Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 36

!"!##$%!&'$()$*#!+',,-#$%!&'$()$*#.',/")'/#,-&,'&$)-0,-&#1#-2'&3,'-#4)+&%',!

#
!
SBS AUSTRALIA, SCREEN AUSTRALIA, FREDBIRD ENTERTAINMENT & NORTHERN PICTURES
)-#$!!2+$&)2-#5)&3#!+',,-#-!5#1#!+',,-#6%,,-!($-/#4',!,-&
IN ASSOCIATION WITH SCREEN NSW & SCREEN QUEENSLAND PRESENT

Once
Once Upon A Time
Upon A Time In
In
+$"'$0$&&$

-!*&!-(.*&%!*(/()*+,$#!*
<8=3>(?6=@1A

4',!!#7)&
!"#$%&'()*$+'(,-$(.$"(/$'"#$01#'&23#+#$4(33%&1'-$(5#,423#$'"#$(**+$
The untold story of how the Vietnamese community overcame the odds
2&*$.(%&*$'"#1,$6)24#$1&$3%)'14%)'%,2)$7%+',2)12 !
and found their place in multicultural Australia.
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

3#!$!%!&'()!*+,-'.+/!0'1(23.,+)4!5)'6)+2
x 1 Hour National Documentary Program

A STUDY GUIDE by! Marguerite


EXECUTIVE PRODUCERS! !
!"!#$%&'!()*+,$#!*- ! SERIES WRITER O’Hara
! & PRODUCER
-!*&!-(.*&%!*(/()*+,$#!*
-01(#2345617(/(#7869(:7858;(
Sue Clothier & Craig Graham! ! ! ! <8=3>(?6=@1A(
Jacob Hickey

8$9:;;$<=>?$@A<=$7$!BC?$AD<E@>!B<=F$A!G$H!EI$F>D??=$7@F!D7HB7I$F>D??=$J@??=FH7=E$7=E$F>D??=$=FKL
© 2011 ONCE UPON A TIME PRODUCTIONS PTY LTD, SCREEN AUSTRALIA, SCREEN QUEENSLAND AND SCREEN NSW
http://www.metromagazine.com.au

ISBN: 978-1-74295-136-2 http://www.theeducationshop.com.au


ONCE UPON A TIME IN

CABRAMATTA
The untold story of how the Vietnamese community overcame
the odds and found their place in multicultural Australia

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 20122


Introduction

O
nce Upon A Time in Cabramatta is a three-part documentary
program chronicling the largely untold and unknown story of
the Vietnamese people in Australia. It shows how the Viet-
namese community in Cabramatta overcame the odds and
found their place in multicultural Australia.

The story begins with the 1979 landmark decision of Australian Prime
Minister Malcolm Fraser to open Australia’s doors to thousands of
refugees fleeing Vietnam at the end of the war. It is a moment in history
that finally buries the infamous White Australia Policy and transforms a
nation.

The years that follow are as dramatic as they are turbulent. In this
one small Sydney suburb, Cabramatta, the 1980s and 1990s see the
emergence of street gangs, a heroin epidemic and the first political
assassination in Australia’s history. The Vietnamese people are vilified
and demonised. Cabramatta seems to represent all that is wrong with
Asian immigration. The universal support for multiculturalism is a distant
memory.

But as the century draws to a close there is a remarkable turnaround.


The Vietnamese people finally find their voice and claim their rightful,
democratic place in their adopted home. Cabramatta is a community
transformed, Australia, a continent changed forever.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 20123


Curriculum Guidelines

This documentary series would be


suitable for students in second-
ary schools studying the impact of
migration on Australian society and
the complex process of re-settlement.
At its heart is an examination of the
reality of ‘multiculturalism’ as a lived
experience. It would be a valuable
resource in SOSE/HSIE and History
for students studying contemporary
society and migration to Australia.

Once Upon A Time in Cabramatta is difficult period of life in Cabramatta Pre-viewing questions
an important series in presenting the from the late 1970s.
historical and social roots of multi- 1. How many students in your class
culturalism in Australia. It should help While Once Upon A Time in Cabramat- group come from non-English
students understand the complexity ta is about the Vietnamese experience speaking backgrounds?
of the Asian-Australian experience, to of those who came to Australia after
look beyond the many media ste- the Vietnam War from the late 1970s, 2. How many people do you know
reotypes and listen to the voices and it clearly has resonance today as new in your social, sporting and work
experiences of people who have come groups of people attempt to come to worlds whose parents were not
to Australia from a number of different Australia to escape war-torn home- born in Australia?
cultures. lands. How people come and how
they are assisted when they arrive are 3. Have you eaten Vietnamese food?
It would also be a valuable resource questions that are as important in the
for students of English and/or Asian twenty-first century as they were for 4. Share your knowledge of the
Studies who may already have some earlier migrants; immigration policy Vietnam War and Australian
knowledge of growing up Asian in remains one of the most important and involvement in that war.
Australia through texts such as Alice fraught issues in Australia. What did we
Pung’s Unpolished Gem and Brian get right and what did we get wrong in 5. Have you visited Vietnam? Describe
Caswell and David Phu An Chiem’s political, social, economic and hu- the country, the people and how
Only the Heart. Both these powerful manitarian terms in the past? Are there they live.
texts, like this documentary series, ex- lessons to be learned from the nature
plore the migrant experience from the of the Vietnamese experience? 6. What is the most practised religion
perspectives of those on the inside. in Vietnam?
Every journey is different. Some background to the Vietnam War
and a map of the region is provided 7. Name any characters of Asian
For students of Media and Film Stud- in this guide for students who may background appearing on
ies, the series provides an excellent not be familiar with the details of this Australian television dramas.
example of an approach to construct- conflict and Australia’s involvement in (Don’t include racial stereotypes
ing history through personal narra- that long-running war. sometimes portrayed in comedies
tives, archival film and the voices of such as Jen in Angry Boys.)
many people, both Vietnamese and As Episode 1 sets up many of the
Australian, who lived through the often situations and stories that are further 8. Why do you think the parents of
explored in Episodes 2 and 3, an migrants tend to be especially am-
understanding of the issues raised in bitious for their children to achieve
Episode 1 will make it easier for the very high standards in education?
students to understand the nature of
the community and family tensions 9. What would be some of the
and their resolution as they are pre- difficulties for you in having to move
sented in episodes 2 and 3. The pre- to settle in a non-English speaking
viewing questions are better suited to country with few possessions and
middle school students or students very little money?
in schools where there may be fewer
students from non-English speaking 10. How can being part of a harmoni-
backgrounds. ous multicultural community enrich
our lives by encouraging us to
expand our personal horizons?

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 20124


The Filmmakers

Key Crew
Bringing recent history to visual life is a complex and rich field for
documentary makers.

A documentary series such as Once Upon a Time in Cabramatta has


a very large number of people working on it, from researchers to
advisors to editors, graphic artists and time-lapse, aerial, still and
many other technical image makers. The people listed in this crew
list are just a fraction of those involved in the project.

Executive producers SUE CLOTHIER and CRAIG GRAHAM

Series writer and producer JACOB HICKEY

Series director BERNADINE LIM

Director of photography JUSTIN HANRAHAN

Narrator TARA MORICE

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 20125


Background

A map of the region at the end defeat the Japanese. After the victory neighbouring Cambodia and Laos in
of this guide shows the location over the Japanese, the Vietnamese an attempt to disrupt supply routes.
and size of Vietnam in relation to expected to gain their independence, Australian soldiers were in South
Australia. It may give students but the French remained as colonial Vietnam as advisers from 1962. In 1965
some sense of the perilous journeys masters. Many Vietnamese troops Prime Minister Menzies, in an attempt
many people made, and still make, now turned to fighting the French. to tie the United States to defence of
to reach Australia by boat. Some- Australia against any threat from Indo-
times they are at sea for up to three In 1954 the French were defeated in nesia, announced that Australia would
weeks with little food and water. the north at Dien Bien Phu, but in the send combat troops. This included
A very brief account of the back- south, Vietnamese leaders did not conscripted soldiers, National Service-
ground to the conflict in Vietnam want to be part of the pro-Communist men, after 1966. These were chosen
and Australian involvement in that system being set up by the north. The by a ballot of all twenty-year-old males,
war is provided below. country was divided along the sev- though only a small proportion of all
enteenth parallel of latitude, with the eligible men were called up.
The Vietnam War arose out of more south being supported by the United
than a century of foreign occupation of States, and the north by Russia and Most Australian Army operational units
Vietnam. It was a war for Vietnamese China. The north began to send troops served in South Vietnam during the
independence, but also a civil war into the south, supported by southern- war. They served mainly in the Phuoc
between two competing philosophies. ers sympathetic to their cause. Tuy province of Vietnam – at the Nui
Dat base and at the logistics base at
Vietnam has always been subject to The main reason for the United States’ Vung Tau. Many officers and warrant
threats and invasion from its large involvement was a fear that com- officers served with distinction in South
neighbours – particularly China. In munism would spread throughout Vietnamese Army units as part of the
the eighteenth century, a new threat Asia. China had become commu- Australian Army Training Team Vietnam
emerged – the French invaded the nist in 1949, and the Korean War of (AATTV). The normal tour of duty was
area (called Annam at the time) and the 1950s had seemed to show the one year with complete unit replace-
established control. They used the spreading power and influence and ment where appropriate, otherwise the
land as their colony, and created a threat of communism. The Australian unit remained in situ and only the per-
strong French influence, though one government shared this view, and was sonnel changed. The Royal Australian
which did not suppress Vietnamese ready to support the United States in Navy and the Royal Australian Air Force
desires for independence. South Vietnam. were also involved in the Vietnam War.

