Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Assessing The Bending Strength and Modulus of Elas
Assessing The Bending Strength and Modulus of Elas
Assessing The Bending Strength and Modulus of Elas
net/publication/290939894
CITATIONS READS
13 872
2 authors, including:
Pavel Král
Mendel University in Brno
66 PUBLICATIONS 232 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Pavel Král on 03 May 2020.
J. HRÁZSKÝ, P. KRÁL
Faculty of Forestry and Wood Technology, Mendel University of Agriculture and Forestry Brno,
Brno, Czech Republic
ABSTRACT: The paper summarizes results of an institutional research aimed at assessing the bending strength and
modulus of elasticity in bending of exterior foiled combined and all-beech plywoods in relation to their construction.
A relationship was studied of the plywood construction and selected physical and mechanical properties. In studied
sheets, moisture, density, bending strength and modulus of elasticity were analysed along and across the grain of the
upper veneer. All measurements were carried out in water-resistant plywoods with surface treatment with a phe-
nolformaldehyde foil 8, 10, 12 and 15 mm thick in combined plywoods and 10, 12, 15 and 18 mm thick in all-beech
plywoods. The construction of plywoods significantly influences their quality that is determined particularly by the
bending strength and modulus of elasticity. Using regression analysis relationships were demonstrated particularly that
with the increasing moisture content of plywoods the bending strength decreased and with the increasing density the
bending strength and modulus of elasticity increased. The same trend was also proved in connection with the increas-
ing number of veneers of plywood sheets. Using correlation analysis, combinations of interrelationships of the given
properties were statistically tested.
Keywords: plywood; density; surface density; moisture; thickness; bending strength; modulus of elasticity in bending;
veneer; statistical analysis
Plywood sheets are defined as sheets with mutual- density) and demonstrate higher values of particular
ly glued plies, the direction of fibres of neighbouring mechanical and physical properties. Their main ad-
plies being perpendicular to each other. In general, vantage is that they maintain an appearance of natu-
outside and inside plies on both sides are symmetri- ral wood. Plywood sheets can also be manufactured
cal with respect to the core (or central ply). as formed moulded articles. In general, their coating
The manufacture of plywood sheets belongs to the (surface finish) is simple. According to the purpose
youngest branches of the wood-processing industry. of use, plywood sheets can be manufactured as ex-
Plywood sheets have occupied one of the leading terior (water-resistant) plywoods by adding special
places on the market of large-area materials. They types of synthetic adhesives or using special foils.
are used in many sectors of human activities, e.g. in Plywood sheets show, however, the greatest use in
engineering, textile industry, furniture manufacture, furniture industry (non-water-resistant plywoods).
transport, industrial and building production, etc. In building industry, however, exterior water-re-
Plywood materials, together with agglomerated sistant plywood sheets are used. Building industry
materials are ranked among large-area materials. uses plywood sheets also for the construction and
They are manufactured by hot-pressing the sets manufacture of floors, plywood lining, structural
of veneers spread with a synthetic adhesive under walls, laminated constructions, etc. As for trans-
interaction of pressure. port, plywood sheets are used in the manufacture of
As against agglomerated materials, i.e. particle- railway cars, buses, trams, lorries, ships, etc.
boards and fibreboards, they show certain advan- Plywood sheets are categorised according to the
tages. They are substantially lighter (showing lower construction to plywoods (joinery, building, pack-
160
Production
140 Export
Import
120
Output (thousand m )
3
100
80
60
40
Normal and shear stress is expressed in N/mm2. Fig. 3. Failure caused by the fibre rupture in the tensile zone
Because of the effect of external forces, changes in
the body size, volume or shift in dimensions occur
and thus also the partial change in the body form.
These changes are called deformations.
