Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Production and Use of Hollow Interlocking CSEB For..ctures Satprem Maini 2010
Production and Use of Hollow Interlocking CSEB For..ctures Satprem Maini 2010
Production and Use of Hollow Interlocking CSEB For..ctures Satprem Maini 2010
BLOCKS 245
BLOCKS 295
Auroshilpam, Auroville 605 101, TN INDIA Tel: +91 (0) 413 – 262 3064 / 262 3330 Fax: +91 (0) 413 – 262 2886
Email: earth-institute@auroville.org.in Web: http://www.earth-auroville.com
PRODUCTION AND USE OF HOLLOW INTERLOCKING
CSEB FOR DISASTER RESISTANCE
Auroville
April 2005
Revised July 2005
25 pages
Humanity as a whole
No rights reserved!
This document is the summary of the training course lectures on production and use of Hollow Interlocking
Compressed Stabilised Earth Blocks (HI CSEB) for disaster resistance, which was held at the Auroville Earth
Institute.
The whole training session was one of such many ventures launched by the Auroville Earth Institute towards the
propagation of cost effective and appropriate building technologies for meeting the reconstruction of zones
affected by natural disasters.
This summary deals with the production of hollow interlocking compressed stabilised earth blocks and their use in
wall masonry for resisting disasters, like earthquakes, cyclones or tsunami. It presents the various stages of a
manual production line using the AURAM equipment and all the technologies developed by the Auroville Earth
Institute.
This document is not therefore exhaustive, but is rather an adaptation of a particular programme through selected
methods of production and use demonstrated during our regular course at the Auroville Earth Institute.
1. EARTH ARCHITECTURE: DIVERSITY & UNIVERSALITY
Generalities
30% of the world and 50% of the developing countries have buildings made of earth.
Earth has been used all over the world as a building material since centuries.
A tradition and modernity characterize the earth architecture.
The oldest earthen building in the world is about 3,300 years old. It is the Ramasseum, made of adobes, which
was built in about 1,300 BC in the old city of Thebes. It can still be visited on the left shore of the nil, opposite
Luxor.
In India, the oldest earthen building is Tabo Monastery, in Spiti valley – Himachal Pradesh. It was built with
adobe blocks and stands there since 996 AC.
It is worthwhile to note that along the ages and all over the countries and diversity of cultures, social &
constructive habits; humans have used this material from our Mother Earth. They created their living spaces
and they adapted their architectural and constructive answers according to the behaviour, and properties of
the soil, in relation to its hydrous states. Therefore, humans have transformed this heavy, dark and formless
material into a lighter building material and found out 12 main techniques corresponding to 4 hydrous states.
2
4. BASIC DATA ON CSEB (5% cement stabilised block)
Dry compressive strength c (After 28 days curing) : 3 to 6 MPa
Wet compressive strength c (After 28 days curing) : 1.5 to 3 MPa (Test done after 24 h. immersion)
Dry bending strength b (After 28 days curing) : 0.5 to 1 MPa
Dry shear strength (After 28 days curing) : 0.4 to 0.6 MPa
Water absorption by weight (After 28 days curing) : 8 to 12 % (Test done after 24 h. immersion)
Apparent bulk density (dry) : 1700 to 2000 kg/m3
Energy consumption : 110 MJ / m2
(This value has to be compared with kiln fired bricks = 539 MJ / m2 and country fired bricks = 1657 MJ / m2
Pollution emission (CO2) : 16Kg / m2
(This value has to be compared with kiln fired bricks = 39Kg / m2 and country fired bricks = 126Kg / m2
Notes
- Kiln fired bricks are also called wire cut bricks
- Per m2, CSEB consume 5 or 15 times less energy than fired bricks.
- Per m2, CSEB pollute 2.4 or 7.8 times less than fired bricks.
- 1 MPa = ± 10 kg/cm2
Fundamental properties
- Granularity or texture = Grain size distribution of a soil. (Percentage by weight of the different grain size)
- Compressibility = Ability to be compressed to a maximum.
It is related to the energy of compaction and the moisture content = OMC
(OMC = Optimum Moisture Content = percentage by weight of water)
- Plasticity = Property of a soil to be submitted to deformation without elastic failure.
- Cohesion = Capacity of its grains to remain together.
Cement is the binder for concrete. In a soil, the binder is replaced by silt & clay. Thus, it is like a concrete, but
silt & clay are not stable under water. Therefore they should be stabilised, to maintain some strength when the
blocks get wet.
The grain size classification adopted by a large number of laboratories is based on the ASTM-AFNOR
standards:
Pebbles Gravel Sand Silt Clay
200 to 20 mm 20 to 2 mm 2 to 0.06 mm 0.06 to 0.002 mm 0.002 to 0 mm
For compressed earth bocks, the pebbles should be removed.
