2 Data January of 2013

3 Fintel et al.
4 Baker et al. (2007), Baidya and Fragomeni (2013), and Russel and Corley (1997)
5 (ACI 209R, 1992).
6 (Neville A.M.,1970)
7 Polivka (1964)
8 (Glanville W.H.,1939)
9 Lorman (1970)
10 (ACI 233R, 20030).
11 (ACI 232.2R, 1996).
12 Gvozdev
13 L’Hermite and Mamilla
14 Haranki (2009),
15 ASTM C512 (2002).
16 Jones and Richart (1963)
17 Yashin (1959)
18 Bryant (1987)
19 Khan (1997)
20 ACI committee 517 (1963)
21 Hannant (1967
22 Nasser and Neville (1965)
23 AASHTO-LRFD 2010
24 ACI 209R-90 Modified by Huo
25 CEB-FIP 90
26 Bazant
27 (Nishiyama, 2009).
29 Person (1998
30 Malhotra (2000).
31 Pickett (1956)
32 Swayze (1960)
33 Bennett (1970)
34 (Khayat, 2009).
36 ODman (1968)
35 (Neville A.M., 1981).
37 Soraka (1979).
38 Tazawa (1989),
39 Sakai (1992),
40 (Nagataki, 1978).
41 Keene
42 Tazawa (1989),
43 Carlson
44 Alfes
45 Mazloom
46 Moragaspitiya et al.
47 Park
48 Russel and Corley
49 Arumugusaamy and Swamy
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
sel and Corley (1997)
 Tab. 5.1 Axial Shortening after 50 years

Column Elastic Creep & Shrinkage

Story Story label ∆z (mm) Ratio (%) ∆z (mm) Ratio (%)

54 FL53ROOF 21.7 28.27% 55.07 71.73%
53 FL52PH 26.8 34.01% 52.003 65.99%
52 FL51MECH 28.35 35.34% 51.875 64.66%
51 FL50 29.36 35.82% 52.605 64.18%
50 FL49 30.19 36.13% 53.377 63.87%
49 FL48 31 36.48% 53.987 63.52%
48 FL47 31.65 36.70% 54.583 63.30%
47 FL46 32.15 36.82% 55.171 63.18%
46 FL45 32.64 36.98% 55.626 63.02%
45 FL44 32.89 36.90% 56.252 63.10%
44 FL43 33.07 36.91% 56.521 63.09%
43 FL42 33.14 36.91% 56.636 63.09%
42 FL41 33.3 37.11% 56.438 62.89%
41 FL40 33.36 37.06% 56.655 62.94%
40 FL39 33.33 37.01% 56.722 62.99%
39 FL38 33.21 36.95% 56.657 63.05%
38 FL37 32.99 36.88% 56.465 63.12%
37 FL36 33.21 37.40% 55.589 62.60%
36 FL35ROOF 32.82 37.06% 55.736 62.94%
35 FL34 33.26 37.76% 54.827 62.24%
34 FL33MECH 33.25 37.21% 56.108 62.79%
33 FL32MECH 33.07 37.35% 55.477 62.65%
32 FL31 32.91 37.31% 55.287 62.69%
31 FL30 32.86 37.45% 54.877 62.55%
30 FL29 32.57 37.47% 54.348 62.53%
29 FL28 32.27 37.55% 53.68 62.45%
28 FL27 31.88 37.58% 52.945 62.42%
27 FL26 31.44 37.63% 52.121 62.37%
26 FL25 30.93 37.65% 51.211 62.35%
25 FL24 30.34 37.68% 50.175 62.32%
24 FL23 29.68 37.68% 49.082 62.32%
23 FL22 28.97 37.68% 47.913 62.32%
22 FL21 28.31 37.75% 46.685 62.25%
21 FL20REFUGE 27.81 37.75% 45.866 62.25%
20 FL19 27.25 37.72% 45.001 62.28%
19 FL18 26.65 37.68% 44.086 62.32%
18 FL17 26 37.61% 43.135 62.39%
17 FL16 25.32 37.54% 42.133 62.46%
16 FL15 24.59 37.43% 41.107 62.57%
15 FL14 23.82 37.29% 40.061 62.71%
14 FL13 23.02 37.11% 39.007 62.89%
13 FL12 22.18 36.86% 37.999 63.14%
12 FL11 21.79 36.87% 37.313 63.13%
11 FL10 19.36 37.28% 32.567 62.72%
10 FL09 17.65 37.67% 29.208 62.33%
9 FL08 16.71 37.81% 27.49 62.19%
8 FL07 15.59 37.64% 25.831 62.36%
7 FL06 14.04 38.11% 22.805 61.89%
6 FL05 12.2 38.17% 19.764 61.83%
5 FL04 9.56 38.47% 15.293 61.53%
4 FL03 7.87 38.41% 12.618 61.59%
3 FL02 6.15 38.32% 9.897 61.68%
2 FL01 4.41 38.30% 7.104 61.70%
1 FL00GFL 2.01 39.20% 3.118 60.80%
0 BASE 0 0.00% 0 0.00%

