Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Summary Thesis - Putri Elisa
Summary Thesis - Putri Elisa
PUTRI ELISA
1813440007
Information :
T1 : Treatment using interactive multimedia based on Google site on a problem based
learning model)
T2 : Treatment using a problem based learning model
O1: Results of the experimental group's Posttest scores
O2: Results of the control group's Posttest scores
F. Research Procedures
This research was conducted in the even semester of the 2022/2023 school
year at SMA Negeri 2 Majene in four meetings. Each meeting consists of two
meeting hours (2x45). The learning process was carried out in four meetings (4x2
JP), and the post-test was administered in one meeting (1x 2 JP). The steps of this
stage include:
1. Preparatory stage
In the preparation stage the activities carried out are as follows:
a. Conduct observations at schools and consult with chemistry teachers for class XI
regarding the class to be used, the time of research, the condition of students and
the material to be studied.
b. Request permission from the agency related to the research to be carried out.
c. Develop learning tools. The learning tools in this study include compiling lesson
plans, worksheets, media and learning aids.
d. Developing instruments and evaluation tools.
e. Perform instrument validation by experts.
2. Implementation Stage
The steps taken in the implementation stage are:
a. Convey the aims and objectives of the research.
b. The experimental group was divided into 5 groups consisting of 7 students, the
group division was carried out heterogeneously. In the control group it was done
in the same way.
c. Carry out learning activities in accordance with the learning implementation plan
(RPP) in groups, using interactive multimedia based on Google sites in the
problem based learning model in the experimental group and the problem based
learning model in the control group.
3. Final Stage
a. Giving a post-test to students in the experimental group and the control group at
the final meeting.
b. Processing the results of the post-test assessment of student learning outcomes
after participating in learning using interactive multimedia based on Google site
in the problem based learning model for the experimental group and without
using interactive multimedia based on Google site in the problem based learning
model in the control group.
c. Provide conclusions based on the results obtained from data analysis.
G. Research Instruments
1. Learning Outcomes Test
The instrument used in this study was the learning outcomes test (post-test),
namely the value of the cognitive aspect in the form of multiple choice questions to
find out the learning outcomes of students after participating in learning activities.
This learning outcomes test consists of 25 multiple choice questions that have gone
through a content validation process by an expert validator and then tested on 30
students of class XII MIPA 4 and processed to determine the validity of the test. In
addition, item validation was also carried out. Item validation was carried out
including determining the index of difficulty, discriminating power, validation using
the correlation of product moments with rough numbers and reliability. Item
Validation Results can be seen in Appendix C.1
a. Difficulty index
The difficulty index shows the difficulty level of the question. The formula
for finding the index of difficulty (Arikunto, 2016), namely:
B
P=
JS
Information :
P = index of difficulty/proportion
B = the number of students who answered correctly on the question
JS = the total number of students who were tested
b. Discriminating Power
The discriminating power of the item is the ability of the item to distinguish
between high-ability students and low-ability students (Arikunto, 2016). The formula
for calculating the discriminating power of questions is:
JBA JBB
D= - atau D = PA – PB
JTA JTB
Information :
D = power of discrimination or discrimination
JBA = the number of students who answered correctly at the top
JTA = total number of students at the top
JBB = the number of students who answered correctly at the bottom
JTB = total number of students at the bottom
PA = upper difficulty index
PB = bottom difficulty index
c. validity
According to Arikunto (2016), a test can be said to be valid if the test
measures what it is intended to measure. The technique used to determine alignment
is the product moment correlation technique proposed by Pearson. There are 2
product moment correlation formulas, namely product moment correlation with
deviations and product moment correlation with rough numbers. Product moment
correlation formula with rough numbers:
rxy = N ∑ XY −¿¿ ¿
Information :
rxy = correlation coefficient between variable X and variable Y, the two variables are
correlated
d. Reliability
Reliability is the determination of a test when it is tested on the same subject. In order
to find out this provision, basically it is seen from the parallel results (Arikunto,
2016). The criteria used to determine determination are outside the test (external
consistency) and on the test itself (internal consistency). To determine the reliability
of all tests, the Spearman-Brown formula must be used as follows:
1/ 21 /2
2r
r11 = 1 /2 1 /2
(1+r )
Information
r ½ ½ = correlation between the scores of each half of the test
r11 = adjusted reliability coefficient
2) Class completeness
∑ Tp
Tk = X 100%
n
Information:
Tk : Finish class
∑Tp : Completed number of individuals
n : Number of students
Percentage implementation =
∑ X x 100%
N
Information:
Σx= total score of each item
N = maximum score
2. Inferential statistical analysis
a. Prerequisite Test
1) Normality Test
The normality test is used to determine whether the data under study comes
from a normally distributed population or not. Test the normality of the data using the
following formula:
2 (Oi−Ei)2
x =∑ va
Ei
Information:
2
x = Kai square (Chi square )
Oi = observation frequency
Ei = Expected frequency
If the calculated Chi squared value is smaller or equal to the table Chi Squared
price ( x 2count ≤ x 2table) then the distribution is declared normal, and if it is greater ( x 2count
< x 2table) is declared abnormal (Sugiyono, 2010).