3
Typical soils
According to the percentage of the four components, the soil will be classified as:
Gravely, sandy, silty or clayey soil.
The name of this classification is given by the component which influences the most the behaviour of the soil.
Note that the soil has to be evaluated as whole and not as separate components. Therefore, it is necessary to
examine how these various components combine with each other. For example, a soil might have more gravel
than normal, but if the clay is very plastic and with the proper proportion, the soil might not be called gravely
but probably good soil.
A soil will have sometimes 2 components influencing its behaviour: one very influent and another one to a
lesser extent. Therefore, a more accurate classification will be defined as follows:
Silty sand soil = Soil mainly sandy with an influent proportion of silt.
Sandy silt soil = Soil mainly silty with an influent proportion of sand.
Structure of a soil
It is how the grains are assembled: - Granular structure = A lot of voids (i.e. gravel)
- Fragmented structure = Discontinuous (i.e. gravel and clay only)
- Continuous structure = The best = proportion of the best soil
6. SOIL IDENTIFICATION
Sensitive analyses:
They follow the four fundamental properties of the earth. One more test has to be practiced for determining the
humus content. They can be practiced by anybody:
- Granularity = - The soil is dry / solid or humid: look and touch it to examine the percentage and
size of the four components.
- Compressibility = - Add a little water to get a moist soil and compress it by hand to try to make ball.
- Plasticity = - Add more water and make a ball.
- Try to pull the ball like rubber elastic.
- Stick a knife into it and cut it with the knife.
- Water absorption in a small print done with the thumb in the ball.
- Cohesion = - Add much more water to loose the cohesion and to wash the hands.
- Humus Content = - An important test is to check the humus, which may give problems with the
stabilization: Take a moist soil and smell it.
The aim of these sensitive analyses is to find out in which categories goes the soil sample: Gravely,
Sandy, Silty, Clayey or combined soil i.e. sandy clay. Then, according to this classification, one must
look into the recommendations for stabilization and soil improvement.
Note that the soil identification should be practiced twice: first on the raw soil, before doing any
modification, and also after correcting the soil (i.e. after sieving).
Laboratory Tests
They follow the four fundamental properties of the earth, but they need special equipment:
- Granularity = Grain size distribution (sieving + sedimentation).
- Compressibility = Proctor for getting the OMC.
- Plasticity = Atterberg’s limits For example: Sand 0 < IP < 10
(LL, PL, IP) 0 < LL < 30
(SL, LS, LA, CA.) Silt 5 < IP < 25
20 < LL < 50
Clay 20 < IP
40 < LL
- Cohesion = = 8 test (mortar < 2 mm)
4
7. SOIL STABILIZATION
Definition
It aims to stabilise under water the binders, which are the silts and clays, in order to obtain lasting properties
and strength when the soil gets wet.
Procedures
PRINCIPLE ACTIONS
- Density and mechanical strength are increased.
Mechanical The soil is compacted. - The water resistance is increased.
- The permeability and porosity are decreased.
The texture of the soil is corrected - The soil is sieved to remove the coarse particles.
Physical by adding or removing - Different soils are mixed to get a better texture.
aggregates, which are inert - Gravel or sand is added to reinforce the skeleton.
materials. - Clay is added to bind better the grains.
Processed products, which are
Chemical active materials like chemicals, - They help binding the grains of the earth.
are added to the soil.
6 Methods
Densification – Reinforcement – Cementation – Linkage – Imperviousness – Waterproofing
DEFINITION EXAMPLES
- Compaction
Densification Create a dense medium, blocking pores & capillary - Adding components
- Mixing different soils
- Straw
Reinforcement Create an anisotropy network limiting movement - Fur
- Synthetic fibres
- Cement
Cementation Create an inert matrix opposing movement
- Fly ash
Linkage Create stable chemical bonds between clay and sand - Lime
- Bitumen
Imperviousness Surround every earth grain with a waterproof film - Resins
- Various chemicals
- Paints, plaster *
Waterproofing Avoid the water absorption and adsorption by the surface
- White wash
Note: * Avoid bitumen and synthetic paints or plasters for earth walls.
Stabilisers
Fibres (natural or synthetic), cement, lime, fly ash, natural products (straw, fur, blood, juice of plants, latex,
etc.), resins, and synthetic products
5
8. STABILISATION CALCULATION
Aim
It is to define the percentage of stabiliser and the quantities of the different components.
Principle
The calculations are always done by weight of dry material. As it is impossible to measure weights on site,
they have to be transformed into volumes. Then, the dry density () is needed.
