Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lagocephalus
Lagocephalus
Gaby Khalaf1, Adib Saad2, Sherif Jemaa1, Waad Sabour2 , Myriam Lteif1 and Stefano Lelli1
1 National Centre for Marine Sciences, National Council for Scientific Research (CNRS), Batroun PoBox 534, Lebanon.
2 Faculty of Agricultural Engineering, Tishreen University, Azziraha street, Lattakieh PoBox 1408, Lattakieh, Syria.
Abstracts: The pufferfish Lagocephalus sceleratus is an invasive Lessepsian species of Indo-Pacific origin that has established an
increasing population over the past decade in the Levantine basin of the Mediterranean. Besides its toxicity due to the accumulation
of tetrodotoxin in its body, it is causing damage to fishing gears and fishermen’s catches. This study aims to provide data on the
population structure and sexual maturity of this species in the eastern basin of the Mediterranean. A total of 214 individuals were
collected in the coastal marine waters of Lebanon and Syria, between January 2012 and June 2013 by means of different types of nets
and lines, on soft bottoms, at depths ranging from 10 m to 170 m. The TL (total length) of the samples varies between 10.8 cm and
71 cm. The most common size classes, represented by 125 individuals, are the ones between 30 cm and 50 cm TL, with a bulge at 40
cm, represented by 44 individuals. The average TL is 43.99 cm (standard deviation: SD = 17.65) for both males and females. The
TW (total weight) of the specimens ranges between 14 g and 4,603 g with an average value of 1,458.52 g (SD = 1,329.49). The sex
ratio (M/F) is 1:1.35 with a total number of 87 males, 118 females and 9 unidentified individuals. The weight-length relationship
(TW = aTLb) shows a negative allometric growth with b = 2.9481 and R2 = 0.9806. The condition factor (K) is close to one for all
samples. The average value of the GSI (gonadosomatic index) shows a substantial increase from winter to spring. The spawning
takes place between April and June.
Key words: Lagocephalus sceleratus, Lessepsian species, population structure, eastern Mediterranean.
way to the Mediterranean through the Suez Canal. It commercial species, they are illegally collected and
invaded the eastern Mediterranean during the last consumed as food in the Red Sea and Gulf of Suez
decade causing damages to fishing gears and areas. Zaki [28] described the clinical manifestations,
fishermen’s catches. A record in February 2003 from age, sex and time elapsed between the ingestion and
Gokova Bay in the southern Aegean coast of Turkey the death of eight cases due to pufferfishes poisoning
[9] demonstrated for the first time the presence of this in Suez City. In the eastern Mediterranean, many
species in the Mediterranean Sea. A previous record cases of TTX poisoning have been reported [23]. In
from the Mediterranean Sea by Mouneimne [10] was a 2005, two cases of human intoxication due to the
misidentification of L. suezensis [11]. The rapid consumption of pufferfish were recorded in Lebanon.
expansion of L. sceleratus can be easily observed as The aim of the current study is to provide essential
the fish had reached the North Aegean Sea in 2006, data and basic information on population structure and
three years after it was reported in Turkey in 2003 sexual maturity of the pufferfish along the Lebanese
[12-15]; four years later in 2010, it was observed at and Syrian coastal waters.
the southern end of the Gulf of Gabès in Tunisia
2. Material and Methods
(central Mediterranean) [16]. Today, it is regarded to
be among the worst invasive species in the This study was performed along the Lebanese and
Mediterranean Sea with a significant impact on the Syrian coastal zone located in the Levantine basin of
surrounding ecosystem and on the fisheries sector [2, the eastern Mediterranean Sea (Fig. 1). The length of
17-19]. the coast line is 390 km (220 km in Lebanon and 170
Like other puffer fishes, it is capable of inflating its km in Syria). The mean surface water temperature in
body by swallowing water. It has two strong teeth in the study area ranges from 16 C to 18 C in winter,
each jaw which are capable of ripping and damaging 22 C to 24 C in autumn and spring reaching 29 C in
fishing nets lines and long lines. In the Mediterranean, summer. Salinity is constant throughout the year and
this fish was found to be voracious and carnivorous, ranges between 39.4 and 39.8. Specimens of the
feeding mainly on shrimps, crabs, fish—including pufferfish L. sceleratus were collected from
individuals of its own species—and cephalopods [20- commercial catches at the principal fishing ports of
21]. Today, it is regarded to be among the most Lebanon and Syria between January 2012 and June
destructive invasive species in the Mediterranean Sea 2013. The collection of samples was performed by
with a significant impact on the surrounding professional fishermen using different fishing gears
ecosystem and on the fisheries sector [2, 17-19]. such as beach seines, encircling trammels, gillnets and
L. sceleratus is considered to be a serious hazard to long lines. These gears were lowered at depths
consumers since it contains a strong paralytic marine ranging from 10 m to 200 m. All samples were placed
toxin called TTX (tetrodotoxin), which can be lethal in labeled plastic bags, transported to the laboratory
to humans [12, 13, 22-24]. Occasional accidental immersed in crushed ice and then processed. For each
intoxications, including deaths, have been reported fish, the TL (total length) was measured to the nearest
from all over the world due to eating pufferfish. The 0.1 cm and TW (total weight) to the nearest 0.1 g. Sex
majority of reported cases have occurred in and maturity stages were determined macroscopically,
southeastern Asia including Malaysia, Taiwan and and the GW (weight of the gonads) was recorded to
Hong Kong [25-27] and the Red Sea [22, 28]. In the nearest 0.01 g. Stages of maturity were classified
Egypt, although landing of this fish is forbidden as
Population Structure and Sexual Maturity of the Pufferfish Lagocephalus Sceleratus (Osteichthyes, 3
Tetraodontidae) in the Lebanese and Syrian Marine Waters (Eastern Mediterranean)
Fig. 1 Sampling stations performed along the Lebanese and Syrian coasts.
