Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy

ISSN: 1103-8128 (Print) 1651-2014 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/iocc20

What is important to patients in palliative care? a


scoping review of the patient’s perspective

Helen von Post & Petra Wagman

To cite this article: Helen von Post & Petra Wagman (2017): What is important to patients in
palliative care? a scoping review of the patient’s perspective, Scandinavian Journal of Occupational
Therapy, DOI: 10.1080/11038128.2017.1378715

To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/11038128.2017.1378715

Published online: 22 Sep 2017.

Submit your article to this journal

View related articles

View Crossmark data

Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at


http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=iocc20

Download by: [Nanyang Technological University] Date: 24 September 2017, At: 05:33
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY, 2017
https://doi.org/10.1080/11038128.2017.1378715

REVIEW ARTICLE

What is important to patients in palliative care? a scoping review of the


patient’s perspective
Helen von Posta and Petra Wagmanb
a
Advanced Palliative Home Care, Region Skåne, Helsingborg, Sweden; bSchool of Health and Welfare, J€
onk€
oping University, Sweden

ABSTRACT ARTICLE HISTORY


Background: The research conducted in palliative care is often medically oriented. There are Received 2 November 2016
few studies clarifying the patient’s preferences, priorities and desires in palliative care. The occu- Revised 19 June 2017
pational therapy research conducted mostly concerns occupational therapy interventions based Accepted 7 September 2017
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 05:33 24 September 2017

on the profession’s experiences. Further knowledge is needed regarding what patients in pallia-
tive care want to prioritize. KEYWORDS
Aim: The aim was to describe what patients in palliative care describe as important at the end Activity; everyday life;
of life. occupation; occupational
Methods: A scoping review was conducted using the inclusion criteria: articles published in therapy; participation;
2004-August 2015; written in English; participants >18 years with life-threatening illness without person centered
possible cure; focusing on the patient’s experience.
Results: Seventeen articles were included in the review and they were based on interviews.
The theme ‘Continuing occupational participation is important for people at the end of life’ was
identified. This included five sub-themes: maintaining previous occupational patterns; feeling
needed; being involved in the social environment; leaving a legacy; and living as long as
you live.
Conclusions: The results show that continued occupational participation is important for people
in palliative care. Occupational therapists can contribute to this by taking a highly person-
centered approach and gaining information about what matters most for their clients.

Introduction therapists are required in the palliative team [6–8] as


they play an integral role in facilitating peoples’ oppor-
Globally, it is estimated that about 20 million people
tunities to live a valuable life in accordance with their
require palliative care at the end of life but only about
wishes, needs and demands from the environment [7].
14% of them receive it [1]. Even in a rich country such
Palliative care is also a new area of research, and
as Sweden, the number of people in need of palliative
the research conducted so far has largely had a med-
care is higher than the number who receive it [2].
ical focus. The lack of research illustrating the prefer-
However, by ensuring that the physical, psychosocial ences, priorities and wishes of patients approaching
and spiritual dimensions are included, palliative care is the end of life has also been highlighted [9]. There is
an approach that improves the quality of life of also a scarcity of instruments adapted for palliative
patients and their families, facing the problem patients, although the fact that ‘no instrument can
associated with life-threatening illness, through a team- replace the partnerships that are necessary to identify
based approach [3]. Palliative care implies taking a hol- patient goals’ has been recognized [10, p 828]. Studies
istic view of the dying person and his or her situation, based on peoples’ perceptions have increased within
working from four cornerstones: symptom control; cancer research, but palliative care is an exception.
multi-professional teams; communication The availability and willingness of these patients is
and relationships; and support for relatives [4]. especially demanding in palliative care due to their
Cooperation in multi-professional teams is central [2]. frailness and vulnerability at the end of life, and it is
In Sweden, specialized units in palliative care have difficult to gather participants to include in studies.
been started, and occupational therapists are included Not wanting to burden dying people or to risk caus-
in many, but not all, of them [5]. However, according ing them stress are some of the reasons why research
to occupational therapy associations, occupational is often carried out on staff or relatives instead, e.g.