Formulas
They are used for all stabilisers but here, the example is with cement. The aggregates are soil or (soil + sand)
or (soil + gravel), etc. The total percentage of aggregates is always 100 % as the binder is not yet included.
1. Density () = Weight per litre
2. Theoretical weight aggregates = Weight cement wanted x (100 - % cement wanted)
% Cement wanted
3. Theoretical volume aggregates = Theoretical weight aggregates x % particular aggregate
(Do it for each aggregate) Density particular aggregate x 100
4. Exact % cement = Weight cement wanted x 100
Total weight*
* Total weight = (Approximated volume of each aggregate x its density) + cement weight
Procedure
1. Define the parameters : -Percentage and weight of cement, which is wanted.
(Cement weight should be calculated for not more than 250 litres of
aggregates. For 5 %, it often corresponds to maxi. 1/3 of a bag per mix).
-Percentage of sand, gravel or else, which might need to be added.
-Volume in litres of the containers available (Wheelbarrows, buckets, etc).
-Check the density of every aggregate = weight of 1 litre (Formula 1).
2. Theoretical weight of : Calculate the theoretical weight of aggregates, required to get the percentage
aggregates of cement wanted (Formula 2).
3. Transformation : Transform the weight of aggregates into theoretical volume (Formula 3).
4. Approximation : Approximate the theoretical volume of aggregates, according to the containers,
which are available on site: to get practical measurements for the site.
5. Exact % cement : Calculate the exact percentage of cement, according to the weight of
approximated aggregates (Formula 4).
6. Selection : Select the result if it is within a tolerance of ± 3% maximum from the
percentage of cement wanted (i.e. 4.85 to 5.15 instead of 5%).
7. Adaptation : If the result is not satisfactory, redo all the process with another approximation
for the volume or with other parameters.
Practical grid
This grid is valid only for one soil with one stabiliser (cement) so as to get ± 5% cement stabilisation.
Soil density () Volume of soil (Litres) Weight of cement (Kg) Percentage of cement
1.20 200 12.5 = 1/4 bag 4.95
1.25 200 12.5 = 1/4 bag 4.76
1.30 190 12.5 = 1/4 bag 4.82
1.35 180 12.5 = 1/4 bag 4.89
1.35 240 16.6 = 1/3 bag 4.87
1.40 230 16.6 = 1/3 bag 4.90
1.45 220 16.6 = 1/3 bag 4.94
1.50 210 16.6 = 1/3 bag 5.00
1.55 200 16.6 = 1/3 bag 5.08
1.60 200 16.6 = 1/3 bag 4.93
6
Example 1
1. Parameters: - 5% cement wanted and 1/3 bag (16.67 kg)
- 200 litres wheelbarrows and 15 litres buckets
- 100% soil required (no sand added)
- Dry density checked for the soil: soil = 1.35
3. Theoretical volume of aggregates (Formula 3): Volume of soil = 316.73 x 100 = 234.61 Lt.
1.35 x 100
4. Approximation: According to the containers available, we choose for the volume of soil:
1 wheelbarrow (200 Lt.) + 2 buckets (15 Lt.) = 230 Lt.
6. Selection: 5.095% is within the 3% tolerance for the cement percentage and we select it.
Example 2
1. Parameters: - 6% Cement wanted and 1/4 bag cement (12.5 kg)
- 100 Lt. wheelbarrows and 10 Lt. buckets
- 70 % of soil and 30% of sand required.
- Dry density checked: soil = 1.2 and sand = 1.45
2. Theoretical weight of aggregates (Formula 2): Soil + Sand = 12.5 x (100 – 6) = 195.83 kg.
6
3. Theoretical volumes of aggregates (Formula 3): Volume of soil = 195.83 x 70 = 114.23 Lt.
1.2 x 100
4. Approximation: according to the containers and to transport easily the materials, we choose:
Sand = 40 Lt. = 4 buckets of 10 Lt.
Soil = 100 Lt. = 1 wheelbarrow of 100 Lt.
6. Selection: 6.56 % is too high compared with the requirements: it is 9% above the desired %.
We can’t select it.
7. Adaptation: Redoing all the process is needed. We have to add 1 bucket of soil (10 Lt.) to get 6.17%
cement or change the wheelbarrow, or other parameters.
7
9. IMPROVING AND STABILISING SOILS
According to the original soil quality, adding materials like gravel or sand can do some easy improvement. Note
that it advisable no to mix clay, as the process would be long for an uncertain result. Improvement can also be
done by sieving the soil or by mixing different qualities of soil. Stabilising a soil will also improve it.
The following recommendations have to be considered as general guidelines and not as rules. The
infinite variation of soil qualities makes impossible to define strict rules for soil suitability.
