Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Draft Proof Hi
Draft Proof Hi
Draft Version
Manuscript ID Draft
The world has known many wars and conflicts, which prompted the
development of
international legal rules to limit their effects. After the prohibition of war,
today the law of war is known as international humanitarian law.
International events are stil
witnessing many armed conflicts, whether internal or international,
which has devoted
attention to international humanitarian law, which is one of the branches
Abstract:
of international law for defining the armed conflict types, this is reflected
in the four Geneva Conventions and their additional Protocols. The
situation in Yemen has now become the subject of international debates,
with no clear answers on how to deal with it. As result, the country was
divided into sections, and the situation of violence remained unresolved.
The researcher relied on analysis and discussion as an analytical method
for the
effects of the conflict in Yemen
Abstract
The world has known many wars and conflicts, which prompted the development of
international legal rules to limit their effects. After the prohibition of war, today the
law of war is known as international humanitarian law. International events are still
witnessing many armed conflicts, whether internal or international, which has devoted
attention to international humanitarian law, which is one of the branches of
international law for defining the armed conflict types, this is reflected in the four
Geneva Conventions and their additional Protocols. The situation in Yemen has now
become the subject of international debates, with no clear answers on how to deal
with it. As result, the country was divided into sections, and the situation of violence
remained unresolved.
The researcher relied on analysis and discussion as an analytical method for the
effects of the conflict in Yemen, using consistent evidence of violations and violence
against civilians, and monitoring samples from conflict areas in Yemen. This chapter
try to answer two (first and second) research questions of the study about the
classification of international law for the armed conflict in Yemen and the impacts of
violations and violence against civilians and the interpretation of international law for
them. The first section dealt with the definition of the term "armed conflict", its
concept and its dimensions, and explore the historical context of the predicament in
Yemen from the seventies until the current situation, and the legal framework for war.
It also dealt with the definition of the parties to the conflict, groups loyal to parties to
the conflict, the factors contributing to the outbreak of the armed conflict. This
chapter also deals with verifying whether the armed conflict in Yemen falls under the
term “armed conflict” under international humanitarian law and the Geneva
Conventions as international armed conflict (IAC) or Non-international armed conflict
(NIAC), using the conflict analysis framework (CAF) method to prove the type of
conflict in Yemen.
1
Cambridge University Press
Page 3 of 13 American Journal of International Law
Armed conflict is still a contested term in international law debates. There are no clear
lines that indicate the nature of an armed conflict in which to be applied in different
levels of skirmishes. However, certain characteristics are necessary in recognizing
whether a conflict is an armed conflict or not. Such recognition is crucial for the
exercise and application of humanitarian law in resolving and monitoring the conflict.
The humanitarian law acts as a guideline for parties involved in an armed conflict as
well as being the bastion for the safeguard of people who are not involved in the
conflict, yet being in the middle of it particularly the civilians.
Armed conflict is distinguished by international humanitarian law into two
types: (1) international armed conflicts involving opposing two or more states and;
(2) non-international armed conflicts involving governmental forces and non-
governmental
groups such as rebels . Therefore, to speak, the legal definition provides that there are
only two types of armed conflicts that are legally recognized .
Observations made by Wallensteen & Sollenberg on the occurrence of armed conflicts
from 1989 to 2000 provides three categories of armed conflicts, each is distinguished
according to battle-related deaths
count:
• Minor Armed Conflict – Number of battle-related deaths during conflict is below
1000.
• Intermediate Armed Conflict – Number of battle-related deaths during conflict is
more than 1000, but fewer than 1000 in any given year .
There are numerous of complex factors which can lead to armed conflicts within
States. Certain conditions are able to increase the probability of war including the
failure of the Governments to provide basic good governance and protection. In many
situations, weak Governments normally have less capacity to stop the eruption and
spread of violence compared to a more organized and legitimate Governments. In
addition to that, armed conflicts can also be viewed as the struggle for power by a
certain section of the elite which was excluded from the authoritarian systems of one-
party rule.
The causes of armed conflict are often linked with attempts to control
economic resources such as oil, metals, diamonds, drugs or contested territorial
boundaries. In countries such as Colombia and the Sudan, for instance, oilfield
exploration has caused and intensified the impoverishment of women and men. Entire
communities have been targeted and killed, displaced and/or marginalised in the name
2
Cambridge University Press
American Journal of International Law Page 4 of 13
of oil development. The control of resources, like the exercise of power, is gendered.
Those who do not have power or resources - groups that are disproportionately,
though by no means xclusively, made up of women - do not usually start wars .
Over the years, the conflict escalated along political, tribal, and religious lines
with intensifying sectarian prejudices. The involvement of other tribes—those who
allied with government or rebel—had exacerbated the sporadic and scattered
3
Cambridge University Press
Page 5 of 13 American Journal of International Law
skirmishes between rebels and government armies in the following years that went
beyond Saada into Bani Hushasyh . Both sides, the government and rebels, were tied
(or allegedly tied) to foreign powers. The government, in attempt to discredit the
rebels as fundamentalist religious group, had sought Western (US) support as well as
backed by the Saudi and alleged the rebels being funded by Iran. While the rebels
perceived the government for being bias towards the religious group as well as
cautioned the influence of Saudi Wahhabism and US in Yemen and Middle East.