CONTACT Helen von Post helenvonpost@gmail.com Advanced Palliative Home Care, Region Skåne, Skånevård Kryh, Patronens v€ag 65B, 252 50
Helsingborg, Sweden
ß 2017 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
2 H. VON POST AND P. WAGMAN

[11]. However, their experiences may not be the same The exclusion criterion was reviews of published
as those of the palliative patient [12,13]. Few studies literature. The following databases were used:
in palliative care have focused on the patients’ experi- Academic Search Elite, Amed, Cinahl, Medline and
ences. One exception is Black [9], who conducted a PubMed. The articles was identified using the follow-
critical review of patients’ priorities. He identified ing search terms: Palliative care AND Patient perspec-
four themes of importance: ‘understanding and tive; End of life AND Patient perspective; Terminally
acceptance‘; ‘holding on to normality‘; ‘family, friend- ill AND Patient perspective; Dying person AND
ships, and responsibilities’ and; ‘health-care support Patient perspective; End of life AND Activities;
and professional relationships’. However, this review Terminally ill AND Activities of daily living; End of
only identified four articles for inclusion [9]. Taken life AND Activities of daily living; Dying person AND
together, there is lack of sufficient knowledge regard- Activities of daily living. The searches were conducted
ing what patients in palliative care want to prioritize. between April 4, 2014 and August 30, 2015.
This also affects occupational therapists. The decision on whether an article should be
Occupational therapists have the knowledge and included involved several steps: first by reading the
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 05:33 24 September 2017

competence to help people to participate in self-chosen titles, then abstracts, and finally the full article. The
occupations in relation to the limitations caused by reference lists and citations of included articles were
their disease [14]. Further knowledge is needed on the also used. The process resulted in 35 full articles, of
best ways of doing this in palliative care, because so far which 17 met the criteria and were included in the
studies have only been conducted about patients’ per- review (Figure 1). The overview of all included articles
ceptions of their current interventions, e.g. Keeley [15], are presented in Table 1.
but no study has been identified concerning what kind
of interventions they want. Currently, occupational Result
therapy interventions in palliative care often focus on
compensations. This implies adaptations of the local Characteristics of the studies included
environment such as the use of assistive devices in The articles included are qualitative studies based on
order to enable continued performance in different open-ended interviews. Individual interviews were
activities of daily living (ADL) [16,17]. Assistive devi- conducted in all but one article, which used focus
ces may aim to reduce the energy or time it takes to group interviews [19]. Most interviews were conducted
conduct, for instance, personal activities in daily life face to face in the participant’s home or in a care set-
[17], but there is insufficient knowledge regarding ting. They had the purpose of letting the person/
whether this is the kind of intervention preferred by patient speak freely based upon an given topic or a
the patients themselves. few open questions. The number of participants varied
The aim of this literature review was therefore to between 3 and 47 and they were 27 to 89 years old.
describe what patients in palliative care at the end of Most of the articles described participants and envi-
life describe as important. ronments in Western societies (Canada, the
Netherlands, Scandinavia and the US), while two were
Method from Hong Kong and Africa. In the majority of the
This study was conducted using the scoping review articles, the participants were diagnosed with cancer
method which is considered appropriate in order to but in two, the general terms ‘incurable illness’ or
investigate a research area and gives a good point of ‘terminal illness’ were used. In two studies, participants
departure for further research. Conducting a scoping with HIV, AIDS, cerebrovascular disease and different
study is based on different phases: identify the research rheumatoid conditions were also included [20–22].
question and relevant studies to include; ‘charting the
data‘; and finally, making a summary and report [18]. Continuing occupational participation is important
The process for identifying relevant scientific articles for people at the end of life
was based on the following inclusion criteria:
The articles’ results could be gathered under the
 Published during 2004 to August 2015 theme ‘Continuing occupational participation is
 In English important for people at the end of life’. The theme
 Includes participants older than 18 years with a included five sub-themes described below: maintain-
life-threatening disease without the possibility of ing previous occupational patterns; feeling needed;
being cured being involved in the social environment; leaving a
 Focusing on the patient’s experiences legacy; and living as long as you live.
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY 3