Gravely Soil
- Sieving (# 8 to 10 mm) is indispensable to remove the coarse gravel.
- A maximum of 15% to 20% by weight of gravel passing the screen should be allowed.
- The maximum size for the gravel passing through the sieve should be 10 mm.
- If the soil is too gravely, a more clayey soil should be added, but not pure clay.
- Stabilisation can be slightly less than 5%: 3 to 4% by weight of cement could be sufficient.
(If the clay content is high enough)
Sandy Soil
- Sieving (# 10 to 12 mm) is only required to loosen and aerate the soil.
- Do not sieve in a very windy area, especially if the soil is dry (not to loose the fine clay).
- Stabilisation can be 5% by weight of cement, if the soil is not too sandy.
- If the soil is too sandy, 6 % by weight of cement might be preferable, especially for handling fresh blocks.
- If the soil is not too sandy and has a good clay quality, 4 % by weight of cement could give good results too.
Silty Soil
- A slight crushing might be required.
- Sieving (# 6 to 10 mm) is required if the lumps are too big and cohesive.
- Adding 10% to 20% of sand might be needed to give more skeletons to the soil.
Remember that adding sand depends of the silt size: if the grain size of the silt is near very fine sand, no
sand should be added.
- Stabilisation should be 6% minimum by weight of cement.
Clayey Soil
- Crushing might often be required.
- Sieving with mesh (# 6 to 10 mm) is required, if the soil is dry.
- Adding 20 to 40% of sand is needed to reduce the plasticity and give some skeleton.
- Stabilization can be: - 5% minimum by weight of cement, if the clay is not too plastic. Sand will be added as
mentioned above.
- 6 to 7% by weight of lime if the clay is very plastic. Sand quantity will be reduced or
could not be needed.
- A combination of cement-lime stabilisation could also give good results:
2% cement + 5% lime. Some sand will be needed (10 to 15 %).
- Note for the stabilisation: - Cement stabilisation will need 4 weeks curing.
(Even for the combined one with lime)
- Lime stabilisation will not need curing.
(Blocks should only be kept 2 days under plastic sheets)
8
10. TESTING SOILS
Sensitive analyses and comments of four typical soils (gravely, sandy, silty, clayey), and a good soil
- Look and touch.
- Add water to get a humid soil and smell it.
- Try to compress the moist soil.
- Add water and make a plastic ball.
- Try to pull the ball like rubber elastic.
- Stick a knife into it.
- Cut the ball in two pieces with a knife.
- Absorption: do a print with the thumb in the plastic ball & fill it with water.
- Wash your hands with water.
Comments on the soil to be used
Sensitive analysis and comments of various soil qualities
Dry density check up
Measure it for the dry soil to be used.
- Take 1.5 litre of loose humid soil.
- Dry this sample.
- Weight 1 litre of dry soil.
- Redo 3 times this check.
- Take the average for the dry density.
Testing typical soils with a press
- Sensitive analysis on various soils.
- Experimentation with the four typical soils and good soil with a press: Making 3 blocks of each soil quality.
- The detailed results of the experimentation are given next page.
9
GRAVELY SOIL SANDY SOIL SILTY SOIL CLAYEY SOIL
H A - Very rough surface - Rough surface (+) - Smooth surface (+) - Very smooth surface
U S (+ +) - Homogeneous (+) - Homogeneous (+ +) (+ +)
M P - Not homogeneous - Porous structure - Matt finish - Very homogeneous
I E (- -) (+ +)
D C - “Honey comb” - Shiny finish
T structure
D A - Easy to break (+ +) - Easy to break (+) - Easy to break (+ +) - Very hard to break
R S - Crumbly (+ +) - Crumbly (+) - Crumbly (+) (+ +)
Y P - No cracks (-) - No cracks (-) - No cracks or very little - Very cohesive (+ +)
E cracks (-) - Big cracks (+ +)
C
T
10
11. PRODUCTS AND EQUIPMENTS
Category of products
In this course we deal with hollow interlocking blocks, which are laid with a 5 mm cement stabilised earth
mortar.
THICK MORTAR
THIN MORTAR
GLUE MORTAR
Category of equipment:
Manual energy Motorized energy
11
Comparison of investment and output
LIGHT MANUAL HEAVY MANUAL MOTORIZED MOBILE UNIT INDUSTRIAL PLANT
SOME AURAM 240 & 290 AURAM 3000 AUARAMATIC CLU 3000 TMR 6750 40
PRESSES AURAM 245 & 295 CERAMAN CERAMATIC ECOBRICK TEROC T2A
BALRAM TERSTARAM PACT 500 GEOBETON 1
CINVARAM TERRABLOC
MARDINI
COST OF THE 0.15 to 0.25 0.60 to 1.00 2 to 5 30 to 40 + 80
PRESS Lakhs Rs. Lakhs Rs. Lakhs Rs. Lakhs Rs. Lakhs Rs.
