Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Effects of A Feeding Intervention in Patients With Alzheimer's Disease
Effects of A Feeding Intervention in Patients With Alzheimer's Disease
Aims and objectives. This study aimed to investigate the effects of a feeding inter-
vention in patients with Alzheimer’s disease with dysphagia. What does this paper contribute
Background. In patients with Alzheimer’s disease, inadequate food and fluid to the wider global clinical
intake can result in malnutrition, dehydration and increased morbidity and mor- community?
tality. Patients may lose self-care abilities such as self-feeding. • A feeding intervention among
Design. A prospective cohort study. Alzheimer’s disease patients with
Methods. A three-month self-control feeding intervention was conducted prospec- dysphagia significantly improved
patients’ food intake, increased
tively in 30 nursing home residents with Alzheimer’s disease with dysphagia. Pre-
eating and swallowing ability
and post-intervention measures included the Kubota water swallow test, type and and improved eating compliance.
amount of food intake and assessment of nutritional status by triceps skinfold thick- • Nutritional status improvement
ness, upper arm circumference, serum albumin and haemoglobin. We used the Edin- was shown by significant
burgh Feeding Evaluation in Dementia scale to evaluate eating compliance and the increases between pre- and post-
Mini- Mental State Examination to evaluate cognitive function. Pre- and post-inter- intervention values of upper arm
circumference, skinfold thickness,
vention results were compared to evaluate the effects of nursing intervention.
serum albumin and haemoglobin.
Results. Patients’ eating/feeding abilities improved overall, including significantly • Our results can be applied to
increased food intake (p < 0001), decreased levels on the Kubota water swallow improve both the eating/feeding
test (p < 0001) and significant differences in skinfold thickness, arm circumfer- care by nursing staff and the eat-
ence, serum albumin and haemoglobin (all p < 001), indicating improved nutri- ing/feeding abilities and nutri-
tional status of AD patients.
tional status. Edinburgh Feeding Evaluation in Dementia scale scores decreased
significantly, showing improved eating compliance. No changes were noted in
cognition post-intervention. Among 22 patients who initially required feeding, five
patients resumed self-feeding after the intervention (p = 006).
Conclusions. Results of this study show that a feeding intervention can improve
food intake, eating compliance and nutritional status in patients with Alzheimer’s
disease with dysphagia and prevent further decline in swallowing function.
Authors: Li-Li Chen, MD, MS, Associate Professor of Nursing, University, Fuzhou City; Jing Li, MD, MS, Nurse Practitioner,
Fujian Medical University Affiliated Clinical Medical Institute, Fujian Medical University Affiliated Clinical Medical Institute,
Fujian Provincial Hospital, Nursing School of Fujian Medical Fujian Provincial Hospital, Nursing School of Fujian Medical
University, Fuzhou City; Hong Li, MD, PhD, Professor of Nursing, University, Fuzhou City; Ping Chen, MD, MS, Nurse Practitioner,
Fujian Medical University Affiliated Clinical Medical Institute, Fujian Medical University Affiliated Clinical Medical Institute,
Fujian Provincial Hospital, Nursing School of Fujian Medical Fujian Provincial Hospital, Nursing School of Fujian Medical
University, Fuzhou City; Rong Lin, MD, MS, Nurse Practitioner, University, Fuzhou City; Hui-Ying Chen, MD, MS, Nurse Practi-
Fujian Medical University Affiliated Clinical Medical Institute, tioner, Fujian Medical University Affiliated Clinical Medical Insti-
Fujian Provincial Hospital, Nursing School of Fujian Medical tute, Fujian Provincial Hospital, Nursing School of Fujian Medical
University, Fuzhou City; Jian-Huang Zheng, MD, MS, Nurse-in- University, Fuzhou City, China
charge, Fujian Medical University 2nd Affiliated Hospital, Quanz- Correspondence: Hong Li, Professor of Nursing, Fujian Provincial
hou, Fujian Province; Yan-Ping Wei, MD, MS, Nurse-in-charge, Hospital, No 134, East street, Fuzhou City, Fujian Province 35001,
Fujian Medical University Affiliated Clinical Medical Institute, China. Telephone: +86-0591-88216007.