Average 61.71%

62.60%
Total Deformation (mm) Differential Proportion

∆z (mm)
76.77 2.03 2.54 1.67
78.803 1.42 1.94
80.225 1.74 1.83
81.965 1.60 1.79
83.567 1.42 1.77
84.987 1.25 1.74
86.233 1.09 1.72
87.321 0.95 1.72
88.266 0.88 1.70
89.142 0.45 1.71
89.591 0.19 1.71
89.776 0.04 1.71
89.738 0.28 1.69
90.015 0.04 1.70
90.052 0.19 1.70
89.867 0.41 1.71
89.455 0.66 1.71
88.799 0.24 1.67
88.556 0.47 1.70
88.087 1.27 1.65
89.358 0.81 1.69
88.547 0.35 1.68
88.197 0.46 1.68
87.737 0.82 1.67
86.918 0.97 1.67
85.95 1.13 1.66
84.825 1.26 1.66
83.561 1.42 1.66
82.141 1.63 1.66
80.515 1.75 1.65
78.762 1.88 1.65
76.883 1.89 1.65
74.995 1.32 1.65
73.676 1.43 1.65
72.251 1.52 1.65
70.736 1.60 1.65
69.135 1.68 1.66
67.453 1.76 1.66
65.697 1.82 1.67
63.881 1.85 1.68
62.027 1.85 1.69
60.179 1.08 1.71
59.103 7.18 1.71
51.927 5.07 1.68
46.858 2.66 1.65
44.2 2.78 1.65
41.421 4.58 1.66
36.845 4.88 1.62
31.964 7.11 1.62
24.853 4.37 1.60
20.488 4.44 1.60
16.047 4.53 1.61
11.514 6.39 1.61
5.128 5.13 1.55
0 0.00 0

1.96
 Tab. 5.1 Axial Shortening after 50 years

Core Wall Elastic Creep & Shrinkage

Story Story label ∆z (mm) Ratio (%) ∆z (mm) Ratio (%)

56 FL55CRF
55 FL54C
54 FL53ROOF
53 FL52PH 18.89 30% 43.21 69.6%
52 FL51MECH 18.21 30% 43.45 70.5%
51 FL50 19.96 32% 42.88 68.2%
50 FL49 20.70 32% 43.25 67.6%
49 FL48 21.35 33% 43.55 67.1%
48 FL47 21.93 33% 43.66 66.6%
47 FL46 22.42 34% 44.01 66.2%
46 FL45 22.88 34% 44.14 65.9%
45 FL44 23.28 34% 44.23 65.5%
44 FL43 23.61 35% 44.28 65.2%
43 FL42 23.91 35% 44.27 64.9%
42 FL41 24.15 35% 44.21 64.7%
41 FL40 24.33 36% 44.13 64.5%
40 FL39 24.46 36% 43.99 64.3%
39 FL38 24.70 36% 43.82 64.0%
38 FL37 24.51 36% 43.50 64.0%
37 FL36 24.43 36% 43.22 63.9%
36 FL35ROOF 24.76 36% 43.31 63.6%
35 FL34 25.46 37% 42.93 62.8%
34 FL33MECH 25.24 36% 44.34 63.7%
33 FL32MECH 25.26 37% 43.03 63.0%
32 FL31 25.20 37% 42.87 63.0%
31 FL30 25.14 37% 42.54 62.9%
30 FL29 25.14 37% 42.11 62.6%
29 FL28 25.02 37% 41.73 62.5%
28 FL27 24.86 38% 41.32 62.4%
27 FL26 24.66 38% 40.89 62.4%
26 FL25 24.45 38% 40.42 62.3%
25 FL24 24.21 38% 39.96 62.3%
24 FL23 23.91 38% 39.48 62.3%
23 FL22 23.61 38% 38.96 62.3%
22 FL21 23.28 38% 38.42 62.3%
21 FL20REFUGE 22.96 38% 37.96 62.3%
20 FL19 22.60 38% 37.49 62.4%
19 FL18 22.24 38% 36.99 62.5%
18 FL17 21.85 37% 36.50 62.6%
17 FL16 21.41 37% 36.04 62.7%
16 FL15 20.95 37% 35.62 63.0%
15 FL14 20.66 37% 35.26 63.1%
14 FL13 20.24 37% 34.97 63.3%
13 FL12 19.76 36% 34.79 63.8%
12 FL11 19.47 36% 34.85 64.2%
11 FL10 17.74 36% 32.02 64.3%
10 FL09 15.80 36% 28.61 64.4%
9 FL08 14.59 35% 26.96 64.9%
8 FL07 13.38 35% 25.33 65.4%
7 FL06 11.63 34% 22.60 66.0%
6 FL05 9.83 33% 19.67 66.7%
5 FL04 7.39 32% 15.36 67.5%
4 FL03 5.92 31% 12.98 68.7%
3 FL02 4.39 29% 10.54 70.6%
2 FL01 2.87 27% 7.94 73.5%
1 FL00GFL 1.75 36% 3.11 64.0%
0 BASE 0.00 0% 0.00 0.0%