In the Second World War the Japa- The United States began sending more From mid 1966 the main task of the
nese invaded and Vietnamese nation- and more troops to South Vietnam Australians was to secure Phuoc Tuy
alists fought beside French troops to and extending bombing raids into province in which they were based.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 20126


This involved fighting the North an important factor in choosing where
Vietnam Regular Army soldiers based to live. There is today a large Chinese
there, as well as the local Viet Cong community in the Eastern suburbs of
guerrillas, and denying them food, Melbourne, including Glen Waverley.
supplies and safe places. There was For an excellent account of why immi-
also a significant commitment to im- grants settle where they do, you could
proving infrastructure in the province, read this paper about multiculturalism
with many Australian soldiers being and settlement in Australia at <http://
employed on road and bridge con- www.multiculturalaustralia.edu.au/
struction, among other projects. doc/hugo_1.pdf>.

In 1967 the Australian commitment So, why did so many Vietnamese


reached its peak at about 8,300 per- people choose to live in Cabramatta
sonnel in Vietnam at the one time. In and the surrounding suburbs of
1970 withdrawals began, and by the western Sydney?
end of 1972, the troops had virtually
all been withdrawn, with security of Cabramatta is a south western suburb
the province being handed over to of Sydney, about thirty kilometres
the South Vietnamese Army. In 1975, from the city centre. It is part of the
after the withdrawal of United States’ local government area of the City of
support, the North Vietnamese and the Fairfield. Vietnamese people also set-
Viet Cong guerrillas took Saigon, and tled in surrounding suburbs including
ended the war with the reunification of Canley Vale, Bankstown and Fairfield.
Vietnam under Communist rule. About
57,000 Australians served at some One of the reasons for the presence of
time in Vietnam, with about 520 (dif- large numbers of Vietnamese Austral-
ferent numbers are given by different ians in the Fairfield local government
authorities, depending on the criteria area is that most arrivals were initially
applied) dying as a result of the war.1 Hien Le says, ‘No-one wants to be a housed in hostels in the area, the
refugee … you are a person without biggest of which was the Cabramatta
As this series shows, when the war knowing your destiny … you don’t Migrant Hostel. Cabramatta has a
ended, with the North Vietnamese have control of your life’. But, like history as a migrant ‘transition zone’,
victorious, many Vietnamese began many asylum seekers, family security and has hosted a succession of
leaving their homeland, first by boat and aspirations for their children are post-World War Two arrivals, includ-
and later, arriving on planes chartered paramount. In Son Nguyen’s words, ing British, German, Greek, Italian and
by the Australian government to offer ‘We wanted our children to come here Yugoslav migrants. By 1989, 10,000 of
a safer, more orderly exit and arrival for a better life than in Vietnam’. Australia’s 100,000 Vietnamese-born
process. As we see in this episode, lived in the Cabramatta area.
many boats arrived in Malaysia and All over the world, it is not unusual for
Bidong Island, a staging point for migrants from particular backgrounds The Vietnamese, like their predeces-
those fleeing Vietnam. Why did they to settle in areas where they are close sors, were channelled into Cabramatta
make for Australia? to their fellow countrymen and friends in the resettlement process. Many of
and family. For instance, when one those who had initially settled else-
Reading some of the brief biogra- of the first waves of mostly European where in Australia, including some
phies (in this guide) of some of the migrants came to Australia after who had been placed with sponsors in
Vietnamese people who came to World War Two, Italians and Greeks regional areas, undertook a secondary
Australia when the war ended, as well tended to settle in the inner Melbourne migration to the Fairfield area to join
as listening to their stories, will provide suburbs of Carlton and Fitzroy and a the nascent community. In addition to
some information about why they felt relatively large population of Lebanese the attraction of having Vietnamese
compelled to escape their country. Australians live in Lakemba in Sydney. neighbours, groceries and restaurants,
These choices were often related to the area was appealing in that land
employment opportunities, as they still and houses were relatively cheap
are for many people making choices and it was close to work in western
about where to live. Equally, being Sydney’s manufacturing sector, where
close to friends and fellow countrymen most Vietnamese refugee and migrant
who speak your language and under- arrivals found their first jobs.2
stand your ideals and aspirations is

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 20127


Brief bios of people appearing in Episode 1

Chau Hoang Thanh Hoang Tony Hoang Angie Hong


(Episodes 1, 2 and 3) (Episodes 1 and 3) (Episodes 1, 2 and 3) (Episode 1)
1979 – Chau and her family escape 1980 – Thanh’s parents arrive in 1980 – Tony’s parents arrive in 1971 – Angie arrives in Australia via
Vietnam. Australia. Australia. the Colombo Plan.
1980 – Chau and her family move to 1981 – Thanh is born in Bondi, 1982 – Tony is born in Bondi, Sydney. 1977 – Angie is a Vietnamese
Australia. Sydney. interpreter for the Department of
1987 – The Hoang family moves to
Immigration.
1987 – The Hoang family moves to 1987 – Thanh’s family moves to Canley Vale (next to Cabramatta).
Canley Vale (next to Cabramatta). Canley Vale (next to Cabramatta). 1993 – Angie opens the Thanh Binh
1995 – Tony gets involved in gangs.
restaurant in Cabramatta.
Chau Tho Hoang is a Vietnamese Thanh Hoang, daughter of Chau
1996 – Tony is arrested.
refugee who escaped Vietnam with Hoang, was born 1981 in Bondi. Angie Hong is a Vietnamese refugee
her husband and seven children Thanh took on the primary role 1997 –Tony moves out of home. and former restaurant owner. Angie
in perilous circumstances in 1979. of translator for the family as her 2004 - Tony finds redemption and came to Australia in 1971 under
The freedom that Chau worked parents did not speak English. turns his life around. the Colombo Plan as a student
so hard to obtain for her family Thanh witnessed Tony, her brother, (study scholarship) and was in
Tony is the oldest son in the Hoang
in Australia came at a high price: rise in the drug world as he tried Australia when Saigon fell. She
Family. Tony believes years of
her family suffered from a cultural to earn money and respect. Thanh worked as a Vietnamese interpreter
childhood domestic violence and an
and generational discord and feels that even though her family for the Department of Immigration
estranged relationship with his father
were exposed to dangerous drugs struggled after settling in Australia, in the early 1990s. In 1993, Angie
led to his involvement in the gangs
and criminality on the streets of the opportunities they’ve had would opened the Thanh Binh Vietnamese
and addiction to heroin. Tony served
Cabramatta. Regardless of this never have been offered to them in restaurant in Cabramatta and
jail time for crimes he committed
Chau does not regret becoming an Vietnam. through her restaurant witnessed
during his teenage years. At his
Australian and, thirty years on, her the highs and lows of Cabramatta
lowest point, Tony begged God for a
family is repairing their relationships. and its people, from its darkest days
sign and the next day was handed a
as the heroin capital of Australia to
flyer that read, ‘If you are looking for
its celebration as the food bowl of
a sign from God, here it is’. From that
Sydney’s south-west.
moment on, Tony’s life turned around.
He now has a wife and three children
and spends most of his time giving
back to the community.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 20128


Joe Le David Giang Hien Le Andrew Nguyen
(Episode 1) (Episode 1) (Episodes 1, 2 and 3) (Episode 1)
1983 – Joe Le is born in a Malaysian 1980 – David arrives in Australia as 1975 – 1980 Hien Le spends five 1975 – Andrew is arrested and sent
Refugee camp. a refugee with his father and two years in a Communist re-education to jail by the communist regime.
brothers. camp in Vietnam.
1983 – Joe Le’s family arrives in 1978 – Andrew and his family escape
Australia. 1980 – David moves to Sydney. 1980 – Hien Le arrives in Australia as to a Malaysian Refugee camp.
a refugee.
1992 – Joe’s family structure 1981 – The first issue of the Sunrise 1979 – Andrew and his family arrive
fractures. Daily is printed. Hien Le arrived in Australia as a in Australia.
refugee from Vietnam in 1980.
1998 – Joe moves out of home and David Giang is the managing editor 1981 – Andrew is the victim of a
Prior to his escape from Vietnam
gets involved in drugs. of Australia’s leading Vietnamese violent home invasion.
he served in the South Vietnamese
newspaper, the Sunrise Daily. He
1999 – Joe gets arrested. government as a police officer and 1991 – Andrew runs for Fairfield
arrived in Australia in 1980 as a
was injured during the Vietnam War. council as an independent.
2004 – Joe is released from prison. refugee with his father and two
Following the fall of Saigon in 1975, 1995 – Andrew joins the Liberal
Joe was born in a Malaysian refugee brothers. His father was a journalist
he spent five years in a Communist Party.
camp in 1983 and came to Australia in South Vietnam and when he
re-education camp. Hien has
with his mother. Joe’s mother arrived in Australia established In 1975, Andrew was captured by the
observed the many events that have
re-married during her resettlement. the Sunrise Daily as a monthly communist regime and spent three
shaped Cabramatta and the way the
Joe’s family structure started to newspaper. David later took over years in prison. After his release, he
Vietnamese community has evolved
fall apart when he was nine years the paper. As a journalist and editor, and his family escaped to Malaysia.
and how it has been perceived by
old and his two older stepbrothers David has met with and interviewed They arrived in Australia in 1979.
wider Australia. Hien’s long term
moved out and became involved with all of the leaders in the Cabramatta
goal is to help build a vibrant, Andrew Nguyen was a local
the notorious 5T gang. Joe left home community, including John Newman
cohesive and resourceful Vietnamese councillor for Cabramatta from 1991
at age fifteen because of family and Phuong Ngo.
community within Australia’s to 1995 and from 2004 to 2008.
violence and moved in with gang
multicultural society. Currently, Hien He was also the Board Director of
members. He tried selling drugs as a
is the Vice-President (Planning) of the the South Western Sydney Area
way to make money and developed
Vietnamese Community Association Health Board and Chairman of the
a serious heroin smoking habit. In
in Australia – NSW Chapter (VCA/ Multicultural Health Committee
1999, Joe was arrested and spent
NSW). Hien is also a Senior from 1990 to 1996, and the Board
time in prison for armed robbery. In
Investigation/Conciliation Officer for Director of the Community Health and
2004 he turned his life around. Joe
the Australian Human Rights and Tuberculosis Association from 1992
has been accepted at North Sydney
Equal Opportunity Commission. to 1996.
TAFE where he will attend a sound
design course.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 20129