Fujian Provincial Hospital, Nursing School of Fujian Medical E-mail: leehong99@126.com
It is suitable for AD patients of all types at any disease ties, including significantly increased food intake
stage. The validated Chinese version of EdFED has a (p < 0001), decreased levels on the Kubota water swallow
Cronbach’s a of 090, a coefficient of inter-rater reliability test (634% of subjects were grade III to V pre-intervention,
of 081, and a retest correlation coefficient of 089 (Lin decreasing to 233% post-intervention; p < 0001). Among
et al. 2008). The EdFED was administered pre- and post- 22 patients who required feeding pre-intervention, five
intervention to assess subjects’ eating compliance. patients resumed self-feeding after the intervention,
although borderline significance was found (p = 006).
Cognitive function EdFED scores decreased significantly (p < 0001), indicating
The Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) is a brief 30- improved eating compliance. Significant increases were
item questionnaire used to assess cognitive function found in upper arm circumference, skinfold thickness,
(Folstein et al. 1975). It is currently the most commonly serum albumin and haemoglobin (all p < 0001), indicating
used dementia screening instrument in Taiwan and abroad. improved nutritional status. No post-intervention changes
Sensitivity of the scale is 066, specificity 090, with an were noted in cognitive function assessed by the MMSE.
overall correct classification rate of 89% in detecting
dementia and a 90% confidence level in measuring changes
Discussion
(O’Bryant et al. 2008). The 30 items address temporal and
spatial orientation ability, memory, attention and computa- Results of this study show that a feeding intervention
tion ability, recall ability, language skills and structural among AD patients with dysphagia significantly improved
copying. Each correct response counts as one point, while patients’ food intake, increased eating and swallowing abil-
each error or failure to answer counts as zero points. A per- ity and improved eating compliance. Nutritional status
fect score is 30 points, with higher scores indicating milder improvement was shown by significant increases between
cognitive impairment. All subjects completed the MMSE pre- and post-intervention values for upper arm circumfer-
pre- and post-intervention to assess cognitive function. ence, skinfold thickness, serum albumin and haemoglobin.
Our results can be attributed to an intervention model
involving general training as well as feeding training. A pre-
Statistical analyses
vious study (Simmons & Schnelle 2006) showed that when
Categorical and ordinal variables are presented as counts AD patients with eating-swallowing impediments receive
and percentages. Due to the small sample size and possible training in oral functioning, they should also receive a gen-
violation of the assumption of normality, continuous vari- eral training regimen that includes muscular strength train-
ables are described as median and interquartile range ing, functional training of the arms to assist with eating,
(IQR). All variables were measured for each patient pre- selection and the use of auxiliary implements, preparation
and post-intervention. Nonparametric tests for paired of foods, maintenance of oral hygiene before and after food
samples were performed to compare differences between intake and assistance and care from helpers (Simmons &
pre- and post-intervention values. The Wilcoxon signed Schnelle 2006).
rank test was used for continuous and ordinal variables Consequently, our intervention employed comprehensive
while the McNemar test was used for categorical variables. feeding training involving environmental engineering, thor-
All statistical analyses were carried out with IBM SPSS statis- ough meal preparation, selection of suitable utensils, the
tical software version 22 for Windows (IBM Corp., New maintenance of suitable posture, individualised feeding
York, NY, USA). Statistical significance was defined as assistance and emphasis on psychological care.
p-value < 005.
A total of 30 elderly AD patients with dysphagia were Normal swallowing involves a series of complex, coordi-
enrolled, including 17 (548%) males and 13 (452%) nated muscular movements, which are directed by the brain
females with a mean age of 824 68 years. Table 1 and require participation of the mouth, throat and oesopha-
shows the results of comparisons between patients’ pre- gus. Pathologies of any of these areas may induce func-
and post-intervention eating/feeding abilities, anthropomet- tional impairment and lead to aspiration (Liu et al. 2004).
ric and physiologic measurements. Overall improvement The mucous membranes of the laryngeal cavity in AD
was found in patients’ post-intervention eating/feeding abili- patients atrophy and thin with age, the throat becomes
IQR, Interquartile range; EdFED, Edingburgh Feeding Evaluation in Dementia Scale; MMSE,
Minimal Mental State Examination.
