Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MANUSCRIPTREALrealreal
MANUSCRIPTREALrealreal
Samuel Baysah1,2,3, Czarleen David 1,2,3, Lianne Malonzo 1,2,3, Jullens Suarez 1,2,3
College of Dentistry
Research Adviser
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
Table of Contents
Endorsement
Table of Contents
1.0 Introduction 1
2.0 Literature Review 2
2.1 Review of the Related Literature 2-3
2.1.1 Statement of the Problem 3
2.1.2 Sub Problem 3-4
2.2 Research Paradigm 4
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
ENDORSEMENT
This is to certify that the research paper entitled “Knowledge About Medical Emergencies
Among Dental Clinicians in Valenzuela City, An Assessment” prepared and submitted by
Lianne Malonzo, Czarleen David, Danica S. Bagtas, Jullens Soriano Suarez, Samuel Baysah
and Abrahem Al-Ali has successfully passed the oral defense and is ready for ethical review
under Institutional Ethics Review Committee.
Respectfully yours,
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
1
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
1.0 Introduction
In a dental practice, medical emergencies are those adverse medical events that may occur in the
course of a dental procedure. Medical emergencies are defined as the sudden onset of a medical condition
manifesting itself by acute symptoms of sufficient severity (including severe pain) such that the absence
of immediate medical attention could reasonably be expected to result in: placing the patient’s health in
serious jeopardy, serious impairment to bodily functions or serious dysfunction of any bodily organ or
part. (Myles Reiner, MD, “the new definition for a medical emergency”
Medical emergencies do not happen daily in a dentist’s practice, but they are not rare as well. Some data
exists about the prevalence and the severity of medical emergencies in a dental practice. These data,
mainly from older or small studies, suggests that these situations again, are not frequent, but can involve
life-threatening emergencies. The study by Müller et al6 (2008) found that over the 12-month study
period, 57% of dentists reported up to three emergencies and 36% up to ten emergencies. Thus, every
dental practitioner needs to have the knowledge and skills for the correct management of a certain
medical emergency that may take place.
In the journal composed by Te Kaunihera Tiaki Niho in December 2012, medical emergencies that are
encountered during a dental treatment are the ff: Angina and Myocardial infarction, Asthma, Choking and
Aspiration, Diabetes, Epilepsy, Syncope, Hypoglycemia, Hyperglycemia, Hyperventilation (due to
anxiety), Anaphylaxis.
In addition to diagnostic and therapeutic capacities in medical emergencies, preventive strategies during
dental treatment are equally imperative. Primary prevention can be achieved by carefully and
comprehensively obtaining and updating patient medical histories, with emphasis on known allergies,
adverse reactions to medications, chronic illnesses and chronic therapy, and accordingly observing
precautionary actions with respect to findings.
The goal of this study is to assess the knowledge of dental clinicians in a higher educational
institution in Valenzuela City about dental emergencies that may arise during a dental treatment.
Specifically, this study is aimed to know what emergencies they have already encountered during their
practice, pre-pandemic, as in-person and actual management of patients were allowed, and how they
managed it; or the theoretical foundation of knowledge they have acquired during online clinical duty
where discussions of hypothetical cases were facilitated. Furthermore, through the study, assessment of
2
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
the perceived readiness of clinicians to deal with medical emergencies during treatment as to the means,
techniques, and medications available in their emergency kits/ or the knowledge related to those.
According to a study by Khadijah Mohideen et al., which aimed to assess the knowledge of
dental clinical students of Tamil Nadu in the ME understanding and management to create awareness
toward patient care; the majority of participants were mindful of the vital signs; only 55% of the
participants know the importance of checking their respiration rate. The knowledge of identifying MEs
such as anaphylaxis was 91%, and only 27%–37% of the respondents knew to identify angina, transient
ischemia, and lidocaine toxicity.
In another study by Ohoud Alotaibi et al., that assessed and compared the level of knowledge and
attitude toward basic life support among bachelor of dental surgery clinical students (third-, fourth-, and
fifth-year dental students), dental interns, postgraduate students and faculty in the Dental College at King
Saud University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. It was recorded that their findings demonstrate that dental
students and staff had inadequate BLS knowledge. However, they had positive attitudes toward it.
Dentistry is a health profession that should provide complete medical care and treat the whole patient
rather than focusing on the oral cavity.
