Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pengaruh Tata Kelola Pemerintahan Yang B 08ea934d
Pengaruh Tata Kelola Pemerintahan Yang B 08ea934d
Pengaruh Tata Kelola Pemerintahan Yang B 08ea934d
HOROD
3HPHULQWDKDQ\DQJ
%DLN*RRG*RYHUQDQFH
7HUKDGDS5HVLVWHQVL6RVLDO
3HUXEDKDQ3HPEDQJXQDQROHK
0DV\DUDNDW
KoZW
^]ho]Z
l
Wvv lo}o u]vZv ÇvP ]l µ o]Z ]lvo vPv ]oZ P}}
P}Àvv uµlv oZ µ Áµiµ µvµl ovPPvÇ vP ÇvP uviµviµvP
lvvPvlÇX:]l]l]lvvPvµZvZuvPµvvuÇlU]o
P}}P}ÀvvµlolvÇvPZµvÇUullvuv]uµolvl]
µ]v]µv}olv]uÇlXlvvÇllµ]Pvvllv
]o uvPµvv µ uvPPµ ZlrZl ] uÇlX WµZv Z µµ
ÇvPµZuv]u]uÇllvuv]uµolvv}olv]uÇlµvµluo]vµvP]
v]o]rv]o]ÇvPµZX,o]v]uvi]vvPvP]u]vZouuuZu]ÇvP
]µµZlvuÇlPl]ovvliZvlZ]ovPlvuvPµvvX
<lµv]W'}}P}ÀvvU]v]UµZvUuÇlX
X WE,h>hE À ] u l v ] ] X D Ç l
'o}o]]ÇvPluvPP]µ uvPu]vlv v uolvlv ]lv
uuvPµZ] P] ]vP lZ]µvU µX /lv ]v] ]iµviµvP vPP] lv
o Z µ v Ç u v Ç v µ Z ] v P uµlvZP]]ÇvPl]iµo}oZ
u ] v Z v o u u v i o v l v µZv uvPµvv ÇvP uru
uvPµvvX W} uvPµvv ÇvP ]l]uu]vZU]µµl]u
]olµlv u]vZ uµlv vµl uÇlX>oµUi]lvÇllvo
vvv Z µZvX ou Zo ou]u}]ouÇlÇvP]iµu]
]v]U µiµv ÇvP ]]vP]vlv oZ uvPµZ Á]oÇZ ÇvP lv uvi] }il
lZ]µv v vPZ]µv uÇl uvPµvvU lZ vv }Pu
l µ ÇvP o]Z ]l ] oµuvÇX uvPµvvlvuuolvvvvÇM
EuµvouiovvvÇUuÇllv Dvµµ vvPv vµo]U vµ lX
vµvP uv}ol Z µZv Dl lv uv] iov µvµl
µX,o]v]vµµlvvovX uolvlvvÇX]]v]oZvu]vZ
P] (l} ÇvP ]uvPlv v vP vvPX ^oZ µ lµv] µvµl
]Zu]}oZuÇl]µv]]X uvPZ] vvPv µ v o]v
/v}v] u]Z lvo vPv lµvÇ l}u]uv ÇvP vPP] ] u]vZ µvµl
]lvv]o]vv}uU]uvu]vPru]vP uvlv ]v] lo}o u]vZv
uÇl uu]o]l] v]o] v v} u ÇvP ]l ~P}} P}Àvv v v]o]rv]o]
*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO
oµZµUuolvlvuvuµlv o}P]l]vµl(X
hvvPrhvvP EP Zµo]l
/v}v]dZµvíõðñX X WD,^E
Wu]vZvÇvP]loZ]lou íX d<o}oWu]vZv
}vZ]ovÇXWvvvu]vZ Wu]vZµ^'}Àvuv_
ouoiµuvPµvv]Pl]vP] ouZ/vPP]]lvP]
i]l l vµv vPv lvvPv ^dZ µZ}]À ]}v v
uÇl v uu}oZ µlµvPv ] u]v]}v }( Z +] }(