*Wilcoxon signed rank test was performed.
†
One unit equals to 2000 kcal.
‡
McNemar test was performed.
§
Shown as number and percentage.
¶
Grade I indicates normal and Grade V indicates severe.
**Higher score indicates higher levels of eating and feeding problems.
loose and lax and patients cannot fully raise their heads. In
Feeding intervention can improve nutrition in AD
addition, sensation in the throat deteriorates, the muscles of
patients
the throat weaken and risk of developing impediments to
swallowing increases. AD patients may readily inhale food In this study, biological and biochemical (serum albumin,
and saliva into their respiratory tracts, causing gagging and haemoglobin) indicators of nutrition, including triceps skin-
suffocation. Long-term dysphagia also puts elderly AD fold thickness, upper arm circumference, serum albumin
patients at high risk for weight loss (Inelmen et al. 2010) and haemoglobin, all exhibited significant improvement
and poor nutrition (McDonald 2008) due to lack of suffi- compared with pre-intervention values. This result was con-
cient food and fluid intake. It may also induce ulcers, aspi- sistent with previous findings (Jia 2002) that biochemical
ration and pneumonia (Sue Eisenstadt 2010). Swallowing indicators of nutrition improved significantly after AD
training in elderly AD patients has been shown to improve patients received 42 days of dietary intervention. The inci-
the flexibility and coordination of the muscles of the dence of poor nutrition among elderly AD patients is about
mouth, throat and neck, reflexively stimulate the central 70% (Li et al. 2005). Long-term poor nutrition reduces
nervous system, promote reorganisation of nerve networks, patients’ ability to respond to stress, impairs immune func-
accelerate establishment of collateral circulation, expand tion, promotes disease progression and increases mortality
the sensorimotor cortex, prevent atrophy of the tongue, (Hong et al. 2005). Feeding and eating skills regress gradu-
throat and neck muscles through disuse, and improve and ally with physical and cognitive degeneration and weight
slow impairment of swallowing function (Qiang 2012). In loss is inevitable despite quality care (Claggett 1989). A
this study, results of the Kubota water swallow test sug- case–control study in AD patients showed that an integrity-
gested that the feeding intervention may effectively delay promoting training programme focused on the eating envi-
deterioration of the swallowing function in AD patients. ronment and encouraging individual eating preferences
The absence of complications of dysphasia such as aspira- resulted in significant weight gains in patients vs. controls
tion and pneumonia also suggested that improving swal- (Mamhidir et al. 2007). The authors concluded that ensur-
lowing may help to reduce the incidence of such ing good meal situations is a high priority for AD patients.
complications. Patients with dysphagia require safe foods that are easy to
swallow and tend not to induce aspiration. Although once elderly AD patients, psychological care must be emphasised
considered ‘life sustaining’, the use of tube feeding is now as well as feeding training, which may help to slow disease
discouraged in dementia patients (Lacey 2004). In this progression and improve patients’ quality of life in addition
study, while considering patients’ preferences, we scientifi- to improving eating/feeding ability and nutrition.
cally selected foods with appropriate forms, and adjusted
the food colours, aromas and tastes with the help of nutri-
Comprehensive feeding intervention supports nurses and
tionists. This gave patients greater eating confidence,
AD patients
ensured adequate nutritional intake and helped to restore
swallowing function, enhancing patients’ quality of life. Throughout the intervention, nurses were supported by
having a defined plan to follow while caring for AD
patients with dysphagia. Research has shown that decision
Feeding intervention can enhance feeding compliance
aids about feeding options in AD increased the knowledge
among AD patients
of nurses and reduced uncertainty and decisional conflict
Among the 17 patients requiring feeding in this study, five (Hanson et al. 2011). Advance care planning is often
began eating on their own after the feeding intervention, neglected in caring for AD patients who cannot participate
which certainly supports more efforts to promote self-feed- in developing a plan, but research shows that having a care
ing in elderly AD patients with dysphagia who can still take plan may benefit end-of-life care for patients with dementia
in food orally. The nutritional status of elderly hospitalised and help improve their quality of life (Sampson et al.