Average 63.5%
Total Deformation Differential Proportion
(mm)
∆z (mm)

62.10 0.44 2.29 0.81 35.00

61.66 1.18 2.39
62.84 1.11 2.15
63.95 0.95 2.09
64.90 0.69 2.04
65.59 0.83 1.99
66.43 0.59 1.96
67.02 0.49 1.93
67.51 0.39 1.90
67.89 0.29 1.88
68.18 0.19 1.85
68.36 0.09 1.83
68.46 0.01 1.81
68.45 0.08 1.80
68.52 0.52 1.77
68.01 0.36 1.77
67.65 0.42 1.77
68.07 0.33 1.75
68.39 1.19 1.69
69.58 1.29 1.76
68.29 0.22 1.70
68.07 0.39 1.70
67.68 0.43 1.69
67.25 0.50 1.68
66.75 0.57 1.67
66.18 0.63 1.66
65.55 0.68 1.66
64.87 0.71 1.65
64.17 0.77 1.65
63.39 0.82 1.65
62.57 0.87 1.65
61.70 0.79 1.65
60.92 0.83 1.65
60.09 0.86 1.66
59.23 0.88 1.66
58.35 0.89 1.67
57.45 0.89 1.68
56.57 0.65 1.70
55.92 0.71 1.71
55.21 0.66 1.73
54.55 0.23 1.76
54.32 4.56 1.79
49.76 5.34 1.80
44.41 2.86 1.81
41.55 2.84 1.85
38.71 4.48 1.89
34.23 4.73 1.94
29.50 6.75 2.00
22.75 3.84 2.08
18.90 3.98 2.19
14.93 4.11 2.40
10.81 5.96 2.77
4.86 4.86 1.78
0 0.00 0.00

1.48 1.81
 19.89
19.21
20.96
21.7
22.35
22.93
23.42
23.88
24.28
24.61
24.91
25.15
25.33
25.455
25.7
25.51
25.43
25.76
26.46
26.24
26.26
26.2
26.14
26.14
26.02
25.86
25.66
25.45
25.21
24.91
24.61
24.28
23.96
23.6
23.24
22.85
22.41
21.95
21.66
21.24
20.76
20.47
18.74
16.8
15.59
14.38
12.63
10.83
8.39
6.92
5.39
3.87
1.71
0
 C E2‐A1 C F2‐B1 C E2‐A2 C F2‐B2
Story Story label ∆z(mm) ∆z(mm) ∆z(mm) ∆z(mm)
56 FL55CRF
55 FL54C
54 FL53ROOF 75 76
53 FL52PH 78 79 79 79
52 FL51MECH 80 80 80 81
51 FL50 82 82 82 82
50 FL49 83 84 84 84
49 FL48 85 85 85 86
48 FL47 86 86 86 87
47 FL46 87 87 87 88
46 FL45 87 87 88 89
45 FL44 87 87 89 90
44 FL43 87 88 90 90
43 FL42 87 87 90 90
42 FL41 87 87 90 90
41 FL40 87 87 90 90
40 FL39 86 87 90 90
39 FL38 86 86 90 90
38 FL37 85 85 89 90
37 FL36 84 85 89 89
36 FL35ROOF 84 84 89 89
35 FL34 83 83 88 88
34 FL33MECH 83 84 89 90
33 FL32MECH 82 82 89 89
32 FL31 81 81 88 89
31 FL30 81 80 88 88
30 FL29 80 80 87 87
29 FL28 79 79 86 86
28 FL27 78 77 85 85
27 FL26 76 76 84 84
26 FL25 75 75 82 82
25 FL24 74 73 81 80
24 FL23 72 72 79 79
23 FL22 70 70 77 77
22 FL21 69 69 75 75
21 FL20REFUGE 68 67 74 74
20 FL19 66 66 72 72
19 FL18 65 65 71 71
18 FL17 63 63 69 69
17 FL16 62 62 67 67
16 FL15 60 60 66 65
15 FL14 59 58 64 64
14 FL13 57 57 62 62
13 FL12 55 55 60 60
12 FL11 54 54 59 59
11 FL10 48 48 52 52
10 FL09 44 43 47 46
9 FL08 41 41 44 44
8 FL07 39 38 41 41
7 FL06 35 34 37 36
6 FL05 30 30 32 31
5 FL04 23 23 25 24
4 FL03 19 19 20 20
3 FL02 15 15 16 16
2 FL01 11 11 12 11
1 FL00GFL 5 5 5 5
0 BASE 0 0 0 0
C E2‐A3 C F2‐B3
∆z(mm) ∆z(mm)