Charmi Solanki et al., conducted a study that aimed to assess the level of medical emergency
preparedness and knowledge among dental students at four dental schools. It had results where a total of
331 dental students participated in their study. The scores are based on 10 case scenarios presented with a
range of 4.35–8.02. There was no statistically significant difference in the level of preparedness when
dental schools were compared. However, Year 1 and Year 2 dental students had significantly lower total
scores than those of Years 3 and 4. The students in Years 1 and 2 demonstrated less confidence in their
current knowledge to manage medical emergencies. Satisfaction with the training received ranged from
38% to 84%.
According to a study by Giath Gazal et al., which aimed to measure the level of medical-
emergency-related knowledge among senior dental students and clinical trainers in Saudi Arabia; there
was a serious lack of knowledge regarding the management of medical emergency scenarios among the
participants. Only 54% of participants knew the correct management for some frequent and life-
threatening conditions such as “crushed chest pain”, and only 30–35% of participants knew the correct
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
3
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
management of deeply sedated patients with benzodiazepine overdose and crisis of hypoadrenalism.
Moderate-quality knowledge (50–74% of participants responded correctly) was noted for the following
conditions: sudden onset of brain stroke, psychiatric patient, unconscious patient with hypoglycemia,
patient with postural hypotension, and patient with hyperventilation. Based on the scale of knowledge,
there were significant differences in the level of knowledge between clinical trainers, senior dental
students, and junior dental students (p ≤ 0.01). Almost all students and 90% of trainers declared the need
for further training.
According to another study by Nishtha Singh et al., which assessed the preparedness of dental
students to manage medical emergencies in dental clinics; students have received theoretical training but
still the majority of participants feel they are incompetent to handle medical emergencies. Most of them
are willing to undergo proper training to handle medical emergencies and also support the addition of
separate ALS and BLS courses.
In a study done by Ehigiator O et al., which aimed to evaluate the medical emergency education
in a Nigerian Dental School. Only 58.1% (72/124) respondents were aware of the inclusion of a medical
emergency in the dental curriculum and fewer, 17.7% (22/124), were aware of guidelines on medical
emergencies formulated by any dental authority. Fifty-two out of all the respondents (41.9%) claimed not
to have received any form of training on medical emergencies.
Haifa Fahad Albelaihi et al., conducted a study which aimed to investigate and assess the
knowledge, attitude, and perceived confidence of dental students and interns in the management of
medical emergencies. According to their results and conclusion, only 37% of participants were confident
to handle any medical emergency in the dental office. 67% were familiar with the right compression
ventilation ratio showing significant difference between academic years and interns (P = 0.003).
What is the knowledge about medical emergencies among dental clinicians in a higher educational
institution in Metro Manila?
1. What is the dental student clinicians’ level of awareness of different medical emergencies that
may arise in their clinical practice?
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
4
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
2. What are the different medical emergencies the dental clinicians are aware of that may occur
during dental treatment?
3. Among the dental clinicians who have treated live patients, how many have encountered medical
emergencies? What are the medical emergencies that they have encountered in treating live
patients? What are the measures they have taken as they encountered them?
4. What are the measures to be taken by dental clinicians as they encounter medical emergencies?
5. What are the medications commonly used by a dental clinician during a medical emergency?
Figure 1. Medical emergencies are the independent variable. Drugs, attitude, preparedness,
diseases, and knowledge are the dependent variables.
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
5
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Quantitative Approach and Descriptive Design will be used by the researchers to determine the
knowledge of dental clinicians about medical emergencies during dental treatment.
The research will be conducted in a higher educational institution in Valenzuela City, Metro
Manila, Philippines. The respondents were chosen in the specified university because it is one of the most
populous dental colleges in Metro Manila, also will provide diversity for the researchers.
The researchers obtained a master list from the chief of clinics and the secretary of the Dean
regarding the total number of clinicians enrolled this semester. A total population of 264 dental clinicians
currently enrolled in the identified HEI this semester. A sample population of 157 will be asked to
participate in the study. The said students will provide enough population for the researchers to get a
conclusion that is needed in the study.
A Probability Sampling technique will be established in this study specifically the simple random
sampling. Easton and McColl defined simple random sampling as the basic sampling technique where
selection of a group of subjects (sample) for a study from a larger group (a population). Each individual is
chosen entirely by chance and each member of the population has an equal chance of being included in
the sample. Every possible sample of a given size has the same chance of selection
A sample consisting of 157 subjects will be selected as participants of the study. Sample size was
determined using Slovin's formula, from the total population of 264 dental clinicians. Age range of the
said respondents will be 21-25 years old.
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
6
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
- Dental clinicians who have transferred from other universities and have not stayed more
than two (2) years in the university
- Declined to participate in the study or those who do not want to give consent.
