Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ackerman Adams 2004 Perceptions of Causes of Performance Related Injuries by Music Health Experts and Injured Violinists
Ackerman Adams 2004 Perceptions of Causes of Performance Related Injuries by Music Health Experts and Injured Violinists
Ackerman Adams 2004 Perceptions of Causes of Performance Related Injuries by Music Health Experts and Injured Violinists
School of Physiotherapy
University of Sydney
Summary.-Skilled violin and viola players, all of whom had a current perfor-
mance-related musculoskeletal injury, were asked to report their perceptions of con-
tributing risk factors, consistent with a participatory ergonomics approach. The 26
players, age 18 to 60 years, had been playing for a minimum of 10 years and averaged
three hours of practice per day. In addition, 7 music health experts, all with more
than 10 years of clinical experience in treating musicians, were asked to report on the
risk factors for musicians' performance-related injuries. A high correlation between
the perceptions of these two groups was found, with the same top five factors in terms
of severity indicated by both groups. Factors rated as high risk were primarily intrin-
sic and related to the manner in which respondents practiced, to playing posture, and
to flaws in skill technique.
'Please address correspondence to Dr. Bronwen J. Ackermann, P.O. Box 192, Civic Square,
ACT 2608, Australia or e-mail (ackerman@netspeed.com.au).
670 B. J. ACKERMANN & R. D. ADAMS
TABLE 1
SUMMARY
OF SURVEYS
ASSESSING
INCIDENCEOF PERFORMANCE-RELATED
MUSCULOSKELETAL
INJURIES
OF MUSICIANS
ing the music, but also an expressive one, whereby gestures and flourishes
add emotion and vibrancy to the performance (Ruggieri & Katsnelson, 1996;
De Poli, Roda, & Vidolin, 1998), so individual differences might be expect-
ed, Furthermore, diverse methods of playing the violin and viola have devel-
oped over centuries from different cultures and countries, and hence there
are considerable variations in playing styles (Dilworth, 1992). Pedagogical
books and papers on both posture and technical aspects of playing written
by violinists and violists tend to reflect their personal views and experiences
(Flesch, 1939; Galamian, 1962; Weilerstein & Neal, 2000) without using sci-
entific or injury data about associations with particular movement patterns.
Eales (1992) noted that the available range of teaching and playing styles
would bewilder the aspiring violin player, with no consensus providing per-
spective on different styles and their relation to performer physical character-
istics or potential injury risk. The importance of recognising players' percep-
tions of risk factors for musculoskeletal injury is a key concept in the field of
participatory ergonomics (Noro & Imada, 1991; Vink, Peeters, Grundemann,
Smulders, Kompier, & Dul, 1995; Kuorinka, 1997; Zalk, 2001). Information
provided by equipment users has been beneficial in implementing programs
to manage risks in several occupational domains, e.g., with steelworkers, man-
ual handling jobs, meat processing workers, and office workers (Kuorinka &
Patry, 1995; Vink, et al., 1995). To date, identification of risk factors among
musicians has been obtained from separate surveys given either to musicians
or to the medical professionals who provide their h d t h care.
The purpose of the current study was to investigate the relative impor-
tance of commonly cited risk factors from both the perspective of the violin-
ist and the music health professional. Information obtained can then be ex-
amined for agreement on the perceived relevant risk factors between these
groups.
Subjects
Highly skilled musicians (N= 28), comprising 26 violinists and 2 violists
who were from three different university music schools and two different or-
chestras and who were currently suffering performance-related musculoskele-
tal disorders volunteered to participate. Subjects were 21 women and seven
men with an age range of 18 to 60 years. Their mean daily practice time was
3 hr. (with a range between 1.5 to 6 hours per day). No subjects were un-
able to practice or perform at their normal capacity due to severity of their
pain. The music health experts group consisted of four medical specialists
and three physiotherapists (three women and four men) all of whom had
worked clinically with musicians for more than 10 years. Musician volunteers
were recruited by notices placed in several university music institutions and
B. J. ACKERMANN & R. D. ADAMS
TABLE 2
-
In
([I
C
.-0
In
V)
2
2
a
6
-
([I
Q)
I
Musicians
FIG. 1. Scatter plot of summed severity scores for different factors made by the injured
violinists and violists and the music health experts. The five factors on the right are intrinsic
and difficult to define. The point of maximum discrepancy between the two groups was the
perceived severity of touring as a risk factor for injuries.
enough to take into account the individual physical and mental characteris-
tics of each performer (Galamian, 1962). In the past, there have been some
attempts to understand the physiological processes involved in playing the
violin as a basis for suggesting ways in which playing stresses may be altered
(Polnauer & Marks, 1964; Szende & Nemessuri, 1971). If necessary it seems
possible that technique could be modified successfully even in these elite vio-
linists as was achieved with elite swimmers (Sanders, 1995), and indeed this
happens commonly when violin or viola students change teachers. However,
the effect of altering the physical movements within a technique on musical
performance is not known, and some interventions may actually have detri-
mental effects (Ackermann, Adams, & Marshall, 2002a). That musicians per-
ceive poor technique to be a relatively critical risk factor indicates the neces-
sity for further research and education to identify whether particular tech-
niques, as with postures, are in fact identifiable and consistently linked to an
increased risk of injuries.
