Metro Manila Subway Project

Outstanding Issues and GC Recommendations - Architecture

High
Moderate
Low

TECHNICAL ISSUES - INCONSISTENCIES BETWEEN PO AND RO

S.No. Items PO RO Priority
Materials (FOH) - Refer to attached 'Material study'
F01 Concourse Floor Tactiles Ceramic Stainless steel High
Floor Finish Granite Granite with inserts Low
Wall / Column Finish Granite (monotone) Granite (striped) High
Ceiling Finish Metal sandwich panel* Aluminum panel Low
Floor Color Light Dark Low
F02 Platform Wall End-wall Stainless steel Colored glass High
Wall (VT encl) External Stainless steel Granite (monotone) High
Wall (VT encl) Internal Stainless steel Ceramic tiles High
F03 CSO / TSO CSO Wall Finish Colored glass Ceramic (striped) High
skirting Stainless steel Granite Moderate
Ceiling Finish Aluminum panel Alum. panel w/ perforation Low
TSO Wall Finish Stainless steel Ceramic (striped) High
F04 Public Toilet Floor Finish Ceramic Ceramic/Granite (urinal) Low
Ceiling Finish Aluminum panel Gypsum Moderate
Materials (BOH)
B01 Janitor / Garabage Floor Finish Vinyl Ceramic Low
Wall Finish Acrylic paint Ceramic Low
Wall skirting Rubber Ceramic Moderate
Ceiling Finish Aluminum panel Gypsum Low
B02 All elec. rooms Ceiling Finish Metal folded ceiling Not provided Low
Design open items (Refer to attached 'Design open items study')
D01 Platform supervisor room with toilet yes no Moderate
D02 Toilet standardisation child urinal yes no Moderate
(Public toilet) diaper changing table yes no Moderate
D03 Staff lockers wash basin location shower locker room Low
wash basin count (no's) 1 2 to 4 Low
D04 Platform lifts fixing system Stick Spider Moderate
Design intent (SS jamb) one sided - assymetrical double sided - symetrical Moderate
D05 FE stairs handrail continuous (FCP) no yes Moderate
D06 TSO counters POS heights standard (m) 1.1 1 Moderate
Windows c/c min (m) 1.2 1.4 High
Typ workstation dims in m 1.2 x 1.1 1.4x1.5 Moderate
D07 VT interface study detailing simple complicated Moderate
D08 Glass types Balusters at VT void 1200 mm high 1400 mm high Moderate
D09 Door Height 2100mm 2250mm Low
VT enclosure at platform Glass door (fire rated) Steel door (fire rated) Low
D10 Station office / Control basis ER JDT formula Moderate
D11 Retail façade Signage no no Moderate
Egress door provision random random Moderate
Retail division no no Moderate
D12 Advertising / Gallery Strategy random random Moderate
D13 Entrances Ventilation mode Natural Air conditioned High
Types Featured / Simplified Simplified / Customised High

FOR FURTHER DISCUSSION AND COORDINATION - DOTR AND O&M

O&M open items (Refer to attached O&M study)
S.No. Items PO RO Priority
M01 Staff dormitories No of beds 6 (3+3) single beds 4 bunk beds (8 no's) Low
Types Male & female separate Unisex Low
M02 Staff lockers Size Set (mm) 500W x 750D x 1700H 900W x 450D x 1850H Low
M02 Staff lockers
Size module (mm) 500W x 750D x 1700H 300W x 450D x 925H Low
Tier no's Single Two Low
Security lockers Size Set (mm) 900W x 380D x 1790H 900W x 450D x 1850H Low
Size module (mm) 300Wx 380D x 445H 300W x 450D x 460H Low
M03 Toilet partitions Fixing Ceiling mounted Floor mounted Moderate
M04 TVF- fans delivery route through plennum through delivery hatch Low
M05 Waste handling room No's 2 1 Moderate
Area (sqm) 20 -35 (random) 20-40 (random) Low
FF&E
E01 Staff room (refrigerator & electric cooker as per ER) yes no Low
E02 Staff dormitory (bed side locker & mirror as per ER) yes no Low
E03 WHD no yes Moderate
E04 Platform benches 5 seater per bench 6 seater per bench Low
E05 Water heater in shower Inside cubicle Wall mounted Low
E06 Refuse bins (platform) yes No (due to security concern) Moderate

FOR OFFICIAL CONFIRMATION - DOTR AND BFP

BFP / FLS concerns
S.No. Items PO RO Priority
B01 Mechanical rooms considered as habitable space yes no
B02 Horizontal exits through rooms no yes
B03 Transfer stairs - with no exit passageways / open to publicways no yes
B04 Sprinkler provisiosn in concourse yes no
B05 Smoke screen / shutter in public open areas no yes
B06 Common path travel / Dead end compliances in BOH rooms yes no
B07 2.9m wide non-standard fire wicket door no yes
B08 Doors width less than 710mm (non FCP compliant) no yes
B09 FE stairs handrail height (865mm FCP compliant) yes no
 GC Comments DOTr comments Status
yes no Remarks

Follow RO
(Possible cost impact for PO)

Follow PO
*VE ceiling for PO is in progress

Follow RO
(Possible cost impact for PO)

Follow PO

Follow RO
(Possible cost impact for PO)
Follow RO
(Possible cost impact for PO)

Follow RO (as per FCP)

DOTr direction awaited on RDT recommendation and operator

approved typical workstation as discussed in 28Jun22 meeting
between PMO, GC-Arc and RDT.

RO to follow PO for functional detailing

Follow RO
(Possible cost impact for PO)
RO to follow PO for improved way finding
Follow RO (Possible cost impact for PO)
PO & RO needs to consider signage provision.
Strategy for retail division / doors as per minimum retail lettable
area to be considered.
Advertising strategy required for line wide consistency

Follow RO (Possible cost impact for PO)

GC Comments DOTr comments Status

Follow RO
(Possible cost impact for PO)
Follow RO
(Possible cost impact for PO)

RO to follow PO
Follow RO
(Possible cost impact for PO)

Strategy to be established

RO to follow PO

Follow RO
(Possible cost impact for PO)

GC Comments DOTr comments Status

BFP aproval required