1146 hits in Amed, Cinahl, Reading the titles, resulting


Academic Search Elite and in 49 articles (23 duplicates)
Medline
1486 hits in Pubmed

Reading the 26 abstracts Searches in their reference


lists and via citations in
Google scholar resulted in 9
more abstracts
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 05:33 24 September 2017

Reading the 35 full articles. Of these, 17 meet the


criteria

= 17 articles included

Figure 1. The process of data gathering.

The results show that occupation is included in form of occupation [26]. In many ways, these were
what people in palliative care describe as being the same as for healthy people – going to a cafe, gar-
important. All the included articles described occupa- dening or cooking with the family – but in the light
tions, but many of them talked about them generally of imminent death, these occupations had a different
and did not mention any specific occupation. The meaning and resulted in a different feeling [26]. To
participants described the importance of being able to see what is important in life, to see beyond trivial
perform some kind of occupation. For instance, when matters and unimportant things [23].
they were no longer able to work, it was important to
be engaged in some other challenging occupation
Maintaining previous occupational patterns
[23]. However, being active did not imply the neces-
sity of being physically active. Current technology and In six articles [19,20,26–29], the importance of being
social media could be used as other ways to be active, able to do the things one has previously been able to
e.g. to continue religious practice via the Internet or do was emphasized as being crucial for experiencing a
television [22]. Being able to do the things they good quality of life. However, the participants did not
wanted was also shown to be of great importance for always specify what was included in the previous
self-esteem [21,24]. Also, planning occupations occupational pattern. Occupations mentioned
became a part of this and was just as important as included household chores, participating in meals and
performing occupations [25]. traveling by car with others [19,20,27], and thereby
Furthermore, not being able to participate in every- feeling to be a part of everyday life [26]. In the study
day life may imply suffering, and the participants by van Rensburg et al. [20], one part of continuing a
described that a feeling of hope and participation previous occupational pattern included being able to
resulted from easing their suffering through some work and contribute to one’s livelihood. The results
4 H. VON POST AND P. WAGMAN

Table 1. The articles included.


First author, Year, What is described as important by patients
Country Aim Method, Participants in palliative care.
Carter, 2004, To explore what people living with terminal An exploratory study To take responsibility and play an active
New Zealand illness considered were the areas of pri- 3 men role for control.
ority in their lives. 7 women To maintain to do what one has been doing
Two <50 years and eight previously.
61–77 years
Volker, 2004, US To explore the nature of what people with Interpretive interaction- To be with one’s family and close by.
advanced cancer want regarding personal ism To maintain caring for oneself and keep
control and comfort at the end of life. 1 man one’s dignity.
6 women Being able to help others in the same situ-
46-76 years ation to have something to do and to do
something good.
Coyle, 2006, US To examine, from the patient’s perspective, Interpretive phenomen- To find themselves in the disease and main-
the work of trying to live with advanced ology tain control of the situation.
cancer at the same time facing the 4 men To not solely be a patient.
immediacy of death. 3 women To create a legacy, a continued existence.
40–79 years
Goldsteen, 2006, To offer insight in how terminally ill A hermeneutic approach To actively deal with their situation i.e. con-
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 05:33 24 September 2017

