Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Music and Depression
Music and Depression
Music and Depression
Objective: To use ecological momentary assessment tech- Main Outcome Measures: We developed multivari-
niques to measure the association of major depressive dis- able models to determine the independent association of
order (MDD) with media use. each type of media use with MDD, controlling for socio-
demographic variables.
Design: Data were collected using an ecological momen-
Results: Of the 106 participants, 46 were diagnosed as hav-
tary assessment protocol with cellular telephone–based brief
ing MDD. In multivariable models controlling for age, sex,
interviews.
and race, each increasing quartile of audio use was asso-
ciated with an 80% increase in the odds of having MDD
Setting: Participants received as many as 60 telephone (odds ratio,1.8; 95% confidence interval, 1.1-2.8; P=.01 for
calls from a trained staff member during 5 extended week- trend). Conversely, each increasing quartile of print me-
ends in an 8-week period. dia use was associated with a 50% decrease in the odds of
having MDD (odds ratio,0.5; 95% confidence interval, 0.3-
Participants: One hundred six adolescent participants 0.9; P=.009 for trend).
who were part of a larger neurobehavioral study of depres-
Conclusions: Major depressive disorder is positively as-
sion in Pittsburgh from January 1, 2003, through Decem-
sociated with popular music exposure and negatively as-
ber 31, 2008.
sociated with reading print media such as books. Fur-
ther research elucidating the directionality and strength
Main Exposure: At each call, participants were asked of these relationships may help advance understanding
whether they were using the following 5 types of media: of the relationships between media use and MDD.
television or movies, music, video games, Internet, and
print media, such as magazines, newspapers, and books. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2011;165(4):360-365
M
AJOR DEPRESSIVE DISOR- transmitted through media affect other
Author Affiliations: Division of der (MDD) is the lead- behaviors related to mental health, such
General Internal Medicine, ing cause of disability in as eating disorders and aggressive behav-
Department of Medicine the world.1 Because its ior.14,15,17,18 Media use may similarly con-
(Drs Primack and Switzer and onset is common in tribute to the development of depression
Mr DeLozier), and Departments adolescence and young adulthood,2,3 it co- via reinforcement of cognitions and/or
of Pediatrics (Dr Primack) and
incides with a pivotal period of physical and affective states.15,17,19 For example, certain
Psychiatry (Dr Silk), University
of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, psychological development and can lead to televised media situations are saturated with
RAND Corporation (Dr Shadel), substantial morbidity and mortality.4,5 The highly idealized characters and situa-
and Center for Heath Equity development of MDD is a biopsychoso- tions,17,20 and constant comparison of one’s
Research and Promotion, cial, multifactorial process influenced by self to these unattainable images may con-
Veterans Affairs Pittsburgh multiple risk and protective factors.2,3,5-7 tribute to or exacerbate depression.19,21
Healthcare System (Dr Switzer), Moreover, given the high rates of media use Other media exposures—particularly on
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania; School in adolescence8,9 and the potential bidirec- television, in music, and in video games—
of Journalism and Mass tional effects between mood and media are highly negative or violent,16,17,22 and re-
Communication, University of use,10-17 examining real-life media use in peated exposure to these messages may en-
North Carolina, Chapel Hill
samples of depressed adolescents is an im- gender a negative and fearful perception of
(Dr Dillman Carpentier); and
Community Health and Human portant area of research in adolescent affect the world, which can also contribute to or
Development and Joint Medical regulation. exacerbate depression.21
Program, School of Public Current total media exposure for youth Being depressed may, in turn, influence
Health, University of California, aged 8 to 18 years is estimated at more than media use. For example, individuals with
Berkeley (Dr Dahl). 10 hours per day. 8 Cultural messages MDD may lack the initiative and/or con-
(REPRINTED) ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 4), APR 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
360
(REPRINTED) ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 4), APR 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
361
(REPRINTED) ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 4), APR 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
362
Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; MDD, major depressive disorder; OR, odds ratio.
a Indicates percentage of completed cellular telephone calls on which individuals were using that particular media type.
b Calculated using the Mann-Whitney test.
c For logistic regression controlling for race, sex, and age. For these analyses, the independent variable was the particular media type (eg, watching television or
movies) divided into quartiles. Thus, ORs represent the odds of having MDD for each increasing quartile of exposure.
d Calculated using a nonparametric test for trend.
e Includes magazine, newspaper, and/or book use.
surement of media exposure, it is also possible that the stereotypical and/or otherwise negative portrayals of fe-
previous study, which relied on participant self-report, male characters in video games.17,50
may have been affected by recall bias and that the hy- Web-based media may be processed similarly to print,51
pothesized association between television exposure and suggesting that computer use (much of which is Web
depression may not be as strong as suggested. based) and print media use may have similar associa-
After adjustment for sociodemographic variables, au- tions with MDD. However, more recent work52 high-
dio (music) exposure had a strong linear association with lights the fact that individuals tend to selectively scan Web
MDD, but television exposure did not bear this associa- content rather than absorbing it more fully, suggesting
tion. Association of music exposure with MDD has been that in other ways Web use may be more similar to tele-
hypothesized. For example, sadness is a common theme vision use. Our results—which did not find statistically
in popular music, and it may be that individuals with de- significant associations between Internet use and MDD—
pression turn to these messages to make themselves feel are consistent with the Web as a possible amalgamation
less alone in their sadness.43-46 Conversely, it may also be of print- and television-type content.
that individuals with MDD turn to happy music to “tune Recruitment for this study focused on a particular geo-
out” their negative moods or to elevate their moods.47 Other graphic region and was not randomly generated; there-
researchers have suggested that heavy exposure to the fore, these results are not necessarily broadly generaliz-
sometimes dark themes of popular music may contribute able. The cross-sectional method also precludes inferences
to the development of conditions such as MDD.43-46 What- about the directionality of the associations observed
ever the mechanism, this empirical study suggests that this herein. Future studies will need to more specifically as-
association may be stronger than previously considered. sess the hypothesized relationships in either direction.
Although MDD was not significantly associated with Another limitation is related to the EMA method, which
Internet or video game use, there was a nonsignificant relies on probability to accurately measure media expo-
trend toward higher use/exposure to video games among sures. Although in general we would expect that EMA-
those with MDD. Previous studies30,48 have demon- based estimates of media exposure will correspond to ac-
strated associations between depression and video games tual exposure and be less error prone than self-reported
in adolescents, and a recent study49 linked video game data, any intermittent sampling method may be subject
use with MDD in women. The authors of the last study to error.
noted that women may self-medicate for depression by In addition, our study used types of media exposures
“losing themselves” in virtual game worlds.49 It is also as independent variables without assessing specific types
possible that women may be particularly vulnerable to of media use (eg, Internet use for real-time social net-
(REPRINTED) ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 4), APR 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
363
(REPRINTED) ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 4), APR 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
364
(REPRINTED) ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 4), APR 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
365