2) Homogeneity Test
Homogeneity test aims to determine whether the two groups of data obtained
are homogeneous or not. Homogeneity testing is carried out using the following
formula:
Big Varians
F count =
Small Varians
The criteria for testing homogeneity with a significant level of α = 0.05,
namely if Fcount˂Ftable, then the data is homogeneous (Subana et al, 2000).
3) Hypothesis Test
Hypothesis testing is carried out using a parametric statistical test, namely
the Mann-Whitmey test with the following hypotheses:
H0 ¿ μ1 ≤ μ2
H1 ¿ μ1 ¿ μ2
Information :
H0 = There is no effect of the use of google site-based interactive multimedia on the
problem based learning model on the learning outcomes of class XI MIPA
students at SMA Negeri 2 Majene in the material of hydrocarbon compounds.
H1 = There is an effect of the use of google site-based interactive multimedia on the
problem based learning model on the learning outcomes of class XI MIPA
students at SMA Negeri 2 Majene in the material of hydrocarbon compounds.
µ1 = Average learning outcomes of the experimental population.
µ2 = Average learning outcomes of the control population.
The Mann-Whitmey test was used because the samples used were not
normally distributed. The Mann-Whitney test is carried out in the following steps:
a) Combine data from the two groups and then arrange the data from high to low.
b) Give the order (rank) of each value contained in the two groups with a range of 1
to N = n1 + n2. Ranking starts from the same data, so the rating is the average of the
same data ranking.
c) Separate again according to the group and add up the order (rank) of each group.
Total ranking for group n1=R1 and total ranking for group n2=R2.
d) Calculating the value of U using the formula:
n 1(n 1+ 1) n 1(n 1+ 1)
U1 =n1.n2 + ( -∑R1) or U2 = n1n2 + ( -∑R2)
1 1
The value of U that is the smallest is the value sought
e) Calculate the value of Z using the formula:
n xn
U 1 2
U −μU 2
Z hitung= =
√
σU n1 n2 (n1 +n2 +1)
12
Information :
n1 = the number of experimental group data
n2 = Number of data for the control group
Σ 𝑅1 = number of orders (rank) of the experimental group
Σ 𝑅2 = number of orders (rank) of the control group
𝜎𝑈 = standard deviation
μ 𝖴 = Mean
Test criteria:
The criteria for testing the hypothesis are at the level α = 0.05. If Z count > Ztable
then H0 is rejected and H1 is accepted. This means that there is an influence of
interactive multimedia based on Google site on the problem based learning model on
the learning outcomes of class XI students of SMA Negeri 2 Majene on the material
of hydrocarbon compounds. Conversely, if Zcount < Ztable, then H0 is accepted and H1 is
rejected, meaning that there is no effect of interactive multimedia based on Google
site on the problem-based learning model on the learning outcomes of class XI
students at SMA Negeri 2 Majene on the material of hydrocarbon compounds.