Wood or more accurately the basis of its cell Fig. 4. Failure – a blunt fracture along the height of the body
walls represents in principle a complex of natural
polymers with long chain molecules. The structure
of polymers determines the nature of their behav-
iour under loading. If external forces act on the
polymers, the following three types of deformations
can occur: Fig. 5. Fibrous failure along the height of the body
– immediate elastic deformation (εp) – caused by
reversible changes in average distances between
chain molecules of polymers (it occurs immedi- forces. Several basic characteristics of failures are
ately during the action of the force and after its distinguished (Figs. 2–5).
relaxation it promptly disappears);
– elastic deformation developing with time (ε t) MATERIAL AND METHODS
– sometimes called elastic deformation con-
nected with the reversible rearrangement of par- Tests were carried out on foiled exterior plywood
ticles of chain molecules (it increases gradually sheets of two types of construction with slip-resist-
with time and disappears after some time after ant (skidproof ) treatment.
relaxation); The construction of combined plywood sheets
– plastic (irreversible) deformation (εpl) – caused is given in Table 1 and that of all-beech plywood
by intermixing the chain molecules. It remains sheets in Table 2.
after the acting force was relaxed (it is also called In both types of plywood sheet construction,
residual deformation, permanent deformation). producers give the surface density of surface foils
In wood, deformations caused by changes in the 167 g/m2, gluing class 3 according to ČSN EN 314-
moisture content occur very often. Wood obtains 2 (49 0173) standard, i.e. complying with AW 100
various dimensions thereby being deformed. Swell- test and formaldehyde emission class A according
ing represents elastic deformations. As soon as to ČSN EN 1084 (49 2407) standard.
wood changes its dimensions and shape, internal According to EN 326-1 and EN 325 standards,
forces have to originate in the wood causing stress plans of plywood cutting were prepared. An exam-
(moisture stress). After the removal of water from ple of the plan for plywoods 15 mm thick is depicted
the wood structure the wood obtains its original in Fig. 6. The number of samples used for the tests
dimensions and deformations disappear. is given in Table 3.
Relationships between stress and deformation Particular physical and mechanical properties of
provide very useful information for the development plywood sheets were determined according to the
of production of construction materials of wood. following standards:
These relationships are of great importance mainly – ČSN EN 310 Determination of modulus of elastic-
in determining parameters for plywood pressing, ity in bending and bending strength
laminated densified wood, particleboards, etc. – ČSN EN 322 Boards of wood – Determination of
Characteristics of failures in bending stress are moisture
various. They are primarily dependent on the geom- – ČSN EN 323 Boards of wood – Determination of
etry of shape, wood structure and effects of external density
Table 3. Number of samples for particular tests from one plywood sheet
B Density 16
C Density profile 6
E Wettability 12
F Dimension change 4
Moisture
Table 5. Modulus of elasticity and bending strength of combined plywoods along the grain (n = 16)
8 mm thick 15 mm thick
–0.1897 –0.1759 0.3359 –0.0908 –0.1449 0.1627
E
p = 0.482 p = 0.515 p = 0.203 p = 0.738 p = 0.592 p = 0.547
–0.1699 0.0156 0.2879 –0.1154 –0.3785 –0.6528
fm
p = 0.529 p = 0.954 p = 0.280 p = 0.670 p = 0.148 p = 0.006
0.3895 0.1720 0.3166 0.3288 0.2262 –0.0903
ε
p = 0.136 p = 0.524 p = 0.232 p = 0.214 p = 0.400 p = 0.739
10 mm thick 18 mm thick
0.1263 0.0194 –0.3291 0.2303 0.3728 0.5714
E
p = 0.641 p = 0.943 p = 0.213 p = 0.391 p = 0.155 p = 0.021
–0.1045 –0.1807 –0.1177 0.3486 0.3568 0.0436
fm
p = 0.700 p = 0.503 p = 0.664 p = 0.186 p = 0.175 p = 0.872
–0.0861 –0.0649 0.0967 0.3409 0.2078 –0.5114
ε
p = 0.751 p = 0.811 p = 0.722 p = 0.196 p = 0.440 p = 0.043
12 mm thick
0.0204 0.1923 0.1469
E
p = 0.940 p = 0.476 p = 0.587
0.1107 –0.0575 –0.1341
fm
p = 0.683 p = 0.833 p = 0.620
0.0991 0.0698 –0.0156
ε
p = 0.715 p = 0.797 p = 0.954
*Marked correlations are significant at p < 0.050; n = 16 (casewise deletion of missing data
Density, strength and modulus of elasticity coefficients expresses probability of the occurrence
of plywood sheets of a studied phenomenon in the basic set.