Prospective participants will be informed about the study. The procedures for the recruitment of
participants will guarantee that implemented voluntary participation, and they will not be forced to
participate in the study. The details of the research will be thoroughly explained to the participants.
This study will be conducted to raise awareness for the dental clinicians of the identified
university in Valenzuela City regarding medical emergencies that they may encounter in the future, and
most importantly to ensure the safety of the patients in the hands of a clinician.
This study will also benefit the dental academe as recommendations in the reinforcement and
enrichment of knowledge, or possible augmentation of the topics about dental emergencies can be
implemented depending on the gathered information through the study.
The respondents were chosen in the specified university because it is one of the most populous
dental colleges in Metro Manila. The respondents are given survey forms and the questions are about
medical emergencies and the way they will handle such emergencies. Answering the survey took more or
less 10 minutes to answer.
The respondents will be completely anonymous, there will be considerations written on the
informed consent in participating in this research. They can freely decline to participate in the research
and when they decide to proceed with it, they have the authority to stop in the middle of answering the
survey form or skip a question that they find uncomfortable with.
The respondents will be given the informed consent form, as the detailed instructions and the
specifics of the study are stated. Once they confirm, the signature of the participants is affixed in the
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
7
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
informed consent form. This is to confirm that they are willing to take part in this study. The researchers
will ensure that the participants understand the study's voluntary nature by providing detailed
explanations of the purposes of the study, data collection technique, data that will be obtained, data usage
approach, and any potential benefits or risks associated with the procedure. The survey will be conducted
virtually using Google Forms. The link will be sent to the participants via email or Messenger.
The survey questionnaire will be accomplished by the participants once and will take only 10
minutes per participant. They will be given the opportunity to choose the day and time they will be
accomplishing the online questionnaire based on their most convenient time.
Breach of data privacy policy, and the feeling of being judged for their choices can be a potential
risk that participants may encounter. To increase safety and security and to avoid discomfort among the
participants, the researchers will ensure that the survey questions used are free of any unethical or
insensitive statements.
All gathered information in this research study will be stored and kept confidential such as
informed consent form, name of the participants and other personal information. It will be made known to
the participants that data will be used only for research. Researchers will make sure to preserve
confidentiality and all the gathered information will be collected in one folder with a passcode to secure
the information of the participants. In case of publication, it will be required that all the personal
information researchers have gathered will be treated with strict confidentiality. To protect the identity of
the participants, a number will be assigned to serve as identifying code instead of the participant's name.
All the data will be stored until the study is ongoing. Only the researcher who conducted the study could
have a copy of who is on those numbers. All the information will be disposed of or destroyed by deleting
and removing it from the trash bin of the device to ensure privacy of information.
There is no provided incentive from the researchers to be given to the participants for taking part
in this research. The participants will be informed that they had the option of participating in the study or
not, and that they might leave at any time. Participants were also told that participating or not
participating in the study activity would have no impact on their study or reputation.
The participants will be informed of all the details with regards to the study, including the
progress and results. All information entrusted to the researchers is strictly observed and will only be used
for the studies purpose only. The researcher will be giving out the 33-item questionnaires from January to
February of 2023.
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
8
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
INFORMED CONSENT
The selected participants will receive the thorough, complete and easily understood Informed
Consent Form through Google Forms. Respondents will be informed of the contact numbers of the
researchers to give them the opportunity to ask questions if there will be some items in the consent forms
that need clarification. The toggling of the choice in the form “I accept….” will indicate that they
voluntarily and willingly participate in the study. The contents of the informed consent include the
specifics, full scope, and limitation of the research study, the role of the key informants along with their
rights, and protection of the confidentiality of the participants. The personal data is strictly confidential
and will only be used as a part of the said study. Respondents will have the assurance of safety from any
forms of harm, let it be mentally or physically. A counseling session with Dr. Javier or Dr. Alvarez will
be facilitated if risk is encountered. All the data that will be gathered from the respondents will remain
confidential and will be used for educational purposes only. All the rights are reserved for the
respondents, that they will be able to decline their participation in the said activity and will be given the
right of self-consideration.
In the process of Data gathering, ethical clearance will be secured which includes informed
consent forms. The study will use primary data collection procedure. Before starting the survey, the
researchers will prepare a letter addressed to the Dean to allow the researchers to conduct the said survey.
Once researchers acquired the permission, Primary Data will be collected through a questionnaire with
33-items from the chosen participants. The questionnaire will be given through Google Form, sent
through email or messenger.