The Netherlands patients define their dying trajectory and 10 men tinuing to be active despite the disease.
how they use current normative ideas 3 women Preparing themselves and others for their
and expectations about dying in their 39–83 years forthcoming death.
stories.
Melin-Johansson, 2006, To describe patients’ perceptions of quality Content analysis Being able to conduct the activities of
Sweden of life in incurable cancer at the end of 2 men everyday life, domestic chores.
life. 3 women Participating in driving tours with family
54–76 years and friends. Living as fully as possible
and making the best of every day.
Melin-Johansson, 2008, To elucidate the meaning of quality of life Qualitative study To have hope. Being at home in a well-
Sweden as narrated by patients with incurable 6 men known environment and close to their
cancer approaching death in palliative 2 women family.
home care. 35–83 years
Prince-Paul, 2008, US To advance understanding of the social Phenomenology Participating socially gives life meaning.
wellbeing domain, a dimension of quality 3 men Continuing to be involved and to live while
of life, from the perspective of dying 5 women dying.
individuals 35–75 years Being close to those who are close to them.
Wrubel, 2009, US To explore how people with a terminal ill- Qualitative methodology Being active in everyday life, does not have
ness live out their lives. 32 participants to be physically – can be via, for
27–73 years instance, television or the Internet.
To live as long as one lives.
La Cour, 2009, Denmark To explore and understand how people Qualitative interviews To do meaningful activities together with
with advanced cancer create meaning and observations the family which simultaneously creates
and handle everyday life through activity. 2 men good memories.
5 women Being 'healthy' despite severe disease.
39–67 years Maintaining previous activities although
modified.
Gourdji, 2009, Canada To explore the meaning of quality of life Qualitative study Doing things I usually do.
from the perspective of terminally ill 5 men Being helpful to other people.
patient on a palliative care unit and to 5 women Living in a caring environment.
identify the factors in their environment 29–79 years Participating as a spectator when you can
that brought quality to their lives. no longer practise.
Mok, 2010, Hong Kong To examine the meaning of hope from the Qualitative content Living a normal life, experiencing social sup-
perspective of Chinese advanced cancer analysis port.
patients in Hong Kong. 9 men Being able to participate in everyday life.
8 women Exemplifying different activities such as
49–84 years. mahjong, fishing, eating, walking.
Andersson Sviden, 2010, To investigate how people with cancer Grounded theory Maintain as normal a life as possible.
Sweden receiving palliative care engage in and 8 men The importance of continuing to do some-
undertake activities in their everyday 39 women thing rather than doing nothing.
lives. <49 to between 70–89 Be able to participate in activities with
years friends and family.
Be able to perform activities that contribute
to well-being and being able to engage
in everyday life.
Experiencing joy and pleasure provided a
feeling of being capable and alive, which
helped them to continue to engage in
activities and participate in everyday life.
(continued)
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY 5

Table 1. Continued
First author, Year, What is described as important by patients
Country Aim Method, Participants in palliative care.
Carlander, 2011, Sweden To describe how people close to death nar- A narrative approach To be able to continue to do everyday
rate themselves in relation to everyday 1 man activities.
life and, thus, gain more knowledge 2 women To remain the same as before the disease.
about aspects of identity close to death. 46 and 50 years To be able to help others.
Social relationships.
Participating in household chores, as this
gave a feeling of being useful.
Planning small activities and carrying them
out.
Making it easier for the family to support
each other; taking a step back but con-
tinuing to participate.
To leave stability and things in order.
Lavoie, 2011, Canada To describe the experience of autonomy Phenomenological Maintaining their identity all the way.
from the viewpoint of the palliative care approach Being able to do what they want; socializ-
patient. 3 men ing with friends.
7 women Being sufficiently independent in daily activ-
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 05:33 24 September 2017

45–79 years ities.


Being able to decide and maintaining one’s
identity.
La Cour, 2012, Denmark To illuminate how persons with advanced 2 men Being able to help those close by.
cancer reflect upon and use engagement 5 women Feeling needed, useful and a part of every-
in ordinary daily activities when facing 39–67 years day life.
impending death. To make every day valuable.
Maintaining activities despite severe
symptoms.
Nissim, 2012, Canada To provide an understanding of the overall Grounded theory To control the dying.
prolonged experience of advanced cancer 12 men Valuing current life.
and how this experience is managed, as 15 women Creating a living legacy.
seen through the eyes of dying individu- 45–82 years Being able to help others.
als themselves. Actively controlling and trying to prolong
the period of living meaningfully with
treatment.
van Rensburg, 2013, To explore quality of life from the perspec- Qualitative phenomeno- To support oneself and one’s family.
South Africa tive of palliative care patients managed logical design Having friends around and support from
at a palliative care clinic serving a 2 men one’s religion.
resource-poor community in Tshwane, 8 women Having employment.
South Africa. 30–79 years Being needed and caring for close ones.