Andrew Jakubowicz Scott Cook Alan Leek
(Episodes 1, 2 and 3) (Episode 1) (Episodes 1 and 2)
Dr Andrew Jakubowicz is Professor Detective Superintendent Scott Cook 1991–1994 Alan Leek serves as
of Sociology at the University of is Commander of the Asian Crime Commander of Cabramatta LAC.
Technology, Sydney. He has an Squad, NSW Police Force. Scott
2000 – Alan retires from the police
Honours degree in Government from began his career in Cabramatta in
force.
Sydney University and a PhD from 1989 at the age of nineteen. Scott
the University of NSW. Since the early experienced first-hand the difficulties 2001 – Alan makes a submission to
1970s, he has been involved in Asian of policing a traumatised migrant the Inquiry into Police Resources.
research and race relations and the community. In 1994, Scott was Alan Leek was Commander of
development of materialist theories transferred to Task Force Oak, which Cabramatta LAC from 1991 to 1994.
of cultural diversity. As an academic was responsible for investigating During his time in Cabramatta, Alan
at the top of his field, Andrew has Asian Organised Crime. As the would make a point of engaging with
unique insights into the context of violence in Cabramatta escalated, the community as much as possible.
the arrival and settlement of the Scott was asked to complete a risk He never wore a gun and believes
Vietnamese in Australia. assessment of crime in southwest that there is no such thing as Asian
Sydney. His report became known Crime; rather, crime is crime that
as the Cook Report and was one of belongs to no race or religion. In
the catalysts for positive change in 1994, Alan’s term as Commander of
Cabramatta, along with Strike Force Cabramatta LAC ended. He returned
Portville – the investigation credited in 2001 to give critical evidence at
with stopping the escalating violence. the Parliamentary Inquiry into Police
Resources.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201210


Episode 1

Synopsis

As thousands of refugees pour into the Sydney


suburb of Cabramatta, the first Vietnamese community
in Australia is born. But it’s not long before problems
arise. The family structure, so important in Vietnamese
culture, has been obliterated by the war. The secu-
rity of this life gone, young refugees find a sense of
belonging through criminal gangs. A lost generation
is born onto the streets of Cabramatta.

Australia is simply not ready to cope with this


huge influx of refugees and the problems that
arrive with them. And as the cracks begin to show
on the streets there is a fracturing of political support
for multiculturalism at a national level. The future
of Cabramatta and the Vietnamese community in
Australia appears precarious.

Keeping a Viewing Log


This viewing log (Table 2) could be downloaded and printed for
students. Different points and even episodes could be allocated to
groups or individuals.

As you watch this series, make notes on the style and approach of the
filmmakers to telling the story of each episode using the pointers in the
SCREEN EDUCATION left-hand column.
© ATOM 201211
Student Activity 1: Watching the Series

Note: not all the viewing note questions on this sheet will be equally relevant to each of the three episodes.

Episode number ____ (1, 2 or 3)


What are some of the images shown and questions posed
in the opening pre-title sequences of this documentary?
How do they set up the story?

How do the filmmakers utilise the medium of film to tell


this story?

What are some of the ways stories such as this one about
people in contemporary society can be effectively told on
film rather than entirely through words? How do faces
matter, particularly as they change and mature over time?

Identify the major focus of the episode.

The use of interview subjects (both Vietnamese


Australians and others) who describe and account for
their experiences.

The range of images and layering of stills used to convey


something of the period and place.

Images, accounts and/or observations you found most


striking.

Information that was new or surprising.

The timeframe, e.g. year or years referred to in the


episode.

Significant events and dates.

Important contributors to bringing the story to life.

Understanding the refugee experience


There are four sets of questions broadly following the narrative development of the episode. Teachers may like to allocate a
set of questions to different groups of students who can then share their responses in discussion.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201212


Student Activity 2: Why did they come?

SET 1 program and fly refugees into


1978–1983 Australia?

Coming to a new country • In what ways and why was the


Australian community quite unpre-
Part of me wants to let this out so we pared for such large numbers of
can tell this story. But at the same Vietnamese arriving in Australia?
time these stories, they’re water under
the bridge. So for me to bring this SET 2
1983–1989

Multiculturalism {noun} Families under pressure


– the preservation of different
cultures or cultural identities My parents were never around– Joe Le
within a unified society
• How does the arrival of thousands
of Vietnamese radically re-write the
up again it’s like, right, what are you previously understood notion of
doing? – Tony Hoang ‘multiculturalism’?

• List some of the reasons • How well prepared and resourced


Vietnamese people left their were state governments to put in
homeland in such numbers when place effective programs to help
the war ended in 1975 and North these new arrivals to cope in such
and South Vietnam were united a different society?
under a communist government?
• What were some of the factors that
• What roles would at least some of Tony and Thanh Hoang and Joe Le
these people fleeing their home- describe that led to some children
land have played during the war of the first wave of Vietnamese mi- The announcement was made
between the south and the north? grants joining what were described but there was never any sort of
as ‘criminal gangs’?
• What are some of the things
consequential commentary like
people feared and often • How did parental aspirations – ‘and therefore the following
experienced that caused them for their children to have a good things are likely to happen in
to take such extreme action; e.g. education conflict with the realities
what were re-education camps in of family life experienced by their
your neighbourhood. And there-
post war Vietnam? children? fore we expect you to reach out
to them. And it’s going to be a
• What were the strongest common • Explain the difference in the values
aspirations of the adults in settling of family life for children of Viet-
bit difficult because you won’t
in Australia? namese refugees and families who understand what they’re saying’.
had been here for generations? None of these conversations
• What were they leaving behind?
• How did the adults and the chil-
took place.
• In what ways was Prime Minister dren respond to these differing val-
– Andrew Jakubowicz,
Fraser’s 1979 decision to open ues and expectations about what it
sociologist
Australia’s doors to Vietnamese means to be part of a ‘family’?
people fleeing their homeland
such an important, bold and even • How do the activities of some
revolutionary decision? members of minority groups, such
as refugees, lead to the whole
• Why did the government decide group becoming ‘demonised’
to set up an orderly departures in society? Provide some other

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 13


examples of groups who have left home and joined street gangs?
become stereotyped and vilified as
a result of the behaviour of some • More than ten years on from
members. Liberal prime minister, Malcolm
Fraser’s decision to scrap the
• Explain how the widely publicised ‘White Australia Policy’, what did
views of Queensland politician 1988 opposition leader John How-
Pauline Hanson, of historian Geof- ard say about ‘multiculturalism’ as
frey Blainey and of John New- a government policy?
man, the state Labor member for
Fairfield were taken up by some • ‘Forming ghettos and taking
people in the community? Australian jobs’. Why are the state-
ments of politicians likely to be
• In what ways do economic so influential and inflammatory in
recessions and tight employment debates about society that focus
conditions make life tougher for on racial differences?
many people, but especially for
recent arrivals? • Why was the election of Phuong
Ngo as a local government coun-
• Why would it have been so difficult cillor seen as so important to the
for Vietnamese families to access Vietnamese in the Fairfield area?
support services available to peo-
ple undergoing family difficulties, • Why is police officer Scott
alcohol and drug problems? What Cook’s description of his work in
skills do government organisations Cabramatta an important element
and individuals such as lawyers, in telling the story of life on the
social workers and interpreters streets in the 1990s?
need to be able to provide services
Recession, racism, the traumas
to Vietnamese and other recent • Alan Leek, who was Commander
of the past and the isolation of arrivals to Australia? of Cabramatta Local Area Com-
the present are all taking their mand from 1991–1994, does not
• What does Andrew Jakubowicz, believe there is any such thing as
toll. The head of the family, in
the sociologist from the University specifically Asian crime. Why does
particular, is struggling to find of Technology in Sydney, suggest he think the Vietnamese were so
his place in a completely alien is important in ‘socially engineer- fearful of police and mistrusted
ing’ multiculturalism so that the ar- them?
culture.
rival of numbers of different people
into a society is better managed? SET 4
– Narrator of
The 1990s and early 2000s
Once Upon A Time In Cabramatta SET 3
1987 and into the 1990s Crime and Politics

Australian family life and Cabramatta is now a symbol for those • What was state member and
Vietnamese family life are really who long for old White Australia. Labor politician John Newman’s
 – Narrator background?
very different. Vietnamese
children listen to their parents • What were some of the criminal •
and do as they are told. activities that became more com-

Vietnamese children live in


mon in the Cabramatta area that
so alarmed residents, police and What can you
Australia for a while, they begin government and attracted a lot of
to adapt to the Australian way. media attention? be shot for?
• What clue does the meaning of the
– Chau Hoang (Question put to police
5T gang (translated by Joe Le) –
‘missing true love or missing love by Vietnamese)
from the family’ – provide to sug-
gest why some young Vietnamese

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201214


Neither Chau Hoang nor her husband could
speak English and their son Tony could not
speak Vietnamese … the relationship was lost in
translation.