Table 1 Mean, minimum and maximum values for length and weight of the female and male specimens of L. sceleratus.
Length (cm) Weight (g)
Number of individuals Mean and SD Minimum Maximum Mean and SD Minimum Maximum
Total 214 43.99 (SD = 17.65) 10.8 71 1,458.52 (SD = 1,329.4) 14 4,603
Females 118 46.12 (SD = 17.97) 10.8 70 1,701.68 (SD = 1,535.1) 16 4,603
Males 87 39.62 (SD = 17.53) 15 71 1,413.83 (SD = 1,026.8) 37.40 3,000
ND 9 52.37 (SD = 16.14) 11 36 142 (SD = 217.39) 14 393
The overall sex ratio of males to females was developing and mature individuals represented 61%
1:1.35, which is not significantly different from 1:1 (P (132 ind.) of the total sample; only 8% (17 ind.) and
> 0.05) and indicated a well-balanced population in 9% (19 ind.) of the caught individuals corresponded to
the eastern Mediterranean Sea [22]. The females the stages regressing and regenerating individuals.
dominated the catch in all the study period. According to size classification (Fig. 3), the length
Length-weight relationships are important in at which 50% of L. sceleratus individuals had reached
fisheries biology because they allow the estimation of maturity was 44.4 cm.
the average weight of the fish at a given length, by The average values of GSI results (Fig. 5) showed a
establishing a mathematical relationship between substantial increase from winter to spring. The
weight and length. The overall length-weight maximum values were recorded between April and
relationship for both males and females of L. July for males and between April and June for females
sceleratus (Fig. 2) showed a good fit to the indicating that L. sceleratus has an extensive
exponential curve (R2 = 0.9806); the values of a and b spawning season. Males and females in the regressing
were 0.014 and 2.9481 respectively. stage were found during the months of summer, while
The length–frequency histogram shows that 58% the regenerating stages were observed during autumn
(125 individuals) of the catches are between 30 cm and winter. L. sceleratus was found to have a similar
and 50 cm size class. No individuals were caught in average condition factor (K) close to one throughout
the size classes of 25 cm and 55 cm. The majority of the year with only summer possessing higher values
classes were dominated by females, with the exception among the seasons for males.
of size class 40 cm that held the highest number of
4. Discussions and Conclusions
individuals (44 ind.) and where the number of males
was identical to the number of females, and size The longest individual’s length examined in our
classes 45 cm and 50 cm, where the males were more case (71 cm) is higher than that reported by Ref. [32]
numerous (Fig. 3). (18 cm) in Malaysia, and relatively higher than those
The period of reproduction for both males and observed by Kalogirou [31] (64 cm) in the coastal
females was reconstructed by examining the temporal habitats of Rhodes Island, by Ref. [23] (60 cm) on the
variation of both gonad maturity stages and Israeli coast and by Aydin [21] in Antalaya Bay (65
gonadsomatic index. In order to exclude all immature cm); however, it was smaller than that reported by
individuals and minimize bias, only fish with TL Sabrah et al. [22] in the Gulf of Suez (78.5 cm).
above 100% maturity were considered. According to According to Takeda [33] and Masuda [34], pufferfish
the gonad maturity stages (Fig. 4), 32% (69 ind.) of can reach 110 cm. The mean length of females (46.12
the individuals caught were mature. The stages of ± 17.65 cm) was significantly higher than that
Population Structure and Sexual Maturity of the Pufferfish Lagocephalus Sceleratus (Osteichthyes, 5
Tetraodontidae) in the Lebanese and Syrian Marine Waters (Eastern Mediterranean)
observed for males (39.62 ± 17.52 cm) and females and Kalogirou [31] but are higher than those observed
were also significantly heavier than males. These by Aydin [21] in Antalya Bay. Moreover, the
results coincide with those obtained by Sabrah [22]
Fig. 3 The length-frequency distribution of the L. sceleratus sample caught along the Lebanese and Syrian coasts.
