence, it is concluded that loss aversion, desire, and fear positively impact the investment
Breda, M., & Berlamont, E. V. (2014, May 26). The Secret of Fear and Greed behind Financial
Chandra, A. (2008, October 1). Decision Making in the Stock Market - Incorporating
CHITRA, D. K., & Jayashree, T. (2015, April). Influence of Behavioural Factors on Investors
Durbin, J., & Watson, G. S. (1951, June 01). Testing for Serial Correlation in Least Squares
Field, A. P. (2009). Discovering Statistics using SPSS (and sex and drugs and rock 'n' roll) (3rd
Guerrero, F. L., Stone, G. R., & Sundali, J. A. (2012). Fear in Asset Allocation During and After
Gupta, S., & Shrivastava, M. (2021). Herding and Loss Aversion in Stock Markets - Mediating
Emerging Markets.
Hu, B., & McInish, T. (2013). Greed and Fear in Financial Markets - The Case of Stock Spam E-
Jain, J., Walia, N., & Gupta, S. (2019). Evaluation of Behavioral Biases affecting Investment
Jausen, I. P., & Nikiforov, A. L. (2016). Fear and Greed - A Returns-Based Trading Strategy
88-95.
Jureviciene, D., & Jermakova, K. (2012, September 3). The Impact of Individuals’ Financial
KARTINI, K., & NAHDA, K. (2021). Behavioral Biases on Investment Decision - A Case Study
in Indonesia. Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business (JAFEB), VIII, 1231-
1240.
KHAN, A. R., AZEEM, M., & SARWAR, S. (2017). Impact of Overconfidence and Loss
KHAN, M. Z. (2017, June). Impact of Availiability Bias and Loss Aversion on Investment
Kumar, A. A., & Babu, D. M. (2018, November). Effect of Loss Aversion Bias on Investment
LEE, C. J., & ANDRADE, E. B. (2011). Fear, Social Projection, and Financial Decision Making.
Li, C. A., & Wang, J. C. (2013). The Influences of Greed and Fear on Fund Performance. The
LO, A. W., REPIN, D. V., & STEENBARGER, B. N. (2005, April). Fear and Greed in Financial
Lowies, G. A., Hall, J. H., & Cloete, C. E. (2013, November). The Influence of Frame
Mahina, J. N., Muturi, W., & Florence, M. (2017, November). Effect of Behavioural Biases on
Mussel, P., & Hewig, J. (2019, July 29). A Neural Perspective on When and Why trait greed
Nalurita, F., Leon, F. M., & Hady, H. (2020, April). Factor Influencing Investor’s Decision
Sekaran, U., & Bougie, R. (2013). Research Methods for Business (A Skill-Building Approach)
(6th ed.).
Wynes, M. J. (2020). Anger, Fear, and Investor’s Information Search Behavior. Journal of
Questionnaire
“The Impact of Loss Aversion, Greed and Fear on the Individual Investors’
Investment Decisions”
The study is being conducted by the students of BS Commerce, Specialization in Accounting and
Finance, University of Gujrat, Hafiz Hayat campus. The primary objective of this study is to find
the impact of loss aversion, fear and greed on the individual investor’s investment decisions. We
wish to assure you that any response you make will be strictly confidential. If you have any
Saniailyas248@gmail.com.
3: 45-57 ( ), 4: 58-70 ( )
3) Education: 1: Under Metric ( ) 2: Metric ( ),
3: Intermediate ( ), 4: Under-graduate ( ),
Fear (Howland, Lachman, Peterson, Cote, Kasten and Jette, 1998) SDA DA N A SA
2 The fear of failing was assessed thought the question “are you afraid of
failing?”
Have you stopped or do you less frequently carry out some of your
3
activities due to fear of failing?
As soon as I have acquired something I start thinking about the next thing
1
I want.
3 I think that happiness is not about the possessions that you have.
5 I prefer to buy too much instead of taking the risk to have not enough.
The uncertainty of whether the market will rise or fall keeps me from
7
buying Stocks.