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
9
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
The data that the researchers will collect will be coded and will be initially examined
using statistical analysis, and will be done subsequently to determine the knowledge of the
respondents about medical emergencies. Using frequency tables and descriptive statistics, a
statistical analysis using percentages. Using frequency
4.0 Results
This chapter presents the analysis and interpretation of data which are arranged in the
sequence of the problems., 29.11%). In terms of experience in handling live patient as clinicians,
majority of them has experienced in handling live patients (n=135, 85.44%)
Age F %
21 4 2.53
22 22 13.92
23 42 26.59
24 44 27.85
25 46 29.11
Total 158 100
Clinic Level F %
1 46 29.11
2 41 25.95
3 26 16.46
4 45 28.48
Total 158 100
Have you managed live patients in F %
the clinic?
Yes 135 85.44
No 23 14.56
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
10
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Table 2: Shows the responses of clinicians when they were asked on how many semesters did
they handled live patient Majority of them handled patient for 1 semester only (n=64, 47.41%).
Responses of clinicians when they were asked whether they have encountered any medical
emergency on live patients, number of times you encountered medical emergency and The
nature or type of medical emergency (n=158)
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
11
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Table 3: Show responses of clinicians when they were asked whether they have encountered any
medical emergency on live patients. Majority of them (n=154, 97.47%) answered no they have
not encounter any medical emergency while managing live patients.
Responses of clinicians when they were asked about the nature or type of medical
emergency they have encountered.
Table 4: Table shows that among the clinicians that have encountered a medical emergency, the
most recurring or common medical emergency is hypertension.
Responses of clinicians when they were asked if they will encounter any medical emergency
in their practice, do they feel the readiness or preparedness to manage it (n=158)
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
12
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Table 5: Shows responses of clinicians when they were asked if they will encounter any medical
emergency in their practice, do they feel the readiness or preparedness to manage it. Majority of
them (n=127, 80.38%) stated that they are ready and prepared to manage medical emergency in
their practice.
ROUTINE PRACTICE
Responses of clinicians when they were asked if they take the patient’s
Medical history before proceeding to their treatment.
Clinic level F %
1 Always 46 100%
Often
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
2 Always 41 100%
Often
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
3 Always 26 100%
Often
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
4 Always 45 100%
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
13
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Often
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
Total 158 100%
Responses of clinicians when they were asked if they take the patient’s blood pressure
before proceeding to their treatment
Clinic level F %
1 Always 43 93%
Often 3 7%
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
2 Always 39 95%
Often 2 5%
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
3 Always 26 100%
Often
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
4 Always 44 98%
Often
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
14
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Sometimes 1 2%
Rarely
Never
Total 158 100%
Table 7: The clinicians’ response on the question I take the patients’ blood pressure before
proceeding to my treatment is 96% of the clinicians answered always and 4% of the clinicians
answered often
Responses of clinicians when they were asked if they take the patient’s temperature before
proceeding to their treatment
Clinician level F %
1 Always 43 93%
Often 3 7%
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
2 Always 39 90%
Often 2 10%
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
3 Always 26 100%
Often
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
4 Always 44 98%
Often 1 2%
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
15
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
Total 158 100%
Table 8: The clinician’s response on I take the patient’s temperature before proceeding to my
treatment 95% of the clinician answered always and 5% of the clinician answered often
Responses of clinicians when they were asked if they take the patients pulse rate before
proceeding to their treatment
Clinic level F %
1 Always 45 98%
Often 1 2%
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
2 Always 40 98%
Often 1 2%
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
3 Always 26 100%
Often
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
4 Always 44 98%
Often 1 2%
Sometimes
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
16
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Rarely
Never
Total 158 100%
Table 9: The clinician’s response to the question I take the patients pulse rate before proceeding
to my treatment is 98% of the clinician answered always and 2% of the clinician answered often
Responses of clinicians when they were asked if they take the patients Respiratory rate before
proceeding to their treatment, they do skin test before administering anesthesia
Clinic level F %
1 Always 41 89%