– Narrator

What did he say about members of


the Vietnamese gangs he believed
posed a threat to Australian socie-
ty and particularly to the stability of
communities such as Cabramatta?

• How do Joe Le and Tony Hoang’s


stories put a human face on this
problem of young Vietnamese
boys becoming part of the ‘gang-
drug culture’ that was part of their
life in Cabramatta at this time?

• How does the beating to death of


a high school student in a restau-
rant illustrate the disturbing nexus
between drugs, gangs, violence
and a wall of community silence?

• What sort of call-outs did expe-


rienced paramedic John Ellems
regularly attend in Cabramatta?
Are these typical of many ambu-
lance call-outs in large cities or
were they statistically more com-
mon in the Fairfield region?

• What difficulties would police and


paramedics have faced in policing
the streets of Cabramatta in the
early 1990s?

• What violent events and simmering


For an interactive
social problems flagged in Episode timeline of the
1 are likely to be central to the Cabramatta story and
exploration of Cabramatta and its
people in Episode 2 of this series? many online extras go to:
sbs.com.au/onceuponatime
Map of South East Asia
and part of surrounding and click on various dates to provide
an understanding of the Vietnamese
region experience both in Australia
• Identify Vietnam and the surround- and in Vietnam.
ing countries that were damaged
in the Vietnam War, especially by
massive American bombing raids

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM  15


Map of South East Asia and part of surrounding region

http://www.world-maps.co.uk/continent-map-of-south-east-asia.htm and intercepting


• Note the position of Vietnam in boats carrying
• Identify Vietnam
the region and itsand the surrounding
distance from countries
asylumthat
seekers? • Why might Malaysia have become a staging point for
were damaged in the Vietnam War, especially by
Australia asylum seekers hoping to get to Australia?
massive American bombing raids. • What does the map reveal about
• Identify Christmas Island in the • What
the inherent dangers does this map reveal about the difficulties for
of attempting
• Note
Indianthe position of Vietnam in the region journeys
Ocean and its across the sea
Australian
in smallCustoms and naval boats in patrolling and
distance from Australia. wooden boats? intercepting boats carrying asylum seekers?
• Why might Malaysia have become
• Identify
a stagingChristmas
point for Island
asyluminseekers
the Indian Ocean. • What does the map reveal about the inherent dangers
hoping to get to Australia? of attempting journeys across the sea in small wooden
boats?

Endnotes
• What does this map reveal about
1
http://www.anzacday.org.au/history/vietnam/overview.html
the difficulties for Australian Cus-
2
http://www.dictionaryofsydney.org/entry/vietnamese
toms and Naval boats in patrolling

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 16


Episode 2

Synopsis

The first political assassination in the history of Aus-


tralia leaves the Vietnamese people of Cabramatta
demonised and vilified – the community and the ideals
of multiculturalism itself are in tatters.

At 9.30pm on Monday, 4 September 1994, police are


called to a house in Cabramatta following reports of
gunshots. They discover the body of John Newman,
the state MP for Cabramatta, lying in the driveway of
his home. He has been shot dead. The Vietnamese,
already vilified for propping up a criminal culture,
are now deemed guilty of committing Australia’s first
political assassination.

Newman’s killing plays into a wider concern that is


brewing in Australia, particularly in conservative
politics, that Asians are a threat to the social cohesion
of a nation. The police hit back with highly orches-
trated campaigns to rid Cabramatta’s streets of drugs
and crime. There is limited success. The only real hope
is that the community, so vilified and fractured, will
somehow find its own way to overcome its problems.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201217


People appearing in Episode 2
Many of the participants from Episode 1 also appear in this episode. (See the earlier
pages of this guide for their profiles). Additional individuals include the following:

1995 – Lam arrives with his family in


Nick Kaldas Deborah Wallace Son Nguyen Australia and settles in Cabramatta.
(Episode 2) (Episodes 2 and 3) (Episodes 2 and 3)
1996 – Lam begins experimenting
with drugs in school.
Deputy Commissioner Nick Kaldas Detective Superintendent Deborah 1976–1982 – Son lives in a commu-
has spent thirty years with the NSW Wallace is Commander of the Middle nist re-education camp in Vietnam. Between the ages of twelve and
Police Force. His distinguished career Eastern Organised Crime Squad, seventeen, Lam Nguyen grew up with
1990–1995 – Son and his family live his family in a Thai refugee camp.
includes time in the armed robbery, NSW Police Force. Deb joined the in refugee camps in Thailand. Life in the refugee camps was harsh,
drugs, counter-terrorism and un- Cabramatta Local Area Command as
1995 – Son Nguyen’s family and Lam learned how to survive
dercover divisions, as well as being a Detective in 1991. Deb’s job was to
arrives in Australia and settles in through the trading of small goods
commander of the Homicide Squad engage newly arrived Vietnamese mi- Cabramatta. with other refugees. At the age of
and later the Gangs Squad. Nick led grants and break down the walls of thirteen Lam was caught and put in
1996 – Son’s son Lam begins
the investigation into the assassina- silence that existed within the com- community prison.
experimenting with drugs.
tion of NSW politician John Newman munity. Deb left Cabramatta in 1997
In 1995, Lam’s family migrated to
in 1994 and subsequent conviction and returned in 2000 as a consultant Prior to his escape from Vietnam, Son
Australia. In 1996 Lam became
of Phuong Ngo for that murder. He to deal with the escalating drug was an officer in the South Vietnam-
involved in heavy heroin use. Lam
ese army, a musician, a writer and a
was deployed to Iraq in 2004 by the crisis, before being appointed Crime was charged with possession of
poet. After the fall of Saigon, he was
Australian Federal Government as the Manager in April 2001. It was while drugs and spent a year in prison. Lam
imprisoned for six years in a com-
Deputy Chief Police Advisor helping to in this position that Deb became a struggled to beat his heroin addiction
munist re-education camp. In search
rebuild the Iraqi police. In late 2007, participant in The Cabramatta Project, through home detoxification.
of a better life, Son’s family escaped
Nick was appointed Deputy Commis- a coordinating body responsible Vietnam by boat and spent five years With the help of his parents, Lam has
sioner, Specialist Operations, before for the implementation of the NSW in refugee camps in Thailand before turned his life around. He is married
taking a one-year leave of absence Government’s response to the 2001 arriving in Australia in 1995. with children and is currently working
in 2009 to lead the investigation into Parliamentary Inquiry into Policing in in the family business.
Son and his family settled in
the assassination of former Lebanese Cabramatta. Deb helped implement Cabramatta and for the next ten
Prime Minister Rafiq Hariri for the the drug house legislation and have years struggled with language bar-
UN Special Tribunal for Lebanon. In drug legislation passed. riers, post-traumatic stress, poverty
August 2011 Nick was appointed and a generational culture clash.
Deputy Commissioner, Field Op- When his only son Lam became
erations, responsible for more than involved with drugs and gangs, Son’s
13,000 police officers across NSW. Lisa Maher dream of a better life became a
nightmare. Son struggled for eleven
(Episode 2)
years to keep his family together and
now works to raise awareness of
Prof. Lisa Maher is Program Head of
drug addiction in the community.
the Faculty of Medicine and Senior
Research Fellow, National Centre Lam Nguyen
in HIV Epidemiology and Clinical (Episodes 2 and 3)
Research at the University of NSW.
1990–1995 – Lam Nguyen grows up
Lisa has worked in Cabramatta since
1995 and during that time she has with his family in the refugee camps
run data and video studies on heroin in Thailand.
use documenting the trends and
patterns of drug use in the area.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201218


Student Activity 1
Use the viewing log on page 12 of this guide
to record responses to what you see and hear
in Episode 2.

Student Activity 2
Serious social problems had developed in
the Cabramatta region in the 1980s and this
episode documents those problems that
included drug-dealing and drug-taking and
the often violent behaviour that accompanies
these activities. Many of the people involved
in this sub-culture were young Vietnamese.

One of the most important aspects of


the story shown in this episode is how
Vietnamese-born and Australian-born people
realised that only by working together as a
community could they address the problems
that were damaging the community in
Cabramatta and destroying the ideal of
multiculturalism – social harmony between
different nationalities.

