Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Alexander
Alexander
Alexander
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Istituto Italiano per l'Africa e l'Oriente (IsIAO) is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access to Africa: Rivista trimestrale di studi e documentazione dell’Istituto italiano per l’Africa e l’Oriente.
http://www.jstor.org
by AlexanderNaty(*)
SpearsagainstGuns
(1) This paper is based on field researchamong the Aari people of southwestEthiopia
between 1988-1990.The fieldworkwas generously funded by a Rockefeller Foundation
AfricanDissertationInternship(RF 87001, #19). The archivalresearchin Rome was funded
by the Istitutoítalo-Africano.I wrote this paper with support froma Social Science Research
Council-MacArthurFoundation Postdoctoral Fellowship while I was a postdoctoral fellow
affiliatedwith the Programin AgrarianStudies, Yale University.I thankthese institutionsfor
theirsupport.
(2) Ras is a commanderof the army.The word literallymeans head . This titlewas
the highesttitlebelow the emperor (negus).For biographical informationabout ras Welde-
Giorghis Abboye, referto Mahateme-SellasieWelde-Meskel (1961:71). Ras Welde-Giorghis
was an older brotherof dejazmachsBashah and Lemma Abboye. Both Bashah and Lemma
were reputedto be warriors,and indeed, Bashah died in the battleof Adua (Prouty1976:177);
Gebre-Sellasie (1959:266).
(3) The Aari did not know about guns prior to the conquest. Therefore,they were
confused when theircomrades were shot by bullets when they foughtagainst the imperial
Ethiopian armyof Welde-Giorghis.The Aari termfor a gun is puula, a word which derived
according to Aari informants, fromthe sound of the firingof a gun.
(4) Dejazmach is a militarytitlebelow ras. Literallyit means commanderor the gate .
(5) Both oral informationand the writtensources confirmthat dejazmach Tesemma
Nadew is a cousin of Emperor Menelik II of Ethiopia.
Sarsar
ι
Massa (d. 1880)
I I I
Anno Mugjobaiso (d. 1896) Diksa (d. 1898)
I I
Guri (d. 1937) Banzi (usurper,d. 1930)
Γ" Γ Ι
Magmi Shei Mari
Tilahun
Table 1: Chronology
of the Governorsof Bakko,1904-1937
Governor's
Name YearsofAdministration
(15) For a discussionof the workingsof the gebbarsiratin Aariland,see Naty (1992).
U6) Kas lesemma Madew and fitaurariJJamteware absent from the list or the
governorsof Bakko because theydid not staylong in the region.Accordingto Aari informants,
Duringthegovernorship of BirruHaile-Mariam,theAariweretold
to bringgrainto the marketin Bakko in exchangefor cartridgesthat
The payingof cartridges
were latergivenas tributeto soldiers-settlers.
as tributewas later abolishedwith the introductionof Maria Theresa
talers.It was also duringthe administrationof BirruthatAari families
wereassignedas tribute-paying peasants{gebbar)to the soldiers-settlers.
ElephantHuntingin Aariland
(19) Aari informantsdid not know the name of Geneme's father.Most likely,theywere
referring to Geneme Dilnesaw. Dejazmach Geneme Dilnesaw was also fromShewa. According
to Mahateme-SellasieWelde-Meskel (1961:89), formerly Geneme had been officerin the army
of ras Gobena. During the reignof Emperor Menelik II, Geneme became a fitaurariin the
armyunderfitaurariHabte-Giorghis.This armywas known as ye sanadiryaiand was stationed
in Gamo. Geneme became a dejazmach during the regencyof Yasu. During this period, he
ruled Kambata region.Later Geneme became a Ministerof Interior.But Geneme was accused
of collaboratingwith Yasu, and consequently,he was banished. He died in June, 1921.