Often 4 9%
1 2%
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
2 Always 38 93%
Often 3 7%
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
3 Always 26 100%
Often
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
4 Always 41 91%
Often 1 2%
2 4%
Sometimes
1 2%
Rarely
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
17
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Never
Total 158 100%
Table 10: The Clinicians responded to the question I take the patients Respiratory rate before
proceeding to my treatment, I do skin test before administering anesthesia is most of the 92% of
the clinician answered always and 5% of the clinicians answered often, 2% of the clinicians
answered sometimes and 1% of the clinician answered rarely
Responses of clinicians when they were asked if they look for signs and symptoms of
systemic illness or medical conditions when they do general observation
Clinic level F %
1 Always 42 91%
Often 2 4%
2 4%
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
2 Always 38 93%
Often 1 2%
2 5%
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
3 Always 26 100%
Often
Sometimes
Rarely
Never
4 Always 40 89%
Often 5 11%
Sometimes
Rarely
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
18
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Never
Total 158 100%
Table 11: Look for Signs and symptoms of systemic illness or medical conditions when I do
general observation the 92% clinicians answered always, 5% clinicians answered often, and 3%
of the clinicians answered sometimes
Clinical level F %
1 Always 1 2%
Often 1 2%
Sometimes 2 4%
Rarely 3 7%
Never 39 85%
2 Always 4 10%
Often 2 5%
Sometimes 2 5%
Rarely 5 12%
Never 28 68%
3 Always 4 15%
Often
Sometimes
Rarely 1 4%
Never 21 81%
4 Always 15 33%
Often 1 2%
Sometimes 12 27%
Rarely 10 22%
Never 7 16%
Total 158 100%
Responses of clinicians when they were asked if they can perform cardiopulmonary
resuscitation
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
19
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Table 12: The respond of the clinicians on the question I can perform Cardiopulmonary resuscitation is
15% of the clinicians answered always, 3% of the clinicians answered often, 10% of the clinicians
answered sometimes, 12% of the clinicians answered rarely, and 60% of the clinicians answered never
Responses of clinicians when they were asked if they attended a BLS seminar
Clinical level F %
1 Always 1 2%
Often
Sometimes 5 11%
1 2%
Rarely
39 85%
Never
2 Always 2 5%
Often
Sometimes 3 7%
1 2%
Rarely
35 85%
Never
3 Always 3 12%
Often
Sometimes 1 4%
1 4%
Rarely
21 81%
Never
4 Always 5 11%
Often 4 9%
10 22%
Sometimes
1 2%
Rarely
25 56%
Never
Total 158 100%
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
20
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Table 13: The clinicians answered the question I attend a BLS seminar. 7% of the clinicians
answered always, 3% of the clinicians answered often, 12% of the clinicians answered
sometimes, 3% of the clinicians answered rarely, 76% of the clinicians answered never
Responses of clinicians when they were asked if they have immediate contact to the hospital
in case of fatal emergencies
Clinical level F %
1 Always 29 63%
Often 3 7%
5 11%
Sometimes
1 2%
Rarely
8 17%
Never
2 Always 21 51%
Often 2 5%
8 20%
Sometimes
3 7%
Rarely
7 17%
Never
3 Always 23 88%
Often 1 4%
1 4%
Sometimes
Rarely
1 4%
Never
4 Always 22 49%
Often 6 13%
6 13%
Sometimes
4 9%
Rarely
7 16%
Never
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
21
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Table 14: The clinicians answered the question I have immediate contact to the hospital in case
of fatal emergencies. 60% of the clinicians answered always, 8% of the clinicians often, 13% of
the clinicians answered sometimes, 5% of the clinicians answered rarely, and 15% of the
clinicians answered never
The clinicians answered the question if they believe they can manage common
medical emergencies that occur during a treatment
Clinic level F %
1 Always 27 59%
Often 6 13%
8 17%
Sometimes
3 7%
Rarely
2 4%
Never
2 Always 19 46%
Often 4 10%
15 37%
Sometimes
Rarely
3 7%
Never
3 Always 13 50%
Often 3 12%
3 12%
Sometimes
4 15%
Rarely
3 12%
Never
4 Always 20 44%
Often 6 13%
15 33%
Sometimes
3 7%
Rarely
1 2%
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
22
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Never
Total 158 100%
Table 15: The clinicians answered the question I believe I can manage common medical
emergencies that occur during a treatment. 50% of the clinicians answered always, 12%
answered of the clinicians answered often, 26% of the clinicians answered sometimes, 6% of the
clinicians answered rarely, and 6% of the clinicians answered never.
Response of the respondents to the question “Which are considered normal vital signs in
adults?”
Table 16: shows clinicians’ answer to the question, “Which are considered normal vital signs in
adults?”. 91% of the clinicians answered correctly to the question, with clinic 4 having the
highest percentage. Only 9% of the clinicians answered incorrectly.
Response of the respondents to the question “When will the patient's respirations be
recorded?”
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
23
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
3 22 (14%) 4 (3%)
4 38 (2%) 7 (4%)
Total 140 (89%) 18 (11%)
Table 17: Shows clinicians’ knowledge on when a patient’s respiration should be recorded. 89%
of clinicians answered correctly to the question, only 11% answered wrong.
Tables 16 & 17: Shows results of all questions answered by respondents about their knowledge
on vital signs and measurement.