Episode 2 Look around you … all


these little slanty-eyed
people buzzing around.
How did it all go so discontent and fear?
– Man on the street
badly wrong? • How can we accurately gauge the
level of hostility within much of the
There are four sets of questions Australian community to recently
We are in danger of being
broadly following the narrative arrived immigrants? swamped by Asians. They
development of the episode. form ghettos and do not
Teachers may like to allocate a set • What does Tony Hoang say was
of questions to different groups of his main reason for becoming a assimilate.
students who can then share their drug dealer when he was only thir-
– MP Pauline Hanson in her maiden
responses in discussion. teen and still at school? What were
speech to the Federal Parliament in
some of his aspirations?
1996. Hanson won the Queensland
SET 1
seat of Oxley in 1996, securing
1990s • How does Vietnamese social
54 per cent of the two-party
worker Vincent Doan account for
preferred vote in what had been
‘Cabramatta is a tattoo … a tattoo that the numbers of young Vietnam-
a traditional Labor stronghold.
I can’t get rid of and that’s it’. – Joe Le ese becoming part of the gang
and drug culture on the streets of
• Negative and often angry Cabramatta? There’s one thing that they
comments about recent Asian
arrivals to Australia are re-iterated • What do questions asked about
do fear, deportation back
in the early part of this episode. MP John Newman’s assassination to the jungles of Vietnam.
Allied with Liberal leader Howard’s and responses from police and
– John Newman in 1998 in
expressed reservations about politicians suggest as the probable
NSW State Parliament
‘multiculturalism’, how would such motive for this crime?
widely publicised comments have
added fuel to the fire of simmering • What was Newman’s openly

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201219


I wasn’t able to adapt.
Our lives were … we
were adrift. We weren’t
expressed stance against the vio- even sure how to live
lence and crime in Cabramatta? anymore.
• ‘The Asian population … that’s – Son Nguyen, a recent
what gets focused on’. Is this refugee from Vietnam
response almost inevitable in
the circumstances? Is it fair or
justified? • How well does Keating’s rhetoric
of national idealism fit with what
• While the police have a suspect, is happening on the ground in
why is it so difficult to bring a places like Cabramatta?
charge against this person?
• What are some of the conse-
• Describe Phuong Ngo’s role in the quences of ‘the code of silence’
Cabramatta community. on the streets of Cabramatta for
the police enquiries into crime?
• How does police officer Nick
Kaldas describe the two sides of • Outline some of the main dif- streets of Cabramatta, talk about
Ngo’s activities? ficulties facing Son Nguyen and the horror of twenty-four people
his family in starting a new life in dying annually on his patch from
• Describe how Son Nguyen’s Australia? heroin overdoses?
hopes for a new life in Australia
are dashed. • How does Son’s Nguyen’s only • What could and should have been
son, Lam, respond to this new done by the authorities to better
• Why are so many of the visuals in world in Cabramatta? manage this situation? What would
this episode centred on the train have been some of the constraints
station? • What were Tony Hoang’s strongest and limitations on the effectiveness
memories of how he felt when he of policing?
SET 2 was arrested at the train station for
selling heroin? SET 3
‘We count the creation of this rich,
pluralistic and peaceful society as one • What was distinctive about Tri ‘The lack of services for those that
of the most successful multicultural Minh Tran’s code of conduct for need them most not only victimises
societies in the world and one of our members of the 5T gang? a community but reduces the idea of
great national achievements.’ multiculturalism to a distant dream.’
– Paul Keating, Prime Minister • Who sold drugs and who used  – Narrator
in 1994 at the Global Cultural them under this code?
Diversity conference • How is Tri Minh Tran’s life seen
• Is this practice hypocritical on the as ‘a dark map of the first
part of people engaged in the drug generation’? How old was he
trade or is it just common sense? when he was murdered?

• How does Alan Leek, a police • Who delivered the eulogy at Tran’s
officer involved in policing the funeral in 1995?

Cabramatta is not a good look. It’s riddled with economic


problems, unemployment. There’s rampant crime. Levels
of personal security are extremely poor and whatever
multiculturalism is claiming, on the streets of Cabramatta
at that time, for many people it’s a meaningless concept.
– Andrew Jakubowicz

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201220


I saw them as a way to make money. All I saw about these
customers was the money they had. That’s the only thing that
interested me. I didn’t care why they were buying the stuff that
I was selling. I just wanted that money and so that’s what hap-
pened. I didn’t care much for them.
– Tony Hoang

• What other networks for alternative related problems during ‘Operation


activities need to be put in place in Hammer’?
communities such as Cabramatta?
• Having escaped bombs and
• How did the election of new MP bullets in Vietnam, what are Chau
Reba Meagher raise expectations Hoang and her family now facing
about a new and different in Australia?
approach to addressing the
• Were the police getting any closer problems in Cabramatta? SET 4
to making an arrest for the 1993
Newman assassination which hap- ‘A generation of children brought here
pened more than two years before for a better life are being lost to the
Tran’s murder? What continued to streets of a so-called multicultural
hamper their enquiries?
Cabramatta became country that doesn’t know how to help
a test case of what them’. – Narrator
• After Tran’s death, how did the happens when a
5T gang members start behaving • In 1996, a new Federal
differently, particularly in relation to suburb and its Government was elected under
drugs? people are ignored John Howard. What does Andrew
Jakubowicz suggest about
• In what ways does the story told
[by governments]. this government’s attitude to
by Chau Hoang and her son Tony multiculturalism as a positive
personalise the dimensions of – Andrew Jakubowicz social model?
the problem for families whose
children were using drugs and • ‘They have their own culture and
almost inevitably becoming part of religion and do not assimilate.’
a criminal world? • What does the name of the police  – Pauline Hanson, 1996
operation ‘Operation Hammer’ How did the election of Pauline
• Would the de-criminalising of suggest about the nature of this Hanson at this election tend to
drugs as well as the provision of operation to stop the dealing and entrench such attitudes?
safe injecting rooms, detox centres crime at the source?
and other support programs have Why is that word ‘they’ so damag-
helped police, families and users • Describe two of the measures ing as a way of characterising a
deal with the drug and crime prob- police put into action to gain some whole race of people?
lems in Cabramatta differently? For control over the criminal activities?
instance, if selling heroin had not
been a viable economic option for • How effective were these
Tony Hoang and other young Viet- measures in addressing the roots
namese, would he have become of the problem? What were the
involved in crime? monthly arrest numbers for drug-

The law enforcements can’t help these people … can’t even


stop them either. You could lock them up but you can’t lock
them up forever. When they get out they’re going to do
exactly the same if we will not do something for them. It should
be something more comprehensive than that.

– Vincent Doan

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201221


Assimilation – integration into a new society. Benchmarks used by sociologists to assess
the degree of assimilation of immigrants: socioeconomic status, geographical distribution,
second language acquisition and intermarriage.

If the community couldn’t fix ‘They [Vietnamese


the problem, what could we as guage and need to work two jobs parents] are ashamed
to pay for rent and food? of themselves because:
individuals do?
– Son Nguyen • Does Lisa Maher, who was study- 1. As a parent they have the
ing patterns of drug use in the obligation to bring up their
Cabramatta area, fully endorse the children and they have failed
way resources are used by govern- to do so.
• What does an expectation that ments to deal with the problems
new arrivals to Australia will ‘as- epitomised by the ‘junkie express’, 2. They lose face to other people
similate’ suggest they should be of the dealers and the users? in the community, and
able to do? What does successful 3. They feel bad because for all
assimilation into a different culture • How do the stories told by Son the Vietnamese people who
and society require of both the Nguyen and Lisa Maher about a came to Australia, we think that
host community and the recent lost generation suggest something
we have an obligation to do
arrivals? of the magnitude and horror of
something for this community
what happened to many Vietnam-
• Today, what are the countries of ese people who came to Australia?
as well.’ – Vincent Doan
origin of most migrants who come
to Australia to re-settle? This episode ends with Thang
Ngo, who currently works for SBS
• How many non-Asian background television, offering his perspective on The biggest thing that every refugee
students in Australian schools why many Vietnamese came to settle says is, ‘I came to Australia in search
learn an Asian language such as in Australia. Thang became a Fairfield of freedom.
Vietnamese, Indonesian or Manda- councillor in 1999 and had great
rin? success in bringing Cabramatta’s If you want freedom and democracy
social issues to the attention of the you also have to express yourself,
• Does the installation of CCTV mainstream media. make yourself heard and be treated
cameras meet with community the same as everyone else. You didn’t
support in Cabramatta? How can ‘When we left our country, my family come for freedom to be a second-
this technology assist authorities? and I left, not for economic reasons, class Australian. You came to be an
but because we were seeking a bet- Australian just like anybody else.’
• How difficult is it to be a parent ter future for our children … not for
and a role model to your children if us because we were already old. We Read the following responses from
you don’t speak the same lan- wanted a better future for our children the makers of Once Upon a Time in
than they’d have in Vietnam. Cabramatta about their intentions and
hopes in making this series about the

There were certainly members of the community who said to us


that you will never get him [Phuong Ngo]. We think he’s done it
[the murder of John Newman] but you will never get enough evi-
dence or get enough people to come forward to supply you with
the truth, with the information that would ultimately convict him.
There was a feeling that if they did talk to us Phuong Ngo would
know about it and there would be recriminations against them.
– Nick Kaldas, senior police officer

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201222


Student Activity 3: From the Filmmakers

Vietnamese people in Cabramatta.