1 Identifying hydrocarbon
compounds in everyday 72.85% Incomplete 62,15% Incomplete
life
2 Describe the
characteristics of the 90,47% Complete 83,83% Complete
carbon atom
Experiment Group Control Group
No Indicator
Percentage Ket Percentage Ket
4 Determining hydrocarbon
compounds based on bond 79,09% Complete 63,64% Incomplete
saturation
5 Determine the structure
and nomenclature of
alkanes, alkenes and 81,9% Complete 77,78% Complete
alkynes based on IUPAC
rules
6 Analyze the properties of
hydrocarbon compounds 65,71% Incomplete 64,49% Incomplete
Table 4.3 shows that the mastery of students' learning outcomes in the subject
matter of hydrocarbon compounds for the experimental group has higher mastery
compared to the mastery of students in the control group. Achievement of
completeness indicators of the experimental group of the eight indicators only five
indicators met the completeness criteria, while for the control group of the eight
indicators only three met the completeness criteria.
b. Observation Results of Learning Implementation
Observation of the implementation of student learning using interactive
multimedia based on google site in the problem based learning model in the
experimental group and learning without using interactive multimedia based on
google site in the problem based learning model in the control group. Observation of
the implementation of learning involves two observers, then the value is averaged.
Based on the results of observations made in the experimental group and the control
group, the percentage of learning achievement is obtained in Table 4.4
Table 4.4 shows that the implementation of the learning process in the
experimental group and the control group has an average percentage value in the very
good category. The table explains that each phase in the syntax of the problem-based
learning model using interactive multimedia based on Google sites or cannot be
carried out very well, although there are phases that are not carried out in the control
group and the experimental group.
2. Inferential Statistical Analysis
a. Testing Prerequisite analysis
Inferential statistical analysis was used to test the research hypothesis, namely
that there was an effect of interactive multimedia based on Google site on the
problem-based learning model on the learning outcomes of class XI students at SMA
Negeri 2 Majene. Before testing the hypothesis, the normality test and homogeneity
test are first carried out as a prerequisite in determining the type of test used in
hypothesis testing.
1) Normality Test
The normality test aims to determine whether the data used comes from a
normally distributed population or not. The technique for testing the normality of
student learning outcomes data is carried out using Chi Square ( x 2) at a significant
level α = 0.05, with the criteria for normally distributed data x 2count < x 2table
From the calculation results for the experimental group, it is obtained that x 2
2
count = 11.35 and x table at the confidence level (𝛼) = 0.05 and degrees of freedom (dk)
= 3, x 2table = 7.81. Thus the experimental group obtained x 2count (11.35) > x 2table (7.81),
meaning that the samples in the experimental group were not normally distributed.
Whereas for the control group, based on the calculation results, it was obtained x 2count
= 12.99 and x 2table at the confidence level (𝛼) = 0.05 and degrees of freedom (dk) = 4,
2 2 2
x table = 9.48. Thus in the control group obtained x count (12.99) > x table (9.48), meaning
that the sample in the control group is not normally distributed. The normality test in
the experimental group and the control group is presented in table 4.5
b. Hypothesis testing
Hypothesis testing is used to test the hypotheses that have been formulated
namely to determine whether there is influence of interactive multimedia based on
google site on the problem based learning learning model on the learning outcomes of
class XI SMAN 2 Majene students on the subject matter of hydrocarbon compounds.
Based on the prerequisite tests that have been carried out, information is obtained that
the learning outcomes data from the experimental and control groups are not
normally distributed, and both groups come from homogeneous populations.
Furthermore, one-sided t-test cannot be used to test the hypothesis because the
samples obtained are not normally distributed, therefore hypothesis testing can be
carried out using non-parametric statistical tests, namely the Mann-Whitney test with
statistical hypotheses: H0 : 𝜇̅1 ≤ 𝜇2 H1 : 𝜇̅1 > 𝜇2. Based on the calculation results from
the Mann-Whitney test, Zcount = 2.61 and Ztable = 1.64 at a confidence level of 0.05.
Because Zcount>Ztable (2.61 > 1.64) then H1 is accepted and H0 is rejected, so it can be
concluded that there is an influence of interactive multimedia based on google site on
the problem based learning model on the learning outcomes of class XI students at
SMA Negeri 2 Majene on the subject matter Hydrocarbon Compounds.