in two of the other articles emphasized the import- was also described that by helping others they also
ance of being able to conduct the personal ADL inde- helped themselves [29].
pendently [21,27]. According to Goldsteen et al. [28], It was also considered important to have the oppor-
it was also considered important to take responsibility tunity to feel needed by contributing to others in the
for maintaining active participation in life and to same situation or by helping those close by
strive towards normality [23]. [20,24,25,28,29,32]. Feeling needed could also mean
When the disease affected the ability to perform preparing oneself and others for one’s coming death,
previous occupations, it became important to be able e.g. by preparing the funeral, getting one’s finances in
to perform at least a part of them [23,26]. The patients order and dealing with other practical issues [28]. This
dealt actively with their situation by continuing to be was done in order to make it easier for the family to
active and moving on in life despite a severe disease support each other and to leave stability and things in
[30]. This could mean continuing to participate in order [25]. Moreover, several participants in the study
social events, socializing with friends [21,31] and mak- by Nissim et al. [24] chose to begin volunteer work
ing choices based on their own priorities [25,29]. after receiving their diagnosis, based on the desire to
contribute to society and to other people.
Feeling needed
Being involved in the social environment
In six of the articles [20,24–26,28,29], the results
showed that being able to contribute to others was The importance of the patient’s surrounding environ-
important for the participants’ quality of life. The ment was highlighted in eight articles [20,23,25,27,
value of feeling that one has something to offer to 29,31–33]. This concerns the physical environment,
others and being needed was recognized [24–26,29]. It such as having a home environment that enables the
6 H. VON POST AND P. WAGMAN

person to stay at home during the last stages of life important. The results showed the importance of con-
[33]. However, the greatest emphasis was put on the tinued participation in life and its occupations, as
social environment, e.g. being able to participate each sub-theme identified shows aspects that fall
socially and continuing to be involved were described within the area of participation.
as giving meaning to live [31,32]. Moreover, the The experience of participation is subjective and
importance of having friends and family around was arises from conducting personally meaningful occupa-
recognized [20,23,25,27,29,31–33]. tions. This experience is affected by personal experi-
ences and individual abilities, habits, volition and
Leaving a legacy roles, as well as by an enabling or restricting context
[36]. Several of our included articles reported that
Creating good memories and a legacy together with
the family was described as important [24,34,35]. their participants emphasized the importance of truly
Some patients were afraid of only being remembered living as long as they do, implying being the same
as ill. Creating a legacy was described as forming ‘a person as before to those closest and maintaining con-
bridge for the participants between existence and trol of the situation as well as life close to death.
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 05:33 24 September 2017