We knew Cabramatta had a rich and


intriguing history – it was home to
Australia’s only political assassination,
it fostered the emergence of the cul-
ture of Vietnamese street gangs, the
suburb had been labelled ‘the Smack
Capital of Australia’, and then there
was the independent parliamentary
commission into police resourcing.
Now it is the undisputed food bowl of
Sydney’s south-west.

This string of high profile events and


its evolution towards a multicultural
epicentre begged the questions:

What was the real story behind the


headlines? Why and how did this hap- a test-case of national importance. Its understood.
pen? growth through migration coincided
with the abolition of the white Australia The production team included key
As we began to research and develop Policy in 1973 and the dream of multi- people who were descendants from
the series, Cabramatta came to light in culturalism was born here. If we were refugee families and grew up in the
an entirely unexpected way. ever going to put the ghosts of the area. We had both academics and lo-
white Australia Policy to bed and make cal social commentators who actively
The documentary wasn’t about the multiculturalism meaningful, it would took part in the research and back-
headlines; rather, what emerged was happen in Cabramatta. ground work for the film.
a story about a group of war torn
refugees who had risked everything The title ‘Once Upon A Time in In the early decades from the late
to begin a new life in Australia. These Cabramatta’ reflects the depth and 1970s the Vietnamese people were of-
otherwise ordinary people faced a importance of ten vilified and demonised. Cabramat-
series of challenging cultural and ta seemed to represent all that was
social events that would ultimately be Cabramatta to Australia’s migrant his- wrong with Asian immigration. What’s
the making or breaking of them as a tory - once upon a time, not so long more, the community exists against a
people. ago, political backdrop that was fractured,
the universal support for multicultural-
The more we researched the more we Cabramatta was not the thriving food ism a distant memory.
realised Cabramatta was much more bowl it is today. It was not always a
than a suburb; it was a living treasure, multi-cultural success story but a sub- But as the century draws to a close
urb on the verge of self-destruction. there is a remarkable turnaround. The
Vietnamese people find their voice
Documentaries offer a rare and – speaking up to claim their rightful,
privileged opportunity to tell complex democratic place in their adopted
human stories to a wider public. They home. Cabramatta is a community
crystallise both the heart-warming and transformed; Australia, a continent
heart-breaking nature of life and it’s changed forever.
always a wonderful experience to be
privy to a special part of someone’s life Our hope is that the viewer will gain a
journey. greater understanding and apprecia-
tion of how and why the Vietnamese
One of the biggest challenges of this people finally were able to claim their
documentary is ensuring a wider rightful, democratic place in multicul-
perspective and understanding of tural Australia. This is a story of hope
Cabramatta’s story than is generally and courage, told in the hope that the

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201223


lessons learned in Cabramatta can be
applied to other communities trying
to define their place in Australia today.
We hope the audience will see this
series as a touchstone for the wider
multicultural conversation that is hap-
pening in Australia today.

• What light do you think this


episode throws on how recent
arrivals need to be assisted if they
and their children are to integrate
harmoniously into Australian
society?

• Make a list of some of the things


you think need to be done dif-
ferently to prevent the problems
experienced by the first wave
of Vietnamese migrants being
repeated with other new arrivals?

• What did you learn about the dif-


ficulties of leaving some of your
past traumas and experiences
behind when you flee your home-
land to find sanctuary in another
country?

• What did you learn about the


social problems that invariably
accompany the selling and using
of illegal drugs such as heroin?

• What is shown to be valuable in


Vietnamese society that we can
learn from?

• How do you think the filmmakers


were able to persuade so many
Vietnamese people to talk so
openly and honestly about painful
and often shameful aspects of
their lives?
For an interactive
timeline of the
• Why is the question —‘What was Cabramatta story and
it really like for you and your fam-
ily?’— so important to under- many online extras go to:
standing this story as much more
than a set of figures and failures? sbs.com.au/onceuponatime
Text of Andrew Jakubowicz article and click on various dates to provide
about the Vietnamese migrant experi- an understanding of the Vietnamese
ence in Australia. experience both in Australia
and in Vietnam.
http://www.theage.com.au/opinion/
society-and-culture/from-war-to-
tough-new-frontier-the-

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 2012 24


References and resources relevant to Episode 2

vietnamese-path-to-cohesion-20120106-1polu.html

Text of 2007 ABC Four Corners program about crime and drugs in Cabramatta.

http://www.abc.net.au/4corners/stories/s72739.htm

An article from the Australian newspaper by Sally Neighbour about the reality of so-called ‘ethnic crime’.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/features/migrant-groups-going-gang-busters/
story-e6frg6z6-1226017998892

Watch a 7 minute YouTube video about the ‘Com for Unity’ programs in Blacktown, run by local police, designed
to address the problems of boredom, alienation and fighting amongst a group of more recent young arrivals.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9VlhQeDYft0

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201225


Episode 3

Synopsis

As a new millennium beckons, the streets of Cabra-


matta remain in the dark ages, infested by drugs and
crime but slowly the Vietnamese community, so quiet
for so long, finds its voice.

The 8.04 ‘junkie express’ pulls into Cabramatta train


station. By lunchtime at least one thousand users will
have arrived. It’s like this every day. 100 dealers,
many teenagers, buzz around the streets—self made
entrepreneurs in a local black market economy of
drugs and gangland crime. The police struggle to keep
control. It’s 1999 and Cabramatta’s never had it so
bad.

Asians and crime are indelibly linked in the minds of


many. Political support for multiculturalism is now a
distant memory. The only hope is that the community
itself, so vilified and fractured, will somehow finds its
own way to overcome its problems. Slowly but surely
they do. A Parliamentary Inquiry is finally forced and
for the first time the problems and needs of Cabra-
matta are met head on. The Vietnamese, so quiet for
so long, find their voice. Cabramatta becomes a com-
munity transformed. Australia, a continent changed
forever.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201226


People appearing in Episode 3
Many of the participants from Episodes 1 and 2 also appear in this episode. (See
the earlier pages of this guide for their profiles). Additional individuals include the
following:

Thang Ngo Tim Priest Helen Sham-Ho Ross Treyvaud


(Episode 3) (Episode 3) (Episode 3) (Episode 3)
1986 to 1988 – Helen works in 1978 – Ross works at the Stardust
1966 – Thang Ngo is born in Vietnam 1986 – Joins NSW Police Drug Squad Cabramatta as a Solicitor Hotel in Cabramatta

1988 to 1998 – Helen becomes a 1993 – Ross returns to Cabramatta


1977 – Thang and his family arrive in 1996 – Detective at Cabramatta LAC
NSW Upper House Liberal member. to work at the Cabramatta Inn
Australia as refugees (Drug Squad)
1998 to 2003 – Helen becomes 1998 – Ross starts ‘Cabramatta
a NSW Upper House Independent Against Crime’ with Thang Ngo
1999 – Thang becomes a Fairfield 2001 – Makes submissions to the
member 2001 – Ross makes a submission to
City Councillor Parliamentary Inquiry into Police
Resourcing in Cabramatta. Tim 2001 – Helen chairs the 2001 Inquiry the Parliamentary Inquiry into Police
Thang was born in Vietnam in 1966 worked in the drug squad of the NSW into Police Resourcing in Cabramatta Resourcing in Cabramatta
and arrived in Australia as a refugee Police Force (based in Cabramatta) in Helen Sham-Ho first worked in Ross worked at the Stardust Hotel in
in July 1977. He was raised in Epping 1986. He was part of the team that Cabramatta as a solicitor in 1986. Cabramatta from 1978 to 1983 (as
and completed his HSC at Penrith arrested one of the first Vietnamese She became a Liberal Party member Manager from 1980). After spending
High School. Thang Ngo became a drug dealers in the area. He returned in 1988 but resigned in 1998 when the next 10 years in a pub in
Fairfield councillor in 1999. Thang as a detective to Cabramatta in 1995 Prime Minister John Howard refused Sydney’s CBD he came back to work
to denounce what she considered at the Cabramatta Inn in 1993. He
had great success in bringing and worked there until 2001. Tim
to be Pauline Hanson’s anti-Asian worked closely with the community
Cabramatta’s social issues to the played a major role in the Parliamen-
rhetoric. Helen subsequently became and the Chamber of Commerce and
attention of the mainstream media. tary Inquiry into Police Resourcing in
an Independent Member of the where possible the Cabramatta police
Thang was instrumental in bringing Cabramatta. and politicians of the area. He was
NSW Upper House. Her proudest
about the Parliamentary Inquiry into a vocal member of the community
achievement in politics was when
Policing in Cabramatta and helped agitating for change. He and Thang
she chaired the Standing Committee
draft its Terms of Reference. Thang is Number 3 which ran the 2001 Inquiry Ngo formed ‘Cabramatta against
currently ALC Strategy and Planning into Police Resourcing in Cabramatta. Crime’ and he played an important
Manager at SBS. Helen retired from politics in 2003. role in the Parliamentary Inquiry with
his submission to the committee.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201227


Student Activity 1
Use the Viewing Log on page 12 of this guide to record respons-
es to what you see and hear in Episode 3.