Figs. 7–9 show dependences of MOE in bending,
Results of measurements with basic statistic bending strength and relative deformation on the
characteristics of density, strength and MOE of sheet thickness in combined plywoods. In Figs. 10
combined and all-beech plywoods and results of to 12, dependences are given of MOE in bending,
correlation analysis are given in Tables 4–12. Ta- bending strength and relative deformation on the
ble 12 is an aggregate table of bending strength and sheet density in combined plywoods, in Figs. 13–15
MOE in bending for combined plywoods, Table 13 dependences are depicted of MOE in bending,
gives results of the respective correlation analysis. bending strength and relative deformation on the
Table 14 is an aggregate table of bending strength number of plies in combined plywoods. Figs. 16–18
and MOE in bending for all-beech plywoods, illustrate dependences of MOE in bending, bend-
Table 15 gives results of the respective correlation ing strength and relative deformation on the sheet
analysis. Table 16 gives results of correlation analy- thickness in all-beech plywoods. In Figs. 19–21,
sis for combined and all-beech plywoods. Important dependences are depicted of MOE in bending, bend-
relationships are represented in italics. Negative ing strength and relative deformation on the sheet
correlation coefficient expresses negative depend- density in all-beech plywoods. Figs. 22–24 show
ence. The value of p given in tables under correlation dependences of MOE in bending, bending strength
and relative deformation on the number of plies in comply with minimum strength values given by DIN
all-beech plywoods. 68 705 Teil 3 standard.
In the bending tests, failures occurred mostly in
Fractures of plywoods surface layers of the tensile zone (Figs. 28–29) or
along the whole thickness of a specimen (Figs. 25
The bending tests have demonstrated that both to 27). In combined plywoods 18 mm thick, 75% of
combined and all-beech plywoods of all thicknesses failures occurred in the central layer during bending
*Marked correlations are significant at p < 0.050; n = 16 (casewise deletion of missing data)
in cross direction. The failures occurred as a result ing force as related to density, surface density and
of surmounting the central veneer shear strength thickness proved the relationships only in a small
(Fig. 30). Fig. 31 depicts failures in the central zone number of measurements.
due to the central veneer defect. Correlation analysis has demonstrated more re-
The results of correlation and regression analysis lationships in aggregate sets for particular types of
for particular thicknesses and directions of the act- plywoods (Tabs. 13 and 14). Table 13 demonstrates
25,000
—— along 90 —— along
20,000 – – across 80 – – across
E (N/mm2)
fm (N/mm2)
70
15,000
60
10,000 50
5,000 40
6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Board thickness (mm) Board thickness (mm)
Fig. 7. Dependence of modulus of elasticity on the sheet thick- Fig. 8. Dependence of bending strength on the sheet thickness
ness in combined plywoods in combined plywoods
9
8 —— along 25,000
—— alongy = 69.85x
y = 69.85x – 31,027
– 31,027
7 – – across 20,000 – – across R = 0.7758
2 2
R = 0.7758
E (N/mm 2)
(mm)
6
5 15,000
4 10,000
3 y = –25.953x + 29,448
5,000 R2 = 0.0509
2
6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 600 620 640 660 680 700 720
3
Board thickness (mm) (kg/m )
Fig. 9. Dependence of relative deformation on the sheet thick- Fig. 10. Dependence of modulus of elasticity on the sheet
ness in combined plywoods density in combined plywoods
y = 0.2963x –126.29
90