Mahateme-Sellasiedid not mention that Geneme ruled Bako or Gofa. But Aari informants
told me thathe ruled Bakko. One neft'ennyareportedthatGeneme was transferred to Bakko,
but for reasons that he did not know, Geneme did not come to Bakko. Two relativesof
dejazmach Geneme whom I interviewedin Addis Ababa, told me that Geneme died in
Garamulettain Harar. Accordingto them,Geneme was also a governorof Illubabor.
-»·£ is' e.
J ' Tripoli'
Ljöo. '
'4v » ^O Ο
Mapl: EquatorialProvince
A Pawn in EuropeanDiplomacy,
Source:Ethiopian, ErnestWork(1935:263).
Publishedby ErnestWork,New Concord,Ohio.
(20) Jesman(1958:123) wrote that in May 1902, Menelik issued a circularletterto all
foreignlegations in Addis Ababa informingthem that Count Leontiev had made false
statements in France, Great Britain, and Belgium regarding his alleged gold mining
concessions.When he was expelled fromEthiopia,Leontiev did not returnto Russia. He lived
in, and died in Paris around 1911 (Jesman1958: 125).
(21) During the period of myfieldwork,one descendantof a Senegalese soldierin Jinka
did not want to be identifiedas a descendant of black Arabs due to the experience he had
encounteredin the 1960s when the Arabs were orderd to leave Ethiopia. During this time,
therewas a rumorthat the descendants of the Senegalese were also to be deported.But in
realitythis did not happen.
(22) Also note thaton pags 45 and 49 in Leontiev's book mentionedearlier,thereare
picturesof ivorythat local people gave as tributeand loaded on muleback.
of Conquestand Colonization
Interpretation
In contrastto the conqueredpopulations,the northernsettlersin
Aarilandholda different interpretationoftheconquestoftheAaripolities
by the imperialAbyssinianarmy. Their understanding of the conquestis
based on economicand legal explanationssuch as are containedin the
idea of colonization(agermak'nat).It is believedthattheobjectiveof the
conquest was to promote economic interactionsthrough market
exchanges,to facilitatesocial interactionsthroughinterethnic marriages;
and to keep law and orderamongthe local populations.One informant
articulatedthe aimsof colonizationas follows:
Colonization{agermak'nat)means to develop the land, to settlepeople
in a land thathas not been settledby populations.When colonization
takes place, markets are established therebypromotingcommerce.
Moreover,law and order are introducedamong the local people. With
colonization,differentethnic groups relate to one another through
(23).
intermarriages
The settlers'perceptionof colonizationemanated from a particular
ideologyofcenter-periphery it had to do with
relations.More specifically,
the notionof a civilizedcenterand a backwardperiphery. The center
was viewed as havinga developed systemof economic exchange,law,
and order.The frontier,in contrast,lacked advanced economic
institutions,law and order.The view thatthe frontiers lacked law and
orderwas based on the assumptionthatsuch regionsand the people
who inhabitthemare wild.
The settlers'view of colonizationhas certainpaternalisticand
"civilizing mission" implications.The introductionof oxen plow
agriculture and marketsamong the conquered populationsare often
mentionedas instancesof their"civilizingmission".Inasmuchas these
practices were promoted, the settlersbragged of their "civilizing
mission's"accomplishments.
The Baaka explain the conquest of theirsocietyby the imperial
armyin termsof the curse of ritualkingMassa. As I indicatedearlier,
the reasonsforthe cursewas the attemptof the threesons of Massa to
Bibliography
I havelistedEthiopianauthorsbytheirfirst I haveusedtheEthiopian
names.Similarly,
calendar(E.C.) forbookspublishedin Amharic.
ASMAI
1901AzioneRussa-Missione Leontieff
e Difficoltà
di Rapporticol Patriarca
Copto.(Posizione
39/3).
1900AzioneRussa.(Posizione39/4,Fascicolo49).
e il Principed'Orléans.(Posizione39/4,Fascicolo47).
1898 Leontiett
1896-97Relazionicol ConteLeontieff-Sua Azione.(Posizione39/4,Fascicolo36).