Response of the respondents to the question “Which medical emergency happens most
commonly in a dentist office?”
Table 18: Shows that only 53% of the clinicians’ knows which medical emergency that happens
most in the clinic, 22% are clinic 1.
Response of the respondents to the question “A diabetic patient may have acute symptoms
such as headache, dizziness, sweating, fatigue, and shaking. Which condition is most
likely?”
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
24
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Table 19: Shows which condition is most likely when a diabetic patient may have acute
symptoms such a headache dizziness sweating, fatigue, and shaking. 66% of the clinician got the
correct answer. Clinic 1 had the highest number of knowledge about the condition, 23% and
clinic 4 having the least knowledge 11%.
Response of the respondents to the question “A patient suddenly gets a severe, itchy,
erythematous rash, along with cyanosis, swelling of the face and lips, and numbness in one
arm. Most likely condition:”
Table 20: Shows that only 58% of clinicians have knowledge regarding a certain condition
(anaphylaxis), clinic 1 having the highest percentage.
Response of the respondents to the question “When will the majority of medical
emergencies happen?
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
25
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
2 18 (11%) 23 (15%)
3 6 (4%) 20 (13%)
4 10 (6%) 35 (22%)
Total 36(23%) 122(77%)
Table 21: Shows that only 23% of the clinicians know that the majority of medical emergencies
happen during or shortly after local anesthetic injection.
Response of the respondents to the question “When will the hypersensitivity or allergic
reaction occur?”
Table 22: Shows that 65% of the clinicians know when allergic reactions occur during dental
practice. Clinic 4 and clinic 2 have the highest percentage, while clinic 1 has the lowest.
Tables 18 to 22: Shows results of all questions answered by respondents about their knowledge
on vital signs and measurement.
Response of the respondents to the question “When a patient experiences syncope during
dental treatment, what would be your immediate action??”
Clinical level Correct Wrong
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
26
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
1 34 (22%) 12 (8%)
2 27(17%) 14 (9%)
3 17(11%) 9 (6%)
4 36(23%) 9 (6%)
Total 114 (72%) 44 (28%)
Table 23 Shows that 72% of the dental clinicians know how to manage a patient experiencing
syncope. Clinic 4 has the highest percentage 23%.
Response of the respondents to the question “A young, highly anxious patient suddenly
becomes pale with flushing of the base and develops shortness of breath along with gasping.
What is the best treatment?”
Clinical level Correct Wrong
1 37 (23%) 9 (6%)
2 26 (16%) 15 (9%)
3 16 (10%) 10 (6%)
4 36 (23) 9 (6%)
Total 114 (72%) 44 (28%)
Table 24: Shows that 72% of the dental clinicians know how to treat a patient having an asthma
attack. Clinic 1 and clinic 4 have the highest percentage.
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
27
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Table 25: Shows that 68% of dental clinicians know the immediate treatment to a patient
experiencing hypoglycemia.
Response of the respondents to the question “What will be your immediate management in
case of epilepsy in the dental chair?”
Table 26: Shows that 69% of dental clinicians knows how to manage a patient experiencing
epilepsy in a dental chair.
Response of the respondents to the question “When a patient gets anginal pain, which of
the drugs would you choose?”
Table 27: Shows that 79% of the dental clinicians knows what drug to administer to a patient
having anginal pain, 21% answered wrong.
Tables 23 & 27: Shows results of all questions answered by respondents about their knowledge
on management of medical emergency
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
28
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Table 28: Shows that only 17% of the dental clinicians know that the best dental office
emergency kit is prepared by a dentist based on their needs. Clinic 4 has the highest percentage,
8%. 83% of the respondents got the wrong answer.
Response of the respondents to the question “Which is the first step in identifying the
patient at risk?
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
29
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Table 29: Shows that 80% of the respondents knows the first step in identifying if the patient is
at risk by obtaining the health history, medication and allergy along with the vital signs. Only
23% got the wrong answer.
Response of the respondents to the question “When a patient that has controlled
hypertension is to undergo tooth extraction, registers elevated blood pressure (high blood
pressure) on the day of his appointment,
Table 30: Shows that 97% of the respondents knows that you have to defer a patient’s treatment
(extraction) when the patient has an elevated blood pressure. Only 3% got the wrong answer.
Tables 28 to 30: Shows results of all questions Shows results of all questions answered by
respondents about their knowledge preparedness to avoid medical emergencies.