TOTAL 0.25 to 0.35 0.80 to 1.40 4 to 10 60 to 80 + 250
INVESTMENT Lakhs Rs Lakhs Rs Lakhs Rs. Lakhs Rs. Lakhs Rs.
DAILY 400 to 600 600 to1,000 2,000 to 4,000 10,000 to 20,000 Above 50,000
OUTPUT Strokes Strokes Strokes Blocks Blocks
Comments: The best ratio investment cost / daily out put is achieved with heavy manual presses.
Quality control
At every stage of the production line
Key words
- Reduce the distance of transportation.
- Optimise the ratio output / number of workers, to get the best efficiency.
- Organize the block-yard as close as possible from the site.
- It is preferable to have a linear organization but a circular one can also be suitable.
12
13. QUALITY CONTROL
Golden rules
- Check the production at every stage (see the production cycle).
- Never mix more than a third of bag cement at a time or never more than 250 litres of aggregates.
- Check the quality of the compression with the pocket penetrometre, always for the first block of every mix.
- Check the height with the block height gauge, always for the first block of every mix.
- Follow daily the production. Record the output, the dates...
- Check weekly or monthly, the production with the field block tester (after 28 days).
13
After the production
- Record the data
- Number of workers
- Number of hours
- Number of bags
- Number of blocks
- Calculate the Number of blocks per mix and per bag of cement (not more than ± 2 blocks difference
according to average production).
- Obviously an entrepreneur will need also to record his stock, salaries, and so on, to manage properly his unit.
- Laboratory tests
Bending + compression + shear crushing + water absorption.
Practical grid for the bending strength test (only for plain blocks)
When testing the blocks by bending, not a single block should break below the following load (load applied on
the plate). Then, they will be above the minimum permissible crushing strength:
5kg/cm2 for the dry bending crushing strength ( b)
30 kg/cm2 for the dry compression crushing strength ( c)
Height Plain block 290 Plain block 240 - 4/4 Plain block 240 –1/2
(29 x 14 cm) (24 x 24 cm) (24 x 11.5 cm)
(cm) Load on plate Force on block Load on plate Force on block Load on plate Force on block
(kg) (Kg) (kg) (Kg) (kg) (Kg)
10 50 292.5 85 467.5 40 242.5
9 40 242.5 70 392.5 30 192.5
8 30 192.5 55 317.5 20 142.5
7 20 142.5 40 242.5 15 117.5
Note: - The load is the weight applied on the plate of the field block tester.
- The weight of the plate of the Auram field block tester is 8.5 kg.
- The space between the angles of the field block tester is L = 18 cm.
- The calculation takes in account the leverage (5 times) of the AURAM field block tester.
14
14. COST ANALYSIS
Block 245 produced on site
Block size: 24.5 x 24.5 x 9.5 cm, with 5% cement Value: Auroville, July 2005, 1 US $ = ±42.5 Rs.
MAIN DATA
Press lifespan (600 strokes per day over ± 5.5 years = 10 Lakhs of blocks) (Blocks) 1,000,000
Daily production (Blocks) 600
Annual production = Daily prod. x 26 days x 11 months (1 month = maintenance +heaviest rains) 171,600
Equipment cost (Rs.) 125,000
Buildings [storeroom 15 m2, simple production shed 75 m2] and infrastructure (Rs.) 40,000
Maintenance for the lifespan of the press (Rs.) 30,000
VARIABLE COSTS Rs./Unit Units Cost / Block %
Labour (Man) 100 8 1.333 26.96 %
Soil (± 80 % = 7.69 m3 per 1000 blocks) 70 4.58 0.534 10.80 %
Sand (± 20 % = 1.92 m3 per 1000 blocks) 360 1.14 0.684 13.83 %
Cement (5 % = 12.82 bags per 1000 blocks) 146 7.63 1.856 37.52 %
Maintenance per block 0.030 1.00 0.030 0.61 %
TOTAL Variable costs (Rs.) 4.437 89.71 %
FIXED COSTS % Total Rs. Cost / Block %
Investment Cost (equivalent to interest of a term deposit) 5.0 % 165,000 0.048 0.97 %
Equipment Depreciation (= press lifespan) 16.8 % 125,000 0.122 2.47 %
Building Depreciation (= site duration) 50.0 % 40,000 0.117 2.36 %
Overheads / Miscellaneous 5.0 % 4.437 0.224 4.49 %
TOTAL Fixed costs (Rs.) 0.509 10.29%
TOTAL cost per block (Rs.) 4.95 100.00 %
NOTES
- The production is done on a construction site, which has the minimum set up (simple storeroom, light
production shed). The latter would be wasted at the end of the site.