uÇlXWu]vZviµP]]llv uvlÁ}uv ]v v}vU U ]ÇU
]l i]l }µlÀ]vÇ uuo]Zlv _ ~vPZv v u]v]]
Z]oÇvPuuµuv]vPllvliZv ÇvPÁvvPlP]v}vPr
uÇl v uu]lv uv v }vP ou µZ vPU vP
í
l]ovX /v]oZ uvP i]l lo}o P]vU l}U v P]vÇX X
u ] v Z v Ç v P l ] l ' } À v v o Z
uuvPµZ] uÇl µvµl uolµlv u ] v Z v l l P ] v
]v]X u ] v Z v U µ l v ] v µ ]
lvoolvPµul u]vZvvÇX '}} P}Àvv
vµo] ]l µvµl uuZ vPµZ vÇ u]vZv ÇvP ]lU
lo}o u]vZv ~P}} P}Àvv Ç]µu]vZvÇvPuv
Z ]v] uvPµvv }oZ ZµlµuU uvPZ}u Zl ]
uÇlX dµo]v ]v] ]P] ou µ uvµ]~,DUuvPZP]v]o]rv]o]
P]vX P]v µ ~í lv uuZ ÇvP ]vµ }oZ uÇlU
uvPv] lo}o u]vZv ~P}} v ] u
P}ÀvvU P]v µ ~î Ç]µ ]v] u u v P µ v ( ] o ] µ v µ l
}]oZuvPµvvUvP]vP uvµuµZlv l}v}u] uÇlU
uvPv]vPµZlo}ou]vZv ]l Po]U v uvPZ}u
~P}}P}ÀvvZ]v]Xou lPuv uµl v]U PuU
uvǵµv µo]v ]v] vµo] uvPPµvlv µ l µ U v µ Ç o } l o X ' } }
u} vlv ǵ]] v}u( ÇvP P}Àvv ZµµvPv vPv
]ovPl] vPv µ] µl uooµ]r oÇvv ]uU Ç]µ ZµµvPv
ÇvPouµlµrµlµUo]µU }v}µµX:]l}lP]v
] lorlo ]vvX D} u]vZv]lv]v]r
vo]] ÇvP ]Pµvlv oZ vo]] ]v] P}} P}ÀvvU ul
lµo](ÇvP]]uµolvuvPPµvlv í
Z}Áov]ul&vv}W]µU
Z©Wll}Áovz]µX+XPµvuXX]l}Ávo}l.olïò
òîòlríïrrlo}oru]vZvX(U]lZ]^µU
íîE}ÀuîìíòµlµoîìXîî
*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO
Z]ovÇoZoÇvv]uUv l Z } o ~ ] Z l Ç v P
ulvÇ oZ liZv lvvPvV
uÇlX vPv u]l]vU P}} X } ] v ] l } v v µ
P}Àvv v oÇvv ]u ~}vvµ }]v}vU Ç]µ
uµlvvµvµluÁµiµlv l]ilvÇvP]u]o]lv
liZvuÇlXî ]o]Zvr]o]ZvÇvP]lU
DvµµhEW~hv]E}v lv llv uµ
Ào}uv W}PuU ll]l µvµuÇlV
µ ]v] ÇvP Zµ ]vµ v (X l]ov ~µ]ÇU Ç]µ
] l u v P l v o u l l vÇ luv ÇvP u
vÇovPPv P}} P}Àvv P] uµ ÁP vPU ]l
ï
uo]µW ol]rol] uµµv uµvU
X W ] ~ ] } v U µ v µ l u v ] v P l l v
Ç]µ ÁP vP ]] liZvvÇV
luv µvµl ]lµ PX (l(v.]v~+À]v
o u } v P u ] o v v 8]vÇU Ç]µ }r
lµµv }o]lll]ilv } v lP]vrlP]v
µo]lV ouP Zµ uvPZ]olv
X µv Zµlµu ~µo }( oÁU }µµÇvPµ]vPvµiµv
Ç]µ u]vZ uviu]v vvÇvP]P]lvUv
PlvÇZµlµuviu]vvÇ uv P Pµ v l v µ u Ç