B. Discussion
Google site-based interactive multimedia is a learning method designed to
assist students in determining and compiling the core of learning material in the form
of links to create class, school, or other websites. This research was conducted with
the aim of knowing whether or not there is influence of interactive multimedia based
on Google site on the problem based learning model on student learning outcomes in
class XI SMA Negeri 2 Majene on the subject matter of hydrocarbon compounds. In
this study, the sample used consisted of two classes, namely class XI MIPA 2 as the
experimental group which was given interactive multimedia based on Google site on
the problem based learning model and class XI MIPA 3 as the control group without
using interactive multimedia based on google site on the problem model. based
learning. The difference in treatment in the learning process produces differences in
student learning outcomes shown in the data from the descriptive analysis of table
4.1.
Based on the table shows that the average value of the experimental group is
higher than the average value of the control group. The average value obtained in the
experimental group was 79.72 while the average value in the control group was
72.85. In addition, there are also differences in the standard deviation value, the
experimental group has a lower standard deviation value than the control group. This
means that the results of data deviations in the experimental group using google site-
based interactive multimedia in the problem based learning model were less than the
control group without using google site-based interactive multimedia in the problem
based learning model. In the experimental group, Google site-based interactive
multimedia was embedded in all syntaxes. The learning material provided is material
for hydrocarbon compounds, where the material for hydrocarbon compounds is
explained as many as eight indicators of competency achievement and distributed in
five meetings with one post-test.
Table 4.2. presents the percentage of completeness of each group. Based on
the complete and incomplete categories, the percentage of completeness in the
experimental group was higher than that of the control group. Where in the
experimental group the frequency met the completeness criteria, namely 26 students
out of 35 with a percentage of 74.29% while in the control group which met the
completeness criteria, namely 19 students out of 33 with a percentage of 57.58%.
This illustrates that the achievement of student learning outcomes in the experimental
group using interactive multimedia based on Google site in the problem based
learning model can attract the attention of students to concentrate. This is in
accordance with the research conducted by Levied and Lentz (in Arsyad, 2014)
learning media has an attentional function, namely attracting students' attention to
concentrate on lesson content related to the visual meaning displayed or
accompanying learning texts. In addition to class completeness, the percentage of
achievement of each indicator on the material of hydrocarbon compounds for the
experimental group and control group can be seen in table 4.3
Judging from the average percentage of achievement of each indicator on the
learning outcomes of the experimental group is higher than the average percentage of
achievement of each indicator on the learning outcomes of the control group.
However, even though the achievement of the indicators of learning outcomes in the
experimental group was higher than the control group, there was one indicator of
learning outcomes, where the control group obtained a higher percentage of scores
than the experimental group. This is because the use of interactive multimedia based
on Google site is not suitable for this indicator.
Based on table 4.3, it shows that in the experimental group there were three
indicators that were incomplete while in the control group there were five
indicators that do not reach its completeness. The failure of indicators in the
experimental group can show that learning using interactive multimedia based on
Google sites in the problem based learning model is not optimal in helping students to
understand the concept of indicators of hydrocarbon compounds. This is seen from
the incomplete indicators in the experimental group and the control group, namely
indicators identifying hydrocarbon compounds in everyday life. This is because
students cannot explain hydrocarbon compounds as organic compounds consisting of
the elements carbon and hydrogen, students are also unable to explain that hydrogen
is an organic compound. Next is an indicator on analyzing the properties of
hydrocarbon compounds based on their compound groups (alkanes, alkenes, and
alkynes). The incompleteness of these indicators is because students have not been
able to analyze the relationship between boiling point and relative atomic mass and its
structure. as well as indicators on analyzing simple reactions in alkanes, alkenes, and
alkynes (oxidation reactions, addition reactions, substitution reactions and elimination
reactions). Where students are still wrong in writing reactions to hydrocarbon
compounds.