patients with at least basic self-care ability is significantly 2011). A report of another comprehensive feeding skills
better than that of patients who require assisted living or training programme showed that nurses’ knowledge, atti-
are significantly or completely dependent on others for daily tudes and behaviour related to feeding dementia patients
living needs (Li et al. 2013). Patients should be encouraged improved as a result of on-the-job training (Chang & Lin
to resume self-feeding using utensils. This may help to slow 2005). Similarly, the consistent application of the
the deterioration of autonomous eating ability, enhance approaches outlined in our comprehensive feeding interven-
their degree of feeding compliance and their nutritional sta- tion contributed directly to the improved eating/feeding
tus. Nurses in this study were instructed to not only provide situation of the AD patients.
assistance and encouragement, but also to observe AD
patients’ food intake closely to prevent accidents.
Limitations
the eating/feeding abilities and nutritional status of AD performed the statistical analysis. RL is responsible for the
patients. data collection and analysis and help prepared the manu-
script. JHZ, YPW, JL, PC and HYC all help with data col-
lection and statistical analysis. All authors read and
Relevance to clinical practice
approved the final manuscript.
The significant improvement in eating/feeding measures sug-
gest that this feeding intervention model could be developed
Funding
as a feeding skills programme to improve both the eating/
feeding care by nursing staff and the eating/feeding abilities Youth Scientific Research Subject of Fujian Provincial
and nutritional status of AD patients. Health Bureau, P.R.C. No. 2011-1-3. Key Project of Fujian
Provincial Department of Science and Technology, P.R.C.
No. 2012Y0013.
Contributions
LLC carried out the study design, collected the data and
Conflict of interest
performed statistical analysis and also drafted the manu-
script. HL participated in the study design and help The authors declare that no conflict of interest exists.
References
Chan KY, Wang W, Wu JJ, Liu L, of the American Geriatrics Society 59, Li Z (2011) Analysis of concepts connected
Theodoratou E, Car J, Middleton L, 2009–2016. with dementia in the elderly. Chinese
Russ TC, Deary IJ, Campbell H, Hong Z, Zhou F, Huang MS, Zeng J, Ding Journal of Nursing 46, 1045.
Wang W & Rudan I (2013) Epidemi- D & Jin MH (2005) Death rate Li YM, Deng YP, Huang SK, Peng BW &
ology of Alzheimer’s disease and other among urban and rural elderly Alzhei- Cheng LP (2005) Nutritional status of
forms of dementia in China, 1990– mer’s disease patients in the Shanghai elderly Alzheimer’s disease patients.
2010: a systematic review and analy- area: death rate and factors predicting Chinese Journal of Gerontology 25,
sis. Lancet 381, 2016–2023. survival. Chinese Journal of Epidemi- 502–503.
Chang CC & Lin LC (2005) Effects of a ology 26, 404–407. Li XW, Chen Y & Yang QB (2013)
feeding skills training programme on Inelmen EM, Sergi G, Coin A, Girardi A Assessment and analysis of the nutri-
nursing assistants and dementia & Manzato E (2010) An open-ended tional status of elderly hospitalized
patients. Journal of Clinical Nursing question: Alzheimer’s disease and patients. Food and Nutrition in China
14, 1185–1192. involuntary weight loss: which comes 19, 82–86.
Claggett MS (1989) Nutritional factors rel- first? Aging Clinical and Experimental Lin LC, Watson R, Lee YC, Chou YC &
evant to Alzheimer’s disease. Journal Research 22, 192–197. Wu SC (2008) Edinburgh Feeding
of the American Dietetic Association Jia HY (2002) Nursing diagnosis of swal- Evaluation in Dementia (EdFED)
89, 392–396. lowing functional impairment and scale: cross-cultural validation of the
Fernandez M, Gobartt AL, Balana M & advances in rehabilitation care. Nurs- Chinese version. Journal of Advanced
COOPERA Study Group (2010) Be- ing Foreign Medical Sciences 21, 12– Nursing 62, 116–123.