Since the start of the conflict, the Yemeni government has received assistance from
the Gulf Arab states led by Saudi Arabia and the US to reinstate Hadi as the president
of Yemen. Amongst countries involved in assisting Yemen are Saudi Arabia, the
United Arab Emirates, Kuwait, Bahrain, Qatar, Morocco, Sudan, Jordan, and Egypt
from Arab states along with US and United Kingdom who provide logistical supports
and intelligence to the Saudi-led coalition. The Yemeni government (legitimate)
consists of the partisan blocs including the Yemeni Congregation for Reform (Islah),
some members of the General People’s Congress (GPC), who support Hadi's
government, and Yemeni Socialist Party (YSP) (named the National Liberation Front
prior to 1978) .
The AQAP is considered as the most active branches of al-Qaeda and posed a
significant threat to the stability of the Arab Gulf. In 2012, during rehearsal for
Yemen’s Unity Day, a suicide bombing that claimed over 120 people lives had been
claimed responsibility by the AQAP. The organization the moved to key stronghold in
Southern Yemen and planted mines that threaten lives of civilians. During the early
phase of Yemeni civil war in 2015, the AQAP took advantage of the turmoil and
captured Mukalla in which they established their base. The city was later recaptured
by Saudiled coalition in 2016. Despite the continuous efforts by the US and coalition
to contain AQAP, the conflict in Yemen actually enabled the organization to expand
its power and influence. The key source of AQAP survival was its focus on sustaining
its relationship with locals in areas they established, which had rendered the efforts to
oust them difficult.
4
Cambridge University Press
American Journal of International Law Page 6 of 13
Abd Rabbu Mansour Hadi, and then-governor Zubaydi . On April 27, 2017, Hadi
responded by sacking Zubaydi as well as Hani Ali bin Brik, Yemen’s former minister
of state .
Both sides in the conflict in Yemen—the Ansar Allah (Houthis) group and former
president Ali Saleh on the one hand, and the Arab Coalition led by Saudi Arabia and
the United Arab Emirates and the administration of President Hadi on the other—have
employed hunger as a weapon since 2016. No less than 26 instances of access to
humanitarian supplies being denied were recorded in 2017 by a local human rights
group . Most of them occurred in the Sa'ada governorate, and their cause was Ansa
Allah (23 incidents). In Al Dhale'e, Shabwah, and Taiz governorates, three incidents
were committed by both the Popular Resistance and the pro-Hadi troops.
5
Cambridge University Press
Page 7 of 13 American Journal of International Law
As many as 89 assaults against people and civilian-related objects were carried out by
the Saudi-Emirati-led Coalition in 10 Yemeni governorates throughout 2017
according to human rights group . At least 357 civilians were killed in these strikes,
including 161 children and 45 women, while 294 others were injured, including 101
children and 56 women. These attacks were launched by the Coalition on fisherman
as well as homes, marketplaces, schools, and farms.
Fatality numbers are often the most poorly reported component of conflict data.
The figure 1 includes only civilians killed as a result of direct civilian targeting. It
does not include collateral civilian fatalities. As such, according ACLED stated that
the number is assumed to represent an underestimate of total conflict-related civilian
fatalities in Yemen. figure 1 show all airstrikes resulting in 35 or more reported
fatalities, form 2015 to June 2019.
The Indiscriminate Ground Attacks
As many as 89 incidences of ground attacks were recorded in the year 2017; the
majority of these events occurred in the Taiz Governorate (66 incidents). Al-Jawf,
Marib, Sana'a, Abyan, and Lahj were among the other governorates where the other
occurrences took place. Most of these heinous, indiscriminate assaults were carried
out by the Ansar Allah group (the Houthis), but Mwatana has confirmed that at least
two of them were carried out by the Popular Resistance and pro-Hadi troops. As a
result of these assaults, at least 160 civilians including 99 children and 14 women
were killed and 184 others— including 92 children and 30 women were injured.
In various Yemeni governorates, notably in Taiz, the parties to the conflict have
continued to launch indiscriminate ground strikes on civilians throughout 2017. The
use of indiscriminate weaponry by participants in the war was recorded by
organization for human right in their report "Chapters from Hell," which was
published in November 2016. High-explosive guided mortars (HEGM), RPG-7s, and
M-21 Grad Rockets fired from BM-21 Grad Rocket Launchers are a few examples of
such indiscriminate weaponry .
6
Cambridge University Press
American Journal of International Law Page 8 of 13
7
Cambridge University Press
Page 9 of 13 American Journal of International Law
8
Cambridge University Press
American Journal of International Law Page 10 of 13
CONCLUSION
The presence of factors that contributed to the existence of armed conflicts in Yemen
and were the main reason for the outbreak of civil wars, including the political,
economic, geographic, military and societal division, and these factors can also be
considered as effects that generated and produced together from the existence of
conflicts and wars. This study explicitly concludes that the conflict in Yemen remains.