The indicators which were also incomplete in the control group but completed
in the experimental group were indicators of determining hydrocarbon compounds
based on bond saturation. Inadequateness in these indicators, students have not been
able to distinguish hydrocarbon compounds based on the saturation of their bonds. As
well as on indicators regarding predicting the type of isomer (isomer frame, position,
function, geometry) of hydrocarbon compounds. Where in these indicators, students
understand more about positional isomers so that in these indicators many students do
not complete.
Based on the description of the percentage of completeness of each indicator
above, although there are indicators that are incomplete. In general, it can be
concluded that the use of google site-based interactive multimedia in the experimental
group's problem-based learning model can help students understand the material so as
to improve student learning outcomes. Where the average percentage of mastery
indicators in the experimental group was 78.27% higher than the average percentage
of mastery indicators in the control group, namely 71.89%. This is in accordance with
Nur (2017), electronic media can help students to improve competence and cognitive
understanding, as well as make it easier for students to learn the content of material in
the media because it is easy to carry anywhere and anytime.
Inferential analysis which aims to test the truth of the hypothesis proposed,
accepted or rejected. Before testing the hypothesis, prerequisite tests are first carried
out, namely the normality test and homogeneity test. Based on the normality test, it
was stated that both the experimental group and the control group came from
populations that were not normally distributed. The homogeneity test based on the
calculation results shows that the data from the experimental group and the control
group come from a homogeneous variance. Therefore hypothesis testing cannot be
carried out using parametric statistics (t-test) because it does not meet the test
requirements, but hypothesis testing is carried out using nonparametric statistics
(Mann-Whitney test).
Based on the results of hypothesis testing, Zcount > Ztable (2.61 > 1.64), thus the
proposed hypothesis is accepted, namely the influence of interactive multimedia
based on Google site on the problem based learning model on student learning
outcomes in class XI SMA Negeri 2 Majene in the study the main ingredient of
hydrocarbon compounds.
The use of google site-based interactive multimedia on the model
problem based learning in the learning process has an important influence
because with this media, the learning process will take place in an active, creative and
effective and fun way. This is in accordance with research conducted by Wicaksono
& Rachmadyanti (2017) stating that through the use of the Google site students
become more comfortable and more active in constructing. The existence of
interactive multimedia based on Google sites using problem based learning models
can help students understand the material of hydrocarbon compounds. Where the use
of google site-based interactive multimedia in problem-based learning models can
visualize hydrocarbon compound material in the form of images, video, text, audio
and animation. This, according to the results said by Darmawan (2014: 55-56) is able
to activate students to learn with high motivation because of their interest in
multimedia systems that are able to display text, images, videos, sounds, and
animations.
In addition, the use of google site-based interactive multimedia in the
problem-based learning model for learning outcomes can provide opportunities for
students to be actively involved in the learning process and find a concept for
themselves in solving the given problem. When viewed as a whole, learning media
using interactive multimedia based on Google sites is suitable to be combined with
problem-based learning models, where the learning outcomes of students in the
experimental group are higher than the percentage in the control group. This is in line
with Dewi's opinion, C.K. (2018) which states that Google site-based learning has
good potential to be used as an effective learning medium because it can stimulate
visual and verbal components.
Hosnan. 2014. Pendekatan Saintifik dan Kontekstual dalam Pembelajaran Abad 21.
Jakarta : Ghalia Indonesia
Nur A. Limatahu., Nurul Aulia Rahman., St. Hayatun Nur Abu., Indra Cipta. 2017.
Pengaruh Video Praktikum Dengan Modul Elektronik Terhadap
Keterampilan Proses Pada Materi Stoikiometri Peserta didik Kelas X
SMAN 2 Tidore Kepulauan. Jurnal Pendidikan Kimia. Vol. 9, No. 1,
Sudjana, N., & Rivai, A. 2007. Teknologi Pengajaran. Bandung: Sinar Baru
Algensindo.
Sudjana, Nana. 2005. Dasar-dasar Proses Belajar Mengajar. Bandung. Sinar Baru
Algensindo.
Susanto, Ahmad. 2016. Teori Belajar & Pembelajaran di Sekolah Dasar. Jakarta:
Prenadamedia Group.
Peserta didik dengan Metode Problem Based Learning pada Peserta didik Kelas