non-existence’, and was of great importance in the These findings support the National Board of Health
process of accepting their current situation [35]. The and Welfare guidelines stating that autonomy, partici-
motivation behind leaving a legacy was not only gen- pation and the social network have, besides easing
erosity but also a wish for continued existence; to cre- symptoms, also been recognized as important aspects
ate a picture for one’s survivors that justifies how they for quality of life [2]. Our results are also similar to
have lived and what they have accomplished [24]. those of Black’s review, based on four articles (of
which two are also included in the present review), in
Living as long as you live which he identified the importance of having the abil-
ity to go on with one’s life even in the last stages and
The last sub-theme identified deals with the import- of keeping elements of normality when dying [9].
ance of feeling that one is living as fully as possible Furthermore, our findings also show that people
and making the best of every day [19,20,26]. This also feel alive when experiencing participation and
contributes to patients’ feeling of being present in being able to participate socially, and that having those
reality and in everyday life activities [23], which is who are closest to them around contributes to a feeling
one aspect of living as long as you live. Another of participation. Another aspect of participation identi-
aspect concerned deciding for themselves, e.g. actively fied as being important in the present study was the
taking control and trying to prolong the period of experience of being needed. To be able to make things
meaningful life with treatment [24]. It was also easier for and help those closest to one was identified
described as important to be able to maintain their as contributing to a feeling of being needed, and this
own identity [21,25] by being the same as before to has also been described in earlier research [13].
those closest to them [26] and by finding themselves The importance of maintaining previous occupa-
in their disease and maintaining control of the situ- tional patterns was highlighted in several articles in this
ation and not solely being a patient, i.e. the import- review [19,20,26–29]. These occupational patterns are
ance of being healthy despite the severe disease formed by our habits, our volition and our performance
[34,35]. Moreover, the importance of maintained con- capacity. People create space for themselves in the social
trol of life was described as an important part of qual- world by what they do, and in order to understand what
ity of life; primarily taking an active role in kinds of occupation an individual will choose, one
controlling the living together with the dying needs to understand the interaction between what he or
[21,24,30,35]. This could concern the decision of what she wants to do and values doing, what he or she
meaning life should have close to death [31]. By con- believes he or she can do and finds meaningful, and the
trolling the pain relief or the life-prolonging treatment
possibilities and restrictions of the environment [36].
they also controlled the time left. Being able to do
As a way of achieving this, occupational therapists could
what one wants also included the ability to think and
be good contributors as they have the knowledge and
argue for oneself in the decision process [21,30,35].
skill to enable people to participate in their self-chosen
occupations in relation to the limitations a disease
Discussion
involves [37]. Loss of independency and roles may
This scoping review aimed to describe what patients result in a social death before the biological death.
in palliative care at the end of life describe as being Occupational therapy may enable patients to participate
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY 7

in new and meaningful functions and roles, maintaining occupational pattern. However, it cannot be ruled out
self-esteem [38] and thereby contributing to continued that some relevant articles were missing from the
participation in everyday life. searches despite using several search terms. On the
The present results also show the importance of other hand, this scarcity has been previously described
occupational therapists conducting a thorough infor- as being related to the fact that palliative care involves
mation gathering process, preferably with the patient as working against time [39].
he or she is the only one who knows what is personally Moreover, one of the inclusion criteria was that it
valuable and can make the right prioritizations. In pal- should illuminate the patient’s perspective and this
liative care, there is a risk of listening too much to rela- means that studies solely including questionnaires
tives due to not wanting to disturb the patient [39]. were excluded which need to be taken into consider-
This implies that those occupational problems that the ation when interpreting the results.
relatives and the occupational therapist see are those
that are solved, and these may be more or less relevant
for the patient. For instance, it may not be considered Conclusions
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 05:33 24 September 2017