ZlrZl]uvµ]V ]luµvPl]vV
X dvv] ~vvÇU ZX lµv]o] ~}µv]o]ÇU
Ç]µ uµ l]ilv µo]l Ç]µ uµ lµµv
Zµ vvU uµo] ] ou u]vZvU ouP
} vPu]ov lµµvU Á U v u Ç l
o l v v U u µ µ v vPPµvPiÁlµo]l
Àoµ]vÇXµ]v(}u]l v o u P r o u P
}oZZovPV lZ}oV
X Ç vPP ~}v]ÀvU ]X s]]P]~P]Z}oU
Ç ] µ u µ o u P Ç]µ u]u]v v µo]l
u]vZvZµuu]lv uu]o]l]À]] P] iµZ l
oÇvv ÇvP ]l l vU uuvPµv u v
u Ç l v ÇvPo]Z]llvv]o]r
î
,v](EµZ}o]Ud}]vWllWu]vZvvK}v}u]
ZU~:lW']v}UîììñUZouvïìì
ï
/]UZouvïììrïìí
*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO
v]o]luvµ]vÇvPµv]Ào uÇlX Wu]vZ oZ ]
vuvÇiZlvX lÇU}oZlÇUvµvµllÇX
<l]l ]v] uµlv îX Z]v] ^}]o dZ WµZv
}v] lo}o u]vZv WuvPµvv
ou uÁµiµlv vP ÇvP ]o > } v } s ] v ] v Z
v iZX ^o]v ll]l ] uvµo]U ^/ ] ] } ] Z
U ]] vvP o]vvÇ ÇvP P]vv]vP Zv Z vX_ <µv
uvÇvPlµlo}ou]vZv µ PlvÇ µ] vPv
Ç]µWð l} v ] ] Ç v P vÇ l i ] ]
X DuZlv lvvPv uÇlU ZÁ ]v] Zu]
lµu o]vP u]l]v v ouZ ]vP]olµlvllu]ovǵµ
~lZµµvÇ l]v vPv }Pv]]uµo]uvlvµµ
lµµvµvµluvPo}l]lv ÇvP µX Z]v] µ v}olv
µuÇuvPµvvV µZv uvPµvv
X W]}] }o]lU }]oU v µuµuvÇ lv i] ll
l}v}u] ]vPµv ] µµ ÇvP uvPvu v]o]
}vvµV } v P µ l o } u } l
X D v P ] l µ l v u µ uÇlX,orZoµµiµP
l v v P v ] o u ]vlvPvµZvrµZv
uvvlv v uµuµlv ]vvoÇvPouuÇlX
µµl]ilvV zvP Zµ ]Zu] oZ
X d v v ] v ZÁovuvP
vPPµvPv iÁ uvi] uÇl uolµlv oÁvv
P]v ]vZv ] ouoµµZ ZµZvµWñ
]lv]olµllµvvÇV X dlµ Z luµvPl]vv
X ] } l ] u ] v Z v ÇvPl]lZµ]X
]olµlv vPv (l(U .]vU WµZvl]l
v]oV llvX^uµ}vPZµ
(X ^µu] Zµlµu ]ollv ZÁllvuµlv
v]olµlvl}v]vX µµ ÇvP l uu]lv
]o]Z ] ]] µ uvvvÇuvX<Pµv
uvµviµllv ZÁ ]}] v llZµv Z
Ç v P Z µ ] P v P o u ÇvPlvi]]luµ]vZ]
î
tZǵv]vP]Z^v}U
uviovlv P}} P}ÀvvU Ç]µ Z©Wll}XP}}PoX}ul}µuvllíÌí&sl<ÁE,<'
ð
D'òPyEîYuôZôPKshl]U]lZ]^µUíî
Z}Áov]ul&vv}W]µUKX]X E}ÀuîìíòUµlµoíõXïðUvPvuvuZlvv
vµo]
*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO
]v]lvuv]uµolvlµX ll ul l uuZu]
X dlµlvlPPovX }µµvÇ v uvPvPP
W µ Z v u u µ v P l ] v l v ZÁµZv]i]ZvÇ