84 83
87 87
89 89
91 91
93 92
94 94
95 95
96 95
97 96
97 96
97 97
97 96
96 96
96 96
96 96
96 95
95 95
94 94
93 94
93 93
94 94
93 93
92 93
92 92
91 91
90 90
89 89
88 88
86 86
84 85
83 83
81 81
79 79
77 77
76 76
74 74
72 73
71 71
69 69
67 67
65 65
63 63
62 62
54 55
49 49
46 46
43 43
39 39
34 33
26 26
21 22
17 17
12 12
5 5
0 0
 W C01 W C02 W C03 W N02 W S02
Story Story label ∆z(mm) ∆z(mm) ∆z(mm) ∆z(mm) ∆z(mm)
56 FL55CRF
55 FL54C 50 50 57 54
54 FL53ROOF 53 52 60 56
53 FL52PH 54 53 60 57
52 FL51MECH 62 55 54 61 62
51 FL50 62 56 55 62 62
50 FL49 63 57 56 63 63
49 FL48 64 58 57 64 64
48 FL47 65 59 57 65 65
47 FL46 66 60 58 65 66
46 FL45 66 61 59 66 67
45 FL44 67 62 59 67 65
44 FL43 68 63 60 67 68
43 FL42 68 63 60 68 66
42 FL41 68 64 61 68 69
41 FL40 68 64 61 68 69
40 FL39 68 65 61 68 69
39 FL38 68 65 61 68 69
38 FL37 68 66 62 68 69
37 FL36 69 66 61 68 69
36 FL35ROOF 68 66 62 67 69
35 FL34 68 67 62 66 69
34 FL33MECH 68 67 63 67 69
33 FL32MECH 70 68 64 69 71
32 FL31 68 67 63 67 69
31 FL30 68 67 63 67 69
30 FL29 68 67 63 67 69
29 FL28 67 67 63 67 68
28 FL27 67 67 63 67 68
27 FL26 66 66 62 66 68
26 FL25 66 66 62 66 67
25 FL24 65 65 62 65 66
24 FL23 64 65 61 65 66
23 FL22 63 64 61 64 65
22 FL21 63 63 60 63 64
21 FL20REFUGE 62 63 59 62 63
20 FL19 61 62 59 61 62
19 FL18 60 61 58 61 62
18 FL17 59 60 58 60 61
17 FL16 58 59 57 59 60
16 FL15 57 58 56 58 59
15 FL14 57 58 55 57 58
14 FL13 56 57 55 57 57
13 FL12 55 56 54 56 56
12 FL11 54 55 54 55 55
11 FL10 50 51 50 50 50
10 FL09 44 45 45 45 45
9 FL08 42 43 42 42 42
8 FL07 39 39 39 39 39
7 FL06 34 35 35 35 35
6 FL05 30 30 31 30 31
5 FL04 23 23 24 24 24
4 FL03 19 20 20 20 20
3 FL02 15 16 16 16 16
2 FL01 11 11 12 12 12
1 FL00GFL 5 5 5 5 5
0 BASE 0 0 0 0 0
W E14
∆z(mm)

49
52
53
54
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
60
61
61
62
62
62
63
63
64
65
65
66
65
65
65
65
65
65
64
64
63
63
62
62
61
60
59
59
58
57
56
56
55
51
45
43
40
36
31
24
21
17
13
6
0

Reduction amount analysis by various
prediction formulas
Reflecting material test properties
Reflecting on-site master shedule
Used for corrrection of analysis values
Construcion stage analysis
Differences in initial nourishment conditions
Differences in load history
Differences in material mixtures
Differences in site climatic (temperature /humidity )Conditions
humidity )Conditions