——y = along
0.2963x – 126.29 R2 = 0.5819 10
—— along y = –0.0131x + 14.035
80
–– 2
R = 0.5819
across
8 – – across R 2 = 0.0406
fm (N/mm )
2
70 6
! (mm)
y =y–0.0353x
= –0.0353x+ 74.103
+ 74.103
60 R2R=20.0109
= 0.0109 4
y = 0.0005x + 4.3108
50 2 R 2 = 0.0001
40 0
600 620 640 660 680 700 720 600 620 640 660 680 700 720
3
3 (kg/m )
(kg/m )
Fig. 11. Dependence of bending strength on the sheet density Fig. 12. Dependence of relative deformation on the sheet
in combined plywoods density in combined plywoods
*Marked correlations are significant at p < 0.050; n = 16 (casewise deletion of missing data)
R 2 = 0.1561
fm (N/mm2)
70
15,000
y = 4.6286x + 18.565
60
2
10,000 yy==2,003.2x
2,003.2x– 1,592.1
– 1,592.1 R = 0.425
50
RR22==0.6863
0.06863
5,000 40
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Number of plies Number of plies
Fig. 13. Dependence of modulus of elasticity on the number Fig. 14. Dependence of bending strength on the number of
of plies in combined plywoods sheet plies in combined plywoods
Surface
Thickness Number w ρ εII ε⊥ fm II fm ⊥ E II E⊥
density
(mm) of plies (%) (kg/m3) (mm) (mm) (N/mm2) (N/mm2) (N/mm2) (N/mm2)
(kg/m2)
8 5 9.16 5.59 650.61 3.99 3.16 78.65 44.26 15,269.08 9,368.89
10 7 8.74 7.05 702.16 3.71 4.01 79.90 43.01 18,519.16 9,683.37
12 7 9.68 7.61 619.15 4.41 3.81 54.00 43.69 12,952.38 11,281.88
15 7 9.24 9.77 655.10 7.03 6.08 68.41 61.09 14,497.44 14,435.53
18 9 9.22 11.97 651.55 7.96 6.10 58.93 62.78 12,634.15 17,381.69
Correlations (summary)*
Variable
thickness No. of layer w surface density ρ
0.9479 0.7245 0.1824 0.9502 –0.2015
Εalong
p = 0.014 p = 0.166 p = 0.769 p = 0.013 p = 0.745
0.9325 0.7592 0.0200 0.9402 0.0106
εacross
p = 0.021 p = 0.137 p = 0.975 p = 0.017 p = 0.988
–0.6510 –0.6037 –0.8295 –0.5791 0.7628
fm along
p = 0.234 p = 0.281 p = 0.082 p = 0.306 p = 0.134
0.9019 0.6519 0.0805 0.9109 –0.1045
fm across
p = 0.036 p = 0.233 p = 0.898 p = 0.032 p = 0.867
–0.6172 –0.3950 –0.8486 –0.5535 0.8808
Ealong
p = 0.267 p = 0.510 p = 0.069 p = 0.333 p = 0.048
0.9833 0.8285 0.2222 0.9846 –0.2257
Eacross
p = 0.003 p = 0.083 p = 0.719 p = 0.002 p = 0.715
*Marked correlations are significant at p < 0.05000; n = 5 (casewise deletion of missing data)
that relationships of bending strength or modulus of in bending across the grain occurs while there is
elasticity show a reversible character of development a decrease in the values along the grain. The fact
along and across the grain in the upper veneer. is caused by the construction of plywoods where
The trend is also evident from Figs. 18 and 19 spruce veneers 3.5 mm thick are used as the second
where an increase in bending strength or MOE outer plies in plywoods 15 and 18 mm thick. These
—— along
8 y = 0.9932x – 1.5327 25,000
7
– – across R2 = 0.525
20,000
6
E (N/mm2)
(mm)
5 15,000
4 y = 0.7329x – 0.4998
2
R = 0.5763 10,000 —— along
3
2 5,000
– – across
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Number of plies Board thickness (mm)
Fig. 15. Dependence of relative deformation on the number of Fig. 16. Dependence of MOE on the sheet thickness in all-
sheet plies in combined plywoods beech plywoods
80
ε (mm)
7
70 6
5
60
4
50 3
8 10 12 14 16 18 20 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Board thickness (mm) Board thickness (mm)
Fig. 17. Dependence of bending strength on the sheet thickness Fig. 18. Dependence of relative deformation on the sheet thick-
in all-beech plywoods ness in all-beech plywoods
—— along
– – across
y = 25.736x + 1,547.6 y = 0.149x – 27.619
25,000
2
R = 0.7352
100
—— along
R2 = 0.8375
– – R across
y = 0.149x – 27.619
90 2
20,000 = 0.8375
