1

Italian army in World War II

Name

Affiliation

Course

Date
 2

Italian army in World War II

The performance of the Italian navy throughout the Second World War can be described

as a combination of achievements and disappointments across numerous theaters of battle

(Sadkovich, 1996). The Italian militia confronted several challenges and encountered both

success and failures, influenced by factors such as leadership, resources, training, and strategic

choices (Sadkovich, 1996). In this evaluation, we will explore the Italian military's performance

in the major theaters of war, discuss the contributing factors to their successes and failures, and

examine the effect they had on the overall course of the conflict (Brown, 1999).

One significant theater of operation for the Italian military was North Africa. Initially,

under the command of General Rodolfo Graziani, they achieved some triumphs by capturing

British-held territories in Libya (Ballinger, 2007). However, their progress was eventually halted

by General Sir Archibald Wavell's British forces (Sadkovich, 1996). The Italian military's lack of

essential resources, such as tanks and aircraft, coupled with inadequate logistical support,

contributed to their failures (Sadkovich, 1996). Furthermore, their command structure and

coordination proved ineffective, hampering their ability to sustain successful offensives

(Sadkovich, 1996). As a result, the Italian forces were gradually pushed back, and their defeat at

the Battle of El Alamein in 1942 became a turning point in the North African campaign (De

Ninno 2020).

In the Balkans, the Italian military faced significant challenges as well. Their invasion of

Greece in 1940 ended in failure, as the Greek forces not only repelled the Italian offensive but

also counterattacked, pushing the Italian army back into Albania (Sadkovich, 1994). Inadequate

leadership, poor planning, and logistical difficulties were key factors contributing to the Italian
 3

military's struggles in the Balkans (Sadkovich, 1994). Ultimately, the German intervention in

1941 secured victory for the Axis powers in the region (Sadkovich, 1994).

Defending their homeland within Italy itself posed a daunting task for the Italian military.

Weaknesses in terms of equipment, training, and morale plagued the Italian army (Sadkovich,

1996). Moreover, Italy's industrial base was not as robust as that of other major powers involved

in the war, limiting their ability to sustain a prolonged conflict (Sadkovich, 1996). When the

Allies invaded Sicily in 1943, the Italian military's resistance quickly crumbled, leading to the

fall of Mussolini's regime (De Ninno, 2020). Italy subsequently switched sides and joined the

Allies, resulting in the occupation of Italy by German forces and a period of resistance

(Sadkovich, 1996).

The successes and failures of the Italian military were influenced by several factors.

Leadership played a crucial role, with ineffective commanders lacking tactical acumen and the

ability to inspire their troops (Sadkovich, 1996). Generals like Graziani and Marshal Pietro

Badoglio struggled to demonstrate strategic vision, while German commanders like Erwin

Rommel showcased superior leadership skills and strategic thinking, significantly impacting the

outcomes of battles in North Africa (Ballinger, 2007). Additionally, the lack of resources and

modernization within the Italian military hindered their performance (Sadkovich, 1996). Italy's

industrial capacity and technological advancements were limited compared to other major

powers in the war, resulting in outdated equipment and ill-preparedness to face the modern

warfare tactics employed by their adversaries (Ballinger, 2007).

Training and morale were additional factors influencing the Italian military's

performance. Italian soldiers often lacked rigorous training and found themselves ill-prepared for

the challenges they encountered on the battlefield (Sadkovich, 1996). Frequent defeats, poor
 4

leadership, and a sense of disillusionment with the war effort all contributed to declining morale

(Sadkovich, 1996). The performance of the Italian military had a significant impact on the course

of the war (Sadkovich, 1996). Their failures in North Africa and Greece diverted valuable Axis

resources and disrupted the Axis powers' overall timetable (Sadkovich, 1996). These setbacks

also provided an opportunity for the Allies to gain momentum and ultimately push the Axis

forces back (Sadkovich, 1996). Furthermore, Italy's switch of sides weakened the Axis alliance

and forced Germany to divert troops to occupy Italy, thereby further stretching its military

resources (Ballinger, 2007).

In conclusion, the Italian military's performance during the Second World War was a

combination of successes and failures. While they initially achieved victories in North Africa,

overall shortcomings in leadership, resources, and training hampered their efforts. These factors,

along with the superior capabilities of their adversaries, ultimately led to the Italian military's

defeat. Their performance had a significant impact on the course of the war, diverting Axis

resources, delaying their overall plans, and weakening the Axis alliance. This highlights the

crucial importance of effective leadership, adequate resources, and comprehensive training in

determining the outcomes of military campaigns.

 5

References:

Ballinger, P. (2007). Borders of the nation, borders of citizenship: Italian repatriation and the

redefinition of national identity after World War II. Comparative Studies in Society and

History, 49(3), 713-741.

Brown, L. (1999). A radar history of World War II. J. Am. Hist. Res.

De Ninno, F. (2020). The Italian Navy and Japan, the Indian Ocean, Failed Cooperation, and

Tripartite Relations (1935–1943). War in History, 27(2), 224-248.

Sadkovich, J. J. (1994). The Italian Navy in World War II. (No Title).

Sadkovich, J. J. (1996). The Indispensable Navy: Italy as a Great Power, 1911–43. In Naval

Power in the Twentieth Century (pp. 66-76). London: Palgrave Macmillan UK.