5.0 Discussion
Medical emergencies can occur in dental wellness centers, and it is imperative for dental
professionals equipped with the necessary knowledge and preparedness to address medical
emergencies that can potentially occur within a dental wellness center. Although medical
emergencies are not a frequent occurrence, in a study conducted in Saudi Arabia approximately
about 67% of then general dental practitioners have managed at least one medical emergency
(Alhamad M, Alnahwi T, Alshayeb H, Alzayer A, Aldawood O, Almarzouq A, Nazir MA.
Medical emergencies encountered in dental clinics: A study from the Eastern Province of Saudi
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
30
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
6.0 Conclusion:
The findings of this study highlight the need to enhance the level of awareness,
experiences, and preparedness of dental clinicians regarding medical emergencies in their
clinical practice. The limited exposure to medical emergencies reported by the majority of
respondents indicates a potential gap in their training.
7.0 Recommendation:
To improve the level of awareness and preparedness among dental student clinicians, it
is recommended to:
1. Increase exposure to simulated and real-life medical emergencies during clinical training.
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
31
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
4. Emphasize the importance of obtaining thorough medical histories, vital sign assessment,
and regular updates on patients' health status.
5. Encourage clinicians to attend Basic Life Support (BLS) seminars and maintain
certification in CPR.
6. Establish clear protocols and guidelines for managing medical emergencies within dental
practice settings.
8. Regularly review and update emergency kits in dental offices to ensure they are
appropriately stocked and include essential medications and equipment.
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
32
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Appendix A
Questionnaire Form
If you had managed live patients, have you encountered any medical emergency?
_____ Yes.
State the number of times you encountered medical
emergency: _________
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
33
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
If you will encounter any medical emergency in your practice, do you feel the readiness or preparedness to
manage it?
_____ Yes.
_____ No.
II. Answer the following questions based on the routine practice while working on live patients or
hypothetical cases:
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
34
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
I can perform a
cardiopulmonary resuscitation
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
35
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
4. A diabetic patient may have acute symptoms such as headache, dizziness, sweating, fatigue, and shaking.
Which condition is most likely?
a. anaphylactic reaction
b. hypoglycemia
c. angina
d. acute myocardial infarction
5. A patient suddenly gets a severe, itchy, erythematous rash, along with cyanosis, swelling of the face and
lips, and numbness in one arm. Most likely condition:
a. convulsions
b. myocardial infarction
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
36
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
c. anaphylaxis
d. transient ischemia
8. When a patient experiences syncope during dental treatment, what would be your immediate action?
a. makes the patient sit in an upright position and give water
b. place patient in Trendelenburg position and give an aromatic ammonia inhalant
c. on their side and splatter water
d. reclined position and give juice or oral glucose
9. A young, highly anxious patient suddenly becomes pale with flushing of the base and develops shortness of
breath along with gasping. What is the best treatment?
a. allergic reaction: epinephrine SC
b. angina; nitrogen-glycerin sublingually
c. asthma: use of albuterol inhaler
d. syncope; lying patient flat and elevating legs
10. A conscious diabetic patient showed symptoms of a rapid pulse, with pale, cold and clammy skin. He also
complained of blurring vision. What is the first-line treatment?
a. oral glucose
b. sublingual nitro-glycerin
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
37
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
c. oxygen
d. IV saline infusion
11. What will be your immediate management in case of epilepsy in the dental chair?
12. When a patient gets anginal pain, which of the drugs would you choose?
a. obtaining a health history, medication and allergy with the set of vital sign
b. by knowing the patient's history during previous dental treatment
c. by identifying and thoroughly charting all existing medical conditions
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
38
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
15. When a patient that has controlled hypertension is to undergo tooth extraction, registers elevated blood
pressure (high blood pressure) on the day of his appointment,
a. I will re-take the blood pressure, and if still elevated, I will defer the treatment
b. I will proceed with the treatment.
Appendix B
Consent Form
College of Dentistry
Information Sheet (to share information about the study with you)
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
39
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Certificate of Consent (for signatures if you agree that your child may participate)
INFORMATION SHEET
INTRODUCTION
Good day! We are dentistry students from Our Lady of Fatima University, currently conducting
research about the medical emergencies in dental practice. We are inviting you to be part of this
research and answer questions involving our topic. You do not have to decide today whether or
not you will participate in the research. Before you decide, you can talk to anyone you feel
comfortable with about the research.
This consent form may contain words that you do not understand. Please ask us to stop as we go
through the information and we will take time to explain.
Medical emergencies in dental practice can occur on a daily basis. We wanted to know how
knowledgeable dental clinicians are about medical emergencies that might occur in their future
practice. We want to know how to handle such situations. We want to be able for this research to
be a guide to future dentists on how to handle such situations and the things that they must have.