- The equipment includes 1 Auram press 3000 + 1 mould 245, 1 wheelbarrow 200 Litres, 1 wheelbarrow
350Kg, 1 soil sieve # 10 mm, 1 sand sieve # 4 mm, plastic sheets, barrel and small tools.
- The soil is extracted from the site and its cost includes sieving in the quarry.
- The sand cost includes delivery by lorry and sieving on site.
- The water cost is included in the overheads / miscellaneous.
- The labour cost includes the yearly bonus and the Employee Providence Fund.
Comments
- The depreciation cost of the equipment, the maintenance of the equipment and the investment cost is only 4.05 %
when the cement is 37.52 % and the labour 37.76 % (for block-making and soil digging). This implies that one
should find a way to reduce the cost of the stabiliser but not the manpower with unskilled labour or the equipment
with cheap presses.
- The soil, which is dug on site, costs 70 Rs./ m3 that mean 0.534 Rs./block. If it has to be delivered by lorry, its cost
per block would become Rs. 1.152. Thus the cost price of the block would be Rs. 5.60 instead of 4.95.
- If the blockyard is organised with a good set up (moveable shed), the cost price of a block will be slightly cheaper
than for the site production (Rs. 4.86) because the building depreciation is less than for the site production.
masonry is 0.4 % costlier than CFB because the masonry with HI CSEB is reinforced (see next page).
15
Cost comparison of masonry
- Data (Materials delivered on site)
- Mason = 150 Rs./day – Helper = 75 Rs./day – Labour male = 100 Rs./day – Labour female = 60 Rs./day
- Cement 43 grades = 146 Rs./bag – Sieved soil 70 Rs./m3 – Sieved sand 360 Rs./m3
- CSEB 245: Rs.4.95 (produced on site) – CFB*: Rs. 1.425 – WCB**: Rs. 3.50
* CFB are Country-Fired Bricks **WCB stands for Wire Cut Bricks, also called kiln-fired bricks.
(0.4 % costlier) but the wall is reinforced with 1 vertical tie and 1 ring beam per m2.
Per m3 of finished wall, CSEB are 33.4 % cheaper than wire cut bricks.
This study is done for Auroville context in April 2005, for the block 245 (245 x 245 x 95 mm). The example studied
is for a blockyard production with manual equipment for 1200 blocks output per day (2 Auram presses 3000).
It shows that the project starts to be viable when two machines are working. The reason is that the fixed costs
(overheads with the manager, storekeeping, etc.) are nearly the same if the unit has one or several presses.
16
ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY OF CSEB WITH AURAM PRESS 3000 (BLOCKS 245 = 245 x 245 x 95mm with 5% cement)
Daily production per press 600 Blocks
Number of presses 2 No.
Months worked yearly 11 Months
MAIN DATA
Variable costs (same as profit & loss account) 1,574,007 1,636,968 1,702,446
Fixed costs (Overhead costs)
Management 15,900 12 190,800 198,432 206,369
Interest on Capital Investment 450,800 12 % 54,096 36,064 18,032
Interest on Working Capital 147,067 15 % 22,060 22,942 23,860
Repayment of Loan (On 3 years) 450,800 3 150,267 150,267 150,267
Total Fixed costs 417,223 407,705 398,528
TOTAL yearly outflows 3,118,230 2,044,673 2,100,475
YEARLY INFLOWS (INCOMES)
Sales of Blocks (All blocks made are sold) 6.81 343,200 2,337,231 2,430,721 2,527,949
Loan for Capital Investment 450,800
Sale of Capital Assets (Equipment only-Rs.) 25 % 250,000 62,500
Sale of land with water supply (Immoveable assets-Rs.) 100 % 749,000 749,000
TOTAL yearly Inflows 3,464,231 2,430,721 3,339,449
NET CASH FLOW (Incomes - expenditures) 346,001 386,048 1,238,475
17
16. EARTHQUAKES
The earth was a single land about two
hundred million years ago. This land split
progressively over a long period of time
and it gave tectonic plates.
Tectonic plates
These movements generate a lot of friction, which generate tensions and compressions in the earths crust. This
friction is like energy, which gets stored in the deepest strata of the ground. Earthquakes happen when the ground
cannot accumulate anymore this energy, which is then released with violence on the surface of the globe.