E (N/mm )
2
fm (N/mm )
2
80
15,000
70
10,000 y = 20.285x – 2,670 y = 0.1652x – 56.36
2 60 2
R = 0.3195 R = 0.9584
5,000 50
650 700 750 800 850 660 680 700 720 740 760 780 800 820 840
ρ (kg/m3) ρ (kg/m )
3
Fig. 19. Dependence of MOE on the sheet density in all-beech Fig. 20. Dependence of bending strength on the sheet density
plywoods in all-beech plywoods
10 y = 49.507x + 20,329
y = –0.0088x + 14.419 25,000
9 2
R 2 = 0.0061
R = 0.1279
8 20,000
E (N/mm )
y = 406.04x + 8,463.6
2
7
(mm)
15,000 R 2 = 0.2877
6 y = –0.0082x + 11.309
R2 = 0.2737
5
—— along 10,000 —— along
4
– – across 5,000
– – across
3
650 700 750 800 850 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
ρ (kg/m )
3 Number of plies
Fig. 21. Dependence of relative deformation on the sheet Fig. 22. Dependence of MOE on the number of sheet plies in
density in all-beech plywoods all-beech plywoods
plies take over the majority of strength in bending Table 15 of correlation analysis calculated for all
stress across the grain and vice versa only surface thicknesses and types of plywoods shows a strong
beech veneers 1.5 mm thick are most stressed along dependence of bending strength and MOE on the
the grain. sheet density.
Table 14. Aggregate table of bending strength and MOE in bending for all-beech plywoods
Correlations (summary)*
Variable
thickness No. of plies w surf.ace ensity ρ
0.9360 0.9631 0.8742 0.8671 –0.5232
Εalong
p = 0.064 p = 0.037 p = 0.126 p = 0.133 p = 0.477
0.9927 0.9959 0.7142 0.9481 –0.3576
ε across
p = 0.007 p = 0.004 p = 0.286 p = 0.052 p = 0.642
–0.5323 –0.5904 –0.3890 –0.3489 0.9151
fm along
p = 0.468 p = 0.410 p = 0.611 p = 0.651 p = 0.085
–0.2154 –0.2894 –0.2261 –0.0115 0.9790
fm across
p = 0.785 p = 0.711 p = 0.774 p = 0.989 p = 0.021
0.1466 0.0782 0.1408 0.3438 0.8575
Ealong
p = 0.853 p = 0.922 p = 0.859 p = 0.656 p = 0.143
0.5920 0.5364 0.4844 0.7417 0.5652
Eacross
p = 0.408 p = 0.464 p = 0.516 p = 0.258. p = 0.435
*Marked correlations are significant at p < 0.050; n = 5 (casewise deletion of missing data)
100
—— along
– – across
10
—— along
– – across
90 y = –2.0274x + 104.24
9
R 2 = 0.3486
8
fm (N/mm )
y = 0.5163x + 2.6734
2
80
ε (mm)
7 2
R = 0.9918
70 6
5 y = 0.3169x + 2.0281
60 y = –1.0301x + 77.678
2 4 R 2 = 0.9276
R = 0.0837
50 3
6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Number of
Number of plies
plies Number
Number of
of plies
plies
Fig. 23. Dependence of bending strength on the number of Fig. 24. Dependence of relative deformation on the number of
sheet plies in all-beech plywoods sheet plies in all-beech plywoods
Fig. 25. Fracture along the height of the specimen in a com- Fig. 27. Fibrous fracture along the height of the specimen in a
bined plywood 18 mm thick beech plywood 15 mm thick
Fig. 26. Fibrous fracture along the height of the specimen in a Fig. 28. Rupture of fibres in the tensile zone of the specimen
combined plywood 18 mm thick in a combined plywood 15 mm thick
*Marked correlations are significant at p < 0.050; n = 9 (casewise deletion of missing data)
(A) (B)
25,000 100
20,000 80
fm �(N/mm )
E �(N/mm )
60
2
15,000
10,000 40
5,000 20
0 0
8 10 8
12 10 12
15 18 15 18
Thickness�(mm) Thickness�(mm)
Fig. 32. Comparison of MOE in bending (A) and bending strength (B) between combined and all-beech plywoods
J. HRÁZSKÝ, P. KRÁL
Lesnická a dřevařská fakulta, Mendelova zemědělská a lesnická univerzita v Brně, Brno, Česká republika
ABSTRAKT: Článek shrnuje výsledky institucionálního výzkumu zaměřeného na posouzení pevnosti v ohybu a modulu
pružnosti v ohybu vodovzdorných fóliovaných kombinovaných a celobukových překližek v závislosti na jejich konstrukci.