6 Population Structure and Sexual Maturity of the Pufferfish Lagocephalus Sceleratus (Osteichthyes,
Tetraodontidae) in the Lebanese and Syrian Marine Waters (Eastern Mediterranean)
Fig. 5 The GSI (gonado-somatic index) for the males and females of the L. sceleratus sample caught along the Lebanese and
Syrian coasts (12 = 2012, 13 = 2013).
maximum weight of fish observed in the present study presence of this species at depths greater than 100 m is
(4,603 g) is higher than that observed by Aydin [21] probably due to feeding because shallow waters in this
(3,465 g) and lower than that reported by Smith and region are known to be oligotrophic [38, 39].
Heemstra (7,000 g) [35]. The value of the length-weight relationship for both
The depth distribution of the L. sceleratus in this males and females of L. sceleratus revealed negative
study is wider than that observed by May and allometric growth in all individuals. The a and b
Maxwell [36] who had found this species in tropical values resulting from this study correspond to the
waters at depths ranging from 18 m to 100 m, but values obtained by all of Sabrah [22] in the Gulf of
lower than that observed by Yaglioglu et al. [37] at Suez, Edelist [40] from the Israeli coast, Aydin [21] in
250 m in the Red Sea. Fig. 6 shows that 94% (202 Antalya Bay and Kalogirou [31] from Rhodes Island,
ind.) of individuals occupy depths less than 100 m, who obtained similar growth patterns. However, this
with a relatively high density in depths ranging from result does not correspond to that obtained by
20 m to 60 m (68%; 147 ind.), and only 12 individuals Anderson and Neuman [41] and Froese [42] who
occupy depths ranging from 100 m to 170 m. In fact, found that the fish is growing at the same rate in
only one individual was caught at the latter depth. The weight and length.
Population Structure and Sexual Maturity of the Pufferfish Lagocephalus Sceleratus (Osteichthyes, 7
Tetraodontidae) in the Lebanese and Syrian Marine Waters (Eastern Mediterranean)
The length classes’ distribution shows that 30 cm to by Aydin [21] in Antalya Bay. However, it started
50 cm size class represents 58% of the collected earlier than that observed by Sabrah et al. [22] in the
specimens in accordance with that observed by Gulf of Suez and by Kalogirou [31] in the coastal
Kalogirou [31] who found that 57% of catches habitats of Rhodes Island, who noted that this period
belonged to the size class 30-40 cm on Posidonia occurred in summer. The precocious sexual maturity
oceanica habitats and 56% of catches belonged to the is probably due to the influence of higher values of
size class 20-30 cm on sandy bottom. temperature and salinity parameters in the part of the
The size of reached maturity in this study (45 cm) is eastern Mediterranean region extended from Antalya
agreed with that observed by Sabrah et al. [22] in the to south of Lebanon [43-45] L. sceleratus has
Gulf of Suez (42-43 cm), and higher than that undergone very rapid geographical expansion in the
observed by Kalogirou [31] in the coastal habitats of Mediterranean; in ten years it has invaded the eastern
Rhodes Island (36 cm). basin of the Mediterranean and made landfall in the
In this study, the spawning period occurring
between April and July, coincides with that observed
Tunisian Central Mediterranean [16]. Its growth is Funding for this research was provided by the
exponential; it occupies almost all habitat s with scientific bilateral Lebano-syrian program and by the
preference for soft bottoms and can be found at depths CANA-CNRS (CANA is the name of village and
reaching 250 m. It causes damage to fishermen by CNRS is the National Council of Scientific Research
attacking fishing nets and caught fish. Several cases of cited in the address of authors) project
poisoning have been reported due to the consumption “Environmental monitoring and sustainable
of parts of this animal containing TTX. If fishing and development of the Lebanese sea” elaborated between
consumption of this species remains tacit in some the Italian government and the National Council for
countries such as Japan [46] and Egypt [22], all the Scientific Research of Lebanon, April 2, 2009.
Mediterranean countries shall recommend legislating The authors would like to thank the scientific and
and prohibiting fishing for this animal. Regular research assistants of the National Center for Marine
monitoring for the presence of this species in the Sciences in Lebanon and the Faculty of Agriculture of
Mediterranean must be performed to control its Tishreen University in Syria for their technical help.
geographical distribution and limit the damage it can We are also grateful to the fishermen along the
cause. Lebanese and Syrian coasts for their regular help in
acquiring fish samples.