important for a patient to be able to enter the bathroom The present study aimed to describe what patients in
but instead very important to be able to enter the kit- palliative care at the end of life describe as being
chen in order to participate and be involved in the important. The results show that continued occupa-
immediate social environment. Therefore, the occupa- tional participation is important for people at the end
tional therapist needs to work in a highly person-cen- of life and that they put great emphasis on being able
tered manner in order to obtain information about to continue their earlier occupational pattern and
what matters most, i.e. getting an understanding of the
life as much as possible. Occupational therapists can
patients based on their values, interests, etc. This also
contribute to enabling this by taking a truly person-
involves the occupational therapist understanding,
centered approach towards their clients.
respecting and supporting the patient’s choices and
actions [36,40]. This is in line with Pearson et al., who
emphasize the importance of occupational therapists Disclosure statement
listening and acting on what the patient values most The authors report no conflicts of interest.
[16], as well as with the National Board of Health and
Welfare which emphasizes the absolute importance of
the health care system providing individually adapted References
palliative care [2] and truly taking the patient’s perspec- [1] Connor S, Sepulveda Bermedo M, editors. Global
tive into account. Atlas of Palliative Care at the End of Life. Geneva:
The results of the present study can contribute to World Health Organization; 2014. Available from:
deeper insights for occupational therapists who meet http://www.who.int/nmh/Global_Atlas_of_Palliative_
patients in palliative care or patients who are reaching Care.pdf
[2] Socialstyrelsen [National Board of Health and
the end of their life: insights into the importance of rec-
Welfare]. Nationellt kunskapsst€ od f€or god palliativ
ognizing and highlighting the healthy aspects of each vård i livets slutskede. V€agledning, rekommenda-
individual, and creating an understanding of the desire tioner och indikatorer. St€od f€
or styrning och ledning.
to continue to live life to the fullest. The latter is a wish [National knowledge support for good palliative care
that may cause resistance towards help and assistive at the end of life. Guidance, recommendations and
devices given to meet an urgent need recognized by the indicators. Support for governance and manage-
occupational therapist. In palliative care work, one of ment]; 2013. Available from: http://www.socialstyrel-
sen.se/publikationer2013/2013-6-4.
the challenges may be to balance professional interven- [3] World Health Organization. WHO definition of pal-
tions with the patient’s sense of participation. liative care. ND. Available from: http://www.who.int/
cancer/palliative/definition/en/
[4] Andershed B, Ternestedt B-M, Håkansson C.
Methodological considerations Palliativ Vård -Begrepp & Perspektiv i Teori och
The aim of this scoping review was considered suit- Praktik [Palliative Care: Concepts & Perspectives in
able for the method chosen, but the study has some Theory and Practice]. Lund: Studentlitteratur; 2013.
[5] Strang P, Beck-Friis B. Palliativ Medicin och Vård
issues that need to be discussed. Firstly, it is based on [Palliative Medicine and Care]. Stockholm: Liber AB;
17 articles and this scarcity shows that further 2012.
research from the palliative patient’s perspective is [6] Canadian Association of Occupational Therapists.
warranted, e.g. based on participation and continued Position statement: occupational therapy and end-of-
8 H. VON POST AND P. WAGMAN

life care 2011. Available from: http://www.caot.ca/ [23] Andersson Sviden G, Tham K, Borell L. Involvement
default.asp?pageid¼1284 in everyday life for people with a life threatening ill-
[7] OTAL Occupational Therapy Australia Ltd. Position ness. Palliat Support Care. 2010;8:345–352.
statement: occupational therapy in palliative care. [24] Nissim R, Rennie D, Fleming S, et al. Goals set in
Aust Occup Ther J. 2015;62:459–461. the land of the living/dying: a longitudinal study of
[8] World Federation of Occupational Therapists. WHO patients living with advanced cancer. Death Stud.
definition of palliative care. 2016. Available from: 2012;36:360–390.
http://www.who.int/cancer/palliative/definition/en/ [25] Carlander I, Ternestedt B-M, Sahlberg-Blom E, et al.
[9] Black J. What are patients’ priorities when facing the Four aspects of self-image close to death at home.
end of life? A critical review. Int J Palliat Nurs. Int J Qualitat Stud Health Well-Being. 2011;6:5431.
2011;17:294–300. [26] La Cour K, Ploug Hansen H. Aesthetic engagements:
[10] Schleinich M, Warren S, Nekolaichuk C, et al. ‘being’ in everyday life with advanced cancer. Am J
Palliative care rehabilitation survey: a pilot study of Hospice Palliat Med. 2012;29:126–133.
patients’ priorities for rehabilitation goals. Palliat [27] Mok E, Lam W, Chan L, et. al. The meaning
Med. 2008;22:822–830. of hope from the perspective of chinese advanced
[11] Hughes N. User involvement in cancer care research. cancer patients in Hong Kong. Int J Palliat Nurs.
Eur J Palliat Care. 2006;13:248–250. 2010;16:298–305.
Downloaded by [Nanyang Technological University] at 05:33 24 September 2017