uvµvµ uÇl µvµl lv uuv] ]
u u ] o ] l ] l u u µ v v ÇvP ]}oZX ^]µ]
]olµ ÇvP µ Z]vPP u]l]vi]]ol
uv]uµolvllZÁvlv lÇv v ]Zl ÇvP
PPo ou uviov] Zo ÇvP uvPµµolv µZv vPv
µµX uÇlX
X d ] l l v P v PX <lÇvX
lµµZvlvµZvX DÇl ] uvPou]
W vvP uvPµvv l}v]] llÇv
uµvPl]v u ZÁ ovPlZ vPlv vµX KoZ lv
µÇvPulvvPoZ ] µ U u Ç l u v }
ovPlZ ÇvP ]l v vX uuZvlvµµ}X
WZo uµvPl]v i ZÁ D Ç l v P P v µ v µ l
o v P l Z µ l µZiµPlv]v]}]oU
]µµZlvuÇlX v o]v lv ul ]l
X dlµ lZ]ovPv µµ ÇvP l]uv]o]~ÀoµÇuÇvP
v]o]P]vÇX o( ovPPvP v ul ]l]
D Ç l v µ ] v P ] v ] l luvv v]ZX
uvPZµ] P]uv ul }u]v] ÇvP ]lv uÇlX
uvPµvvulX:]l }u]v] ]v] uµvµo ] ]Zlr]Zl
uÇl]vZÁullv Ç v P uo lµ l v u v Pµ v v
lZ]ovPvµµUulul µX oo uvPlvU
vµlvuv}olX ^W]v] µuµu uÇl ZÁ ]
X vPPv uv]vPPolv Á]oÇZ uv }u]v]U ul lv
ÇvPµZvÇuvX oÁvv ~v}olv Z
<oµ ] Á]oÇZ ÇvP µZ }u]v]UvP]vPvv
uu]lv lvÇuvv vµ }Çl ov( vvP P]uv
uvPvµvP]l}X uvPµ lZ]µv }]o ~ooW
(X <lZuvvlv íõõóU ÆÀ]]X ^]u }u]v] uvµµ
lÇvX tot]vl~íõõîoZlo}u}l
DÇl uv}ol µZv }}] µv ÇvP uullv
*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO
lµvÇ ]Zl o]vU µ ] uµµv v}v (}uo l ]]lµ
] l l v l o } u } lr l o } u } l l v o u Z
}u]vv µv ÇvP uullv v v v ~ ] v
lµvÇ]Zlo]vµvµl]]lµ }PuV
u]lvvPvvÇX<vul X :]l µµo }Pu µZv
oZ lo}u}l }u]vv ul vv ]lv l
}u]v] ul µZ uvi] lvvPv ~ov ]]
]u ÇvP iµP ]]lv µ }vP µ }vP
ò
]µlvovuvvvÇX uruV
DvPv]}PuuZµv X :]l v}urv}u µÇU
vv ÇvP ]µiµlv µvµl v }]oU v l]vr
uµZ ]olµ uÇlU Zo l]vuÇl]]lvV
µ uµlv µÇ ÇvP X :]l l}uµv]l] ÇvP
vPi]olµlvPµvuv]vPllv lµvP ]l v vPo}o
vPl]vlvuooµ]lP]v }PuvPvuÇlÇvP
]vÀv]vPvvµvvPv lvvvPvµZv]µV
uZµv ] oµ ]u }]o (X :]lllZÁvlv
uÇl ~}µ] ZvP PvX lPPov ou olvv
Dvµµ >]]© ~íõòõU }PuU ]l vPo}o
ov ~ô (l} ÇvP uvi] } P u u µ µ v o u
vÇ i]vÇ ]v] }]o uÇlV
ou uÇl Z }Pu PX : ] l ] Ç µ Z v ] µ
µZvvvUÇ]µWó ]lv ooµ uZoU µ
X : ] l µ i µ v } P u ] u o v Ç v P ] } o Z
u Z µ v ] µ l uÇl ] µZv