Out of the five risk factors rated as most likely to cause an injury re-
lated to playing an instrument, poor practice habits could account for three
out of the top five. Long hours of practice and sudden increases in practice
time were reported consistently despite the variability in practice hours be-
VIOLINISTS: PERFORMANCE-RELATED INJURY 675
tween the performers and the lack of practice information given to the mu-
sic health professionals. Hence, this may be considered to be a relative phe-
nomenon rather than an absolute one. That there is a risk from a sudden in-
crease in hours of practice or long hours of practice may partiaUy reflect in-
adequate preparatory muscle endurance conditioning (Ackermann, et al.,
2002b). Insufficient rest breaks was also considered important and may act
by increasing tissue injury as a result of not dowing sufficient time for tis-
sue recovery (Hagberg, 1997)) creating similar types of tissue overload to the
highest ranking two factors.
This poor management of practice scheduling suggests musicians' inade-
quate understanding of the physiology of muscle recovery and basic training
principles. To approach the management of these problems, musicians and
music teachers may need to evaluate how they manage practice and perfor-
mance schedules and be involved in suggesting how more appropriate sched-
ules can be introduced into their practice regimes. Increasingly emphasised
is that musicians should ideally be given adequate training in these areas
while studying at music conservatories (Tubiana, 2000; Spahn, Hildebrandt,
& Seidenglanz , 2001). Graduated schedules of increasing practice when com-
mencing playing after holidays or an injury, such as the return to play strat-
egies suggested by Norris (1996)) do not appear to be commonly used. Lit-
erature in pedagogical books on this topic is sparse, with one famous violin
pedagogue recommending rest breaks of 15 min. after every hour of practice
(Flesch, 1939). However, it is likely that such a time frame would need to be
adjustable depending on the familiarity and musical demands of the piece to
be played, as muscle fatigability alters according to differing physical require-
ments (Gandevia, 2001; Visentin & Shan, 2003). In professional situations,
rest breaks may be partly set by conductors who can reduce the control the
professional musician has over this aspect of their performance (Horvath,
2002). In the orchestral situation, a participatory ergonomics team approach
with orchestral management bodies, musicians and specialised health practi-
tioners may be helpful in scheduling so the risk of injury to players is re-
duced.
Risk factors below the top five identified above showed overall good
agreement, with some differences which may reflect a result of the training
differences between the two groups. For example, the music health profes-
sionals rated poor physical condition far more highly than the violinists,
which may mean condition is not an apparent problem to the musicians who
are less likely to be aware of the benefits of good physical condition. Extrin-
sic risk factors showed more variability in perceived importance and were
overall rated lower than intrinsic risk factors by both groups.
Interestingly, in one area there was little agreement. The injured violin-
ists identified touring as influential in developing injuries, a viewpoint not
676 B. J. ACKERMANN & R. D. ADAMS
shared by the music health experts. This may partially reflect relatively little
experience of touring amongst these health practitioners working predomi-
nantly in a clinical practice. Injuries whilst touring do occur, and those sus-
tained by musicians have been previously documented (Ackermann , 2002).
From these data, part of the solution to reducing injury in violinists and
violists may be better provision of health education to the music teachers
and musicians (Spahn, et al., 2001). Understanding the interface between the
performer and the instrument in relation to different individual physical
characteristics may help early troubleshooting (Ackermann & Adams, 2003).
This may allow musicians and teachers to develop a "repertoire" of knowl-
edge to fit differing physical and musical requirements.
Conclusion
Intrinsic factors related to both performance characteristics and dura-
tion were suggested by both musicians and music health experts as of great-
er importance in injury than extrinsic or environmental demands. The five
factors rated by both health professionals and skilled violinists as the most
likely to cause injury are essentially difficult to define. The ideal practice
structure, posture, and technique could arguably be only judged after detail-
ed consideration of an individual's anthropometrics, style of playing, and the
relevant requirements of repertoire. Further research may indicate whether
more widespread health education could assist more teachers when fitting
pedagogical viewpoints and ideas about playing styles with physical charac-
teristics of individual violinists or violists.