Acknowledgments
8 Population Structure and Sexual Maturity of the Pufferfish Lagocephalus Sceleratus (Osteichthyes,
Tetraodontidae) in the Lebanese and Syrian Marine Waters (Eastern Mediterranean)
[28] A.M. Zaki, Tetrodoxin poisoning associated with eating [38] M. Abboud-Abi Saab, M.T. Kassab, A study of the
puffer fish in Suez City (Egypt), in: 1st International annual cycle of phytoplanctonic population in the palm
Conference on Natural Toxins, October 6 University, (it island nature reserve, Lebanon, Lebanese Science
is the name of the University, so it’s correct) 18-19 Bulletin 10 (1) (1997) 61-79.
Decembre, 2004 Egypt, 72 pp. [39] L. Ignatiades, Scaling the trophic status of the Aegean
[29] R.O. Anderson, S.J. Guteruter, Length, weight, and Sea, eastern Mediterranean, Journal of Sea Research 54
associated structural indices, in: L.A. Neilsen, D.L. (2005) 51-57.
Johnson (Eds.), Fisheries Techniques, Amercian Fisheries [40] D. Edelist, New length-weight relationships and Lmax
Society, Bethesda, 1983, pp. 283-300. values for fishes from the southeastern Mediterranean
[30] T.W. Fulton, The note of growth of fishes., 22nd Annual Sea, Journal of Applied Ichthyology 30 (3) (2012) 521-
Report of the Fishery Board of Scotland (3) (1904) 141- 526.
241. [41] R.O. Anderson, R.M. Neumann, Length, weight, and
[31] S. Kalogirou, Ecological characteristics of the invasive associated structural indices, in: B.R. Murphy, D.W.
pufferfish Lagocephalus sceleratus (Gmelin, 1789) in Willis (Eds.), Fisheries Techniques, 2nd ed., American
Rhodes, eastern Mediterranean Sea: A case study, Fisheries Society, Bethesda, 1996, pp. 447-482.
Mediterranean Marine Science 14 (12) (2013) 251-260. [42] R. Froese, Cube law, condition factor and weight-length
[32] E.H. Chan, H.C. Liew, Characteristics of an exploited relationships: History, meta-analysis and
tropical shallow-water demersal fish community in recommendations, Journal of Applied Ichthyology 22
Malaysia, in: J.L. Maclean, L.B. Dizon, L.V. Hosillos, (2006) 241-253.
(Eds.), The first Asian Fisheries Forum, Asian Fisheries [43] G. Khalaf, Assessment of surface fresh water, in: H.
Society, Manila, Philippines, 1986, pp. 349-351. Kouyoumjian and M. Hamzé (eds), Review and
[33] A. Takeda, Blowfish and Trade (BLOWFISH Case), Perspectives of Environmental Studies in Lebanon,
TED Case Studies: An Online Journal, Case Number 283, INCAM-EU/CNRS Lebanon, 2012, pp. 328, 57-78.
Washington D.C., American University, The School of [44] M. Abboud-Abi Saab, Marine biodiversity in coastal
International Service, 1996. waters, in: H. Kouyoumjian and M. Hamzé (eds), Review
[34] H. Masuda, K. Amaoka, C. Araga, T. Uyeno, T. Yoshino, and Perspectives of Environmental Studies in Lebanon,
The Fishes of the Japanese Archipelago, Vol. 1, Tokai INCAM-EU/CNRS Lebanon, 2012, pp. 328,1-29.
University Press, Tokyo, Japan, 1984, p. 437. [45] M. Fakhri, The state of the Lebanese coastal waters, in:
[35] M.M. Smith, P.C. Heemstra, Tetraodontidae, in: M.M. H. Kouyoumjian and M. Hamzé (eds), Review and
Smith, P. C. Heemstra, (Eds.), Smith’s Sea Fishes, Perspectives of Environmental Studies in Lebanon,
Spring-Verlag, Berlin, 1986, pp. 894-903. INCAM-EU/CNRS Lebanon, 2012, pp. 328, 31-54.
[36] J.L. May, J.G.H. Maxwell, Trawl Fish from Temperate [46] T.A. Torda, E. Sinclair, D.B. Ulyatt, Puffer fish
Waters of Australia, CSIRO Division of Fisheries (Tetrodotoxin) poisoning: Clinical record and suggested
Research, Tasmania, 1986. management, Medical Journal of Australia 1, (1973) 599-
[37] D. Yaglioglu, C. Turan, D. Erguden, G. Mevlut, Range 602.
Expansion of Silverstripe Blaasop, L. sceleratus (Gmelin,
1789) to the northeastern Mediterranean Sea, Biharean
Biologist 5 (2) (2011) 159-161.