Over the past year, these alliances have fractured. Houthi forces, which still control
much of northern and central Yemen, killed Saleh after clashes in December 2017. In
southern Yemen, Saudi Arabia and the UAE have backed rival Yemeni groups—the .
Saudi-supported Yemeni government led by President Abdu Rabbu Mansour Hadi
and the UAE-backed Southern Transitional Council (STC).
9
Cambridge University Press
Page 11 of 13 American Journal of International Law
REFERENCES
Abdullah Al -Ashhaal. (2010). The Future of International H.L, International H.L, Prospects
and Challenges. Publications of Al -Halabi Human Rights, Beirut, 3(c), 10.
Ahmadzai, T. K., Maburutse, Z., Miller, L., & Ratnayake, R. (2016). Protecting public health in
Yemen. The Lancet, 388(10061), 2739.
Al-Basha, A. (2019). Yemen Events of 2019. Human Rights Watch.
https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2020/country-chapters/yemen#119ef1
Al-Dameer. (2022). Enforced disappearances in Yemen as a direct result of impunity. OCHA
Services. https://reliefweb.int/report/yemen/enforced-disappearances-yemen-direct-
result-impunity
Al Arabiya News. (2014). Houthis sign deal with Sanaa to end Yemen crisis. Al Arabiya News.
http://english.alarabiya.net/en/News/middle-east/2014/09/21/Clashes-in-Yemeni-
capital-cast-doubt-on-deal-signing.html
Angrist, M. P. (2010). Politics & society in the contemporary Middle East. Lynne Rienner
Publishers Boulder, Colo.
Arimatsu, L., & Choudhury, M. (2014). The legal classification of the A.Cs in Syria, Yemen and
Libya.
Ashley, L. (2020). Human Rights Violations in Yemen and the Prospects for Justice. Human
Rights in War, 1–23.
Ayres, R. W. (2000). A world flying apart? Violent nationalist conflict and the end of the cold
war. Journal of Peace Research, 37(1), 105–117.
Bajpai, A. (2018). Child rights in India: Law, policy, and practice. Oxford University Press.
Bakta, J. (2000). International H.L, its development and principles. In studies in international
H.L (Vol. 1).
Bayoumy, Y., Browning, N., & Ghobari, M. (2016). How Saudi Arabia’s war in Yemen has
made al Qaeda stronger and richer. Reuters Special Report.
Becker, J. (2022). Houthis Commit to End Violations Against Children in Yemen (Pledge
Comes Amidst Ceasefire in Prolonged Conflict). Human Rights Watch.
Bellinger, J. B., & Padmanabhan, V. M. (2011). Detention operations in contemporary
conflicts: four challenges for the Geneva Conventions and other existing law. American
Journal of International Law, 105(2), 201–243.
Boed, R. (2002). Individual criminal responsibility for violations of article 3 common to the
Geneva conventions of 1949 and of additional protocol II thereto in the case law of the
International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda. Criminal Law Forum, 13(3), 293.
Budustour, L. (2022). Yemen’s Dire Humanitarian Crisis. Available at SSRN 4110052.
Children, S. the. (2022). Yemen: Explosive remnants of war the biggest killer of children since
truce began. OCHA Services. https://reliefweb.int/report/yemen/yemen-explosive-
remnants-war-biggest-killer-children-truce-began
10
Cambridge University Press
American Journal of International Law Page 12 of 13
11
Cambridge University Press
Page 13 of 13 American Journal of International Law
12
Cambridge University Press
American Journal of International Law Page 14 of 13
Shue, H., & Wippman, D. (2001). Limiting attacks on dual-use facilities performing
indispensable civilian functions. Cornell Int’l LJ, 35, 559.
Sihaloho, R. A. H., Prabowo, T. B., & Kusuma, R. P. (2022). Food Crisis in Yemen: The Roles of
Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) from 2015 to 2020. Nation State: Journal of
International Studies, 5(1), 59–74.
Slantchev, B. L. (2003). The power to hurt: Costly conflict with completely informed states.
American Political Science Review, 97(1), 123–133.
Solis, G. D. (2021). The law of A.C: international H.L in war. Cambridge University Press.
UNFPA. (2021). United Nations Population Fund in Yemen. UNFPA.
https://www.unfpa.org/data/transparency-portal/unfpa-republic-yemen
Varfolomeeva, A. (2019). Houthis recruit 50,000 Yemen child soldiers in 3 months, minister
says.[online], 2019. 06. 20. Forrás: Thedefensepost. Com [2020. 10. 04.].
Williams, P., Sommadossi, T., & Mujais, A. (2017). A Legal Perspective on Yemen’s Attempted
Transition from a Unitary to a Federal System of Government. Utrecht J. Int’l & Eur. L.,
33, 4.
Wright, R., Berger, J. M., Braniff, W., Bunzel, C., Byman, D., Cafarella, J., Gambhir, H.,
Gartenstein-Ross, D., Hassan, H., & Lister, C. (2016). The jihadi threat: ISIS, al-Qaeda,
and beyond. JSTOR.
13
Cambridge University Press