REFERENCES
ACKERMANN, B. (2002) Managing the musculoskeletal health of musicians on tour. Medical
Problems of Performing Artists, 17, 63 -67.
ACKERMANN, B., ADAMS,R., & MARSHALL, E. (2002a) The effect of scapula taping on elec-
tromyographic activity and musical performance in professional violinists. Australian Jour-
nal of Physiotherapy, 48, 197-203.
ACKERMANN, B., ADAMS,R., &MARSHALL, E. (2002b) Strength or endurance training for under-
graduate music majors at a university? Medical Problems of Performing Artists, 17, 33-41.
ACKERMANN, B. I., &ADAMS,R. (2003) Physical characteristics and pain patterns of skilled vio-
linists. Medical Problems of Performing Artists, 18, 65-71.
BEJJANI,F. J. (2000) Musculoskeletal occupational disorders. In R. Tubiana & P. C. Amadio
(Eds.), Medical problems of the instrumentalist musician. London: Martin Dunitz, Ltd. Pp.
219-244.
BLOOMFIELD, J., ACKLAND, T., &ELLIOTT,B. (1994) Applied anatomy and biomechanics in sport.
Victoria, Australia: Blackwell Scientific.
BRANDFONBRENER, A. G. (2000) Epidemiology and risk factors. In R. Tubiana & P. C. Amadio
(Eds.), Medical problems of the zizstrumentalist musician. London: Martin Dunitz, Ltd.
Chap. 8, pp. 171-194.
BROCKMAN, R., TUBIANA, R., & CHAMAGNE, I? (1992) Anataomic and kinesiologic considerations
of posture for instrumental musician. Journal of Hand Therapy, April-June, 61-64.
CALDRON, I? H., CALABRESE, L. H., CLOUGH, J. D., LEDERMAN, R. J., WILLIAMS,
G., &LEATHER-
MAN,J. (1986) A survey of musculoskeletal problems encountered in high-level musi-
cians. Medical Problems of Performing Artists, 1, 136-139.
VIOLINISTS: PERFORMANCE-RELATED INJURY 677
DAVIES,J., & MANGION,C. (2002) Predictors of ain and other musculoskeletal symptoms
among professional instrumental musicians: ekcidating special effects. Medical Problems
of Performing Artists, 17, 155-168.
DE POLI,G., RODA,A., &VIDOLIN, A. (1998) Note-by-note analysis of the influence of expres-
sive intentions and musical structure in violin performance. Journal of New Music Re-
search, 27, 293 -321.
DILWORTH, J. (1992) The violin and bow-origins and develo ment. In R. Stowell (Ed.), The
Cambridge companion to the violin. Cambridge, UK: Cam\ridge Univer. Press. Pp. 1-29.
DOMMERHOLDT, J. (2000) Posture. In R. Tubiana & P. C. Amadio (Eds.), Medical problems of
the tizstmmentalist musician. London: Martin Dunitz, Ltd. Pp. 399-419.
EALES,A. (1992) The fundamentals of violin laying and teaching. In R. Stowell (Ed.), The
Cambridge companion to the violin. CamEridge, UK: Cambridge Univer. Press. Pp. 92-
121.
ERICSSON, K. A., KRAMPE, R. T., &TESCH-ROMER, C. (1993) The role of deliberate practice in
the acquisition of expert performance. Psychological Review, 100, 363-406.
FLESCH,C. (1939) The art of violin playing. (Rev. ed.) New York: Carl Fischer Publ.
FRY,H. J. H. (1986) Overuse syndrome in musicians: prevention and management. The Lancet,
1, 728-731.
GALAMIAN, L. (1962) Principles of violin playing and teaching. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-
Hall.
GANDEVIA, S. C. (2001) Spinal and supraspinal factors in human muscle fatigue. Psychological
Reviews, 81, 1725-1789.
HAGBERG, M. (1997) Conce tual and definitional issues in occupational injury epidemiology.
American Journal of b8usrrial Medicine, 32, 106-115.
HINER,S. L., BRANDT, K. D., KATZ,B. l?, FRENCH,R. N., & BECZKIEWICZ, T. J. (1987) Perfor-
mance-related problems amongst premier violinists. Medical Problems of Performing Ar-
tists, 2, 67-71.
HODGSON, (-1958) Motion study and violin-bowing. Urbana, IL: American String Teachers
Association.
HORVATH, J. (2002) Playing (less) hurt. Kearney, NE: Morris Publ.