BUREAUJACQUES, A DiachronieStudyof two Gamo Titles.In WorkingPapers on Societyand
from the 1880s to 1974, Donald
Historyin ImperialEthiopia: The SouthernPeriphery
L. Donald and WendyJames,(eds.), pp. 169-84.Cambridge(U.K.), AfricanStudies
Centre,1980.
DONHAMDONALD, Old Abyssiniaand the New Ethiopian Empire: Themes in Social History.
In The SouthernMarchesofImperialEthiopia:Essaysin Historyand Social Anthropology,
Donald DonhamandWendyJames,(eds.),pp. 3-48,New York,Cambridge University
Press,1986.
Foreign Office,(ReelNo. 18, p. 50), 1898.
-, (ReelNo. 28, p. 158), 1900.
Gebre-Sillasie,E.C, TarikeZemenZe DagmawiMinilik,Addis Ababa, ArtisticPrinting
Press. 1959.
HODSON ARNOLD,Seven Years in SouthernAbyssinia,Wesport,Connecticut,Negro University
Press, 1927.
JENSENADOLF (ed.), AltvolkenSud-Athiopiens:Ergebnisseder Frobenius-Expeditionen
1950-
52 und 1954-56,Stuttgart,
W. Kohlhammer
Verlag,1959.
JESMANCZESLAW(ed.), The Russians in Ethiopia: An Essay in Futility,London, Chatto and
Windus,1958.
Leontiev NICOLAIS., ProvincesEquatoriales dAbyssinie,Paris, 1900.
LeymarieH., Un Dieppoisen Abyssinie,
Dieppe,Impremeriede la Vigiede Dieppe, 14 rue
Claude-Grouland,1989.
Mahateme-Sillasie,Wolde-Meskel,E.C., Che Belew,AddisAbaba,Commercial Printing
Press,1961.
NATY ALEXANDER,1he Cultureof Fowerlessnessand the òpint of Rebellion among the Aart
PeopleofSouthwest
Ethiopia,Ph. D. diss.,Stanford 1992.
University,
PROUTYCHRIS,EmpressTaytuand Menelik II: Ethiopia 1883-1910, New Jersey,The Red Sea
Press,1986.
ROSENFELDChrisP., A Chronology
ofMenelikII ofEthiopia,
EastLansing,Michigan,African
StudiesCenter,1976.
SeifuABAWELLO, E.C, Ye TankK'irs,AddisAbaba,Artistic 1953.
Press,*
Printing
WORK ERNEST, Ethiopia, a Pawn in European Diplomacy, New York, The MacMillan
Company,1935.
ZERVOSAdrian, L'Empired'Ethiopie:Le Miroirde l'EthiopieModerne,1906-1935,Alexandria,
de l'Ecole Professionnelle
Egypt,Imprimerie des Frères,1936.
RIASSUNTO
RESUME
IKIIX/FD CO RIVISTABIMESTRALE
Wlvl If LflvV DELL'ISTITUTOGEOGRÁFICOMILITARE
resp.: Gen.Costantino
Direttore MAGLIO Redattore
capo:Magg.Antonio
FINIZIO
Direzione e Redazione:
presso la sede dell'lstitutoGeográfico Militare- Via C. Battisti,10 - 50122 Firenze
Telefono:(055) 2775242 - TelegrammiGEOMILES - FIRENZE
Condizioni di abbonamento
per il 1995
ABBONAMENTO ANNUO FASCICOLI SEPARATI
Italia £ 36.000 Italia £ 7.000
Estera £ 54.000 Estera £ 10.000
Pubblica articoli, studi, monografie dei più insigni cultori su argomenti di:
geografia física, antropica, económica, política, astronómica, ecc: geologia,
fotointerpretazione, antropologia,etnografia,geografia storica. Si présenta in ricca
veste editoriale,copiosamente illustrataanche a colorie documentatacon artee grafici.