Student Activity 2
‘It was absolutely unbelievable that crime could get to the level it
did in this area and nobody seemed to care’. (Ross Treyvaud)

Serious social problems had developed in the Cabramatta region


in the 1980s and beyond, manifested in drug use and drug
dealing and the often violent behaviour that accompanies these
activities. Many of the people involved in this sub-culture were
young Vietnamese.

One of the most important aspects of the story shown in this final
episode is how Vietnamese born and Australian born people from
many walks of life realised that only by working together as a
community with the help of police and politicians could they turn
around the situation that had led to Cabramatta being dubbed as ‘Cabramatta became the
‘the heroin capital of Australia’. The Vietnamese people needed
to show a new and different face of what multiculturalism could epitome of all that might
be. As the new century began, changes were beginning and the be wrong with Asian
image of Cabramatta began to change. This episode shows how migration to Australia....that
some of those changes came about and the people behind them.
anyone form Cabramatta
suddenly became a criminal,
a murderer, a drug fiend,
prostitute.’
Episode 2 A community finally finds its voice
Andrew Jakubowicz.

There are four sets of questions SET 1


broadly following the narrative devel-
opment of the episode. Teachers may How bad could things get? • How did the arrest of Phuong
like to allocate a set of questions to Ngo for the murder of John New-
different groups of students who can ‘The heroin capital of Australia...and man entrench negative attitudes
then share their responses in discus- Tony Hoang {after 6 months jail} goes towards the whole Vietnamese
sion. back to making a living in a place that community?
appears to have become an aban-
doned hell’. Narrator. • Describe the conflicted feelings
Tony Hoang’s mother felt about
‘People labelled Cabramatta as • What did the media and many her son’s choices and way of life.
people in the Australian commu-
a bad place from just the minority nity suggest that the charging of • What prompts publican and Presi-
of the people that, like me, got Phuong Ngo with John Newman’s dent of the Cabramatta Chamber
on drugs and did bad things murder signified about the Viet- of Commerce, Ross Treyvaud,
namese community? into action to promote and effect
and gave Cabramatta and our change?
community a bad rap.’ • Is it reasonable to generalise about
a whole community based on the • How did the fact that Cabramatta
(Tony Hoang) crimes of a few individuals? What was a safe Labor seat possibly
is the term often used for such delay the complex interventions
– Son Nguyen generalising, particularly about an that were required?
ethnic group?

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201228


• What was the result of the police • What are many people’s main ob-
crackdown on the streets of Op- ‘The wall of silence...is jections to the setting up of such
eration Puccini on how the dealers, a sign that the community places?
including young Tony Hoang,
don’t trust the wider
conducted their trade? (Read a 2011 article about council
political system’. support and State Government rejec-
• What does Tony Hoang’s story re- tion of a proposal to set up a safe
– Andrew Jakubowicz
veal about the insidious attractions injecting room in Richmond in Victoria
of the illegal drug trade for young at http://www.abc.net.au/news/2011-
men like Tony?
‘It’s four and a half years 05-18/baillieu-vetoes-injecting-room-
since a detox centre was plan/2717488
• How did the ‘drug houses’ create promised’.
further problems for the commu- • What was being used as defacto
nity, the police and paramedics like – Narrator shooting- up place in Cabramatta?
John Ellems?
‘All we’re doing is SET 3
SET 2 facilitating people
‘ The Vietnamese people finally have
‘Thang was able to represent his com-
injecting drugs and not a new leader willing to fight on their
munity and give his community a voice doing anything to help behalf and they also have an Aussie
and stand up to the authorities and rehabilitate them.’ publican on their side — old and new
say, ‘Listen...you can’t say all Vietnam- Australia joining forces in the battle.’
ese are silent because I’m not silent –Thang Ngo describing (Narrator)
and I’m here to tell you exactly what’s the way people shoot
going on’. (Ross Treyvaud) up in the area • What is the reality of Prime Minis-
ter Howard’s call to ‘get tough on
• What work experience and per- drugs’ in 1997?
sonal qualities made Thang Ngo
a strong advocate and role model • Did this call and the visits of ex-
for young Vietnamese people who perts and politicians to the streets
often felt powerless? How are the • When 20 hospital beds are opened of Cabramatta cause any real
local roots of his political activities up to treat drug addicts, does this changes in Tony Hoang’s life?
similar to those of Phuong Ngo, make a large dent in the problem?
John Newman and Chris Bowen What is the problem with offer- • What are some of the crimes that
(currently Federal Minister for Im- ing treatment programs that are are becoming increasingly com-
migration)? Check Thang’s profile not necessarily appropriate or mon in Cabramatta?
in the early part of this Episode 3 adequate to meet the needs of the
guide. community? What are some of the
problems Vincent Doan describes
• How is his refusal to accept how in relation to these programs being
bad things have become different able to assist the Vietnamese?
to the fear of authority and silent
passivity Thang saw in many oth- • What possible approach to helping
ers? Vietnamese kids get off drugs per-
manently does Vincent Doan think
• What is the contrast described by might be worth trying?
Thang Ngo between his life and
that of many other young Vietnam- • How does then Mayor of Fairfield,
ese he encounters on the streets Chris Bowen, respond to the call
of Cabramatta? for safe injecting rooms in the
Cabramatta area?
• How does the Nguyen family’s
struggle with their son Lam’s • What are some of the problems
drug addiction demonstrate the that can be better managed in safe
urgent need for a detox centre in injecting rooms in places where
Cabramatta? Outline the Nguyen illegal drugs such as heroin are
family’s own desperate attempts to being used on the streets?
get Lam clean.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201229


‘ Somehow it {the Police
Database} shows that
Cabramatta is one of
the safer suburbs in
the entire state....of 80
patrols, Bankstown tops
the list and Cabramatta
is 51st.’

‘There are now


something like 1500
addicts living in and
around Cabramatta’.
• What were some of the immediate amongst other things, that a short-
list of recommendations that were age of heroin in 2001 helped clean
implemented even before the final up Cabramatta. However, turning
report of the Parliamentary Enquiry a community around is never the
was officially released? result of a single factor. What do
you think were the most crucial ini-
• What is being measured by the • How is the conviction of Phuong tiatives in assisting the resurrection
new Police Database? Why is Ngo who is found guilty of the of Cabramatta and its Vietnamese
the result that shows Cabramatta murder of John Newman seen as population in effecting significant
to be relatively crime-free quite an important moment in drawing a changes?
unbelievable to those who live and line in the sands of history?
work there? What are some of the • What lessons can be learned from
crimes excluded from this index? • What do we see of Tony Hoang as this story about how we welcome
he finally decides he’s had enough and help integrate new arrivals into
• What does Ross Treyvaud decide of his drug world life? the Australian community? Create
to do when he is offered drugs on a list of ‘could do better’ ideas
the streets of Cabramatta? • What happened to Lam Nguyen from members of your class.

• How did the letter from the local and his extraordinary parents? • Who should be responsible for
primary school students about ensuring that different ethnic
syringes in their playground gal- • The final on-screen texts at groups are assisted in the process
vanize Thang to enlist the help of the end of this series mention, of re-settlement?
Helen Sham-Ho, Member of the
NSW Legislative Council?
‘It’s so wrong, so ridiculous that a suburb where people
• What action did Helen Sham-Ho
live and work and you have this war zone in your back
initiate at State Government level?
yard. It’s just not right.’
SET 4
Helen Sham-Ho
‘The everyday people of Cabramatta
are about to be given the chance
to prove that in a true multicultural ‘First time the Cabramatta community had the eye of
community, everyone has a voice.’
(Narrator)
State Parliament. An Upper House enquiry looking into
the problems of the area and specifically looking into the
• How did the everyday people problems of policing. Not into the people and where they
respond to the invitation of the
Parliamentary inquiry to voice their
went wrong. Looking into the police and what we can do
concerns? to help them’.
(Thang Ngo)

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201230


Student Activity 2: History documentaries

Using historical sources 5. Who should be responsible for • Statistical records about, for
preserving written and visual mate- instance, crime figures. Official
Once Upon a Time in Cabramatta rials that tell us about our past? records such as those collected in
raises questions about the nature of a national census every 5 years by
historical enquiry and the sources The period explored in these programs the Australian Bureau of Statistics
available to filmmakers telling a story begins in the late 1970s when the war can be very useful to historians,
about a place and people from our in Vietnam between the north and demographers and politicians.
recent past. The medium of television south ended and thousands of Viet-
certainly ensures a much broader au- namese fled their homeland. The se- • Public media records such as
dience than is likely with many written ries incorporates a variety of resources newspaper articles and pho-
accounts but like any history it is a to tell the story of the Vietnamese peo- tographs, television programs,
representation of a place and time in ple in Australia, sometimes described films and newsreel footage. This
the recent past. Here are some ques- as ‘the first boat people’, though most material provides visual evidence
tions to consider: came by plane as do the majority of that creates a vivid account of how
arrivals today. people lived, what they valued and
1. How can and do we know about what the media considered impor-
what happened in the distant and • Many people from this turbulent tant at the time.
more immediate past? period are able to describe what
life was like for them when they left • What are some of the newspaper,
2. What constitutes historical evi- Vietnam and settled in Cabramat- television and filmed records of
dence? ta. Such accounts are known as what happened during the past 35
eyewitness accounts or sometimes years in Cabramatta?
3. How can we represent what we anecdotal evidence.
discover, whether in writing or in • How complete and accurate is the
visual terms? • Make a list of the range of people media representation?
appearing in this program to tell
4. In what ways does it matter that their stories about their family life, • Personal records including photo-
we understand what life was like work and what happened to them. graphs and home movies. Such re-
for people in earlier times? cords are important in conveying a