Seismic waves
The original focus of the earthquake is called the hypocentre. It lies deep into the ground. The geographical
point on the surface, which is vertical to the focus, is called the epicentre
P Waves S waves
They create a change in Are very destructives.
volume and generate a They oscillate vertically
compression and a and perpendicularly to
dilatation of the ground. their direction.
18
Measure of seism
Two scales measure earthquakes: the Richter scale and the Mercalli scale.
- The Richter scale gives a quantitative measure of earthquakes. It defines the magnitude of an earthquake,
which is the amount of energy released on the surface. The Richter scale is logarithmic: each whole number
increase in magnitude represents a ten-fold increase in the measured amplitude of the seism. This scale has
no upper limit, but the largest known shocks have had magnitudes up to 8.8 to 8.9.
- The Mercalli scale assesses the effects of an earthquake. It defines the intensity of the earthquake, which is
expressed from 1 to 12. The intensity and thus the effect of the seism are related to the distance from the
epicentre. It is based on more subjective effects, like movement of furniture, extents of damages to
structures, modification of the landscape, etc.
Earthquake effect
Earthquakes don’t directly kill people. Ground shaking destroys infrastructure and buildings and hence, it is of a
material nature. Death of people is occurred by the collapse of buildings in which they live. Therefore, the real
cause of life’s loss is badly built or un-appropriate constructions, which instantly collapse without warning.
Seism prediction
It is not possible to predict earthquakes.
Earthquake prevention
If it is not possible to predict earthquakes, it is possible to prevent major damages and most of life’s losses. The
prevention of earthquakes is based on the possibility of buildings to resist earthquakes without sudden collapse.
19
17. EARTHQUAKE EFFECTS ON STRUCTURES
Failure mechanism of walls
GROUND MOTION IN THE WALL PLANE GROUND MOTION PERPENDICULAR TO THE WALL
Site location
Very loose sands and sensitive clay should generally be avoided. They are liable to be destroyed.
Compressive strength
- Design the walls (thickness + stability) according to the load bearing capacity of wet CSEB.
- Keep a safety factor from the wet crushing strength: 10-safety factor for the seismic zones 3, 4 and 5
Example: A CSEB has a c wet of 20/kg/cm2: the maximum load bearing for the basement will be:
20 = 2 kg/cm2, on the basement for the zones 3, 4 and 5
10
Shear strength
- Avoid any major difference of load bearing in CSEB walls: especially near windows, for verandas...
- For earthquake resistant buildings of the seismic zones 3, 4, and 5, place a ring beam on the sill level.
Module of blocks
- Design the building according to the module of blocks. (Module of a block = its nominal size + mortar thickness)
21
20. DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR EARTHQUAKE RESISTANCE
Building shapes
The best shapes for earthquake resistant buildings are regular shapes and preferably with two symmetry axis.
Thus the centres of gravity and rigidity will be the same or close to each other and there will not be any torsion.
When it is not possible to have regular shapes, it is possible to improve the earthquake resistance by dividing
the building in several parts.
GOOD SHAPES
DEFICIENT SHAPES
AND IMPROVEMENT
Separation gap
Buildings with irregular and asymmetrical shapes should be split into simpler shapes like shown above. The
various parts will vibrate at a different frequency and amplitude. They will hit each other and will damage each
other. A gap (filled with a crumbly material or left empty) should be kept between them to avoid collision: 25 mm
minimum for ground floor buildings and for higher ones the gap should be increased by 10 mm per storey more.
Ductility
Reinforcements can be added to make a structure more ductile with brittle materials: wood, bamboo or
reinforced cement concrete members. They should be well distributed with ring beams at various levels and
linked together with vertical ties. This will reinforce the structure very well and make it ductile.
Rigidity distribution
The centre of gravity should also preferably be the centre of rigidity. This would avoid torsion of the building.
PROPER DISTRIBUTION
OF WALLS AND OPENINGS
TORSION
DUE TO BAD DESIGN
Vertical ties should link the various floors and ring beams.
Foundations
Isolated footing of columns can easily be subjected to differential settlement. Mixed foundations in the same
building are also not suitable. What works best in most of cases are trench foundations.
Long walls
They should be designed as shear walls and braced either by a buttress or by a cross wall.
Openings
Doors and windows reduce the lateral resistance of walls to shear. Hence, they should preferably be small and
rather centrally located. When a specific design cannot follow this basic specification, the specifications
mentioned below (IS 4326: 1993) must be followed.