[12] Jeyasingam L, Agar M, Soares M, et al. A prospective [28] Goldsteen M, Houtepen R, Proot I, et. al. What is a
study of unmet activity of daily living needs in pal- good death? Terminally ill patients dealing with nor-
liative care inpatients. Aust Occup Ther J. mative expectations around death and dying. Patient
2008;55:266–272. Educ Couns. 2006;64:378–386.
[13] Steinhauser K, Christakis N, Clipp E, et al. Factors [29] Gourdji I, McVey L, Purden M. A quality end of life
considered important at the end of life by patients, from a palliative care patient‘s perspective. J Palliat
family, physicians, and other care providers. JAMA. Care. 2009;25:40–50.
2000;284:2476–2482. [30] Carter H, MacLeod R, Brander P, et al. Living with
[14] World Federation of Occupational Therapists a terminal illness: patients’ priorities. J Adv Nurs.
2004;45:611–620.
(WFOT). Statement on occupational therapy 2010.
[31] Prince-Paul M. Understanding the meaning of social
2010. Available from: http://www.wfot.org/Portals/0/
well-being at the end of life. Oncol Nurs Forum.
PDF/STATEMENT%20ON%20OCCUPATIONAL
2008;35:365–371.
%20THERAPY%20300811.pdf
[32] Volker D, Kahn D, Penticuff J. Patient control and
[15] Kealey P, McIntyre I. An evaluation of the domicil-
end-of-life care part II: the patient perspective.
iary occupational therapy service in palliative cancer
Oncol Nurs Forum. 2004;31:954–960.
care in a community trust: a patient and carers per- [33] €
Melin-Johansson C, Odling G, Axelsson B, et al. The
spective. Eur J Cancer Care. 2005;14:232–243. meaning of quality of life: Narrations by patients
[16] Pearson E, Todd J, Futcher J. How can occupational with incurable cancer in palliative home care. Palliat
therapists measure outcomes in palliative care? Support Care. 2008;6:231–238.
Palliat Med. 2007;21:477–485. [34] La Cour K, Johannessen H, Josephsson S. Activity
[17] Trump S, Zahoransky M, Siebert C. Occupational and meaning making in the everyday lives of people
therapy and hospice. Am J Occup Ther. 2005;59: with advanced cancer. Palliat Support Care. 2009;7:
671–675. 469–479.
[18] Arksey H, O‘Malley L. Scoping studies: towards [35] Coyle N. The hard work of living in the face of
a methodological framework. Int J Social Res death. J Pain Symptom Manage. 2006;32:266–274.
Methodol. 2005;8:19–32. [36] Kielhofner G. Model of human occupation: theory
[19] Melin Johansson C, Axelsson B, Danielson E. Living and application. 4th ed. Baltimore (MD): Lippincott
with incurable cancer at the end of life-patients’ per- Williams & Wilkins; 2008.
ceptions on quality of life. Cancer Nurs. 2006;29: [37] Keesing S, Rosenwax L. Is occupation missing from
391–399. occupational therapy in palliative care? Aust Occup
[20] Jansen Van Rensburg J, Maree J, Van Belkum C. Ther J. 2011;58:329–336.
Quality of life from the perspective of the palliative [38] Burkhardt A, Kannenberg I, Low K, et al. The role
care patient in a resource-poor community in South of occupational therapy in end-of-life care. Am J
Africa. Palliat Support Care. 2013;11:21–28. Occup Ther. 2011;65:66–75.
[21] Lavoie M, Blondeau D, Picard-Morin J. The auton- [39] Conner A, Allport S, Dixon J, et al. Patient perspec-
omy experience of patients in palliative care. J Hosp tive: what do palliative care patients think about
Palliat Nurs. 2011;13:47–53. their care? Int J Palliat Nurs. 2008;14:546–552.
[22] Wrubel J, Acree M, Goodman S, et al. End of living: [40] Pizzi M. Promoting health and well-being at the end
maintaining a lifeworld during terminal illness. of life through client-centered care. Scand J Occup
Psychol Health. 2009;24:1229–1243. Ther. 2015;22:442–449.

You might also like