havioural symptoms in patients with 14. Liu YC, Ku HA, Zhao YX, Cui BY, Yang
Alzheimer’s disease and their associa- Kalia M (2003) Dysphagia and aspiration XP & Yu SF (2004) Survey of elderly
tion with cognitive impairment. pneumonia in patients with Alzhei- persons’ cognitive risk factors and
BioMed Central Neurology 10, 87. mer’s disease. Metabolism 52, 36– awareness of misaspiration. Chinese
Folstein MF, Folstein SE & McHugh PR 38. Journal of Nursing 39, 26–27.
(1975) “Mini-mental state”. A practi- Kverno KS, Rabins PV, Blass DM, Hicks Mamhidir AG, Karlsson I, Norberg A &
cal method for grading the cognitive KL & Black BS (2008) Prevalence and Mona K (2007) Weight increase in
state of patients for the clinician. Jour- treatment of neuropsychiatric symp- patients with dementia, and alteration
nal of Psychiatric Research 12, 189– toms in advanced dementia. Journal of in meal routines and meal environ-
198. Gerontological Nursing 34, 8–15; quiz ment after integrity promoting care.
Hanson LC, Carey TS, Caprio AJ, Lee TJ, 16-17. Journal of Clinical Nursing 16, 987–
Ersek M, Garrett J, Jackman A, Gil- Lacey D (2004) Tube feeding in advanced 996.
liam R, Wessell K & Mitchell SL Alzheimer’s disease: when language McDonald P (2008) Making the connec-
(2011) Improving decision-making for misleads. American Journal of Alzhei- tion between diet and nutrition and
feeding options in advanced dementia: mers Disease and Other Dementias cardiovascular and Alzheimer’s dis-
a randomized, controlled trial. Journal 19, 125–127. eases. Explore 4, 148–153.
Mitchell SL, Teno JM, Kiely DK, Shaffer ease: a pilot study. Dysphagia 12, controlled trial of a complex inter-
ML, Jones RN, Prigerson HG, Volicer 212–221. vention. Palliative Medicine 25, 197–
L, Givens JL & Hamel MB (2009) Qiang YY (2012) Effect of evidence-based 209.
The clinical course of advanced care on rehabilitation of dysphagia Simmons SF & Schnelle JF (2006) Feed-
dementia. The New England Journal following stroke. Chinese Journal of ing assistance needs of long-stay
of Medicine 361, 1529–1538. Medical Guidance 14, 1076–1077. nursing home residents and staff time
O’Bryant SE, Humphreys JD, Smith GE, Salva A, Andrieu S, Fernandez E, Schiffrin to provide care. Journal of the
Ivnik RJ, Graff-Radford NR, Petersen EJ, Moulin J, Decarli B, Rojano-i- American Geriatrics Society 54, 919–
RC & Lucas JA (2008) Detecting Luque X, Guigoz Y & Vellas B 924.
dementia with the mini-mental state (2011) Health and nutrition promo- Sue Eisenstadt E (2010) Dysphagia and
examination in highly educated indi- tion program for patients with demen- aspiration pneumonia in older adults.
viduals. Archives of Neurology 65, tia (NutriAlz): cluster randomized Journal of the American Academy of
963–967. trial. Journal of Nutrition Health & Nurse Practitioners 22, 17–22.
Onishi S & Sun QL (1997) Assessment of Aging 15, 822–830. Watson R (1994) Measuring feeding diffi-
feeding-swallowing impediments in Sampson EL, Jones L, Thune-Boyle IC, culty in patients with dementia: devel-
stroke patients and training. Chinese Kukkastenvehmas R, King M, Leur- oping a scale. Journal of Advanced
Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 12, ent B, Tookman A & Blanchard MR Nursing 19, 257–263.
141–142. (2011) Palliative assessment and World Health Organization (2012) De-
Priefer BA & Robbins J (1997) Eating advance care planning in severe mentia: A Public Health Priority.
changes in mild-stage Alzheimer’s dis- dementia: an exploratory randomized World Health Organization, Geneva.