D1, D2 = W1, W2, W3 = Windows V1, V2 = Ventilators CW = Cross walls T = cross walls thickness
Doors
B8 is wider than B2 - B7 is wider than B9
1 STOREY 2 STOREY 3 STOREY
B1 +B2 + B3 0.5 L1 0.42 L1 0.33 L1
B6 +B7 0.5 L2 0.42 L2 0.33 L2
B4 0.5 H2 (But not less than 60 cm)
B5 0.25 H1 (But not less than 60 cm)
H3 0.5 B8 (But not less than 60 cm)
H4 0.5 B7 (But not less than 60 cm)
Notes: H3 is calculated from B8, which is wider than B2 – H4 is calculated from B7, which is wider than
B9
23
21. DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR HOLLOW INTERLOCKING BLOCKS
Trench Foundations
Isolated foundations, like footings of columns, are not adapted. Stabilised rammed earth will be a very
appropriate solution if the natural ground is suitable. Stabilised rammed earth foundations normally have a
square section: i.e. 60 x 60 cm for a ground floor structure.
On coastal areas, which are tsunami prone, buildings should have deeper foundations. Its minimum depth should
be double the width: i.e. 60 cm wide x 120 cm deep. This will avoid the bearing ground of the foundations to be
excavated by the flow.
If reinforced concrete foundation are to be used it is essential that the vertical ties are inserted very
accurately from the bottom of the foundation.
Basement
It can be done with various materials, by steps or like a monolithic plinth. Note that the height of the basement
varies with local conditions. The example shown below is the minimum height. A reinforced concrete ring beam
on top of the foundation and a plinth beam on the floor level should always be cast:
- At the top of the foundation (unless RCC foundations are used) is laid a first a reinforced concrete ring beam,
1cement: 1.5sand: 3gravel, in which are anchored the vertical ties.
- It is essential top locate very accurately the vertical ties in the first reinforced concrete ring beam.
- Above it starts the step plinth and its height depends of the local conditions. The minimum height will be one
block above the first concrete ring beam, as shown below.
- A plinth beam is laid on the basement and its top level will be the floor level. This plinth beam is cast in U
blocks with 1cement: 1.5sand: 3gravel.
All courses of the step basement are laid in stabilised earth mortar, SEM: 1cement: 1 soil: 3 sand. The mortar
thickness is everywhere 5 mm thick, for the horizontal and vertical joints. Note that on top of the plinth beam will
be laid a damp-proof course of 1 cm thick with CS 1: 2 and waterproofing compound.
Ring beams
They tie horizontally the building and the maximum vertical spacing between them should be 120 cm and the
minimum should be 50 cm (below the roof). They are 5 or 6 ring beams, depending on the case:
- Roof with a concrete slab or ferrocement channels = 5 ring beams.
- Roof with a vault or dome and a parapet wall = 6 ring beams.
If windows have arches and not lintels, the lintel ring beam should be on top of the arch. Reinforcements are
made with 2 bars of Ø10TS and stirrups Ø6MS @ 25 cm c/c maximum.
Ring beams for ferrocement channels Ring beams for RCC slab roof Ring beams for vaulted roof
24
Vertical ties
The ring beams are tied together with vertical ties (Ø 10 TS), so as to create reinforcement net. The vertical ties
are laid on the foundation and anchored in a PCC 1: 1.5: 3, just above the foundations. The bars should be
bend 30 cm in the PCC and their height will not exceed 150 cm, so as to slide down the blocks. The overlap of
the extension rod will be 50 times the bar diameter (50 cm for Ø 10TS). They should follow the spacing shown
hereafter.
BLOCK 245 BLOCK 295
Long walls Maximum every 200 cm Maximum every 150 cm
Openings 1 bar, on either side, in the first hole, 1 bar on either side, in the first hole,
(At 12.5 cm) (At 15cm)
L Corner walls 1 bar on either side, in the first hole from the 1 bar on either side, in the first hole
inside corner (At 12.5 cm) and 1 bar centred in from the inside corner (At 15 cm)
the L
T Cross walls bar on 3 sides, in the first hole from the inside 1 bar on 3 sides, in the first hole from
corner (At 12.5 cm) and 1 bar centred in the T the inside corner (2 bars at 30 cm, on
the length and 1 bar at 15cm on the T)
X Cross walls bar on 4 sides, in the first hole from the inside 1 bar on 4 sides, in the first hole from
corner (At 12.5 cm) and 1 bar centred in the X the inside corner (At 30 cm)
Large opening
In case of a large opening in a facade (i.e. veranda), it must
have a shear wall at least on one side, or several smaller
shear walls. The total length of these small shear walls will
not be less than the half of the front facade. This (these)
shear wall(s) will be more reinforced:
Binders
- Stabilised Earth Mortar SEM 1: 1: 3 – 5 mm thick for laying the blocks
The soil should not have more than 20-25 % of clay. The mortar should be plastic and not too liquid. Note a
cement sand mortar (i.e. 1: 4) will have a very low workability as the mortar thickness is only 5mm.
25