KUORINKA, I. (1997) Tools and means of implementing participatory ergonomics. International
Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 19, 267-270.
KUORINKA, I., & PATRY,L. (1995) Participation as a means of promoting occupational health.
International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 15, 365-370.
LARSSON, L. G., BAUM,J., MUDHOLKAR, G. S., & KOLLIA,G. D. (1993) Nature and im act of
musculoskeletal problems in a population of musicians. Medical Problems of pe&rming
Artists, 8, 73-76.
MEDOFF,L. E. (1999) The importance of movement education in the training of young violin-
ists. Medical Problems of Performing Artists, 14, 210-219.
MIDDLESTADT, S. E., &FISHBEIN, M. (1989) The prevalence of severe musculoskeletal roblems
among male and female symphony orchestra string players. Medical Problems oj!~erform-
ing Artists, 4, 41-48.
NORO,K., &IMADA, A. (1991) Participatory ergonomic^. London: Taylor & Francis.
NORRIS,R. (1993) The musi&nJs survival manual: a guide to preventing and treating injuries in
instrumentalists. Saint Louis, MO: MMB Music, Inc.
NORRIS,R. (1996) Return to play after injury: strategies to support a musician's recovery.
Work, 7, 89-93.
POLNAUER, F. F., &MARKS,M. (1964) Sensorimotor study and its application to violin playing.
Champaign, IL: American String Teachers Association.
RUGGIERI, V., &KATSNELSON, A. (1996) An analysis of a performance by the violinist D. Oistra-
kh: the h othetical role of postural tonic-static and entourage movements. Perceptual and
Motor ~ k % s ,82, 291-300.
SANDERS, R. (1995) Can skilled performers readily chan e technique? An example, convention-
al to wave action breaststroke. Human Movement fcience, 14, 665-679.
SPAHN,C., HILDEBRANDT, H., &SEIDENGLANZ, K. (2001) Effectiveness of a prophylactic course
to prevent playing-related health problems of music students. Medical Problems of Per-
forming Artists, 16, 24-3 1.
678 B. J. ACKERMANN & R. D. ADAMS
SZENDE, O., &NEMESSURI, M. (1971) The physiology of violin playing. Budapest: Collett's, Ltd.
& Akademiai Kiado.
TUBIANA, R. (2000) Functional anatomy. In R. Tubiana & P. C. Amadio (Eds.), Medical prob-
lems of the instrzmzentalist musician. London: Martin Dunitz, Ltd. Pp. 1-4.
TULCHINSKY, E., & RIOLO,L. (1994) A biomechanical motion analysis of the violinist's bow
arm. Medical Problems of Performing Artists, 9, 125-130.
TURNER-STOKES, L., &REID, K. (1999) Three-dimensional motion analysis of upper limb move-
ment in the bowing arm of string-playing musicians. Clinical Biomechanics, 14, 426-433.
VINK,I?, PEETERS, M., GRUNDEMANN, R., SMULDERS,I?, KOMPIER, M., &DuL, J. (1995) A partic-
ipator ergonomics approach to reduce mental and physical workload. International Jour-
nal o h d u s t r i a l Ergonomics, 15, 389-396.
VISENTIN, I?, &SHAN,G. (2003) The kinetic characteristics of the bow arm during violin per-
formance: an examination of internal loads as a function of tempo. Medical Problems of
Performing Artists, 18, 9 1-97.
WEILERSTEIN, D., &NEAL,C. (2000) Violin technique. In R. Tubiana & P. C. Amadio (Eds.),
Medical problems of the instrumentalist musician. London: Martin Dunitz, Ltd. Chap. 31,
pp. 573-594.
WELDON, E. J. 111, &RICHARDSON, A. B. (2001) Upper extremity overuse injuries in swimming.
Clinics in Sports Medicine, 20, 423-438.
ZALK,D. (2001) Grassroots ergonomics: initiating an ergonomics program utilizing participa-
tory techniques. The Annals of Occupational Hygiene, 45, 283-289.
ZAZA,C., &FAREWELL, V. T. (1997) Musicians' playing-related musculoskeletal disorders: an ex-
amination of risk factors. American Journal of Industrial Medicine, 32, 292-300.
ZETTERBERG, C., BACKLUND, H., KARLSSON, J., WERNER,H., &OLSSON,L. (1998) Musculoskele-
tal problems among male and female music students. Medical Problems of Performing Ar-
tists, 13, 160-166.
ZUKOFSKY, l? (1992) Aspects of contemporary technique. In R. Stowell (Ed.), The Cambridge
companion to the violin. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge Univer. Press. Pp. 143-147.