Byl zkoumán vztah konstrukce překližek a vybraných fyzikálních a mechanických vlastností. U zkoumaných desek byla ana-
lyzována ve vzájemných souvislostech vlhkost, hustota, pevnost v ohybu a modul pružnosti v ohybu podél a napříč vláken
vrchní dýhy. Veškerá měření byla provedena na vodovzdorných překližkách s povrchovou úpravou fenolformaldehydovou
fólií kombinovaných o tloušťce 8, 10, 12 a 15 mm a celobukových o tloušťce 10, 12, 15 a 18 mm. Konstrukce překližek vý-
znamným způsobem ovlivňuje kvalitu, která je určována zejména pevností v ohybu a modulem pružnosti v ohybu. Použitím
regresní analýzy byly prokázány závislosti – zejména to, že s rostoucí vlhkostí překližek klesá pevnost v ohybu a se zvyšující
se hustotou roste pevnost v ohybu a modul elasticity. Stejný trend se prokázal i v souvislosti se zvyšujícím se počtem dýh
překližovaných desek. Korelační metodou byly statisticky testovány vzájemné kombinace závislostí uvedených vlastností.
Klíčová slova: překližka; hustota; plošná hmotnost; vlhkost; tloušťka; pevnost v ohybu; modul pružnosti v ohybu; dýha;
statistická analýza
Překližované desky jsou definovány jako desky se vzá- Překližované materiály, které řadíme spolu s mate-
jemně slepenými vrstvami, přičemž směr vláken soused- riály aglomerovanými k materiálům velkoplošným, se
ních vrstev je na sebe kolmý. Ve všeobecnosti jsou vnější vyrábějí lisováním souborů dýh nanesených syntetic-
a vnitřní vrstvy na obou stranách vzhledem ke střední kým lepidlem za tepla a za spolupůsobení tlaku.
(případně středové vrstvě) symetricky uspořádány. Proti aglomerovaným materiálům, tj. třískovým a vlák-
Výroba překližovaných desek patří k nejmladším od- nitým deskám, mají určité výhody. Jsou podstatně leh-
větvím dřevozpracujícího průmyslu. Překližované des- čí (mají nižší hustotu), vykazují vyšší hodnoty jednot-
ky se během času dostaly na jedno z vedoucích míst livých mechanických a fyzikálních vlastností. Jejich
trhu s velkoplošnými materiály. Používají se v mnoha hlavní výhoda spočívá v tom, že si uchovávají vzhled
odvětvích lidské činnosti, například ve strojírenství, přírodního dřeva. Překližované desky se dají rovněž vy-
v textilním průmyslu, ve výrobě nábytku, v dopravě, rábět ve formě tvarovaných výlisků. Ve všeobecnosti se
v průmyslové a ve stavební výrobě apod. dají jednoduše povrchově upravovat. Podle účelu pou-
Corresponding author:
Dr. Ing. JAROSLAV HRÁZSKÝ, Mendelova zemědělská a lesnická univerzita v Brně, Lesnická a dřevařská fakulta,
Lesnická 37, 613 00 Brno, Česká republika
tel.: + 420 545 134 159, fax: + 420 545 212 298, e-mail: hrazsky@mendelu.cz