This research will involve surveys in the form of questionnaires that will take about less than ten
minutes to answer all the given questions.
RESEARCH INSTRUMENTATION
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
40
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
SELECTION OF PARTICIPANT
Our Lady of Fatima University is a prominent dental university that has been teaching dental
students since 1996. We choose dental clinician’s that are in their 5th and 6th year because they
have completed the clinical courses, and they are attending clinical duties.
VOLUNTARY PARTICIPATION
Your participation in this research is entirely voluntary. It is your choice whether to participate or
not. You can skip questions that are not comfortable answering. You may change your mind later
and stop participating even if you agreed earlier.
PROCEDURES
We are inviting you to take part in this research project. You will be given an online
questionnaire that will be given through email and has questions about the said topic. If you do
not wish to answer any of the question/s included in the questionnaire, you may skip them and
move on to the next question. The information recorded is confidential, your name is not being
included on the online questionnaire, only a number will identify you, and no one else except us
the researchers. This online questionnaire will be stored in a secured computer that only us, the
admin, will have access to. This will be deleted once the research is done.
DURATION
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
41
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
We will hand you a questionnaire to fill up, which will take just about ten minutes to answer all
the given questions. The research study will last this November 2022 and will end this February
2023.
RISKS
We are asking you to share with us some very personal and confidential information, and you
may feel uncomfortable talking about some of the topics. You do not have to answer any
question or take part in the survey if you don't wish to do so, and that is also fine. You do not
have to give us any reason for not responding to any question, or for refusing to take part in the
interview.
BENEFITS
The study will benefit the dental academe as policies in the integration of topics and modules
about the medical emergencies, including their management can be further strengthened and
reinforced.
REIMBURSEMENTS
The information collected will be only used for the purpose of this research study. Your privacy
and responses shall be protected at all times. After the study has been finished, a copy of the
manuscript will be provided to the school and can be accessed at your will. In order to protect the
research participants from any negative effects of harm, confidentiality and anonymity needed to
be maintained. Therefore, researchers treated all information and data in a confidential manner as
possible.
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
42
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
The results of this research will be shared with you and other participants in the research study
before it is made widely available to the public. We will also publish the result so other
interested researchers may learn from the result of this research study.
You may stop participating in this research at any time that you wish without losing any of your
rights.
DATA STORING
The data records that will be gathered are intended to be placed inside a locked file cabinet at
Our Lady of Fatima University (College of Dentistry).
DATA DISPOSAL
After a period of six months, the data records will be destroyed through shredding the paper
records and by deleting the data records in the hard-drive
WHO TO CONTACT
If you have any questions you may ask the researcher now or later even after the study has
started. If you wish to ask questions later, you may contact the researcher Lianne Malonzo at +63
947 264 106.
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
43
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
I have read the foregoing information, or it has been read to me. I have had the opportunity to
ask questions about it and any questions I have been asked have been answered to my
satisfaction. I consent voluntarily to participate as a subject in this study and understand that I
have the right to withdraw from the study at any time without in any way it is affecting my
further medical care.
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
44
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
References:
Müller et al. (2013) Awareness of dental practitioners to cope with a medical emergency:
a survey in Belgium. International Dental Journal, 63(7), 312-316.
https://doi.org/10.1111/idj.12046
Ohoud Alotaibi et al (2015) Basic Life Support: Knowledge and Attitude among Dental
Students and Staff in the College of Dentistry, King Saud University. The Saudi Journal
for Dental Research 122(1) 323-328. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.sjdr.2015.06.001
Ahmed A. (2016)
Knowledge_attitude_and_perceived_confidence_in_handling_medical_emergencies_amo
ng_dental_students. Journal of Research in Dental and Maxillofacial Sciences, 7(4), 233-
240. http://dx.doi.org/10.52547/jrdms.7.4.233
Ehigiator O et al. (2016) Knowledge and awareness of medical doctors, medical students
and nurses about dentistry in Nigeria. Pan Afr Med J., 1(23) 138-145.
https://doi.org/10.11604/pamj.2016.23.172.7696
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3
45
KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MEDICAL EMERGENCIES...
Haifa Fahad Albelaihi et al (2017) Knowledge, Attitude, and Perceived Confidence in the
Management of Medical Emergencies in the Dental Office: A Survey among the Dental
Students and Interns. J Int Soc Prev Community Dent, 7(6), 364-369.
https://doi.org/10.4103%2Fjispcd.JISPCD_414_17
March 18, 2023. Version 3.0 Resubmitted Study Protocol. Reference # 2022-IERC1-
20520 V3