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201231


picture of attitudes and values and records from the past are never • Do the often conflicting public and
showing us details about aspects complete and comprehensive. The personal stories encourage us
of people’s lives such as housing, representation is also likely to be consider the degree of spin and
dress and social life. framed within the historian’s own be- ‘political correctness’ to which we
liefs and experience. Filmmakers and are often subjected by politicians
• Economic figures which tell us historians alike must work with avail- and the media?
about the complex relationship be- able materials to tell a story. We, as
tween economic conditions such viewers, need to decide whether the • Why do the stories of everyday
as recessions and/or booms and ways the stories are told are a fair and people matter in the construction
how people lived and worked. reliable representation of the period of an historical account?
and place depicted. How do we make
• Changes in government policy and such judgements? If you look at the • Finally, do we want to keep people
legislation e.g. the Government extensive Crew List for Once Upon a out of Australia, to treat them as
Enquiry into policing in Cabramatta Time in Cabramatta that appears later interlopers, not ‘people like us’
in late 2000. in this guide, you will get some sense or do we want to embrace their
of the range of researchers and expert skills and cultures and ensure that
A range of evidence is essential for advisors who worked on this series. immigrants have adequate op-
compiling a complex and detailed portunities to play their part in a
picture of the intersection be- At the same time, filmmakers are democratic and open society?
tween private and public life. This always conscious of the need for their
is important for showing what life work to be not just informative, but Should recent arrivals continue
was like for the everyday people, entertaining. Facts and figures need to to suffer as many Vietnamese
their political representatives at the be melded with the stories of individu- did when they come to settle in
local, state and national level and als in order to engage an audience. Australia or should we be assisting
public authorities, represented in Individual stories need to be carefully recent arrivals to become pro-
this series by police officers and developed over the series so that we ductive and happy members of a
paramedics. don’t fully understand these very per- multicultural Australia?
sonal stories until the final chapter.
Historians and documentary film-
makers always have to decide what • How well do you think the series
material to include and what to leave balances the personal and public
out. Any representation of the past stories?
is based on available evidence, as

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201232


Vietnamese food begins on SBS television on February Nam Le - author of The Boat, winner
23rd, 2012. of the 2008 Dylan Thomas Prize
Many students may be familiar with
Vietnamese food which is justly Many Vietnamese Australians have Tan Le - 1998 Young Australian of the
famous for its variety, flavours, fresh- established successful careers in Year
ness and value for money. Footscray, Australia in many areas from medicine
Springvale and Richmond in Mel- to art, film and television, the law, Luke Nguyen, owner chef of The Red
bourne are known for their Vietnam- politics, science and engineering. Lantern restaurant in Sydney
ese restaurants. In Sydney you can Some of these people, apart from
head to Cabramatta or Marrickville or those appearing in Once Upon a Time You may be able to add to this list any
Surry Hills or Canley Vale and in other in Cabramatta, include: Vietnamese Australians you know of
Australian cities you will find great who have achieved public acclaim for
restaurants wherever Vietnamese have Anh Do - Comedian, actor, author of their work (or who should have).
settled. There are fine Vietnamese The Happiest Refugee and brother
restaurants in Tasmania, Darwin, Bris- of Khoa Do
bane, Perth and Adelaide. For a range
of Vietnamese recipes see: http:// Khoa Do - Young Australian of the For an interactive time-
www.taste.com.au/recipes/collections/ Year in 2005, writer, director and
line of the Cabramatta story
vietnamese+recipes brother of Anh Do
and many online extras go to:
Luke Nguyen is Australia’s best-known Hieu Van Le - Lieutenant Governor
Vietnamese cook. You can catch his of South Australia and Chairman sbs.com.au/onceuponatime
programs on SBS television and check of the South Australian Multicul-
out his books and recipes online. tural and Ethnic Affairs Commission and click on various dates to provide
(SAMEAC). an understanding of the Vietnamese experi-
His new program, Luke Nguyen’s ence both in Australia and in Vietnam.
Greater Mekong, where he extends Hung Le - Comedian
his culinary journey beyond Vietnam, You can also contribute your opinion
about the series to an online forum
at this site.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201233


Production Credits

EXECUTIVE PRODUCERS STILLS PHOTOGRAPHY COLOURIST Service


Sue Clothier Preston Clothier Trish Cahill Getty Images
Craig Graham ITN Source
SOUND RECORDIST SOUND DESIGNER
NFSA Film Australia Collection
SERIES WRITER & PRODUCER Chris McCallum Tony Murtugh (1)
Nine Network Australia
Jacob Hickey David White (2 & 3)
DEVELOPMENT RESEARCHERS SBS News and Current Affairs
SERIES DIRECTOR Katherine Anderson SOUND MIXER The Seven Network
Bernadine Lim Elizabeth Kaydos Peter Purcell UNHCR
Kristin Lee
NARRATOR NARRATION RECORD THE PRODUCERS WISH TO
Kristin Quayle-Graham
Tara Morice Liesl Pieterse THANK
ARCHIVE RESEARCHER The Vietnamese community of
LINE PRODUCER COMPLETION GUARANTY
Naomi J Hall Cabramatta
Nicola Sullivan Provided through First Australian
ASSISTANT EDITOR Completion Bond Company Pty. Ltd. The Hoang, Le and Nguyen families
PICTURE EDITORS
Liam Rodden Ambrose Dinh
Sam Wilson (1 & 3) LEGAL ADVISOR
Casula Powerhouse
Nikki Stevens (2) TITLE DESIGN Robert Reeve
Defence Housing Australia
Adam Ludd
POST PRODUCTION PRODUCER SBS LEGAL ADVISORS Fairfield City Council
Tim Clark GRAPHIC DESIGNER Sally McCausland Rail Corp
Luke Harris Lyn Kemmis Martien Coucke
ASSOCIATE PRODUCER
Stephanie Walsh ORIGINAL MUSIC PRODUCTION ACCOUNTANT Marilyn Gallo
Christopher Elves (1 & 2) Bronwyn Speziale Katherine Hristoforidis
PRODUCTION CO-ORDINATOR & Natalie Johnson
ADDITIONAL RESEARCH MUSIC BY SERIES ADVISORS Prof. Lisa Maher
Peta Ayers Dinesh Wicks and Adam Gock (3) Andrew Jakubowicz Mary-Ellen Mullane
Hien Le Heather Oxenham
ADDITIONAL DIRECTION POST PRODUCTION SUPERVISOR
Thang Ngo Corrie Soeterboek
Shannon Jones David Gross
ARCHIVE FOOTAGE AND STILL Liz Stevens
DIRECTOR OF PHOTOGRAPHY ONLINE EDITOR
IMAGES COURTESY OF RESEARCHER
Justin Hanrahan Ben Blick-Hodge (1)
Australian Broadcasting Maria Tran
Simon Ashby, David Gross (2 & 3)
TIMELAPSE Corporation Library Sales In association with Screen NSW
Tim Pass ONLINE FACILITY CriticalPast Slingshot Attachment Program
Definition Films Fairfax Photos
AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHY
The Fairfield Advance Newspaper SBS COMMISSIONG EDITOR
Nathan Tomlinson
Fairfield City Council Library John Godfrey

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201234


References and Resources

Once Upon a Time in Cabramatta official


website
http://www.sbs.com.au/onceuponatime/

The Vietnamese Community in Australia,


NSW chapter
http://www.vietnamese.org.au/

Fairfield City Council


http://www.fairfieldcity.nsw.gov.au/

Fairfield Library – The Way We Were project


http://fairfieldcity.oralhistory.com.au/

The Refugee Council of Australia


http://www.refugeecouncil.org.au/

Amnesty International – Refugees and hu-


man rights
http://www.amnesty.org.au/refugees/

Department of Immigration and Citizenship


http://www.immi.gov.au/

Pulau Bidong – A Boat People Legacy


http://www.pulaubidong.org/

Cabramatta Community Centre


http://cabracc.org.au/

Open Family Australia


http://www.openfamily.com.au

A 2008 essay by Alice Pung, author of


Unpolished Gem and Her Father’s Daughter,
writing about starting her life as an Asian
immigrant to Australia in 1980
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/
features/alice-pung-on-new-australians/
story-e6frg8h6-1111117529999

Marguerite O’Hara
20/1/2012

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201235


This study guide was produced by ATOM. (© ATOM 2012)
ISBN: 978-1-74295-136-2 editor@atom.org.au
For more information on Screen Education magazine,
or to download other study guides for assessment,
visit <http://www.metromagazine.com.au>.
Join ATOM’s email broadcast list for invitations to
free screenings, conferences, seminars, etc.
Sign up now at <http://www.atom.asn.au/lists/>.
For hundreds of articles on Film as Text,
Screen Literacy, Multiliteracy and Media Studies,
visit <http://www.theeducationshop.com.au>.

SCREEN EDUCATION © ATOM 201236

You might also like