]]v(}u]lv vPv µlµ µlµvPuu]V
i o v ] u v P } o Z ZX :]llvlvP]lv
uÇlV oZuuµlvP]P]v
X :]l }l}Zr}l}Z luµl uÇlX
ou uÇlU ]l (}uo
ò
v]oEµZuUDîììõU
ïX WvPµZ d <o}o Wu]vZv
Z©Wll}]}ÇXµlÁXµl]ulíîïðñòóôõlïðïïlîlZdz9î dZZ]v]DÇl
ìv]o9îìEµZuz9îì^]u9îì}u]v]9îìv9îìZ]
v]z&µoo9îìÆX(U]lZ]^µUíîE}ÀuîìíòU ^ ÇvP µZ ]Z ]
µlµoíõXïï
ó
^µÇt]iÇU U uÇl Zl ou
Z©WllÁÁÁXlu}XP}X]lu}µoXZMvuA}vvAZ}Á
P]AíñôU]lZ]^µUíîE}ÀuîìíòUµlµo
íõXïî
*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO
uuµµlvl]ilvÇvP]u]o µ Z v X D o o µ ]
u]vZX ou Zo µZv µl]]Zlv lv uuZu]
uvPµvvU uÇl Zl vvPvÇ µZv Z]vPP
uvPoµlv vvPvvÇX ] u l µ v l v u v ] u
]v]oZ µP u]vZ ou µZv µXZ}volo(r
uviovlv ]v]r]v] v ]] ] v Z v P P Ç Ç ] µ
P}} P}ÀvvX Wu]vZ Zµ uvµviµllv v. ~lµvµvPv
uviu]v ZlrZl ] uÇlX ÇvP lv ]}oZ ]v]À]µ ]
P ] u v i ] l u v P µ v v ]lvvÇ µµ µZv
µ u v P P µ , D v Z]vPP ]v]À]µ µ vPv
ul ll]ovM :]l v]]vÇ lv ]l uolµlv
u u v P u v P µ v v Ç v P µ Z v r µ Z v X h v µ l
]vvP u]vZ ]lU ul vlv (} ZvP PÇU
u]vZ Zµ vv v vµo] uu]o]l] l]uvPv lv
u u ] l v v P v v Z o ] v ] X & } Z v P
viov l uÇlU PÇuµlvµZv Zµ
lv µZ µZv lv i] ~]llv v }vP ÇvP
u v ] u µ o l v l l v X uvPZµlv i]vÇ
Du]lv viov l µZvoZ}vPÇvPuu]o]l]
u Ç l i µ P Z µ llµvU Ç]µ ]u]vvX <l
u u Z l v u } Ç v P ]u]vv ÇvP uu]o]l] llµv
]PµvlvU lv uÇl (}uo oZ uuµµlv vÇ
uu]o]l]oolvPÇvPr µ Z v U ul µ o]l Z µ
X uv]u µZv µX
À] ~îììí uvPµµolv P Wvlv ]v] lv µµl i]l
vlv ÇvP ]lv ]lv P] ovPlZ u
o u u v P ] ] v ] ]v]vPlvvPvµvlv
uÇlU Ç]µ (} ZvP ÇvP o]vX :]l Zo µ i]U
PÇU µÀ ZvP PÇU ul u]vZ l uvlv
v }volo(r]v ZvP ]v]P}}P}ÀvvX
PÇXô µÀ ZvP PÇ ou } vlvU oµ
Ç]µ uvPµl] uÇl µ ]uvPlv vÇv ÇvP
u u ] l v v P Z µ v v ]luµllv &] ~íõóìU ZÁ
]v(}u] vvP oµvÇ µµ ^ou uvPZ] ]u }]o
ô
tZǵv]vP]Z^v}UKX]X
*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO
uÇl ivPv l] v vPv ]l v vµZvÇU ul
}oZr}oZ uÇl l Zµ lv Áµiµ vP ÇvP ]o v
µv uvPv] µµ Zo ÇvP iZX
lvv vPv µÇl ÇvP lv
]µZ_X DÇl l lv X <^/DWh>E
u o l µ l v ] ] v ] ] o Wu]vZZµuvlvlo}o
u v P µ v v µ l u]vZv ÇvP ]l ~P}} P}Àvv
uvPPvPPµ ÇvP ou ]v] vPv vµZvÇX DÇl l }oZ
]lZµ] uÇl v ÇvP oP]o]ZP]}iluvPµvvXZlÇ
l]lZµ]u]vZX Zµuvi]µiluvPµvvXhvµl]µU
ou uvPµvvU l]ilv ou µZvluvPµvv
u ] v Z i µ P Z µ ÇvP ]olµlv u]vZ Zµ uooµ]
u u Z l v l ] o v v } ] uv uÇl µvÇ llµv
l i Z v u Ç l X µvµl uvvµlv v uuvPµZ] }
W u ] v Z Ç } P Ç vÇ µ µ v uvPµvvX K]v] uvPµvv Zµ
uvvPlv uoZ ÇvP ]µiµlv µvµl liZv v l]ov
lvi]i]lu]Zuolµlv uÇl lo uvvPZ l ÁZX
uvPµvvµX:]luuvP WuvPµvv Zµ vrv uviu]v
u]vZ ]vP]v uolµlv l uÇl µvµl uv]lu
uvPµvv µU µZ uvPµvvU v uviu]v ZlrZl
ZµvÇ u]vZ uuZu] uÇl ]o uvPµvv µ l
v uvvP ovPlZ ÇvP uvPµvµvPlvP]uÇlX
Zµ]µZlrZluÇll
PvPPµU uv]uµolv
uv v ]oX hµo Z
uvPµvv iµP ivPv ur
u µvµl lvvPv }vP
µ lo}u}l ]v]À]µ ÇvP lv
uvPPµlvvPvµo]lX,o]µ
u i u u ] l v ] u
}u]v] ÇvP vÇrvÇ lv
uul]ovvliZv
uÇlX
:]l P}} P}Àvv olv
*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO
&dZWh^d<
µlµ
EµZ}o]U,v](Ud}]vWllWu]vZvvK}v}u]ZU~:lW']v}Uîììñ
t]vv}Uµ]U'o}o]]WoµvPµvuv/v}v]U~:lWovPPUîììô
t
v]oEµZuUDîììõU
Z©Wll}]}ÇXµlÁXµl]ulíîïðñòóôõlïðïïlîlZdz9îìv]o9îìEµZuz9îì^]u9îì
}u]v]9îìv9îìZ]v]z&µoo9îìÆX(U]lZ]^µUíîE}ÀuîìíòUµlµo
íõXïï
Z}Áov]ul&vv}W]µU
Z©Wll}Áovz]µX+XPµvuXX]l}Ávo}l.olïòòîòlríïrrlo}or
u]vZvX(U]lZ]^µUíîE}ÀuîìíòµlµoîìXîî
^µÇt]iÇUZ©WllÁÁÁXlu}XP}X]lu}µoXZMvuA}vvAZ}ÁP]AíñôU]l
Z]^µUíîE}ÀuîìíòUµlµoíõXïî
tZǵv]vP]Z^v}U
Z©Wll}XP}}PoX}ul}µuvllíÌí&sl<ÁE,<'D'òPyEîYuôZôPKshl]U
]lZ]^µUíîE}ÀuîìíòUµlµoíõXïð
awtMqajszqnx
^Z/ h>/^,U oZ] ] :lU ó ^u íõõñX :vivP v]]lvvÇ
oZd<WovP]l]U^E:luìól]U^DWEíõî:lU^DE
òó:lUv]v]]&lµo,µlµuhv]À]]}vP}}^uvPX
WvZ uvi] vPP} Wo]µ Á vPo WD< &, hv] îìíðrîìíñU
<}}]v}Wo]µÁvPoWD<&,hv]îìíñrîìíòUvPP}Zl]
>WD 'u <]ov îìíðU Zlµ Wolv D] Kvo]v >WD 'u
<]ovîìíñUv]v]P]ZlµWolvDioZv:µvo
>WD'u<]ovîìíòXu]oW]µo]ZPu]oX}uX
*HPD.HDGLODQ(GLVL-XUQDO